5 ms·
YouTube Premium is getting a big price hike internationally
- noobermin 2y agoI'm all for paying for things instead of paying for things instead of ads, but someone enlighten me, is youtube not profitable these days as is, even premium isn't paying for itself? Moreover, even paying for youtube premium, you cannot avoid all ads (for example, sponsored segments).
- vouaobrasil 2y agoYouTube is profitable, but Google isn't content with profitable. They want profit maximization, which is a bad thing. I feel like the world would be a better place if we had something like eBay but for companies: just like the seller gets the SECOND highest price bid, companies should also be content with the second highest level of profit maximization, defined in terms of percentile...
- grecy 2y agoThe only amount of profit that is acceptable is more profit. $5B in profit is utter failure if you made the same amount last year. For a long time now companies will do anything to be MORE profitable. EDIT: Seems very appropriate https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fquky4comqhqd1.jpeg https://www.reddit.com/media?url=https%3A%2F%2Fi.redd.it%2Fq...
- fkyoureadthedoc 2y agoSponsored content doesn't really bother me, I usually skip it, but I watch some of them depending on the creator. One reason (other than just money in general) that it's useful for YouTubers is because it's pretty easy to get demonetized depending on what kind of content you make. Ad situations like "the publisher payed me to play this game" is usually fine with me too if the game is interesting and the content is good.
- Rychard 2y ago> you cannot avoid all ads (for example, sponsored segments). Look into SponsorBlock, as it allows the community to mark such segments, and your browser will automatically skip them.
- ap-andersson 2y agoThere is also projects you can run in your local network that skips the segments when playing youtube videos on chromecast. Using the same crowdsourced data from SponsorBlock. The one I use: https://github.com/gabe565/CastSponsorSkip https://github.com/gabe565/CastSponsorSkip
- jsbg 2y agoit might be profitable but they figure they can make it more profitable; there has been a lot of inflation in the last few years and every other video subscription service has been hiking up their pricing recently
- surajrmal 2y agoI think the average number of minutes per user must be increasing. Creators get paid by watch time, so premium would need to scale with watch time in order to remain lucrative.
- Rinzler89 2y agoIt's what happens when you are a monopoly, you can keep jacking up the prices whenever you feel like it if you have no competition.
- tantalor 2y agoYT competes with premium video content streamers like Netflix, music streamers like Spotify, live streaming like Twitch, and social media like TikTok.
- queuebert 2y agoFor music streaming, maybe. For all of the other content, you can't be serious.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoI think they're right though. When I sit down on the couch and turn on my Roku or Apple TV, the question is whether we want to open Youtube, Netflix, Hulu, Peakcock, etc. They absolutely are competitors even if they have different video content. So much so that once I got Youtube Premium, I cancelled two streaming services after realizing how much we watch it.
- queuebert 2y ago> So much so that once I got Youtube Premium, I cancelled two streaming services after realizing how much we watch it. That's exactly my point. For YouTube-type, independent creators and instructional content, there is no substitute. If you want to watch a drama or comedy, you have a lot of options. This is not scientific, but I know an increasing number of people who don't watch "traditional" media at all and look entirely to YouTube for something to watch, especially if they prefer non-fiction.
- edgarvaldes 2y agoYT is not a monopoly, I agree. But OTOH there is not a single yt replacement.
- Max-q 2y agoI wonder if this will increase creators payout with 30-50%.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoYeah right. It will be used to fatten the bank accounts of high-level Google employees.
- noobermin 2y agoAlphabet stock holders more likely than employees.
- vouaobrasil 2y agoWell both. Look at the massive salaries at Google.
- Rinzler89 2y agoThe real question is why would they?
- medion 2y agoThey won't, but they should... Because, creators are ... What make YouTube.
- Rinzler89 2y agoYou can make the same argument that companies should pay their workers more because in theory they'd be nothing without them when the truth is there's other workers out there to take their place if the current ones don't like it, and that goes 10x for creators, most of who get into it out of passion first making them easily exploitable and replaceable due to this supply/demand power imbalance. Life is unfair and business is never about doing what's the fair or morally right thing to do, but doing what's the best for your shareholders. Youtube only cares about creators if they're whales like Mr Beast, LTT, MKBHD, etc otherwise they don't give a damn about you, and creators still flock to YouTube because there's nowhere else for them to go to.
