9 ms·
Supershoes are reshaping distance running
- whoiscroberts 2y agoEPO
- waderyan 2y agoGolf is facing a similar crisis with distance gains caused by driver technology. Many of the world’s famous golf courses can’t hold the best players. Two of golf’s governing body, the USGA (the United States Golf Association) and the R&A (the Royal and Ancient) have recommended a rollback of the golf ball, which has caused significant debate in golf circles.
- cainxinth 2y agoSwimming dealt with it in 2009 after complaints that suits like the LZR Racer provided too much buoyancy and records were being broken at an unusual rate: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LZR_Racer#FINA_rule_changes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LZR_Racer#FINA_rule_changes
- smittywerben 2y agoWhile the advancement to carbon fiber in running shoes is similar, the exploitation in swimming was far more extreme. This was an unintended side effect of the suit when shifting from skimpy Teflon Speedos ("Fast Skin") to full-body polyethylene LZR suits. The key issue was layering multiple suits. Wearing two suits would trap a huge air bubble between the layers, pushing your body above the surface and reducing your drag substantially. The multiple suits issue is generally downplayed because it doesn't promote Speedo's new technology and casts swimmers as cheaters. Imagine showing up to a race with your new carbon fiber running shoes, only to see your opponent wearing "Moon Shoes" strapped over their high-tech shoes. It looks ridiculous, but there was no rule against it at the time.
- thih9 2y agoWhat happens with the world records that were scored before the rule change?
- bobbiechen 2y agoThey stand. But if you look at the current records (based on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_world_records_in_swimming https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_world_records_in_swimm... ), most of them were set after the 2009 ban. In other words, the full-body suit advantage was not overwhelming.
- fire_lake 2y agoBigger golf courses, just what we need…
- toss1 2y agoTennis also changed irrevocably when they changed from wooden to composite rackets.
- randomcarbloke 2y agoI'm contemplating a switch from the minimalist shoes I adopted not long after Born to Run was released. Although I don't run as regularly or consistently as I used to, I suspect there are gains to be had from wearing a squishy carbon-plate 8-10mm drop shoe. I'm on a stint of running at the moment, and wonder whether it's better to persist with my minimalist shoes until I (once again) reach a plateauing of gains, or do I switch now and benefit immediately?
- dgimla20 2y agoAs a fellow runner, it really depends on where you are currently at to answer questions like this. I think of myself as a pretty good runner, but doubt these shoes would benefit me in a meaningful way at this point.
- randomcarbloke 2y agoI watched a video recently where a reasonably good runner switched from minimalist to vaporflys and it was transformative, I think you're underestimating just how significant the advances in performance shoes have been (as the article points out).
- mikestew 2y ago...doubt these shoes would benefit me in a meaningful way at this point. You would probably be surprised. Can you race at 8:00/mile? Do you not heel strike like you're pounding fence posts? Then they'll probably work for you. I've run 50 mile races averaging around 9:00/mile in Vaporflys, and I still benefited greatly, if only because my legs weren't as trashed as they might have been in other shoes.
- jurassicfoxy 2y agoI can assure you that many super shoes will make you noticeably faster. Try them on in the store, you'll know right away. That being said, some of them (Nike's especially) are really hard to run in. Almost zero heel support, and so you do have to be quite fast to make some of them work. I have run in Endorphin Pro 3's and they are super super stable. I've work them for very slow ultras as well as fast workouts: excellent shoes all around.
- thenoblesunfish 2y agoAnother way that, a bit sadly, running is becoming more like triathlon or F1. In those, there are a lot of rules about what technology you can use. Annoying, but it will have to happen with running - consider that these "supershoes" in part work like prosthetic running blades do, and those are more efficient than human feet (as they are springs).
- matt-attack 2y agoTo me this notion that shoes like this have a spring action that are actually useful seems dubious. Prosthetic blades have a spring constant that’s clearly calibrated to match the cadence of your running step. I really don’t think the little springs on these shoes could possibly have the necessary correct spring constant to be beneficial in that way. Yes they might cushion your knees and joints from the blows associated with your foot landing on pavement but that’s a different effect that saying the spring action is actually helping you run more efficiently (like prosthetic blades do).
- _DeadFred_ 2y agoIf we are going to limit tech I think they should reduce the improved precision of chronometers. Lots of records fall simply because of this. It isn't fair that previous record holders lose their record simply due to better measuring technology.
- sfn42 2y agoI don't get your point. If a more recent record is accurately measured, then that's entirely fair isn't it? It seems like you're implying that an old record was inaccurately measured to be slower than it really was, and then beaten by a more accurately measured modern record? Inaccuracy goes both ways, less accuracy could just as easily lead to a better time than a worse one.
- bluecalm 2y agoI see it the opposite way. Triathlon (and cycling time trialing) becomes very expensive if you want to be competitive because there is too little regulation. You can buy a lot of performance on a time trial or triathlon bike and I don't think it's good for those sports long term.
- saltybytes 2y agoVivid runner here with very low arches. My question is: do these supershoes work with supporters (that prevent my arches from collapsing)?
- digging 2y agoGlad you asked here. I was taking down notes during the article to inquire about if this would help me get into running. I have very flat arches as well, but I've never been a runner and my knees are already pretty bad. (Aside: I think you meant "avid runner here")
- jasonpeacock 2y agoI too had flat fleet, and wore arch supports for many years, but after training in barefoot running for a year I "fixed" the issue. I even ran a marathon in barefoot shoes! It sounds like an advertisement, but it was life-changing for me. (I'm also a big guy at 240lbs) The book I used is "Chi Running" but there's many similar books.
