10 ms·
Deals with the devil aren't what they used to be
- office_drone 2y agohttps://archive.is/1jr1B https://archive.is/1jr1B
- jmugan 2y agoThis is written for someone with a higher reading level than me. I skimmed the first few paragraphs and have no idea what it is about beyond the title.
- idle_zealot 2y agoIt meanders around the history of tales involving selling one's soul for worldly power or gratification, then in the last sentence says that's what smartphones are, because we trade privacy and identity for convenience.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- galdosdi 2y agoI don't mean this offensively, but if this is beyond your reading level and you went to college, your college did not do a good job. The vocabulary and structure is nothing out of the ordinary for college level reading. That said, like some college level reading, it definitely meanders a bit, is a little self-important and feels padded with unnecessary filler, and is just only somewhat but ultimately not deeply interesting unless you are already pretty interested in how tales of the devil featured in medieval Europe. It's ok. I didn't finish it. If you misspoke and meant you didn't feel like reading it, but certainly could have comprehended it, then never mind I guess But again, this isn't personal-- but if you are a successful educated software engineer who genuinely finds this beyond your reading level, your reading level is low for your station in life. It will limit your rise. Take it as an insult if you like though I don't mean it that way or else a wake up call. The reason I dare stick my fingers into this fire and possibly offend you is, there is a trend of "educated" people who know science but completely skipped humanities, and thus have huge blind spots. My real audience for this comment is other people who will be encouraged to value the ability to read obtuse things and write clearly, to understand history and literature. And if you are picking a college for your kids, check out the readings for some classes. If they are not expected to easily be able to read something at this level, then it's a waste of money unless it's very cheap.
- acheron 2y agoYou must be old. Nowadays even Harvard students aren't expected to be able to read anything complicated. From coincidentally, another New Yorker link: https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/03/06/the-end-of-the-english-major https://www.newyorker.com/magazine/2023/03/06/the-end-of-the... -- "The last time I taught 'The Scarlet Letter,' I discovered that my students were really struggling to understand the sentences as sentences—like, having trouble identifying the subject and the verb," she said. "Their capacities are different, and the nineteenth century is a long time ago."
- galdosdi 2y agoAh. So that's why so many people think chatgpt is such a boon for drafting trivial things that a competent writer could do almost as fast, but with more control. They really can't do it. The deskilling continues. "What can be expected of a man who has spent 20 years putting heads on pins?" PS: I am not that old. I was in the college class '11 at an average small liberal arts college with an over 60% acceptance rate. I was not exceptional. I think the deskilling has accelerated very greatly and very recently.
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoThe story by E.M. Forster is actually "The Machine Stops". The dystopia that came to mind for me was Harrison Bergeron, only instead of a human Handicapper General enforcing an equality of sub-mediocrity, it will be the masses and the tools they were bequeathed by the FAANGs. Having also been at uni in '11, I agree - GenZ and below are unnerving to observe.
- galdosdi 2y agoNB- this is in reply to an earlier version of my comment, which I edited out purely for brevity, but now guiltily am restoring here-- where I worried we're marching towards a dystopia like the ones imagined in many works like Idiocracy, Wall-E, or The Machine Stops (misremembering the title as The Machine Breaks Down or something) You make a very good point. I am starting to hear things along the lines of "But it's normal that some people learn better from videos" and "Why are you gatekeeping this knowledge" and even here you increasingly see references to videos that are much lower detail but higher time commitment summaries of writing that has much more detail available yet could be consumed, skimmed, etc more quickly than sitting through a video that your eyes have no ability to skip around, rushing past the irrelevant and dwelling on the relevant, without ever having to click a button. They already invented telepathic interfaces -- books.
- giraffe_lady 2y agoThis happens every time an article from the new yorker is posted. Now we will mostly talk about this, about the merits or pointlessness of literary nonfiction and literature in general. Maybe recommend each other some brandon sanderson or malcolm gladwell and all have a great time.
- jonchang 2y agoDeveloping media literacy is an important skill! One way to approach this work is to understand the genre of the work you are reading! We can determine genre in a few ways, but in this case, we see that the publication is the New Yorker, which tells us to expect magazine-style writing, specifically longer form feature pieces. Another important clue is that this is published in the New Yorker's "Books" section, suggesting that this is a book review. And, if you know much about the New Yorker's book reviews, they often include things such as history of the field the book addresses, compares the book to other related books, and what the book's thesis might imply about our world today. This longer form book review can introduce important context and enrich your understanding of the world! I encourage you to keep an open mind and continue to read pieces that are outside of your usual genre.