- kranner 2y ago> YouTube already hiked its subscription prices in India by 15-20% in late August. This is incorrect. There was a 58% hike, at least for the Family plan.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bearjaws 2y agoI am waiting for the day they finally kill family plan sharing. I have my family (three accounts) but share an account with one of my friends. Only a matter of time, even though its already pricey.
- vouaobrasil 2y ago> YouTube's latest price increase comes as it explores new ways to push ads to regular users I feel like advertisements are one of those things that need more than just the free market to decide their limits. And that's because the ways of psychological manipulation are just too vast to be countered by rational human judgement.
- iwishiknewlisp 2y agoThis includes a lot of things. We have had less than 100 years to adjust to the technological revolution and rapid globalization. Its seem that we take for granted that we will adapt to a completely different world. Humans have spent the majority of our existence in a wildly different environment and our adaption to a completely new environment won't be quick nor without many lives lost and quality of life affected. For example: Unhealthy, addictive food along with modern food preservation is responsible for the most deaths in the US through obesity and heart disease, with obesity having a a high number of comordibities including sleep apnea, anxiety, depression, and (arguably) ADHD (further research needs to be conducted). Food in the past was limited and not available in vast excess to the average human, and certainly not foods that are extremely unhealthy and addictive. Another example would be a higher average life expectancy. How do you deal with a population of 70-80 years olds who many can't work, require disproprotionate resources for their survival, and age related mental & cognitive decline. What is the solution? We can wait for humans to adapt, evolotuarily and socially, which will take many thousands of years. Or we can enact political change. The issue is that we these changes need to balance the increasing power and ability of the state with individual freedoms. Along with having a lean political machine that can further change for the future. I don't see a way forward, not that it doesn't exist, but this is an environment more unlike any other one we have ever known and the next 10-100 years of the species is as unpredictable for us as it has ever been spanning back as far as the start of the agricultural revolution.
- travoc 2y agoFortunately yt-dlp and all of it's fancy front ends are still free. I enjoy YouTube commercial-free.
- englishspot 2y agohow long before google kills it, though?
- EduardoBautista 2y agoMy most used YouTube premium feature is pausing on my phone and picking up where I left off on my Apple TV. It's more than just ad free watching.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoOr just consuming Youtube videos on demand from my phone in general.
- ActionHank 2y agoI've been looking at this with the recent invidious blocking sadness. Any pointers for your setup?
- ghusto 2y agoHere you go: https://freetubeapp.io/ https://freetubeapp.io/
- eimrine 2y agoFor me it is the only way to enjoy YT because regular videos except streams use to freeze for me in browser from time to time recently even with enough number of frames cached.
- mcbuilder 2y agoThat's like me saying, well who cares that movie prices are going up, I get all on the TPB. Not exactly something to brag about.
- chankstein38 2y agoWhy is this article written as if YouTube Premium was a music service? It even calls Spotify and Apple Music competitors. YT Prem for me is about removing ads from the videos I'm watching and from the interface. I don't know how it relates to Spotify or Apple Music or how they're comparable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- SpaghettiCthulu 2y agoBecause YouTube Music exists
- ImHereToVote 2y agoBecause Youtube Music is included in the price. It has a much wider selection than the competitors since some YouTube videos are included in the music collection.
- ActionHank 2y agoIt's because they bundle yt music with it.
- nervousvarun 2y agoYoutube Music comes with Premium. I canceled my Spotify account when I joined YT Premium. Honestly it was part of how I justified paying for it (allowed me to "kill two birds" and drop another service).
- anvuong 2y agoBecause YT Music is also bundled into the price, and in my opinion it's a decent music streaming service. The big advantage of YT Music is you can find a lot of covers or mashups if you are into that, thanks to Youtube videos.
- 2y ago
- amotinga 2y agoit maybe time to look into curiosity stream I guess.
- petercooper 2y agoI shouldn't tell them this but I'd keep YT Premium at double the price. I'd give up every other video service first. That said, I don't love the idea of paying much more for an unchanged product - I'd expect new features, improved options in the client apps (subscription groups would be epic), and larger payments to the creators I watch, ideally.
- ghusto 2y ago> I shouldn't tell them this but I'd keep YT Premium at double the price. I'd give up every other video service first Why? What is the incredible value you're getting out of YouTube? Genuinely curious, because the moment uBlock stopped working, I just stopped using YouTube and haven't noticed.
