11 ms·
Tomorrow people: For a century, it felt like telepathy was around the corner
- 29athrowaway 2y agoTelepathy is around the corner, with Neuralink it will be possible somehow.
- thuuuomas 2y agoYou first
- swayvil 2y agoWhat will we exchange? Language? Memories? Streams of sensory stuff? Because language is, in the big picture, very very small. And if we were going to exchange memories etc, we might have to encode it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- JumpCrisscross 2y ago> language is, in the big picture, very very small You may enjoy Ted Chiang's "The Truth of Fact, the Truth of Feeling" [1][2]. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20140222103103/http://subterraneanpress.com/magazine/fall_2013/the_truth_of_fact_the_truth_of_feeling_by_ted_chiang https://web.archive.org/web/20140222103103/http://subterrane... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Truth_of_Fact,_the_Truth_of_Feeling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Truth_of_Fact,_the_Truth_o...
- 29athrowaway 2y agoBetter than talking and being overheard. Also, with telepathy you could have any voice of your choice, with any sound effects.
- TheRoque 2y agoYeah, you could buy the Morgan Freeman voice pack for only 20$
- mistermann 2y agoInsightful question...unless something emergent came along with Neuralink for free, we have a hard problem of how to figure out how to use the new bandwidth. And both ends need to be able to encode and decode, and understand the result, with multiple levels of error handling. An exception: high resolution transmission of emotions could be revolutionary.
- swayvil 2y agoIt would change the art world for sure. Why craft emotionally evocative images or sounds when you can deliver it directly?
- drewcoo 2y agoOdors. Smellepethy. The future William Castle saw for us. Um . . . sniffed for us.
- labster 2y agoIn just 20 years, we’ll have fusion-powered telepathy.
- passwordoops 2y ago<snark> In space in the metaverse on the blockchain! </snark>
- ozim 2y agoWell I can app/sms my GF in other room without yelling already. The same with sending her notes on situation in a crowded room or on a bus/train without strangers knowing. I feel like I have it covered without implanting stuff in my head.
- JohnMakin 2y agoNo it isn't. We have absolutely no way to transmit messages to the brain yet, we've barely only been able to go brain -> computer interface so far. The other way around we don't even know how to do.
- criddell 2y agoWould cochlear implants qualify as transmitting to the brain?
- nemomarx 2y agoIn the same sense that a Bluetooth headset is transmitting information to the brain? I assume people mean without going through one of the existing senses, although I wonder if it would really feel like telepathy. If you suddenly had a sense for magnetism would that just feel like a new addition to your ordinary senses, for instance?
- vdqtp3 2y agohttps://www.theverge.com/2017/7/21/15999544/biohacking-finger-magnet-human-augmentation-loss https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/21/15999544/biohacking-finge...
- swayvil 2y agoI think that we, as a society, are really attached to language and convention. And telepathy is incompatible with that. So any evidence or argument for telepathy is voided. There is a mountain of anecdote, however.
- lxgr 2y agoAll of which can be adequately be explained for with unexpected physical nonverbal communication channels, confirmation bias and various other cognitive biases, and none of which reproducible in a methodologically correct setting, despite decades of trying.
- swayvil 2y ago"Adequate explanation" is a tool of relatively small scope, dependent upon the judgment of individuals, which is of relatively great scope. If many individuals judge it "telepathy" then that carries weight. Let's not put the cart before the horse.
- lxgr 2y ago> If many individuals judge it "telepathy" then that carries weight. No, science is not a trial by popular vote. What carries weight are models, theories, experiments, and falsification. This can include subjective reports, but the human mind, as brilliant as it can be, is also a never-ending source of biases and (conscious or unconscious) deception, which all need to be corrected for via proper experimental setup.
- wumbo 2y agofriends! let us have it both ways! Humans have telepathy and cognitive biases!
- RobotToaster 2y agoWhat if collective cognitive biases are the result of telepathy?
- throwanem 2y agoIf we're going to talk about telepathy and all mean the same thing by it, we need a rigorous definition of the term. Does anyone have one? If asked to guess, I'd start with "the communication of meaning among humans in the absence of signification", but I am unstudied in the field and have no idea what prior art exists. edit: I did say "rigorous". Please cite your sources, and note that while I am admittedly guessing above, I'm borrowing the terms "meaning" and "signification" from the jargon of semiotics in order to do so; considering the subject matter, to raid a sort of philosophical "fringe science" for terminology seemed apropos.
