6 ms·
You generally want to minimize the number of passwords you manage; for instance, you should generally be paying the SSO tax and getting as many services as you
by tptacek 2y ago
You generally want to minimize the number of passwords you manage; for instance, you should generally be paying the SSO tax and getting as many services as you can onto OIDC. After that, just do the cloud version of 1Password, which is easy to audit and manage access for, which you'll thank yourself for when it comes time to SOC2.
Remember, as you give people access to passwords, that those passwords will need to be rotated when those people change to incompatible roles or depart the company. If passwords aren't a total pain in the ass for you, you're probably doing something wrong.
- Normal_gaussian 2y agoThat is the answer. SSO, then password manager. I'd strongly recommend bitwarden, having deployed and managed it. I would warn against lastpass, strongly, due to papercut level issues everywhere. I haven't used 1password in an appropriate scenario to comment on it.
- oefnak 2y agoExcept the search function of bitwarden is totally broken. Searching for A B shows everything with A or B, not even with A and B at the top.
- hu3 2y agoThis could be a good first contribution to Bitwarden for me or anyone really. Do you mean the browser extension search feature? Thanks for pointing it out.
- Normal_gaussian 2y agoJust checked, and its indeed doing this nonsense in the browser extension (on firefox). Its implemented sensibly in the Android app, and I haven't tested the website vault viewer or the desktop app.
- hu3 2y agoThank you for checking and reporting back. I never touched Bitwarden project but I hope I or someone could contribute to a better search in the extension.
- bluemax 2y agoThere is a syntax you can use to search for entries that contain both A and B: >+A +B It is annoying but it works.
- ZuLuuuuuu 2y agoWe have SSO + 2FA in place, and would like to use Bitwarden for the rest of the password management. But for a company around ~50 people, the pricing feels too expensive, considering the only purpose is to manage a few passwords. So for now we are using Keepass which is kind of painful, but free. We would probably be willing to pay ~2$ per user per month, but instead it is 6$ if you want Bitwarden to work integrated with your SSO which means 3600$ per year.
- MrDrMcCoy 2y agoWhy not self-host Vaultwarden? It implements most functionality and supports the standard Bitwarden clients with virtually no resource requirements.
- ZuLuuuuuu 2y agoI'll look into it, thanks!
- teekert 2y agoWas going to suggest the same, of course you're taking matters into your own hands, so know what you are doing, but it's free, very light weight and supports "organizations" as a way of sharing passwords between people. I have hosted it for my family for years and was very happy with it (until I switched to Proton Family, now doing ProtonPass). And you get all the excellent Bitwarden apps and extensions to go with it.
- lostlogin 2y ago> LastPass There was the time they lost customer data in a hack and then lots of customers data was exploited. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LastPass https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/LastPass
- runjake 2y agoThe thing about the LastPass Wikipedia article is that someone keeps editing it to reduce the number of really bad security issues LastPass has had over the years. You can Google almost any year, along with "lastpass security incident" and get results. Nobody with the goal of security should be using LastPass. Nobody.
- dayjah 2y agoI’m still suffering from this; somehow in this hack <<something>> happened to my LastPass account and login/unlocking it became impossible. LastPass support (rightly) can’t help, so 3 or so years later I’m still stumbling into sites that I can no longer access. Many sites have forgotten password flows, they’re easy, but many other sites related to municipal services, etc, require hours on calls, often on hold, proving my identity and getting access reinstated.
- imglorp 2y agoNot once but multiple breaches. Just no.
- gpvos 2y agoI'm surprised they still exist.
- noname120 2y agoI was first using 1Password and then I really tried to love Bitwarden for two entire years (paid user). But it was riddled with bugs and UX mishaps. I gave them detailed feedback by email, they acknowledged it, but nothing changed and my frustration grew over time. I eventually switched back to 1Password one year ago and I'm delighted. For example here some issues I flagged to the team. Note that some of them may possibly have been resolved since then: – The “incorrect ciphers” error that keeps happening where you have to restart Bitwarden and lose all your changes. – Basic searches take multiple seconds if you have more than 400 entries. – Editing items is awkward. Whenever I scroll down an item and want to edit a specific entry, I have to find the edit button and then WOOSH a new panel appears and I don’t know where the field I wanted to edit ended up in the new panel. – Bitwarden doesn’t automatically categorize login items by type and it's not possible to exclude items from the “All Items” list. So it's a big mess and when you try to search a massive amount of irrelevant auto-generated entries pop up. – Scrolling is super laggy on Android. – Android logins don't have icons (they could very easily extract them when Bitwarden automatically creates an entry when logging on an Android app). – Phone numbers are not formatted. Same for many other data types. – Credit/debit cards show a generic icon rather than Mastercard, Visa, American Express, etc. – The whole interface is marked as selectable in CSS and when you try to move the window around it keeps selecting irrelevant text from the UI such as “Search Vault” and “Item Information” instead of moving the window. Likewise, if I try to select actual text the selection isn't constrained to the field I'm selecting from so I often select a bunch of crap I didn't mean to select. – Clicking on a password field doesn't offer the option to generate a password. – Password generation settings don't synchronize between Bitwarden instances. Every time you install the app or the browser extension you have to reconfigure the length, symbols, letters, casing, etc. Again. By default it uses Bitwarden's default basic (and pretty insecure) criteria. – Bitwarden frequently doesn't detect password fields, and frequently doesn't offer to automatically save the password. – Can’t drag & drop an item from the list to a folder. I have to manually edit the item entry and select the folder from the dropdown. Every time. – When editing an item, the ‶Attachments″ entry is a tiny line hidden below ‶Master password re-prompt″ so it's incredibly easy to miss and hard to find. – Attachments don’t have previews and you can't rename them. You have to manually download a given item and open it in order to see what it's about. – Can't copy attached images to the clipboard. Instead you have to press the download button, pick a folder, find it, copy the file (or possibly open it with an image editor when you need to copy the image itself), and then paste it where you want. – Automatic entry names are dumb. For example for Android apps it just picks the package name (e.g. com.voyagerx.scanner) instead of the name of the app (in this example the corresponding app's name is vFlat, so not clear from the package name!). And this is only the tip of the iceberg. I had many more issues than those with Bitwarden. None of these issues happen on 1Password.
