3 ms·
Tiny bright objects discovered at dawn of universe baffle scientists
- imhoguy 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- davedx 2y ago> Leja explained that if you took the Milky Way and compressed it to the size of the galaxies they found, the nearest star would almost be in our solar system. The supermassive black hole in the center of the Milky Way, about 26,000 light years away, would only be about 26 light years away from Earth and visible in the sky as a giant pillar of light. Pretty crazy galaxies.
- bsenftner 2y agoHow's about super massive black holes are massive enough their gravity well accelerates the mass being captured faster than the speed of light, and they plunge back in time. The Universe is self regenerating, by sending super massive black holes back to the beginning of time, where they explode into our universe. Or something like that. Maybe, maybe not.
- exe34 2y agothis would make really good sci-fi, you should write it up!
- robxorb 2y ago[GPT has entered the chat.]
- VagabundoP 2y agoNot only is space time probably curved back on its self but the arrow of time as well. Time is a flat circle!
- ramon156 2y agoMaybe flat earther are yet to discover an even bigger truth, flat time
- EdwardDiego 2y agoPfft everyone knows it's a cube.
- dreamcompiler 2y agoI didn't expect the Rust fans to show up in this particular topic, but you pulled it off.
- anon291 2y agoGravity doesn't get to 'cheat' special relativity.
- bsenftner 2y agoInside a blackhole?
- oldmariner 2y agoLeftovers from an old Big Crunch?
- exe34 2y agoit'd be tricky to get them from one side to the other. you'd think the quark soup would vaporise them.
- oldmariner 2y agoPerhaps it didn't compress evenly? There's no reason a previous universe had to form, expand, or stay distributed evenly.
- frutiger 2y agoUnfortunately we have not observed any anisotropy so it seems implausible.
- downvotetruth 2y agohttps://arxiv.org/abs/0811.2732 https://arxiv.org/abs/0811.2732 1. Introduction Since the discovery of the anisotropy of the cosmic microwave background (CMB) radiation by COBE...
- exe34 2y agois this the same one that penrose saw the ghost of universes past in?
- downvotetruth 2y agoPenrose has published many papers on ghosts of black holes from another universe (see https://www.livescience.com/63392-black-holes-from-past-universes.html https://www.livescience.com/63392-black-holes-from-past-univ... for commentary), but 0811.2723 does not have Penrose as an author or state a reference to him by name.
- Zigurd 2y agoIt was just 101 years ago that galaxies outside the Milky Way were discovered and that the universe we can observe grew from being 100k light years to 93 billion light years in diameter. The existence of black holes was first observed in the 1970s. It is a good bet other astonishing objects are yet to be discovered.
- DexesTTP 2y agoNot quite that, we've known about galaxies outside our own (like the Magellanic clouds or the Andromeda galaxy) for a few millenia, and the main reason black holes haven't been discovered for a while because they're black and we needed a theory to know where to look. The current theory of cosmology has overall been pretty stable for a while. What's interesting there isn't that much the object themselves which are bog-standard as far as celestial objects go, but how red-shifted (and therefore how far away/long ago) they are, which is something the model doesn't quite exclude but does warrant some tweakings of the "initial parameters" of the universe to make it work this way compared to what we expect.
- actionfromafar 2y agoBut did we know they were galaxies and not just some shining object?
- ahazred8ta 2y ago> In 1924, Edwin Hubble established the distance to classical Cepheid variables in the Andromeda Galaxy, until then known as the "Andromeda Nebula" and showed that those variables were not members of the Milky Way. Hubble's finding settled the question raised in the "Great Debate" of whether the Milky Way represented the entire Universe
- macintux 2y agoTheir nature wasn’t confirmed until the 20th century. Wikipedia tackles the history: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda_Galaxy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Andromeda_Galaxy
- someplaceguy 2y agoMaybe this is what a white hole looks like...
- prettyStandard 2y agoGalaxy Brain thought: I feel like the big bang is a white hole. Come back I have more! All world lines end in black holes. All world lines start at white holes. Many Worlds theory is pretty popular. I buy into it. Every thing that can happen does happen, but also... There's this one that goes every black hole spawns a new universe, with slightly different laws of physics, based on the parent universe. So the multiverse starts favouring universes that can make new ones. Does this mean the Spiderman universe is out there somewhere? Even hypothetically IDK. There's probably some constraint on consistent laws of physics.