- moomoo11 2y agoIs this written by gpt
- robbiep 2y agoIt absolutely feels like it
- dalmo3 2y agoIn the style of New Yorker, a joke as old as gpt itself.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoThe style matches, but I think that's because it's just a median style of writing. It's too… je ne sais quoi, to be produced by that algorithm.
- darth_aardvark 2y ago"And, if you know much about the New Yorker's book reviews,", specifically feels like a phrase GPT would never use.
- wizardforhire 2y agoIts making a longwinded comparison between eulas and faustian bargains, trading short term gains for long term suffering.
- dylan604 2y agoSo it's a tale of Boeing?
- CatWChainsaw 2y agoAlmost any company now. If you're not growing faster or making more profit than you were last quarter, forever, the entire world will crash, apparently.
- alekq 2y agoIs English your native language?
- echelon_musk 2y agoFor what it's worth I absolutely loathe this writing style. Just look at this sentence: > No longer open to the pressing torque of divinities and djinns, we moderns are closed off and shut down, buffered and buttressed, marching efficiently through our merely material world, grim-faced assassins of mystery. You could say instead: "Since the Enlightenment people believe in magic less." Come on, "buffered and buttressed", really?! This article is one close to my heart but the pompous writing put me off.
- buescher 2y agoAh, yes, an article about deals with the devil should be straight to the point for the effortless efficiency that only the best bureaucracy can provide. As I tell my team, "bottom line up front, folks!". I hope I have understood you here so please understand me - that is meant with irony but not sarcasm. Perhaps there is a reason for the purple prose, if we only could find it.
- Flop7331 2y agoIt's not that well-written. It's mostly a literary review with a paragraph about silicon shoe-horned in at the end to try to bring home some kind of thesis.
- neves 2y agoI love deals with the Devil. What's your favorite Deal with the Devil tale? Tell me one off the beaten path. My favorite is the Brazillian "Grande Sertão: Veredas"
- paxys 2y agoStingy Jack (namesake for the Jack O'Lantern) – https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingy_Jack https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Stingy_Jack
- jononor 2y agoHere is a Norwegian tale of the Devil, in form of a traditional fiddle song. Music at the bottom, recommend playing it through once before reading the post. https://www.norskkornolfestival.no/2019/06/18/fanitullen/ https://www.norskkornolfestival.no/2019/06/18/fanitullen/
- mac3n 2y agohttps://kasmana.people.charleston.edu/MATHFICT/mfview.php?callnumber=mf97 https://kasmana.people.charleston.edu/MATHFICT/mfview.php?ca... “The Devil and Simon Flagg” in which Flagg sells his soul in exchange for the proof of Fermat’s last theorem. No proof is found, but the Devil becomes consumed with mathematics.
- mihaic 2y agoCool, someone should update the story now with the Collatz conjecture.
- bee_rider 2y agoI love any story about ancient super powerful creatures being defeated by modern people. Humanity kicks ass. These things are often scaled to be something extremely powerful but possible for the hero to struggle against, at the time, which often puts them far below the capabilities of modern society. This is usually missing the point (the ancient God or gods probably set up an adversary that like that on purpose, or whatever, to show something to the mortals), but just taking that on face value and trouncing the thing will never not be funny to me.
- alejohausner 2y agoThe story of Faust is about the dangers of knowledge and technology. If you know too much, you will eventually lose your soul. As this book review explains, with the enlightenment and industrial revolution, this fear of knowledge receded. But the myth is still there. For example, take the "Terminator" movies. They're about the dangers of technology: what if we create machines that are intelligent enough to turn on their creators and seek to destroy them? There is a parallel between gaining forbidden knowledge and making artificial creatures. Today, we are afraid that corporations and governments will use our inventions to control us, but I think that fear has an echo of the old myth that it is dangerous to learn forbidden knowledge, or create artificial life, because that would be entering the realm once reserved for the Almighty.
