7 ms·
X is justifiably slow (2022)
- danans 2y agoAt the very least, X is definitely the most overloaded product name in tech.
- bravetraveler 2y agoThe same way flat earth as a debate topic has been misappropriated, as has this - the concept of a variable
- adolph 2y agoPro gives X a run for its money. Xtreme iAir Pro+ | AI for My Blockchain
- airstrike 2y agohttps://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/XMakesAnythingCool https://tvtropes.org/pmwiki/pmwiki.php/Main/XMakesAnythingCo...
- xwowsersx 2y agoI only realized this post wasn't about Twitter when I reached the end.
- pohl 2y agoThe rebranding from Twitter to X, then, has been more successful than anticipated. It should have been X Windows that one mistook the topic for.
- pxc 2y agoX11 is indeed what I first thought this was about.
- GaggiX 2y agoIf you know Twitter already or it's like the opposite.
- marcosdumay 2y agoI guess people stopped associating "X11" with "slow" at some point in the early 00s.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- amaccuish 2y agoIs the post not deliberately ambiguous for humorous effect?
- yuliyp 2y agoWhat did you think after the first two sentences?
- GeorgeTirebiter 2y agoMe too. I'm not sure I would have clicked if the tagline weren't, effectively, clickbait.
- beretguy 2y agoNuh, elon screwed it up for everybody
- userbinator 2y agoMe too. It makes very general points but it could apply to Twitter, which is IMHO what makes this so ambiguous. The fact that X is actually slower than I think it could be (remember the "light" version that didn't need JS at all?) adds to that ambiguity.
- neilv 2y agoI'm just going to keep calling it Twitter. Usually, I will call people however they preferred to be called, even when it seems silly. But renaming Twitter to "X" crosses the line of confusing. I'm not sure it should've been allowed.
- inquirerGeneral 2y ago[dead]
- isodev 2y agoSame, I kept thinking "Are there really that many people still on Twitter to make it slow or do they just lack funding for infra".
- asveikau 2y agoI thought this was about X11, not twitter.
- spion 2y agoSame. Coincidentally, wayland is pretty fast.
- wyldfire 2y agoThe site currently shows a footnote: > As should be obvious from the framing, X here is a variable, not a web site formerly known as Twitter.
- asveikau 2y agoI know. I read that. I didn't say it was about twitter. I'm saying that many commenters, and the article itself, seem to think people will confuse it with twitter, but I confused it with X11.
- nasretdinov 2y agoYes, even during my career computers became faster by a factor of ~100 or so, yet computers don't feel much faster if at all. Yes, they're much more _capable_, but usually even less responsive than e.g. in Windows 95 days. I think just having the intuition of how fast computers can work is what the industry is sorely lacking. I am usually able to achieve very good performance for the stuff that I'm working on, despite the fact that it often requires a stupid amount of computation, just because I know how much a computer can actually do in a given amount of time when it's tuned correctly.
- JTyQZSnP3cQGa8B 2y agoI can only agree to this. 500 times faster and still slower than Windows 3.1 for almost the same set of features.
- Semaphor 2y agoIt's hard to say after all this time, but I think I was frequently waiting on everything in the win 95 days, while now even a small delay is annoying and standing out. Pressing a key to start a launcher, typing and using enter within a second does not seem to have been possible back then.
- endgame 2y agoBut back in those days, you had confidence that the event loop didn't randomly drop things, and you could type ahead of what was on screen with confidence.
- arp242 2y agoMy computer boots in about 10 seconds. That's probably about average? In the Windows 95 days that would have seemed almost impossible. Most applications and games launch in single-digit seconds. I don't recall this being the norm in the Windows 95 days either.
- dylan604 2y agoJust the spinning rust turning at 5400rpm seems like that would have been all but impossible. With modern NVMe devices, waiting for data to load isn't really a bottle neck. At 1200MBps+ speeds, we had to span 16 7200rpm drives in RAID-0 to get close to that speed. With all of that, it does feel wrong to have to wait for apps to load. How much of that is the calling home to validate the app has been signed?
- threeseed 2y ago> As should be obvious from the framing, X here is a variable, not a web site formerly known as Twitter This could be one of the needlessly confusing articles I've seen yet.
- al_borland 2y agoIs the world going to have to agree on a new generic variable/placeholder name, just because of Twitter... I think X on its own should never be Twitter, it should always be referred to as x.com to eliminate any ambiguity.
- foobazgt 2y agoIn CS, foo, bar, and baz are those metasyntactic variables.
- marcosdumay 2y ago> it should always be referred to as x.com I vote on "the website previously known as Twitter".
- TeMPOraL 2y agoHow about just "X Twitter", as in "ex Twitter"?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- chuckadams 2y agoI'm tickled that "Xitter" is gaining traction. Use the Chinese pronunciation of X.
