8 ms·
It is hard to recommend Google Cloud
- underdeserver 2y agoGoogle's problem has always been customer support. Not just the process but the idea that your customers deserve to be supported when using your product. You shouldn't ask people to migrate before having a documented, tested, tool-assisted, clear and intuitive migration flow that takes very little time.
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y agoAllow me to drop this classic: https://steve-yegge.medium.com/dear-google-cloud-your-deprecation-policy-is-killing-you-ee7525dc05dc https://steve-yegge.medium.com/dear-google-cloud-your-deprec... (and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24165445 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=24165445 and https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38023392 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38023392 ). Because yeah, "support" includes "are you going to keep making me do work just to keep using your platform". (Edit: To be clear, that's negative support, but it's on the same axis)
- yawnxyz 2y agoAt least with Cloudflare they'll get back to you in five minutes as soon as you complain on HN
- usr1106 2y agoI don't know about the 5 minutes, but the CTO replied when I complained in some comment and asked me for a trace. That was extraordinary user service (I am not even a customer), but the problem has not really been solved some 3 months later after sending the trace. One error has been replaced by another one...
- initplus 2y agoI'm also completely sick of fielding API migration emails from Google on mobile Android/Firebase. Feel like I get some "action required" every couple of weeks. This stuff saps our resources, both to fix it, and to diagnose if the issue even applies to us in the first place. If you are lucky Google includes details of the app using the API, but often this part is even left out.
- jdance 2y agoYeah the amount of disrespect of developer time they show here is crazy. You could have made the billing api backwards compatible for 10 years, its a super small api, but instead they force breaking changes every couple of years Maybe it is a strategy for cleaning up old apps or something, but I doubt it
- notepad0x90 2y agoI would say that Googlers are painfully aware of this. But the real problem is leadership. It starts with the CEO and various execs. Their employees are still living in the "growth hacking" and highly academic world (at least their engineers) and their execs are drunken with arrogance, convinced their Titanic will never sink. And they may be partially right, it may not sink but it will never regain its former glory. It will rot on the shelf, besides IBM,AT&T, HP and many more. At its core, alphabet is a services company, it does not sell goods (to the most part). Their board needs to decide if the company should focus on business services or consumer services and replace the executives with people who have experience in that area. The actual quality of GCP is superb in my opinion. They have a flair for architecting excellent solutions. I prefer GCP over any cloud from a purely technical perspective. Their leaders just don't get that it isn't enough. They're not operating a toy or a museum of technical marvels. Actual people need to use it.
- underdeserver 2y agoI worked on GCP, left Google about two years ago. Some Googlers are aware of this, fewer care, and fewer still act on it - you sort of have to be an insane employee* to do that. I saw tickets from high-paying, top-10 customers, go unanswered for days; no one senior enough on the team to answer felt it was more important than the day-to-day, and no one from the support/account executive staff felt they had the authority to demand it. I see it otherwise. I think solving customer support is crucial to GCP's success, and since I agree with you that GCP is the better underlying product, there is a deluge of money passing Google by, just waiting for the right executive team to start caring about this to pick it up. Kind of like Microsoft pre-Satya. * https://yosefk.com/blog/people-can-read-their-managers-mind.html https://yosefk.com/blog/people-can-read-their-managers-mind....
- pm90 2y agoThis is really sad to read. I agree with you that GCP has the superior product. Azure is a fucking joke. AWS sucks but they do respond to feedback and will even get engineers on a call with you if you hit certain edge cases. The level of apathy you describe will very quickly sour users.
- chews 2y agoAfter what they did with domains, it's hard to recommend them for anything to do with cloud.
- jclulow 2y agoThey also just totally fucked anybody making use of the Google Photos API to access their own data: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41604241 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41604241 They're a trash company, and anything you get from them, even when you pay for the storage, is at best accidentally delivered to you and they could roll over in their sleep at any moment and snuff it all out.
- yawnxyz 2y agodon't forget the time everyone's Google Drive photos got corrupted
- initplus 2y agoEven grosser is that they explicitly limited the iOS version of Google Photos to refuse to work with scoped access. So on iOS the app will refuse to work without being granted whole library access, a permission that Google no longer allows to any third party photo app on Android. Blatantly anticompetitive.
- pvtmert 2y agoPS: There is a double/extra words on the first paragraph. > "had to migrate my domain after Google decided to shut down Google Domains decided to shut down."
