9 ms·
MeTube: Self-hosted YouTube downloader
- dreadlordbone 2y ago[flagged]
- pdntspa 2y ago"Self-hosted" ... on something that very much used to be a fairly simple desktop app... JDownloader anyone? Or yt-dlp ????
- EasyMark 2y agoor just use freetube?
- ryandrake 2y agoI totally agree. The idea of running a server application in Docker and then firing up a browser for something like this just seems so... round-about and alien to me! Is this the direction software development is really going?
- happyopossum 2y agoFor a large group of people, the vast majority of their computing and consumption is done apart from a desktop or laptop. Something like this makes perfect sense in a mobile-first world.
- pdntspa 2y agoMy generation dropped the ball on teaching computer literacy
- meroes 2y agoCurious if this is at millennials for not teaching the next generation(s) or at genz/alpha for not teaching themselves.
- TechDebtDevin 2y agoIve encountered a shocking amount of 30yr olds that don't own a computer or know how to properly type. I'd say GenZ and Alpha have plenty of computer literacy as laptops were better integrated into education by time they got or will get to high school. Outside of some AP classes that had their own computer labs most kids in my age group (early 30s) took one computer class in their entire secondary education. I knew one other person in my entire high school that coded. Hell you can code Python on ti-84s now.
- redwall_hp 2y agoThey're all issued Chromebooks and live in a glorified browser and GSuite. There's something of an epidemic of students landing in college CS programs and not knowing how to manage files outside of Google Drive. Millennials got to use real computers growing up. Gens Z and Alpha got locked down Google appliances tightly monitored by schools.
- ryandrake 2y agoMy kid still cannot really grasp the concept of "things being stored locally on the computer or on the phone vs. things being on the Internet". She doesn't understand why some apps require Internet and others don't. No concept of the boundary between local and network. "What do you mean 'it's stored on the phone'? YouTube is stored on the phone, right?" I think a lot of this is developers intentionally blurring the line between local and cloud storage. If you were a layman iPhone user, would you be able to confidently tell me which of your photos are stored in iCloud and which are stored on your device? Apple is deliberately obfuscating it.
- pdntspa 2y ago> I think a lot of this is developers intentionally blurring the line between local and cloud storage. If you were a layman iPhone user, would you be able to confidently tell me which of your photos are stored in iCloud and which are stored on your device? Apple is deliberately obfuscating it. It is exactly this. I'd like to think it is less developers and more marketing/product manager/bizdev types trying to keep their customers ignorant as a form of lock-in.
- rqtwteye 2y agoComputers have become generally good enough to be used without much knowledge. Same happened with cars. 30 years ago it was very beneficial to know how your car works. These days you can own and a car without knowing much about it and you will most likely be ok.
- ryandrake 2y ago> These days you can own and a car without knowing much about it and you will most likely be ok. It's a pretty expensive way to own a car, though: having to take it to a mechanic in order to maintain or fix things. But you're absolutely right that it's an option today that wasn't really an option 30+ years ago.
- joseda-hg 2y agoOr have a family member (Or trusted person) with enough knowledge to keep you trucking on when things go south, seems to work with both cars and tech
- saidwhatisaid 2y agoExcept this breeds a learned helplessness, and makes every layman beholden to some wizard who knows the Old Wisdom, the right incantations to make the devices we rely on every day even function. It must feel awful to have to go through life at the mercy of tech crap that just doesn't work half the time, and little to no ability to reasonably deal with it. Besides, so many problems now aren't even fixable by end users. Why? Because all of our computation happens somewhere in the bowels of us-east-1. If your budgeting program breaks on your computer, you might be able to fix it, especially if you have the source. But GET /budgets/123 returning a 500 is the equivalent of saying "pound sand", and you have zero hope of actually fixing the issue. You're at the mercy of some faceless on-call person halfway across the globe, and they're overworked and on their third bourbon of the evening.
