6 ms·
Puerto Rico files $1B suit against fossil fuel companies
- JumpCrisscross 2y agoDoes this have legal legs? Also, if “Puerto Rico says it expects to pay billions of dollars in the future to cope with catastrophes made worse by climate change,” why are they only asking for $1bn?
- woodruffw 2y agoNo idea on standing. But as for the amount being asked for: it's possible that the lawyers determined that only so-and-so much of PR's expected climate damages could be clearly attributable to oil and gas companies, even if the total damages are significantly higher.
- Qwertious 2y agoAlso, if they win the suit and fossil fuel companies are forced to pay for damages in Puerto Rico, then they've established a precedent, opening a floodgate of similar suits from e.g. New Orleans.
- swader999 2y agoDoes the suit describe any real damages already incurred?
- melling 2y agoHow have we done in the last 40 years dealing with climate change? Peak fossil fuels Real Soon Now I’d say Carl Sagan nailed it: https://youtu.be/Wp-WiNXH6hI?si=wJuFlcBbelXVfn6u https://youtu.be/Wp-WiNXH6hI?si=wJuFlcBbelXVfn6u
- analognoise 2y agoStill waiting on that global consciousnesses. It’s a nice idea though.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoStill waiting on his first suggestion of cutting down on the subsidies given to oil and gas, which is, in theory at least, simpler to achieve.
- therealdrag0 2y agoMy impression is there aren’t really subsidies for fossil fuels other than as a rhetorical tool. What is calculated as subsidies are things like wars in the Middle East or not pricing in externalities. So everyone can go “ra ra remove the subsidies” and then the politician is left with no subsidy to remove. Instead they have to do much more difficult work of passing new legislation that to the average voter sounds like punishing fossil fuels.
- ZeroGravitas 2y agoWell the IMF thinks there are over a Trillion dollars of explicit subsidies every year. https://www.imf.org/en/Topics/climate-change/energy-subsidies#A%20Global%20Picture%20of%20Energy%20Subsidies https://www.imf.org/en/Topics/climate-change/energy-subsidie... And another 6 Trillion in implicit subsidies by ignoring the costs of local pollution etc. But yeah, if you categorically define something as "too hard" then it's too hard. Getting some percentage of that blood money back as campaign contributions and bribes is I'm sure not a factor, it's just those pesky voters to blame.
- therealdrag0 2y agoThanks for sharing. Notably to me the “explicit” category appears near zero in North America which is what I’m most familiar with and concerned about, and where I mostly hear people complain about subsidies. But for sure would welcome those other regions to remove their subsidies!
- mc32 2y agoI think this is silly. Without fossil fuels we’d not have had progress. We’d have wood fires to cook, no AC, lots of missing modern inventions. Now if fossil fuels were made illegal or were used illegally, sure. But it’s not like the gov outlawed them and now they are seeking damages. If you want to sue, sue Jane Fonda and her then allies who misled people, corporation and government resulting in 50 lost years of nuclear power progress.
- djent 2y agopollution
- mandmandam 2y agoFraud is illegal. Fossil fuel co's knew from their own research that their product would bring disaster to the planet at incomprehensible scale. Rather than make the knowledge clear and available to buyers, they chose to lie and deceive the public. The result: fraud, false advertising, arson, and pollution on a global scale. All of those things are very fucking illegal and for very good reason.
- ChurchillsLlama 2y agoNevermind the billions of people who (still) drive cars and buy shipped products because there hasn't been a more cost-effective alternative. This entire oil-based economy situation is simple supply and demand and transitioning to clean energy takes a lot of time. I get that their motive comes from oil companies not disclosing the risks to the environment but this is a bit of a stretch and an obvious political stunt.
- keybored 2y agoNever mind what? Companies like British Petroleum have used marketing to frame climate change as “consumers doing bad things” with their “carbon footprint”. So if that’s what your mind goes to first, that’s no coincidence. It’s all about the money. Money buys media which buys narrative and mindshare.
