15 ms·
Recall: Stealing everything you've ever typed or viewed on your own Windows PC
- jasonjayr 2y agoThere was a movie about this exact thing. Antitrust (2001) was about a Microsoft-like company monitoring everyone’s computer and stealing code. 23 years later and here we are.
- ch4ch4 2y agoThat was an enjoyable movie, aside for the fact that the writers thought fiber optic cables are used for hidden cameras.
- tomalpha 2y agohttps://www.detective-store.com/optical-fibre-micro-camera-ss-3427-72.html https://www.detective-store.com/optical-fibre-micro-camera-s...
- gravescale 2y agoIn 2001, image sensors and the electronics to drive them were far larger then they are today, an endoscope-style fibre optic isn't necessarily ridiculous if you only had a tiny hole to sneak through a thick obstruction. Even today, a non-CIA-grade camera head is probably 2-3mm across and the optics on a fibre optic can be far narrower. You can only have a pinhole spy cam if you have a void directly behind the pinhole.
- kjkjadksj 2y agoWhats the spec on the CIA grade stuff then?
- gravescale 2y agoWell, I assume they can do better than a £10 USB endoscope from AliExpress! But even if you have some ultratiny thing hot out of a classified lab, fibre optics also keep the active electronics further away and harder to detect.
- thebruce87m 2y agoThey probably don’t even have to bother, just hack the targets phone, tv, iPad, laptop to get every bit of content they consume and conversation they have.
- aleph_minus_one 2y agoWhen I watched this film, I immediately thought during the finale of this film that the story of this film is so "wrong" because the public will barely care about the misdeeds of NURV (or rather: those who do care basically already "know"). From todays's perspective, considering for example the Snowden and Wikileaks revelations that caused exactly these barely-nil reactions in the public, I know that I was right regarding this feeling.
- accrual 2y agoI wouldn't say they caused barely-nil reactions. Maybe to the general public and to a random bystander if asked, but they still had implications for the public's overall trust in the government. And for users in the affected spaces (tech, security, etc.) the reaction was stronger and longer lasting.
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> but they still had implications for the public's overall trust in the government. In my observation it really was as I described: - those who already deeply distrusted the government continued to do so - the others (the huge majority) simply did barely care or even attempted to justify the crimes Concerning your point about tech and security sectors: those who form the inner core of the people working in these sectors basically already knew what was happening since at least the 90s.
- vasco 2y agoNobody votes for net neutrality or internet rights or privacy focused groups. I agree that there were almost no reactions. June 6th people will vote for European elections, lets see how many seats the pirate party gets.
- makeitdouble 2y agoIt depends on what you see as an appropriate reaction to wikileaks and Snowden. It was a structural problem, and no governing parties ever tried to stop it so voting it out for instance wasn't a solution. Perhaps Trump's support could be a far reaction to it, with no clear direction but just a strong wish to screw it all. We see the same in other countries where people go to the extremes as discomfort rises with no actionable way.
- thierrydamiba 2y agoAm I missing something or is this as big of a disaster as I think? This is terrible news right?
- ocdtrekkie 2y agoSort of but AI PCs are going to be more expensive than normal PCs so most users won't and will continue to not have a PC that does this. Pushing it out to existing machines would be a very different tier of problem.
- walterbell 2y ago> AI PCs are going to be more expensive than normal PCs The Qualcomm Oryon SoC is about half the price of an Intel CPU.
- ocdtrekkie 2y agoCurrently an Inspiron 7440 (non-Copilot+) starts at $849 and an Inspiron 7441 (with Copilot+) starts at $1,099. That's a $250 premium to get an "AI PC".
- walterbell 2y ago12-core Oryon dev kit with 32GB RAM is $899, https://www.windowscentral.com/software-apps/windows-11/qualcomm-launches-snapdragon-developer-kit-with-12-core-x-elite-at-build-2024 https://www.windowscentral.com/software-apps/windows-11/qual... It's a brand new device family. OEM price competition should improve as more devices ship in Aug/Sep. Oryon should run Linux with good performance-per-watt. Hopefully the NPU can be disabled to save energy.