- ashishb 2y agoThanks for pointing it out. Just fixed.
- jsemrau 2y agoA couple of months I was evaluating Dialogueflow for a chatgpt like ReAct agent I was working on. They have this blue "contact sales" button where you can chat with the sales team. Easy enough I thought, jumping right into it to ask my questions. I am greeted by a virtual guide that doesn't help. Then I ask for a human "Live chat with sales". Again another bot. How did I find out? The bot didn't bat an eye when I informed them I have 6 Billion customers on Mars, Venus, and Pluto. I ended up using streamlit.
- rurban 2y ago> Again another bot. How did I find out? The bot didn't bat an eye when I informed them I have 6 Billion customers on Mars, Venus, and Pluto. That reminds me in their interview process with me. So you are hinting they also use bots for hiring developers. Would explain everything.
- jsemrau 2y agoWouldn't surprise me.
- ehaikawaii 2y agoThis is why everything Google feels evolved, nothing lasts long enough to be obvious legacy bullshit. Cut backs have finally forced AWS to sunset services, but they just hard refused for many, many years. People like using it because the workflows evolve, but AWS will not force migrations on you, sometimes to your own detriment. When you first build an app, everything is fresh because developers haven't had to hamfistedly shove assumption breaking models and patterns into their program yet. Cloud customers want to evolve to the latest tech, but redoing 20 years of the company for no business reason makes programmers happy but executives nervous.
- srockets 2y agoAWS used to just bake keeping the light on into the cost of launching a product. They wouldn’t launch something they weren’t ready to support until the sun becomes a supernova. Sadly, that seems to not be the case anymore, and it’s a worrying development. AWS giving up on their customer obsession makes it easier for the other CSPs, who aren’t as customer friendly, to compete.
- throwaway290 2y agoWhat did AWS sunset? I probably didn't use any of what they killed so that's why unaware, would be good to know
- ocrow 2y agoFor one, the OpsWorks configuration management tool is being replaced with Management Console, which is more encompassing, but different. You have to manually migrate or rebuild any deployed resources from one to the other.
- captn3m0 2y agoQLDB as well.
- gregw2 2y agoSimpleDB, S3 Select, old style EC2s outside VPCs, QLDB, AWS Data Pipelines, Cloud9, CodeCommit, SnowMobile, Forecast are the ones I know. A few more can be found at: https://github.com/SummitRoute/aws_breaking_changes https://github.com/SummitRoute/aws_breaking_changes https://www.thestack.technology/aws-deprecations-services-codecommit/ https://www.thestack.technology/aws-deprecations-services-co... From the outside I dont perceive the promotion dynamics for engineers working on old services is that different at AWS than Google or Azure. Finance and engineering do conspire to kill off things despite customer annoyance, perhaps as they should. There is also a constant churn of retiring EC2 instance types, security certs, old database versions, EMR versions, OS versions, security practices, cost optimizations, etc to suck up your time with minimal business value. This is not different fundamentally than on prem, you just have slightly less control and an outside party forcing your hand to do the right thing isnt purely a bad thing... AWS is pretty good about giving you a grace period to migrate off and informal warnings if they strategically want you to move to a different service of theirs before stuff gets killed if you are looped in with a TAM (e.g Data Pipelines vs more-expensive Glue). They seem to have recently migrated to a strategy where they disable services for new customers but actually dont kill them completely off but keep them on life support.
- patrickhogan1 2y agoI completely agree. The CLI tools are fantastic, and the logging tools are much more user-friendly than AWS. Plus, the console manager is way better than Azure’s clutter. But the decision about domains was a huge misstep. It used to be so easy to buy a domain from Google and get a server running quickly. Why make the user experience so frustrating right from the start?
- ashishb 2y agoI can't agree more, GCP CLI is better than both AWS and Azure's CLI.
- iTokio 2y agoThey definitely lost my trust with Google Domains, somehow I thought that such a foundational infrastructure layer will not be axed as easily, oh boy was I wrong..
- joshdavham 2y agoThat also took me for surprise. You’d figure the company that indexes the web could at least maintain a project like that.
- devsda 2y agoGoogle registry owns like 40 odd gTLDs. A company that maintains that many TLDs is expected to have long term commitment to the domain related businesses but it turns out to be just a fleeting interest.
