4 ms·
Weight-loss drugs are causing people to spend less at the grocery store: study
- biosboiii 2y agoHappy to see some positive news stories regarding Ozempic/Semaglutide. I really dislike that most stories try to taint it in the "diet trend", "TikTok challenge" light, obesity is a serious illness which is extremely unhealthy and leads to many many preventable deaths, this drug is a miracle. And yeah, there shortages, but then the drug stores shall give out this drug to those who need it the most, and not who pays the most. It's not like the US healthcare system is fair anyways. And also the suppliers can ramp up production (as they are already doing). Friendly reminder: The STEP 5 trial of semaglutide showed that even in long-term usage a sort of "cutoff" BMI is reached, so even skinny/normal bodied people who take semaglutide don't drop to an anorexic level BMI, but stay above the 18.5 line (after which you are considered underweight) [1]. [1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-02026-4/figures/2 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41591-022-02026-4/figures/2
- toomuchtodo 2y agoIndeed, here here. As manufacturing capacity ramps up, and cost approaches $1-$5/month/person, it is an antidote against an economy wired to profit off of miswired reward centers. Success is comin'. Healthier humans, less spending on poor nutrition, lower healthcare costs and improved health at scale. There is even robust evidence that GLP-1 agonists reduce addictive consumption of alcohol, nicotine, and opioids [1] [2]. It's the next metformin imho (cost to benefit ratio). We should be scaling up production like it's a war effort. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40558601 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40558601 (citation) [2] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40357197 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40357197 ("u/comova: 1. GLP-1 drugs appear to dramatically reduce addictive drive across substances. 2. GLP-1 drugs can reach vastly more patients than existing medications and they have positive mental health benefits for anxiety and depression. 3. This is our first ever opportunity to make a big dent in the addiction crisis, which kills 770,000 people a year between opioids, cigarettes, and alcohol.")
- oigursh 2y agoI stopped binge drinking as a side-effect of semaglutide. I'm down 20kg and don't feel like shit all the time.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- pixl97 2y agoHeh this drug sounds like an economy destroyer, companies are hooked on selling addiction and this is breaking the cycle.
- pfdietz 2y agoThere are multiple GLP-1 agonists on the market (five approved by the FDA for glycemic control, two of those also for weight loss) so I expect competition to drive down prices.
- toomuchtodo 2y agoAn interesting fact is that as long as there is a shortage of a compound, pharmacies can make a version using compounding. If demand always outstrips supply, compounding will be permitted. https://kffhealthnews.org/news/article/glp1-compounding-pharmacies-wegovy-zepbound-copycat-drugs-shortages/ https://kffhealthnews.org/news/article/glp1-compounding-phar...
- consteval 2y ago> miswired reward centers I wish we'd finally start calling obesity food addiction. It's an addiction that we've allowed to be economically viable, no different than alcohol and tobacco.
- Someone1234 2y agoThere isn't a shortage of the drug, there is a shortage of auto-injector pens, and it is impacted multiple medications. If you go vile+subcutaneous syringe it bypasses this limitation and is readily available. The auto-injector pens are great, but when people need medication, it should be offered optionally with or without.
- refulgentis 2y ago> Happy to see some positive news stories regarding Ozempic/Semaglutide. Have you really not seen any? The ones I've read over the last year were universally positive. > I really dislike that most stories try to taint it in the "diet trend", "TikTok challenge" light What? Source on either of that? It's not a diet and certainly not a TikTok challenge.
- okasaki 2y agoWe might imagine a future where US and UK grocery stores aren't 3/4 alcohol and junk food.
- justinator 2y agoFor the longest time, laws in my State prohibited grocery stores from carrying any alcohol, but that has changed. Now new laws are in place to not allow for example random baskets of wine to just be plunked in random isles as it all got ridiculous how much alcohol was being pushed out.
- 15155 2y agoLiquor stores had regulatory capture in many states for quite a while - this is slowly changing.
- justinator 2y agoWhat is the advantage of booze in grocery stores?
- 15155 2y agoI don't have to go to two stores to obtain it? Normally these same laws restricting sales to private liquor stores also come with a convenient quota on the number of licenses issued to protect sales. Most areas that remove the liquor store limitations also remove the license quota out of necessity.
- justinator 2y agoHmm -- I found more booze in grocery stores means less you know: food selection. Seems a bad deal to swap food for an addictive drug, but: "give me convenience or give me death" and all.
- 15155 2y ago
- inglor_cz 2y agoNo surprise here. I am on Saxenda right now and my savings from groceries exceed the cost of the drug.
