9 ms·
A Post-Google World?
- wslh 2y agoBefore reading the article, I assumed it was about LLMs. It looks like the regulators have perfectly timed their focus on Google’s business. Is Microsoft laughing at this point?
- kmeisthax 2y agoOnly in the narrow sense that Microsoft managed to avoid structural remedies due to Bush Jr. shenanigans that were forgotten because the case was settled three days before 9/11. In the broader sense they've got loads of consent decrees on them, first from the US, then from the EU. They can't even kick CrowdStrike out of the NT kernel! Even among big tech, Google is an unusually meaty target because: 1. Literally all but two of their consumer product lines are acquisitions. A significant part of their ads network is also acquisitions. Most of those product lines and ad network divisions were preceded by internally-developed business units that were marketplace failures. Google does not build, it buys. 2. Android is FOSS, which neatly tidies away a lot of the "we have a right to monetize our IP" arguments that Apple loves to trot out. 3. They paid Facebook bucket-loads of money to keep them from launching a competing ad network under the "Jedi Blue" program. This is textbook illegal behavior and doesn't require any new theories of antitrust like, say, the Epic lawsuit did. 4. Google doesn't comply with litigation holds. Civil litigation is a Constitution-free zone, you can't take the 5th in this kind of trial, meaning that you can be forced to self-incriminate, and if you do not do so, the judge is free to make adverse inferences. 5. Google doesn't have a single charismatic(?) leader. Apple had Steve Jobs, who could invent the monopolistic business model and then conveniently die[0] before anyone with power started to question it. Google has a bunch of executives that all have to e-mail one another, which means that even with their cavalier attitude towards recordkeeping, something winds up getting recorded, making the missing information even more incriminating. The one thing I can't answer with this set of answers is why Facebook isn't getting as much scrutiny as Google is, especially since Facebook has proven to be such a good conduit for scammers and disinformation. Facebook has even less ability to leverage "copyright disclaims antitrust" than Google does. [0] Constitution or no, a judge can't compel a corpse to testify.
- fallingknife 2y agoBesides 3, what does any of this have to do with anti-trust law?
- wslh 2y agoRegarding point 1, and in comparison to Microsoft, the company has historically acquired other businesses to fuel its growth (DOS, cough cough...). This is a normal playbook.
- oldpersonintx 2y ago[dead]
- LegionMammal978 2y ago> At some point, they will give up and realize that the writing is on the wall for their current business model. I'd sooner think hell would freeze over than Google would ever 'give up' on its business model of its own accord. I can hardly imagine half of its services being viable as separate businesses. Which might well be a boon for competitors (especially in adtech), but not for any of Google's current employees or stakeholders.
- tmpz22 2y agoIf profits degrade for Google society will feel the impact pretty quickly. Think about how many schools rely on Google for Education for email, SSO, and Chromebooks. Think about people who rely on Google Maps, Sheets, Docs, and other loss-leading products. Think about all the data they scoop up in all their apps. Late game capitalism applied to Google's portfolio would be catastrophic.
- tylerrobinson 2y agoThat bad, huh? I reckon everything you mentioned has a perfect substitute. What am I missing?
- sethjgore 2y agoI would think the sense of seamless integration contributes to the experience. Almost all third party software systems have integrations and plugins that make crossing over between Google suite and these near painless. Obviously this would be solved if we had a way to centralize our identity and file storage and such across platforms and systems. Yet at the moment the silo is what makes it seems painless and increases its value beyond the fact there’s a substitute to each platform and product.
- Arainach 2y agoIntegration, management, accessibility, auditing and compliance for starters. Tech folks love to say "X is is perfect substitute for Y" in the same way they say "what's so hard about X, I could write that in a week" by considering only simple ideal workflows. The real value, and the real moat for these products, is that they're tied in with SSO and other products, easy for organizations small to huge to manage, have dozens or hundreds of specialized features crucial to large organizations. They comply with legal regulations, accessibility standards (which ARE legal regulations in many jurisdictions such as if you want to sell to the government), and more. Writing an email server is perhaps 2% of the work involved in building an email product.
- talldayo 2y ago> Neither case is finished. In the Epic Games case, Judge Donato is likely to come out with a proposed remedy shortly, which will basically force Google to allow other app stores to exist. Android users are all glancing at each other like John Travolta in Pulp Fiction right now.
- SoftTalker 2y agoI don't see how this is a problem. Back in the days when we used to buy software for PCs you could go pick up WordPerfect or Lotus or whatever at any number of bookstores, office supply stores, or mail order outlets. Fundamentally I see no problem with multiple app stores, it will be a boon for developers as the stores will have to compete over how much of a cut they take. Or developers can sell direct.
