11 ms·
Water is bursting from another abandoned West Texas oil well, continuing a trend
- toomuchtodo 2y agoOriginal title "Water is bursting from another abandoned West Texas oil well, continuing a troubling trend" condensed down due to title limits.
- Cyphase 2y agoAnother option would have been: "Water bursting from another abandoned Texas oil well, continuing troubling trend"
- curtis3389 2y agoIf this is fracking water, it's truly horrifying.
- jvanderbot 2y agoTFA posits that it's actually fracking water creating the pressure that is pushing the old "fill" water out of these wells. That's somehow less reassuring b/c it means the fracking water is creating enough pressure to blow old wells out, doesnt it?
- NegativeLatency 2y agoSeems like the difference between fracking water and fill water could be very little under some circumstances
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hedora 2y agoThis water is probably worse than fracking water. In addition to being contaminated with oil, etc, according to the article it's 5-8 times saltier than sea water. These wells are literally salting the earth around them.
- ZeoVII 2y agoand also lots of >hazardous compounds such as arsenic, bromide, strontium, mercury, barium, and organic compounds, particularly benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes. This will likely contaminate the land, rendering it unsuitable for agriculture and, I dare say, potentially transforming it into a barren wasteland incapable of supporting organic life.
- callalex 2y agoSalt will definitely render the land unusable, but most of those other things are the consumer’s problem, not the producer. I find it highly unlikely that governments in Texas will ever successfully prevent a farmer from growing food on poisoned land, for the same reasons that governments in Texas let these wells become seeping messes in the first place.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoWatched a video of a guy who owns an oil and gas company and when a nearby company started fracking their well, it produced enough pressure to 10x his own output without any effort on his part.
- DowagerDave 2y agoreservoirs are big sponge-like rocks. The pressure has to go somewhere.
- ok_dad 2y agoSocialism is alive and well for corporations. Oil wells should be fully plugged and dealt with before they can be abandoned by the companies pumping them. Instead, private land owners and taxpayers foot the bill. Disgusting.
- SOLAR_FIELDS 2y agoOstensibly they are, but the article posits that the definition of “fully plugged” here is not really actually “fully plugged”.
- ok_dad 2y agoI was thinking they could have solved this earlier, perhaps if they had found they couldn’t plug wells properly decades ago, they might not have allowed as much drilling, or would have researched and experimented sooner to figure it out. My point being, the fact that these companies abandoned it without thinking is a cause of the current issues.
- DowagerDave 2y agoThere's definitely an orphan well problem and cases of very irresponsible O&G companies, but you gloss over the challenges with hindsight and an incomplete understanding of the science & technologies involved. It's more like space exploration than it's like "digging a deep hole"
- ok_dad 2y agoI’m sure it’s a hard problem, too bad taxpayers are the hook now instead of the corporations that took that unknown risk.
- krunck 2y agoIf you let people pump garbage water into the ground on your property, you deserve what comes back up. Unfortunately, subterranean water movement doesn't obey private property borders.
- thoronton 2y agoThe land owners do not always have a choice. "Under split estate law, the surface owner must allow the mineral rights owner reasonable access. Protections for the surface owner vary; in some states an agreement is required that compensates them for the use of the land and reclaims the land after extraction is complete." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fracking_in_the_United_States https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fracking_in_the_United_State...
- SOLAR_FIELDS 2y agoEven not taking that into account, aquifers and groundwater and other subterranean formations don’t stop at property lines. If I’m your neighbor and I inject some dirty water at high pressure into my ground there’s a nonzero chance it might pop out on your land
- ToucanLoucan 2y agoNever get tired of watching libertarian ideals collide with reality. Property rights do not make you an island, and what you do on your property with your property might well affect mine if I happen to be next to you.
- IncreasePosts 2y agoWell, they had a choice to sell their mineral rights, or purchase land that had no mineral rights.
- dontlikeyoueith 2y agoThis is often just false.