- hgomersall 2y agoYeah, not quite the same but my arches stabilised by moving to a more forward strike - mid to forefoot. We've been careful with my son who is now 6 to have flexible soled shoes and he naturally runs like this (may not be related, but interesting to note).
- tiffanyh 2y agoOff topic: you'd think a university site wouldn't bombard you with pop-ups, ads and subscription sign-up. Immediate first impression isn't good, for this (presumably) respected publication.
- inemesitaffia 2y agoNo affiliation with the university
- tiffanyh 2y agoIt's owned by the university. Just the editorial is independent (no influence from university on topics/content published). > MIT Technology Review is a bimonthly magazine wholly owned by the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, and editorially independent of the university. > Technology Review billed itself as "MIT's Magazine of Innovation". Since 2001, it has been published by Technology Review Inc., a nonprofit independent media company owned by MIT. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIT_Technology_Review#:~:text=MIT%20Technology%20Review%20is%20a,1998%2C%20under%20then%20publisher%20R https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MIT_Technology_Review#:~:text=....
- getwiththeprog 2y agoI agree, I u-block zapped the elements, but it dissuaded me from seeking other articles on their site.
- mcswell 2y ago"... physical attributes more common in this group that are conducive to an energy-efficient gait, including... a high ratio of leg length to torso." I wonder how much the added height of the shoes mimics (or exaggerates) having long legs?
- AtlasBarfed 2y agoIncreases the torque arm. Also probably increases the amount of elastic energy stored in the Achilles tendon.
- Qem 2y ago> Increases the torque arm. Does the increased torque arm of thick sole shoes also increase ankle spraining risk?
- stevesimmons 2y agoHere's a very good article from The Guardian about the rise of supershoes. I remember it well: it was published on the morning of this year's Paris marathon - which I was running in - and it made me feel inadequate for not having supershoes of my own. https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2024/apr/07/carbon-fibre-super-shoe-running-marathon-vaporfly-adziero-tracksmith https://www.theguardian.com/sport/2024/apr/07/carbon-fibre-s...
- fire_lake 2y agoWe take up running to get fit and then spend hundreds of dollars on footwear to reduce the effort it takes to run. People are funny :)
- yread 2y agoit's even worse with cycling. You could get fit cycling a heavy bike around the neighborhood instead you spend thousands to go 100kms. And accidents always happen at the point most distant from home. And you get more flats the further you go
- stavros 2y agoI took my (cheap and heavy) bicycle to the shop. The guy was going to oil the chain, but I told him not to, as my commute is fixed and I want it to be good exercise. I guess that, when you're racing, you want to win, not necessarily to expend max effort. For a commute where I use a bicycle instead of motorcycle specifically for the exercise, I want the opposite.
- fire_lake 2y agoThis would lead to increased component wear though.
- stavros 2y agoYeah, definitely. I expect I'll have to pay something to keep fit, and the chain and gears are probably cheaper than a gym subscription. They're also not very good components, which puts them in the bottom end of the price range, so that's good too.
- nsteel 2y agoPlease do be careful and monitor the condition of your chain if you're going to deliberately let it degrade. You can cause yourself quite a nasty accident when your chain snaps, or even slips on the teeth at an unfortunate moment. I'd personally find a different way to increase the effort e.g. carry more mass
- 6510 2y agoBetter running shoes are like recumbent bicycles getting banned from bicycle races or turbochargers from formula 1. I read Nike had in the 80-90 figured out some thicker bouncy sole that was so good they banned it. Now we have faster shoes only in theory. lol This was the first hit in google (I'm that lazy) it illustrates nicely how all the rules are designed for a competitive sport on equal footing (pun mine) http://www.uka.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/World-Athletics-Shoes-Rule-T5-formerly-143.pdf#:~:text=5.13.3%20must%20have%20a%20sole%20with%20a%20maximum,a%20maximum%20thickness%20of%20no%20more%20than%2030mm%29 http://www.uka.org.uk/wp-content/uploads/2020/10/World-Athle.... > Athletes may not use any appliance, either inside or outside the shoe, which will have the effect of increasing the thickness of the sole above the permitted maximum, or which can give the wearer any advantage which they would not obtain from the type of shoe described in the previous paragraphs It is kind of sad for real innovation if everything that works gets banned.
- thenoblesunfish 2y agoIt's sports so the whole thing is contrived to have a fun set of rules (if you're just trying to go fast, get a car, etc.). So innovation is ultimateld really only impressive if it helps reduce injury or improve comfort. Making it more expensive to participate is not super impressive.
- codersfocus 2y agoThis makes me wonder if when the 4 minute mile was broken, and thereafter broken by several more people in short order, was this due to improved shoes? The example is frequently cited as a "mental shift" causing improved performance, but was it just better shoes?
- baxtr 2y agoIf I had to guess it was a combination of better shoes, better food etc that all mounting up to this point.
- CyberDildonics 2y agoI would guess steroids before shoes. The record was broken in May 6, 1954, steroids were developed in the 30s and started to be used in the 50s. https://www.acog.org/clinical/clinical-guidance/committee-opinion/articles/2011/04/performance-enhancing-anabolic-steroid-abuse-in-women https://www.acog.org/clinical/clinical-guidance/committee-op...
- jasonjmcghee 2y agoImproved workouts / training etc too. The mile at that pace is a lot like a long sprint- which requires pretty different muscles / preparation. Look at how close the top high school kids are to breaking 4 and how many have. I don't think it can be explained away with their shoes and diet.
- Hasu 2y agoThe shoes Roger Bannister broke the 4 minute mile in are NOTHING like modern running shoes, which were invented in the 1960s and only popularized in the 70s. https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/sep/11/roger-bannisters-sub-four-minute-mile-running-shoes-sell-for-266500 https://www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2015/sep/11/roger-bannis...