8 ms·
The sun's magnetic field is about to flip
- cko 2y ago> One side effect of the magnetic field shift is slight but primarily beneficial: It can help shield Earth from galactic cosmic rays — high-energy subatomic particles that travel at near light speed and can damage spacecraft and harm orbiting astronauts who are outside Earth's protective atmosphere. Buried three sentences from the end of the article, after a wall of ads and filler (I'm impatient).
- andrewfurey2003 2y agoThanks
- nomel 2y agoWhy? Is it because the poles are aligned with earths, complimenting our own magnetic field? It appears the magnetic poles are in continuous rotation [1], that sometimes aligns to the rotational poles and sometimes doesn't, with a "flip" event being the binary classification from the slow and smooth traversal over the equator. I feel silly, but I always assumed it was from some more fairly sharp step in the rate of change! [1] https://www.stce.be/news/211/welcome.html https://www.stce.be/news/211/welcome.html
- eerpini 2y agoThere is an animation further down that shows the magnetic field generated by the sun when it is a dipole. Apparently the 3-d wave like pattern better shields from cosmic rays originating outside the solar system.
- whaleofatw2022 2y ago... interesting question though.. Is this related to why my part of the US has had UV notices lately?
- gleenn 2y agoInterestingly this happens every 11 years and also their is a longer cycle called the Hale cycle which is double the length at 22 years. It flips from a mostly dipole where the poles match the orientation of earth to a reverse and much more irregular magenetic orientation. I didn't see anything about how this really affects Earth directly other than what I knew previously about sun spots make Coronal Mass Ejections sometimes towards Earth. Think we had a few things happen recently due to those but nothing too crazy.
- stanislavb 2y agoThank you so much. I came to the comments looking for a similar explanation.
- anilakar 2y agoIs it related to the 11 year sunspot cycle or just a coincidence?
- teamonkey 2y agoDirectly related
- type0 2y agoFor layman explanation it was just discussed it on StarTalk just a few days ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lty_55JbkmE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lty_55JbkmE
- lofaszvanitt 2y ago[flagged]
- wegfawefgawefg 2y agoThe point of the show is to bring science to common people. Many of the startalk episodes he brings on pop culture icons or sports commentators. They dumb down the content substantially, but my mom and my grandma really liked those types of episodes so it must work.
- ck2 2y ago(it's gradual and takes five years, not like a day)
- HumblyTossed 2y agoBut that doesn't earn you a lot of clicks...
- michaelteter 2y agoIn a cosmic timescale, it's practically instant.
- renewiltord 2y agoYeah but if it flips every 11 years and takes 5 years to flip that's got a little less of the "about to flip" flavor to it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ck2 2y agoOn a solar scale though earth goes through a full orbit in just a year, Mars two years. It is interesting that Jupiter has an 11 year orbit and that kind of matches the flip, might just be coincidence but that mass has a huge tug though. Sun is only 1000 times the mass of Jupiter, if you think of it like a "failed star" it's kinda like a pseudo binary? Eh I am grasping at straws.
- lukan 2y agoIf Jupiter was a failed star, it failed big time. "Although Jupiter would need to be about 75 times more massive to fuse hydrogen and become a star,[66] its diameter is sufficient as the smallest red dwarf may be only slightly larger in radius than Saturn." It got as big as it could be, though. "Theoretical models indicate that if Jupiter had over 40% more mass, the interior would be so compressed that its volume would decrease despite the increasing amount of matter. For smaller changes in its mass, the radius would not change appreciably.[63] As a result, Jupiter is thought to have about as large a diameter as a planet of its composition and evolutionary history can achieve.[64] The process of further shrinkage with increasing mass would continue until appreciable stellar ignition was achieved" https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jupiter https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jupiter
- teepo 2y agoI'm having trouble parsing tfa; does this mean the sun is at "solar maximum" now, and does this also mean we may be in for some more frequent and intense auroras?