- hughesjj 2y agoIt's crazy to think that one of the oldest religious stories, the whole Adam and Eve don't eat from the fruit of the forbidden tree of knowledge, actually has a coincidence (...I mean, I believe it was a coincidence) in our past diet https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2017/03/27/521423216/what-gave-some-primates-bigger-brains-a-fruit-filled-diet https://www.npr.org/sections/thesalt/2017/03/27/521423216/wh... I don't believe pre-human primates somehow passed that story down or anything but old stories always make me curious into their origins. Sometimes cool and interesting stuff comes up when you do
- gowld 2y agoFruit is great, as described. Knowing fruit is great is of course adaptive and this receives selective presure. Most life forms naturally seek out the things that they need to survive. Intelligent beings will use their intelligence to seek out such things, and will understand their value.
- krapp 2y agoI've been told the whole Genesis narrative was essentially political propaganda based on the Babylonian creation account in the Enuma Elish and written during the Babylonian exile. I don't know how accurate that is but they do share similarities and given the relative cultural influence of Babylon I wouldn't doubt some influence was there.
- IIAOPSW 2y agoThis was really nice. I'll just say, it starts out deconstructing the way "magic" in the modern world has given way to "engineering" and thus mythological things like 'deals with the devil' are no longer believed. But, in my view, a significant part of the appeal of the 'deal with the devil' is that it isn't mysterious. A Faustian bargain works according to exactly the letter of the deal, and the devil always keeps his end of it. Part of what makes it interesting, enticing even, is that it looks like there might be ways to outwit the devil. The devil then is a force of nature to be engineered just like any other branch of engineering in modern times, not an arbitrary fact of life beyond our comprehension.
- mrec 2y agoCoincidentally, I've just finished Thomas' Religion and the Decline of Magic. It's very long and massively overexampled, but still a good and eye-opening read. When it came out in 1971 it cost an extortionate £7; one national newspaper had an editorial saying people might be forced to pay for it in instalments.
- petschge 2y agoHow is that extortionate? Using the inflation calculator of the Bank of England that is 86 pounds now or $110. Admittedly that more expensive than the current price of $24 for the paper back, but at worst that seems to be twice as expensive as a common price for a 850 page book?
- throwanem 2y agoThis reads as if the author set out to make a point about modern traditionalism, got distracted with Renaissance literature halfway through, and then gave up on the piece with three or four paragraphs still to write. It's a shame. Something a little trenchant about the vacuity of "forward unto the past" would've made a better read than this.
- why_at 2y agoI agree it seems pretty unfocused. To be fair I read it quickly so I might be missing something, but I'm struggling to pull a thesis out of this piece. At the beginning it seems like it's trying to make a point about society becoming better after eliminating superstition, but then it mostly just goes through a history of Faustian bargains in literature before ending with one paragraph that implies that the modern equivalent is EULAs in software. EDIT: I just realized from the URL that this is supposed to be a book review? I probably didn't notice because the book isn't mentioned in the title or even in the article until four paragraphs in.
- throwanem 2y agoYeah, on reflection my initial reading was a little unfair. The focus makes sense given what it is, although it still feels odd to start out with what sounds like it wants to be a critique of a critique of materialism.
- turing_complete 2y agoEspecially funny since he calls Goethe's Faust incoherent.
- fnikacevic 2y agoI don't know if I'm missing something about the Newyorker but every article I've tried to read loses me in a similar chaos of literary references and excessive thesaurus usage. I can't tell if I'm illiterate or it's overhyped.
- beembeem 2y agoI'm glad I'm not the only one who found the title and content disconnected. Seems like the author got a chance to talk about their interest in literary history by adding a paragraph at the end and an enticing title.
- plg 2y agoIt drives me BONKERS that I can read the new yorker within the apple news app (because I pay money) but I cannot in any way through any means read the same words via a web browser to the actual new yorker site. I know, welcome to the new internet. Apple sells me discounted access via their app because in doing so Apple can monetize my eyeballs. I hate it.
- RandallBrown 2y agoCould this be the New Yorker's problem and not Apple's? I'm not super familiar with how Apple News subscriptions work, but there's probably a way they could let you log in to the New Yorker with your Apple ID or link the accounts somehow.
- crazygringo 2y agoOnly insofar as the New Yorker chose to be available on Apple News. If you subscribe to Apple News, you have to read this article in the Apple News app on your Mac, not in a browser. It does seem like there ought to be a way to take a web URL and tell Apple News, hey, I want to read this article in your app. I don't know if that's a thing, though. It certainly should be.
- riwsky 2y agoShare button does that, at least
- jajko 2y agoNot sure what problem you are facing, but I could read that article just fine, no subscription. Win 10, Firefox. For the rest there is always archive.is
- mceachen 2y agoGosh, one might even characterize this as a Faustian bargain with some sort of FANGed daemon.