- ocdtrekkie 2y agoThe part where you are pointing out a dev kit and about how well it runs Linux is really just admitting you don't understand the conversation we are having here. Most users buy a cheap HP from Costco for $300. Businesses will buy the same standard line OptiPlex they bought last year. Very, very few people will magically end up with Windows Recall who didn't intend to.
- walterbell 2y agoRelated threads: "Giving Windows total recall of everything a user does is a privacy minefield", 41 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40470806 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40470806 "AI PCs are the final nail in the coffin of open computing", 60 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40436975 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40436975 "How the new Microsoft Recall feature fundamentally undermines Windows security", 50 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40433884 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40433884 "Windows Recall sounds like a privacy nightmare", 298 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40443682 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40443682
- ok_dad 2y agoThis is something you have to specifically enable right? Right?! I’m sick of brain dead execs and product managers. What world do these people live in?
- colechristensen 2y ago>What world do these people live in? Getting promoted by other execs based on the visibility of delivered features.
- lstamour 2y agoIt’s enabled by default on a select number of laptops they sell, and no one else has access to it yet. But they plan to roll it out further. I’d personally hoped for some kind of “Secure Enclave” such that only certain processes could be run, but this is about what I would expect of someone shipping a minimum viable product because AI is a hot buzzword. Weirdly, even AI could theoretically solve some of the privacy issues simply by looking for PII and removing them. Extra weirdly, this would have been more secure if they uploaded screenshots to the cloud, because access could be better monitored there and exfiltration limited.
- ocdtrekkie 2y agoIf anything, it's likely they imagine the PII being useful. Imagine being able to ask your computer for your bank account number instead of digging it out of a website or file. Obviously useful... but also obviously exploitable.
- LegitShady 2y agoFirst it's opt in, then it's on by default, then it's mandatory and what do you have to hide anyways? The default progression of this sort of "feature" and business practice.
- frizlab 2y agoAnd in this particular instance it did not even start with opt-in. They went straight to on by default!
- walterbell 2y agoThe idea other people with access to the device could see a photographic memory is.. very scary to a great many people on a deeply personal level. Windows is a personal experience. This shatters that belief. How did we get here? A 20-year lifelog. 2003, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_LifeLog https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DARPA_LifeLog >The objective of the LifeLog concept was "to be able to trace the 'threads' of an individual's life in terms of events, states, and relationships", and it has the ability to "take in all of a subject's experience, from phone numbers dialed and e-mail messages viewed to every breath taken, step made and place gone". 2007 Microsoft Research, https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/video/the-microsoft-sensecam-and-other-lifelogging-devices/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/video/the-microsoft... > The SenseCam is a personal, wearable camera developed by Microsoft Research in Cambridge, UK, and used as a lifelogging device in projects like MyLifeBits.. is based on wearing the SenseCam for lifelogging of ‘events’ during your day, and generating a fast-forward movie of the event as the memory recall interface. 2010 Microsoft Research, https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/now-let-me-see-where-i-was-understanding-how-lifelogs-mediate-memory/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/now-let... > Lifelogging technologies can capture both mundane and important experiences in our daily lives, resulting in a rich record of the places we visit and the things we see.. Previous work has demonstrated that Lifelogs can aid recall, but that they do many other things too. They can help us look back at the past in new ways, or to reconstruct what we did in our lives, even if we don’t recall exact details. https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/project/mylifebits/ https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/project/mylifebits/ & https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MyLifeBits https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MyLifeBits > MyLifeBits is a life-logging experiment begun in 2001. It is a Microsoft Research project inspired by Vannevar Bush's hypothetical Memex computer system.. The "experimental subject" of the project is computer scientist Gordon Bell.. For this, Bell has digitized all documents he has read or produced, CDs, emails, and so on. He continues to do so, gathering web pages browsed, phone and instant messaging conversations and the like more or less automatically. The book Total Recall describes the vision and implications for a personal, lifetime e-memory for recall, work, health, education, and immortality. Lifelogging was referenced by 10,000 academic papers over two decades, https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=lifelogging https://scholar.google.com/scholar?q=lifelogging
- jiggawatts 2y agoIt’s just a matter of time until they introduce an InTune feature to enforce this setting and send AI-written summaries of all employee behaviour to management. https://x.com/AlexBlechman/status/1457842724128833538?lang=en https://x.com/AlexBlechman/status/1457842724128833538?lang=e...