- wtallis 2y agoYes. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_2024_solar_storms https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/May_2024_solar_storms and https://xkcd.com/2930/ https://xkcd.com/2930/
- photochemsyn 2y agoYou can see the sunspot cycle progression here, looks like solar maximum will last a year or two: https://www.swpc.noaa.gov/products/solar-cycle-progression https://www.swpc.noaa.gov/products/solar-cycle-progression
- razodactyl 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- telotortium 2y agoDon't post ChatGPT-generated summaries here - I got told off by the mods for doing it before.
- nonethewiser 2y agoIs there any correlation between these cycles and earth temperature? This seems to suggest yes? > The atmospheric temperature spike, which was caused by successive geomagnetic storms, suggests the "solar maximum" is fast approaching. https://www.space.com/earths-thermosphere-highest-temperature-solar-storms https://www.space.com/earths-thermosphere-highest-temperatur... And would something like El Nino be included in this effect or is it separate? Don't get me wrong - the earth has obviously been getting warmer for a long time now. But the narrative on the cause of recent high temps seems way over-simplified.
- f1shy 2y agoYes, but not well understood, and not, global warming has nothing to do with it.
- riedel 2y agoAnything that monotonically goes up over the last 100yrs currently correlates with the earth's average temperature, unfortunately. A 11yrs cycle does not seem to fit that criterion.
- lancesells 2y ago> help but feel like recent high temperatures are getting vastly oversimplified I could see this if it was just a regular person that you know weighing in on climate change and temperatures, but there seems to be a pretty overwhelming global concensus of experts for maybe 50 years saying this. I'm sure timelines are wrong, studies are sometimes wrong, but I'm going to put my faith in the experts that recent high temperatures are the result of humans. I'm also going to place a bet that this is only going to rise and get worse as we're offloading our own internal energy and capabilities to things like robots and AI, everything using extra energy to connect to the internet, non-replacable batteries, locked devices, fast fashion, and junk stores like Temu and Amazon. I can buy a speaker from 1970 and it works. I won't be able to buy a speaker from 2020 and have it work 50 years from now. New tech has much better qualities than old tech but the tradeoff is comsumption increases as nothing is repairable.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- datavirtue 2y ago[flagged]
- nikso 2y agoIf you're open to exiting an novel theories on why this happens, check out Dr. Robitaille liquid sun: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUZ0Obpihbc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qUZ0Obpihbc
- raylad 2y agoVery interesting hypothesis. Anyone here with more expertise want to comment? The summary is that the sun is actually metallic hydrogen, which forms a lattice similar to layers of graphite. This both explains the black-body radiation of the sun and provides a mechanism to explain sunspots and the solar maximum and pole flip: sunspots are non-hydrogen elements that are excluded from the metallic hydrogen lattice and push it upwards as they migrate to the surface and are ejected.
- gavindean90 2y agoI am not an expert but boy does that feel right based on the available evidence that I’ve seen.
- causality0 2y agoHe's a retired radiologist who knows nothing about astrophysics. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zi_mQ0sKOfo https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zi_mQ0sKOfo
- temp0826 2y agoI think there is a more interesting (and longer scale) trend that is less talked about, that the last couple solar cycles have been overall less intense (less activity/spots at the maximums)- http://solen.info/solar/images/comparison_recent_cycles.png http://solen.info/solar/images/comparison_recent_cycles.png I wish that chart went further back to see if there is a greater cycle at play. At a glance it looks like this cycle is a slight rebound over the last.
- c0brac0bra 2y agoI recall back a few years reading some articles speaking about the sun entering in a Grand Solar Minimum cycle similar to the Maunder minimum, and that the result could be global cooling, etc. Not sure if there's been additional research or conjecture since then.
