5 ms·
Crooks threaten to leak 3B personal records 'stolen from background check firm'
- wdb 2y agoFascinating. I always request my details to be removed after completion so if my details are leaked they have a problem.
- Rygian 2y ago> according to the VX team: "The database DOES NOT contain information from individuals who use data opt-out services. Every person who used some sort of data opt-out service was not present." You're good, perhaps! The rest are opted-in for a data leak.
- r00fus 2y agoThis is a great example of why everything should be opt-in given the risk the individuals incur, not to mention the company. If society appropriately disincentivized data collection, we could even get to where companies don't see customer data as an asset instead more as a liability.
- xkcd-sucks 2y agoIt seems hard to disincentivize "data" in the same way it's hard to disincentivize "cocaine", e.g. to most companies "10 kg of cocaine" is a liability but there exist certain companies generally staffed by more unpleasant people who make it their business to treat it as an asset. Which means going to a different layer / structural solution maybe. How does the value of data go to zero?
- rusk 2y agoLots of companies ran a mile from data once GDPR dropped and it’s pretty much a standard threat model for new information architectures
- onemoresoop 2y agoNothing meaningful should stored due to data leaks liability, period. Now if data really leaks out users should be able to sue and get compensated. If companies are made to pay they'll clean up their act fast.
- fragmede 2y agoIt shouldn't be opt-either. It should be treated as radioactive waste that you don't want anywhere near you, your family, not in cold storage, not even in a mine in the Yucca mountains.
- e40 2y agoI briefly looked into these opt-out services. Quite expensive, they are. This is the first I've seen of them. Are they scams or worth the expense?
- adamomada 2y agoYour details just go into a different file, and you show as sus on the next background check.
- londons_explore 2y agoThis is why I don't use those privacy services. An awful lot of companies use background checks as a decider on if they are going to offer you service, or to give discounts to low-risk customers. I might end up paying extra because my insurance company decided I didn't fall into their 'lowest risk' bucket because my background check came back as "we have never heard of this gal" because I once used a data privacy protecting service or they can't find my facebook/linkedin/twitter.
- namaria 2y agoSo your rationale is to avoid seeking out privacy on the off chance that you might not get the biggest discount available when buying insurance?
- londons_explore 2y agoor a mortgage, credit card, or bank account, yep. There is easily a 10x difference in insurance prices between "known good customer" and "probably fraudulent customer" - and that difference is the difference between being able to own your own house (with mortgage to begin with) and renting for life. Most people would value owning their own home over having some computer system using their data to select one ad over another.
- namaria 2y agoWhile there might be such a difference in price, equating trying to avoid data collection through legitimate means with being flagged as a probable fraudster and having to pay 10x is not sound reasoning. If people were routinely getting gauged like this for trying to opt out of something, there would be a pretty huge story in that and I doubt it would go unreported.
- johnea 2y agoSo, one criminal gang steals data from another criminal gang, and then sells it to a 3rd criminal gang. Sounds like capitalism is functioning as intended...
- dmitrygr 2y agoThis will continue until we make having a huge collection of personal data into a liability and not an asset for companies. Actual jail terms for CEOs for leaks would be a wonderful start. Or, at least, we should have fines that are not wrist-slaps. For example, a fine of $1000 paid to each individual per leak would be a good starting point. Then, companies will properly start minimizing the amount of data they store, in fear of a crippling loss.
- hedora 2y agoAlso, the money should go into an escrow account with a list of claimants. Some neutral third party should handle getting the checks to individuals. That way, there's no financial incentive to make it hard to claim damages, and people won't need to bother filling out a form every few weeks to claim the cash.
- robertonoa 2y ago> a fine of $1000 paid to each individual per leak would be a good starting point They would just fold the company and start another? Most data brokers do not have 3 trillion dollars.
- dmitrygr 2y agoSome people will still get some money. And spinning up a new company still has costs. However, this is precisely why this is the second-best option, after actual jail time for actual CEOs. Then they can fold whatever they want in their prison cells
- Gibbon1 2y agoCan make the board personally liable.
- tithe 2y agoCan't you do this via class action seeking to demonstrate negligence?
