10 ms·
This won't have nearly the same impact, but when you're considering how vulnerabilities like this might influence your future purchasing decisions, remember tha
by tptacek 2y ago
This won't have nearly the same impact, but when you're considering how vulnerabilities like this might influence your future purchasing decisions, remember that Kia's decision to omit interlocks from their US vehicles (but not Canadian ones!) led to a nationwide epidemic of Kia thefts so large it fed a crime wave, something a number of US cities are suing Kia over. If you've read about carjacking waves in places like Milwaukee and Chicago: that was largely driven by a decision Kia made, which resulted in the nationwide deployment of a giant fleet of "burner" cars that could be stolen with nothing but a bent USB cable.
- wasteduniverse 2y agoDon't anthropomorphize the lawnmower and blame Kia for this, blame the NHTSA for making it legal to skimp out on immobilizers in the first place. Regulations matter!
- tptacek 2y agoSince Kia/Hyundai is the only automotive group to have this problem, I'm going to go ahead continuing to blame them.
- piva00 2y agoI agree and still it's also the lack of regulation that enabled it to happen, and 2nd order effects of it is the increase in carjackings. It's a pretty good argument for the regulation, since everyone else is already doing it just make it the standard.
- searealist 2y agoOf course you are. The alternative is to blame the governments (of places like Chicago or Milwaukee), or the people doing the theft.
- BoorishBears 2y agoWhy are those alternatives for you? I find it very easy to hold the governments, people, and companies as all culpable in the own way.
- bombcar 2y agoExactly. The situation should be examined like the NTSB does for plane crashes, usually a proximate cause and other contributing causes. Maybe we’ll see a return of The Club™
- cryptonector 2y agoLmao, good reference to u/bcantrill.
- rideontime 2y ago?
- lambda 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10040429 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10040429
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pengaru 2y ago> Volkswagen has entered the chat
- jshdhehe 2y agoWow they will not live that down!
- adolph 2y ago> If you've read about carjacking waves in places like Milwaukee and Chicago: that was largely driven by a decision Kia made, which resulted in the nationwide deployment of a giant fleet of "burner" cars that could be stolen with nothing but a bent USB cable. "A nationwide epidemic of Kia thefts" seems to be a natural consequence of decreased security. However, that carjacking in Milwaukee and Chicago specifically would follow from a nationwide omission of interlocks is not obvious as the vehicles are easily stolen without the need for personal confrontation. What is the connection of Kia interlocks to carjacking in Milwaukee and Chicago?
- Terr_ 2y ago> However, that carjacking in Milwaukee and Chicago specifically would follow from a nationwide omission of interlocks is not obvious as the vehicles are easily stolen without the need for personal confrontation. I think parent-poster means that the easily-stolen cars are being used as tools of carjacking, rather than the targets of it. In particular, carjacking that occurs by somehow provoking a victim to stop on the highway shoulder, a location where attackers can't exactly arrive by foot or bus or bike. That way they don't involve a vehicle that might be observed and traced back to them. An alternate explanation is that they meant to write something like "theft" and accidentally put down "carjacking" instead.
- levocardia 2y agoThis is correct, the usual procedure is: steal kia or hyundai with your friends using the no-interlock exploit --> find other cars to carjack (at gunpoint), or individuals to rob --> ditch stolen cars when no longer needed. Exploit no-pursuit policies as needed.
- tptacek 2y agoI've posted this point a couple times on HN and I guess I will keep posting until people stop expressing surprise that trivially stealable cars are a precursor to carjackings. I'm not dunking, there's no good reason for people to intuit that! But it's a really important thing to understand.
- Eumenes 2y ago> something a number of US cities are suing Kia over I can think of nothing more American than suing car manufactures because they're too easy to steal. The US is truly screwed.
- dangitman 2y ago[dead]
- tptacek 2y agoThey're being sued because they deliberately made the cars easier to steal in the US than they are elsewhere.
- userbinator 2y agoIn some places in the US, you can leave your doors open and car unlocked and no one will touch it. Perhaps a friendly neighbour may remind you, but that's about it. As much as some narrative wants us to think, we don't need to be forced to live in effectively the same conditions as a maximum-security prison in order to have no crime. Cars (and other things) being easy to steal isn't the problem.
- tptacek 2y agoI have to lock my car doors. There isn't anyone within 10 square miles of me who feels like they live in a maximum-security prison.
- hackernoops 2y agoSounds like you live in Stockholm. (syndrome)
- dangitman 2y ago[dead]
- wallaBBB 2y agoRegarding the Kia Boyz - immobilizers have been mandatory in most of Europe since late 90s, in Canada since 2007. Basically there is something to put on (lack of) regulations as well as on HKMC.
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoIn the USA, we believe we don't need regulations, the Free Market(tm) will punish corporations that don't behave in a way that benefits their customers! Insane to me that so many people believe this...