- sf_sugar_daddy 2y ago[dead]
- L-four 2y agoRecall will track every you do this would be a massive invasion of privacy if Microsoft didn't already track everything you do.
- datahack 2y agoLet me be clear: I will literally burn any computer equipped with this technology I am forced to use and post the aftermath online. This is societal cancer. Total information monitoring is the death of any semblance of human independence and should be violently resisted. I have never been more disgusted by a management team. How clueless can you be? Combined with digital intelligence, this technology is profoundly dangerous to anyone who works with a computer or technology (which is almost everyone).
- CoastalCoder 2y agoI think that kind of sabotage would only work if a very large number of persons joined you. You might want to consider an alternative plan, as doing that to an employer's / government's computer could get you in a lot of trouble.
- datahack 2y agoOBEY.
- NegativeLatency 2y ago“Someone else will do it”
- datahack 2y agoWhat happened to the punk in cyberpunk?
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> What happened to the punk in cyberpunk? It began to wane as soon as programming and in particular working in big tech became an opportunity to get rich.
- wilsonnb3 2y agoWho do you anticipate forcing you to use a computer with this functionality?
- bee_rider 2y agoThe only silver lining on this is that, previously, the idea that your computer might visually spy on everything you do and index it for easy searching was the domain of paranoid conspiracy theorists. So I guess at least marketing that as a feature now makes it obvious that it is possible, I guess.
- EGreg 2y agoIt was always possible. But now they will claim you have a way to turn it off. Who knows ! There is so much telemetry being recorded anyway. This is like people preferring Macbooks from 2016 because it was pre-touchbar. I honestly consider good tech from previous years to be far more secure than what’s around now. Who knows what’s in your products now?
- thsksbd 2y agoAhhh, I knew it was important to keep my 20 year old SGI fuel. :P
- zuminator 2y agoThat was very well written and reasonable, neither minimizing the risks nor succumbing to hysteria. The idea behind Recall, universal, machine-assisted search, is a good one but it's embarrassingly clear that in terms of implementation, this ain't it, chief. Microsoft should do what Google has done with Sky -- withdraw the product, take the hit, and hope that something can be salvaged from this debacle, both in terms of an improved product, and better company-wide testing and rollout practices.
- shostack 2y agoI think the idea is a good one, I just have zero trust in Microsoft to have my interests in mind so it becomes a question of when, not if, it becomes abused, if not by them then some bad actor.
- emmelaich 2y agoWhat's this Google Sky that was withdrawn?
- zuminator 2y agoSorry, my flub, I meant OpenAI's Sky of course!
- lostmsu 2y agoThis is poorly written and completely nonsensical. Also a clickbait: nobody is stealing anything. If you get malware or you have other admins on your computer, they can already record anything you do at their will. The data is NOT uploaded to M$. The whole fuss is stupid and I am impressed 90% comments here seem to think otherwise.
- kccqzy 2y agoIf you get malware, these malware will only begin to record things once they are installed. They do not automatically get years of computer use history. Until Recall. It seems like you live in the same kind of detached echo chambers as the people at Microsoft who approved this feature. No wonder you find this nonsensical. I bet the product managers responsible for this also find this article nonsensical.
- technion 2y agoMy hot take on this has been that although the tech community universally hates this - the sales and management types that drive these decisions will love it, and recall will go down as a resounding success for Microsoft. You're also going to find disabling it reduces your 'azure score' which is absolutely used by such types as a measure of their sysadmins skills.
