8 ms·
> Lot of people critiquing this, but you can't deny the success. You could say that about literally any shady business. Imagine seeing a PDF proving tobacco le
by latexr 2y ago
> Lot of people critiquing this, but you can't deny the success.
You could say that about literally any shady business. Imagine seeing a PDF proving tobacco leaders knew for decades that it caused cancer and saying what you did.
Being monetarily successful does not mean you’re good or shouldn’t be criticised.
- t_mann 2y agoCan you point to the parts of the document, or other resources about Mr. Beast, that warrant a comparison with tobacco companies?
- TibbityFlanders 2y ago[dead]
- ipsento606 2y ago> Can you point to the parts of the document, or other resources about Mr. Beast, > that warrant a comparison with tobacco companies? The part where the GP says "Lot of people critiquing this, but you can't deny the success." invites counterexamples of companies that are successful but still deserving of critique.
- wesselbindt 2y agoThey make money in ways that others would find morally reprehensible. The tobacco industry makes its money off of addictive substances that kill millions per year, and Donaldson makes content for entertainment that literally tortures people in the sense of being a violation of the geneva convention. In both cases they're highly efficient operations that make a lot of money, but whether or not you would call it a success story depends on your definition of success. If your definition of successful is "makes money", then the tobacco industry, Donaldson, fentanyl dealers, etc are indeed successful. If your definition is "the world is a better place for its existence", then not so much. Regarding sources: if you're genuinely interested and not just being argumentative for argument's sake, you're capable of googling "MrBeast geneva convention" and following the sources from there.
- gruez 2y ago>and Donaldson makes content for entertainment that literally tortures people in the sense of being a violation of the geneva convention What specific acts are we talking about? "violation of the geneva convention" could mean literally anything between "putting red cross symbols on soldiers" and "summarily executing civilians", so it doesn't really narrow things down. If they're being put in uncomfortable positions, but they're not risking long term harm and it's voluntary, I don't see what the issue is.
- ahmedfromtunis 2y agoI'd love to see that document and I'm sure there's a lot to learn from it and a lot of knowledge to use for the good of humanity. The fact that a shady business used some tactics to advance its cause doesn't automatically condemns the means.
- MeetingsBrowser 2y agoMost shady businesses can be boiled down to, “we exploit people for personal gain”. Which is always bad.
- ahmedfromtunis 2y ago[flagged]
- brailsafe 2y agoAnd Mr Beast dangles a fortune in front of one of his employees that grew up in poverty to pressure them into staying in a room for 100 days with all the lights on. Guess it's all the same though.
- hsbauauvhabzb 2y agoHow is that worse than grocery stores price gouging resulting in malnourishment, starvation and homelessness?
- chefandy 2y agoYou're dramatically overestimating the profitability of selling groceries. Most of the high prices come from further up the supply chain, or other parts of the local economies like rent, utilities, transportation, and labor. Obviously some stores are better than others, but if some company is just milking people in any given grocery market, competitors will show up in a second to take their customers away. Even in food deserts served only by expensive bodegas and the like— selling fresh food at low volumes is fucking expensive because of how much waste you have, and beyond that, your street corner retail space is a whole lot more expensive per food item than a grocery store on the edge of town.
- ocean_moist 2y ago>Imagine seeing a PDF proving tobacco leaders knew for decades that it caused cancer and saying what you did. The difference is the game he's playing (youtube) is similar to the game we're playing (startups) so the success is tantamount. The game tobacco companies play is also very different, so the tobacco companies success will teach you very little about being successful in startups.
- barrell 2y agoPersonally the game I’m playing (building an effective edtech company) is probably less similar to the game he is playing (running illegal lotteries targeted at children) than the game Tabacco companies play (lean heavily on branding, marketing, and trying to control the academic narrative).
- wrsh07 2y agoIgnoring the ethics of Mr Beast, he is producing real videos at an incredibly high volume and they consistently do numbers. None of those videos is easy to make. Sure, it's maybe not great to be so impressed by logistics or supply chain of a tobacco company, but from a business and systems view some of it is interesting
- lxgr 2y ago> Ignoring the ethics [...] I think that's very straightforwardly the point of contention here. Some people are doing that and are discussing the business aspects; others aren't. I don't think any particular discussion is more appropriate than the other, as long as people are in agreement on which one they're having.
- barrell 2y agoI don’t know if they’re necessarily two different conversations - there’s a conversation to be had whether the business practices discussed would have been effective in an ethical operation. It’s entirely possible the success has nothing to do with the business principles and 100% the ethics. Same the other way around, or anywhere in between.
- dclowd9901 2y agoI would be genuinely curious to hear: in your mind, could any system be interesting to you, no matter its ethical basis? Or is there a line, and if so, what is the line to you?
- supriyo-biswas 2y agoWhy I can't separate learning about a topic and finding the knowledge interesting vs. its value judgement against my worldview?
- teucris 2y agoAgree and I’ll take it a step further: shouldn’t we encourage deep understanding of malicious or unethical systems so we can know how they work and possibly thwart them?
