5 ms·
Hosting the Olympics has become financially untenable, economists say
- paulcole 2y agoSo? The Olympics are really cool. And there’s always more money. Does anybody think the Olympics are what’s going to be the end of Los Angeles in 2028?
- toast0 2y agoProbably not Los Angeles. It will be their third Olympics, their 1984 Olympics was well managed, and it looks to be on track for a well managed 2028. But when a city/region/country tries to vastly increase prestige by hosting, it's often a big strain on their economy and can leave a legacy of waste. It's one thing to use a big event to upgrade or build facilities that are in demand and will be used, but construction costs were hard to justify. But it's a waste when they're built and then not used after the games; which is unfortunately common. You can often sneak in some infrastructure projects that will be of lasting benefit too. As I understand it, LA's network of highway information signage was built for the 1984 Olympics, and is sort of useful for other things. I read that Paris built some runoff storage/treatment facilities to augment their sewage system[1] so that they could run Olympic events in the Seine, but improving water quality will benefit residents and the environment after the games. [1] Most old cities, including Paris, have a first to market problem with their sewage systems. When there was little concept of sewage treatment, it made sense to build combined sewers that manage rain water and sewage in the same system; you didn't want either in the streets, so pipe it all to the river. Over time, sanitary sewers required treatment plants to clean the water before discharging it into the river; but in a combined system, rain water will oftwn overwhelm the treatment plant capacity, and you get less treated or minimally treated discharges during sustained rainfall. It's difficult to build a second system in an established urban environment, but cities that grew in the 1950s or later tend to have separate storm and sanitary sewers. Of course, time has shown we should treat water from storm sewers too, when possible.
- kcmastrpc 2y agothis is exactly what occurred in barcelona. a huge complex of stadiums and public facilities that are now crumbling.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- vsuperpower2021 2y agoCounterpoint: The Olympics are not cool and I'd rather have the money.
- 0cf8612b2e1e 2y agoGreat, do publicly funded sports stadiums next.
- paulcole 2y agoSee my other comment here. Sports are cool. Put a stadium bond or tax or whatever on the ballot where I live and I’ll vote for it every time. Everything doesn’t have to make financial sense.
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoBillionaires don't need assistance to fund their entertainment venues. When they do want public money to lower the horrible economic burden of supporting their money printer, the public should be equitably treated as an investment partner that gets a proportional share of all revenue.
- whatshisface 2y agoYou would benefit if all members of the public bore the costs of your game tickets, but would you benefit if the same principle was applied to things that you didn't want?
- lolinder 2y agoI do not participate in or watch any sports, but this logic would preclude public investment in anything whatsoever. I enjoy publicly funded museums. I hang out in publicly funded parks. I check books out of publicly funded libraries. None of these are used universally by all of the taxpayers whose money is used to fund them, but I don't feel guilty for that—I pay for things that they use that I don't use. That's part of the deal. Whether sports need public funding is a good question that's worth exploring, but the mere fact that not everyone would enjoy them is not sufficient reason to not fund them.
- ok_dad 2y agoThe difference is that sports stadiums profits go to a billionaire while a public museum’s entry fee, if any, goes back into the museum.
- SoftTalker 2y agoStop trying to outdo the last host's opening ceremony. That boat procession in the rain was a disaster, and whatever they were trying to do with the masked man carrying the torch was absurd. Just have each county's athletes march around the stadium like they used to. Focus on having good venues for the competition (that doesn't necessarily mean you have to build new ones) that's what it's about.
- throwuxiytayq 2y agoWDYM? The Paris Olympics were super cheap to organize, and the way they used the river was very efficient and breathtaking to see…
- Aeolun 2y agoTo be fair, Japan made it really easy for everyone. You could even argue they reset expectations to a much lower level.
- Ekaros 2y agoThe ceremonies are table stakes... Burning even millions there isn't that big deal. The venues are the killer. Expectations are way too high and their utilization after the events is just crapshoot. Maybe we should just go all digital. Do it in VR or 3D or something... Second thing is infra in general that must be build to support these stations, that is often also enormously costly and will not be fully utilized afterwards.
- mrmetanoia 2y agoWas it a disaster? My wife and I thought it was lovely and pretty cool.
- op00to 2y agoSame, it seemed cool to me and my kids.
- jim-jim-jim 2y agoThe opening ceremony is a fashion show. It's fun to judge all the teams' costumes. Hard to do that when they're shoulder to shoulder, leaning on the rails of a distant barge, seen through a rain-soaked lens. And then there was a concurrent runway show to distract from the athletes, which was more of the same featureless body positive chaff they've been bombarding us with for the last decade. It just looked like an American commercial. When are we going to hand the keys to North Korea and let them show us how it's done?
- Aeolun 2y ago> “All Games, without exception, have cost overrun,” researchers wrote. “For no other type of megaproject is this the case, not even the construction of nuclear power plants or the storage of nuclear waste.” Have these people been living under a rock? Literally ever megaproject—even much smaller ones—I’ve heard of in the past 10 years has had overruns much higher than 100%
- p1esk 2y agoThe full quote: “Cost overruns are the norm for the Games, past, present, and future; they are the only project type that never delivered on budget, ever.”
- pfdietz 2y agoThe Los Angeles Olympics in 1984 made a profit of $250 M. Was it delivered on budget? If not, it didn't go far over.