- not2b 2y agoThe management types who think they love this, because they can monitor their employees more effectively, will change their minds in a hurry when a competitor sues them, discovery starts, and the competitors' lawyers get to go through everything that Recall saves.
- Take8435 2y agoWTF are you on about? Lol
- technion 2y agoI am "on about" the fact that HN is frequently a bubble that doesn't reflect business. As an example, there has been many threads full of assertions that no good manager would ever deploy "bossware", and yet companies selling these products are reporting sales going through the roof.
- counterpartyrsk 2y agoAnother great reason to use Linux.
- alpha123123 2y agoThreads on similar "apps": "Show HN: Rem: Remember Everything (open source)", 196 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38787892 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38787892 "I made an open source Windows app to rewind and search everything on screen", 166 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40105371 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40105371 "Rewind: The Search Engine for Your Life", 92 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33421751 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=33421751
- wavemode 2y agoI thought this concept sounded familiar. I remember Rem being relatively well-received. I guess people trust Microsoft a lot less.
- zuminator 2y agoThose third party apps are not enabled by default, won't modify their functionality without your permission, and two of the three are open source. And for me it's not so much that I trust Microsoft less than any other company. It's that using their services require so much trust, yet they give so little trust in return.
- andrewstuart 2y agoIt should be called "Clean Sweep".
- MarkMarine 2y agoI just assumed windows work computers were doing this already.
- aleph_minus_one 2y ago> I just assumed windows work computers were doing this already. In most sectors the installed corporate spyware is from a different company than Microsoft.
- smaudet 2y agoWork computers are like this, a bit, but typically they don't exfiltrate their own data outside their own corporate borders. That's a big deal/difference. The other issue, the vendors tend not to leave glaring security holes in their software, both because of IT desire to maintain control of the operating environment, but also because there is intense awareness that corporate espionage is a constant, real, and ongoing threat. It sounds like the MS folks rushed out a "feature" and wanted to pretend we all live in some utopia where nobody does anything bad, ever. Possibly all snorting coke or something...
- Animats 2y agoIs there a law enforcement analysis tool for this yet?
- ternus 2y agoI'm confused. According to the article, several days working results in a 90kb compressed DB. If that's the case, it can't be capturing all the text you see, including web pages - perhaps "working" here doesn't involve general web browsing? What am I missing?
- tsujamin 2y agoPresumably the snapshots it takes and summarises are periodic, but at what interval I'm not sure. Alternatively (and this is a technical possibility) it could be hooked into WebViews and HWNDs to get notified when it's worth taking a screenshot. Given that you can exempt particular website (in addition to private browsing modes in "supported browsers" already being exempted [1]), that implies some integration between a browsing context and Recall. [1] https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/retrace-your-steps-with-recall-aa03f8a0-a78b-4b3e-b0a1-2eb8ac48701c https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/retrace-your-ste...
- gigel82 2y agoText compresses very well. Also, it wouldn't be capturing the entire web page, just the text you actually see on screen. Obviously that 90kb doesn't include the separate folder with all the jpegs.
- xcv123 2y agoThe full screen OCR will capture the jpeg file names
- wombat-man 2y agoYeah I'm also wondering what kind of perf drag it would be. I'd probably just turn it off. Like when would I ever want this?
- pkilgore 2y agoHoly shit, when I was doing litigation these databases would be my wet dream. I might seriously quit my job and start a discovery consulting / tech company just for targeting these databases.
- twobitshifter 2y agoThe new text messages / browser history
- fh9302 2y agoRecall can't be disabled during the Windows setup. It has to be disabled manually in Windows settings. https://x.com/tomwarren/status/1796681578984182066 https://x.com/tomwarren/status/1796681578984182066
- autoexec 2y agoEventually they can just re-enable it as part of an "important update". They can even stop you from being able to disable it entirely. If you're using Windows, it's not really your computer. At least you aren't the administrator of that device. Microsoft can access any file, install any software, change any setting, or remove any access at any time for any reason with no notice or indication to you that it happened. They can even shutdown your computer. Any device which works like that is not one that's under your control. Every internet connected windows computer is insecure by design and cannot be trusted to protect your privacy or security.
