4 ms·
Climate change deniers make up nearly a quarter of US Congress
- kkfx 2y agoWell, it's NORMAL to have deniers in general, because any change, especially if substantial and not pleasant got denied en mass in a general population. That's a classic psychological phenomenon. In this case it's more normal since most of those talking about climate change, those most listened by the people are objectively PRs who push and agenda using the climate as an excuse and the others talk about mean values changes people typically do not understand. The average Joe hearing about +1.5℃ imaging a daily maxima +1.5℃, that's is. So switching from 30℃ to 31.5℃ (88.7℉) it's unpleasant but not that dramatic. The average Joe can't think about ANNUAL mean values vs extreme values during the years, for instance. Anyway: IF we want to share the relevance of climate change it's about time to talk about food crisis and how hard is sourcing food around the world. We should show, locally, area per area, the amplitude and effects of extreme weather events. We should state clearly WE CAN'T AVOID THE CHANGE just reducing the animal flatulence etc, we MUST adapt. Then we mast be realistic stating clear that many currently densely inhabited places have no future fully knowing the real estate storm that will follow, and observing where we can instead go and how, or cease the rhetoric about smart cities, novel Fordlandia equally distopic with equal (no) future and admit we can only implement the New Deal at PERSONAL/FAMILIAR/SME level creating small buildings not wasting gazillion of resources in un-evolvable hyper fragile modern dense cities. While most people do fear any change, to reject any change, to not understand any change a thing like the 2030 Agenda it's understood enough, the current impoverishment of all, especially of the middle class is very understood. The rest it's not since like every years we witness people die from heat not only working because they need to but also at the beach because "they do not have consider much their body tolerance to heat". I know it's unpopular among current US Liberals dreaming the friendly, social, connected nice and dice clean, silent and green city, but sorry, I'm between those who have studied and implemented the Green New Deal building a new home, all electric car included with p.v. etc, I know enough to understand what could be done and what not. If you the reader are one of them try to draw yourself a possible or impossible scenario and share your conclusion and process.
- soco 2y agoAnd then you have voters which think doing agriculture is pointless because yall could shop for vegetables at Target.
- defrost 2y ago> and the others talk about mean values changes people typically do not understand. Perhaps it's because I grew up near the coast and read tides charts to go fishing but I, and all the average Joes I know with a similar background, understand MSL (Mean Sea Level) how a small rise there is unusual and distinct from the moon related King Lows, and King Highs that flux by tens of metres.
- kuschkufan 2y agoI feel like the number here on HN is higher.
- Kelteseth 2y agoAnd now about 90% of X. At least most of them are bots...
- _xnmw 2y ago[flagged]
- OccamsMirror 2y agoWhat the hell are you talking about?
- defrost 2y agoI've not heard of a single person who denies the existence of reproductive male humans and|or reproductive female humans .. can you name any that do in the US Congress?
- TibbityFlanders 2y ago[dead]
- robxorb 2y agoWell I'll be proudly labelled a "_____ denier" denier. This pejorative term does nothing for anyone making any argument. It weakens your position because you're attempting to rely on emotions and psychology to make your case instead of... well, making your case! It predictably has the reverse effect of your intention. Those who disbelieve you strengthen in their resolve because now not only do they disagree with you on a factual basis, but they also believe themselves to have been unfairly characterised in a pejorative way for their position. Dumb move, you had one obstacle, now you're made yourself have two. If Christians went around calling Muslim's "Christ-deniers" instead of Muslims, how well do you think that would help tensions and resolution? To me it's primitive and ineffective behaviour, and I lose respect for those who resort to it.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> If Christians went around calling Muslim's "Christ-deniers" instead of Muslims, how well do you think that would help tensions and resolution? They'd probably laugh a bit; Muslims consider Jesus to be a legitimate prophet, just not the last. That aside, religious stuff like "was Jesus the Messiah?" isn't quite the same as "is climate change happening". Some of the fervor around it may be religious-like, but the core facts are... facts.