- 98Windows 2y agoHow about TWPKAT? It looks a bit like twat
- 2y ago
- poochkoishi728 2y agoIs X not X11? I read the article thinking it was that.
- poochkoishi728 2y ago> As should be obvious from the framing, X here is a variable Not only did I misunderstand the article, the author tops it off by calling me a dummy at the end..
- wtetzner 2y agoIt probably would make more sense to put that at the top of the article.
- Dwedit 2y agoNot an article about Twitter.
- Chyzwar 2y agoIt is consequences of industry moving to feature factory model. It takes time to learn how to improve, understand and profile performance. Furthermore, it is not only performance, it is everything. Doctors spend like 10 years learning, but there is expectation that a fresh bootcamp developer can build a full-stack application.
- tempestn 2y agoI think this is the first time the Twitter rename has caused me significant confusion with an unrelated article.
- renegat0x0 2y ago1) Most of web programs are slow because of ad business. You need to be evaluated. Are you a robot? Which cohort you fit into? Which ads should it fed you? They capture every bit of information about you, so you could be tracked more, or to sell your data. Then they display what you want to see. Corporations focus not on providing info you would like to see. Therefore X/meta/youtube will not have a good subscription UI / behavior. The corporations focus on suggestion algorithms so they can spoon feed you with data they want to monetize for advertisers. 2) Big corporate projects are built by thousands projects, and thousands abstractions tied together by a duct tape. Layers upon layers, built by engineers not happy with outcome, but engineers that met deadline.
- gen220 2y agoThere are lots of technical reasons why web apps are slow, and this is a technical site so, as a community, the discourse tends to over-index on "react/electron/python/whatever is slow". But these are the messy human + economic reasons why things are actually slow. I'd add some nuance to (2), that even small corporate projects are often built by companies that are explicitly incentivized to build as quickly as possible, any other barometer of success goes out the window. If you use software developed by companies or projects that are outside (1) and (2), you'll find it is actually pretty fast, subjectively.
- captainmuon 2y agoI think often people don't put in the extra mile to make things resource efficient or snappy (they may or may not have good reasons not to of course). It starts with choosing the right algorithms, using an index instead of doing a linear search, minimizing network traffic, ... but sometimes there are just unneccessary sources of slowness. I was tinkering with a react-native app the other day which shows a map and lets the user click on a building, and then highlights the building and shows some information. There was a noticable delay after clicking which made it not much fun to use. So I spent a couple evenings (hobby time, not company time) to integrate a proper spatial database with a fast spatial index, precache a lot of data, so I didn't have to hit the network. It got snappier, I could query a lot of geometry much faster, but it still felt slow. Then I looked into the source of the libraries, and in some react-native glue code I found that the event handler was waiting after the first tap for a double-tap, and thus would only register the tap after a couple hundred ms. One tiny change and it became blazing fast. I believe most apps could do most things instantaneously. Google can find any document on the net in a few ms, after all. But of course not everybody has the time and money (or even skills) to polish their apps that much. If the customer will buy your app when it is good enough then why should you put in more work (besides from a personal sense of craftsmanship)?
- nevermore24 2y agoThey don't know how, that's the entire problem. Six months in a crappy boot camp doesn't teach you a single thing about computers qua computers. The industry has been suffering with mediocrity for so long, that even today's managers don't know what performant software looks like. But as long as people get paid, nobody cares. It's depressing as all hell.
- bongodongobob 2y agoIt is. I'm contracting for a company right now and they have a number of scripts to automate various day to day things. More than once I've taken a look at them and have been able to 100x their speed due to a little common sense. Caching some things, not pulling ALL the data when not needed, precalculate stuff outside of hot loops, etc. Like really basic stuff. No one cares anymore. I don't get it.
- nickdothutton 2y agoIf you have time, begin with the physics. How many bits have to change, how many have to move, how many have to be computed? Do they really have to move? Do they really have to be computed? Do they really have to change? Do they have to change now and every time? Can they remain in-situ? Works on the CPU register scale, and on the availability region/continental/global scale. While modern hardware provides a wealth of capabilities WRT SIMD, multi threading, and of course the revolution in storage over the last 20 years… sometimes you can design-out a lot of the heavy lifting. My first program ran on a 2MHz CPU with 64KB RAM and (floppy) disk access time measured in seconds. I think something of the art and science has been lost when even a wonderful “toy” computer runs at 2.4GHz. Often when I ask “what is the system really doing when X is slow?” people (including developers who built it) have little idea.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoNo matter how fast CPUs get, shitty programmers and their managers with enshitification strategies will make software slow again. What new features does windows 11 have compared to win XP? Now compare the requirements needed to even start the OS. Web is even worse... 2kB of usable information means tens of megabytes of downloaded crap, and that's even before the ads. Why does a simple site with a sidebar need megabytes of javascript?!