- driverdan 2y agoThe industry group Grocery Doppio is the source. Anyone have insights into how well known they are and if they use proper methodology? The NYPost article adds nothing, as usual. https://www.grocerydoppio.com/performance-scorecard/state-of-digital-grocery-performance-scorecard-h1-2024 https://www.grocerydoppio.com/performance-scorecard/state-of...
- toomuchtodo 2y agohttps://www.goldmansachs.com/intelligence/pages/gs-research/weighing-the-glp1-market/report.pdf https://www.goldmansachs.com/intelligence/pages/gs-research/... (pages 11, 18-19) https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-10-04/walmart-says-ozempic-weight-loss-drugs-causing-slight-pullback-by-shoppers https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-10-04/walmart-s... | https://archive.today/O0zr5 https://archive.today/O0zr5 ("Ozempic Is Making People Buy Less Food, Walmart Says")
- Someone1234 2y agoAside from the absurd prices of these drugs ($500/month) and the initial shortages (mostly caused by shortages of auto-injectors, not the drug itself); there doesn't appear to be many downsides. They essentially reduce food addiction/cravings. Significantly reduce T2 diabetes risks via two distinct mechanisms. It is interesting the moral stance people place on this and how you don't see the same thing on nicotine patches or other cessation products. Seemingly if people are overweight that is a moral failing, and doing something that helps live a healthy lifestyle is also a moral failing. These drugs literally cause people to crave vegetables, and that is bad because they aren't raw-dogging it. Ultimately the only problem here is the criminally high prices. Hopefully other countries can get a better rate so more lives saved/chronic diseases mitigated.
- refulgentis 2y agoReading this, I'm ultimately reminded that the internet has driven us to a place where we can observe ~every opinion, and in fact, some people implicitly, even explicitly, compete to have opinions that are obviously wrong enough that they'll attract more attention than a subtle one. TL;DR: I haven't see anyone take a moral stance.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoWell, I'm too lazy to do it, but you can search for some HN responses to previous comments I've made on this topic if you want to find folks taking a moral stance.
- Tagbert 2y agoI e certainly seen posts here that the people just need the strength of will to eat less.
- silverquiet 2y agoI don't hear it explicitly, but I hear all kinds of static about these drugs from essentially everyone I know, and I assume it's coming from some sense that people are taking the easy way out. I feel it a bit myself as I've had weight issues myself and never taken this type of drug, but if it was cheap and easily accessible (as far as I know it is neither), I'd probably at least try it.
- EcommerceFlow 2y agoHow long until we have injections to boost confidence, help people get over phobias, etc?
- kylehotchkiss 2y agoDrugs don’t fix either of those problems. Deciding to have courage and initiative does. Just trying to say hi to a few people each day does wonders for your confidence.
- BoingBoomTschak 2y agoExactly like being fat, then? Anyway, can't wait for my decadent shithole to be full of splicers, will be fun to watch during the long fall.
- consteval 2y agoI would say no, food addiction is more in line with tobacco than confidence. Meaning, it's an accepted and relatively easy addiction to target, so economically it's huge. Sure, you can quit smoking. Can everyone quit smoking? Now we have a problem. Addressing society-wide problems, like obesity, is not helpful with an individualistic approach. It's just not. Because anyone can do anything. If you'd want to argue the "discipline" route, you'd have to demonstrate what society-wide socioeconomic changes occurred from the 1970s to now, that collectively lowered humanity's discipline. That's a tough ask, so surprise surprise nobody does that.
- lazide 2y agoApparently you’ve never met anyone on Cocaine. Well, actually I’m sure you have but you just probably didn’t know it. P.S. drugs are often a problem because they work. Often too well. Which can often lead to maladaptive behaviors. Not because they don’t.
- gcr 2y agoWillpower isn't sufficient to lose weight. Uncomfortably for you perhaps, these drugs show that willpower is not necessary either.
- Animats 2y agoThe junk food industry is worried.[1] Parts of the industry are fighting back by promoting "fat acceptance".[2] "Amy Cohn, General Mills’ senior manager for nutrition and external affairs, promoted the cereal company’s anti-diet messaging to a room of registered dietitians at a national food conference this past fall. Cohn denounced the media for “pointing the finger at processed foods” and making consumers feel ashamed of their choices. “You can help derail the cycle of shame,” Cohn told the dietitians. During the session, Kathryn Lawson, a registered dietitian and director of regulatory and scientific affairs at the food giant Nestlé, tweeted: “People need to feel heard and seen to help break the cycle of shame when it comes to losing weight and eating.” Turns out there are a large number of paid fat influencers. [1] https://www.wsj.com/business/ozempic-impact-snack-food-companies-9eec87e5 https://www.wsj.com/business/ozempic-impact-snack-food-compa... [2] https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2024/04/03/diet-culture-nutrition-influencers-general-mills-processed-food/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/wellness/2024/04/03/diet-cult...
