9 ms·
The secret inside One Million Checkboxes
- jeanlucas 2y agoThat was so fun to read! It's nice to see internet's creativity at best. Plus: one more data point proving that creativity flourishes when resources are limited
- asolove 2y agoThis part is so important: > The adults in my life were largely not mad at me. They asked me to knock it off, but also made me a t-shirt. I don’t think I’d be doing what I do now without the encouragement that I received then. Teena need a place to be moderately mischievous, with semi-real social outcomes, but also some boundaries and help to not take it too far. And adults who aren’t authorities over them except insofar that they have cool talents the kids want to learn.
- metadat 2y agoThis is very sweet, and I'm sure I'd have responded infinitely better to this than what I received growing up..
- bjackman 2y agoI did almost exactly the same thing at my school (brought down the system with a VB6 script that wrote infinite text files to networked storage). They sent my mum a letter accusing me of terrorism. At the time I thought I was pretty ridiculous and unfair (lucky my mum agreed), but now looking back with adult eyes I also see it as an almost criminal level of disregard for the job of raising children. Just absolutely irredeemably small-minded, truly pathetic, it makes me so angry to think that there are still young people growing up in that environment and being taught by those people.
- diggan 2y agoPeople are afraid of what they don't understand - Someone, at one point The adults in that situation didn't understand the full (or rather, how small) scope of what happened, so for them it looks wildly different than to you or me. To them, computers are black boxes that are not to fuck with, and the ones who do, are only out after destruction and ruining things. That's why they react like they do. Not to excuse the behavior, they should of course have talked with people who understand what happened before trying to address it, but lack of resources, knowledgeable people and understanding often leads to being able to. Similarly, I at one point (before I'd consider myself a programmer) worked as a customer support agent contracted out to a popular fruit technology company, saw efficiencies in how things were done manually and hacked together a browser extension. At first just me and my colleague next to me was using it. Eventually, it spread and eventually management found out. Instead of trying to elevate the processes and seeing that things could be better, they decided to eventually get rid of me, too risky they said.
- mauvehaus 2y agoI wasn't screwing around with the network in high school, but got called in to the principal's office to answer some uncomfortable questions because (and I swear on my life I am not making this up) I knew how to change the desktop background on my account. This apparently made them suspicious of me. Simpler times, I know. It was an early lesson in the fact that there are a lot of people doing IT in schools who, frankly, suck at their job. Most of the good IT people are getting paid way more elsewhere. The crappy ones are working in an environment where easily 1 in 50 of the students know more than they do and some of them feel threatened and lash out when someone is outing them for being lousy at their job, intentionally or otherwise. Like you did (disk quotas much?). Like they suspected me of. Fixing the structural problem would require paying IT people in schools a rate that more closely matches what they'd make in industry. Fixing the social problem would require hiring people who understand what you and the author figured out: that nurturing people and directing their impulses productively yields better long-term outcomes for everyone.
- seattle_spring 2y agoYup, absolute insanity. My good friend was expelled because he used "net send" while our teacher was giving a presentation. Wasn't even anything vulgar.
- jszymborski 2y agoThe first time I heard a Chuck Norris joke was via "net send" in a high school computer lab.
- eythian 2y agoYes, I had a similar experience in high school. I ended up modifying a virus that infected a bunch of computers and causing problems, so I got kicked out the lab until the next year (but this was late September, so no biggie.) The next year I mentioned to the teacher that I had something I wanted to play with, can I please get access to a PC (the lab computers were Acorns), and so he gave me after school access to the accounting classroom, more storage on the network drive (50MB when everyone else had 5!), and basically free reign if I didn't break things. So I didn't, and was running Tierra on piles of machines overnight, just to see it doing cool things, and getting in in the morning to save everything and reboot them. It certainly set me up well for the future. And didn't break things, because I didn't want to kill the golden goose!
- Sohcahtoa82 2y agoBack in 1999 while I was in high school, I played a goofy harmless prank on one of the school computers. I created a 2-page slideshow presentation. Both of them had the same black background with grey text that appeared to be a DOS session indicating that Windows was deleted, except one had an underscore at the prompt. By telling the program to automatically advance the slides every second, and to loop the presentation, it gave the impression of a blinking cursor. It looked like a broken computer, but simply pressing Escape would get out of it. Of course, it's worth mentioning that these were Macs, so they didn't even have DOS or Windows. Anyways, a teacher saw it and thought I had hacked/broken the computer and sent me to the principal that didn't think it was funny and punished me by making me spend the second half of my lunch period with the school IT guy for the next 2 weeks so I could shadow him and see how much vandalism he has to deal with. When I saw him the first time, he was like "Wait, what did you do?" and I recreated it. He thought it was funny as hell and thought it was ridiculous for them to act like I broke a computer. We had a lot of fun hanging out. Even after my punishment was over, I still frequently went to his office to chat or walk around and fix computers.