- op00to 2y agoI’ll certainly never buy another Korean car.
- thfuran 2y agoAnd never an American one after the Pinto, and never a German one after the VW testing scam, and never a Japanese one after the recent safety scandal? I guess you can still get a Jaguar, so your mechanic won't complain.
- worik 2y agoI drive a car made in the 1990s I was planning to upgrade it I might not...
- thfuran 2y agoI had been planning to keep driving my car for quite some time, but recently it's developed a weird engine noise and a check engine light that nobody can resolve. I'm not sure I'll be able to give EV charging a few more years to sort itself out.
- Dylan16807 2y agoVW didn't really affect the customers. How big of a difference was the actual safety of the Japanese cars? Are the corrected numbers poor, or still pretty good?
- mass_and_energy 2y agoWe Canucks needs all the features we can get to stop cars from being stolen, without exaggeration a car is stolen in Canada every 5 minutes on average.
- SpaghettiCthulu 2y agoToo bad the only thing our current government can think to do is ban the FlipperZero.
- zerd 2y agoJust wait, next they'll ban USB cables.
- emptybits 2y agoFellow Canuck here. Yes, that statistic is sadly, insanely true. And some background ... https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy79dq2n093o https://www.bbc.com/news/articles/cy79dq2n093o
- voidmain0001 2y agoI'm about to take delivery of a Toyota Sienna in Canada, and despite it being a minivan, it's a Toyota which are popular to steal right now. I plan to use both a steering wheel and accelerator pedal club. I've watched videos of both devices being rendered futile in less than 60 seconds but I hope that it will deter the less determined thieves. Then, after my kids have thoroughly destroyed the interior, I will hope that it gets stolen.
- ndileas 2y agoHave you considered not living in such an environment of fear? I have no idea of your circumstances, but this is something I see in my local relatives all the time. They buy ring cams and security systems, scrutinize nextdoor, etc. In reality, they are incomparably rich and safe compared to most. Personally I refuse to buy into this nonsense and just go about my life, despite living in a place that's far more dangerous by the numbers.
- bnralt 2y ago> it fed a crime wave, something a number of US cities are suing Kia over A large part of the crime wave stems from the policies these cities implemented. Many times from the same leaders who are suing Kia now. For instance, a friend got their car stolen in D.C. After they caught the guy, they let him go with no consequences, because they said he was under 25 and it was the first time they caught him. D.C. recently put a convicted murderer on the sentencing commission who believes that this kind of "it's not really their fault if they're under 25" thinking should be extended to murders as well. Local politicians even told us there wasn't a crime wave, and that it was just a fake narrative. Then when that stopped working, they started pointing fingers at everyone else they could.
- ethbr1 2y agoIt's fair to say that a company which makes cars that can be stolen with only a USB socket bears significant culpability for car thefts. Anything political doesn't have to be only this reason or only that reason. "Both" is an option too. - Kia fucked up, to make more $ - Some cities have ineffective enforcement
- rcthompson 2y ago> car thefts To be specific, I don't think the cities are suing over the car thefts. If I understand correctly, they're suing because the availability of easily hacked Kia cars enabled a wave of other crimes, because the criminals knew they had easy access to a getaway vehicle that couldn't be traced back to them.
- kortilla 2y agoI’ll take victim blaming for $200, Alex. Breaking into a house is easy as a rock through the window but we don’t sue homebuilders for not putting in stronger glass.
- ethbr1 2y agoSo if a window manufacturer decides to save money and not put latches on their windows, enabling them to be opened from the outside at will, and home invasions spike, that manufacturer isn't a large part of the problem?
- sidewndr46 2y agoBecause car manufacturers have such a clear decision making role in the legal and judicial process of a place like Milwaukee. It can't be that the government simply realized that they aren't legally obliged to deal with any problems the populace have and simply let them eat cake in a 21st century way. This couldn't be the same state where they tried to just bribe a foreign company known for exploitative labor practices to set up a facility there could it: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wisconn_Valley_Science_and_Technology_Park#:~:text=The%20Wisconn%20Valley%20Science%20and,with%20the%20state%20of%20Wisconsin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wisconn_Valley_Science_and_Tec....
- xyst 2y agoKia is a joke car manufacturer. It’s surprising that they are still able to sell cars and stay in business
- roberttod 2y agoI wasn't sure what an "interlock" was, and it's a breathalyzer that prevents the vehicle from starting. Was that a mistake? Edit: ah! I think you meant engine immobilizer
- Dylan16807 2y agointerlock. noun. an arrangement in which the operation of one part or mechanism automatically brings about or prevents the operation of another Requiring a breath or a specific key signal are both interlocks.
- sandos 2y agoHow did the insurance companies respond to this? They should have made the cars extremely expensive to insure, no?
- incrediblydumb 2y agoLargely driven? You're forgetting at least one variable