- forrestthewoods 2y agoWhat’s shady about producing entertaining videos that people want to watch? Are Marvel films shady for being popular? Is HN shady for adding features which increase engagement?
- vintermann 2y agoHeck yes, Marvel films, any big Hollywood films, are shady. HN is basically a vanity project so it's less shady. If HN was "optimized for engagement" the way a MrBeast video or Marvel film is, I bet I'm not the only one who would be out of here.
- briandear 2y agoHN puts the most popular submissions on top. Allows commenting and reviews, greys out low voted content. You don’t think this is optimized for for engagement? Don’t let the beige design fool you.
- ralfd 2y agohn is not optimized (thank good) and didn’t change in forever. There is also no monetizing, it doesn’t have ads nor subscription, and if it were more popular it would be more expensive to host. Instead look at reddit is desperately trying (inline ads, chat, avatars, forcing app use)
- icemelt8 2y agonot everyone likes to run a charity, some have a family to feed
- high_na_euv 2y agoHN has ads.
- itishappy 2y ago> There is also no monetizing, it doesn’t have ads nor subscription... This is false. HN is hosted by YC, and as such promotes YC ventures. On the front page right now is the following link (with disallowed comments and upvotes): https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/continue/jobs/smcxRnM-software-engineer https://www.ycombinator.com/companies/continue/jobs/smcxRnM-...
- nine_k 2y agoImagine that our bitter enemies invented a superior logistics tool, known as the wheel. Should we even consider adopting it, given its clearly ethically unacceptable origins? If you think that this is an entirely artificial example, consider the fact that the same man designed the V-2 rockets which were hitting London during WWII, and the Saturn-5 rockets which brought astronauts to Moon: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wernher_von_Braun https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wernher_von_Braun
- barrell 2y agoImagine that our bitter ememies invented a superior logistics tool, known as the wheel. They also invented airplanes and the concept of blitzkrieg. Should we attribute their success to the wheel, and study how it was designed, since they clearly had a mighty army? I think the idea being debated here is that it’s impossible to know whether the business practices would work without the lack of ethics. It might not be a good case study or a direction you want people going in as it might put them in some of the ethically compromising positions, or even worse require people to put themselves in those positions to work
- TeMPOraL 2y agoIf we're going this way, the next question - and a real one, this time - is whether we should study and use the medical data they acquired doing very unethical things to prisoners.
- barrell 2y agoI’m not going to pretend to have an answer to that question, it’s above my pay grade. But I would be comfortable pushing back on the idea that we should structure and operate our medical clinics like theirs because they made scientific breakthroughs.
- TeMPOraL 2y agoIt's above my paygrade too, but what I remember from occasional discussions of that case is that: - The obvious take is, the evil deed's already been done, the knowledge it produced can save lives and can't realistically be re-gathered any other way, so why not use it? - The counter to that is, using it legitimizes and encourages similar acts in the future. (Personally, I can see the encouragement angle; disagree with legitimization.) - There's often a side thread going on about how the atrocities and those who committed them were not Up To Scientific Standards, therefore all their data is invalid, so there's no reason to use it anyway. (Personally, I think this is a lame cop-out, used when one feels the ethical argument is too weak to stand on its own.)
- xupybd 2y agoThis is not comparable
- COAGULOPATH 2y ago>Being monetarily successful does not mean you’re good or shouldn’t be criticised. Is anyone saying that Mr Beast is good and shouldn't be criticised? I can't see them.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thisisabore 2y agoNo but bro, listen bro, he does numbers.
- oulipo 2y agoExactly!! we need to stop conflating "efficiency" with "success" Being efficient at destroying the planet is NOT success If anything we need to go slower and gentler (environmentally, socially, economically), not "faster"
- wrasee 2y agoBut also perhaps not conflating “success” with morally positive outcomes. Being efficient at destroying the planet is to successfully destroy the planet. I think the original point was precisely to separate the concepts that make something successful - to be successful at what you do - from a judgement on the outcomes - the thing that you are doing.
- mihaic 2y ago> But also perhaps not conflating “success” with morally positive outcomes. The reason why I would conflate them is that success had a positive social implication. You get respect if you're successful. In order to separate these concept, I'd use language that doesn't have positive connotations. "Efficient" is more than accurate.
- this_steve_j 2y agoThe scope of “success” under examination in this guide is tailored for an artificial economic organism that wants to survive and capitalize in a particular competitive marketplace (YouTube). It is almost certainly not generalizable advice for achieving “success” in the cooperative game of life on earth.
- johnnyanmac 2y agoThat's probably why we need some morals to come in and balance stuff. You want quick and easy money, you run drugs or sell your body. I'm sure you can be very successful in both if you optimize to be successful in those ventures. But those are not only societally looked down upon but illegal is most US states. Your success here also lies on the ability to operate discreetly out of the eyes of the law. Would that be a success? (even if I personally believe they should be legal).
- bulbosaur123 2y ago> You could say that about literally any shady business. Right, and where is the problem with that again?
- 31337Logic 2y agoExactly this. Thank you. We share a planet with nearly 10 billion other people. Money isn't everything.
- dang 2y agoWe detached this subthread from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41550368 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41550368.