12 ms·
"This is a small example of a big problem with usability and cybersecurity. This is what happens when apps are developed by engineers who don’t have a strong kn
by SoftTalker 2y ago
"This is a small example of a big problem with usability and cybersecurity. This is what happens when apps are developed by engineers who don’t have a strong knowledge of customers"
This really rings true. Just think of all the nonsense you have to deal with in the name of "security." Mandatory password change intervals. Insane rules for constructing passwords. Completely undocumented password requirements that you just have to figure out by trial and error. Complicated error messages full of security jargon. "Secret Questions" that you can't remember the answers to. And on the other side of the coin, the security of these systems themselves is like a sieve. So many data breaches, information disclosures, they are in the news almost daily. I often wonder how they get away with it all.
- robertlagrant 2y agoThis isn't engineers doing that. It's CYA IT cyber policies.
- SahAssar 2y agoSure, but a lot of engineers aren't completely blameless. They should push back and explain why these are bad choices just like I would expect a building engineer to say to me that cardboard is not the ideal load bearing element for my skyscraper. If the company still pushes forward with bad choices its on them, but they should be clearly informed how and why those choices are bad.
- harimau777 2y agoPushing back is a great way to lose your job or get past over for pay raises.
- SahAssar 2y agoIn bad orgs, yes. In good orgs you get appreciated for speaking up and communicating what will be future problems.
- recursive 2y agoOk and? Some people work in "bad" orgs.
- stoperaticless 2y agoWe all can choose to either just follow orders or try to influence the direction. Some caveats: 1. Nobody will be convinced to change the position on the first attempt, but seeds of knowledge can be planted in other peoples heads and some of those seeds will bear fruit later. 2. Being not nice, shuts down the passageway of ideas.
- Spooky23 2y agoUsually this nonsense is driven by regulatory inertia out of control of the org.
- SAI_Peregrinus 2y agoIt's usually driven by industry standards, not government regulations.
- sigseg1v 2y agoMany large orgs, even if individual companies are doing "fine" (not gonna say perfect, but also generally competent) have a parent organization that manages all this audit and policy stuff. In my experience the parent org is nearly impossible to change from the direction of bottom-up. I can get someone to forward an inquiry to them but it takes forever and from their side it's going to look like "hey boss, so, 4 of the 5 subsidiary companies passed the security audit already 2 months ago and the 1 that didn't pass is trying to tell us to modify the policy" to which they'd say "how did nobody else mention this? sounds like they are being difficult. Can we just hurry them along? The audit is already overdue and we need all companies passing for this quarter" and the response you'll get back is essentially "deal with it"
- vips7L 2y agoAll in the name of audit check boxes.
- meroes 2y agoSo far https://studentaid.gov/ https://studentaid.gov/ is the worst I've come across (I don't want to enter fake info^ and I can't duplicate my account to double check the requirements). From memory it was something like: 1) No words! 2) Can't reuse last 24 passwords 3) Excludes some special characters 4) 5 Security questions 5-10) Several other password requirements Are the security questions case sensitive? Who knows. ^ "I understand that I’ll be required to certify that the information I provide to create an account is true and correct and that I’m the individual I claim to be. If I’m not the person I claim to be, I understand that I’m not authorized to proceed and that I should exit this form now. If I provide false or misleading information, I understand that I might be subject to a fine, prison time, or both."
- lostlogin 2y ago> If I provide false or misleading information, I understand that I might be subject to a fine, prison time, or both Enter your password wrong and you're off to jail?
- thaumasiotes 2y agoMight, not will.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoHopefully "Fakename Q Notarealperson" won't get me arrested… Here's the password help message: --- Your password must be 8 to 30 characters in length and must contain at least one uppercase letter, one lowercase letter, and one number. Your password is case-sensitive. You can’t use personal identifiers such as your first or last name, date of birth, or Social Security number in your password. --- Here are some error codes the API returns: ["NULL_USERNAME", "NULL_EMAIL", "PWD_ILLEGAL_CHARACTERS", "PWD_CONTAINS_SPACE", "NULL_CHALLENGE_QAS"] The UI doesn't expose the password error codes. It just says “You entered an invalid response. For more info, select the help (?) icon.” (The NULL_USERNAME and NULL_EMAIL errors seem to be spurious in this context.)