- janstice 2y agoAnd when you set up 1Password, make sure you also get the CLI going, so passwords & shared gunk that's needed to access other people's services can be scripted, and when the passwords, etc get rotated no-one needs to know because no-one needs to store them.
- bankcust08385 2y ago[flagged]
- Hnrobert42 2y agoYou're going to have to elaborate. I've been using 1pw for about 7 years, including at several startups where I've handled IT. It has worked really well, yet to be breached, has a CLI, handles passkeys and SSH keys, easily separates work and personal creds, and their support is fantastic. What specifically is terrible?
- matwood 2y agoPeople are still upset from when it went from a mac native user focused app to a subscription based multi-platform enterprise focused app.
- vermilingua 2y agoI can't imagine what you'd have to have experienced to recommend Keeper over 1Password
- urda 2y agoIt's actually not and is arguably the leader in password managers. Full stop. You should elaborate your future comments a bit more.
- bankcust08385 2y agoNever pay the "SSO tax" by outsourcing to Okta, etc. There many FOSS IdP solutions that are usable with some customization and integration.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- tptacek 2y agoThe SSO tax is the premium your vendors add to accounts that link with any IdP.
- hypeatei 2y agoFOSS solutions like Keycloak are absolutely capable but it completely ignores the "tax" you pay in terms of maintenance and setup. For smaller teams, it's not feasible at all to keep something like that up-to-date and running smoothly (i.e. no downtime)
- cedws 2y ago1Password is brilliant. They have all sorts of open source libraries and integrations on GitHub.
- f4c39012 2y ago1password is solid, and works everywhere and in most situations. Features are however quite limited on the more basic packages
- wodenokoto 2y agoWhat’s SSO and how do I put vendor API keys into it? Like one of the most important APIs we have is just 1 key and that’s it. I don’t think the vendor has heard the term “key rotation”
- steve1977 2y agoI would recommend you get some people with IT security knowledge on board, either permanently or at least to do a review.
- duckmysick 2y agoFor API keys you want to look into secrets management, for example Hashicorp Vault or OpenBao. AWS/Azure/Google Cloud also have their own secrets management features.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pjerem 2y agoUnfortunately the SSO tax isn’t the worst. Most companies pay for it anyway. In my experience (as in IC), the real issue is when the company don’t want to pay enough seats for everyone. Honestly sometimes it makes sense when you don’t use the tool everyday but it’s a PITA. I think, maybe, that SaaS companies should reflect on a (capped) per-day billing for those accounts.
- bheadmaster 2y agoYou can even avoid using passwords altogether by using hardware security keys.
- koliber 2y agoOn top of this, prefer individual accounts and passwords over shared accounts. Some services require shared passwords, keys, or tokens. Consider grouping them by sensitivity. Key to the kingdom shared accounts should be accessible only to a tiny number of people. Finally, never send credentials over plaintext, such as email or Slack. 1Password and other password managers have a “share” feature. If need be, send a zipped and encrypted text file and share the password via a voice call.
- poincaredisk 2y ago>If need be, send a zipped and encrypted text file and share the password via a voice call. Because people are lazy and not everyone wants to write a file, zip it, encrypt it, call someone, spell the password... Consider sending the password regularly over slack, wait a minute till the other side confirms they got it, and remove the message. Mediocre solutions that people use are better than perfect solutions that everyone circumvents.
- insane_dreamer 2y ago> never send credentials over plaintext, such as email or Slack Slack works for us in a very small (<5) number of trusted long-time remote devs, but with two important conditions: 1. New/updated password(s) to be shared are in an encrypted Keypass file (encrypted with a preset and prearranged password that was only shared once offline). Recipient merges into their local keypass file. 2. Confirm recipient is online, send, confirm receipt, delete immediately afterwords. We use many AWS services so obv all those are handled with AWS Secrets and IAM, so we only need to save the login pwd externally. And for services which support multi-user, Google, GitHub, etc., each user has their own pwd. So not many passwords need to be shared in the above manner. In daily use I keep KeyPass open and copy/paste passwords into the browser when needed -- nothing stored online.
- corford 2y agoAgree. The trio of Okta + Bitwarden + AWS Secrets Manager covers most bases and has served us well. The SSO tax is real though, especially if you're a < 50 person entity and don't need everything else that normally comes with "Enterprise" plans <sigh>. Shout out to the few enlightened/kind SaaS peeps that don't do this (e.g. Windmill.dev) !
- gottoupvote 2y agoConsider updating https://sso.tax/ https://sso.tax/
- mathiasn 2y agoOr better ssotax.org which is already way ahead.