- lmpdev 2y agoLA was the most successful of that era especially after Canada’s incredible disaster This mini documentary is a fantastic look into the topic https://youtu.be/sqPubAjtbc4?si=HXCeTYdzoj8_YXbH https://youtu.be/sqPubAjtbc4?si=HXCeTYdzoj8_YXbH
- toast0 2y agoSaw this somewhere else. Here's a map of the events from 1984 [1]; or at least many of them. Two venues were built for the 1984 games; a velodrome at CSU Dominguez Hills, which operated for two decades until it was replaced by a new velodrome will also host (track) cycling and fencing for the 2028 games; the other venue was an olympic swim pool at USC, which was rebuilt 30 years later although it won't host the 2028 games; both venues had corporate sponsorship to help with construction costs. Only one venue was built for the 1932 games, a swimming stadium that's still in use today, renovated in 2003. Venues aren't fully confirmed for the 2028 games, but everything so far is either existing or temporary (these tend not to be very expensive). Although softball and canoe slalom are planned to happen in Oklahoma City in order to existing venues, since there apparently aren't appropriate venues in the LA area. [1] https://www.raremaps.com/gallery/detail/63575/games-of-the-xxiiird-olympiad-los-angeles-1984-daijogo https://www.raremaps.com/gallery/detail/63575/games-of-the-x...
- xenospn 2y agoArts and culture have never been financially beneficial. Neither are universal healthcare and making cities accessible. Sometimes the benefit is beyond finances.
- Ekaros 2y agoHmm, how much would 10 billion buy in culture? Or spend on promoting sports among general population? To me it has long time seemed like Olympics does not have cost-benefit correct. Money spend could likely get more effective and bigger benefits in other ways. Then again getting money to waste without big ticket item is hard.
- GasTheKayaks88 2y ago[flagged]
- poidos 2y agoI've always thought the summer games should be in Greece each time, with a different co-host country to set the theme etc. Much less waste (you're using the same stadiums and grounds etc), consistent viewing times, and scheduling. Not sure where the winter games could be but I think the same for that too.
- Izkata 2y agoAntarctica?
- jmclnx 2y agoThat is where it will be in say 100 years or so. And will probably be the only place where the Winter Olympics could be held in the future.
- captn3m0 2y agoThe third half of the recent 99% Invisible podcast goes into the same proposal with a bit more detail: https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-2024-olympics-spectacular/transcript https://99percentinvisible.org/episode/the-2024-olympics-spe... Play at 30:30.
- AlbertCory 2y agoBent Flyvbjerg has made a career of analyzing very large projects and why they turn out so badly. Lest we get smug in this techie corner of the world, he found that large ERP projects are terrible even in the context of large projects. Anyhow: This headline made me think, "So you're just now discovering this?" Montreal was a disaster; LA 1984 ran a surplus. Cities that already have the sports venues can do all right; other cities have learned by now that building a whole bunch of new stuff is foolhardy. > To ensure true long-term viability of the Olympics, Matheson, Zimbalist and Phalin said it may come down to designating a single city or rotating through a couple of cities to serve as permanent hosts for the games. Right: LA, London / Paris, Sydney. All of these could farm out some events to other places, like surfing in French Polynesia. Done.
- tzs 2y ago> This headline made me think, "So you're just now discovering this?" Montreal was a disaster; LA 1984 ran a surplus. Cities that already have the sports venues can do all right; other cities have learned by now that building a whole bunch of new stuff is foolhardy. Los Angeles 1984 had another plus besides having nearly all the sports venues already (they just needed to build a new velodrome and a new swim stadium). They also already had nearly everything they needed for Olympic Village and to house the athletes and teams. They used student housing at USC and UCLA. It was summer and both of those schools have a large number of undergraduates who go home for the summer which left plenty of rooms available for the Olympics.
- AlbertCory 2y agoI had moved out by then, but I remember all this scare talk beforehand about how it was going to be the traffic apocalypse from hell. AFAIK it was no big deal.
- massysett 2y agoThe linked news article doesn’t describe how it arrived at its cost figures. Suppose a city widens a freeway before hosting the Games. The widened freeway is used afterward. Is this a “cost”? Does it make sense to count it as one? Maybe the underlying paper discusses this. Hopefully it does as it’s an important question.
- Nasrudith 2y agoI cynically thought that the massive overspending was the reason it exists at this point, hosting the Olympics being one big money laundering operation to give an excuse to take out loans and pay the connected without even having to fit your graft into a normal budget. That so many kleptocrats want to host is a further strong hint. Which cynically might be the real reason behind the push for reduced building, it becoming an embarrassment like FIFA's corruption scandals from nearly a decade ago.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThe world should fund the creation of a new island.
- klipklop 2y agoThe bread and circus scam has always existed to grift tax money. It’s all one big money grab that people for some reason watch and get emotionally invested in.
- orwin 2y agoIt seems misomusie is much, much more prevalent than I thought. I know Rap enjoyers who listened to Gojira, Lennon and Piaf for the first their life and who were boulversed (I've seen people cry), and a few metal/classical music enjoyers who enjoyed the rap parts. 'Les machines de l' île' once again showed to me they were the greatest mechanical artists (sorry for Korean people: I've seen some of your art in Venise permanent exposition, it's really good, exceptionally good even, but live art will always surpass museum art in my mind). Also: people will now remember Parkour is a French sport, and video-games are now officially a legitimate art I think (I never played assassin's creed, but everybody recognized it, right?). One thing that I didn't like: the Algerian delegation shouldn't have had to bring their own flowers, it should have been an happening organized by Jolly. Still a beautiful, artful moment. And the costs are 5 billion less than the Tokyo Olympics, so I guess it'll be OK.
- sys_64738 2y agoWhen a city rebels against the Olympics. https://www.nbcboston.com/news/local/boston-2024-olympic-bid/3404090/ https://www.nbcboston.com/news/local/boston-2024-olympic-bid...
- jmclnx 2y ago>The Olympics in Boston? It almost happened No, I still ROTFL at this. It would have made Greece's Olympics a model of stability. I think it would have ended up being cancelled if Boston was selected.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]