- wiseowise 2y agoAndroid already has alternative app stores.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- webstrand 2y agoNevertheless you can't install a Kindle app that you can actually buy books through: Google's monopoly has prevented this.
- oasisaimlessly 2y agoYou definitely can; just get the Kindle app from anywhere[1][2] besides Google Play Store. I installed it via Samsung's "Galaxy Store" and I buy books in-app often. * [1]: https://galaxystore.samsung.com/detail/com.amazon.kindlefs?langCd=en https://galaxystore.samsung.com/detail/com.amazon.kindlefs?l... * [2]: https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-com-Kindle-for-Android/dp/B004DLPXAO https://www.amazon.com/Amazon-com-Kindle-for-Android/dp/B004...
- soared 2y agoGenerally an excellent and accurate write up, nervous/excited to see where this goes. A bit over the top with some of the things google has done in the programmatic space, but aligns with reality. I disagree with the display/programmatic space innovations being held back by google - there are an insane amount of small players who are doing different things and it’s easy to integrate them into the existing space. IE if I want to measure foot traffic, there are like 6 vendors who all do it slightly differently, 1 huge and 5 small companies, some super anti-privacy and some very pro privacy. Its is called out in the article but not made extremely clear - the vertical integration google has is insane. They own the sell, intermediary, buy, measure, and operations software for a large percentage of the space. Imagine if NYSE owned Fidelity, SP500, and the SEC.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 2y agoAt least with NYSE, Fidelity, SP500 and the SEC, one could avoid them, eg., by choosing not to invest, working for unlisted employers, etc. But avoiding the web or mobile apps is becoming nearly impossible. Google tentacles are all over this stuff. No escape. For example, one visits a US government website and it needlessly sends data to "google-analytics.com". The blog tends to be a bit hyperbolic but the author does do the research. If his facts were wrong and he was notified, I suspect he would publish a correction.
- ilrwbwrkhv 2y agoCan't wait for Google to be broken up and made an example of. Same with Amazon soon, I hope.
- marcyschidler 2y ago[dead]
- victor106 2y agoThis is a well written article. What resources are available for someone to understand more about the online ad tech space?
- layer8 2y agohttps://clearcode.cc/adtech-book-pdf-download-hardcover/ https://clearcode.cc/adtech-book-pdf-download-hardcover/ https://www.playwire.com/blog/adtech-landscape https://www.playwire.com/blog/adtech-landscape
- danjl 2y agoNothing will really change. Even if they are found to be a monopoly. The appeals process and the commensurate change in the world during those years will allow Google to work around any proposed remediation before it is enacted.
- khana 2y ago[dead]
- Animats 2y agoNow we have to get rid of "Log on with Google" for non-Google properties. Google has to get out of the authentication-provider business. That allows Google to cross-link usages or other services. Need to raise this issue with the California PUC, about Waymo wanting a Google login.
- jeffbee 2y agoThree assertions, no supporting argument. Why do "we" need to eradicate Google as an authentication service?
- dredmorbius 2y ago"That allows Google to cross-link usages or other services" is the justification, or argument, if you prefer.
- beachy 2y agoSimple authentication is not as strong a chokehold as it appears, and most "log on with" integrations are very simple, just doing auth and passing across name and email. You wouldn't see e.g chatgpt having login with Google if it was such a threat.
- Animats 2y agoYou have to have a Google account. This is a problem if you cancelled Google.
- walterbell 2y ago> John Maynard Keynes had penned a private letter to Franklin Delano Roosevelt about business leaders. He wrote, “You could do anything you liked with them if you would treat them (even the big ones), not as wolves or tigers, but as domestic animals by nature, even though they have been badly brought up and not trained as you would wish.” FDR tamed big business. Anti-monopolists today are nowhere near that level of accomplishment broadly speaking, as we don’t have a political consensus. But in a few areas, we can start to see the outlines of what a world run with some element of the public interest in mind might look like. How is "public interest" defined after Citizens United, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC?
- daedrdev 2y agoI think reddit recently signing an exclusive deal with google for crawling its website is quite anticompetitive and will be a surprisingly big draw to google.
- mastodon_acc 2y agoIt was not an exclusive deal. Other companies can also sing similar deals.
