14 ms·
With congestion pricing stop, New York City enters new era of economic gridlock
- rayiner 2y agoCongestion pricing is a no-brainer for the environment and urbanism alike, and we can’t even make it happen in the country’s biggest city. It’s such an uphill battle to get any buy-in from the voting public. Even in such a politically homogenous city like New York.
- woodruffw 2y agoThe law in question is a New York State law, not a NYC one. The state is much less politically homogeneous than the city is, and Hochul's (tepid) argument for suspending the law is in part based on this political dynamic. (The entire situation is a pathetically self-inflicted one: the MTA is a state entity instead of a city one, meaning that the city's single most important mode of transportation is perpetually shackled to the state's political slapfights.)
- ikjasdlk2234 2y agoThere is a similar issue playing out in Boston too, where the MBTA, the public transit authority that operates the busses and trains predominately in the Boston metro, is a state entity.
- rayiner 2y agoIsn’t the MTA a state-level agency so it can access state-level tax resources? While in recent years the city has become rich, in the 1960s-1990s the city was in dire financial straights. The city’s transit system was unified under the MTA in 1968, and in 1975 the city nearly had to declare bankruptcy.
- woodruffw 2y agoThat’s not the reason I’ve heard. You’re right that it was originally handed over because of the city’s bankruptcy (which did actually happen, not just nearly), but the underlying reason wasn’t tax revenues: it was because the state wanted a bargaining chip for future negotiations, and unifying NYCT with the rest of the nascent MTA was an ideal one. (To my knowledge, the MTA is not significantly availed of the general state budget. They get some money from it, but not disproportionate to the amount their service base puts in via transit taxes.)
- EasyMark 2y agoThat said, I feel it should be left to the people in the district (Manhattan) that have to live with it day in and day out. It should be a direct vote and not some politician’s call.
- FredPret 2y agoI think the Swiss have a system like this. Referendums galore
- timr 2y agoAs someone who lives in New York and doesn't own a car (and hasn't for almost two decades), this was such a poorly thought out plan that I hope it never comes back. It was little more than a backdoor tax on all city residents, disguised as urbanism. Good riddance. (FWIW, I even support more funding for the MTA, within reason, but this wasn't the way to do it.)
- BowBun 2y agoAs someone living here, I'll share my sentiment - millions of dollars and years of time spent to come up with a plan, however unpopular. Hochul did not signal she would do this during all that time. And right near the finish line, boom, she pulls the rug out. It's just embarassing the level of dysfunction in planning any major projects in this city. It kills all hope that our public transit can be brought into the modern era, honestly.
- acdha 2y agoYeah, she was talking accurately about the benefits until very recently. The complete reversal using transparently-untrue claims should cost her the governorship since it also means nobody can trust her on anything.
- woodruffw 2y agoMaybe it's wishful thinking, but I think it will: NY's Democratic governors have historically received a "default" vote from the city's voters (especially when the governor themselves is from the city), and this will challenge that default. Hochul also hasn't helped herself by spending a bunch of state money (i.e. city money, since the city contributes disproportionately to the state budget) on her own local, i.e. Buffalo, pork-barrel topics[1]. [1]: https://hellgatenyc.com/the-buffalo-bills-just-need-another-billion-dollars https://hellgatenyc.com/the-buffalo-bills-just-need-another-...
- woodruffw 2y agoOne of the more ridiculous things about the chaos Hochul has wrought over the last 72 hours is that it isn't remotely clear that she can even order the suspension of congestion pricing like this: it's the law of the land in New York, one she already signed, passed by our legislative branch, funded by taxes, and administrated solely by an independent public corporation (the MTA) that she has only minority authority over. It's the equivalent of a president signing a bill and then attempting to post-facto veto it. It's been very frustrating to see so little news (both local and national) pick up on this basic reality: Hochul is acting far beyond her constitutional powers as the governor, and the legislative branch has so far responded only tepidly (by refusing to pass her last-minute tax alternative).
