5 ms·
Since they actually went past the SQL injection and then created a fake record for an employee, I'm shocked that Homeland did not come after and arrest those in
by dylan604 2y ago
Since they actually went past the SQL injection and then created a fake record for an employee, I'm shocked that Homeland did not come after and arrest those involved. Homeland would have been top of the list to misinterpret a disclosure and prefer to refer to the disclosure as malicious hacking instead of responsible disclosure. I'm more impressed by this than the incompetence of the actual issue.
- beaglesss 2y agoThe statute of limitations is long and HSI often delays their indictment until the investigation is mostly wrapped up.
- dylan604 2y agoSo you're suggesting they're not out of the woods?
- beaglesss 2y agoDepends. If no one currently cares, there is no significant structure or personnel or political change in the future several years, and they don't have any assets worth taking, and the government doesn't get any more desperate for assets to seize -- then they're out of the woods.
- dylan604 2y agoI doubt asset seizure is what they'd be after. I was thinking more of the "make an example out of them" mentality as an attempt to prevent others from being curious. Government entities don't tend to do well with knowing the difference of malicious hacking and responsible disclosure. The infamous governor and the View Source is a fun one to trot out as exhibit A.
- beaglesss 2y agoBoth are definitely valid. I think saving face and cash grabs are the two fastest way to get in deep shit with the government.
- garyfirestorm 2y agodon't even need to make an example... they probably have a warning/welcome pop up that says 'unauthorized access to this system will result in...' because the TSA lawyer is going to follow this simple train of thought - were the 'accused' authorized to access the system - gotcha!
- smsm42 2y agoAsset seizure is not because the government needs the money. It's because you need the money to pay for lawyers, legal experts, etc., and if your assets are seized, you can't - so you are much easier to pressure into making a quick guilty plea and get another successful prosecution added to the list. Of course, the whole process is the punishment as usual, but the asset seizure also plays an important coercive role there.
- aftbit 2y agoYou're not wrong, but I would have a hard time as a jury member convicting them of a CFAA violation or whatever for creating a user named "Test TestOnly" with a bright pink image instead of a photo. If they had added themselves as known crewmembers and used that to actually bypass airport screening, then yeah, they'd be in jail.
- beaglesss 2y agoWhat if they incremented a number in a url on a publicly available website?
- debo_ 2y agoIs this a reference to a past event? I don't get it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hyperhello 2y agoIt's an incredibly basic form of pen testing. For example, this reply page URL refers to id=41393364, which is presumably your comment. So what happens if I replace it with a different number? Probably something innocent, but maybe not.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- qup 2y agoYes. https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1ahkgc/i_am_weev_i_may_be_going_to_prison_under_the/ https://www.reddit.com/r/IAmA/comments/1ahkgc/i_am_weev_i_ma...
- bjoli 2y agoJeez, I just read about him. Was he the first who went down the alt right pipeline? What happened there? From goatse security to the Daily Stormer.
- cabaalis 2y agoIf anyone from there reads the parent, they should know they have created an atmosphere where the worry of possible prosecution over responsible disclosure has the potential to scare away the best minds in our country from picking at these systems. That just means the best minds from other, potentially less friendly countries, will do the picking. I doubt they will responsibly disclose.
- smsm42 2y agoI personally don't comprehend how these people are taking such a huge risks. Once bureaucrat wakes one morning in the wrong mood and your life is ruined at least for the next decade, maybe forever. Why would anyone do it - just for the thrill of it? I don't think they even got paid for it?
- newscracker 2y agoI’m not sure any country’s bureaucracy really appreciates responsible disclosures that make the government’s systems look very poorly designed. There is always the risk of being classified as an enemy agent/criminal depending on who’s reading the report and their own biases.
- mpaco 2y agoThe timeline mentions the disclosure was made through CISA, and on their website there is an official incident report form. I can imagine an email to some generic email address could have gone down the way you describe, but I guess they look at these reports more professionally. https://myservices.cisa.gov/irf https://myservices.cisa.gov/irf
- Enginerrrd 2y agoI mean... they still might if the wrong people end up getting embarrassed by this. The wheels of bureaucracy are slow.
- neilv 2y agoGood catch. Of course, different people wear different shades of hat, and I guess the author might have good rationale for going quite as far as they did, I don't know. Kudos to the author for alerting DHS. Methodology questions aside, it sounds like the author did a service, by alerting of a technical vulnerability that would be plausible for a bad actor to seek out and successfully discover. But regardless, I hope any new/aspiring security researchers don't read this writeup, and assume that they could do something analogous in an investigation, without possibly getting into trouble they'd sorely regret. Some of the lines are fuzzy and complicated. BTW, if it turns out that the author made a legality/responsibility mistake in any of the details of how they investigated, then maybe the best outcome would be to coordinate publishing a genuine mea culpa and post mortem on that. It could explain what the mistake was, why it was a mistake, and what in hindsight they would've done differently. Help others know where the righteous path is, amidst all the fuzziness, and don't make contacting the proper authorities look like a mistake.
- lyu07282 2y agoIn some countries where this is the norm, like Germany, the usual route is to report the issue to journalists or to non-profits like the CCC and those then report the issue to the government agency/company. This way you won't get prosecuted for responsible disclosure. Alternatively an even safer route is to write a report and send it to them anonymously with a hard deadline on public/full disclosure, won't get any credit for the discovery this way of course.
- bryant 2y agoDHS officially uses bugcrowd, for what it's worth. https://bugcrowd.com/engagements/dhs-vdp https://bugcrowd.com/engagements/dhs-vdp They've had that relationship for a few years now, so I'm guessing they're somewhat versed. TSA specifically might be less so, but I can't imagine the DHS referring anything to the DOJ for prosecution given that they both have a VDP for the entire department and advise other departments on how to run VDPs (via CISA). But I might just be overly optimistic.