- daedrdev 2y agoThats a good point I didn't realize, thanks. I guess this is reddit cashing in on being the most useful search result for many topics.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- animal_spirits 2y agoIn the end we will all lose, in my opinion. Google will start to charge more for access to YouTube, along with increasing ads. They will begin to pay creators less due to the increased cost in serving the ads. We will see a decline in the quality and quantity of high production video education.
- Eisenstein 2y agoIf we get independence in ad space, we may see publications flourish again, which is a net win. I would prefer a local newspaper be profitable than have youtube creators be paid more.
- ethbr1 2y agoIt's difficult to imagine margins in advertising and app store management would remain as high as they are when opened to competition. The primary reason Google has fought so hard is because it knows, even if left whole, its margins would drastically shrink once it has to compete on price.
- pclmulqdq 2y agoThey won't be as high, but the profit will be more dispersed.
- 39896880 2y agoGoogle will charge more for access to YouTube, which makes competitors like Nebula more appealing.
- animal_spirits 2y agoThe problem here is Nebula doesn't have to do any more innovation to attract customers. There are two ways to compete; sell the same product for a better price, or sell a better product for the same price. You can sell the same product for a better price by innovating on technology/business, but when we artificially increase the cost of Google's product, it makes competitors artificially cheaper. The competitors don't need to actually do anything better than Google and they win out at the expense of the consumer.
- animal_spirits 2y ago> video sharing, mapping, mobile phones, and the other Google infrastructure. These are all areas ripe for innovation and disruption, This is incredibly wrong. We've had mountains of innovation in all of these areas under Google's leadership and from competitors like Apple, Mapbox, Microsoft, AWS, etc. When Google ends up costing more to use, competitors will _not_ need to innovate to attract customers to their platforms, and the technology will stagnate.
- ethbr1 2y agoWhat innovation has happened in Maps in the last 19 years? Aside from buying Waze in 2013?
- Mochsner 2y agoAnti-features like copying a location being a gmaps unique URL instead of the actual location
- 8organicbits 2y agoAds in the map is another.
- tantalor 2y agoStreetview was only 17 years ago.
- tikhonj 2y agoOne thing I appreciate is how much better maps have gotten for non-drivers: bike and pedestrian paths, public transport (especially live schedules, delays, alerts) and legitimately good directions generated for walking, biking and taking transport. I believe that using wifi to improve localization on phones also happened within the last 19 years—quick Google found me an article from 2010 about how they started gathering data for this in 2007. I definitely remember this having a real improvement on how accurate my phone's location could be, which made using maps much nicer day-to-day.
- winddude 2y ago> However, it does mean that Google will have to give up on its mission, “to organize the world's information.” Though that slogan looks benign, it is in fact anything but. Being the organizer of the world’s information is far far too much power for anyone to have. It’s time to give up on it. Giving up on that is stupid, and would set society back. We need more companies and organisations doing it. AI has brought a few new startups into the search space, but yes, splitting the companies up may make more opportunities for them. That said, if you can raise the capital you can get into search, because of opportunities presented by AI, and google has been sacrificing quality for optimising ad revenue. Email has also seen some startups making big leaps by adopting AI. I wouldn't touch video sharing platforms, or ad networks.
- eastbound 2y agoAfter traveling through the middle east: Google is far from present here, it’s Yandex territory. And I bet Asian countries can be conquered by Chinese companies the same way.
- metadat 2y agoI have to use Yandex almost daily, because Google has stopped indexing a massive amount of the Internet. It's almost more useless than Yahoo was after Google came along, which is crazy.
- dimator 2y agoWhat kind of stuff do you find missing? Is it strictly regional/firewalled content?
- ghssds 2y agoWhile my main search engine is still Google, I use Yandex more and more. I have no specific example right now but it's not unusual for Y to give me meaningful result when G, with the same search string, give me crap.
- 2y ago
- Havoc 2y agoIt does seem like their cash cow is facing a bit of an existential risk. Things like kagi and perplexity work just as well as search if not better. And if google search collapses then the rest of the empire won’t be far behind
- hootz 2y agoGoogle is so unusable right now that I couldn't care less. I just started paying for Kagi and it's excellent. I forgot how it's possible for a search engine to just find the information I want without blasting my eyes with corporate slop.
- accurrent 2y agoNot every tom, dick and harry is going to be able to pay for services. Personally, If I dont own the software and cant change its source code I dont trust the company. Hopefully at some point in the far future computing and AI will become so efficient that we will be able to own our own search infrastructure.That being said once this future arrives Im probably going to have to search for a new job as I dont see software engineering as being particularly lucrative.