- bayareabadboy 2y agoThis is the core issue. Unchecked executive overreach, by politicians of both parties at the federal and state level, will end terribly for the republic. But no one cares if it serves their political interests.
- highcountess 2y agoI argue that it has already ended poorly for the republic since the republic effectively no longer actually exists and what does exist is a fraudulent and inherently illegitimate government based on its own words and actions. The Constitution that created the federal republic is essentially an agreement, a form of contract. It has been violated to every degree and in every imaginable way possible that the only thing holding any of this together is that people still have not realize that they still trust in a lie. I get indications that there is possibly a kind of realization starting to work its way through the country, where people are starting to realize just that … that they’ve been had, defrauded, conned, lied to, deceived, stolen from, plundered, and abused. We shall see how deep the cracks go once an economic event stresses the foundation. I’m agnostic on which way it will go or if the crack will cause the foundation to crack catastrophically. I could make arguments either way.
- ip26 2y agoPossibly a natural consequence of gridlocked legislature or judiciary. If only the executive branch can get anything done, allowing overreach is the only way for government to continue functioning. That doesn't mean it's good, but suggests directions for solutions.
- cglan 2y agoPopular or not, all this has taught me is that NYC, and with that most of America has no vision for any future. If after 10 years and millions in setup just to get congestion pricing in place, it falls thru because of the whims of a governor there’s just no hope for any more difficult capital projects. Realistically, we’re never going to see any ambitious projects in my life time and it’s sad to see
- returningfory2 2y agoThe problem is not NYC though. I think if NYC was left to its own devises its government could be much more visionary. The problem is that so much of the control of NYC lies with state-level Democrats who are structurally incentived to prioritize the suburbs over the city because the suburbs are more likely to vote Republican in various races. This is exactly what happened here. Hochul -- working with the federal House minority leader Hakeem Jeffries -- paused congestion pricing to make it easier to win House seats in the suburbs. If they lose support in the city they don't care because the city districts are so safe.
- PaulHoule 2y agoI think also you will see Democrats even in blue states back off on any unpopular policies so it can’t be used as ammunition against Biden as they see a Trump victory as that catastrophic.
- noobermin 2y agoJust like in 2016, republicans will never choose diet-coke over coke. The appealing to republican voter strategy has never worked when they can just vote for a republican. Not that it matters for the political consultant class, they can get higher fees the more mailers they can send out when they're losing talking about how the republicans are ruining America. Don't take democratic politicians at their word, they only care about keeping their money flowing into their coffers.
- BeFlatXIII 2y agoThese aren't core Republicans; they're the rare breed of never-Trumpers. People want to believe they don't exist, and they're mostly right: they pretty much only exist in suburbs surrounding Dem strongholds and in Utah. It may not be a viable national strategy (though they're probably to thank for Biden winning in 2020), but they definitely could flip local & state races, especially if the core Republicans went MAGA during the primary.
- wtp1saac 2y ago‘Rep. Gottheimer hopes this is the end of the road for congestion pricing, and as far as it coming back after the upcoming elections are decided, “I don’t think so,” he said. “We got it done. ... indefinite pause, the word indefinite is key here,” he said.’ what a joke of a statement; then none of you mean to pause it, you meant to kill it. if you’re going to ruin what little progress this damn country can make at urbanism in its most urban city, at least wear your mockery and ruination on your sleeve proudly, rather than weasel out of it with a bullshit “pause.” garbage politicians.
- carterschonwald 2y agoHochul keeps on messing with every nyc / nys initiative I get excited about.
- hersko 2y agoDo you have a car?
- rickydroll 2y agoAn interesting write-up on what went wrong the the NYC congestion charge and better alternatives. https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2024/06/05/new-york-governor-kills-congestion-pricing-heres-how-to-do-it-better/ https://www.forbes.com/sites/bradtempleton/2024/06/05/new-yo...