- throwup238 2y ago> Dunlap suspects it may be related to the injection of fracking wastewater. West Texas oil producers pump millions of gallons of so-called produced water, laced with chemical lubricants and numerous hazardous compounds such as arsenic, bromide, strontium, mercury, barium, and organic compounds, particularly benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes, underground every day for disposal, often into old oil and gas wells. No shit. The Permian Basin is home to some of the biggest fracking operations and they've been depleting the ground water to supply the wells so much they've started to run out and have to recycle the waste water: https://www.texastribune.org/2022/12/19/texas-permian-basin-fracking-oil-wastewater-recycling/ https://www.texastribune.org/2022/12/19/texas-permian-basin-... Pennsylvania is increasingly having a similar problem with what they're calling "frac-outs" where the fracking water breaches nearby wells and poisons residential water: https://www.wesa.fm/environment-energy/2022-07-15/dep-investigating-a-frac-out-at-an-eqt-well-in-greene-county-residents-claim-water-contamination https://www.wesa.fm/environment-energy/2022-07-15/dep-invest...
- mlindner 2y agoThe Pennsylvania situation is completely different. Those were wells drilled decades ago that were extremely shallow and done with very simplistic methods that didn't isolate the well from ground water. That type of drilling is no longer done. The wells in the Permian are below multiple levels of bedrock well below any pumpable ground water and they're lined with impermeable barriers all the way up the well. Further this article isn't even about fracking. The wells water was pumped into were ancient abandoned wells, not fracked wells.
- Johnny555 2y ago>Further this article isn't even about fracking. The wells water was pumped into were ancient abandoned wells, not fracked wells.* The oilfield firefighter quoted in the article (who has experience with wells in 102 countries), suspects that the Texas problems are related to fracking. So I don't think fracking can be dismissed out of hand, even if it's the old wells that are failing. Hawk Dunlap, an oilfield firefighter who lives in Crane County and surveyed the recent blowout for Wight last week. “It’s not clear what the source is.” ... Dunlap suspects it may be related to the injection of fracking wastewater
- exabrial 2y agoSigh... all thats happening is formation pressure overcoming an improperly capped well. This article is making it out to be some stupid mystery but it's pretty obvious... even the original article contains errors or leads the user to incorrect conclusions (likely intentionally). I'll surmise a guess to whats happening at the bottom of my comment. "Capping" is supposed to be temporary, with the intention: of usage later combined regular reinspection, or permanent kill later ("plugging"). A plugged well is injected with high pressure concrete to/past the impermeable rock layers, past the multiple steel/concrete well casings that travels through aquifers. Why would you cap a well instead of plugging? lets explore that and see if you can guess the correct answer. I'm greatly oversimplying this, but the state is supposed to keep track of capped wells to make sure 'something' is done with them. Given the age of these wells (80+ years ago or WW2 era) it doesn't surprise me if shortcuts were taken and records don't exist. I think if you're going to be against something, it's really important to understand it. My opinion is this is an environmental issue that should be addressed, but treating it with sensationalism and throwing pseudoscience in is just going to add confusion and tie up resources that could be used to fix the problem. These fluids need to stay in the ground... especially the salt water, as that simply does not break down in nature. The articles author and comments here lack a basic knowledge of Geology: > Dunlap suspects it may be related to the injection of fracking wastewater This shows a fundamental misunderstanding of whats happening. Fracking involves the injection of fluids to expand cracks in formations, then flash filling them with an aggregate. This allows formation fluids to flow faster. It's not like you're sitting here pumping up formation pressure to eleventy billion and keeping it there. That would be counterproductive to production anyway: you want stuff to come out of the well, not stay in the ground. To be perfectly transparent though, there are extractions methods where a flow is introduced into a formation by creating a pressure differential in a formation; you suck at one end and blow on the other. No idea if that's present where the issue is taking place, but it's unlikely. > If this is fracking water, it's truly horrifying If a formation underwent production after fracking... where do you think that "fracking water" went? This comment shows a fundamental misunderstanding of whats happening. > Pennsylvania is increasingly having a similar problem with what they're calling "frac-outs" where the fracking water breaches nearby wells and poisons residential water This is more than likely surface contamination by some ding dong fracking company, but that doesn't make good headlines. It's hard to take stuff like this seriously... production formations are thousands of feet below ground, far far far below the water table, which sits on top of the bedrock and impermeable layers. If said layers _were_ permeable, no water table could exist, because the water would simply keep going "down". The sensationalism around fracking is face-palm inducing. > The Permian Basin is home to some of the biggest fracking operations and they've been depleting the ground water to supply the wells so much they've started to run out and have to recycle the waste water (link) > If you let people pump garbage water into the ground on your property, you deserve what comes back up Fracking is a one time operation. It's important to understand that. The other comment links an article that says: > Fracked wells in West Texas don’t just produce petroleum. Much more than anything else, they spit up salty, mucky water. This is actually really important to prevent earthquakes and ground movement. If you remove x number of fluids and don't replace them, you'll cause shifts in rock layers. The best place for extracted fluids is back where they came from, in roughly equal amounts. What's happening in Texas is people are extracting fluids from one area, seperating oil from the saltwater, then gung-ho slapping that water back into the earth in another. This produces a formation pressure imbalance and causes earthquakes among other issues. Nobody can really predict whats going to happen when you do this... we simply don't know "whats down there". As such, a "Dead" formation is probably now being pressurized and blowing out caps that were half-arsed capped. As a matter of fact, companies will keep old wells unplugged for the explicit purpose of turning them into salt water disposal wells. So in conclusion salt water injection is the root problem, but the media puts a magnifying glass on "fracking" for whatever reason and nothing actually gets done.
