6 ms·
YouTube's eraser tool removes copyrighted music without impacting other audio
- umvi 2y ago"AI powered algorithm" or just plain old Fourier Transforms?
- toxik 2y agoIt is pretty hard to subtract a signal like that, if it’s really just signal C=A+B then maybe if you have exactly B you can get A back from C, but with microphones picking up radio or something like that? No shot
- codetrotter 2y agoAlso it has to be able to work on remixes that it doesn’t know about of the songs, etc. All in all I’d say yeah this definitely requires some clever engineering and I believe them that they use AI as part of all of this.
- spockz 2y agoI guess both. One to detect which waves are copyright protected and the transformation to remove it.
- AlyssaRowan 2y agoThey're all actually AI powered, generally some form of real-time RNN trained on identifying and isolating voice content from background noise or music. rnnoise2 is an open-source model that does very well. There also are things like Waves Clarity VX, the Nvidia Broadcast (Audio Effects SDK) too, as well as plenty of other solutions like Supertone Clear, Krisp, etc etc etc.
- CursedUrn 2y agoDoes that mean youtube is AI generating your voice to "add it back" after silencing that part of the video? Does it ever generate different words to what you actually said?
- delusional 2y agoI'm still waiting for Canon to release a tool to scrub pictures of the buildings I own. What makes people believe they can just post photos of my buildings? I purchased the rights to that architecture.
- toxik 2y agoYou can’t take a song photo, there is no permanent one unique recording of a song that has to play forever for it to exist.
- zamadatix 2y agoI'm not sure I follow. The equivalent to a photo of a visual would be a recording of a audible. Whether either core thing exists is independent of a specific recording in both cases. The main difference in the above analogy is probably that a photo is not a primary intended way for the architecture to be consumed whereas it is for a song.
- lttlrck 2y agoSubstitute photo for 3D model of building for VR consumption and it works better. Also some music may be/is intended to be heard live. So the recording/model analogy can certainly fit.
- tmtvl 2y agoThe way a piece of music is supposed to be experienced is not the same as the way a building is supposed to be experienced. Seeing the picture of a building is not the same as seeing the actual building. Hearing a piece of music is the same as hearing the piece of music.
- skyyler 2y ago>Seeing the picture of a building is not the same as seeing the actual building. Sure, I agree with this. >Hearing a piece of music is the same as hearing the piece of music. Gonna disagree there; in the same way that looking at a picture of something isn't the same as looking at something, hearing a recording of a performance is not the same as being present for the performance. The Treachery of Images, as Magritte called it.
- sandworm101 2y agoIncorrect title. >> remove copyright-claimed music from your video This tool will only remove music that has been reported/claimed by someone and reported to youtube. It certainly cannot remove all copyrighted music given that most all recorded music is copyrighted already irrespective of youtube. This tool can remove stuff that has been reported and shared with youtube's copyright systems. That is a different thing than the title.
- kelnos 2y agoI don't think the distinction really matters. If no copyright claim has been made on some background music in a video, then the person who posted the video need not care if that music is copyrighted or not.
- teeray 2y agoIt’d be nice to have a fair use tool, identifying when copyrighted music is a fair use.
- mikae1 2y agoFair use doesn't exist in many jurisdictions (where artists may come from). I would assume carpet bombing is easier than surgery.
- mananaysiempre 2y agoFair use may not exist, but rights of citation or parody still do.
- mike_d 2y agoNo they don't. https://seanmiller.us/blog/parody-laws-by-country/ https://seanmiller.us/blog/parody-laws-by-country/
- ricardobayes 2y agoI know a few small youtubers who make "walk around" live-stream type videos and they always struggle with music from bars etc. It's always kind of funny when they attempt to talk over the music or start walking faster. Kind of sad how megacorporations can affect our behavior. I hope this won't spill over to a general deterioration or avoidance of music. People are really good at copying behavior they see from people they see as "authoritative figures" and influencers are that, for young people.
- Waterluvian 2y agoI feel like if any meaningful amount of society adopted a “avoid copyrighted music” behaviour, the problem would resolve itself pretty fast.