- toofy 2y ago> …this breeds a learned helplessness… while i agree that we might be moving too fast with our “progress” regarding tech, my guess is we’ll get it smoother before we fully move on. however, don’t confuse helplessness with having better things to do with your time. for example, we’re not helpless when we turn on a faucet to get water. we’re totally capable of hauling heavy buckets down the hill to the river and hauling heavy pales of water back home, then boiling the water to cook with and then again to take a bath. we just decided it’s a waste of time for every single person to do that for hours every single day. now we just turn a faucet and boom, that’s it. that’s not helpless. we’re not incapable of hunting and gathering for hours every single day either. we just found a better way. now i can just go to the store grab a bag of chips without needing to grow potatoes for months first. we’re not helpless, we just decided to be more efficient. good news is, those who like growing a potato to make their own chips can still absolutely do it. if you’re someone who likes hauling 50 gallons of water by foot everyday from the local river, set up that fire and boil that water to your hearts content. you may not have been implying it, but a lot of people lately seem to often confuse having different priorities with “helplessness.”
- thaumasiotes 2y agoThere's already a mobile application for downloading from YouTube, NewPipe. It's a simple desktop app, except that your desktop is a phone. Nobody hosts anything.
- AyyEye 2y agoThose people don't have servers, docker, and hosting. Besides that, Invidious has a download button for audio and video. As far as apps there's very simple mobile apps: Tubular and newpipe both support downloading, and ytdlnis and seal are explicitly for downloading. I'm sure there's a dozen more in F-Droid.
- happyopossum 2y ago> Those people don't have servers, docker, and hosting. In my experience they do. Do you never use a mobile for browsing/videos/etc?
- AyyEye 2y agoNobody that is managing servers, self-hosted services, etc is doing it primarily from mobile.
- A4ET8a8uTh0 2y agoI normally would agree, but there are some use cases I was not aware of until more recently. Unraid server may be a good example here. In that case, docker for a self-hosted instance works well for most purposes AND can be accessed by less technically minded family members depending on what you actually use. FWIW, I agree with you that it probably should not be the default.
- mixmastamyk 2y agoKinda sucks but freetube doesn’t work well with wayland or touchscreen, so I may give this a go in desperation.
- rqtwteye 2y agoI see that a lot in the stuff our interns produce. Instead of a simple command line too they often create a node server you need to post your requests to. This may somehow have some advantages but it makes building scripts or pipelines much harder than it should be.
- hashslingingsha 2y ago[flagged]
- turtlebits 2y agoIt's not the most elegant, but for cross platform, a web app and container are the easiest UI and deployment methods.
- tveyben 2y agoSo what’s the actual goal? - easy to deploy (developers problem) - easy to use (everybody else’s problem) There’s like ~1 dev and >x.000’s of users, so…
- SparkyMcUnicorn 2y agoIt is yt-dlp under the hood. > Web GUI for youtube-dl (using the yt-dlp fork)
- jactoryfoe 2y ago[dead]
- theadultnerd 2y agoI'd be excited to have this on a NAS. Something in a container makes it easy and I can direct it to save in a directory that has Plex or something like that.
- adra 2y ago+1 for me. As a yt premium sub, I still think it'd be great if I could just pick a channel and have a recurring check to see if new content is up and to just dump them into a folder which my video player can show to avoid needing to open the app all the time. It'd work for my consumption uses better than relying on the sometimes great, sometimes terrible algorithm to surface the content I want to watch.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- IncreasePosts 2y agoCould I use this hypothetical desktop app from my desktop, my other desktop, my mobile phone, my wife's mobile phone, and the Chromecast on my media center?
- pdntspa 2y agoDepends, do you know how to use Remote Desktop? There are RDP or VNC clients for all of the above.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoSure. But I think using a web page is a much nicer solution than getting a remote desktop stuffed onto my phone screen and trying to use a desktop-native app that way.
- hashslingingsha 2y agoDesktop applications never worked on phones, mostly because Google and Apple want you using their own version of what used to be called "programs". Of course, if you need to download YouTube videos on every device you own and the toaster, then sure, maybe don't use yt-dlp. But, ya know, I'd wager that most people don't need to do that.
- fragmede 2y agoand then your laptop gets stolen/lost and the video is deleted from YouTube. maybe some people want an archive that's theirs that won't be deleted it edited?