- cogman10 2y agoAnd these fossil fuel companies aren't just doing this in the US. When you look at what they view as the path forward to keep selling oil to burn, it's all about doing things like setting up floating power plants for developing nations and subsidizing road construction to aid in the sale of ICE vehicles. The problem with these companies is the externalities of their actions are not priced in. For them, it's more a simple game of figuring out how to get the world to burn more oil. This lawsuit may not have merit, but it does point to the need for trying to price in the impact on climate change with oil burning.
- LudwigNagasena 2y ago> Companies like British Petroleum have used marketing to frame climate change as “consumers doing bad things” with their “carbon footprint”. So if that’s what your mind goes to first, that’s no coincidence. It's also common sense. Literally nothing stops first-world consumers from not buying stuff that requires emission of greenhouse gases except for their lifestyle preferences. > It’s all about the money. Money buys media which buys narrative and mindshare. Yep, you bought into the idea that you don't have to change your lifestyle because it is all fault of the big oil.
- purpleblue 2y agoShould Puerto Rico pay back the benefits it received from fossil fuels, like increased tourism from airplanes, and for allowing cars and combustible engines on the island? Are they going to get rid of ICE vehicles immediately now? Are we going to start filing lawsuits against sugar manufacturers for all of the health issues they caused? What about manufacturers of fatty foods? Oh wait, are fatty foods good for you or bad for you? Fatty foods were bad for you in the 80s and 90s but now the science is showing the opposite. This entire lawsuit is nonsense.
- keybored 2y agoThe benefits that Puerto Rico has enjoyed are probably comparable to that of mainland America. While the downsides are presumably worse. Which is I guess whence the lawsuit.
- n2d4 2y agoNo, they shouldn't pay back the "benefits", because they already paid for the fuels. No market failures there. There is a very obvious market failure with the downsides of fossil fuels however (negative externalities), and Puerto Rico claims said companies willingly misled the public about those — that absolutely is reason for a lawsuit.
- WillDaSilva 2y ago> Are we going to start filing lawsuits against sugar manufacturers for all of the health issues they caused? Like with the fossil fuel industry, the sugar industry also invested heavily into misleading the public about how damaging their product is. With that in mind, it seems at least somewhat reasonable for governments to file lawsuits against them to punish them, and to recoup some of the lost value due to their negative externalities.
- spiderfarmer 2y agoSome of these lawsuits may be aimed not just at winning in court, but at pushing broader changes in policies or public awareness. Even if these cases are challenging to win, they can influence public opinion and policy, encouraging stricter environmental regulations and corporate practices. Personally I think lawmakers should focus their effort on making stricter legal frameworks for today's world. Use the full force of the law to make companies behave better. It's the only language they understand.
- keybored 2y agoI really hope that it’s about more than public awareness. The power of public awareness is a liberal fiction. The “public awareness” of climate change gets co-opted and neutralized by limp-wristed slogans like bicycle-to-work (where, on the pedestrian-hostile US commuter roads?) and upper-middle class solutions like “buy more Teslas”. And now everyone knows about climate change. Only there are two camps: those who believe it’s real and those who think it’s a conspiracy theory. More awareness so to speak only makes the two camps dig their heels in further. The only way to make corporations change is to threaten their bottom line. But at this point I’m sure many have been convinced that the corporations have no responsibility in this.
- TrapLord_Rhodo 2y agothey sell... Oil, gas and other minerals that make our life go around... It makes that computer your typing on, and gets 90% of us to work/ around. I get it, use of gas and oil causes pollution... But that's on the end user, no? I know people love to villify gas companies, but they are some of the most productive engines of society.
- phalangion 2y agoOne of the roles government can play is to take the negative externalities of an activity (e.g., pollution) and internalize it so that those costs are paid by those who are profiting. The way to do that is to create taxes, fee structures, etc. so that those making money on activities contribute to the overall societal cost.
