4 ms·
Isn't that true of all diseases? What is the upside of being autistic? I don't think anyone who was somehow given the choice of autism or no autism at birth wo
by IshKebab 2y ago
Isn't that true of all diseases? What is the upside of being autistic?
I don't think anyone who was somehow given the choice of autism or no autism at birth would choose autism would they?
- hombre_fatal 2y agoI'm sure the parents of an autistic kid who's nonverbal at age 10 and punches himself in the face are comforted online when they hear about how discourse around autism downplays its advantages.
- IshKebab 2y agoI'm not sure what your point is. What are its advantages? I wasn't aware of any.
- wizzwizz4 2y agoVery few people are incapable of communication. Mutism is neither exclusively nor inherently autistic, and there are many other communication options available beyond voice (though they'd have to be made available to the child – that includes tools, where necessary, and training). Real-time spoken language is a complicated skill, and we shouldn't require that people master it before their needs are respected. Punching yourself in the face is a sign of unmet needs. Sadly, the usual response to something like that is to (1) restrain the person, then (2) not try to figure out those needs, much less address them. I don't make a habit of blaming caregivers, but if an autistic kid's punching themself in the face enough for it to count as a character trait, there have been significant failures at multiple levels. I'll repeat that. Punching yourself in the face is not an autistic trait. It's a caged lion trait. Put an allistic kid in the right (wrong) situation, and they'll do the same.
- kuschku 2y agoI was that kid (though I'd hit my head against walls, not punch myself), and 20 years later I can tell you that autism does have its advantages. The suffering wasn't caused by my autism, but by society forcing me to behave in a way that was unnatural to me. Now that I'm living on my own, able to shape my environment according to my needs, I'm not suffering anymore. I'm genuinely happy, and I've got a successful career in software engineering. And every day I experience situations where my autism helps me understand logical issues much more deeply, care for order much more (refactoring is <3), and allows me to speak out when needed.
- fragmede 2y agoyou and I might have made it out the other side, but what about the ones who didn't?
- wizzwizz4 2y ago> What is the upside of being autistic? A strong sense of right and wrong, ability to use the outside lens on allistic societal structures, a rich internal experience, deep interests that actually give you something to talk about other than "the weather" and "the football" and gossip. These can all, of course, be framed as downsides: difficulty acting immorally / being a bystander, tendency to confuse others in what "should" be formulaic social interactions, Theory of Mind® Deficit™ (#NotPseudoscience), "specific and limited interests" / deficit in "small talk" ability.
- 0x1ceb00da 2y ago> a rich internal experience What does it even mean? You don't know what is going inside other people's head.
- wizzwizz4 2y agohttps://neuroclastic.com/exploring-the-inner-worlds-of-autistics/ https://neuroclastic.com/exploring-the-inner-worlds-of-autis... This link isn't what I was referring to, but it is a different thing that could be described as a "rich internal experience". What I was referring to is hard to explain, but it is apparent after a few hours of observation and conversation. I'm not saying allistics are in some sense lesser,¹ but you can tell, when talking to them, that most allistics just… don't have anything going on between the ears except future plans, the occasional daydream, and worries about their positions in status hierarchies – that is, when they're not actively engaged in a task. (When they are, they can have insights into what they're doing as deep as anyone else.) Most allistics need to explicitly meditate in order to pay attention to anything beyond their narrow internal subjective experience – and, not coincidentally, most allistics who sing the praises of "meditation" and "mindfulness" actually have no clue what it is or how it works or even how to do it. ¹: Yes, I am being deliberately provocative. No, this isn't an acceptable way to talk about entire categories of people, but in my experience, most allistics don't notice what they're doing to other people until somebody does it to them. The Golden Rule is, it seems, a heuristic that they have to deliberately and consciously employ, rather than something they have an intuitive understanding of: undeliberated-upon allistic morality is "do unto others what your neighbours are also doing unto those Others". So: if this wording upset you, that was deliberate. I'm still sorry for it.
- yareal 2y agoI'm medically diagnosed autistic. I struggle with a lot. But some upsides I've encountered: I tend to form stronger empathy and justice models, and commit to them wholly. This has allowed me to, for instance, work on improving access to benefits or healthcare for others while other people around me burn out. But I often fight way too long, and I get upset when people disagree. I often hyperfocus on projects I'm interested in and can produce a high level of output if given an interesting task. I enjoy counting, categorization, and organization tasks. Find all bugs that meet these rules, or, double check every unit test to check we're meeting coverage goals. Give me those tedious, repeatable, rules based gardening tasks and I'll churn through them all day every day. I believe I have a more systemic way of thinking than my peers, and while this does cause problems sometimes it also enables me to decompose systems more easily. I tend to maintain my cool under pressure or bullying. I simply do not notice nor care about emotionally loaded conversations. This causes problems often but also helps often, I can mediate with "we're here now, let's focus on how to improve". These, of course, are not the upsides of every autistic person. They are my upsides for me. Again, I am medically diagnosed and do require support to operate as an adult. My childhood was... not good. I do not want to say it's only upsides, but I do think for some autistic people there are things those people do consider up sides. Edit: if I could choose to not be autistic, even with the massive burden it has for me, I would choose to remain autistic and I would fight tooth and nail against anyone who tried to change me to remove it.
- dogtorwoof 2y agoWhat type of projects are you working on?
- yareal 2y agoTypically software engineering projects in a variety of domains, but mostly distributed systems.
- dogtorwoof 2y agoIf some of that involves you trying to fix healthcare, I salute you!
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]