- seattle_spring 2y agoHeh. I made a Visual Basic 6 program that showed a static screenshot of the desktop. I did this because I only got a few hours in the evening to use the family computer, but if i ever got up to use the bathroom my dad would "play one game of bejeweled real quick" that would sometimes end up taking the entire evening. When I tried using it, he lost his fucking shit and went berserk. At least it taught me how to be a better parent
- Klathmon 2y agoI love that story, and that's actually such a fantastic punishment IMO (even if it was a bit unwarranted). I did some similar harmless "hacking" in my high school that accidentally ended up crashing a major switch causing the whole schools network to die for the day. I told my programming class teacher right away, but unfortunately in my case the superintendent decided to press charges. In the end all it taught me was to never never trust anyone, not exactly the best lesson for an already introverted teen to internalize...
- jszymborski 2y agoOur high-school had an intro to programming class which taught folks how to use VB6 in a computer lab. It was exceptionally self-driven and gave me a lot of rope to do whatever I wanted. The PCs in the lab were very slow, and a known prank (taught to everybody at some point by virtue of being a victim) was to hold Win+E, spawning hundreds of Explorer windows and bringing the PC to its knees. Sometimes you could wait it out, but a stealthy pranker could hold it so long a restart was required. Well, I created a little VB6 programme named "DoraTheExplorer.exe" which would do exactly that when you clicked on it. I put that on the schools shared drive (where you could sometimes find portable executables of the original Halo game until the admin found and deleted it). My prank was successful for a short while until, however, it became quickly evaded by folks just hitting Alt+F4 quickly and exiting the Dora Programme. I then discovered you could get the programme to launch another instance of itself on exit, but this was also countered by spamming Alt+F4 rapidly. Finally, I hit my magnum opus. A hydra. Everytime you'd close dora.exe, it'd open two more. It was an ICBM in the Explorer prank wars and defeat was declared. The admin knew about this the whole time, and they were generally chill. They made it clear that if anyone lost work or if it caused harm, then I'd be held responsible. But that never happened because everyone knew what dora.exe did, I was too proud not to tell folks :P People only clicked on dora.exe for the dumb pleasure of crashing their PCs and trying to see if they could evade it. Very grateful for that class and the generally chill environment I was in.
- nhggfu 2y agowhat a wild ride.
- mportela 2y agoThis is what I pay internet for
- eieio 2y agoauthor here :) this is my favorite story from running the site, and possibly the best story I've ever been a part of. I'm not a big crier but I have cried so many times thinking and trying to write about it over the past 2 months. And of course, the process of discovery (and going from panic to excitement) was pretty crazy too. One of my favorite things about this is that it validated one of the core beliefs I have when making these things - that you need constraints for the small group of people that are jerks, but that for the most part those constraints are fodder for the largely-good and very creative folks that play around on the internet. Happy to answer any questions folks have!
- JadoJodo 2y agoHi! I missed the site but I have enjoyed reading about it after. As much as I enjoyed the last article, I enjoyed this one even more. Thank you for both the site and the articles.
- switchbak 2y agoThis sounds like a perfect recipe for an episode of the Corecursive Podcast!
- Yenrabbit 2y agoFantastic telling of it in both text and video form. Great to celebrate these people doing the kinds of things we learned so much from! Thanks for sharing.
- isoprophlex 2y agoThanks for the great writeups, this one, the one about scaling, and your work in general. It's been very inspiring. Also, you're absolutely right about largely good and creative people. I built a OMCB clone because the concept possessed me; i threw it online, a day later, okay a couple of dicks, whatever. Holy shit someone put a huge Hokusai's The Great Wave in there! (My version uses a fixed width/height, a big scrollable canvas, so that was easy to spot) Seeing that felt so good, so joyful :)
- thatswrong0 2y agoI loved this. It's really.. endearing and adorable? And it's what I wish the internet was used for more. Thanks for the writeup!
- insane_dreamer 2y agoI never heard of OMCB before, but it's the kind of site that I would love for my teenage kids to find and play with the way those teens in the discord channel did--providing opportunity for creativity and engineering.
- larodi 2y agoIf this really happened, on both sides - author, and haxor, well, ... there is still hope for this world. Amen.
- Sophira 2y agoAs one of the people who found the original Discord server back when the site was live, I can attest that this is absolutely true.
- memorabilia 2y agoYou were one of the elites!<3 How did you find the link? Please share... Really interested to find out.