- meroes 2y ago
- tetrep 2y ago> Just think of all the nonsense you have to deal with in the name of "security." Well, the good news is that everything you listed is known as a bad idea to both end users and people who understand security (which is, sadly, not most people who implement security policies). Using 4 or more dictionary words provides excellent password security and you can do the same for all of your security answers too. There's a variety of free and paid for password managers that solve the issue of trying to remember all your secrets (great for backing up 2FA secrets too). I'm not sure what you mean by "complicated error messages" but I assume it's errors that they expect the user to fix themselves, otherwise they could return a generic nonspecific error and a unique ID for you to provide when you contact support to get help. While it sucks to get jargon spammed, I feel like pretty standard human ineptitude at explaining an error rather than anything specific to security. I also think it's how many people feel about any error message that contains computer jargon (PC LOAD LETTER!?!?). > I often wonder how they get away with it all. My thinking (and experience...) is that most organizations are failing at a lot of things at any given time, even if the business overall is successful. Security is just one of those things. I wouldn't be surprised at a small elite organization not following that trend, but any sufficiently large organization is going to have incompetent people doing incompetent things.
- Dylan16807 2y ago> Using 4 or more dictionary words provides excellent password security I would not call 44-48 bits "excellent". It works if there's a good password hash being used, but if someone left PBKDF on basic settings then a GPU might be able to do 50 million guesses per second, or for a plain old salted hash 50 billion guesses per second.
- norgie 2y agoHow does that math work?
- Dylan16807 2y agoThe bits, I'm assuming a list of about 2k-4k words. The XKCD example is 2k, so 11 bits per word. The guesses per second, I looked up some hashcat benchmarks to get a rough range.
- brookst 2y ago> Completely undocumented password requirements that you just have to figure out by trial and error. My favorite is: 1. I go to a website I haven’t used in a while but know I have an account on 2. I sign in with my email and what I’m sure is the right password for that site (algorithmically generated from site URL) 3. Password not valid 4. Ok, maybe this was an older version my my algorithm from way back 5. Password not valid 6. Fine, hit password reset 7. Get reset email and click it 8. Enter algorithmically generated password as new password 9. Error, can’t have that special character 10. Fine, per my rules, replace that special character with next one 11. Sorry, can’t reset password to your current password 12. Aaaaaargh.
- rightbyte 2y agoThis has bugged me a lot. Have I been gaslighted? Like, do sites lose my password? I can swear there have been like 10 occasions in the last 20 years where I had to reset my password where I am pretty sure I knew it.
- 14 2y agoThat’s how I lost my Hotmail account.
- gerdesj 2y agoThey emailed you the password reset link?
- 14 2y agowell I am definitely to blame though it still makes me sour. When I created the account it was a time when the issue of corporations abusing your information was a hot topic. So when I created the account I was in the mindset that I should not give all my information to any company so I made up my details. So I did not have a real name it was obviously fake and I used a fake birthday. I had all this information but I strongly believe they realized my name was a fake and cut me off. I tried to do the reset link but it never worked. Still to this day I get the occasion email from that account as I did set it up to forward to my gmail. Just yesterday I got an email about verifying my insticart account and it was not me. I am still bothered years later that I was logged out and my password that I am sure i knew did not work. I feel like they forced me to try a reset and when I did it failed. That was my first email. I wish I could get back in. I screwed up with the fake info. I was young. I have given up and don't think there is a fix at this time, it has been years. I have grieved and moved on.
- jlarocco 2y ago"This is what happens when apps are developed by engineers who don’t have a strong knowledge of customers" I'd replace "engineers" with "product owners". I'm sure the engineers at Microsoft know some of the stuff they're doing is braindead and are unable to do anything about it.
- surfingdino 2y agoIt's likely that the subject of overwriting accounts has been discussed with business more than once, but the business are so stupid that they do not see it as a problem, or think that if anything goes wrong (as it inevitably will) they will loose their pension. So nothing changes. All software companies have an expiry date and Microsoft is a couple of decades past its own.
- delecti 2y agoMy bank introduced "usernames" at some point, breaking login with email addresses, but didn't document this fact, or enforce that usernames not be set to email addresses. For a few months, every time I went to login, I had to use the "find my account" function, and each time I would again set my username to my email address (and why wouldn't I, it had been my login credential for nearly a decade by that point). At no point did it ever enforce a restriction on the @ or . in the username, until I went to login. It took me literal months to figure out and set it to something else. This is Capital One by the way. My account was originally ING Direct, then Capital One 360, before being fully incorporated into the rest of their nonsense, and I assume that's related to the username situation.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- EduardoBautista 2y agoAt a Mexican bank, Banregio, there was a character limit to the username on mobile but not on web. So I originally had a username that was accepted at registration but not when I tried to log in on my phone and it wouldn’t allow me to input my entire username. Edit: The issue was with the password field, not the username.