- sigspec 2y ago[flagged]
- anothername12 2y agoThat’s right. These ranchers are basically reaping the side effects of that sweet mineral royalty they invited into their lands. If you’re ever in Midland, you’ll find it smells like ass. I think in another decade or two it might be uninhabitable and maybe acutely toxic. Also from the article, it seems the railroad commission is paying for clean up?? Is the public paying for the externalities of rancher and mineral extraction?
- jandrese 2y agoThe public is almost always on the hook for this kind of environmental damage. Even if you can track down the company that did it and prove that it was them it will be stuck in the courts for decades while the problem only gets worse.
- NotYourLawyer 2y agoSometimes the land owners have some of the mineral rights. Often they don’t.
- rayiner 2y agoMoney is just a proxy for goods and services in the economy. Cheap energy (along with cheap Latin American labor) is what allows Americans to live in houses twice the size of someone from say France or Germany, and drive their kids around in 5,000 pound SUVs.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoAlso more disposable income over all. Not to mention no millions homeless from midcentury warfare, generous federally supported housing loans came instead.
- jmclnx 2y agoThat is what you get when you cut the budget of the EPA over and over. Hate to be snarky, but there is a reason for EPA oversite. Maybe this will get people in Texas understand why the EPA is needed.
- ryandrake 2y agoCome on, this is crazy talk. If we empowered the EPA, they might decide to further regulate companies, and those companies might subsequently capture slightly less profit for shareholders. How can you even suggest this? Won't someone spare a thought for the resource extraction company shareholders, if only just for a minute?
- diob 2y agoNope, they'll conclude that the EPA is ineffective, then cut and / or eliminate it!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- hindsightbias 2y agoI guess the next goldmine idea of carbon sequestration will work great with hundreds of thousands of leak points. https://undark.org/2024/03/26/carbon-storage-abandoned-wells/ https://undark.org/2024/03/26/carbon-storage-abandoned-wells...
- burningChrome 2y agoI'm still trying to figure out if dealing with OPEC and having to constantly control and monitor some of the most conflict prone areas and governments that have no love for America. . . . OR. . . .having to deal with trying to be energy independent and all the issues that come with it like what's being pointed out in the article. There is no silver bullet for being able to power a country with 340+ million people - some of who live in very inhospitable climates (Arizona/Alaska) where one solution will work for everything and everybody. I'm not sure what the solution is, but every time something like this happens, we focus on all the negatives instead of understanding the alternatives aren't that great either.
- kingkawn 2y agoThe military interventions around the world are not only due to our own needs for oil but also to control the access of others. Even if the US was energy independent the national security complex would still insist on invading everywhere
- burningChrome 2y agoOur military and standing as a super power has been in decline for a while now. I don't think we really have the military superiority or ability to just simply invade countries any more. With China, Russia and Iran aligning against us both economically and militarily, I don't see much of what you're talking about happening. Russia annexed Crimea and we did nothing. Russia invaded Ukraine and besides sending billions in aid, we haven't done anything militarily. The attacks against Israel went unprovoked and we've got all we can handle with the anti-Israeli protests going on here on our own soil - let alone trying to send troops to any of these hotspots. China has been sabre rattling about taking over Taiwan and all we can manage at this point are sternly worded memos. Add in the amount of conflict going on in Africa that nobody seems to want to deal with either. All the while China has steadily moved economically in on Africa and has essentially pushed us out of the country altogether. What you're saying in 2024? I don't see the US has the capabilities to do that any more.