- Waterluvian 2y agoTransfer of information not using the existing senses.
- loceng 2y agoIs intuition a sense - or is that potentially some people excelling at reading physical cues that 99.999999% of people can't see or relate to what someone is then likely thinking?
- Waterluvian 2y agoIntuition isn’t a sense. There’s no data being measured. Intuition is a processing and synthesizing of past and sometimes presently sensed data into some meaning. When I understand “sense” in this context I’m understanding “sensor.” A sensor is measuring something. I think the closest I can get to telepathy without it being a completely wild paradigm shift in understanding is if we could implant technology directly into our brains, thus introducing new sensors.
- loceng 2y agoThere are "famous" people on YouTube who seem very telepathic-psychic - but I suppose people would really only become a believer if they have an anecdotal experience themselves that defies all odds.
- snowwrestler 2y agoGrowing up I read a lot of “golden age” science fiction, and I remember realizing how many classic “hard” sci-fi novels and short stories feature super mental powers like telepathy, precognition, teleportation, etc. - Asimov’s Foundation series - Herbert’s Dune series - Larry Niven’s Known Space stories - Heinlein’s Stranger from a Strange Land - Alfred Bester’s Demolished Man and Tiger Tiger - Clarke’s Childhood’s End I’m sure there are more that I forgot to mention. It really did seem to be a pervasive expectation that the mind was the next frontier for seemingly magical scientific advancements. But it never panned out with actual results, and mental powers faded from hard sci-fi stories.
- Apocryphon 2y agoI also noticed that Starship Troopers threw in hypnosis among its many military technologies, for some reason, which feels like a related sci-fi concept. I don't think teleportation counts. Feels like either Star Trek-type super-science or outright mysticism.
- mwigdahl 2y agoStarship Troopers also had "special talents" -- "sensers" capable of detecting and mapping Bug tunnels underground, "memory men", "lucky men", and telepaths. Heinlein at least nods to the possibility that the sensers' abilities were the product of very powerful hearing, but telepathy would be tougher to explain that way.
- BarryMilo 2y agoI know it's not your main point, but I think most of us big sci-fi fans agree that "soft" vs "hard" sci-fi is a false dichotomy. Who knows what is and what will be possible? Just because the technology is wrong doesn't mean the idea is not interesting.
- shrimp_emoji 2y agoHard means it's kept within tasteful range of today's sense of technoplausibility. Usually it also implies that it grapples with the nitty gritty details to "earn" the tech. Hohmann transfers vs. brachistochrone trajectories omg squee https://projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/torchships.php https://projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/torchships.php
- spacecadet 2y agoWe have telepathy, any unspoken private message is as good imo.
- spacecadet 2y agolol down vote, please someone define telepathy... Telepathy is the purported vicarious transmission of information from one person's mind to another's without using any known human sensory channels or physical interaction. I mean come. on.
- airstrike 2y agodon't you use your eyes to read that private message?
- spacecadet 2y ago"as good" not a direct replacement*
- TeMPOraL 2y agoThe article mentions Star Trek and Vulcan mind melds, which continue to be an important element of the franchise today, but misses a more obvious case: there was a lot of ESP and telekinesis motifs in the Original Series in the 60s, that were severely toned down or outright abandoned by the 90s. For example, you don't hear much about Gary Mitchel anymore, except for that one episode of Lower Decks. Also, I think a lot of sci-fi shows had direct ESP references before mid-90s, then the trope suddenly died out.
- 7thaccount 2y agoTNG has several species like the Q that have evolved to godlike abilities and there are episodes where a humanoid undergoes the final stage of physical evolution and then ascends to a higher plane of existence (becomes something like the Q). Star Trek Picard (relatively new show) had a lot about exploring internal conflict and I think even in TNG one of the final episodes has Q tell Picard that the final frontier is internal and doesn't involve mapping out stellar nebulae. Other shows like Stargate also have the concept of "ascension" as a pivotal plot point of many episodes. Farscape covers this as well in several episodes. Things like mind melds and mind reading are pretty common in these shows once someone ascends. There is a lot of "woo" in science fiction as it is kind of hard to still believe in gross limitations for us over a cosmic scale of thousands of millions of years. Assuming we don't die out, I'd believe our ultimate potential is unfathomable to us now.