- swagasaurus-rex 2y agoIsn't the faustian bargain a warning against taking money from unscrupulous lenders? The promise of riches, but in the process you lose your freedom (still true for business owners)
- kderbyma 2y agoit's selling your soul to the devil for something you desire
- crazygringo 2y agoNot historically -- not in Faust nor in the history of the concept [1]. You're certainly free to call borrowing money a "deal with the devil" or a "Faustian bargain", if it's something you can describe as metaphorically "selling your soul" -- e.g. losing control of your company or giving up your vision for it -- but the concept did not arise out of anything related to lenders. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deal_with_the_Devil https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Deal_with_the_Devil
- swayvil 2y ago"Engineering" reflects the popular way of thinking. So when magic is explained for the popular mind it looks like engineering.
- excalibur 2y ago> Jesus again rejects material gain, and finally banishes the tempter: Satan is not the real God, because there is only one God; the Devil doesn’t have the best tunes. Hard disagree. Though playing them on a golden fiddle certainly doesn't help.
- jimhefferon 2y agoOne thing I never understood about dealing with the Devil. When the Devil shows up, it changes the calculus. Now the person knows there is a heaven and hell, etc. What used to be a reasonable decision is now outrageously wrong.
- antonvs 2y agoYou're applying a modern sensibility. Originally, the skepticism you're alluding to didn't exist. The existence of a god and the various related phenomena was taken for granted. Given the knowledge of the time, how else could humans have come into existence? Widespread skepticism of those beliefs didn't start until the Englightment and the discovery of evolution.
- im3w1l 2y agoI wonder.. Back in polytheistic times did people really believe all those stories about their pantheon? It seems to me that the lines between true history, pious belief, and entertainment were all kinds of blurred. Maybe people simply didn't really care too much whether the stories were true or not?
- solresol 2y agoPretty much. The Greek pantheists weren't that different to Marvel or Star Wars fans. The point of the mythology was to have a common identity. If you asked the priest at the template of Demeter "Next spring, I'd like to go and meet Persephone on her journey to home to Demeter, which road does she normally take?" -- they would think you were some kind of fool getting reality and myth confused, while thinking up some mythology about your journey that would turn into a nice play next year. The modern-day equivalent would be meeting a travel agent at a DC Comics convention and asking them to book flights for you to Gotham City. The best-case outcome is that they write some fan-fiction about you. This was one of the reasons that Christianity was very disruptive, and exploded across the Graeco-Roman world over the following centuries. It provided a common identity with historical grounding -- if you wanted to go to the temple in Jerusalem where Jesus had kicked the merchants out, you could, and there was no ambiguity or vagueness about which one this happened in even after it was destroyed.
- motohagiography 2y agoweird story, I happen to have known the devil quite well. all the things they say about him are true, and that's the uncanny thing. you'd look at this man, slightly too large, objectively not attractive, impossibly clever and disarming, wealthy, seemingly impervious to any known law, known and welcomed everywhere, the exception to every rule and convention, accompanied everywhere by beautiful women, with literal horns on his head, and never once said a dishonest word even for the sake of politeness. Rationally, it was impossible that he could have been the devil, even if he specifically said it, broadcast it, and advertised it in every humanly possible way, the more he told you, the less you believed it, the more you felt like you were in on it. After all, he was harmless and fun, nobody around him ever did anything they didn't want to do. They always chose, they always consented with enthusiasm, and there are thousands of people who would rush to his defence and aid if anyone were to suggest he had ever done anything untoward. He is quite legitimately a great man in this world of men. Even when you knew, how much harm could be done in letting people who are already lost mislead themselves? We are not their keepers. They were having the time of their lives, but without him, their lives were less. He encouraged them up the hedonic treadmill to see how well they swam out of their depth. Decadent nights out became credit card bills, indulgences became needs, flings became transactions, familiarity contempt. They were all my choices as well, and I spent them unwisely, and at some truly astonishing personal cost, because we were spending what we wouldn't miss until it was gone. You couldn't know because you didn't know you were valuable. That was the impossible brilliance of it. I allowed myself to be seduced and misled because that was the whole ride. It's awesome. You can't judge the devil, it doesn't mean anything to him, but you can learn to appreciate and respect him for what he is, it's only a question of what you will pay for that education. I haven't seen him in many years and it's hard not to miss him, but with some distance and respect I'm good with that. If you don't believe me and maybe think I'm insane, it doesn't matter either. If you ever want to prove it to yourself and find him, all you need to do is want for the material things in this world a bit more than others for whatever reason, and I guarantee he will find you. Bye old friend, you're missed, and may we never meet again.