- 2y ago
- FrustratedMonky 2y ago""It’s the latest in a string of mysterious water features in the arid Permian Basin"" ""Last year, an eruption of salty water swamped several acres on Wight’s cousin’s ranch, a geyser shot up from a well in Crane County, then another on the Antina Cattle Ranch. Nearby, a large pond of gassy groundwater has become a permanent feature called Boehmer Lake."" This is the opening line of a disaster movie. Dinosaurs? Climate Change? The Earths Core heating up? Neutrinos?
- ck2 2y agoIf you don't force people doing nasty business to pre-pay cleanup costs, they get to keep the profits and socialize the expenses of cleanup to everyone else. That's why there are hundreds of EPA superfund cleanup sites, no-one has to pay, just bail out of town and keep the profits.
- DowagerDave 2y agoAlberta has an orphaned well program to cover this (more likely the drilling company no longer exists vs. "skipped town") but even with the forethought it still doesn't work.
- red-iron-pine 2y agobecause the Jason Kenney & Danielle Smith (aka UCP leadership) decided to let the oil companies off the hook.
- SECProto 2y agoThe parent comment specifically talked about prepayment of cleanup costs - i.e. taking their money before it's drilled, so that when companies go bankrupt, there is already money set aside to do the cleanup. The Alberta system does not do this.
- ProllyInfamous 2y agoThe book Empty Mansions [1] is about the heiress of Montana copper mining interests, Hugette Clark (father is namesake of Nevadah's county). IIRC, she inherited multiple properties and $300m+USD. A quite fascinating view into the insanity of an eccentric ultrawealthy, who lived into the 21st Century at times thread-barren. The unfathomable wealth she squandered on bullshit throughout her mostly-anonymous lifetime of luxury... could have supported hundreds of other 20th century families. As specific example, she maintained a Santa Barbara mansion, for decades, without ever visiting the property. That she was given it all from her father creating a superfund site... probably helps explain much of her reclusiveness [that and loss of sister at a young adult age]. [1]: https://www.amazon.com/Empty-Mansions-Mysterious-Huguette-Spending/dp/0345534530/ https://www.amazon.com/Empty-Mansions-Mysterious-Huguette-Sp...
- irrational 2y agoWhy is a Railroad Commission in charge of capping oil wells?
- thefourthchime 2y agoIn Texas that's how it works, the Railroad Commission of Texas. The RRC was created in 1891 to regulate railroads, but its role expanded to include oil and gas regulation in the early 20th century.
- dredmorbius 2y agoThat's a more interesting question, and history behind the answer, than you might expect. The Texas Railroad Commission was founded in the 1880s during a progressive political movement there against monopolistic businesses, largely railroads. Its remit extended to more general monopoly regulation first to oil pipelines in 1917, perhaps reasonable as another transportation-related activity, then oil and gas production in 1919. It took on natural gas delivery in 1920, bus lines in 1927, and trucking in 1929. In the 1930s, as the East Texas Oil Boom developed, the TRC along with the US Department of Interior effectively became part of the structure which managed US, and by extension, global oil markets until the early 1970s, when the US no longer had surplus oil production. In the 1930s, the TRC and the Texas Rangers literally seized wellhead production by force of arms in order to curtail wildly surplus production which was both tanking (so to speak) oil prices (hitting a low of $0.03 per barrel) and premature oilfield depletion through excessive extraction. (Oilfield extraction at the time largely relied in the inherent gas pressure of the fields, resulting in early drilling producing "gushers" where oil could spout hundreds of feet into the air. Like poking many holes into a balloon or bottle, excessive drilling reduced that pressure, and could often leave much oil unrecovered within formations. Limiting drilling and extraction reduced individual operators' yields but increased the overall field yield. Other countries, particularly those with nationalised oil operations such as Saudi Arabia, Mexico, Brazil, Venezuela, etc., effectively arrived at similar trends.) There are also principles of resource recovery which were either established or enshrined by the TRC, notably "Rule of Capture", a whole 