- moralestapia 2y agoNot a lawyer, so no idea if this will get somewhere. But on the moral side of this, yes, if the operation of oil companies incurs damages to other entities/people, they have to make them whole. The "Netflix wouldn't exist without fossil fuels" argument is silly. The cost of restoring the environment should be factored in to the cost of producing oil, like any other liability. If that makes everything go up in price, well ... that's the actual cost of that product, consume accordingly.
- nradov 2y agoAll human civilization (not just use of fossil fuels) is going to cause some level of environmental damage. This is inevitable. The cost of "restoring the environment" is infinity. So, it's really just a question of what level of damage we're willing to accept. Different people prefer different levels of damage on that spectrum. If not for fossil fuels then we would be living in essentially an 18th century civilization. A lot more stuff then Netflix would never have been created without the safe and cheap energy supplied by fossil fuels.
- energy123 2y ago> what level of damage we're willing to accept Who is "we"? Why do you get to decide whether Africa's heatwave is 52C instead of 48C? Are you going to compensate them for that heatwave, and the resulting strain on their growth & development and political stability? That's the crux of this case. There are significant negative externalities that are not being priced in by the market. The people doing most of the damage owe some compensation to the people who have to bear most of the consequences of their activity.
- moralestapia 2y ago>The cost of "restoring the environment" is infinity. It's not, actually. And if it turns out that your business does something so expensive to repair that for all practical purposes could be considered "infinite damage", then your business shouldn't exist at all (e.g. the Sackler family and Oxycontin).
- adolph 2y agoI wonder if a lawsuit like this could ultimately indemnify petrochemical companies for a known and finite amount, with the most lasting "benefit" being warning signs on gas pumps and anything else produced using petrochemicals: "WARNING: This product is known to the territory of Puerto Rico to cause more and more severe meteorological events." Then at some later time in the inevitable march to Idiocracy, bright minds at low margin businesses will start tossing some food grade paraffin on everything so they don't have to distinguish between SKUs that need the sign and those that don't.
- vivekd 2y agoI think the climate movement is going to fail soon. This mentality of find villans and blame and attack them instead of looking for productive solutions isn't sustainable for a movement. I don't know about the future of the climate but I think unfortunately the climate change issue, like so many pressing issues might be one we have to give up on until we make fundamental changes in our societies
- Ekaros 2y agoI do believe too that it is going to fail. Technology won't solve it. And people who got emissions now are not ready to do enough. And people who do not want the same things that people who do. Outside rather small segment of population not enough people are ready to either substantially lower their standards of living or not increase them.
- vivekd 2y agoThis is where I disagree. I think techonology can solve it, and policy can also solve it. But I think the movement has been hijacked by people with other agendas that differ from solving climate change. And I think you can sort of glimpse it here - the agenda is not solving climate change, it's making the oil companies pay.
- nmz 2y agoThe climate movement wasn't taken seriously 70 years ago, but as people see its effects more and more and the more you live and remember that you could actually walk outside without AC and not melt the more its strengthened. So I highly doubt what you say.
- vivekd 2y agoThat's the other reason it's going to fail, the dishonesty. Frankly I don't remember the weather being that much different when I was a kid. And aside from my personal observations or views, the bigger issue is climate and weather are different things. It is scientific and backed by evidence to think that climate change is happeing and that the earth's climate is getting warmer. It is unscientific and not backed by evidence to think we can feel or experience that now in our current year at the level of weather. That doesn't mean that climate change isn't an important issue but there needs to be a serious change in the way it's presented to people, and I think a huge start is that things need to be led less by journalists and activists and politicans and more by climate scientists We've been claiming that we need to take action by 2030 or there will be disaster. And the movement is going to pay a high price in 6 years from now when we notice that the weather isn't much differet.
- PM_me_your_math 2y ago[dead]
- ziofill 2y agoOnly $1B? These days it feels like way to little.