- Sophira 2y agoIn my case, I kind of worked backwards from the way eieio found it. I was at the very bottom of the million checkboxes when I noticed there was a repeating pattern. And if you zoomed out enough, and sized your window large enough, it looked like this: https://matrix.theblob.org/omcb-repeating-pattern.png https://matrix.theblob.org/omcb-repeating-pattern.png It was obviously a bot, but it definitely wasn't random. It was a pattern that repeated every 208 checkboxes. At first I thought it was a barcode, but it wouldn't scan even when I turned it into a form that should scan. Then, I figured it could potentially be a binary code, so I tried treating the repeating pattern as binary, with the checked boxes as 1s and the unchecked boxes as 0s. That got me the URL that eieio talks about in the original article. Once I was there, I discovered from the other members that I had taken a more arduous route than I needed to; it turns out that the site's API was such that it sent its initial state as a base64-encoded version of the full binary state of the board. Decoding the base64 and looking at the end of the data would also have gotten you the same URL, and as such many of the people in the server were bot developers who had done exactly that because they wanted to reverse-engineer it.
- memorabilia 2y ago
- data-ottawa 2y agoI really enjoyed this post, it brings me back to when I was in high school learning java and I made an app that took over your whole screen with a grid of “x” buttons where only one of them actually closed the window. When someone left their computer unlocked I would pop in a a floppy disk and run the program then leave. We had an IT guy at our school who would always ask us what we were up to which we would answer honestly. He never got mad at us for figuring out how to get Halo CE or Starcraft or other games running over the network, but he did tell us to knock it off when we got too bold.
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 2y agoMy friend memorized his SC CD key so he could reinstall it quickly. Good times We had a network file share so no floppy necessary. Very easy to hack everyone's computers. I wrote a script that would read the title of all your open windows and close free games.com or whatever the popular game site was at the time. Shouldn't be playing games in class right? I felt bad when it closed some 3d modelling program because of the save file name he chose. Oops.
- pxx 2y agoif you're just playing on LAN, both 1234-56789-0123 or 3333-33333-3333 work as a cd-key for original StarCraft. installing Brood War on top doesn't even need a cd-key
- b3lvedere 2y agoBack when i was a teenager i was so excited when me and my friends found (technical) loopholes in stuff. It was a game in itself. Getting away with cheating, getting away with "hacking", etcetera. We did some things that may have cost someone some revenue, like writing down cd keys and other stuff, but we meant no harm. No real big damage was done. Nowadays i have two teenagers myself. Whenever some/we suspect they are "up to no good" i will try and remember my own teenage years. Then i tell them something like that i think that was awesome and i'm proud, but don't get caught again. :)
- Cthulhu_ 2y ago
- Scoundreller 2y ago> To do this I said - a checkbox has two valid states. It’s checked or it’s unchecked Ah, i see someone has been burned by true, false and null before!
- aidenn0 2y agohttps://thedailywtf.com/articles/numb-to-truth https://thedailywtf.com/articles/numb-to-truth
- trescenzi 2y agohttps://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/:indeterminate https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/CSS/:indetermin...
- 8n4vidtmkvmk 2y agoThat's actually useful, but annoying it doesn't have a corresponding HTML attribute. And also.. it can be both checked and indeterminate, which is fun.
- rafram 2y agoThis is an awesome post and sounds like it was an awesome experience. I’d be interested to see an alternate-history version of this, in a universe where it was built with a serverless architecture. My hunch is that a lot of the late-night hacking sessions wouldn’t have been necessary, but when it went down (due to resource caps) it would’ve been down down, not just slow.
- fragmede 2y agoYou'd have a serverless Lamda hit Elasticache/Redis and then still run into scaling issues because the code you wrote wasn't optimized. Given enough Lamdas and no connection pooling, you'll still exhaust Elasticache and have to do something about it. You'll run into the question about how the bandwidth bill is going to look like in the morning and want to figure out a way to not bankrupt yourself before going to sleep. Worse, AWS is known to gouge for bandwidth, and Lamda doesn't give you the same absolute rate limit control as the author's setup did. If you're just gonna give up if/when you hit eg Redis rate limits, that doesn't inspire confidence in serverless.
- jackmalpo 2y agowe are so back
- pajeets 2y agothis reminds me of the one million pixels website
- airstrike 2y agoThis is peak internet. Thanks so much for sharing. What a lovely read.
- move-on-by 2y agoI was one of those hating on the bots. Thank you for this post, I needed it. I too got in trouble at school for programming things I shouldn’t have. But I’ll forever be grateful to the math teacher who said I was allowed to use programs on my TI-83+ calculator as long as I was the one who had written them and I didn’t share them with anyone else.
- Uptrenda 2y agoBro thinks we need to look at their hello world bit shifts and basic js.
- genewitch 2y agofeel free to link your projects that were in The New York Times - or better, knowyourmeme.com!
- Uptrenda 2y agoI had projects that were in every major news outlet when I was about 20. Press doesn't mean your projects are good. Don't believe your own hype. its p toxic.
- genewitch 2y agoI had a projects that was mentioned by the president of america and also the premier of Japan!