- waterproof 2y agoUSAA had a similar issue for some time, but with the password field. One interface (web or mobile, I don’t remember) would silently truncate the password. You couldn’t even tell it was being truncated because it was all **!
- EduardoBautista 2y agoActually, looking at the credentials in 1Password for this bank, my issue was with the password field, so similar to USAA. Mobile had a 15 character limit.
- bongodongobob 2y ago> Mandatory password change intervals. Hasn't been best practice for a decade. > Insane rules for constructing passwords. There needs to be a minimum standard. Generally length is enough, but the special character type stuff is annoying. > Completely undocumented password requirements that you just have to figure out by trial and error. I haven't come across this. > Complicated error messages full of security jargon. "Secret Questions" that you can't remember the answers to. That's a you problem. Y'all complain about password breaches but want to use Mypassword69! for everything. Pick a lane.
- smohare 2y agoI encounter some bogus undocumented password constraints probably half the time I create an account. Usually it is a maximal length requirement that is not mentioned in the error message. Don’t defend these idiotic practices.
- bongodongobob 2y agoI'm not. The only time I've seen a maximum length password was like 10 years ago on Dell's IDRAC I think? I just don't think the complaints being thrown out here are good arguments.
- tsimionescu 2y agoLook at Microsoft's personal accounts (live.com or whatever they are calling it this week) - they still have this limit.
- pasquinelli 2y agoi just had it happen day before yesterday to create an account for a service to do a background check for a new job. it rejected my password without saying why and i could only get past it by shortening it to 15 characters. and then the deeper question is, why do i need to create an account for this?
- 2y ago
- racked 2y agoMicrosoft SSO/auth flows have that feel in general. Really feels like something hacked together. Some examples from the top off my mind: - In MS Authenticator, having to click on each subject rather than just showing the code immediately. If Google's Authenticator can show the code, why can't MS's? - Azure DevOps randomly redirecting to the login form and back while already logged in. - Azure DevOps randomly opening an authentication popup (presumably some SSO stuff) and closing it again - Clunky-looking Office365 account management flows
- Sylamore 2y agoMS Authenticator will show the codes for TOTP if you go to the hamburger menu and select "show codes".
- racked 2y agoHah, you're right. Thanks!
- vladvasiliu 2y agoI only very rarely use Azure DevOps, but that seems tame. If you have multiple accounts open in the same browser session, regular Azure portal won't remember which one you chose when opening in a new tab. If you got to a new tab by clicking a link, it will send you to select which account you want, then helpfully send you to the portal homepage, forgetting the initial URL. Well, that was before. Since a few days, they seem to have improved the experience, since they no longer ask which account I want to use, but helpfully pick the first on the list. No, they still don't remember which account was already being used when clicking the link. And no, switching accounts from the top-right icon doesn't keep you on your current page but sends you back to the portal homepage. Then there are other webapps which seem to implement their own login flow: they figure your session is expired, but don't allow you to switch accounts. The only way to use a different account from this flow is to sign out of the current one, which, of course, signs you out from everywhere. The solution is going to a different site, say myaccount, login with the second one, go back to the first site which now allows you to choose.
- blackeyeblitzar 2y agoA few years ago Yahoo forced a password reset on old accounts. People had to remember the answer to secret questions from many years back, instead of the password they could enter correctly. And if they couldn’t guess the secret question, they were simply locked out of their email account. Utter insanity, but these types of quirks are everywhere still. Banks have strange password rules very often. And they may support only SMS 2FA. United Airlines still forces users to enter secret questions and answers. Medium has a bizarre “magic link” workflow. Etcetera.
