6 ms·
Earth Is on the Brink of Breaching a 7th of Nine 'Planetary Boundaries'
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoThe Planetary Boundaries framework is so bad, I don’t understand why it’s so popular. Most of the "boundaries" are directly correlated. Most of them are fairly arbitrary. It’s such an awful tool to discuss the actual very serious issue it underlines. I wish it would just disappear. Just to be clear, there is nothing magical about most of these boundaries. The situation is not in any way suddenly worse today than yesterday. Some of the axis actually showcases issue which would be a problem at any level. Others are debatable. Thresholds are overall a bad way to think about dynamic systems.
- FrustratedMonky 2y ago"correlated" isn't an evil term, it doesn't mean there can't be useful observations in different domains. To nit pick, since "correlation isn't causation" is often an internet meme to discredit any science.
- exe34 2y agoif 7 of the 9 are highly correlated, then breaching all 7 isn't as bad as it sounds, it's just one boundary.
- FrustratedMonky 2y agoAre they thought? Guess that is part of the meme, anybody can say "well correlation isn't causation" and sound kind of smart. Then the onus is on the other to go prove they aren't correlated, when they are not obviously correlated to begin with, so then need to devolve into a deep dive showing percentages of correlation. It's part of the 'easy to produce BS' type argument. I'd push back and say. Ok, then show how 7 of 9 are highly correlated. Just saying 7 of 9 are obviously correlated so boom, who cares. Is just as invalid as someone saying there is no correlation. You have to prove it either way. And there is no clear proof. And these aren't obvious. Just everything going bad at once doesn't mean they are highly correlated thus we really don't have to care about any single item.
- exe34 2y agoI'll direct your attention to the first word in my post - "if". I'm just as lazy as you are!
- croes 2y agoWe could define similar boundaries for humans: Wealth, education, health etc. They are also directly correlated but still a indicator of a humans condition.
- paxys 2y ago"The fire has spread to 50% of the house." "Now the fire has spread to 90% of the house." "Meh, the metrics are meaningless because they are correlated. The house is fine."
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoThe issue is not the metrics. The boundaries are meaningless because the issue was that there was a fire from the start. The correct analogy would be "Fire in the house boundary on the brink of being breached. We can confirm that 49% has already burned and the threshold of 50% will have burned in the next minute. This is the second catastrophic boundary to be crossed: the fume in the house boundary was breached five minutes ago." which is indeed a completely pointless way of looking at the issue.
- balozi 2y agoThe cynic in me sees people building careers off promotion of pseudo-science, and other on the creation of content around said pseudo-science. Reminds me of string theory for some reason.
- scarmig 2y agoYou announce a set of boundaries, imply that crossing them shifts the system to some new, disastrous attractor state, and get a lot of media and donor attention. For a couple years you get lots of mileage out of it, until you need to come up with a new set, except this time it's For Real. Repeat. It's counterproductive: once people see small violations of the boundaries result in only small changes, they start to tune them out. And, with global warming, the accumulated small changes will ultimately result in significant harm, so there's no need to invent fake boundaries.
- photonthug 2y agoNever heard of planetary boundaries framework before but the way it’s discussed in this piece kind of immediately tripped my hippy pseudoscience alerts. TFA is actually a maddening read from beginning to end anyway.. lots of awkward phrasing, bad diction, weird punctuation.
- sharpshadow 2y agoThey love fancy titles - reading it I thought we got accepted into the intergalactic federation.
- Molitor5901 2y agoIt's useful for political and media purposes. Some might call it climate propaganda, such as when Al Gore claiming (based on what we was told by top climate scientists) that the arctic would be ice free in 5 years. It's used to make a point and to shock people. It does not appear that any of those same type of doomsday predictions (Gretta, etc.) ever came true. They really do a disservice to the underlining, and very important, issue. Instead of trying to scare people with future predictions of doom, talk about what is happening right now, today, and what will continue to happen. Educate, stop trying to shock and manipulate.