- pdntspa 2y agoNot sure what this has to do with anything, external and backup drives are cheap and cloud storage is even more cheap.
- shiroiushi 2y agoEven more cheap? I have to disagree: every time I've looked, purchasing your own backup drives outright always appears to be much cheaper than subscribing to cloud storage. Cloud storage has its advantages of course, but sheer cost savings per TB I don't think is one of them.
- hashslingingsha 2y agoTimes my laptop has been stolen: 0. Times a video I like has disappeared from YouTube: 10,000-ish. Offsite backups: priceless.
- ChrisArchitect 2y agoRelated: Yark: YouTube Archiver with Offline UI https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41100820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41100820
- lookup 2y agoWould be nice if there was an interface into Jellyfin so that you could search Youtube, have yt-dlp download, and then stream through Jellyfin without ads.
- Yodel0914 2y agoThat's pretty much what I do, except the yt-dlp step is manual. A Jellyfin plugin would be great.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- candiddevmike 2y agoSee also yt-dlp-web-ui: https://github.com/marcopeocchi/yt-dlp-web-ui https://github.com/marcopeocchi/yt-dlp-web-ui Not AGPL, support for custom profiles, better UX (IMO)
- progman32 2y agoConsider also Tube Archivist. If you just want to download a few videos it's overkill, but I use it to archive and index technical channels I like. It can do advanced full text and metadata searches on the transcription/subtitles as well as comments (and title and description). Much better than what alphabet provides, annoyingly. https://www.tubearchivist.com/ https://www.tubearchivist.com/
- stndef 2y agoI second this. It's great!
- toomuchtodo 2y agoHow does it compare to PeerTube? Would be cool if these instances could be federated, ActivityPub or something similar.
- grep_name 2y agoI've been meaning to migrate to tube archivist forever, but I have several TB of youtube videos I don't want to re-download which I gathered using tubesync. Luckily I have the format string used to save the files by name and since tubesync uses django and a postgres backend I might be able to tie them to the youtube ID. But migration still seems like it might be a bit of a nightmare
- password4321 2y agoAnother option on the home page earlier today: Yark: YouTube Archiver with Offline UI https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41100820 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=41100820
- nirav72 2y agoI was looking at TubeArchivist. But didn’t like that it required 3 separate containers. Then I found Pinchflat on the selfhosted sub. It works as a single container and was easy deployment. Has been working well. https://github.com/kieraneglin/pinchflat https://github.com/kieraneglin/pinchflat
- 2y ago
- Andrews54757 2y agoIt was pretty straightforward for me to install and use yt-dlp. On a Mac with Homebrew you can do `brew install yt-dlp` to install it in one command. IIRC yt-dlp also provides binaries you can install directly. I'm not sure if installing docker and running a web server is any way easier than that. However, there are ways to download Youtube videos without installing a native app. For example, it is possible to use a library like Youtube.js [0] to make a browser extension that downloads Youtube videos directly. You won't find those on Google's web store due to policy, but you can find a handful on Github. 0: https://github.com/LuanRT/YouTube.js https://github.com/LuanRT/YouTube.js
- cortesoft 2y agoThis project is literally just a UI for yt-dlp. This is for people that want a front end for it.
- NayamAmarshe 2y agoPretty cool! I currently use https://cobalt.tools https://cobalt.tools, it's nice as well.
- thoughtpalette 2y agoGreat link! Bookmarked
- AntronX 2y agoPerfect! It has option to download original yt audio format without transcoding to mp3.
- siddheshgunjal 2y agoI don't understand one thing...why do you need to host it on a server? It can be just a standalone app on windows/Linux/mac. I recently just started using yt-dlp and have thought of making a simple app. Should I though? Are there any alternatives in existence of this kind?
- loloquwowndueo 2y agoWhat, like Stacher? https://stacher.io/ https://stacher.io/
- sva_ 2y agoOr Seal for Android: https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.junkfood.seal/ https://f-droid.org/en/packages/com.junkfood.seal/
- siddheshgunjal 2y agoThis is a very neat implementation! Exactly what I was thinking. I'm gonna try it out. Thanks for the suggestion!