- jerf 2y agoThere is definitely a difference between "these beings have become so advanced as to do things we would believe impossible like reading state directly out of our brains" and "for vague and in fact aggressively unspecified reasons this critter can read the 'minds' of those around them". When people pontificate about "brain uploading" they are certainly speaking of some physical process that does what is now currently impossible, but may not be impossible forever. But perhaps the more relevant objection is that episodic television can't really be read for more than the vaguest of philosophical content across their wholes. One episode can be written by an ardent materialist and the next by a New Age guru writing a New Age story wrapped in science terminology, and as long as they do a good enough job in general writing ability and following the series bible for consistency, it might take a lot of analysis to notice. Such series aren't so much statements themselves as platforms.
- trhway 2y agoI think empathy is a brain feature/circuitry which would be a foundation for anything resembling telepathy, and our societal development took us into the opposite direction of suppressing empathy, and thus further from any chance of telepathy/etc. Instead we’ll ultimately have AI guessing/calculating our thoughts better than any telepathy.
- detourdog 2y agoI agree, I also think empathy provides the clairvoyance capabilities of the force.
- lawrenceyan 2y agoYou have to contextualize it with the historical background. The Cold War was ongoing and there was an arms race in research occurring between the Soviet Union and the United States with regards to directed energy weapons and influence/control of the mind.
- imglorp 2y agoUltimately, the mind control vision came true far beyond those cold warriors' dreams. The answer wasn't chemical or subliminal or mind-ray like they thought, but tailored, addictive, adrenaline jolts of a/b tested, emotional, persusive jolts, infinitely scrolled in a social proof setting. And the victims seek it out, you don't have to force it on them.
- lawrenceyan 2y agoI think you would be surprised as to how far the research has gotten. But I get what you mean with social media / the modern internet. Probably the most direct way you can get without actual modulation of neurons.
- resource_waste 2y agoPlato and many philosophers have a special disdain for poets(artists). Where they urge people to live among reality, artists paint a picture that can never be possible. There are ideas like: "Who knows what war looks like, a soldier? Or an artist? We get false ideas of war, and it corrupts our minds. Let us not pretend that the brain can fully separate our fiction media from what we are told is 'close enough' to real to be entertaining. I worry most when it comes to expectations of interpersonal relationships. What poison is happening to the population when they read/watch unrealistic romances?
- pnut 2y agoA soldier telling a story from experience is a soldier artist. If Plato's point is that knowledge can only be derived through direct experience, then one must endure war to know what war looks like. If there is any value to be derived from the experiences of others, either through descriptions or related empathetic resonances, then those are dependent on communication and storytelling, and now we're in the realm of being effective at putting your reality into another's mind, and that is art. The authority or accuracy of your message doesn't negate that fact, and is entirely down to the individual in the receiving end in any case. Funny to hear a philosopher, whose entire domain is abstract thought and whose power and relationship to the world is through the art of communication, be so petty. Maybe that quote has more context?
- resource_waste 2y ago>If Plato's point is that knowledge can only be derived through direct experience Its not. Its that poets corrupt.
- glonq 2y agoI stopped listening to him years ago because he became too unsufferable, but I remember Joe Rogan on his podcast frequently asserting that telepathy or some kind of mind-to-mind communication was always just a few years away...
- Animats 2y agoBetween smartphones and drones, everybody is now way ahead of what telepathy in SF was supposed to be able to do.
- ErigmolCt 2y agoIndeed, modern technology surpassed some of the capabilities that telepathy in science fiction was imagined to achieve. But still something is unattainable.
- mettamage 2y agoNeurallink will fix all of that Said in 75% jest and 25% all seriousness (if you have a long time horizon on it)
- jancsika 2y agoI mean, FAANG pissing people off at scale for clicks must be like the tutorial level in the telepathy game. Even minor telepathy plot points seem miles ahead of that: didn't Spock's half-brother take over the entire spaceship by healing everyone's trauma[1]? 1: except for Kirk (of course :)
- devmor 2y agoThe obsession with telepathy via fiction is probably a large part of why people buy into Neuralink, despite it not actually doing anything new (other than eschewing ethical standards). Musk's invasive BCI is so far, slightly less technically impressive than hobby toys you can build with exterior electrodes and nowhere near as impressive as the research from BrainGate that it builds off of. It's baffling why anyone grounded in reality would lend credence to applying his "startup culture" approach to this field especially.