- Reason077 2y agoNot a good article. The author understands the problem, but the "alternatives" offered are much more complex and difficult to administer than the simple, practical, proven solution of a congestion charge.
- ars 2y agoI think this would have been more likely to be politically viable if the credit for entering via a tunnel or bridge was dramatically increased, after all a bridge or tunnel toll is already a form of congestion pricing. Double charging is just a money grab rather than a form of congestion pricing. They should have also given a credit for exiting immediately and not staying in the city, i.e. transiting through the city. This would have made New Jersey considerably more likely to be in support. Without both of those things New Jersey has it right: everyone would just travel through New Jersey to avoid that part of Manhattan when they're just trying to get through Manhattan.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoShifting traffic to jersey is a good thing because theres more road infrastructure there than in manhattan
- ars 2y agoIf that was the goal (was it? I have not seen anyone say something like that) but if it was, then they should share the money too. Manhattan can't take all the money and shift all the expenses to New Jersey.
- woodruffw 2y agoIt's NY State, not Manhattan. Neither NYC nor any individual borough "sees" any of the money from congestion pricing; it's handled at the state level. But for the state, certainly they can: it's state roads and state transit infrastructure, maintained and paid for by the state. NY didn't tell NJ to kneecap NJT's budget[1], or to develop car-dependent cities and suburbs. [1]: https://www.nj.com/news/2024/04/nj-transit-study-targets-600m-in-budget-cuts-expansion-and-reform.html https://www.nj.com/news/2024/04/nj-transit-study-targets-600...
- leetnewb 2y agoNY State collects billions of tax dollars every year from NJ residents that work in New York. Every mass transit NJ commuter to NYC is subsidized by NJ and subsidizes the NYS budget. That structural dynamic, in effect, kneecaps NJ and by virtue NJT's budget.
- autodiecomment 2y ago[flagged]
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- bastard_op 2y agoWhat no one really seems to talk about that I can find is just how the money flows through NYC and then to TransCore, the company that is running the service. Most of these are some sort of profit sharing arrangement, usually with most of the fee going to the provider vs the local government. This is almost always some sort of shady friend of a friend deal that makes the only real winner the service provider, in this case TransCore, so it would be interesting to trace the money through the deal to see just what the real motivation and reality is of this. Now particularly that it's turning into a circus, who pays the company running it now that it's installed and NOT being used and no profit to be had? It was already stated that NYC wanted tracking of cars even without the congestion fees, and thus tracking the people in or around them, so likely the real reason they're there. Since the local law enforcement cannot effectively police the city, this is meant to do something, hopefully anything to help, but with most of the crime originating from undocumented migrants at this point, the only persons to be punished will be real citizens. Funny thing, in the UK they are trying this as their ULEZ plan, and people took to this by chopping down the cameras installed on the side of the road to the point they've disabled effectively more than 10% of them. The city of course is trying to find the "vigilantes" doing this, but mean time they are deploying vans equipped with cameras and readers in their place to deter vandalism. The "blade runners" as they're called have now taken to following them around and blocking them with cars, objects, or otherwise still disabling them with spray paint and other means however to negate their efficacy. Sadly the NYC cameras are mounted in such a way to make this more difficult to do, but I'm certain where there's a will, there's a way.
- readthenotes1 2y ago[flagged]
- BowBun 2y agoCan you clarify what you mean? This sounds extremely untrue. The tax was passed as part of the whole package, and then the tax was repealed by congress while Trump was in office.
- ceejayoz 2y agoIt was delayed by a Republican congress in 2015 as part of a budget deal: https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/cadillac-tax-and-two-other-aca-taxes-part-of-budget-deal-on-hill/2015/12/16/e2b01ff8-a365-11e5-ad3f-991ce3374e23_story.html https://www.washingtonpost.com/national/health-science/cadil... It was then canceled entirely in 2019 under Trump's watch. https://www.wsj.com/articles/finance-chiefs-relieved-after-repeal-of-cadillac-tax-11577137387 https://www.wsj.com/articles/finance-chiefs-relieved-after-r...