- stonethrowaway 2y agoAnd on the other hand I’m chuffed if it means less people at the drivethrough for when an absolutely mad craving of junk food pounces. Mind you, where there is even a whiff of money to be made there will be influencers. Morals and tasteful (ahem) choices are orthogonal. All this to say, not surprising in the least.
- hypercube33 2y agoFunny you Segway into drive thru fast food. When a crappy meal costs 10-20 bucks there and they forget your cheese or meat or i can basically get three times the food that's much better at a local diner or make it myself - my choice is very clear and it's not to eat fast food anymore.
- Uehreka 2y agoWhere does GP say they use a Segway at the drive thru? That’s admittedly hilarious, but I don’t see it in the comment.
- sk11001 2y agoIt mean this is as obvious as it gets medication -> appetite suppression -> you want to eat less food -> you buy less food
- paulpauper 2y agoManufactures can fight back by raising prices, like with shrinkflation. Or selling mark-ups on food targeted to these GLP-1 users to negate deficiencies . Also, many people discontinue the drugs after a few years, either due to cost, side effects, or failing to lose enough weight to justify continued use.
- sk11001 2y agoThe "failing to lose" group should be very small, these drugs are very effective. The main reason to discontinue will be people who have reached their goal weight, many of whom unfortunately will gain it back after stopping the medication.
- Guid_NewGuid 2y agoI think there is absolutely a moral issue with these drugs but it's not the usual "personal responsibility" nonsense. The problem is it makes it far less likely we'll address our poisonous food system. The US subsidises (crops including those that produce) HFCS to the tune of billions. Fresh fruit and vegetables aren't subsided. Advertising has been shown to impact consumer behaviour in other countries. These drugs are, provisionally, miracle drugs. But they must be paired with regulation otherwise whatever addictive poison the industry comes up with next will repeat the cycle until everyone on earth is on them.
- crooked-v 2y agoI think the key thing to keep in mind here is that the effects of semaglutide is extremely broad, potentially to the point of being a broad spectrum aid against addictions in general (as has been suggested with animal testing with alcohol). If that's the case and nobody discovers any really horrifying side effects, it's going to potentially affect a whole lot of things outside of just food that exists right now.
- sk11001 2y agoAre those additional positive effects reported specifically for semaglutide/GLP-1? Because over time we're moving away from semaglutide - tirzepatide is much more effective for weight loss than semaglutide and is a much weaker GLP-1 agonist but unlike semaglutide it's also a GIP agonist. I'm wondering if the newer drugs will have those other non-weight loss effects.
- crooked-v 2y agoYes: https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/24/well/eat/ozempic-side-effects-alcohol.html https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/24/well/eat/ozempic-side-eff...
- Guid_NewGuid 2y agoThis is positive news, I wasn't aware of this research. Nevertheless the point remains that the food industry having a free hand to craft the most addictive possible products and then advertising them to kids is also a problem we should address in parallel with getting these drugs to the people who need them now. We should do both.
- FooBarBizBazz 2y agoDo what you need to do, but if the right switch flips in your brain, possibly in combination with lifestyle changes like exiting a high stress situation, you can Just Do It, without pills or anything. "Just" focus your brain on it. Count calories. Avoid sugars and carbs and manage your blood sugar more like a diabetic would. Keep it up for six months. I'm telling you, even if you can't afford Ozempic, well, fuck The Man, you're still in control of your own goddamn body if you really choose to be.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- crooked-v 2y agoIf "just do it" reliably worked, we wouldn't see obesity rates rise in direct relation to how much junk food is available to the average person.
- orwin 2y agoIf you can't afford Ozempic, you probably don't have the time or enough willpower left at the end of the day to do all that.
- hnbad 2y agoIf you are able to "just do it" by putting your mind to it, I'd say you didn't have a problem to begin with. If you can literally walk away from a habit of heavy drinking and stop forever, were you actually an alcoholic or did you just drink too much?
- gcr 2y agoYou sound like my friend's parents who didn't realize until sixth grade that my friend needed glasses to see well in school. "Just focus your brain on the blackboard! You're not paying attention, that's why you can't see!" "You should be doing whatever it takes to learn the material, whether office hours or asking fellow classmates." Dumbass parents didn't think to get their child's vision checked. Amazing how a pair of $60 glasses instantly gave their child "so much more willpower" to become a "star student."
- dangerouszone 2y agoWhats it like being fat