- TheBlight 2y agoI'm convinced in a few hundred/thousand years scientists are going to be urging politicians to figure out how to pump more CO2 into the atmosphere due to cooling from cyclic perturbations of Earth's orbit. Too bad I won't be around to enjoy the irony.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- idiotsecant 2y agoIs it ironic? Right now it's getting too hot so we want fewer greenhouse gasses, in the future it might be cold and we want more. I think it's less ironic and more just the intentional infant science of planet-scale climate engineering
- hughesjj 2y agoI don't think it would be any more ironic than a house using the heater in the winter and ac in the summer Also, acidification is another problem of co2. Honestly you might rather release methane or refrigerant if your goal was only to heat/insulate the atmosphere with minimal changes to chemistry, but I'm not a chemist etc Also never forget the great oxygenation event and the azola cooling the planet to the point of mass extinction and snowball earth
- andoando 2y agoIts so perplexing to me how the laws of physics replicates simple properties into massive scales.
- localfirst 2y agoso then i wonder why do people struggle with the impact of polar shifts on climate?
- defrost 2y agoWhat makes you think that people do struggle? Are you hinting at the sun's poles or the earth's? Further do you mean the rotational pole, or the magnetic poles? FWiW, NASA has written on all of these, for example: Why Variations in Earth’s Magnetic Field Aren’t Causing Today’s Climate Change https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/flip-flop-why-variations-in-earths-magnetic-field-arent-causing-todays-climate-change/ https://science.nasa.gov/science-research/earth-science/flip...
- mensetmanusman 2y agoThat makes all of us.
- mordae 2y agoSo... What's the range and how do we modulate it?
- MadnessASAP 2y agoThe range would be awesome, but the city took pretty significant offense to my plan to setup a 11 lightyear dipole antenna on my property. It's a hard life being an amateur radio operator these days...
- somat 2y agoWhich made me think. I would expect other stars to do this. Would magnetic polarity be detectable at interstellar distances? could novel astronomy* be done on stars this way? * Does the magnetic flip period tell us anything about the star that would otherwise be hard to figure out.
- Aspos 2y agoCan one use Sun's magnetic field for navigation? I imagine Sun compass would be far more precise than Earth compass, no?
- contravariant 2y agoYou want something to make it easier to find the sun? Anyway the sun's magnetic fields is ridiculously weak on earth.
- dredmorbius 2y agoWell, one always has to consider the first manned expedition to the Sun and how they'll navigate. Telling time of day would be the first problem as it's always high noon. And star sightings might prove challenging, at least at optical frequencies. (Am now thinking of an SF story set on the Sun in which navigation and timekeeping play critical roles....)
- lukan 2y agoIn that SF story, I would be far more interested in the tech, that allows human life (or anything we bring) to withstand that slightly bigger problem called heat and radiation.
- dredmorbius 2y agoPshaw! Trifling details. (Focusing on the non-obvious problems might make for a more interesting and/or fantastical story.)
- alfor 2y agoThe earth too it seem, but on a longer timeframe. Does someone here know more about this?
- emporas 2y agoEarth's magnetic field rotates in irregular intervals. The terrifying part is, the time it takes to complete the rotation, the different intermediate magnetic poles cancel each other out, and we are left with a much smaller magnetic field overall. As low as 10% of what earth has today. Astrum's channel on youtube has several pictures and complete analysis[1]. (I have downloaded the whole channel on my computer, that's the filename.) [1] How The Earth Got Its Magnetic Field (And Why It Might Not Protect Us Much Longer)
- mr_toad 2y agoAs the sea floor plates that are being created in the mid ocean ridges cool the magnetic orientation is recorded in the alignment of particles in the newly frozen rock. We can see alternating bands of polarity in the rock that show what the orientation was over geological time. The bands that spread outward from the ridges are separated by millions of years and provide a clear picture of sea floor spreading, and continental drift.
- hscontinuity 2y agoWe know so much and yet so little. The writing is in the article stating how mathematically they have no model, therefore they cannot truly understand it yet (researchers/academics). This is true for climate change and it's own challenges along with many other applications of similar nature where models are incomplete or entirely missing large portions of data needed to further true understanding of a given process.
- mandibeet 2y agoThe sentiment captures the essence of the human pursuit of knowledge...