- nc0 2y agoAmen brother, hope everything is good for you now
- djaouen 2y ago[flagged]
- cratermoon 2y agoI disagree. "For most people, life was a business of terrifying external forces and arbitrary powers, both spiritual and legal." Substitute "economic" for "spiritual" and it describes the experiences of the majority in modern societies. To most, searching for a job involves appeasing various inscrutable forces, such as AI resume filtering, HR hoops, and interview questions that might as well be asking about how to cast spells. Employers are arbitrary and capricious entities of enormous power over individuals and with the ability to influence the world in ways the individual has no hope of matching. We don't call it magic, but there are other incantations for it. The adherents to the True Way of economics and law elevate themselves to positions of power and influence.
- wsc981 2y ago> In these two early stories lie most of the subsequent Faustian motifs: the temptations of knowledge and power; the bargaining away of more distant spiritual gains for nearer material ones; the almost symmetrical rivalry of good and evil forces; the taint of the commercial or contractual bond; the picaresque flights through time and space; even the odd obsession with exciting women called Helen. In apocryphal Bible texts, it's claimed corrupted angels called "The Watchers" gave humans various technologies, in exchange for their women. > In the Book of Enoch, the watchers are angels dispatched to Earth to watch over the humans. They soon begin to lust for human women and, at the prodding of their leader Samyaza, defect to illicitly instruct humanity and procreate among them, arriving on a mountain called Hermon. The offspring of these unions are the Nephilim, savage giants who pillage the earth and endanger humanity. > Samyaza and his associates further taught their human charges arts and technologies such as weaponry, cosmetics, mirrors, sorcery, and other techniques that would otherwise be discovered gradually over time by humans, not foisted upon them all at once. Eventually, God allows a Great Flood to rid the earth of the Nephilim, but first sends Uriel to warn Noah so as not to eradicate the human race. The watchers are bound "in the valleys of the Earth" until Judgment Day (Jude verse 6 says, "And the angels which kept not their first estate, but left their own habitation, he hath reserved in everlasting chains under darkness unto the judgment of the great day."). Source: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watcher_(angel)#Rogue_watchers_in_the_Book_of_Enoch https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watcher_(angel)#Rogue_watchers...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- Animats 2y agoI thought this was going to be about deals with VCs.
- askvictor 2y agoI thought it was going to be about the Disney+ shenanigans: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41242400 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41242400
- niemandhier 2y agoWe are witnessing the beginning of a significant shift in how we perceive the world—a "remagicalization" driven by technological advancements. Technology has progressed to a point where it often feels indistinguishable from magic to many. In the past, building a radio, the primary tool for real-time information, was within reach of anyone with basic components like wire, a speaker, a capacitor, and a coil. Today, however, technology has become so advanced that it is incomprehensible to most, controlled by experts who can seem like modern-day wizards. I fully agree with the conclusion of the article. * We’re all Faustians now. These days [...] we write our contracts not in blood but in silicon—both figuratively, insofar as we sign away our identities and privacies for all the short-term benefits of material ease, and literally, whenever we scroll rapidly through one of those unreadable online contracts, eager only to assent.*
- gbjw 2y agoGreat piece, though I do wish there was some more discussion about the Book of Job, in which God Himself makes a deal with the 'accuser' (Satan). The parallels with later 'deal with the devil' stories are numerous. I think it's particularly interesting to note that in Job, 'Satan' must still get permission from God to torment Job, and that, arguably, Job's final redemption rests on God coming down and speaking directly to him.
- ranprieur 2y agoDisenchantment was well underway in the 1600s, and arguably peaked in the 1700s, the Age of Reason, before it was partly undone by Romanticism. The disenchantment narrative goes back at least as far as Chaucer: https://aeon.co/essays/enlightenment-does-not-demand-disenchantment-with-the-world https://aeon.co/essays/enlightenment-does-not-demand-disench... If you want to go back the age of magic, try the 900s, or better yet, prehistory.