- ErneX 2y agoSame here and I even unsubscribed from Google One after I moved my domains.
- ocular-rockular 2y agoWhat cloud storage solution do you use instead? That's been one of my problems for things like photos and documents so I've just stuck with Google One.
- ErneX 2y agoI signed up when I had a Pixel and now I'm back to iPhone so I'm subbed to iCloud now, also because it includes HomeKit cameras recording functionality. I used Google Photos on the iPhone for a while though, it worked fine you just have to open their app so it syncs.
- jpgvm 2y agoGoogle Domains shutdown was an own-goal. They should have just ran it at a loss forever if that is what it took, the optics were and are just awful. I get it, it was a "consumer" product essentially, hence selling the business to Squarespace instead of someone like Cloudflare. But anything related to DNS is going to make infra folk very wary of what else you might be willing to kill or neuter. It's just at that level of fundamental things that make operators skittish.
- MattGaiser 2y agoShouldn’t have been much of a loss. Tons and tons and tons of domain registrars exist, so it’s not an inherently expensive business.
- wolpoli 2y agoWhile it's likely profitable, it's probably not generating AdSense level margin/growth.
- Kwpolska 2y agoGoogle Domains was a service where no new features could be added, so nobody would get promoted for working on it, so nobody wanted to maintain it. Classic Google.
- jmillikin 2y ago> I get it, it was a "consumer" product essentially, hence selling the > business to Squarespace instead of someone like Cloudflare. Ironically, I moved all my Google Domains domains to Cloudflare. Their revenue from being a domain registrar is likely a rounding error compared to their other products, but (1) now they have my credit card on file for value-add services, and (2) sometimes people with corporate spending authority ask me for advice about who they should buy cloud services from. Grocery stores don't make their money from selling bread and milk, but a store that doesn't sell bread and milk is run by fools.
- ac50hz 2y ago
- xyproto 2y agoI wonder if Cloud Run or Kubernetes is the safest bet for the future, when using Google Cloud.
- joshdavham 2y agoFingers crossed. I love Cloud Run.
- cpa 2y agoIt’s good but extremely expensive. I opted for a custom solution, and it’s now costing me a tenth of the price.
- xyproto 2y agoInteresting. Did you buy and setup your own servers, use a different company to host services in the cloud, or something in between?
- cpa 2y agoI just rented servers on OVH instead. I mostly do CPU intensive and highly parallel computations, and went from 3500€ to 300€ for my usage. As a startup I often put simplicity and ease of use before pricing but in this case that was too much of a difference!
- xyproto 2y agoThat makes sense. Thanks for the insight!
- icedchai 2y agoSame. Cloud Run is a really nice product. It makes deploying containers a breeze and simpler than AWS's equivalent service (ECS / Fargate.) I also found GCP's developer tools and docs to be quite solid, better than AWS. Example: It's nice that they provide Terraform snippets for most of their resources.
- eastbound 2y agoMany here say they won’t use Google for anything cloud, but hoe many of you have Gmail for Workplace at work? Probably everyone. It’s the best solution for work emails, docs, calendars, etc.
- zinekeller 2y ago> It’s the best solution It's the least worst solution for "whole-workplace" systems, but most people who are saying "won’t use Google for anything cloud" probably self-host or use something like PurelyMail (https://purelymail.com/ https://purelymail.com/) or FastMail (https://www.fastmail.com/ https://www.fastmail.com/) for their own emails
- Dalewyn 2y agoI use my Hotmail for all my important emails, my Gmail is my catch-all for everything else. Why Hotmail? Because if the name isn't enough indication it's because I've had it for well over 25 years at this point and I like Microsoft anyway.
- throwaway984393 2y agoOffice365 is way better. You get native apps, which are obviously better than a web app, you get device integrations for enterprise, you get more advanced tooling, more features. Plus MS has better compliance options. If you're actually running a business, and not just a startup employee who doesn't need to do much, MS is the way.
- ryanjshaw 2y agoNot sure why you got downvoted to dead. In big companies, M365 is a way more common and complete solution compared to anything else out there. This is just a fact - I actually really like e.g. Google Sheets, but the reality is that M365 can integrate with your Microsoft stack top-to-bottom and has low-code app, automation and database services that allow you to build out a good chunk of common LOB apps with minimal complexity (not that Dataverse doesn't have some ridiculous issues).