- spwa4 2y ago[flagged]
- tapoxi 2y agoReligions are a matter of faith, climate change has overwhelming scientific evidence. If you don't call those people deniers, then you're signaling to third parties it's some sort of unanswered question.
- mysterydip 2y agoThe unanswered question in some peoples' minds is the cause, not the effect. Like if you called people "forest fire deniers" for questioning whether it was arson or not.
- hilbert42 2y agoAs a native English speaker who doesn't live in the US but who has been there many times and even has relatives who live there—some of whom were born there—I no longer feel I even know the country anymore. US politics and US attitudes towards the rest of the world have changed so much in recent decades the country now seems a strange place to me.
- wakawaka28 2y agoIndeed, many so-called Americans don't even believe in the first and second amendments anymore...
- criddell 2y agoI would wager that more than a few are climate deniers only because it's politically expedient. The Trump era of US politics has revealed how quickly many politicians will fall in line when necessary to retain their political power. I'm sure it's always been this way, but it's been painfully obvious the past few years with Lindsey Graham, Mitch McConnell, etc... reversing course when it's clear not doing so will cost them their power. Vonnegut's novel "Mother Night" (one of my favorites) warns: > "We are what we pretend to be, so we must be careful about what we pretend to be".
- lumb63 2y agoThe definition they use is so incredibly broad as to mean anything. If you think man-made climate change is real but doesn’t take a higher priority than the activities causing climate change, you’re a climate denier. If you think man-made climate change is real but aren’t sure that natural disasters are increasing in frequency or severity because of that, you’re a climate denier. Both of these types of people believe in man-made climate change yet are said to deny it. Does that even make sense? This article is trying to drive a wedge between people and foment hate, as is anyone using the term “climate denier”, whether they know it or not. It’s not productive. The readers of this article could be talking to people, learning their nuanced views, exchanging ideas, and finding common ground with the so-called “climate deniers”, but instead they’re reading a hit piece that makes them think Republicans are going to cause the literal end of the world.
- mcphage 2y ago> If you think man-made climate change is real but doesn’t take a higher priority than the activities causing climate change, you’re a climate denier. If you think climate change is real, but don’t care, because of the economy—then yes, you’re a climate change denier. > If you think man-made climate change is real but aren’t sure that natural disasters are increasing in frequency or severity because of that, you’re a climate denier. If you think climate change is real, but isn’t having deeply unpleasant effects—then yeah, you’re a climate change denier. There’s plenty of room for nuance and distinctions within climate change beliefs, but these positions ain’t it, chief.
- shrimp_emoji 2y agoThe "ain't it, chief" sealed the deal.
- mcphage 2y agogives you the double fingerguns clicks my tongue
- wakawaka28 2y ago
- BLKNSLVR 2y agoThis doesn't surprise me based on my knowledge (or lack thereof) of the demographics of US Congress. Exemplified by Trump: 78, Biden: 81. Most older folks I have conversational relationships with are deniers of literally anything that may negatively affect the lifestyle to which they've become accustomed. Even to the point that they think such changes are actually going to be worse for their grandchildren. As per the old adage: science advances one funeral at a time.
- spacebanana7 2y ago> The report defined climate deniers as those who say that the climate crisis is not real or not primarily caused by humans, or claim that climate science is not settled, that extreme weather is not caused by global warming or that planet-warming pollution is beneficial. A narrower definition may be more productive.
- ceejayoz 2y agoThe narrow definitions lead to the tentacles like “CO2 is good, actually!” as deniers find things becoming untenably silly to espouse.
- spacebanana7 2y agoNarrower definitions help target the debate. Debating climate change proponents or fatalists about the existence of climate change is a waste of everybody's time, since it's something they already agree with.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Narrower definitions help target the debate. They also make it like trying to squeeze clay in your fist. Little bits squirt out everywhere and make a mess. > Debating climate change proponents or fatalists about the existence of climate change is a waste of everybody's time, since it's something they already agree with. Only very recently, and immediately moved on to the next incremental level of unscientific bullshit objections they'll espouse for another decade.