- orwin 2y ago>the arctic would be ice free in 5 years The claim at the time was that if nothing was done in the 5 following years, the Arctic would start an unstoppable heating process that wouldn't stop even if we stopped all emissions. Nowadays, almost all ice and thermoaline specialists work on Antarctica because we already know what will happen with the Arctic, that's why almost nothing new is published. At least new routes will open :)
- gmuslera 2y agoIf the floor have 0º of inclination you can walk up and down without risk of falling down, 10º is still good, 20º? probably on. But there is some point after which most people could slip down. There, that is boundary. It is not a meaningless line, just that the odds of everything falling down gets high enough.
- RandomThoughts3 2y agoThat’s a meaningless line. People fall gradually more as inclinaison rises. There is no arbitrary cliff as 20° is crossed. Plus, minor issues but not insignificant issues like slippage probably started at very low level. You have artificially transformed a continuous issue into a threshold which is intellectually shoddy.
- johnchristopher 2y ago> That’s a meaningless line. That absolute is actually intellectually shoddy to me when parent is clearly using "could" and the slope to indicate it's around 20°, not at 20°. It doesn't really matter what the error margin is if it's low enough. Let's try another analogy: of course the patient looks fine, but he's cancer terminal and in his last weeks. Tests are showing his internals are fucked up beyond certain thresholds. Yeah, they are smiling and talking but it's over, they are dead in two weeks top. Omae wa mou.
- princevegeta89 2y agoLooking forward to the when the next two are also taken care of...! Seriously though, this is some really depressing stuff :/
- withinboredom 2y agoI’ve kind of accepted we are screwed. Whether I am alive when shit hits the fan or not is another question. But seeing that people are trying to build satellite mirrors to put MORE solar energy into the planet without even thinking about it for more than a few minutes, I would say we are more screwed than we realize. The first law of stupidity applies.
- lotsofpulp 2y agoWhere is the assumption coming from that a “shit hits the fan” event will happen? What if it is just a slow degradation in myriad aspects of quality of life only felt over the course of decades?
- djbusby 2y agoYep, multiple shits hitting multiple fans.
- bko 2y agoAh yes, the myriad aspects of quality of life that has degraded over decades. https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty-in-brief https://ourworldindata.org/extreme-poverty-in-brief https://www.wsj.com/articles/climate-activists-disasters-fire-storms-deaths-change-cop26-glasgow-global-warming-11635973538 https://www.wsj.com/articles/climate-activists-disasters-fir...
- redsunglasses 2y agoI thought it was clear that the person you responded to (as well as the grandparent comment) was talking about the future. No one is denying that we are much better off right now as a species than we ever have been. The point is that we can't safely assume that that trend will continue in the next 25, 50, or 100 years.
- AQuantized 2y agoNot sure how this is relevant given it's the effects of a future climate catastrophe being discussed, not something that has already happened.
- eagerpace 2y agoIt’s hard for me to read an article when the clickbait headline is completely walked back in the first paragraph.
- bbor 2y agoHow so?
- cwillu 2y ago“These boundaries are not tipping points—it’s possible to recover from passing them” Debatable whether that is completely walking back the headline, but the headline is clearly trying to give the impression it's irreversible without actually making a claim that could thereby be defeated: “brink”, “breaching”, “boundaries” “support life” are all very suggestive of irreversible doom, and yet…
- micromacrofoot 2y agothat's not really walking it back... recovery is much more difficult than not causing the problem in the first place, and because it can be reversed doesn't mean it will be
- cwillu 2y agoLike I said, it's english prose and the applicability of “walking it back” is subject to debate. I'm not arguing the point, just pulling out the obvious triggering line and explaining where I think the sentiment is coming from.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- micromacrofoot 2y agobut why
- 2y ago
- pavlov 2y agoSeven of nine. Proceed with Earth borgification.
- ToDougie 2y agoSeven of Nine can borgify me.