- wilsonnb3 2y ago> Microsoft can access any file, install any software, change any setting, or remove any access at any time for any reason with no notice or indication to you that it happened. They can even just shutdown your device. Any device which works like that is not one under your control. Having this power is inherent in making the OS. Whoever is the vendor of your particular Linux distribution has the same powers, it is just that you trust them not to use them (or, in a very small theoretical minority of cases, you’ve audited the code and binaries yourself). So yes, you shouldn’t use an OS from a vendor you don’t trust, I agree completely. I don’t understand why people are acting like this is earth shattering news though, this has always been the case since people started using software they didn’t write themselves.
- autoexec 2y ago> Having this power is inherent in making the OS. No, it really isn't. For decades I owned computers with operating systems which didn't have that capability. Once installed and configured, the OS was consistent and (reasonably) stable. Someone would literally have to break into my house or office to modify my settings or install software against my wishes. Even after I started connecting my devices to the internet the OS itself had no ability to do these things and couldn't gain that ability unless I explicitly chose to install updates that enabled that behavior. That's entirely different from the situation today where MS forces updates and restarts, installs unwanted software on our computers, and has files and folders that we (even using administrator accounts) don't have access to. Linux too is very different. Linux is transparent about what it does, adds, or changes. You have the power to choose which updates to apply or not. You have the power to modify any part of your OS so that it does what you want. I can't speak to all distros out there, but I've never seen a linux system force a restart in the middle of the day, or reinstall applications users removed without notice. Can't say the same for Windows. Unlike Windows, linux typically respects its users and their wishes. You really don't have to write your own software in order to have software that respects you and leaves you in control of your own devices. It's kind of crazy that you'd think there could be no other way.
- autoexec 2y agoWindows already had a built in keylogger with Window 10 (https://www.pcworld.com/article/423165/how-to-turn-off-windows-10s-keylogger-yes-it-still-has-one.html https://www.pcworld.com/article/423165/how-to-turn-off-windo...) but all that data was only going to Microsoft and couldn't be accessed by you or anyone with access to your device. Law enforcement, attorneys, and three letter agencies must be extremely excited about Recall. Now they won't have to hope that MS has records of everything you've typed while using your device, because with Recall all of that evidence will be stored on the device itself. "If one would give me six lines written by the hand of the most honest man, I would find something in them to have him hanged." imagine could be found using everything a person ever types on their computer.
- gigel82 2y agoAs far as I can see based on the data already posted online, this is literally the Windows 10 Timeline feature, it even (re)uses the same API from that feature (that was deprecated just 3 months ago) and apparently shares the implementation as well (that feature also used a sqlite DB in your AppData and a subfolder with jpegs). They just put a little AI lipstick on that old pig in the form of OCR and some image classification. The Windows 10 Timeline feature has been around for 6 years. It is a bit surprising there is so much pushback this time around for effectively the same thing. I wonder if it's because Microsoft has been burning away people's trust through ads and dark patterns and all that bullshit, and this is the direct result of that.
- ooterness 2y agoWindows Timeline stores a list of recently opened apps and documents, not screenshots.
- rezonant 2y agoActually Timeline was a semantic store from what I understand-- it didn't store screenshots of what you were doing, instead apps that used the Microsoft Graph API could contribute information about what you were doing to be included in the Timeline. As far as I know, nothing used it except for MS' own apps. This new solution bypasses that problem by having no requirement for apps to use the Graph API-- it will just use an AI to deduce what the tasks were, and provide a search-like conversational experience on top of the collected images.
- matt3210 2y ago> Hackers can't get it Same as > The Tesla will never crash in FSD Same as >out platform is hacker proof
- throwaway22032 2y agoRemember when we used to warn about software that phoned home? Malware? Keyloggers? Adware? Rootkit DRM? Turns out they changed what "it" is, and I'm not even halfway to my pension yet...