- rootusrootus 2y agoMaybe as this becomes so ubiquitous, we will finally see 'identify theft' recognized as BS. If you allow someone who is not-me to pretend to be me and rip you off, this is not ever my problem; it's yours.
- zippergz 2y agoCue the posts complaining about how impossible it is to do any transaction online because you have to provide so much proof (and the companies collecting even MORE data about us, to later be stolen).
- svachalek 2y agoMost transactions online use some kind of payment system, which is vulnerable to various forms of fraud and hackery but not "identity theft". "Identity theft" (and GP is right that this is a made up crime to discount corporate greed and laziness) occurs during an application for credit, which doesn't need to be a common and easy process.
- barbazoo 2y agoAnd even that has been solved by more privacy forward societies. For instance PostIdent in Germany where you verify your identity with a trusted third party.
- Loughla 2y agoHonestly. Someone walks into a bank with a gun and takes the money, it's Bank robbery. Why would them using false identities be any different? Why is it MY problem that someone else stole from a bank? If they wear a mask with my face on it during a physical robbery, does that mean I'm liable?
- celdon25 2y agoFrom the opt-out link: > If you are a California, Virginia, Colorado, Connecticut, or Utah resident, you have the right to request that we delete personal information that we collect about you, subject to certain exceptions. I think it's time to require this on a national level. This is getting ridiculous.
- aljgz 2y agoThat's a step forward, but not a solution. There are so many firms collecting data on everyone. There should be something similar to a "National no call list". If you register there, all firms should delete your information or face consequences.
- radicaldreamer 2y agoUnfortunately this will be used to discriminate against people when applying for a loan or a job, so we must make it illegal to discriminate when these data brokers return nothing for a search because someone has opted-out.
- nickff 2y agoIf you’re going to make it illegal for anyone to use the data broker information to make decisions, you should just ban the data brokers from existing.
- anon373839 2y agoBingo. This is clearly the answer. However, law enforcement buys from data brokers, so it will never happen.
- hdkwnwnen 2y agoThis is the crux of the issue. The ever evolving police apparatus would never give up such a thing. The people who write the laws and their spook handlers want to increase data collection, if anything. Does anyone else feel like we are slipping into a Dark Mirror episode? I fear that nothing will be sacred soon.
- WhackyIdeas 2y agoHow has this American data broker got my data when I am a British citizen? Wtf?
- pbhjpbhj 2y agoWhere did you check that your data was in the leak?
- FireBeyond 2y agoApropos of anything else, because these companies couldn't care where or who you are. The more data they can slurp up on more people, the better and more valuable their databases sound.
- brewdad 2y agoYou've never done business with a company that has a US presence? You've never visited the US for work or holiday? There's lots of ways to get your data and once they have it, it gets sold repeatedly.
- Y_Y 2y agoCrooks threaten to leak data stolen from other crooks.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoThe thing I don't understand is how, with SOOO much leaking of nearly everyone's personal data who is a US citizen, can KYC requirements (that is, what is required to own a bank account in someone's name online) still be so low. In many (most?) cases all you need is full name, address, date of birth, social security number, possibly also phone and/or email. If those pieces of content correlate with each other, and there is no other suspicious information about the account opening request, the account is likely to be opened. All that information is essentially semi-public these days for nearly all US citizens. How is this still allowed for KYC purposes?
- lettergram 2y agoIt’s the validation of that info that is KYC
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- ethbr1 2y agoIs there really validation in the current system though? Or is it simply providing self-consistent (publicly available) details? KYC in an environment where all the data points are openly available looks very different.
- lijok 2y agoThere is. Liveness checks prove the user submitting the info is the user in the documents.
- lolinder 2y agoFor the uninitiated, can you elaborate on how a liveness check can be used to show that the human being who typed "John Doe" in the name field, "01/01/1970" in the birthday field, and "000-00-0000" in the SSN field is in fact John Doe who was born on 01/01/1970 and has the SSN 000-00-0000? I get that we can determine if it was a human being with some acceptable level of accuracy, but what actually matters is that it's the right human being. How does a liveness check solve the problem of these numbers that are used as passwords being de facto public information?
- markus_zhang 2y agoOK great, we are being leaked left and right. You know what, we should just demand $10 per collection. Collect and leak whatever you want, because I cannot stop you, but you need to pay me.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]