- nevermore24 2y agoYou can only optimize at your current level of abstraction. Writing JavaScript? Have fun, there's a floor to your performance, because you're on the 28th floor of the abstraction skyscraper, and you can only go up. Part of the issue is that developers don't know any better, the other part is that everyone suddenly decided that four virtual machines crammed inside each other like a matryoshka doll is the only valid way to write software anymore.
- redox99 2y agoJS by itself isn't that bad. You could calculate pi digits reasonably fast using JS. The problem usually is: really poor code that is blocking, triggers a million rerenders for every interaction, insane bloat, or just the absolute massive amount of abstractions through packages. Plus HTML + CSS is really slow.
- syngrog66 2y agoback in 2022 Twitter was Twitter and "X something something" had a very different expectation of meaning, by default thanks Elon
- JadeNB 2y agoActually, the name change took effect in 2022, and is mentioned in the article: > As should be obvious from the framing, X here is a variable, not a web site formerly known as Twitter.
- syngrog66 2y agoname change was in July 2023
- JadeNB 2y agoYes, you are right, sorry. I thought that (2022) in the submission indicated that the article must be from 2022 (though it seems actually to be from 2024), indicating that the mention of the name change in the article must mean that it had already happened by 2022; and then, though I checked Wikipedia, I confused the date of acquisition with the name change.
- jiggawatts 2y agoI’m not even sure what the argument is here. The author appears to be saying that ‘X’ is slow despite a lot of effort has already gone into making it fast, so what remains must be that it is doing irreducible hard work. I assume he’s using X as a generic placeholder instead of formerly-known-as-Twitter, but the argument applies in either case. In my experience this is never the case. There’s always ridiculously low hanging fruit. On the ground and rotting, in fact. I’ll use Jira as an example. Their online version takes a solid minute to open an empty form. A minute! Do you have any idea how much computing power this represents!? I can install Windows Server 2022 into a virtual machine in less time than this! I can read 42GB of data from disk, or download a DVD from the Internet. Someone working for Atlassian was here making excuses: customers implement many complex customisations, they have security rules, etc, etc… “The system is doing a lot of hard work” is what he was trying to say. I tried a new, empty tenant. No data, no customisation of any kind. Took nearly a minute to show an empty form. That’s not “hard work”, that’s the baseline. It can only get worse from there!
- filleduchaos 2y ago> The author appears to be saying that ‘X’ is slow despite a lot of effort has already gone into making it fast, so what remains must be that it is doing irreducible hard work. This is the literal opposite of what the author is saying though? The article even closes with him expressing annoyance because people who claim that X is justifiably slow have almost certainly not done enough analysis to say so.
- jiggawatts 2y agoThis is what I mean that the article's core argument is a bit hard to follow.
- jonathankoren 2y agoThis is a bad article, primarily because multiple people, myself included, have no idea what this person is talking about. I thought he was talking about Twitter. Someone else suggested X11, and a third group says he’s talking in the abstract. If you fail at making it clear what the topic of your writing is, then you failed as writer. I shouldn’t have to guess what the subject under discussion is. Now assuming he is taking in general, the whole article is just content free, because the writer is reduced to literally just brainstorming anything and everything, and saying, “See? There’s lots of reasons for something to be slow!” Well, fuck dude, I think we all know that.
- burgerrito 2y agoThis is from 2024? Or was this updated?
- dec0dedab0de 2y agoX is slow because management told everyone to work on something else the moment we got a prototype barely functioning
- torginus 2y agoOne of the funniest things around this is whenever I pay for any sort of official content service (comics, manga, books etc.) and I use the official 'cloud reader' service of the respective content owner, the site is super effing heavy and often fails to load images, page turns feel like molasses with image load speeds comparable to late 90s dialup. As opposed to this, whenever I don't feel like bothering with this and just type in 'Read %THING% online free', the resulting sites tend to be just html pages where the pages are linked in as images and the whole things is blazing fast, and I can scroll without bother. I'm quite the former sites re built by a small army of engineers and it's some kind of orchestrated microservice thing running region-replicated on some cloud provider-hosted kubernetes cluster, and is loaded to the brim with DRM authorization. While the latter sites are probably running on some kid's old surplus gaming PC tucked into the corner of their bedrooms, on some PHP site thrown together over the weekend. Yet the latter is infinitely more usable.
- 6SixTy 2y agoThe Xorg foundation/whoever should have given Elon a C&D the instant he tried to name his hellsite X with also basically the exact same logo. E: this article is deeply confusing and I should probably bill the owner for my time
- vondur 2y agoI remember having built a PC for Windows NT 4. It was fast. However, it had good hardware for that time. Adaptec UW SCSI hard disk, Matrox video card and 128MB of RAM.