- Uptrenda 2y agoAbsence of evidence isn't evidence of absence. Believe it or not, not everyone wants to release every work under their identity. I know that most HNers are only motivated by ego and money though. So it's probably an alien perspective to you. Though none of that really matters here because you missed the main point: Getting press attention does not make a work substantive. What the press are attracted to is sensational, current-event stories. It's more about finding a hook and a story that will be entertaining than anything else. Once you realize this its quite easy to get reporters at major outlets to cover your work. Though its not going to work if your work is a CRUD app. The context matters a lot. The reason I don't like posts like this on HN is because they don't provide anything useful and the engineering would be obvious to any junior dev. Novelty stuff like this is just honestly goofy. The same goes for every post filled with people reinventing wheels because they get to use their favourite hammer to do it. Is this a place where people post hello world programs and programs designed to do literally nothing. Or is it a place to celebrate things that are actually clever, useful, or worth celebrating? Oh hell, who am I kidding, it's just a place to promote anything you've built providing you have enough friends to vote for it. Forgive my foolishness.
- renewiltord 2y agoHahaha, you legends. Brilliant stuff from the kids. Love it.
- bravoetch 2y agoThis would make a great talk at Defcon. Wholesome hacking at it's best.
- discr3t3 2y agoI was an intern with you when you were at Deepfield ! This is super cool to see!
- eieio 2y agoAh hello! Glad you enjoyed it, and hope post-Deepfield life (if you're not there anymore) is treating you well :)
- adityapurwa 2y agoI don’t know. Reading this made me tear up a bit. I learned software engineering when I was in junior high school. I learned it because I sucked at math, and I want to write programs that solve my homework. Then I continue writing LAN chat, HTTP server, Anti Virus, and a lot more things just because it was fun to do. It was fun, it was challenging, it was rewarding, it was amazing. Now that I’m working, with the endless stream of new technologies, the debates of X considered harmful, J is better than K, and a barrage of never ending new things. It started to numb my mind. Somehow, those joyful feeling of engineering no longer feels like the blue sky. I think its still blue, but for an eye washed in silvers, everything looks gray. Reading this story somehow light up that childhood feeling of me learning software engineering. It can still be fun. I can still write things for the sake of me and not for the sake of exit nor a new shiny SaaS. Thank your for writing this. It gave me a ray of hope that it can still be fun.
- maxbond 2y ago> Somehow, those joyful feeling of engineering no longer feels like the blue sky. I think its still blue, but for an eye washed in silvers, everything looks gray. Beautifully said. I'm glad to hear that you feel hope for rekindling this feeling. It sounds like you've already figured this out, but I want to highlight that this a symptom of burnout, and that people who resonate with this should take it seriously. I remember once I was helping someone at work who was learning Python. They were having trouble understanding how binary file types worked. When it clicked for them, they were so delighted. I realized I hadn't felt that way in years. It wasn't long after that I realized I was too burned out to stay in my position, and needed to take some time to work on my mental health.
- adityapurwa 2y agoThank you. Now that you mentioned it. Maybe it was a burnout. If you don't mind sharing, what did you do to improve your mental health?
- maxbond 2y agoLet me disclaim that this is a work in progress and that I am not a doctor. Part of it was that I had a breakdown. That was unpleasant. But ultimately it was part of the process. (Not to say this is necessarily true of everyone!) This forced me to quit my job. I have a one track mind, so I couldn't really do the work on myself I needed while I was working. I hope this isn't necessary for you or anyone else though. When I was breaking down, I lashed out at the people in my life. I made things very hard for them. But they forgave me and supported me. Sometimes I have a mad instinct to smash everything and start over. But they didn't let me push them away. Reading the Zhuangzi helped me to conceptualize why I allowed myself to be burned out and didn't do anything about it until I was a wreck. In particular, there's a refrain about people who are useful being ground down by being put to use. I realized that I invested my identity in being useful to others, and my team especially, because I didn't respect myself enough to be useless. I didn't value myself outside of being valuable to others. That attitude will inevitably burn you out. Studying Zen and Taoism and meditating has helped a lot. Partly it's just a very different perspective from what I'm normally exposed to, so it broadens my horizons and helps me take things less seriously. The Zen notion of "practicing" with a problem is a perspective I find really valuable. I started therapy and I started taking an antidepressant. This was a mixed bag, my therapist ended up moving away and I think I need to change my medication, but I think it was an important step. Something I struggled with was that I didn't understand the mechanism of action behind therapy and I didn't really see any benefit in any particular session. But I've also had to accept that I just don't understand what I need in my life, I think I do but I'm constantly proven wrong, so not being able to see why something is helping doesn't actually mean it isn't. Similarly, my medication doesn't seem to do anything. But there have been a few times I've had a really hard day, and then when I'm taking my meds in the evening, I realize I had forgotten yesterday. I also think the lows haven't been as low. About a year and a half after my breakdown, I had a profound spiritual experience I'm not entirely comfortable discussing, you might call it a breakthrough. None of these things caused it. But I think they were all preconditions. I'm not "fixed," and in the intervening time I've had depressive episodes and panic attacks on occasion. But I was "fixed" for ten glorious days, and it proved to me that, regardless of whether such a thing can be permanent, it is possible.