- Workaccount2 2y agoYouTube has tons of content that isn't borderline brain damage (it has tons of that too though, no doubt). Other streaming services guide all their content into a wide-audience general-public-friendly funnel. You are not going to find hour long specials on Fourier transforms or technical analyses on the Hubble tension. YouTube also has tons of low-production quality, high informational quality content that doesn't exist anywhere else.
- fkyoureadthedoc 2y agoI, and probably everyone else on my family plan, watch more YouTube than anything else. That isn't saying much for me because I very rarely watch TV shows or movies. I haven't watched Netflix in ages, I just keep it for the family members who do. My kids use mainly YouTube and Crunchyroll, sometimes Disney+.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoIt's the only platform with content in every niche. Netflix, on the other hand, has maybe three niches: documentaries, high production reality TV, high production fiction movies/shows. And that's after scrolling for 20min debating which one you want to watch lest it be a dud after you invested 30min of your time. On Youtube, I consume everything from debates to conversations to the news to police body cam footage (guilty pleasure) to gaming reviews to "upcoming RPG games 2025" to Let's Plays to Starcraft 2 tournaments to video versions of podcasts to interviews with an expert about cardiovascular disease to old seasons of Gordon Ramsay's Kitchen Nightmares to scary story montages for falling asleep. And that's just from me scrolling my homepage while writing this. And I can consume most of that while running around the park with my phone in my pocket. There's just no contest when it comes to which service I'd cancel first vs last.
- sschueller 2y agoI had the special intro rate of 9.99 for Google Music Family which eventually extended to Youtube Premium and then became Youtube Music. Last year google decided "fuck loyalty" and hiked the price to 22.99. Same with Google Apps for Business. What used to be free now costs me $75+ per month and I can't get out of it because I have older family members with large amounts of data that I can't move to another platform. I also can't just upgrade one users account (as was possible before) but instead I need to pay for the more expensive package that has more storage for all users.
- miloignis 2y agoHuh, that's odd - I'm still on my 7.99 personal plan from Google Play Music, and it's working fine - did they only end it for the family plan?
- highcountess 2y agoI am not sure what would make someone expect something like "loyalty" from a corporation. They will lie to you just like any other exploitative narcissistic psychopathic cluster of people, until the second they don't need or want you anymore. Corporations basically a manifestation of what people all across the globe and all throughout time have all identified as various forms of malevolent entities; effectively endless bounds to do harm and effectively zero accountability or consequences. Corporations are essentially parasites on humanity at every single level, from what is kind of like parasocial relationship by proxy that people have largely dependent on or from their connection to the corporation, to the vapid also parasocial identity that many build around their connection to corporations, to the heinous crimes the "corporation" commits on a global scale, often totally around the objective of sucking resources and wealth out of a particular place and/or people.
- sschueller 2y agoBack 20 years ago it cost companies more to aquire new people than to keep existing customers happy. Hence "grandfathering" people was common. Loyalty paid off. I have a netflix account that is older than the founding date listed on Wikipedia yet I pay exactly the same as someone who signs up today.
- lifeinthevoid 2y agoWhat would it take to have some p2p video streaming service to rival Youtube? Say that everyone reserves some space, compute and bandwidth on their phones and computers, what kind of figures are we talking about to make it work at Youtube scale?
- jansan 2y agoWhat will be next? Introducing ads to premium users? I remember when I signed up to Amazon Prime and expected the movies to be ad-free. Haha, how naive I was.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- swozey 2y agoIt's wild how greedy google has gotten with Pichai. Nearly all of my friends who worked on Kubernetes since 2014-2015 have left google with their RTO requirements since 2022-23 where they told everyone they could work remotely now they're actually checking attendance. Advertising over peoples paused videos now? I can't leave Youtube paused in one of my rooms and go to another room and use the internet without 1080p-4k advertisements stealing my bandwith when I'm specifically not using it? I wanted to leave to go to twitter to work on distsys stuff prior to Elon..
- ceronman 2y agoYouTube Premium was already quite expensive. They increased my family plan from €17.99 to €25.99. This is almost a 45% hike! Compare to Netflix which is €13.99. I only pay this to skip ads, but a lot of content creators still have their own ads on the videos. There doesn't seem to be enough value to justify such price hike. I am likely to cancel my subscription.