- teamonkey 2y agoAs is common in physics, a subject can be extremely well studied, theories can be produced, models can be created that predict future behaviour incredibly precisely, but because we can’t poke it hard enough or with enough precision the exact underlying mechanism remains unconfirmed.
- Apocryphon 2y agoSo going off of the previous HN thread, I thought we were due for a Carrington event a month ago (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40321821 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40321821). Will this next bout of astronomical magnetic phenomena pose a threat to technological civilization as we know it?
- ben_w 2y agoPerhaps. The Carrington event was 2-4 times as strong as the one last month, but on the other hand it also looks like most of the electrical systems are a lot more resilient than they used to be.
- anileated 2y agoI am curious about how would the general public be made aware of another Carrington-class storm. NOAA rated May 2024 storm as G5, which is the highest rating for a geomagnetic storm regarding its effect on the public.
- Apocryphon 2y agoJust need Bruckheimer + Bay and/or Emmerich to make a couple of disaster movies about the concept to incept it into the public's mind. Hopefully that will then provide NOAA the popular support to do what they need to do.
- bityard 2y agoWhen we had the CME headed towards Earth recently, I was pretty amazed at the sheer number of highly-upvoted HN comments whose authors seemed to believe that the power grid, copper phone lines, and communications satellites were all about to be wiped out. Fortunately, most engineers in all of the fields above are well aware of the Carrington Event. And while it's not beyond possibility that there might be some corner cases if (when?) another one happens, we know how to design these systems to keep another one from causing any major outages or damage.
- 2y ago
- P_I_Staker 2y agoIt's just really sad to see all in the storys about the ends of earth. Every thing a new day to kill us. Now were to be wiped out enterirely.
- defrost 2y agoIt's not a story about the end of the earth. It's a story about a regular recurring solar phenomenon.
- P_I_Staker 2y agoI don't think the earth can servive without the sun. Pretty basic, I think.
- ianburrell 2y agoThis is the Sun's magnetic field. It reverses on 11 year cycle, the same cycle as sunspots. It has reversed multiple times during your lifetime. The current cycle seems to be stronger than usual. And produce some strong solar flares recently. Those could cause problems for electrical grid. But there have been stronger cycles back in the 1950s.
- P_I_Staker 2y agoThese magnetic rays you keep talking about. I don't think they're going to keep us warm or grow the plants when theres no sunlight.
- BurningFrog 2y agoRelax. Humanity has always produced stories about the ends of earth, and we always will. It's just something we do.
- P_I_Staker 2y agoYou may be relaxed at the end, but I DO NOT want to die. Don't know whats going in your lives, but I don't die. Life it for living.
- NikhilVerma 2y agoI wonder what the astrologers have to say about this
- Etherlord87 2y agoThe article says the transition takes 2-5 years and happens every 11 years. Isn't the title a clickbait then?
- casenmgreen 2y agoI recall a few years ago a what seemed to be ground-breaking white paper from I think a Russian scientist, who argued (and convincingly) that there are two cycles at work, one deep in the Sun, the other shallow. The co-incidence of these two cycles both being at maximum, or both being at minimum, explaining the extremes of solar activity.
- defrost 2y agoThat sounds like Gnevishev, M. N.; Ohl, A. I. (1948). "On the 22-year cycle of solar activity" which first appeared in the Russian journal Astronomicheskii Zhurnal 76 years past.
- casenmgreen 2y agoVery interesting! but not that - it was much more recent, few years ago. What I'm thinking of was not writing about a 22 year cycle; it was arguing for two independent cycles, one deep in the solar atmosphere, one toward the surface.
- defrost 2y agoSure, you more than likely did read a more recent paper. That said, the earlier paper was about two cycles, the already known 11 year cycle and seperate observations that only occurred every two 11 year cycles. There's a chance the two papers are related via a common coupled driver, or not.
- phillias 2y agoAnd so is the Earth's. The poles have been traveling to meet together in the Indian Ocean