- richardw 2y agoMatthew 7:27 “And everyone who hears these words of mine and does not do them will be like a foolish man who built his house on Google’s ever-shifting infrastructure.”
- joshdavham 2y agoIt’s true. Two weeks ago, I did a bit of light consulting for a data engineering project involving an IoT device and half way through designing the GCP architecture of the pipeline, I realized that Google was shutting down their IoT service… I ended up having to recommend AWS.
- postsantum 2y agoGoogle lost the rest of my trust with the ongoing fiasco with google play dev verification where many developers are not able to confirm their phone numbers for months and are at risk of losing their accounts. I can totally see myself being banned from GC for some nebulous reason or being locked out of account with no recourse. Their support bots are useless
- arresin 2y agoThat worries me in general about Google. You will trip some wire in some garbage code somewhere and that’s it, you’re locked out and banned for life with effectively no recourse and no hope.
- merb 2y agoGoogle domains was not integrated into google cloud. And artifact registry is the better product and you had like 3 years time to migrate , which was a simple button press and changing the urls of the images. Of course it took some work, but it is not more expensive, effectively it’s cheaper since you can more easily clean up old images
- Kwpolska 2y ago> and changing the URLs of the images The URLs might be mentioned in many different places. Why break URLs just to make a "better product"? Why couldn't the new product keep old URLs working?
- throwaway984393 2y ago[dead]
- darby_nine 2y agoIt's clear google wants to be a dumb pipe rather than a business that's responsive to end-user needs. Unfortunately, they're also notoriously unreliable as a dumb pipe.
- postsantum 2y agoTheir end-users are advertisizers spending millions. For them Google is probably very responsive. The rest of us are users of pet projects at best and product at worst
- darby_nine 2y agoThe term end-user does not refer to advertisers by definition. Typically most people use the term "user" to refer to humans. You're not wrong, but advertisers are a cancer on society that not only do not contribute any value but actively destroy the world around us. it's difficult to assign anything but deeply negative value to their needs and concerns.
- peterbmarks 2y agoNever forget what happened to Australian UniSuper when google accidentally deleted their account. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/article/2024/may/09/unisuper-google-cloud-issue-account-access https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/article/2024/may/... "More than half a million UniSuper fund members went a week with no access to their superannuation accounts after a “one-of-a-kind” Google Cloud “misconfiguration” led to the financial services provider’s private cloud account being deleted, Google and UniSuper have revealed."
- politelemon 2y agoMozilla had an outage in 2022 when gcp deployed an unannounced change. https://hacks.mozilla.org/2022/02/retrospective-and-technical-details-on-the-recent-firefox-outage/ https://hacks.mozilla.org/2022/02/retrospective-and-technica...
- throwawaygoog31 2y agoThis is completely false. TA account because I am not authorized to speak on this, but that’s not at all what happened.
- nielsole 2y agoI think the latest public information was that it was a VMware "private cloud", a set of VMs, in GCP which accidentally had an expiration date set. So no GCP projects/billing accounts were ever deleted. Is that accurate?
- antifa 2y agoWhat is an expiration date if not a scheduled deletion date? Is it a soft-deletion? It's clearly ambiguous to me, who has no previous knowledge of this event before a minute ago. "Google auto deletes account at expiration date" seems to be a reasonable interpretation of what's been presented to me so far.
- smitty1e 2y agoWe should always maintain a healthy skepticism in either direction, and maybe supporting that is your purpose, but: why should your throwaway account be believed?
- mupuff1234 2y ago> there has been little upside in doing these migrations. Maybe the upside is that Google is in exchange able to offer: > Google Cloud - great engineering, good product.
- KeepOnTruckin1 2y agoI remember once consulting one of my client who used GCP and to get SSH to one of the instances where pain in ass, I spent couple of hours on that. If I recall correctly they do have concept of users and then user gets SSH key and you can't just put SSH key on instance out of the box as on any other VPS...
- icedchai 2y agoThey make it pretty easy to SSH in through both the console and with the gcloud command. If you set it up correctly, Linux user accounts are tied to GCP IAM accounts and are automatically provisioned. It's actually super slick! Maybe your client didn't want to do that.
