8 ms·
Can a person be identified by just the way they type?
- 1123581321 14y agoI'd love to see this analysis broken down by qwerty, Dvorak and Colemak.
- melvinmt 14y ago> To view this content, please install Wolfram CDF Player. This will take 538.4 MB of space on your computer. Erh.. no thank you.
- lucian1900 14y ago231MB for the linux version, but it's 32bit only. Yeah, no thanks.
- vnorby 14y agoIt seems like this could be built in Javascript. Might not be as precise but at least it would be demoable.
- qq66 14y agoThe major purpose of this post is to get you to install the plugin, so I doubt that would achieve what they want it to.
- pavel_lishin 14y agoMy first thought is that this can trivially be spoofed by installing a keylogger with playback functionality, but at that point a password wouldn't save you, either.
- JoeAltmaier 14y agoCould you keylog/model a user when using another machine i.e. a public library computer, then use that model to simulate the user (playback) elsewhere? Do you have to capture them typing the 'passphrase'?
- cristianocd 14y agoNo only a keylogger, but a "soundlogger" would also work. Checking long posts on news sites or blogs just to make sure it is the writer would be interesting, but boring and not worth it.
- shabble 14y agoFor interesting research here, see: Keyboard Acoustic Emanations Revisited, Li Zhuang, Feng Zhou, J. D. Tygar http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~tygar/keyboard.htm http://www.cs.berkeley.edu/~tygar/keyboard.htm "We examine the problem of keyboard acoustic emanations. We present a novel attack taking as input a 10-minute sound recording of a user typing English text using a keyboard, and then recover- ing up to 96% of typed characters. There is no need for a labeled training recording. Moreover the recognizer bootstrapped this way can even recognize random text such as passwords: In our experi- ments, 90% of 5-character random passwords using only letters can be generated in fewer than 20 attempts by an adversary; 80% of 10- character passwords can be generated in fewer than 75 attempts.
- Splines 14y agoNow that would be magical - visit a website and start making comments, after a period of time it'd create an account for you with no input at all. Now, visit it from a different browser or computer and make another comment - it would log you in as you again, somehow. Errors would likely make it unpractical, but it'd be an amusing demo for the unaware.
- joe_the_user 14y agoYour first thought is correct. This fails. Trivially. If you got through the problem of people's keystroke speed varying with local factors, you'd wind-up with a situation where not only is your "password" the same on every site, even sites you visited without logging into could "sniff" your "password". 0-factor "identification"!
- horsehead 14y agoCouldn't it also be beaten by, say, a professional drummer who cadences each keystroke perfectly?
- ctdonath 14y agoAccording to a recent meme going around, the answer is "no" because the question is a headline.
- aiscott 14y agoThe meme should specify the headline is a statement with a question mark, rather than a proper question. I.e. THIS POST TO BE DOWNVOTED? Vs SHOULD THIS POST BE DOWNVOTED?
- sirclueless 14y agoSo the ability of this method to identify you based on your typing style would require a certain amount of consistency in the way you type. Well done, you found the answer. A lot of people can't be positively identified, and the whole thing is error prone.
- sbornia 14y agoI'm sure the way I type is quite different when I type on another computer's keyboard... I don't see the point of this...
- mdaniel 14y agoAnd it differs quite a bit based on _what_ I am typing, too. Plus the tactivity(?) of the keyboard factors in, because as soon as I have feedback that the key was registered, I am on to the next one.
- ColinWright 14y agoIt's sometimes said that if you aren't embarrassed by your product at launch then you've waited too long. It's important to get early feedback, and build on early reactions and responses. Likewise, by making ideas like this, along with an early investigation, perhaps someone can build on it, or throw out another idea, and perhaps people can work together to find a good solution to the mess that is current user identification. Or would you rather people beavered away in secret, never sharing ideas, never sharing their results, and never working together?
- alaithea 14y agoEspecially if a Dvorak user is forced to use Qwerty on another person's computer. At that point, they become completely unable to log in via this method.
- colanderman 14y agoThe major problem with this scheme is that if I type it "wrong", I have no conscious way of recalling how to type it correctly. In fact, my natural cadence will likely be thrown off even more by the stress of not being able to log in. I would quite literally have to walk away from the computer, do something relaxing for a few hours, and then walk back hoping that I type naturally again.
- mertd 14y agoI think gatekeeping example serves just as a proof of concept. It could be more useful for continuous monitoring. For example to tell you that somebody else may be using the computer that you are still logged in to.
- Trufa 14y agoIndeed, I'm pretty sure a lot of people are missing the point by commenting that this isn't a successful replacement of the password login mechanism.