- dspillett 2y ago> Stacher is a Desktop App Come Back on your PC/Laptop! That is terrible UX. I can't even read about it on a mobile device? Maybe I'll check back next time I'm at a desk, likely I won't.
- siddheshgunjal 2y agoThis looks like a good implementation. But I have to go to my desktop to explore more
- grey_earthling 2y agoCelluloid streams using yt-dlp automatically if you ask it to open a supported URL. Parabolic is a purpose-made downloader that uses yt-dlp. https://flathub.org/apps/details/io.github.celluloid_player.Celluloid https://flathub.org/apps/details/io.github.celluloid_player.... https://flathub.org/apps/org.nickvision.tubeconverter https://flathub.org/apps/org.nickvision.tubeconverter
- LeSaucy 2y agoI have an ios shortcut I use to "share" a url to metube for background download.
- atum47 2y agoI made one similar thing to download music. It kind of worked but I end up giving Spotify a chance.
- EasyMark 2y agoWhy self hosted when you can use something like freetube? So you can access through mobile? I only tend to watch videos one time so this seems like overkill unless you use youtube A LOT and regularly for the same streams.
- rmm 2y agoDoes there exist a “light weight” YouTube self hosted clone. Something like plex for YouTube? I want to auto download videos from my favourite podcasts, but then have a super simple dashboard that shows the videos and lets me watch them.
- conception 2y agoJust use plex?
- rmm 2y agoI have tried but it’s really taxing. A lot of the videos are like daily podcasts or whatever and it’s a battle to get them to import correctly, with correct naming, etc.
- dewey 2y agoI'd use https://flexget.com https://flexget.com + Plex for that
- AyyEye 2y agoYep, just add the channels to a text file and itll download them for you and keep them up to date. Put the script into crontab. Zero running processes and only a couple of KB on disk. That's as Lightweight as you can get. https://github.com/TheFrenchGhosty/TheFrenchGhostys-Ultimate-YouTube-DL-Scripts-Collection/ https://github.com/TheFrenchGhosty/TheFrenchGhostys-Ultimate... You could have a shortcut or hotkey that reads it from your clipboard and appends. Just add the destination dir to your media player (or set it to your videos folder) and you're done.
- rmm 2y agoWow thank you internet stranger!
- wahnfrieden 2y agoI discovered that brave for iOS has a playlist button which downloads YouTube videos and stores them on your device, allowing PiP and offline playback without ads. I wonder why more apps don't do this as they have an open license based off a Mozilla iOS backend. They found a way to get Apple to accept it and their CEO has even posted HERE about it defending their technique as valid. Essentially, it triggers only after loading the video inside the regular YouTube website, like a reader button that works across any video content (not just YouTube).
- treflop 2y agoI use this to download videos I add to my playlists into our shared Plex server. Mostly concert videos and skate parts. We have an archive.
- thinkloop 2y agoI wouldn't mind a single program like this that let's you download from all sources: youtube, reddit, ig, twitter, facebook, etc.
- jobigoud 2y agoDespite the name youtube-dl can download from almost any platform.
- efilife 2y agoLets! Not let's! Lets is a form of word let, let's is a contraction of let us. Those are completely different words and are not inrerchangeable https://youryoure.com/?apostrophe https://youryoure.com/?apostrophe
- corobo 2y ago> inrerchangeable https://youryoure.com/?inrerchangeable https://youryoure.com/?inrerchangeable
- efilife 2y agoThis is obviously a typo. Which can't be said about deliberately inserting an apostrophe into a word
- Sincere6066 2y agoYou assume it is deliberate. It's more likely that it was a simple mistake.
- efilife 2y agoThey keystroke that produced the apostrophe was deliberable. The keystroke that produced not the letter I wanted was not
- wiether 2y ago
- covercash 2y agoI think that one of these yt-dlp based servers wrapped in a dead simple PiHole-like imager and some nice front end client apps for playback could really take off in the same way PiHole did with less technical users. Buy a Raspberry Pi, image the microSD card, select your favorite YT channels, install client apps… all your favorite YT content now available locally and ad free!