- jodiug 2y agoI'm surprised to find all comments so strongly against Google. I do not like their customer support nor their surprise product closure acts... but I do find their cloud interface easy to use, pricing is solid, and (K8s/Cloud Run) I have barely been affected by any significant outage in some 8 years of use. Contrast to Azure who despite their SLA had significant outages every few months that were very noticeable, sometimes even requiring us setting up an entire new K8s project from scratch. AWS is better in terms of reliability. Their UX is not great though, I often feel like I'm a wizard waving my wand with permissions and connecting things like audit trails. Many actions are a bit delayed in their effect. I've also had to contact support at times to raise arbitrary limits in the platform. In balance I would recommend GCP. Their product closures have not affected me enough to scare me away. I guess experiences vary depending on which product we are using.
- chii 2y agoi would say that smaller, independent enterprises/solo shops tend to not hate GCP. Large shops - aka, a shop where you're not part of the controlling entity - tend to prefer either AWS, or Azure depending on how hard the CIO got wined and dined previously (and existing inertia - older shops that used AWS as an early adopter seems to stay with AWS). > Their UX is not great though i agree, but nobody really cares enough. On the other hand, i'd not pay more for better UX. Judging by the current state, i say a lot of customers fall into this category.
- politelemon 2y agoAssuming AWS/Azure were chosen due to thinly veiled bribery is unnecessarily reductive and in bad faith.
- makeitdouble 2y agoAs a matter of fact Google Cloud will also wine and dine a CTO as needed. That's part of the sales process IMHO. A decision maker can basically choose from where they want to get bribed, so it won't be a crucial factor most of the time.
- throwaway343233 2y agoEh. I wouldn’t use GCP precisely for this reason if I was building something on cloud. Customer obsession (ugh) is just not in their DNA. I can tell firsthand they care more about what they want to do than what the customers want.
- cornflake23 2y agoQuite frankly, it’s hard to recommend any Cloud Service nowadays. Technical issues apart, the strategy _everywhere_ is to maximize picking the customers’ pockets. AWS is super expensive, Azure is super unreliable and GCP … well, it’s reliable yet features on it could vanish at a moments notice. Where might one go?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- surgical_fire 2y ago> Where might one go? Most should just own their infrastructure, or use a more simple hosting service. Most companies could go very far with that. Unless youf business is a global one with hundreds of millions of users in many jurisdictions, there is really no reason to go for cloud services. They tend to be much more expensive then the alternative, and have many ways to lock you in by making migration very expensive and time consuming.
- nvarsj 2y agoFor a medium size biz, I'd probably still recommend using GKE or EKS. A smallish EKS cluster of a few nodes will cost <1k a month for everything, it's fully managed so you don't need to pay anyone except for the initial setup. Otw the cheaper operational cost would be to setup a few hetzner servers and manage your own infra via kubernetes or docker/ansible runbooks. But you should budget a few days each month for maintenance and general support, plus you'll need someone skilled in server maintenance to set it all up (becoming a rarish skill these days). If on a ramen budget, you can set it up and let it rot until everything breaks, then migrate to EKS. :)
- ashishb 2y agoI have yet to see a GKE/EKS setup that does not require ~250+ hours of a mid-level engineer's time a year (amortized). Unless there is a team of 20+ engineers, I cannot recommend Kubernetes to anyone. It is a great primitive that's too primitive for smaller teams.
- 2y ago
- acje 2y agoI generally view churn and nice primitives to be the essential balancing act for a platform. Perhaps any leading edge (software)system. We aren’t going to get anything complex perfect the first time, so it is change or mediocrity.
- acje 2y agoFunny. This is genuinely one of my deepest insights after 17 years in IT, some of it even as lead on infrastructure and platforms. Perhaps not well formulated, ok. And to date one of my most down voted comments on HN. What are the incentives supposed to achieve?
- bob1029 2y agoAWS has been feeling like the least terrible of the big 3 lately. Domain registration is the canary for me. Only AWS does it right. Azure has some approach but they force you into a lock in service and rely on GoDaddy for the actual registration. These vendors underestimate the impact of having something so fundamental managed by a weird 3rd party. Route53 gives me a lot of confidence that I'm not going to be jerked around with domains and DNS. This factors heavily into my purchasing decisions.
- remram 2y agoI use the free tiers of Google Cloud and Oracle Cloud, and pay AWS for everything important (that I can't run bare-metal). Azure I can't use at all. Impossible to find the products I want in the UI.