- ChuckMcM 14y agoThis is the more compelling case for me. Train it across an organization and then you can monitor who typed what. In operations, this is my killer use case. The problem is that we have 'server' machines and a system which requires 'root' access to do certain things. We'd love to know who on the operations staff did something on the server (a workaround is to set an environment variable but which works in the 'normal' case but fails if someone is being a bad actor). So you train it up across the org, and then when ever you have a session where the signal from the type sig doesn't match the logged in UID, you alert it (or log it). SO instead of 'root just changed the date to last year' you get 'Chuck just changed the date to last year'. That would be a very very very useful tool to have in one's toolbox.
- cavilling_elite 14y agowhy wouldn't you disable root login and only use sudo with command logging enabled. http://aplawrence.com/Basics/sudo.html http://aplawrence.com/Basics/sudo.html EDIT: noticed the 'root', making a new assumption this is a windows server box.
- Terretta 14y agoThe late Michael Crichton wrote an Apple II program in the mid 80's using intra-letter timings to check if the person typing a password in was the person who set it. Worked pretty well; better if improved to sample multiple times, use long phrases, and adjust tolerance.
- marquis 14y agoThat's an interesting idea for 2-factor auth. I know how to enter my computer password blindingly fast, it's pure physical memory.
- ceejayoz 14y agoWouldn't be much fun when you change it, though.
- batista 14y agoWhy? The algorithm could acknowledge and adapt to a changed password, and try to learn the timings anew, instead of expecting the same speed as with the older one.
- StavrosK 14y agoYou'd probably type your name or email. I know I've got more training on that than anyone else I know...
- jdrake3 14y agoI'm just sick of wolfram. <--- Period.
- inportb 14y agohttp://hackaday.com/2009/10/09/safelock-biometric-typing-security/ http://hackaday.com/2009/10/09/safelock-biometric-typing-sec... I experimented with this a couple of years ago when I saw that video, by implementing an ajaxy authentication system that timed keystrokes. Ignoring the fact that you could probably keylog the heck out of it, I found that a single user's typing patterns varied substantially, depending on typing skill, input device, and so on. Oh, well.
- jeremyarussell 14y agoSo for authentication this doesn't seem like it could completely replace the password. That said wouldn't it be interesting as a way to tell when someone is stressed out or tired. For instance I know when I'm super mad my spelling goes down the pot.
- eliasmacpherson 14y agoRemember gmail's arithmetic questions after watershed to prevent drunken users writing 'regrettable' emails? This could be another angle to provide the same functionality.
- mistercow 14y agoThe biggest problem with this is that it requires uniqueness to be traded for error tolerance. People are going to have different typing styles depending on their mental and physical state, and their typing styles will change over time. In addition, while the space of possible typing signatures is very large, the space of actual typing signatures is much smaller. So we simultaneously have to assign each person a blob of signature space which is big enough that it can positively identify them regardless of whether they've had their morning coffee (or, god help them, they cut their finger or break their arm), and small enough that we don't have so much signature overlap as to make the system useless. In either case everybody will have to have a fallback password in case their stride is off one day. If the system works well, then that password will be rarely used. A rarely used password is harder to remember than a regularly used one, so people will choose weak passwords for the fallback. So the only way that this system has any chance of working without grossly compromising everyone's security, is if it barely ever positively identifies anyone. Of course, even if it did work perfectly, it would be the equivalent of having the same password everywhere. In that case, why not just memorize one strong password?
- brey 14y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridges_Law_of_Headlines http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Betteridges_Law_of_Headlines I'm going with "no" ;-)
- paulhodge 14y agoThis idea has some history to it, I remember reading that they tried to use this same analysis in the trials against Kevin Mitnick. Some clever sysadmin had recorded Mitnick's telnet activity (as it went across some crappy modem) and claimed to be able to identify him based on the timing of different keys. The judge threw it out as not being reliable evidence. Wish I could remember where I read that; it was some book about hackers in general.
- Zimahl 14y agoI built some network security software in the early part of the 2000s. Around 2005, a local guy built a keystroke pattern recognizer utilizing neural networks to learn your keystrokes and was able to correctly identify who you were after a minimal amount of learning (typing). He brought it buy to see if we were interested in licensing it and using it in our product. While somewhat of a black box demo, we were able to play with the technology. We tried a ton of stuff to fool the system (physical only, we didn't use keystroke macros or anything like that) and it would correctly identify us every time. It was showing us the probabilities as they'd change and it was uncanny how it would immediately know that I started typing instead of a coworker. So, it's not only probable/possible/exists, it's only drawback is the lack of necessity. Outside of the the highly paranoid using it to prevent outside intrusions (government mostly), not many systems need it due to lower-end attacks that are much easier to do and typically successful enough.
- mistercow 14y agoHow many people were there? Did he have any way of estimating the entropy of the signatures? Did you try the demo over multiple days, and at different times of day, to see if it continued to identify you correctly? >it's only drawback is the lack of necessity No, that's not the only drawback. Be very careful when talking about cryptography and security never to assume that you are aware of all of the weaknesses unless you've got a formal proof. One very big drawback I can think of off the top of my head is that it would essentially be like having the same password everywhere, and being completely unable to change that password. If someone records your typing style once, they will be able to get to absolutely everything that identifies you based on typing style. At least with retina scans and fingerprints, there are mechanical obstacles to producing a facsimile.