- r_hanz 2y agoEnjoyed the site personally when it was up, enjoyed this post even more. tyvm
- archeantus 2y agoI love this story but I wish I understood it better. How did people find their way to the URL if they didn't have DB access? Did they inspect the traffic with a proxy and see the db file going back and forth? I'm just trying to understand what one of these teens had to do to find their way onto that channel where they were hanging out. What steps did they have to figure out on their own?
- zulban 2y agoWhen you loaded the page you got the state of each of the one million checkboxes. That's the data. People just wrote computer code to read that. You can also check a box to write, manually or with computer code. So you can read and write. Usually you talk to a database with a language like sql but in this case, checkboxes work too ;) Once you have the data, folks just tried looking at it in different ways to see what was there.
- hunter2_ 2y agoI guess the question might be more along the lines of... Does JavaScript watch each checkbox and POST to some URL when the local user toggles one? Does it poll some URL to learn about changes from the server? Maybe web sockets?
- MarkSweep 2y agoThe author has another post that describes how the website worked, including how it changed over the course of its existence. But briefly, yes, web sockets are used to stream updates from the server. http://eieio.games/essays/scaling-one-million-checkboxes/ http://eieio.games/essays/scaling-one-million-checkboxes/
- lupire 2y ago[flagged]
- apsurd 2y agoThe video is very good. You seem like a natural. I watched it all. Thanks for the story ^_^
- dheera 2y agoSee also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Million_Dollar_Homepage
- romanhn 2y agoI'd say the mechanics are more similar to https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/R/place https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/R/place
- sweca 2y agoThis is a really heartwarming story
- hunter2_ 2y ago> The typical ways that folks - especially folks who don’t program - bump into bots are things like ticket scalping and restaurant reservation bots. Bots that feel selfish and unfair and antisocial. This reminded me of how a ski resort, Palisades Tahoe, implemented free but scarce parking reservations for weekend parking last winter. Since it's one of the most popular ski destinations from the Bay Area, you can imagine that bots were written. Every time new spots would "drop" (become available for the following weekend) I think on Tuesdays and Fridays or something like that, they'd be gone in seconds. Clearly bots! So naturally I had no choice but to write one. It just alerted me (via Pushover) when cancelations would lead to open slots, it didn't actually reserve spots on its own, but that was good enough to get the job done for me and my crew. Several Reddit threads had non-bot-writers discussing that bots must be slurping everything up. I felt so antisocial, but really had no choice.
- beachy 2y agoI use a bot for booking overnight huts on the more popular hiking trails in my country. They become available for booking online at a fixed time each year and are all taken a few seconds later. Using a bot is the only reliable way to get one. Amusingly there are news articles every year about whether or not people are using bots to book these huts and the operators always deny it vehemently. Whereas I know my bot is up against loads of other bots.
- MattJ100 2y agoOut of curiosity, what tech do you reach for when building something like this?
- beachy 2y agoSelenium
- hunter2_ 2y agoFor mine, I just used a $1/mo VPS with a cron job running a bash script that used curl to poll the parking system and determine if its response was interesting. I used "copy as cURL" from browser dev tools to find something usable (which incorporated a slightly fragile, but very long lived, session token corresponding to my "cart") and I actually had to use curl-impersonate [0] for Cloudflare bot detection to stay out of my way. And then curl to alert me via Pushover. [0] https://github.com/lwthiker/curl-impersonate https://github.com/lwthiker/curl-impersonate
- langcss 2y agoReminds of something I thought of as a kid. You know the two way switches for a light bulb: where both switches can turn the same single light on and off. You probably have one. What if it were a 100 way switch and you had the challenge of keeping the light on (maybe everyone else is trying to keep it off). This is like just one checkbox in this game. It is cool to see this exists and someone figured out how to keep the lights on.
- Perz1val 2y agoIt's just a XOR gate, isn't it?
- genewitch 2y agoToggling either switch in a 2 way (in the US it's called 3 way) toggles the load on or off. it appears if you toggle any input in xor it toggles the output, so, yes. I logged in to disagree, found out i had misconstrued a specific part of NEMA (and hallucinated a wiring diagram, to boot!)
- arrowsmith 2y agoSide note but just wondering what you use to capture those little screen recordings as gifs?
- genewitch 2y agonot the author but any screen recorder (OBS) can record the video, and ffmpeg + imgmagick can make a video clip into an animated gif (that's how i would have done that specific conversion) but gifv exists so maybe ffmpeg or one of the others can output gif directly from video. there's also "services" online that will gif-ify a video.
- peterbozso 2y agoThis is exactly the kind of content I visit HN for. Thank you!
- venins 2y agohttps://web.archive.org/web/20240830020803/https://eieio.games/essays/the-secret-in-one-million-checkboxes/ https://web.archive.org/web/20240830020803/https://eieio.gam...