- thaumasiotes 2y agoWhat's especially terrible about this is that secret questions only weaken the security of your account, so someone doing the right thing will have provided a random answer unrelated to their life. Years ago, I went through this process with Blizzard: 1. Blizzard started deactivating my World of Warcraft account on the grounds that I hadn't paid my subscription. 2. I would log in and pay for a subscription, reenabling the account. 3. (Steps 1-2 repeated several times. Blizzard never provided any explanation beyond the fact that, in their opinion, my payment was invalid, which it wasn't.) 4. After several rounds, Blizzard disabled the account completely, requiring me to contact customer support. 5. Customer support, for the first time, informed me that the reason my payment was viewed as invalid was that the preferred payment card on my account was set to a different card. The card I was actually using was also listed on my account, but it wasn't the preferred card, which made it invalid. 6. Since my account was disabled, I didn't have the option of paying with my preferred card. I had to answer my secret question. 7. Since I am not stupid, my secret question didn't have an answer. It was a long string of random characters which I didn't know. But customer service happily accepted my oral answer of "it's gibberish", defeating the purpose of the secret question. So I guess the lesson here is that the correct way to answer a secret question is that you need to provide an answer which... (1) Looks like a real answer when customer service looks at it, so that they have a better chance of rejecting someone who doesn't know the answer; but also (2) Doesn't belong to the class of answers that would be easy for someone to guess, such as a car model when they ask you for the model of your first car. These requirements are incompatible with each other. I don't know what secret questions are supposed to be doing. And I have to note that my assumption that there was no reason for anyone, including myself, to know the answer to my secret question would have been completely correct if Blizzard hadn't made the decision that using a payment card that was already registered to my Blizzard account was a sign of fraud.
- surfingdino 2y agoDon't forget "business objectives" i.e. making it work, but be incompatible with other authenticators and claim that other authenticators are inferior. Classic Microsoft FUD combined with low quality of product.
- ahoka 2y ago“Mandatory password change intervals” This is against all current commonly applied security recommendations (NIST, OWASP).
- kayodelycaon 2y agoAnd the rest of the world hasn’t gotten the memo. Rotating passwords was best practice for so long that every standard required it. Those haven’t been updated. Until it’s considered to be actively harmful and you fail audits for it, it won’t die. :(
- Tostino 2y agoI had to push back at my company after getting acquired multiple times that no, I am not implementing your much worse password policies that NIST has argued against for years. All because some 15 year old security document said that's what all their products adhere to.
- sgbeal 2y ago> So many data breaches, information disclosures, they are in the news almost daily. #YesterdayILearned the highly-appropriate phrase "breach fatigue."
- mejthemage 2y agoThose rules sound more like they were developed by admins that don't know proper security and so they add complicated rules to feel like they are improving security. The only password rule that needs to exist is "use something you've never used before". That really does make it difficult for most users though.
- laserbeam 2y agoMy bank password is 5 digits + MFA. I am FORCED to have it 5 digits. I can’t use any other type of passwords with them.
- 8organicbits 2y agoThat has some nice attributes though. Five digits should be quite easy to memorize, avoiding written down passwords. Most phone PINS are four digits, so you avoid phone PIN reuse. Realistically, the second factor is providing the bulk of the security. If that's a typical six digit TOTP, and they validate the PIN and TOTP together then an attacker has a one in one hundred billion chance of guessing correctly (10^5 + 10^6). Add in rate limiting by account and IP address, account locking, and other tools and that's extremely secure. You COULD have a longer password, but the extra entropy is probably excessive. It probably increases the chance of password reuse problems, so pragmatically it may be worse. I wouldn't recommend this approach in general, however.
- DaSHacka 2y agoUSAA? If not, do they also do the weird Symantic codes that're literally vanilla TOTP under the hood[0] but wants you to be locked in to a proprietary app instead? [0] https://locima.com/2019/06/01/replacing-symantec-vip-with-a-generic-totp-app/ https://locima.com/2019/06/01/replacing-symantec-vip-with-a-...
- buro9 2y agoYesterday I had a good example of this. Website: "Please choose a complex password of at least 8 characters including special characters and numbers" Me: Fires up the password manager, generates a 128 character random password, feels smug. Website on next visit: "Please enter the characters in the 31, 98, 102 position from your password" Me: WTAF Context: Mortgage website in the UK Edit: It's now dawned on me that they're storing this plain text so that they can do this... or at least encrypting rather than hashing, meaning that they can always decrypt the password.
- thedanbob 2y agoMaybe we need a corollary to "don't roll your own crypto": "don't roll your own password scheme".
- lazide 2y agoSo what is the ‘standard’ then that doesn’t suck?