- oefrha 2y ago> Everything a user has ever seen, ordered by application. Every bit of text the user has seen, with some minor exceptions (e.g. Microsoft Edge InPrivate mode is excluded, but Google Chrome isn’t). Microsoft was the company that used to add bespoke code to Windows to maintain compatibility with old third party software, patch explorer.exe to stop third party customizations from crashing it, etc. While the whole Recall thing is a pretty bad idea for most users, the lack of care extended to the third party browser with overwhelming market share among their users is just sad. Are they counting on people switching to Edge because “PSA: you’ll be recorded if you watch pr0n in Chrome!”?
- ajross 2y agoIt was surely just schedule pressure. There's no system-visible API for "incognito mode" (nor should there be, obviously, as it would defeat the purpose) so they just skipped it. I dunno, and I say this as someone who works for a competitor and has no love for MS... a lot of the responses here seem really uncharitable. This isn't bad faith, it's just a rushed product with some poor planning. If Apple had rolled this same feature out with glitz and a giant slideshow about privacy and explained how everything was encrypted and never left the device, we'd all be crowing about how great it is even if it too was screenshotting incognito windows.
- twinge 2y agoIt seems contrary to their docs[0]: > Recall won’t save any content from your private browsing activity when you’re using Microsoft Edge, Firefox, Opera, Google Chrome, or other Chromium-based browsers. Without a system-level incognito mode feature I could see apps allowing users to denote their windows as DRM content to avoid Recall. 0: https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy-and-control-over-your-recall-experience-d404f672-7647-41e5-886c-a3c59680af15 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy-and-cont...
- oefrha 2y ago> apps allowing users to denote their windows as DRM content to avoid Recall That would prevent user-initiated screen captures as well. Not a good idea for browsers at least.
- userbinator 2y agoMeanwhile, features like "secure" boot will stop you from patching this spyware out when it inevitably becomes impossible to disable completely via ordinary means, and even if you manage to find an exploit to "jailbreak" through, remote attestation will ostracise your machine from all the services that will eventually use the "telemetry" gathered to grant or deny you access based on how "human" you are.
- 20after4 2y agoTo anyone who thinks this sounds far fetched, check back in a couple of years. I can only think of one alternative future, in which things are not headed in this generally Orwellian direction, and the alternative may be even worse (complete or nearly-complete social collapse)
- temp3000 2y agoIn a system where everyone breaks the law (because there are so many) and everyone is spied on (so you can prove anyone did some sort of “ crime”) you can now coerce anyone you like if you get to make the decision of who to charge (like governments do) which is useful for silencing descent or opposition.
- jonas_kgomo 2y agoI have shared a similar post about another app of the same kind. It is called Invisibility (already using it, but concerned)! https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40530354 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40530354
- mikehearn 2y agoI'm trying to square the claims in this article with what Microsoft says. Article: "This database file has a record of everything you’ve ever viewed on your PC in plain text" Microsoft: "Snapshots are encrypted by Device Encryption or BitLocker, which are enabled by default on Windows 11." https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy-and-control-over-your-recall-experience-d404f672-7647-41e5-886c-a3c59680af15 https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/privacy-and-cont... The article is a little bit hand-wavy about how exactly the database comes to be decrypted and remotely exfiltrated. The headline says it takes "two lines of code" but unless I'm missing it, I don't see those lines discussed in the article.
- rezonant 2y agoWell bitlocker (ie device encryption) is only protecting you from offline attacks, ie when someone pulls your hard drive to examine it. Code running on the machine itself wouldn't be affected by it.
- walterbell 2y agoFrom the article: Q. Have you exfiltrated your own Recall database? A. Yes. I have automated exfiltration, and made a website where you can upload a database and instantly search it. I am deliberately holding back technical details until Microsoft ship the feature as I want to give them time to do something. I actually have a whole bunch of things to show and think the wider cyber community will have so much fun with this when generally available.. but I also think that’s really sad, as real world harm will ensue.