- AlexDragusin 2y ago> the inevitable tug of war over how much moderation is required to prevent a digital space from becoming an uninhabitable cesspool. I am wondering what is it in humans that it must follow this pattern ending in a cesspool? This would make a very interesting study in human psychology and hopefully gaining enough understanding to maybe improve this condition. On the other hand, antagonists also help driving progress as well, the pendulum like back and forth is also very beneficial to humanity. How do we reconcile these?
- razakel 2y agoI have a work-in-progress theory that permissiveness for some level of misbehaviour is what is necessary for freedom. For example, as Gibson put it, Singapore is Disneyland with the death penalty. Now, how many Singaporean artists can you name? But you know who Banksy is.
- BrandoElFollito 2y agoWhen I was at the university, I was frustrated with how the Unix servers were managed (IBM AIX 3 to give you a timeframe). I social-engineering-hacked my way in and fixed some stuff (very basic stuff, I knew nothing about administration back then). Then went to the sysadmins to explain. They offered me to join their team and this drastically changed my future (for the best). The annoying kid can be a godsend sometimes, I always try to remember that when sighting at what they did or attempted too do (this cover both my kids and the young recruits in my team)
- eiiot 2y agoAs a current student and self-taught developer this is one of the best representations I’ve seen about what makes the world of CS fun. You have a bunch of people with a crazy idea that’s just SO niche and they’re able to use their brains to create something beautiful of immense value.
- shahzaibmushtaq 2y agoI like every simple boring idea executed in an interesting way. Making things for sheer fun and presenting them to the world is just a few hours away. I am sure if we all count the silly ideas together that we have in our head or somewhere in diaries like One Million Checkboxes the numbers could be close to one million. Maybe this is a message to all of us, we shouldn't be afraid to test our ideas. I can't wait any longer to start working on my ideas ASAP.
- jo-m 2y agoThis reminds me of the Pixelflut multiplayer Canvas project: https://wiki.cccgoe.de/wiki/Pixelflut https://wiki.cccgoe.de/wiki/Pixelflut
- LoganDark 2y agoThis is why I've always encouraged people to hack my games. Exploits that ruin other players' fun will obviously be moderated accordingly, but if they're just doing cool stuff, I don't want to ruin their fun!
- genewitch 2y agooffhand, gggg (4g) has this same outlook; and requests that people who cheat or hack the game merely disable stat reporting (leave the leaderboards alone if you want to cheat). I should make a list of devs/studios that encourage hacking/cheating in their games. for example, Thomas Gervraud (Brotato creator) put sliders in the gameplay settings that let you set enemy speed, health, and damage stats (up and down!). Anytime i load up wemod and a game isn't in the database, i fire up cheatengine (i donated, even) - and if that gives me a hard time, i usually request a refund on the game.
- memorabilia 2y agoHi, I read the twitter thread and also watched the video. The people are really awesome and creative! I'm just learning about the codes and I did not understand some things, so I'd be very grateful if anyone helps me to understand these things... 1. The 1000x1000 image is the million checkboxes in 1000 rows x 1000 columns right? 2. Do they create the image directly with the checked and unchecked boxes, or we have to convert them to binary/ASCII etc to see the image? 3. The site can have only 1 1000x1000 image, right? So to make the image change, someone has to overwrite the present image with the help of another bot?
- sillysaurusx 2y ago1. Yes 2. Directly 3. Yes
- memorabilia 2y agoThank you for answering. The process is very hard to comprehend for me. These guys are so creative!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- memorabilia 2y agoDid only one bot acted on the page at a time or multiple bots controlled the checkboxes at once when there were many small pics/elements to form the 1000x1000 image? I meant to ask did multiple people draw on the canvas at the same time or it was only one person/bot at a time?
- beepbooptheory 2y agoMaybe I am misunderstanding the question but it seems like there were/are various bots at work here, but in principle a "single" bot could do these things, and is certainly how they handled animation. But even a single bot could be running many times over, or be otherwise multi-threaded. It does seem important that as far as the page was concerned you couldn't, say, check two boxes at the exact same time. So whatever work they did to coordinate the animations had to happen through tons of single requests.
- ainiriand 2y agoWhat an amazing story. I think I also think about my younger self, just a bit dumber! Thank you for posting this.
- codeptualize 2y agoI love this. Got me a bit nostalgic. This is the type of stuff we used to do in high school with too much time and a lot of "would it work if..?", but nothing anywhere near this level though, amazing!
- ndr 2y agoThe internet is still cool, the kids are all right. I'm more hopeful now, thanks OP and thank you discord kids!
- isaacremuant 2y agoWhen I saw the checkboxes image at the beginning I immediately thought of Reddit's place so it was only natural people would draw on it with bots.