- fsflover 2y agoA few Google-support-related threads on HN: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32547912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32547912 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33737577 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33737577 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35133917 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=35133917 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22146082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22146082 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22705122 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=22705122 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4013799 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=4013799
- siscia 2y agoThe article mentions that some primitive of GCP are nicer (than AWS?). I wonder if you guys have any example of those nicer primitives.
- arianvanp 2y agoI find IAM a bit easier in google. I am policies attach to resources instead of principals. And resources are hierarchical. Basically as if you had S3 bucket policies for everything. Though I'm sure you'll find someone saying the exact opposite is more useful
- cess11 2y agoI agree. This is the one thing I find easier on GCP than AWS, taking total control over a GCP environment I'm about to enter is much faster and less confusing. It's irritating that I need old accounts to do exports but usually I can reset credentials on some old ones and find one with MFA I can bypass. But it's still a rather nasty environment to handle, as is all the big clowns. There's lock-in, confusing products, lots of general weirdness. Unless the corporation I'm taking control over has exercised discipline and restraint and stuck to a rig with simple EC2 instances every project makes me hate them more. As far as I can tell the way to go if you enjoy this kind of operating environment is to buy on-prem OpenShift. The guys I've met that run that seem to think it's the lesser evil.
- ashishb 2y agoAs an example, Google Cloud Run[1] is far superior to AWS Fargate and Azure App Services[2] 1 - https://ashishb.net/tech/how-to-deploy-side-projects-as-web-services-for-free/ 2 - https://ashishb.net/programming/how-to-deploy-docker-images-on-microsoft-azure/ Even Google Cloud CLI is far more usable than AWS CLI.
- jeffrallen 2y agoCome over to the second tier side... Smaller cloud providers cannot (and do not want to) afford the costs of constant product churn. So you get a smoother, long term relationship with a smaller company that's more likely aligned with your goals. Disclosure: I work for a European second tier cloud provider.
- asah 2y agoFascinating to see all this hate, and at the same time Google is reporting terrific growth and profitability for GCP. Any idea how? Large customers? https://www.google.com/search?q=google+cloud+profitable https://www.google.com/search?q=google+cloud+profitable
- aabhay 2y agoDiscounts
- asah 2y agoThe profitability is publicly reported, and would be after discounting. (that said, if the discounting came from another division say ads, then it could be buried... no idea if Google is doing this...)
- re-thc 2y ago> Fascinating to see all this hate Is this "hate" coming from the actual buyers though? Often the 1s commenting are the actual "users" just not the 1 that's paying the bill.
- PunchTornado 2y agoI guess people will rant about any cloud provider the same way. The tech needs to mature. Wait till someone starts an azure thread, God I wish i never have to touch azure anymore in my life.
- edem 2y agothe main problem with Google is that they can delete your account... in fact automation will do nasty stuff to you and you can't reach a human. this makes their products a hard no. in fact i spent weeks migrating away even from gmail and now i have my own hosted domain
- abrbhat 2y agoGoogle just does not have enterprise DNA which requires providing long-term support for legacy systems. AWS on the other hand was able to achieve this through their customer obsession. But the absolute king in this still remains Microsoft which is why enterprises will adopt Azure with their eyes closed.
- emadda 2y agoThe pricing on some services can also be surprising. A cloud load balancer is $20/month before you even handle traffic. I think they are introducing a $1.50 charge for every uptime check, when they were initially free.
- andrewstuart 2y agoGo get yourself an IONOS VPS $50/month. 1GBps internet connection 12 vCores CPU 24 GB RAM 640 GB NVMe SSD Unlimited outbound data.
- themoonisachees 2y agoMost people paying for GCP are in need of much more than a VPS and also are quite probably not the decision makers
- tjpnz 2y agoThe fact that Google will shutdown accounts without warning and either ignore or gaslight those who seek to rectify the situation is enough reason for me to never recommend GCP. No argument that they're somehow different remotely sways me - I do not trust them.
- unkoman 2y agoIn 2019 when working for a cloud consultancy they paid us to certify for Google cloud with the promise of many new customers. In reality since then the consultancy fired all pure Google cloud consultants. I myself have had about three Google cloud only focused projects. A lot of promises but nothing came out of it. It doesn't help that the platform has stagnated and customers are afraid of committing due to loss of features. In comparison AWS doesn't remove features for customers or always provide alternative ways to migrate to. SimpleDb is the prime example here.