- AJ007 2y agoThat's a shakedown amount. You can't even build 1 nuclear power plant with $1 billion.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y agoI remember that 20, maybe 25 years ago, the major oil companies were all rebranding themselves as "energy" companies because "we all knew" that we had to be weaned off oil and onto alternative energy sources. Then somehow that effort seems to have petered out. What happened?
- njovin 2y agoThey realized it was cheaper to buy politicians than to actually change anything.
- smolder 2y agoThat is all branding. They greenwash themselves publicly but still to this day show PowerPoint presentations to investors about how they are working to undermine renewables and electric transportation in order to fatten their wallets. (Source: climate town youtube channel.)
- beart 2y agoI think the shale revolution probably changed the calculus. It removed the "dependency on foreign oil" argument from the debate completely in the U.S. (though you still hear it mentioned from time to time without merit). It also reduced the cost of energy in the U.S. which eliminated a lot of the economic pressure.
- HeyLaughingBoy 2y agoI hadn't even thought of that. I bet you're right.
- smsm42 2y agoTurned out unicorn farts are not a good source of energy, nuclear energy is a good source but is scary because scary, and the rest is way too hard (and slow) to scale to the energy levels we need. Yes, I know some tiny country managed to produce 100% of it's energy by some exotic source, just as I know somebody implemented a fully functional OS in Brainfuck. That doesn't mean Brainfuck is a viable industrial system programming platform. And exotic energy is still not a viable stand-alone solution for overall world energy needs (especially if you count transportation). So PR is one thing, but the reality turns out to be a bit different.
- greenavocado 2y agoMoney grab by an irrelevant, corrupt, and desperate US colony.
- notarealllama 2y agoAs someone who lives here and understands the politics and nuance... eso es. ("This"). The people of Puerto Rico are fed up with the government and energy company here (LUMA) and do want change, current governor lost the primary and the candidate replacing him will likely win in November (even though it's the same party, business as usual) is partially because she's very, very anti-LUMA and appeals to the frustrations of people with the situation and is advocating change. Unfortunately, decades of corruption have really impacted our politics and the energy and infrastructure here, and with the recent $4 million transformer issue, it doesn't surprise me that they are suing to try and get a windfall of money.
- greenavocado 2y agoI hope your community sees better days
- keybored 2y agoIs being a US colony (read: not the same rights as most US citizens) a “diss” now?
- greenavocado 2y agoColonialism is bad
- Ekaros 2y agoClearly Puerto Rico do not want anything produced with oil or any petroleum products. Maybe these fossil fuel companies should give them their wish and ban their buyers from using their products to transport goods and people there and also in manufacturing of any goods sold there. That way Puerto Rico could do their part in stopping these emissions. Surely it would not be too big sacrfice?
- johnohara 2y agoPR has struggled to recover from the effects of hurricane Maria, and I get the logic behind the lawsuit, but she also lies near major fault lines that have caused 2.5-3.5 Richter earthquakes every day for millennia. If PR were more creative she'd strike a tentative development deal with China to build a huge deep-water port capable of servicing the largest cargo ships AND the largest naval warships then sit back and wait for the U.S. to write a check to fund the strengthening of its relationship with its "strategic partner." Assuming PR doesn't experience a leadership change shortly thereafter.
- neilknowsbest 2y agoTo be sure, Puerto Rico is a territory of the US. I imagine that making deals with China as you describe would draw the ire of Washington, if it's even "legal" in the first place.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nashashmi 2y agoFossil fuel companies are valued on their infrastructure, and its shareholders leverage that value (VAL) for gains/loans/financial strengths in other pursuits. Fortifying VAL necessarily means discrediting any harms by fossil fuels. It necessarily requires winning against renewable energy suppliers. How can these "necessities" be made moot? By getting the shareholders to also invest in renewables, using the loans leveraged from VAL. But then the loaners will be invested in VAL. Solution is to make sale of fossil companies and infrastructure illegal. Government should buy it out.
- mlism 2y ago[flagged]