'nother discussion. And the (unrelated) issue of regulatory capture, in which a government regulatory agency overseeing an industry tends to over time answer to rather than govern over that industry. Wikipedia of course has a good general overview: <https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzWlrARDVbQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lzWlrARDVbQ> Daniel Yergin's epic history of the oil industry The Prize discusses the TRC in the context of the East Texas Oil Boom in chapter 13, which makes for fascinating reading, not only about the oil industry but about the actual realities rather than the theoretical operations of "free markets" and natural resource extraction. And for those interested in a deep dive, several books, including David Prindle's Petroleum Politics and the Texas Railroad Commission (1984) <https://openlibrary.org/works/OL9371845W/Petroleum_Politics_and_the_Texas_Railroad_Commission?edition=key%3A/books/OL10294015M https://openlibrary.org/works/OL9371845W/Petroleum_Politics_...>, Mark A Miller's Oils & Gas and the Texas Railroad Commission (2015) <https://openlibrary.org/works/OL24732694W/Oil_Gas_and_the_Texas_Railroad_Commission?edition=key%3A/books/OL32834836M https://openlibrary.org/works/OL24732694W/Oil_Gas_and_the_Te...>, and William R. Childs's The Texas Railroad Commission (2005) <https://openlibrary.org/works/OL5476040W/The_Texas_Railroad_Commission?edition=key%3A/books/OL8816911M https://openlibrary.org/works/OL5476040W/The_Texas_Railroad_...>.
- MisterBastahrd 2y agoAnother fun part of having capped oil wells all over the place is that they can seep hydrogen sulfide gas. It can permanently disable you or even kill you. https://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/energy/article/toxic-h2s-gas-leaks-west-texas-map-19461968.php https://www.houstonchronicle.com/business/energy/article/tox...
- downrightmike 2y agoCause: They poked holes deep in the ground and billions of tons of land, at a minimum, are pressing down as hard as it can.
- nashashmi 2y agoUnless the holes are huge enough like 1000 feet wide, the pressure of the land above should be able to even out on the surrounding walls of the hole. Geoligical event similar to this are sinkholes that happen in Karst areas. But those are sinkholes. And the surface depression from that sinkhole is visible. Instead, what would be more rational to assume is that the grounds are settling (which they generally do), and the water inside the voids are being squeezed out. The water is coming into contact with softer deepwells and is bubbling to the surface.
- demarq 2y agoWhy not conclude it’s a chemical reaction… > West Texas oil producers pump millions of gallons of so-called produced water, laced with chemical lubricants and numerous hazardous compounds such as arsenic, bromide, strontium, mercury, barium, and organic compounds, particularly benzene, toluene, ethylbenzene and xylenes, underground every day for disposal, often into old oil and gas wells.
- jofer 2y agoBecause volume expansion from a reaction wouldn't be that large. Things aren't burning/etc. Direct injection of large volumes of water (with those things in it) is more than enough to explain it. No need for reactions of any sort. The issue is that the injection should be into far deeper sections. Something in the active injectors is leaking and therefore the injected liquids aren't making it to the bottom of the well and are flowing out the sides and into shallower permeable sections. The simplest explanation would be a bad casing (i.e. the steel sides of the well) in a major disposal well, but it's likely more convoluted than that. Either way, it's a significant problem for a lot of reasons.
- cyanydeez 2y agoYeah, its probably a more boring problem of inadequate regulations and corporate negligence.
- cyclecount 2y ago>> Texas’ oilfield regulator, the Texas Railroad Commission, has yet to offer… can anyone explain why the Railroad Commission regulates oilfeilds? is it because there aren’t many railroads in Texas?
- rstuart4133 2y ago> There’s nothing uncommon about a leaky old well. Many in West Texas were drilled during World War II and 80 years underground can do major damage to steel and concrete casing. This makes me hope carbon sequestration never takes off.
- fransje26 2y agoWhat could possibly go wrong... (And yes, their pilot test locations have been, indeed, leaking..)
- rekabis 2y agoCaPiTaLiSm WiLl InNoVaTe!!!1!