- bbor 2y agoNever loved this framework because the arbitrary quantization can make things look better than they are (“sure temps are up 4° but we’re still banning aerosols, so drill baby drill!”) but it’s certainly a good starter framework for getting people’s attention. And to those that read this and just give up: please don’t. We’ve done incredible things as a species, and today’s world is not based in unchangeable natural constants, but rather social constructs. We can win. And assuming we can’t is, frankly, immoral. What will you tell your grandchildren? https://slrpnk.net https://slrpnk.net
- anigbrowl 2y agoEvery time I say the solution is to restrain those who callously and deliberately profit off climate damage, by force if necessary, people get upset and downvote me, metaphorically speaking. But all the 'yay humanity let's all cooperate in pursuit of a solution' thinkers are demonstrably failing, because selfish people make up the largest bloc (though still a minority) of humanity. People who go to a museum and throw paint at a work of art (which is protected behind glass) are routinely condemned and sent to jail. But even if they were actually destroying art, their point is that many extractive industries are actually destroying the environment and killing off whole species, damaging human health etc., and not only does society tolerate this, in many cases it subsidizes it. We choose instead to condemn the people who draw attention to this.
- fzeroracer 2y ago> People who go to a museum and throw paint at a work of art (which is protected behind glass) are routinely condemned and sent to jail. They're condemned because their way of protesting is worthless. Protesting only works if it either inconveniences people enough to trigger action or if it targets the people actually responsible. If they truly believed that climate change was a critical issue, then they should take a page from how union strikes used to work.
- bbor 2y agoThe movement was characterized by nonviolent mass protests and civil disobedience following highly publicized events such as the lynching of Emmett Till. These included boycotts such as the Montgomery bus boycott, "sit-ins" in Greensboro and Nashville, a series of protests during the Birmingham campaign, and a march from Selma to Montgomery. Eh, none of that seems to fall into either of the buckets you describe, other than maybe sit-ins "targeting" racist owners of restaurants. Plus, I know this is annoying but... source? Any data backing that claim? Re:JustStopOil, they also regularly target banks and private jets. It's just that those protests get much less attention in the press, and draw harsher criminal punishments. How else do you make progress on changing laws other than convincing voters that it's a problem? Assuming we can't just do what the US did for civil rights and rely on an unusually powerful judiciary to save the day via anti-democratic fiat ;)
- throw73737 2y agoNuclear war is a bit more urgent threat.
- roschdal 2y agoHumanity needs to stop flying all the time.
- mistrial9 2y agohumanity is not flying.. a very, very small subset of humanity.. and "largest carbon footprint has most prestige" is a very real phenomenon among that set. Four times in the last month I have read bragging stories mentioning very privelaged and therefore "elite" individuals described, including extreme private airplane use. Watch for the kneejerk response, too. Anti-"climate protest" media commonly uses the "flying hypocrisy" attack against those who are actively agitating against Fossil Fuels.. it works! Compare and contrast to "Climate Week New York City" this week and the passenger miles involved with that. Hint- there is no "truth" in the analysis.. it is reactive and exaggerated on all sides.
- Aachen 2y agoOn that topic, I was recently very surprised to learn that only 3% of Indians were ever on a flight in their life. With the country being so geographically large and so many Indian people in workplaces and conferences and everything (as in, it's just normal to me), it blew my mind to realise that most of these are actually all among the top richest fraction It's just crazy how well-off we are compared to so many people around the world in not just low- but also middle- income countries. We really could do well to take a small step back and get everyone onto some fair middle ground while we fix these emissions Edit: found the source: Polymatter's video "Why there are no flights between India and China" from earlier this month, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuWAdYl5icY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KuWAdYl5icY at 16:32
- sickofparadox 2y ago"No vacations far away" or "No visiting distant family" are not winning rallying cries for climate change and will, in fact, doom any movement that tries to use them.
- swayvil 2y agoYou'll have my unlimited consumption when you pry it from my cold dead hands.
- _rrnv 2y agoPlanet Earth will be fine. It survived much worse than some little human emissions. The meteor and winter that followed that killed off the dinosaurs was much worse than some elevated CO2. Whether humanity survives this is another question. My bet is we will, since we are like roaches. But many will die for the sins of the few. Interestingly, these few who will survive are probably the ones who created this mess and can afford to. The many that will die are probably for the better anyway. The future of humanity is not yet decided, but it will take a great leap of tech to overcome this. One thing is for sure: we cant save the Planet by trying to "save the planet", meaning downsize, recycle, emit less etc. Exactly like one cannot become a millionaire by saving. We need to invest in our future and find efficient ways to extract CO2 from the atmosphere and convert it to power. Optimize and cheapen stuff like E-Diesel made from atmospheric CO2 and hydrogen from desalinated seawater using solar and wind. And stop giving space and time to idiots from Extinction Rebellion and The Last Generation. I hope not all here are brainwashed and understand what I'm saying.