- wickedsight 2y agoThis story kinda makes me nostalgic for the 4Chan that I experienced before it became a QAnon driven cesspool. Back then, between all the gore and other unmentionable stuff, there was the community that formed the 'Anonymous' of that time. Some highlights for me from that period were: - botting Rick Astley to win 'Best Act Ever' at MTV EMA in an effort to 'Rick Roll the world' [0] - botting to help a random average looking lady win a cruise and a cover shoot for a fashion magazine, ahead of actual models - faxing tons of black pages to Scientology centers This also helped me end up with a career in IT, so I really understand the sentiment of the writer and I appreciate how they interpreted these acts of 'vandalism'. 0: https://www.theguardian.com/music/2008/nov/07/rick-astley-best-act-ever https://www.theguardian.com/music/2008/nov/07/rick-astley-be...
- weinzierl 2y ago> The adults in my life were largely not mad at me. They asked me to knock it off, but also made me a t-shirt. I don’t think I’d be doing what I do now without the encouragement that I received then. When I started college, the WWW was quite new. I quickly learned to view pages with NCSA Mosaic at the CIP pool, but had no clue at all how all of this worked. I was determined to find out, though. I read somewhere that you needed a patchy server to make your own pages. So I googled Apache on Altavista, was briefly surprised that the first hit wasn't about the tribe, and carefully followed all the instructions without knowing what I did. After a while I could see my test page in Mosaic and happily went home. It was late already, I was tired, so I pondered if I should boot my computer and dial-in to find out if I could see my page from home as well. I did not understand much, but I figured, if I could view the page from home, everyone in the whole world must be able to see it. This thought left me no peace, so I did it and to my biggest surprise it actually worked![1] I didn't sleep much that night. Having grown up in a rural place without even a library, this absolutely rocked my world. About two weeks later I received a notice from the university, that I wasn't allowed to run services on university resources without permission, so I had to shut it down. But apart from that, nothing bad happened, I am very glad they reacted reasonably. [1] Our computers had public IPs and firewalls were yet to come.
- coreyh14444 2y agoNot your core point, but it is fun to remember that NAT wasn't always a thing, and many networks just PCs with public internet addresses and no firewalls. Even NetBIOS worked over the plain Internet back then. You could just \\x.x.x.x\c$ and it would work a decent percentage of the time.
- aduermael 2y agoGreat story, it added a delightful touch to my breakfast! ^^ Kid developers are free from all the modern (not always in a good way) tooling and routines of the professional world. I'm working on a platform that's kind of an open-source Roblox alternative, and it attracts profiles like theirs. They're so creative and always eager to help, reporting bugs and potentially harmful hacks. Cheers to them!
- Tepix 2y agoAgreed, this is my favourite story on HN in a long time!
- dhype 2y agoAwesome read! thanks for sharing this story.
- yard2010 2y agoThis reminded me of Archer Scavenger Hunt[0] From Wikipedia: Shortly after episode 2 aired, a viewer noticed that a serial number featured on the computer screen in the episode was actually hexadecimal ASCII code for a website URL. This URL was the first step in an extensive interactive online "scavenger hunt" which animator Mark Paterson had devised as a side project to the season, which was awarded the Primetime Emmy Award for Outstanding Interactive Program for 2015. [0] https://figgis.agency/walkthrough https://figgis.agency/walkthrough
- hacker_88 2y agoReminds me Reddit Place
- thread_id 2y agoThis is reminiscent of a story in the New Yorker about Reddit - there is a part of the story that describes r/Place: Last April Fools’, instead of a parody announcement, Reddit unveiled a genuine social experiment. It was called r/Place, and it was a blank square, a thousand pixels by a thousand pixels. In the beginning, all million pixels were white. Once the experiment started, anyone could change a single pixel, anywhere on the grid, to one of sixteen colors. The only restriction was speed: the algorithm allowed each redditor to alter just one pixel every five minutes. “That way, no one person can take over—it’s too slow,” Josh Wardle, the Reddit product manager in charge of Place, explained. “In order to do anything at scale, they’re gonna have to coöperate.” https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/03/19/reddit-and-the-struggle-to-detoxify-the-internet https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2018/03/19/reddit-and-the...
- urda 2y ago> “That way, no one person can take over—it’s too slow,” Josh Wardle, the Reddit product manager Except reddit admins / mods abused Place, bypassing the timeouts, to place as many pixels as they wanted.
- heraldgeezer 2y agoWe’ve got “be gay do crime” - love that of course, ya gotta
- astrobe_ 2y agoIt reminds me the Contact movie [1]: Arroway [the protagonist] discovers the signal contains over 63,000 pages of encoded data. Hadden meets with Arroway and provides her with the means to decode the pages. The decoded data reveals schematics for a Machine that may be a form of transportation for a single individual. Actually, IIRC there's a subplot in which an autistic child draws pages over pages of 0 and 1 while watching TV noise; the protag discovers they represent something, by chance, when looking at the pages tiling the floor, from a balcony. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_(1997_American_film) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Contact_(1997_American_film)
- eythian 2y agoWasn't that from the X-Files? Or maybe I'm misremembering. I think I'm thinking of this: https://x-files.fandom.com/wiki/Conduit https://x-files.fandom.com/wiki/Conduit but I also remember it being seen from a balcony, so maybe I'm conflating two things I've seen together.
