6 ms·
How Deep Can Humans Go?
- tusslewake 2y agoHave seen at least one other of these articles lately, on the theoretical limits of some human physical capacity. Here's another, on sprinting: https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/olympics/interactive/2024/olympics-records-athletes-unbreakable-human-limit/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/sports/olympics/interactive/2... A few follow-up questions that occur to me: will an understanding of theoretical limits make the actual record breaking seem more routine and less interesting? And will many records be broken beyond the theoretical limit, making these calculations seem rather crude and short-sighted?
- abrahms 2y agoThere was a youtube video I came across a few weeks ago which took Usain Bolt's world record and did a bio-mechanical analysis to see how far off he was from his absolute theoretical best. It was... surprisingly close. I think they had him at like an 8.9s 100m if he did everything perfectly.
- maicro 2y agoFor those who don't know the current records well, from Wikipedia[0]: The men's world record is 9.58 seconds, set by Jamaica's Usain Bolt in 2009, while the women's world record is 10.49 seconds, set by American Florence Griffith-Joyner in 1988[a]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/100_metres https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/100_metres [a] is a footnote on the wikipedia page, discussing the validity of the record due to wind speed measurement concerns; read the page and footnote if you care about that level of detail
- gadders 2y agoIt will be interesting to see what records the Enhanced Games (where athletes are allowed to take [more/different] performance enhancing drugs openly) throw up when they are held. You'd need to persuade someone already at a pretty elite level to take part though. Maybe someone who just did their last Olympics?
- nonameiguess 2y agoThey may do better than unenhanced humans (a fair number of eastern bloc records from the pre-testing era still stand today, especially in women's throwing events), but they're not going to exceed any hard biomechanical limits. No drug can grow more type II fibers or change the firing rate of the nerves. The one extreme option out there is surgery to change the attachment point of the tendon to the bone, generating more torque from the same contractile force. Some possibly acropyphal rumors claim lifters in nations with very unscrupulous doctors may have done that when the opportunity presented itself because of an incidental muscle tear.
- gadders 2y agoI agree in that they won't make bones tougher or tendons more elastic. They maybe able to add more TypeII fibres though if they grow additional muscle? The other big thing on the horizon is gene doping, such as with Myostatin in Bully Whippets.
- knallfrosch 2y agoWhy should we believe this theoretical approach is more accurate than the 30 meters believed to have been the limit for diving?
- karaterobot 2y ago> In addition to the challenges posed by these high pressures, FDs have no access to oxygen (O2) as they are underwater in a hypoxic (no O2) environment. Am I missing something, or is this the most unnecessary statement you could possibly make in an article about free diving? I think most readers know you can't breathe underwater.
- antiquark 2y agoAnd to add to the confusion, there is actually "hypoxic water" which is water containing no oxygen and is harmful to marine life.
- actionfromafar 2y agoIt can be quite dramatic. Fish can die almost instantly if they traverse the boundary.
- gmane 2y agoIt feels like it might have been written by AI. The cadence of the text is really unnatural.
- etiam 2y agoApparently the author is fresh out of B.Sc. She may not have much practice with writing pieces like this. (Daniela is a recent B.Sc. graduate from the program of Physiology at McGill. She is very passionate about understanding the human body and how we can all individually adapt our daily lifestyles to improve its functioning. Part of the OSS mandate is to foster science communication and critical thinking in our students and the public. We hope you enjoy these pieces from our Student Contributors and welcome any feedback you may have!) Another, more disturbing, possibility is that she could be right to include it for some of today's lay audience. I am seeing staggering levels of ignorance about chemistry in media here. Latest example being a radio anchor who had obviously never encountered the word cadmium in her life and made a very awkward (and failed) attempt to sound her way through it.
- karaterobot 2y ago
- ziddoap 2y ago>Of these, the no-limits category presents FDs with the greatest challenge as they descend using a loaded sleigh and ascend using an air balloon. I thought that ascending too quickly could lead to issues (if I remember House correctly, "the bends")? Or does that only occur at greater depths than a freediver would reach? This seems even more dangerous than normal freediving, which seems pretty dangerous as-is. (I know nothing about diving).
- gosub100 2y agoThey're not breathing in compressed air at depth (which could then expand in their blood upon surfacing), just what they brought in from the surface.
- ethbr1 2y agoIt's not breathing compressed air that causes the problem, but rather that the gasses in your lungs are pressurized at all + rapidly lowering pressure on your entire body on ascent. In freediving, the air in your lungs is still pressurized equally at depth to what it would be with scuba, so the same thing happens. In scuba, you do replace the amount of problematic gas in your lungs as you breathe, which potentially leads to higher body saturation (as you're not just exhausting what's in one single lungful). But that's more about gas interchange at all than pressure. If you spend long enough at depth, even without breathing, you run into the same problem.
- stonemetal12 2y agoThe bends are caused by accumulated nitrogen dissolving in tissue\blood. No breathing, means no added nitrogen, so no build up. Also it is a somewhat slow process, no breathing means they aren't under long enough for it to develop even if they had extra nitrogen. It is a problem caused by Scuba, and the fact that Scuba does what it is supposed to, extend the time you can spend underwater, is what causes the bends.