- Ekaros 2y agoOnce they finally break ad blockers I might be willing to pay 10 or something just to get rids of adds on video. But I doubt they offer anything that sensible without music or other useless crap.
- beejiu 2y agoAt this point, YouTube is just an advertising channel to serve programmatic ads and for creators to sell or promote products to their audience. The content is over-optimized and too commercial. Why would anyone pay that much just to be promoted to, when they can access a production-quality curated library on Netflix, Paramount Plus or Disney+?
- Workaccount2 2y agoIt really depends on what you are into. YouTube is the biggest player (by far) in the higher-level-STEM-video category, which I think many on HN are into. Other big streaming services won't release content if it shoots higher than a 10th grade level. There is Nebula and the like, but even that is still missing a lot.
- nbittich 2y agoWhat's the point if you're still annoyed by nord vpn sponsorships during the video?
- butz 2y agoMore people need to know about Peertube and federated video websites alternative to Youtube. Some creators even post to both.
- MisterTea 2y agoAll streaming services are going up. The other day I received am email from Hulu stating their pricing was going up another dollar for ad free Hulu from $18 to $19. I realized I haven't used Hulu in about two months so I cancelled it with the reason being too much money. I then had to click through two more desperation pages "We'll give you a whole year of 2.99 Hulu if you stay" - No. "How about a whole Disney plus package for the introductory price of" - No. At this point I have no more streaming services. Talking to friends about it and they use vance for youtube and illegal streaming services. I don't think I know anyone who pays for youtube. These companies are only hurting themselves by jacking up prices for what little content they offer.
- imiric 2y agoSlightly tangential: is anyone else flabbergasted at the cookie consent form on this site, and others that use the same ad network? It reads "We value your privacy", followed by a list of 1,573(!!!) "partners" who want access to my personal data. Some of these are opt-in by default due to "legitimate interest", and I'm not sure if the "Reject all" button even applies to them. At least there is one, and it's relatively prominent. The state of advertising on the web has become absolutely insane. The fact YouTube now also shows ads when videos are paused, and they have the gall to increase the price of YT Premium is pure greed. Not only will I never pay for this because I don't won't anything to do that would support this insidious business model, I will dedicate my time and effort to teach others how to do the same. Fuck everything to do with this, and Google primarily for ruining the web. None of their tech contributions comes close to negate the harm they've caused.
- AStonesThrow 2y ago> Some of these are opt-in by default "Opt-in" means that the default is off, and it is optional to the user, if they wish to take action to opt-in to sharing/communications. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opt-in_email https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Opt-in_email "Opt-out" seems like what you mean, where a legitimate interest makes them default to sharing, and you are doubtful whether a "Reject all" opt-out will affect those settings?
- imiric 2y agoRight, that's what I meant. "Opt-in by default" to me means that the default is to share my data, but I can see how that could mean the reverse. Thanks.
- Dylan16807 2y agoI would suggest you say "opted in by default" when you want that meaning, if you particularly want to use the word 'opt'. Then "opt-in" can continue to mean you have to opt to be in, and everyone should avoid saying "opt-in by default".
- 2y ago
- gklitz 2y agoSo google is the new Microsoft trying to bundle their way to market supremacy to murder competitors. I wonder if they just figured they’d calculate in the fines they’ll get for misuse of monopoly already and just don’t consider the cost high enough to care compared to the gain they’ll have from taking over music streaming.
- scoofy 2y ago>The higher subscription fee applies to both individual and family YouTube Premium plans. In Ireland, Belgium, the Netherlands, and Italy, YouTube's Family plan will cost €26 from November, up from €18 — an increase of €8. The individual plan is also getting expensive by €2 to €14 in these countries. Two euro!?! I mean... I subscribe because I think it's a better deal than spotify even if the app is suboptimal, because I want the content creators I visit to get paid, but I've been paying about $14 for years. How in the hell were they only charging two euro.
- maxglute 2y agoI would sub to youtube premium again if 1) replace spotify sub, but right now playlists and likes between youtube and youtube music gets disgustingly intermingled 2) replace patreon sub, determine exactly how much of payment goes to which producers. I don't want an even split, I want my favoured producers to get significantly more $$$. Better yet, I want to make sure I never give a certain cent to some producers. Like if 50% of fees is going towards producers, I want to pick who to support.