- SoftTalker 2y agoThere is no power to be extracted from CO2. It takes energy to break the C-O bonds.
- yieldcrv 2y agoI think people are more concerned about the coral reefs than the humans
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Aachen 2y agoAny data to back up that extraordinary claim?
- aaomidi 2y agoIMO. You’re brainwashed for thinking technology is going to save us from this tbh. Climate already saw a lot of improvements during the 2020 lockdowns.
- gruntledfangler 2y ago“The health check will also serve as a “mission-control center” for decision-making, per the statement, by using satellite data, A.I. and multiple scientific disciplines—as well as the wisdom of Indigenous peoples, which is something the researchers hope to incorporate more of in following editions” Just in case you were considering taking this seriously…
- superb_dev 2y agoSounds like they’re using all available resources. What’s wrong?
- Vecr 2y agoAre they limiting the input to a 1% cap, then multiplying the difference from the actual model by 0.000000001? If so it might not be too bad in practice, but it's still bad science. It's like someone today took planetary epicycles and copied them verbatim into their car physics simulator. Yeah, it probably won't be a material detriment, but why are they in there?
- cabirum 2y agoThey are just looking for funding that's all.
- redleggedfrog 2y agoWay back in the SimEarth days I got introduced to the Gaia concept, which at the time seemed a little hokey, but as time goes on seems more and more apt. Not trying to sound like Agent Smith, but sure seems like the earth is treating humans like a virus and is warming itself up to get rid of us. We had a long time to see it coming, but it's not politically popular to acknowledge it, and here in the U.S. you can signal your affiliation by dismissing it publicly (Huckabee-Sanders). But mother nature always wins in the end regardless of your politics, and now mother nature wants you dead.
- superb_dev 2y agoThe earth is not warming itself, WE are warming the earth
- butterknife 2y agoWhy are WE distinct from Earth?
- bregma 2y agoWell, no. Primarily, the sun warms the surface of the Earth, and the Earth itself generates heat. What WE are doing is reducing the amount of heat radiated from the surface of the Earth until atmospheric expansions reaches a new equilibrium. In other words, we're affecting the radiative cooling equilibrium of the Earth. We are not heating it in any way.
- redleggedfrog 2y agoI take your point - admit it's a leaky abstraction.
- carapace 2y agoIf Mother Nature wanted to roll us up as a failed experiment she could eliminate us overnight with one virus. Lighten up.
- abeppu 2y ago> “The overall diagnostic is that the patient, Planet Earth, is in critical condition,” says Johan Rockström The planet as a patient is a problematic metaphor. What does this mean? A human patient in critical condition is at risk of dying. But the planet is not going to "die", though many species will. We need better ways of talking clearly (not with hyperbole) about the current situation and the stakes. Even with serious and aggressive policy changes, we'd still be on a track for key measures to get worse for some time, and we're bad at discussing "under costly policy A, X will be k% worse than today with expected outcome Y, but without adopting policy A, X with be (k+l)% worse than today expected outcome Z." So people end up saying "we're doomed regardless, so why should I have to pay/change/act?"
- bongodongobob 2y agoWhy does this argument always come up? We all know the planet won't die. Humans might though. That's why we're concerned. This is always presented as some "ackshully" very smart argument. Yeah, it's a big fuckin rock, of course it won't die. That's not the concern.
- exe34 2y agoonly poorer humans will suffer and die. the rich will be fine.
- worldsayshi 2y agoIt will probably take a lot to make humans die out at this point. Humans will die, but not humanity. Technological society might collapse, although I think our adaptability will ultimately save it. And it will continue to destroy the conditions for other species to survive, as we collapse and then grow again - until we figure out how to not do that. There only one resolution to this big conundrum and that is to make technological society to not compete with the biological ecosystem of earth.