- itishappy 2y ago> It is a problem caused by Scuba, and the fact that Scuba does what it is supposed to, extend the time you can spend underwater, is what causes the bends. To expand on this a bit (pun intended), freediving after SCUBA is extremely dangerous, and this even includes shallow stuff like snorkeling. SCUBA adds dissolved gas to your blood, but once it's there decompression from any source puts you at risk for the bends. Repeated dives will have additional safety limits imposed due to the residual gas, which is managed by a complicated series of dive tables or a modern dive computer. https://www.naui.org/resources/dive-tables-review/ https://www.naui.org/resources/dive-tables-review/
- klodolph 2y agoThe limits for other types of diving are interesting, too. All of the different gases you use for SCUBA diving have a maximum operating depth. At high pressures, various gases become toxic or cause side effects. Oxygen has a limit somewhere in the 1.2-1.6 bar range, and it becomes toxic. For deep dives, you need a lower percentage of oxygen in the mixture. Nitrogen causes nitrogen narcosis at higher pressures, so for deep dives, you need a lower percentage of nitrogen in the mixture. You need to add something else if you want to lower both nitrogen and oxygen, and that’s helium. At high enough pressures, helium causes high-pressure nervous syndrome, a.k.a. helium tremors. That’s normally the limit. Pretty much every gas is bad for you at these pressures. There is an experimental alternative, which is to use hydrogen gas for the deepest dives, but people are understandably cautious about breathing a mixture of oxygen and hydrogen.
- VBprogrammer 2y ago> people are understandably cautious about breathing a mixture of oxygen and hydrogen Wimps.
- qayxc 2y agoIn principle liquid breathing is still an option. It's not great, but certainly better than oxygen + hydrogen.
- therein 2y agoSince we are talking about interactions with the nervous system, how do we go from the pressure at which these gasses were delivered to the alveoli to their behavior in the blood? I understand the practice GP is describing pretty well but when I try to simulate what is going on in my mind, it's not like these gasses are in gaseous form once they are in the blood. Are we just talking about the concentration that are reached because the pressure affects the diffusion gradient?
- hbrav 2y agoYou've got exactly the right image in mind: higher partial pressure of a gas in the lungs corresponds to a higher dissolved concentration of that species (H2, He, N2, O2, whatever) in the blood and tissue.
- ashton314 2y agoThis is one of those things that, were an alien to encounter the stats sheet for humans, they would go, "holy crap humans do that?" Ability to lift crazy heavy things when there's enough adrenaline rushing through your system is pretty wild too. Yay humans!
- teddyh 2y agoI am told that <https://old.reddit.com/r/HFY/ https://old.reddit.com/r/HFY/> may be for you.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- mcswell 2y agoI learned about shallow water hypoxia when I first took up SCUBA diving (before most of you were born :)). It occurs during ascent, for two reasons. The most obvious is that you've been holding your breath longer when you're ascending. The other is that when your body is under pressure, the partial pressure of oxygen in your lungs is higher, allowing the hemoglobin to absorb more. As you ascend and the pressure lessens, the partial pressure of oxygen decreases accordingly. Apparently shallow water hypoxia is now a thing that life guards worry about, despite the fact that it's unlikely in a swimming pool. I swam underwater about fifty feet in my neighborhood pool, which is five feet deep, and was told by the lifeguard never to do that again. Indeed there's a sign that says "don't hold your breath underwater." Maybe you're supposed to breathe underwater? I blame the American Red Cross, which has a history of dumb things IMO, starting with teaching the crawl stroke to non-swimmers instead of the side stroke or back stroke, both of which require far less coordination, and allow you to keep your face out of the water while swimming. But don't get me started, or I'll tell you about "drown proofing."
- BalinKing 2y agoI'm somewhat confused about how the Red Cross is involved with shallow water hypoxia... could you clarify? Also, now I'm curious about "drown proofing," if you wouldn't mind elaborating!
- foxyv 2y agoThe only drown proofing I can think of is what the Navy Seals do in BUDs. They tie their hands behind their back and their legs together and then pop up for air when they need it. It's a lot harder for those guys because their body fat percentage is microscopic so they sink like rocks. They would probably have to give me a couple pounds of lead to sink properly... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Pe3L5OcAEg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1Pe3L5OcAEg
- mcswell 2y agoSorry, I didn't see your question before. I think there's an article in wikipedia about it, but from what I recall: there were studies that said most people drown in water just over their head, not in deep water. Drown proofing was a technique where you held your breath, and sank. I'm not sure how that was supposed to work, since most people are positively buoyant, especially if they take a deep breath--something about kicking up so your shoulders came out of the water, and then you sank down at first from the weight of the part of your body above water, and then the rest of the way from momentum. When you hit the bottom, you kicked off with your body angled toward shore. Rinse and repeat, until you were in water where you could stand up. What's wrong with that? Lake and river bottoms (and ocean beaches) can have troughs, you could easily wind up in water too deep to do this. And if you can kick enough to get your shoulders out of the water, why not just use your arms to propel yourself toward shore? It just seemed like teaching people a simple stroke (like breast, side or back--anything but crawl) would be easier and safer. But then I fail to understand how people drown because they get caught in rip currents. Getting out of one is so easy.