- polski-g 2y agoThe IPCC report itself says they extreme weather is not caused by climate change, and that the warming of the planet can be useful.
- tpush 2y agoSource, please.
- Am4TIfIsER0ppos 2y agoWhat fraction of the US population would be classified as climate change deniers alongside them? If it is 25% then the congress is perfectly representative and should be applauded. [EDIT] > polls show the proportion of Americans who share this view is significantly smaller, by as much as half So it is supposed to be over-represented but did the congress critters answer the same question? The linked poll of the public says another 11% were "doubtful" which is enough to get you labelled by the eco-commies.
- ceejayoz 2y agoDoes this hold for racism, criminality, and intelligence? Should a certain percent of Congress be intellectually disabled?
- defrost 2y agoIt's a gerontocracy and both gerontology and simple observation tell us that a number have significantly declined in intellectual capacity since their first entry into politics.
- acdha 2y agoDon’t forget, none of this is happening in a vacuum. The fossil fuel industry has spent billions of dollars trying to delay accountability and that has had a huge impact on the makeup of the Congress. The Republican Party didn’t used to be the anti-science party – that took decades of ideological filtering, setting up an alternative media environment and quasi-intellectual think tank career path, etc. to ensure that the people who get elected are the ones who represent the interests of certain businesses and training voters that the true unforgivable offense was bipartisan compromise on any issue. That wasn’t just fossil fuels - tobacco paid for a lot of it, including many of the same erstwhile “science experts” – and other factors played in (Obama’s election really stepped up the pressure not to be bipartisan even on previously innocuous things) but the important thing to remember is that it’s no more natural than a rose garden and requires constant maintenance.
- jmclnx 2y agoAre they really deniers or are they people who kisses Trump's Ring and/or pander the Oil Industry. I was against term limits, but since around the year 2000, I have turned around. Personally I would now like to see Term Limits plus once you leave Congress you are forbidden to be a lobbyist for 10 years. Most congress people are now there for the bribes (contributions) and favors along with a cushy job once they leave. Most do not care 1 bit for the people the represent.
- wakawaka28 2y agoThe oil industry makes money but it also facilitates life as we know it. Shutting it down would raise prices of everything 10x at minimum and maybe force us all to be subsistence farmers. Those of us who survive the initial die off, that is...
- sebow 2y ago"Climate change deniers" Like holocaust deniers, like nazis, etc.? More and more buzz-words and labels broadly and freely used in order to dilute their respective meanings. Our parents, grand-parents, etc. did not teach us good virtues "by shaming" (i.e by telling us we're X/Y/Z buzzwords), but either through example(of what not to do) or through rationality (explanations until comprehension). It's no wonder we have rising "X/Y/Z" sentiments when, ironically, the people who seemingly advocate against "these bad boys" resume to just label and categorize individuals instead putting the effort to either educate, explain, reference. Low-effort means low results, and virtuous traits are definitely not gained through complacency. You solve things with dialogue (not monologue*). And if those people who use these buzzwords don't like dialogue "because some guy proved it" [it's actually irrelevant if the referenced fact is true or not] and dismiss discourse shamelessly, then they're doing more damage to their own narrative. Nobody likes being told what to do(this includes knowing/believing/etc.), and facts matter as much as they're being understood.
- ceejayoz 2y ago> Our parents, grand-parents, etc. did not teach us good virtues "by shaming"... Oh, they absolutely did. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scarlet_Letter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Scarlet_Letter was written in 1850.
- O1111OOO 2y agoThe article did not include a list of companies and individuals who benefit financially (and otherwise) from denying climate change. And then... cross-referencing that list with members of the US Congress. Too many of our representatives have long ago sold themselves (and this country) to outside money and influence. At this point, this is common knowledge.