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoI would add that Christianity was all about "disenchanting" the world (and my interpretation of Die Nibelungen as taken to express this in literary form). The enchanted universe, a world of magic rather than wonder (some may confuse the two, but they are quite different), is rather characteristic of the pagan world and its superstitions and irrationalities, rather than the rational world of the Divine Logos. To disenchant is to "free from enchantment, deliver from the power of charms or spells" [0], that is, to free people from lies and deceit, the fake and unreal, sometimes tyrannical constructions. You find neopagans today who want to "reenchant the world". It is an expression of hopelessness running into the arms of a demon who promises them relief if only they believe his madness. What they don't understand is that it isn't their rationality that has produced their misery, but they're irrationality. [0] https://www.etymonline.com/word/disenchant#etymonline_v_11420 https://www.etymonline.com/word/disenchant#etymonline_v_1142...
- lo_zamoyski 2y agoI would also add that the article confuses Christianity with superstitious Christians. They still exist. But this is an aberration, and always was. Human beings are prone to the vice of superstition. Our age is no less superstitious, I would say. We've merely given our superstitions other labels, or they've taken other forms. And it was in Protestant societies that witch hunts really took place, which makes it all the more mystifying why the author would have expected Protestant England to deal with superstition better than the Church, who was not in the business of witch hunts and who condemned superstition as irrational, as rooted in a lust for power over and domination of others, and as an attempt to coerce God into doing one's will, defects of will and intellect that predispose a person to still further evils. (He does admit that Protestant theology actually predisposed people to more superstitious compulsions, but the fictitious examples suggest otherwise. I would also point to the Puritans as perfecting Protestant rebellion in the Salem witch trials.) Knowledge and power, in the abstract, are good as such, but like all appetites, they can get the better of us. Lust for knowledge, or curiosity as it was called, is self-destructive and irrational, as opposed to studiousness, the pursuit of knowledge according to right reason (our information glut today is rather shallow curiosity and desire to know what is none of our business to know; gossip). Lust for power is likewise, turning the desire to be and to do good into an irrational craving to dominate and exploit other people, even forgetting that one's very being is utterly dependent on the will of God sustaining you in existence at every moment; were it not for God willing you, you would not be. Also, the failure to distinguish between "religious" (a wishy-washy and nebulous term, if there ever was one) from "magic" is annoying. Magic is about power. True faith is but trust in what the human mind can only partially, but sufficiently grasp to warrant trust. There is no Manicheanism in Christianity, as evil is privation of the good, not an ontological equal of the good, and Jesus could very well have expelled the Devil. He was not in danger of succumbing, though his human side, as it were, was subjected to the temptation. I don't see how the author could claim otherwise. What I see is lazy prooftexting, not serious scholarship. The idea of "selling your soul" is figurative. One can live in accordance with the objective good, or violate it. One cannot sell a soul, and God is not in competition with created beings, but rather their fulfillment, as God is Being. The author's view suggests strongly a liberal view of freedom, not as the ability to be what you are by nature and to do what is good, but the ability to choose anything, even your own harm. But how is that freeing? It isn't. That's the fundamental mistake of philosophical liberalism. No one claims pleasure in this world brings pain in the next. The Church has never taught that pleasure as such is bad. It only taught that the pursuit of illicit pleasures is harmful. We get this, so why do we pretend otherwise? We know that eating tasty treats in excess jeopardizes the higher good of health. We know that pursuing depraved desires, like pedophilia, is evil and jeopardizes both the good of the pedophile and the children he intends to exploit and abuse. There are wicked pleasures, and there is a hierarchy of objective goods. Ultimately, the vice is pride, the refusal to submit to the truth, the refusal to live according to reality. As Satan, the poster child of pride, says in "Paradise Lost", "The mind is its own place, and in itself can make a heaven of hell, a hell of heaven." This is the essence of pride, to live in the "enchanted" fictions of one's mind rather than face reality as it is. So yeah, we're all Faustians because we're all sinners. We all whore ourselves, bit by bit, some more and some less, betray higher goods for the sparkle of a lower good. This lower good may be an illusion, or it may even be good as such, but it is the decision to violate a higher good for its sake that offends and corrupts.
- southernplaces7 2y agoThere's no way to see this and not include this neat little Twilight Zone episode. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29sd4IneEm4&pp=ygUZaSBvZiBuZXd0b24gdHdpbGlnaHQgem9uZQ%3D%3D https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=29sd4IneEm4&pp=ygUZaSBvZiBuZ...