- disparate_dan 2y agoI wonder if there are lessons to be drawn from other marine mammals which can diver way deeper and longer than assisted humans, although they all also metabolise oxygen. How for example do cetaceans deal with the nitrogen in their bloodstream on returning to the surface?
- _a_a_a_ 2y agoevolution
- nradov 2y agoMarine mammals have evolved adaptations that reduce nitrogen uptake, but there is some evidence to indicate that they do suffer from decompression sickness. https://www.nature.com/scitable/blog/saltwater-science/do_whales_suffer_from_decompression/ https://www.nature.com/scitable/blog/saltwater-science/do_wh...
- ratrocket 2y agoIf you're interested in freediving or want to know more about it, and you like reading, James Nestor (maybe more well known for his book "Breath" about... well, breathing through your nose) wrote a book called "Deep" that is quite readable and I found informative (had no prior interest in freediving and haven't thought about it much since the book, but it was still worth reading!) I've found so many good book recommendations on HN, so thought I'd drop that here!
- NKosmatos 2y agoI highly recommend the film “The Big Blue” by Luc Besson. One of the best freediving movies based on a fictional story about Jacques Mayol and Enzo Maiorca. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Big_Blue https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Big_Blue
- makeitdouble 2y agoTrigger warning: suicide is touched upon in the movie (in a bit more romanticized version than the real life events, if I remember correctly)
- hermitcrab 2y agoIIRC the plot is a bit thin, but the visuals are stunning.
- chandlore 2y agoAn enjoyable article on free diving from 2009: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/08/24/the-deepest-dive https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2009/08/24/the-deepest-di...
- riffraff 2y agoI think the article intro timeline is incorrect, Wikipedia on the page for Enzo Maiorca[0] reports the record in 1956 was already 41 meters. [0] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enzo_Maiorca https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enzo_Maiorca
- hermitcrab 2y agoI've had nitrogen narcosis while scuba diving. It manifested itself as underwater kleptomania, with me trying to take various worthless tat off the sunken trawler we were diving on. I remember unscrewing light bulbs and trying to remove some manky old curtains, to take as 'prizes'. It seemed quite logical at the time. Rather concerning for my dive buddy though!
- madaxe_again 2y agoI’ve had shallow water blackout - and let me tell you it feels great - as if you hyperventilate before diving, you can suppress the urge to breathe after fighting it a little while - and that period between suppressing the urge to breathe and your brain just going lights out is unbelievably tranquil.
- hermitcrab 2y agoAs a kid I used to dive into the pool at an angle and spin round really fast at the bottom of the dive. The caused a small 'high' (from blood rushing into the brain?). It was probably quite dangerous!
- ljf 2y agoGreat video presentation on an experimental dive to 230 meters, using hydrogen: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=skL5EQa8DFY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=skL5EQa8DFY "The probability of survival in such a dive is greater than zero" - 20m17s
- AeZ1E 2y agowho are all these people thinking we humans have reached our limit for diving? with each record broken, it just proves we can go beyond! let's see how far the human body can go, maybe we'll discover something new - like gills or something!
- _yb2s 2y agoAs a freediver, the author is not correct that “freedivers often hyperventilate.” Not hyperventilating before diving is one of the most important safety rules in freediving. It drops your blood CO2 so you don’t feel like you need to breathe, but doesn’t actually increase your O2- leading to losing track of how long you’ve been down, and blacking out. Instead, you just learn to handle the feeling of high CO2, but use that feeling as a timer to tell you when you’ve been down too long.
- hermitcrab 2y agoPerhaps they are confusing hyperventilation (rapid breathing in and out) with gulping extra air (without exhaling)?
- ablation 2y agoDon’t they also discus that with the frog breathing technique?
- hermitcrab 2y agoBTW, for anyone that has never dived to any depth, you don't really feel the change in pressure much at 20m or 30m, even though you are at 3 to 4 times atmospheric pressure. Apart from your ear canals, which can very painful if you don't manage to equalize them. The air from the scuba tank is fed at ambient pressure, so your chest isn't compressed and you don't really feel it on the rest of your body.
- patrakov 2y ago(Former freediver here) Down to ~27 meters, there is also nothing special when freediving, assuming that you took the fullest possible breath before diving. This is because the water pressure compresses your chest, but it is within the normal excursion limits, i.e., it would compress to the same degree if you fully exhale on dry land, so it feels like something that commonly happens. Below that, it feels like something tries to squeeze you softly. You can try to emulate this feeling on dry land by forcefully exhaling everything that you can plus a bit more with arms down, closing the glottis, and then lifting your arms up.