- abeppu 2y agoSo what does it mean? A lead person with the project said it, and it was the only quote from that person that made it into the article. The boundaries are explicitly said to not be known tipping points, so we don't know that some new mechanisms become dominant outside of them. We're only told that leaving these bounds is "higher-risk" and that inside the bounds is some "safe zone" but the actual risk or the meaning of "safety" in this context are not communicated. This is a leading science publication reporting on an apparently notable finding about how serious the current situation is, but the actual information presented is either vague or hyperbolic. Note, I'm not saying the situation isn't serious, or that drastic action isn't warranted. I'm saying this piece, discussing this work, is at minimum sloppy and unclear, and I think this is at the level of being counter-productive. When the situation is serious, try speaking clearly rather than in shrill metaphor.
- ghastmaster 2y ago> Earth’s oceans absorb carbon dioxide from the atmosphere, providing a valuable carbon sink as humans burn fossil fuels. But this process also makes the oceans more acidic, which can disturb the formation of shells and coral skeletons and affect fish life cycles, per the report. Atmospheric CO2 levels are at historic lows.[1] Bivalves have shells and evolved during the Cambrian Explosion. The Cambrian explosion took place around 540 to 520 million years ago (Mya)[2]. During the early history of bivalves atmospheric CO2 levels were around 4,000-5,000ppm. Current levels are around 400ppm. References: 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmosphere#/media/File:Phanerozoic_Carbon_Dioxide.png https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmo... 2 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bivalvia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bivalvia
- BenjiWiebe 2y agoDefinitely not historic lows. Perhaps it's been higher, but it's definitely been lower than now.
- ghastmaster 2y agoIn the last 400,000 years the concentration has fluctuated from about 180ppm to about 300 many times.[1] My historical reference in the previous post was the last 500,000,000 years. In that context we are low. 1 - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmosphere#/media/File:Vostok_Petit_data.svg https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carbon_dioxide_in_Earth's_atmo...
- redsunglasses 2y agoSince our species' collective life comprises the last 400,000 years, and we are 420ppm now, do you think it's also fair to say that we are historic highs?
- infinite8s 2y agoMaybe ghastmaster is a super-intelligent bivalve.
- photochemsyn 2y agoWe are heading for Pliocene conditions and yes, the tipping point is in the past. Even complete cessation of fossil fuel use and zero net deforestation (growth of timber == harvest of timber) would not stop it at this point, as it would take ~100 years for the system to come to a new equilibrium, and even then, permafrost melt and methane/CO2 outgassing from permafrost would continue (with some offset from tree growth in northern polar regions as the permafrost retreats). Thus continual sea level rise is going to be a fact of life, possibly for several thousand years, until sea levels are 10 to 25 meters higher than today. Average temperatures will be 2-3C higher than the preindustrial Holocene average, (currently ~1.2C higher) with significant regional variation. Many regions that support large human populations will become inhospitable on a decadal timeline (i.e. it takes about ten years for signal to emerge from noise at current warming rate). As far as ocean acidification, this is probably the least of our worries, unlike ocean hypoxia and anoxia, which are steadily expanding due to all the organic matter and fertilizer dumped into the oceans by human civilization. Coral reefs were widespread in the Pliocene, and the acidification is just a surface water phenomenon and is fairly minimal - the buffering capacity of the ocean is vast, and it's just a mixing issue as surface water tends to sit on top of the deeper waters.
- aszantu 2y agoif that's true, sea-food market will go up, esp. mussels will be more expensive. Any stock to look out for?
- swayvil 2y agoDo we trust the science on this one?
- carapace 2y agoI don't want to write a whole big thing this morning but I feel it's important to point out that we already have all the solutions we need to integrate our economic systems with the global ecology. All the solutions were worked out decades ago, they are "off the shelf". E.g.: https://newalchemists.net/ https://newalchemists.net/ We could do it rapidly and with very little inconvenience and everyone can have a nice standard of living while repairing the ecosystem. We just have to notice this and get on with it.