- TeMPOraL 2y ago
- kernal 2y agoNot only Remove, but also Trum and even Replace the song.
- jimbobthrowawy 2y agoI think they had a similar system before to replace all the audio in your video with something from the youtube audio library. The first thing in the list was a song called "009 Sound System Dreamscape" which became notorious as the background audio for tutorials where someone types into notepad due to this system. I wonder what the pre-eminent audio library song is going to be this time.
- thih9 2y agoNow we need a client side algorithm to add that back, perhaps provided by a music platform where the user is a subscriber. I’m sure streaming services would enjoy this kind of windfall.
- scosman 2y agoSync rights are expensive and complicated. Not covered in your Spotify subscription.
- mindslight 2y agoIt's covered by my rtorrent subscription.
- zamadatix 2y agoThis is a much better approach, I like it. Does anyone have a demo videos of this actually being used from when it was in beta? The demo in the video about the feature doesn't demo the results, just the UI.
- kragen 2y agoi wonder if you can use this to make a viral video of someone screaming like a lunatic by erasing the loud music they were trying to be heard over. like the dean scream video that sunk the howard dean presidential campaign it's disturbing to me when youtube permits post-publication editing of videos like this
- Waterluvian 2y agoIt feels quite plausible that soon enough we’ll be able to ask it to replace copyright music with generated “soundalike” music.
- freedomben 2y agoWe'll see. Rightsholders are doing everything they can to fight that, and having the laws and giant corporations all doing their bidding makes them much more powerful than "the people." They will fight this with everything they have, which is a considerable number of billions.
- kelnos 2y agoI guess it's good that there's a new solution to this problem, but I wish it just wasn't a problem in the first place. It's ridiculous that someone can't just walk around outside, making a video of what they're doing, and post it, without having to worry that some copyrighted music is playing in the background for some portion of it. That sort of situation should be considered fair use, and copyright owners who attempt to make trouble for people caught up in this situation should be slapped down, hard, and fined.
- prox 2y agoAgreed. It is stupid and vile to use a few words. I am all for enforcement if it reaches a significant audience with commercial interests. But now anyone for any reasons gets this crap.
- Jerrrry 2y agoThey can, they just shouldn't expect to be paid for it.
- vanchor3 2y agoPersonally I would say people should not be able to make money off someone else's copyrighted content without permission, but someone putting a lot of work into making a good video and having someone else claim all the money over 10 seconds of audio doesn't seem right either.
- clob 2y agoRecursive attribution (e.g. a profitable video used 10 seconds of a remix of a song ultimately belonging to xyz) would be fair. It should be easy for YouTube engineers to engineer profit sharing. Say hypothetically that the song writer gets paid 100% every time their song gets played 100% in any video, why does copyright care at all? It's right to safeguard the primary creator's intellectual property to the extent of allowing them to claim share in profits, but it's strange to use copyright to restrict use.
- bmar 2y agoThey should add AI that improves audio as well. Some older MIT and Stanford course playlists have pretty bad audio. It would be nice if they could just enhance the audio in place.
- djmips 2y agoI use Nvidia's Broadcast tool to do it locally on my GPU in realtime. It works fairly well and has made some older videos, especially courses or presentations at conferences satisfactory to watch but I agree it would be great if YouTube could automatically provide it as a tool as well. I'm hoping to find a tool that removes umms and ahhhs, mouth clicks and other annoying tics.
- bmar 2y agoAh, looks like you need RTX to run. Sadly I only have a 1080ti
- MaxikCZ 2y agoI think Nvidia Broadacst is just a repackaged clone of original"RTX Voice", and that one, despite the name, ran also on non RTX cards, including 970. Perhaps Broadcast will also run? Its even possible you just need to flip value in config to force it to run on nonRTX cards
- genewitch 2y agoThere was a java tool that could improve audio but it was designed for archival of tape, film audio, and old records and the like. I lost the computer i ran it on, i even paid for it but i can't find the receipt to redownload (or even rebuy it). It worked very well - about as well as i can do manually, and perhaps a few percent better - i don't remember many shimmering artifacts https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xazubVJ0jz4&t=85s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xazubVJ0jz4&t=85s [0] I'd be pleasantly surprised if nvidia can "fix" audio, as i have.. oh, a few thousand hours of audio that i could clean up in an automated way. [0] hilariously, youtube gave me a copyright strike for this video, even though it's obviously an archival upload. Jerks.