- miiiiiike 2y agoWhat I’d really like is a YouTube TiVo. There are about 100 channels that I watch religiously, but, release infrequently. I never want to miss a video from these channels. I also don’t want to open YouTube and sift through hundreds of releases from channels that release four times/day just to find the 1-2 videos that I actually want to watch (and will inevitably miss.) Just give me a priority feed of the stuff I actually want/need to watch. If I can download everything and watch it over DLNA, even better, Making sure we don’t miss the things we love isn’t YouTube’s M.O. Keeping the feedbag strapped to our faces while we watch someone stretch a 3 minute video into a 18-22 minute one, is.
- Group_B 2y agoI believe youtube still uses RSS. Could try using that
- aquova 2y agoI was just going to suggest this. I don't use Youtube logged in anymore or have any subscriptions, I instead subscribe to any I want to follow via RSS feeds. Any Youtube channel has its own native RSS feed, no third party service required. You could create different lists in your RSS client of choice for your different priorities.
- defrost 2y agoIt's pretty easy - I have the FeedBro chrome extension (there are many RSS clients, that is just one) and a typical youtube RSS entry for a channel lookes like https://www.youtube.com/feeds/videos.xml?channel_id=UC2wdo5vU7bPBNzyC2nnwmNQ https://www.youtube.com/feeds/videos.xml?channel_id=UC2wdo5v... that's the channel ID for Cutting Edge Engineering in QLD, Australia (mechanical engineering for life size mining | civil tonka toys)
- kiliankoe 2y agoThis is exactly what I do as well. Instead of subscribing on YouTube, I just subscribe to the RSS feeds of channels I'm interested in and then use my feedreader to go through them channel by channel.
- 404mm 2y agoI currently use TubeSync. Despite its simple functionality and many bugs it has, it works well enough for me. My only task: subscribe to a channel or playlist, download videos to a path and check once a day for new stuff. The only UX I need is for setting up the channels. Then just save the files and let Plex take it from there. Anyone knows of a better option?
- andix 2y agoIt's a bit puzzling to me, how many YouTube mirroring tools are available out there. If you're using something like that, what's your reason to download/archive the videos instead of just streaming them from YouTube? I get that sometimes it's great to archive a video in the case it get's deleted from YouTube, but in my case this very rarely happens. I watch the video and I'm done with it. If I can't re-watch it, this doesn't really matter to me.
- XCSme 2y agoI usually download my own videos, or videos that I need to edit/repurpose.
- dspillett 2y ago> what's your reason to download/archive the videos instead of just streaming them from YouTube? 1. Removal of ads is a pretty big reason for many. 2. As you already note: you can't stream a video again if it or the entire channel has since been taken down due to copyright claim (spurious or otherwise) or other complaint. This may matter a lot more to some people than it does to you, depending on the content they are consuming. 3. Some may be downloading for offline play. You can do this with the official YouTube app too, but not without paying for Premium (which seems exorbitant to me) and still being subject to the takedown problem. 4. Local indexing: if keeping reference to videos for future rewatch or sharing, arranging then in your own structure may be more convenient than maintaining bookmarks to YouTube copies or searching for them each time. 5. Some mix of the above, and likely other reasons I've not considered/remembered.
- zepolen 2y agoIt's a bit puzzling to me, this guy is wondering why a tool exists and then gives the number one reason why that tool should exist. Not to mention that sometimes streaming from youtube might not be possible (internet down) or cost prohibitive (mobile plan abroad), or just plain removing those shitty ads.
- counterpartyrsk 2y agoBlock YouTube on kid's home network, but give them assess to your locally curated DadTube.
- null0pointer 2y agoThis is awesome! I’ve been putting off building the same thing myself.
- roshankhan28 2y agoreally great tool. can it also download the videos that are in members only?
- spants 2y agoMeTube works really well. There are browser plugins for it too. I supports not only YT, but x.com and (a-hem) other sites too
- abx12 2y ago[flagged]