- Morpholemew 2y agohttps://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63b.html#memsecret https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63b.html#memsecret Basically, 8 characters or more, but prevent the user from picking a password that appears on any of the leaked password lists. Store in pbkdf2 or better; use argon2id per https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/Password_Storage_Cheat_Sheet.html https://cheatsheetseries.owasp.org/cheatsheets/Password_Stor... That's it. Simple. No mandatory symbols. No mandatory changes after a period of time. A password strength estimation meter is optional. If it needs to be more secure, I might require more minimum characters, but no other restrictions.
- lazide 2y agoAh, yet another standard. How many years do you think before it’s obsolete? Also, the ‘no previously leaked passwords’ are gonna piss off a lot of customers.
- 8gt786gv87g 2y agoengineers typically do not understand people very well as a baseline. i think engineering attracts the type of people who struggle with social behavior. you can't make it work unless you filter those engineers out and companies do not hire engineers to understand the customer anyways. companies hire data science to ascertain human behavior, but this is not understanding the customer. if you want to improve your products and actually understand the customer then start giving your customer service or customer experience departments a financial boost instead of treating them like the bottom feeders of the entire company. > I often wonder how they get away with it all. unregulated industry + no union. tech workers practically beg to be exploited.
- indymike 2y agoComplexity is the enemy of both security and usability. I had a day last week where I had to authenticate 28 times to different services due to forced re-auths. No security benefit. None. It cost me 2-3 hours of my life. The IT team needs to realize their security is costing our company 4102avg_hourly_pay*26 for this. That’s a lot of money for zero benefit.
- mirekrusin 2y agoSomething tells me those kind of mistakes are not done "by engineers" / "by developers" – who rarely have any saying at all and if they do they are ignored more often than not – more likely that's incompetent pseudo-architects and/or product owners/managers.
- bgro 2y agoI’ve been reporting major problems nonstop for the past like 20 years. It usually takes me less than 5 minutes when I first learn of some new security feature to find a problem with it. Most of that 5 minutes is physically writing my email to security highlighting major oversights. I don’t know how these people get jobs and gatekeep me out of both hiring or my scientifically accurate and backed feedback for not passing the buzzfeed security quizzes for certifications. I’m otherwise a full stack software engineer. Even my simple requests like not auto flagging emails from confirmed and fully validated Microsoft services gets denied because it’s “too hard” so everything except internal users and random whitelisted services like github and azure AWS is instead flagged as suspicious, causing alertness fatigue. I’ve reported major logic problems to many major companies and usually the only response I get is an indirect followup email through HR or some other non technical people sent to the entire distribution list as a followup saying how it’s technically better than what was there before (it’s scientifically and mathematically not) and that we just need to do it. I never get recognized or win bug bounties because there’s always some loophole where I didn’t actually help them and they just magically fixed the long standing issue by coincidence after I reported it. Most recently, I discovered a “feature” with Microsoft OAuth that has a severe flaw and could essentially shut down all MS OAuth functionality, and all consequences branching from that. Still no response. I’m not even trying to find these. They just keep getting in my way of trying to do work. For example, I have to authenticate up to FIVE times per authentication, per authentication —- Auth syncing can be slow leading to multiple auth requests that would otherwise only need a single one to propegate. 5 authentications * 5 programs needing individual (slow-sync) auth = 25 authentications I have to already pass to be able to start standup or pass in order to un-hard-freeze my live demo to potentially hundreds of engineers. Imagine driving your car, and the steering wheel locks when it loses internet connection (like in a tunnel or just randomly) or because the re-auth period has passed. Security devs don’t want to full stop the car because they’ll get yelled at, so just lock steering so they can’t steer home. Well now if you’re on a highway, that’s pretty stressful and dangerous. But it’s like they are just salting the wound by adding a series of glitchy minigames where you have to first read all the spammy popup dialogs, and then solve a Baldi’s Basics math puzzle, and then rotate a ball to not be upside down (?) and then manually match a missile launch code.
- danparsonson 2y agoMy favourite recent example was an app that made me create an account, and allowed me to provide a 24 character password, which then sent me a validation email requiring a login on their website, where a 20 character password limit was in force.
- jollofricepeas 2y agoI actually blame the auditors. In the case of password construction and complexity, we’ve learned that rotation and complexity leads to worse password practices. https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63b.html https://pages.nist.gov/800-63-3/sp800-63b.html However many large companies do not adhere to the latest NIST guidance (which is many years old by now). This is why password complexity and rotation is still so nuts.