- ctoth 2y agoAfter reading her book on Nuclear War, I read Annie Jacobsen's Phenomena: The Secret History of the U.S. Government's Investigations into Extrasensory Perception and Psychokinesis. I recommend it. I'm not sure what was going on with Pat Price, but those are some damn weird stories. The incident with the Church specifically was particularly interesting. > In a separate outbounder-beacon experiment with Price, a more dramatic physiological event occurred. Green was in the car with an experimenter from SRI. They had opened their sealed envelope and were headed to the target when, “ten minutes into our drive, I said stop the car,” Green recalls. After his earlier experience with Uri Geller remotely viewing a page from one of the medical books in his CIA office, Green intended to devise a fail-safe remote-viewing test. This was it. The experimenter driving the car insisted that he wasn’t allowed to deviate from protocol. Green told him, “I’m the contract monitor, and I say stop the car.” So the experimenter stopped. “But I’m supposed to drive to the target,” he said. > Green instructed the driver to back up. “I said, I want you to go to that church back there,” pointing to a small Episcopal church beside the road. The driver did as Green asked and pulled into the church parking lot. Green checked his watch and waited until the prearranged time. Then he got out of the car. “I crunched across the gravel and into an arbor,” Green recalls. “I caught my foot on something and nearly tripped. I walked down to the sacristy,” the room where the vestments were kept. “I opened a window. I turned around, walked into the nave, walked down the right-hand aisle. Stopped and stared at a beautiful rose window over the altar.” In this moment in the church, he says, he was reminded of his time in seminary school and the strange notion of how different his life might have been had he become a clergyman instead of joining the CIA. Green felt a wave of emotion and decided to pray. “I knelt down, said a prayer. There was this beautiful baptismal font in front of me. I leaned over and looked into it. Then I was done. I crunched across the gravel, went back to the car.” The two experimenters headed back to SRI. > “Back at the lab, we went into the Faraday cage where the remote viewer [Price] had been [the entire time]. He was having a cardiac event,” Green recalls. “At minimum he was having an angina attack, and possibly he was having an MI [myocardial infarction],” more commonly known as a heart attack. After Price’s heart rate returned to normal, he turned to Green and said that that was the worst experiment he had ever done. Green recalls Price telling him, “It just made me so sick. You walked down an arbor. You almost tripped. You went into the most terrible building I’ve ever seen in my life. I saw you walk down an aisle and crumple to your knees. I began to worry about you. I saw you lean over and vomit into an octagonal basin. I began to feel nauseated. I got chest pains.”
- o_nate 2y agoAlan Turing's paper in which he first lays out the idea of the Turing Test for AI is surprisingly prescient in many particulars. But one thing that stands out is when he is considering various arguments for why computers might not be able to pass the Turing Test, he considers the objection that humans will be able to display some telepathic abilities that computers won't as one of the strongest counter-arguments. He considers it nearly a given that these abilities exist.
- nullc 2y agoI wonder if people who are less adept at non-verbal communication are more prone to believe that telepathy exists?
- spyridonas 2y agoI remember growing up I watched a documentary on telekinesis. It concluded that people with high amounts of iron on their blood could move items from distance
- mcswell 2y agoI guess they have magnetic personalities.
- prewett 2y agoGiven the 50% divorce rates, we don't seem to be able to handle our most intimate relationships right now. Being able to access people's naked thoughts sounds like a disaster. Both the perceiver and the thinker are going to need to be pretty saintly for this to be a positive experience. The relatively restrained Babylon 5 scenario seems to be on the pretty good side, and that seemed pretty dark.
- wsintra2022 2y agoMaybe the rate is 50% precisely because of ESP/etc People can’t turn the other persons disappointed thoughts off so they argue.
- petercooper 2y agoBeing able to access people's naked thoughts sounds like a disaster. That's the part of it I can't quite get a grip on. If we end up with systems that perform "telepathy", what do they actually pick up? The active part of the mind that filters and decides (the "ego" if you will) or all the random noise and nonsense that's in there but not really willed or deliberate? If all the random thoughts and impulses, critical voices, and what not were tapped into, a lot of people would be in huge trouble quickly, and not necessarily of their own volition.