- at_a_remove 2y agoI am unsure about that last bit. From website design (style) to UX to how a given application works, I have found the people who want these things to be unable or unwilling to articulate what it is they actually desire, nor are they likely to go anywhere but the Happy Path. Instead, one ends up looking at the actual logged usage of previous or similar software, doing interviews with a multitude of different people who will use the application in different ways, and finally a deep contemplation of How This Will Actually Need to Work (and Break) to get anywhere.
- MrDisposable 2y agoI was a paid Kagi subscriber. I unsubscribed due to my temporary financial difficulties, but I'm resubscribing as soon as I'm able to afford expenses like this. I'm VERY happy with them.
- accurrent 2y agoYou do you. To be entirely frank 90% of the world is not software engineers. If I were to ask the guy who sells food at my local food stall to pay for a search engine where free (as in dollars) alternatives exist he is going to pick the free one. To be entirely frank he probably does not have enough money to pay for yet another service. My major concern with kagi is that its good now, whos to say it will ne good in the future. Plenty of SAaS have ebshitiffied. We NEED open infrastructure fpr search. What that lools like Im not sure but it may be possible in the far future.
- zombiwoof 2y agoPeople are addicted to their phones.
- notepad0x90 2y agoThe term "enshittification" is used a lot these days. But there is this pattern where human organizations -- be it companies, codebases, countries and many other examples -- undergo this transformation from simple, humble and efficient systems to complex, arrogant and inefficient ones. I wouldn't dare to speculate on the cause of this devolution. There are theories like becoming publicly traded for companies, and subsequently execs chasing short term profits to make shareholders happy, or elected officials chasing after votes for the next immediate election cycle. But it would be nice if there was some sort of a large scale in-depth study on the topic and research into solutions for it. Honestly, the more I think about so many issues, the more I feel like there needs to be a dedicated field into the study of incentives and how they shape the systems and organizations humans build and maintain. Everything from google search being terrible to climate change feels like it all has a shared root cause of misaligned or defective incentives. Perhaps existing fields like game theory, economics or systems design should cover this topic? Either way, our systems design methodology is faulty and this fault is nearly universal and systemic, affecting all humans in almost every area of our lives. One theory I have (full disclosure: subjects I am not too familiar with) is economics and game theory, specifically the "Nash equilibrium" game theory, which as I understand boils down to "everyone should participate in the system, only taking into account their own success and profit, and nothing more than that" might be at fault. Or maybe, it simply codified the innate faulty organizational instinct we have?
- left-struck 2y ago> Honestly, the more I think about so many issues, the more I feel like there needs to be a dedicated field into the study of incentives and how they shape the systems and organizations humans build and maintain. That currently falls under economics, sociology and game theory. It’s not really a dedicated field sure but it’s well covered
- Timwi 2y agoYou're right about "everyone should participate in the system, only taking into account their own success and profit, and nothing more than that" being (at least part of) the root problem. However, this is not a description of a Nash equilibrium. It uses the word “should”. It's a philosophy. It is, in fact, the philosophy of capitalism. It creates incentives for short-term thinking, profit-seeking at the detriment to the public good, and competition in areas where collaboration is more appropriate. It doesn't have to be that way, no matter how much the rich and powerful less us that it should. A Nash equilibrium is a state of affairs in which no single person can improve their position without the collaboration of others. A frequently cited example is a bank run: if the bank goes bust, you better get your savings out quickly, but if everyone does it, the bank goes bust. The solution is for everyone to cooperate and agree to refrain from a run on the bank. Such collaboration is not easy to organize and not easy to convince a majority to participate in; but the ego-centric philosophy of capitalism makes it infinitely harder.
- rldjbpin 2y agointeresting parallels are drawn for this opinion, but i would be with it if it was just limited to web search like most people started clamoring after genAI. some comparisons with past american monopolies were made, but there is a key difference between those and google - the direct impact to people across the world. to me it came across slightly myopic to look only inside one large economy, for things that impact everyone's lives but not directly. we already have large portions of the world not impacted by google - just look at china. but even there android in its different form has been vital. it is not just a matter of "we got a disruptive new tool to replace the current choice". google is able to bankroll key internet services that could stand by itself even when broken up - android, search (people still use it to open websites they literally spell out), youtube, gmail to name the key few. change is inevitable but i don't see it happening the way it is envisaged here. pretty much all the "disrupters" are backed the same way that made today's big tech. which goes beyond just google. the now-subsiding ai boom has shown that big tech is still swaying investors for immaterial promises.
- methuselah_in 2y agoPost Google world means android without devlopment and money as well I guess.