- Gud 2y agoDon’t rely on large multi domain mega corporations for basic infrastructure. They can yank it away from you in no time and they probably will.
- sireat 2y agoRant time: Why does anyone use GCP? I had not used GCP for a few years and recently tried to get a simple webapp scaffolding up. So I see the myriad of services offered by GCP, I pick: https://console.cloud.google.com/products/solutions/details/dynamic-web-app https://console.cloud.google.com/products/solutions/details/... Dynamic web application with Python and JavaScript. Okay, I've built these things before, let's see the Google way. Nice, there is a diagram, there's Firebase, there's Django, there's PostgreSQL, something called cloud storage. A bit of an overkill, but let's roll with it. Okay, let's click Deploy. This should give us some sort of ready to use stub, placeholder, template right? Wrong. Resources tab shows 65 actions/resources created. All nice green checkmarks, there is IAM, there Firebase, there is Cloud Storage, Secret Manager, and everything else under the sun. 65 green checkmarks - that is good right? However the app itself is not ready to be shown to the world! Apparently there is something missing in Firebase config (remember this is the default deploy for a new user): Google helpfully informs me Why am I seeing this? There are a few potential reasons: You haven't deployed an app yet. You may have deployed an empty directory. This is a custom domain, but we haven't finished setting it up yet. How can I deploy my first app? Refer to our hosting documentation to get started. So I go hosting documentation link and that is just generic: https://firebase.google.com/docs/hosting/ https://firebase.google.com/docs/hosting/ Meanwhile all this nice setup is costing about $2.40 every 24 hours. The issue isn't the complexity of the solution, or the lack or over abundance of documentation. The issue is that their sample "Hello World" app is not ready. I should not need to go through stacks of extra documentation to find out what is wrong when trying a sample product of some complexity. Why should I be forced to fight abstraction leaks immediately when starting to use GCP?
- edem 2y agoI never used GCP NGL. Google always rubbed me the wrong way and I ended up migrating away even from gmail
- ashishb 2y agoIf you always used Azure, then you have no idea what reliability is. If you always used AWS, then you have no idea what great developer experience is. GCP is fairly reliable and has a great developer experience. I wish more AWS folks used GCP to make AWS a better developer experience.
- more_corn 2y agoI wrestled with GCP a month ago. Never again. Hundreds of internal permissions issues, a thing Google invented for no reason. APIS needing to be turned on. A feature I didn’t ask for and don’t want. Service accounts that don’t have permissions to do what those service accounts are for. I used to think any cloud is as good as another. Not anymore. It’s not hard to recommend Google cloud. It’s impossible.
- godisdad 2y agoShoutout to the GCP apologists: your faith in the face of overwhelming evidence contradicting the stability of the offering will be remembered heroically by history
- synthc 2y agoGCP has the superior UI, api and design. I prefer it over the other clouds: Azure plain sucks and AWS has too much bloat and does IAM/accounts worse. In my experience GCP's core services are very stable: I had a site running on free tier App Engine for over 10 years without any supervision. However it is clear that many GCP products are run by skeleton crews and will not improve. Documentation is also lacking sometimes. Dataform for example is conceptually a great tool, but hampered by really basic UI bugs. I found Datastream (change data capture tool) impossible to use. You would think that shoveling data between 2 GCP products (Postgres and BigQuery) would be easy, but I spend a week fiddling with obscure network settings before giving up.
- ashishb 2y ago> GCP has the superior UI, api and design. I prefer it over the other clouds: Azure plain sucks and AWS has too much bloat and does IAM/accounts worse. I agree. > In my experience GCP's core services are very stable: I had a site running on free tier App Engine for over 10 years without any supervision. I won't be surprised that Google App Engine is already in maintenance mode. > In my experience GCP's core services are very stable Would you call Google Domains a core service or not? Would you call Container Registry a core service or not?
- 486sx33 2y agoHonestly I’ve been so disappointed in Google since they dropped don’t be evil They are evil now
- LaserToy 2y agoTry Azure. I thought AWS was bad till I faced GCP support and some weirdness. I thought GCP was not great till I faced Azure.
- gerash 2y agoWhy do these shallow pointless blog posts get up voted to the first page of HN?