- BubbleRings 2y agoYeah, you are right, the “TV noise” sub plot is not part of Contact.
- astrobe_ 2y agoYou are indeed correct. Funny how I mixed them up.
- bckmnn 2y agoThat is a wholesome story. Thanks for letting it play out like this. In a world of increasing abstractions that hide the details, it's great to encourage the next generation to experiment and explore.
- eimrine 2y agoWhen I firstly saw the Million Checkboxes website I was disappointed by the impossibility to see all picture at once. Now I know this was my fault.
- pavel_lishin 2y agoOnce back in the day, when I used to admin a vBulletin forum, we installed an arcade system. It was a fun way to play games, and earn pointless currency ("XMB Bucks") to lord over each other like it mattered. But a few months after that, I realized that the arcade had a hidden sub-forum feature, that was being very actively used by a bunch of people. They managed to bypass the registration screen on vBulletin, and somehow register directly for this hidden arcade feature. They'd been chattin' it up, like a colony of rats living under our floorboards.
- crapbass 2y agoi'm one of the people who was in the mentioned discord server: it was really fun :) me and my friends had a lot of fun drawing stuff, we drew the calmjak, jet lag the game logo, the bottom right qr code (covered up by some other person's art though) and other stuff (they're visible on the "the grid at it's most chaotic" image)
- kaycebasques 2y agohttps://nekoweb.org https://nekoweb.org is another great place to get back in touch with the fun side of computers. There are lots of teenagers just figuring out how to make basic sites, which is heartwarming in its own right, but there is also some really creative, impressive stuff.
- mehulashah 2y agoThis restore my faith in positive human creativity. It makes me wonder what I can do to encourage the constructive collaboration among the younger generation. I agree that todays doom scrolling has destroyed so much of todays potential.
- 3pt14159 2y agoThis blogpost reminds me of the type of content that was more frequent on HN back years ago.
- personality1 2y agoSay this was a malicious actor, how would one place a block/filter for this type of activity? Track each IP request and rate limit on an individual level?
- cdelsolar 2y agoThat email server story could have been written almost verbatim by me. In high school (this was around 1998 or 1999) I also wrote a mass-mailer bot to spam my friends. I showed my friend how to do it, then he modified it a bit but left it running too long and it ended up crashing the school's mail server. I was terrified for a bit because I thought this is the kind of thing that gets you expelled, or suspended. But our CS teacher (Hi Mr. Zamansky) talked to us for like 10 seconds, essentially saying "hey guys, knock it off, ok?" and it was all good.
- psadri 2y agoOne of the most profound lessons I learnt early in my career: if you give people a ”canvas” you will be surprised/blown by how they use it. Found this out with one of the first Yahoo UGC products,Yahoo! Travel Trip Planner. Again with Yahoo! Pipes and then again with Polyvore.
- mrmetanoia 2y agothis warmed my frigid heart. so glad to see this sort of curious spirit endures :)
- bnchrch 2y agoThis was already such a fun and interesting project, but its even cooler to watch the community give back to it in the same spirit! On the note of community, I would kick myself if I didnt link the Elixir clone it inspired. As I think its the best example of how powerful the primitives of elixir are when it comes to massive and distributed concurrency https://github.com/PJUllrich/twomillioncheckboxes https://github.com/PJUllrich/twomillioncheckboxes
- dang 2y agoRelated: Scaling One Million Checkboxes to 650M checks - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41079814 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41079814 - July 2024 (51 comments) One Million Checkboxes - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40800869 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40800869 - June 2024 (305 comments)
- bix6 2y agoBeautiful
- mattw2121 2y agoLove stories like these. I miss the old internet where people just created things for the shear joy of it. I've tried my hand at two different things so far, but neither has found much steam. https://toggles.codewalkers.net/ https://toggles.codewalkers.net/ https://trust-trials.codewalkers.net/ https://trust-trials.codewalkers.net/
- netsharc 2y agoTL; DR for the first part of the story: Developer discovers ASCII. You're storing bits and you panic about hackers when the bits translated to ASCII display a URL? Come on...
- genewitch 2y agoIt means that someone was using checkbox status to encode ascii which isn't at all obvious unless you "happen" to convert the raw bytes to ascii. i'm guessing BSON when output as ascii doesn't have such shenanigans.
- drivers99 2y agoThis is the site I went to (65 days ago), saw the swastikas, clicked back, mentioned that fact on HN, got downvoted to -4 and told I was "pearl clutching". But it also kicked off an interesting thread[0] about how sites handle users being able to draw anything. I wonder what it's like now. Oh. It's 1,000,000 solid checks because he disabled unchecking in order to end the site. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40802456 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40802456
- mazzxer 2y ago[flagged]
- mazzxer 2y ago[flagged]