- paulsutter 14y agoYes. A friend of mine has a patent on a gun that fires only for one person. The gun has been extensively tested and works great. The fire/no-fire decision is based on the way the trigger is pulled. Gun manufacturers hate it because it has scary gun control implications. But if/when it does become available New Jersey police will all use it. Keystrokes should be way more distinctive than a trigger pull. EDIT: Michael Recce is his name, http://www.njit.edu/news/2003/2003-125.php http://www.njit.edu/news/2003/2003-125.php
- defen 14y agoThat's fascinating. Can you share more detail? How do they key it to the individual? Do people really not pull the trigger differently in high-stress situations vs at the firing range?
- 3pt14159 14y agoI bet it works on a combination of force, centroid of pressure, time, and shake.
- simcop2387 14y agoCould also be measuring the galvanic skin response and the like to try to further narrow it down. But I don't know how well that works for reliability since stress can change it i think.
- icegreentea 14y agoAnd gloves. It seems likely that gloves may be involved with guns. Best not to rely on it.
- gaius 14y agoIf it's patented, you can just read the patent.
- Cushman 14y agoIt does seem like even a very consistent shooter would be too different between slow, aimed shots and rapid firing. Perhaps one would be able to record a great number of pulling patterns in different stress levels, and still have the lockout be effective? I would also be fascinated to learn more.
- derrida 14y agoYour writing style can identify you. 'Jstylo' is a tool that detects authorship. 'Anonymouth' is a tool that spoofs authorship (ever wanted to write HN replies as if you were JK Rowling? You can do it.)
- hippich 14y agoyes. i did it back in 6th grade (i.e. somewhere in 1997 probably) using Turbo Pascal without all this fancy/shmancy neural stuff. just 3 dimensional array, one plane for each user and get average time between key strokes. It was good enough to detect me, my mom, father and my friend. It also have downside - your patter will change overtime and if this is sole authentication measure - it will fail eventually. I would use it as fuzzy monitoring to detect stolen credentials instead.
- golovast 14y agoI've once evaluated a product like this pretty extensively. This was about 5 years back and I think the company is now called Admit One Security. Surprisingly enough, that company's userbase absolutely hated carrying tokens and they wanted to bend over backwards to accommodate them. The entire point was to provide an alternative way of doing 2-factor authentication. The bottom line is that it mostly did work as advertised. The place where it struggled were poor typers of the hunt and peck variety. They just didn't have a good enough pattern and the failure rate was fairly high. Another weak point would be any type of hand injury or even being under the influence would throw it off completely. I liked the approach a lot, but ultimately, when it does fail, its extremely frustrating to the end user, since they don't really understand what they did wrong.
- zafriedman 14y agoCounter question. Can a person be identified by just what it takes to get them to download the Wolfram CDF player?
- devs1010 14y agoI worked for a company that makes test taking / proctoring software that attempts to do this, I didn't work on the product myself but it seemed a bit of a trainwreck as they would always be having to do overrides for people who couldn't make it past the typing authentication (which was based on a previous sample of their typing), it measured pace, speed, etc.. the company itself wasn't that great so not surprising their implementation of this wasn't optimal, however its an interesting concept.
- xtractinator 14y agoThe way I type changes dramatically from day to day, depending on my emotion. Sometimes I top very choppily at 35wpm, and sometimes I type like a waterfall flowing over rocks in waves at 120wpm. There's no way that this method would work reliably for me.
- davidwparker 14y agoInteresting... until I have an injury or someone with disabilities has to use it and are not consistent typists anymore.
- ThomPete 14y agoSo basically you could create a service where: 1. You ask a user to type in a couple of words. 2. Create a profile for them. so that when you sign up for something you: 3. verify they are who they say they are as they fill out the form. 4. can skip captcha? (i.e. the form filling is the captcha) ?
- zserge 14y agoOK, that may work with a hardware keyboard, but what about a manner of typing on on-screen keyboards? Will I be able to log in from the tablet or phone?
- zserge 14y agoOK, that may work with a hardware keyboard, but what about a manner of typing on on-screen keyboards? Will I be able to log in from the tablet or phone?
- holri 14y agoI once wrote a simple keystroke analyzer for a login page. It was based just on the duration and pauses of your keystrokes. Worked great but had little practical usefulness. The advantage and disadvantage is you cannot simply write down the password.
- jacobr 14y agoCould this be used to combat some types of spam? There are of course legitimate uses of copy/paste, but you could for instance get a captcha if your typing patterns do not match a human's when writing a blog post.
- mdanger 14y agoWasn't this true back in the telegraph days? I seem to recall reading that operators could identify each other just listening to transmissions.