- DEADMINCE 2y agoThat's some great sci-fi.
- wiml 2y agoThis is a bit of a background point in the novel Learning the World (Ken Macleod).
- alecdote 2y ago[dead]
- yencabulator 2y agoI think you'll love this: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4v9A9hQUcBQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4v9A9hQUcBQ
- chgs 2y agoSo what is it?
- kolanos 2y agoObligatory Red Dwarf reference. [0]: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxWN8AhNER0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TxWN8AhNER0
- seo-speedwagon 2y agoNaive thought incoming: If these old galaxies are so dense, could that help explain why their black hole is disproportionately large? With so many stars so close together, maybe they’re gravitationally interacting with each other far more, causing a lot more instability. So you have a bunch of stars knocking each other around and as a byproduct more of them get flung close enough to the center to get captured by the black hole?
- hansvm 2y ago(not an expert, just a math guy who occasionally tunes in to this sort of thing) The pop-sci treatment of what you're describing is the "force-feeding" theory. Black holes exert an outward pressure as they consume material, naturally limiting the rate they're able to grow. There were some recent results lending credence to the growing body of evidence that force-feeding was, at the very least, not a common phenomenon. One such tidbit was discussed here at HN recently [0]. Nobody really knows for sure yet though. [0] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40761465 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40761465
- MattPalmer1086 2y agoLoving how we are finding mysteries the further back we look. Super massive black holes far larger than our models can account for. Galaxies with more structure and more older population stars. What is it telling us? Our current ideas are certainly wrong. Looking forward to what it leads us to.
- awinter-py 2y agoso quick bright things come to confusion
- SoftTalker 2y agoScientists looking at JWST data: My god, it's full of stars
- suzzer99 2y agoThere better be a new season of How the Universe Works about all this new stuff the James Webb is finding.
- SaintSeiya 2y agothey will keep getting "confused" by older-than-expected objects because the premise is wrong to begin with: the universe is not 13 billion years old, the universe is infinite and eternal.
- Horffupolde 2y agoAre you being facetious or what are you basing on?
- nataliste 2y agoBruno probably had the right of it.
- Sabinus 2y agoOr our models for stellar evolution don't account for the true conditions in the early universe.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThat means there are an infinite number of exact copies of you typing on HN and on an infinite variety of HN analogues in their respective timelines. Infinity is big!
- aoeusnth1 2y agoMost people don’t realize that, unless the universe has positive curvature, it’s infinite in extent according to the usual General Relativity cosmology. We have no evidence that the universe is anything but flat.
- mr_mitm 2y agoThe age of the universe is a measurement, not a premise.
- dreamcompiler 2y ago"The researchers were also perplexed by the incredibly small sizes of these systems, only a few hundred light years across, roughly 1,000 times smaller than our own Milky Way. The stars are approximately as numerous as in our own Milky Way galaxy...but contained within a volume 1,000 times smaller than the Milky Way." If the diameter of a galaxy is one-thousandth, then its volume is one-billionth. They can't both be one-thousandth.
- free_bip 2y agoThe milky way isn't a cube.
- tsimionescu 2y agoUnless it's an almost linear object, its volume is still a power of two or three of its linear dimensions. Many galaxies are quite flat, so their volume could be approximated as X * r^2, though spherical galaxies also exist. Long thin cylindrical galaxies, where you could see a linear relationship between length and volume, aren't a thing.
- lostmsu 2y agoI think they mean volume both times. They just forgot to delete bad wording.
- tsimionescu 2y agoI think it's more likely they meant a millionth or a billionth the second time - it's much more common to talk about the size of galaxies in terms of their relative radius than talking about their volume, which you can't directly measure and that's much harder to compute.
- tsimionescu 2y agoMany types of galaxies are nearly flat - all stars are approximately orbiting the center of the galaxy in the same plane. Still, that would mean that the "volume" (essentially the area of the disk) is on the order of one millionth the size of the Milky Way if the diamater is one thousandth. Of course, it's possible that this galaxy is spherical, so your original numbers apply.
- lenkite 2y agoIsn't this yet another shot fired against the timeline of the Big Bang theory ? Lost count now of the observational data that comes up every year or so that either contradicts or is unexplained by the current, prevailing hypothesis.
- mr_mitm 2y agoOr another shot fired against the prevailing theories of galaxy formation. You cannot discern which one it is just from this.