- OptionOfT 2y agoThis is actually a better solution. If someone complains you can scrub it and still maintain your full ownership of the video, while still keeping your video watchable. Replace is nice if it's only the song, but you lose any voice-over. Mute also loses your voice-over.
- dvngnt_ 2y agoit's technically possible to separate into stems but not sure how well it works in practice
- ajdude 2y agoThis is essentially how Earworm[1] started [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JlxuQ7tPgQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-JlxuQ7tPgQ
- londons_explore 2y agoI really wish the content id system was open to all. Simply default to the first person to upload a piece of video to the site 'owns' it. If you're a film studio or something you can upload a video and set it to private to 'own' content before you release it. I get that technically scaling content id is hard, but it seems like a solvable technical challenge considering the market position it would give YouTube as the de facto copyright reference index. Everyone has to upload there first unless they want to risk getting their content 'owned' by someone else and a battle to get it reassigned.
- garblegarble 2y agoFor a while this was basically how it worked for all intents and purposes. I assume it's not like this anymore, but we used to do this with live tv broadcast material: rush out a private youtube video of individual segments for Content ID to ingest while on-air (because somebody else was posting clips from the show faster than us, claiming Content ID and stealing the ad revenue from the broadcaster's official public video of the final show) Getting Google to care enough to fix that problem was harder and slower than a technical solution.
- Hizonner 2y agoYoutube's eraser tool removes any music that any moron or bullshit artist has chosen to claim...
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThey will have to do this in real time for twitch streamers. There have been some pretty funny instances of people on among us competing against streamers, so they play copyrighted music to keep the streamers away. It was the first time that DMCA acted as a paladin-like aura in a video game.
- magnetowasright 2y agoThis made me think of all the copyright claiming against classical musicians performing pieces for the sound recording copyright (rather than the piece itself being copyrighted; so many pieces are out of copyright in a significant number of places[0]). I don't use youtube so I'm not sure if it's still a thing that happens? If it is, I wonder how this eraser tool will behave. Would a few bars of someone's performance of a piece be removed because there's inevitably going to be similarities when performing a piece? [0] imslp.org is a great source for pieces no longer under copyright. Not all the sheet music itself on imslp is out of copyright in all jurisdictions, of course.
- cwillu 2y ago> Would a few bars of someone's performance of a piece be removed because there's inevitably going to be similarities when performing a piece? This still happens, yeah.
- kevinh 2y agoThis feature has existed since at least 2014.[1] I guess they're just advertising it now because AI is the new hotness? It's generally worked for me pretty well, although sometimes the sound gets a bit strange. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20140427195913/https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2902117 https://web.archive.org/web/20140427195913/https://support.g...
- zamadatix 2y agoThe article notes the functionality has existed for a while and that this announcement is an improvement of it.
- dingaling 2y agoIf they made this available to viewers too it would be a valuable way of removing overbearing background music from otherwise interesting videos.
- MaxikCZ 2y agoThis is my main grupe with these Innovations. They use it as they want, but rarely as we want. The fact you cant seek in Shorts is just atrocious.
- Log_out_ 2y agoGreat now i can easily remove the content i paid for fair and square from videos of the software i work on, cause i do not have the bureaucracy Time for all those maniacs who strike there custonners. And its all to protect a ecosystem that their own geberative ai research has doomed to die anyway . Makes perfect sense, in a asylum hallway kind of way. The public will have to bail out YouTube . https://github.com/PicassoCT/MOSAIC/raw/master/sounds/advertising/advertisement99.ogg https://github.com/PicassoCT/MOSAIC/raw/master/sounds/advert...
- RecycledEle 2y agoThe music industry will never let this fly. They would lose their ability to control our home movies that have an undetectable slight note or two that might have come from a neighbor's stereo system. Mark my words, YouTube will drop this to give the music mafia their control back.