- robbyiq999 2y agoThe premise seems pretty silly, as you’d expect some kind of jumping off point where remote mental telepathy could be possible. But, there is absolutely none. So it’s strange to think that “scientists” were testing for something completely made up and unobserved.
- dreamcompiler 2y agoFunny there was no mention of why this societal obsession mostly faded away in the 1980s and 1990s: Every single experiment into tele-whatever and psychic whichever under suitably controlled conditions revealed no result or outright fraud. No exceptions. And the person responsible for defining suitably controlled conditions was magician James Randi. As a magician he recognized the tricks that con artists like Uri Geller were using. The scientists of that era like Puthoff and Targ had no understanding of perception hacking (which is what stage magicians do) so they were easily fooled by con artists who did know perception hacking. James Randi put a stop to all that with several investigations of his own that made public fools of such scientists, and he funded a 1 million dollar prize for anyone who could prove they had psychic abilities under controlled conditions. The prize was never claimed. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Randi https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Randi
- Izkata 2y agoThe application process for that prize is always brushed under the rug, and in general it doesn't surprise me no one has won it. The criteria set you up for failure, for example demanding a far higher success rate than the psychic claims themselves. Sometimes to the point where they'd have to go through months of continuous testing, then be disqualified by a single off day.
- LawrenceKerr 2y agoJames Randi was notoriously biased, stubborn, and dismissive of any evidence contrary towards his views. His Million Dollar Challenge has been criticized for its lack of transparency and fairness. The challenge was not conducted under the auspices of an impartial third party. Instead, only Randi himself and his organization set the conditions and judged the outcomes. This raises questions about bias, as Randi had a vested interest in maintaining his stance that psi phenomena do not exist. Despite the fact that several participants in the Stargate Project, such as remote viewer Ingo Swann, produced results that were statistically significant under controlled conditions, Randi dismissed these findings outright. He did not engage with the data or attempt to replicate the experiments. Instead, he simply declared that because psi phenomena _cannot exist according to his understanding of the laws of physics_, any positive results must be due to fraud or error. Furthermore, Randi's challenge required 100% success rate for claimants to win the prize. In any scientific experiment, such a requirement is unreasonable as it does not account for statistical variance. Even established scientific phenomena cannot always be demonstrated with 100% accuracy due to various factors such as measurement errors or environmental influences. Lastly, the absence of evidence is not evidence of absence. The fact that no one claimed Randi's prize does not conclusively prove that psi phenomena do not exist. It could simply mean that the conditions set for the challenge were too stringent or biased. Or... the sheep-goat effect really does exist, and the attitude & beliefs of the experimenter affect the result.
- illuminant 2y ago[flagged]
- iaaan 2y agoDo you experience this personally?
- illuminant 2y agoYes, I have actively and adamantly fought against American Thought Control for fifteen years. I was "recruited" (press ganged,) discovering their lawlessness and lies for myself. All of the dark conspiratorial things you think might be happening but cannot accept are possible in our modern world (America) are happening, only the story (conventional narrative) is that of a society that cannot know or accept the true circumstance (voices in our heads sacrifice of the innocent and lawful? Crazy talk! Someone would do something!) I hope to publish an incendiary account, though that time may be long from now. Until such a time, I struggle to be your undeceiver.
- heyitsguay 2y agoAt first i thought this was going to be about social media influencers and disinformation. But no, just schizophrenia. You should talk to a professional! Share your thoughts with them in a safe and trusting place.
- illuminant 2y agoAmazing that you can blow something so significant off so easily. This is literally the greatest crisis of our age (underlying nearly every other great crisis of our age.) while at the same time the most profound revelation of our psycho-spiritual humanity (down right magical, if you understand the implication of "worlds within worlds".) While schizophrenia is certainly real (chemical imbalances triggering all manner of internal confusion), I speak of a truth that many also live with, for which you do no favor by your dismissal. The signs are there and have always been there throughout history. Obviously without "inside knowledge" the layperson is hopelessly caught in this incomprehensible and isolating nightmare. This truth can certainly trigger the crazy in anyone. For the bold few with insight, this is literally the precipice of life and humanity (our consciousness is spiritual technology.) We are not alone in our own minds!