- dang 2y agoRelated. Others? NYC Congestion Pricing Delayed Indefinitely by Governor Kathy Hochul - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40587485 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40587485 - June 2024 (16 comments) MTA board votes to approve new $15 toll to drive into Manhattan - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39841703 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39841703 - March 2024 (831 comments) The new toll to drive into Manhattan won't change much by itself - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37475743 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=37475743 - Sept 2023 (87 comments) New York City will charge drivers going downtown - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36270597 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36270597 - June 2023 (671 comments)
- Reason077 2y agoLondon has had this sort of congestion pricing for years. £15/day, about USD $19. Exemption for zero-emission vehicles, but that will end from 2026. As a London resident I'd say it only has benefits: frees up road space for those vehicles that really need it. Makes walking and cycling safer and more pleasant. Shifts some journeys to public transport. Generates revenue that gets reinvested in transport projects.
- vosper 2y agoDoes reduced congestion not also make it much healthier to walk/live/work close to busy roads? We know that combustion and tire pollution causes a number of health issues.
- Reason077 2y agoCertainly, London's air has gotten noticeably cleaner in recent years. Although I suspect most of this gain is from incentivising zero-emission vehicles through the congestion charge exemption and also the ULEZ ultra-low emission zone (an additional charge on older dirty vehicles), not just from reducing traffic volumes.
- bko 2y agoPerson who doesn't pay a tax, actually likes the tax. In other news: water is wet. In all seriousness, doesn't this also impact cab prices? How much is a typical fare for 15min ride in central London?
- Reason077 2y ago> "doesn't this also impact cab prices?" Not directly, because most London taxis and Ubers are electric and thus exempt from the congestion charge. This exemption will end by 2026, but even then we're talking about £15 spread between many fares over the day.
- timr 2y ago> London has had this sort of congestion pricing for years. £15/day, about USD $19. Exemption for zero-emission vehicles, but that will end from 2026. City of London has had it. It's an absolutely trivial area when compared to what is proposed in Manhattan, where literally half of the island -- and almost every major entry/exit point to the island -- is included in the "congestion area". London's congestion area is something akin to lower Manhattan south of Wall St., by proportion of land and overall impact. It's completely disingenuous that supporters of this plan keep confusing the tiny London congestion area with the entirety of London. You can see the actual proportion on the maps on these pages: London's zone: https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/congestion-charge/congestion-charge-zone https://tfl.gov.uk/modes/driving/congestion-charge/congestio... NYC's zone: https://www.fox5ny.com/news/nyc-congestion-pricing-map-exemptions-start-date https://www.fox5ny.com/news/nyc-congestion-pricing-map-exemp...
- neilv 2y agoThis congestion pricing seems to partly be a handout to the wealthy: for a cost that's negligible to them, they get more use of the public streets, due to fewer poors in the way.
- elbasti 2y agoNo congestion charge seems to be partly a handout to the wealthy: for a cost that's negligible to them, they get to pollute _public_ streets.
- BHSPitMonkey 2y agoYou're implying that the main/only "use" of public streets is to fill them up with car traffic. Fewer cars on the streets means they can be better leveraged by buses, cyclists, and pedestrians, which is how it should be in a place like Manhattan.
- standardUser 2y agoYou say it like they'll be cruising down empty double-wide lanes while waving to the grateful peasants. In reality, the time commuters cut off their driving time will probably be measured in single digit minutes, while the benefits to the city and the millions of us who live here will be huge.
- neilv 2y ago> while the benefits to the city and the millions of us who live here will be huge. OK, so also preclude private vehicles of the wealthy, to remove more congestion. If you're talking about the revenue, then increase taxes on the wealthy (without selling them preferred use of public streets).
- kelnos 2y agoI'm not against congestion pricing per se, but aren't these sorts of policies regressive? White-collar workers (with higher-paying jobs) are more likely to have employers that will pay these costs for their employees, so I would expect the costs to be borne directly mostly by middle- and lower-income workers. (Assuming lower-income workers could even afford the bridge/tunnel tolls plus parking costs in the first place...)
- standardUser 2y agoI think the idea is that most lower-income and many middle-income workers are already taking transit, so the impact is primarily on higher-income commuters. I'd only consider it regressive if a lot of middle-income commuters were forced to pay a fee because transit options from their home are either non-existent or take too long. That's a rare situation in NY but is probably pretty common in other US metros. There's also usually various exemptions to these kinds of laws, such as in this case... "Low-income drivers who earn less than $50,000 a year can apply to pay half the price on the daytime toll, but only after the first 10 trips in a month."
- bluGill 2y agoLower income includes various 'handman' type services which need their truck of tools and supplies with them. Some are poorly paid.
- noitpmeder 2y agoHow many of these are driving through NYC on a daily basis?
- bluGill 2y agoProbably more than you would guess. They tend to work where they can and buildings need a lot of work. Some of it (plumbing) is more skilled than others.
- matrix87 2y agoDon't forget that Hochul also neutered the right to repair bill before signing it into law [0]. She also vetoed the non-compete bill [1] and asked for it to be watered down It's a shame that the GOP candidate she competed against was so unelectable, it just makes it easier for the other party to sink to the same shitty level. Good to see that news outlets aren't trying to shield her, hopefully this term is the end of her political career [0] https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/29/23530733/right-to-repair-law-new-york-tech-hochul-oems-parts https://www.theverge.com/2022/12/29/23530733/right-to-repair... [1] https://ogletree.com/insights-resources/blog-posts/new-york-governor-vetoes-noncompete-ban-bill/ https://ogletree.com/insights-resources/blog-posts/new-york-...
- objektif 2y agoAs much as I like the idea this was nothing but a money grab by MTA. So what happens to the cars of rich Manhattanites? They can run their cars up and down park ave freely once the congestion pricing is in effect? Why do I have to pay so they can fund their subway system?
- EasyMark 2y agoI would say it’s best to let the voters affected vote for what they want, but they must also live with the consequences, and they don’t have much choice. Then if it’s awful they can reconsider, that’s why democracy works, rather than than all these technocrats telling us what is best for us; give us your arguments technocrats, we will decide what we do with our lives.
- kevin_thibedeau 2y agoNo problem. Since we can back out of deals at the last second, just divert the $850M going to a billionaire's entertainment complex he was too poor to build on his own.
- causality0 2y agoAs a car lover, I don't understand the attachment to cars in big cities. Driving in them, with or without admission prices, is an utterly miserable experience. Why would you want to take an hour to go five miles while surrounded by screaming noise and horns and the constant threat of hitting a pedestrian or another car? It sucks out of control. I don't see the point in allowing personal vehicles to operate in that motorist's hellscape at all. You want to live in a human termite mound, you don't get to drive an apartment with wheels around. You wanna drive your car to work, live and work where it makes sense.
- AdrianB1 2y agoNot a car fan, but I use one from time to time: - grocery shopping every week requires a car - it takes me 1.5 hours to commute to work by subway, ~ 1 hour by car in a good day. When it's freezing outside and I have to walk 2 kilometers to the subway, I would prefer the car. When there are 38 degrees Celsius, I would prefer the car (also from the subway to the office is over .5 kilometers). Getting sweaty in the office is bad. Luckily I work from home most of the time or I take a motorcycle, much faster than a car and better most of the time (except when it's freezing) - driving the kids to school sometimes requires a car when the school is 2 km away and there is no direct public transportation in that direction (or you have to change 3 different bus lines) Work from home is not always and option and most of the time is not the employee's choice. All the greenwashing companies that require their employees in the office for work that does not require physical presence bear more guilt on pollution than their employees.
- throwaway290232 2y ago[dead]