- MiguelHudnandez 2y agoThe database is not encrypted while the system is running. Microsoft's claim that it's encrypted is due to the machine being encrypted at rest with Bitlocker. The databases are plain-text sqlite files within the current user's %appdata% folder. So, literally anything that can grab those files and put them somewhere else can qualify as exfiltration. Any backup product worth its salt would be covering these databases.
- teraflop 2y agoBitLocker encrypts the hard drive contents at rest, but while the system is booted, the drive is transparently decrypted. So what Microsoft says is technically true, but doesn't necessarily present any kind of barrier to the database being exfiltrated by malware. It only protects against somebody stealing your hard drive.
- delta_p_delta_x 2y agoI genuinely like Windows. I was raised on it, and have used every consumer version since 98, and have programmed on it since Windows 7. I believe that from a purely technical, systems programming, and even UI/UX perspective, it is superior to the competition—both commercial and free/libre open-source. I will be very happy to defend this statement as factually and reasonably as possible, because I also program on 'the competition OSs' at work, and every time I do so, I want to go back to a cohesive platform like VS 2022 which, for me, is unparalleled in terms of productivity. But this sort of tone-deaf move from Microsoft is irritating me. I already dislike Windows 11's UI and UX flow because it is so reminiscent of macOS; this is why I haven't updated to it on my personal main computer yet (which is running Windows 10 Education, courtesy of my alma mater's Azure subscription). I've seen rumours that Microsoft hired a bunch of UI designers who used nothing but macOS and decided it was a good idea to port macOS UI designs to Windows. What a terrible terrible thing. UI responses that are instant even on Windows 10 now have a jelly-like lag to them on Windows 11, for no good reason. Also consider the regression of the right-click context menu, the ads and Copilot everywhere, a preference for unlabelled icons over text, amongst many others. As another comment says, Windows Recall appears to be an AI evolution of the already-present Windows Timeline feature. The privacy outcomes of this are concerning and I really really wish we didn't have 'AI' and 'Copilot' stuffed down our throats all the time. I would like to opt-in to features I want, rather than have them all pre-enabled. Some of them are very useful, like clipboard history with Windows-Ctrl-V; some less so and are flagrant privacy violations. I have already disabled almost every tracking, phone-home and auto-update feature possible using group policies; this is just another thing to add to my list of disabled 'help' features. That being said, if Recall doesn't phone home—which appears to be the case here—I don't buy the argument that 'it's stealing everything you do and hackers can access it if they have physical access'. I believe that the moment a computer's physical access record is compromised, the entire computer is compromised, regardless of security theatre like disk encryption in the form of BitLocker/LUKS, Secure Boot etc. It doesn't matter whether Recall is present or not.
- 20after4 2y ago> if Recall doesn't phone home—which appears to be the case here—I don't buy the argument that 'it's stealing everything you do and hackers can access it if they have physical access' The risk is not physical access, the risk is malware installed on the machine, or a security hole in some browser feature enabling malicious actors to covertly uploading the recall database to a remote server.
- at_a_remove 2y agoI am trying not to be reactionary but I swear, my usual response to the announcement of a new Windows feature is often "... and how do I turn that off?" Still, sqlite ... tempting. Sometimes, if I am missing something I read months or even years ago, the right query to the sqlite files Firefox keeps can give good results.
- gmerc 2y ago“the future of windows is cloud”.
- 29athrowaway 2y ago1. Turn user activity into data 2. Turn data into AI that replaces users
- thebeardisred 2y agoI find the irony that I keep getting advertised the podcast* by some VP of Security ding-dong at Microsoft *delicious*. (* I am intentionally not stating the name because they don't deserve the attention or free advertising)
- 999900000999 2y agoRecall needs to ship as a completely separate application. In fact Microsoft should also charge a nominal fee for it so no one accidentally installs it. Still this is the worst spyware ever made. Have a telehealth appointment, lawyer conference, loan application, now Recall will store all that like it or not. This made me decide to go with a non Snapdragon Laptop since I want nothing to do with this. Gonna dual boot with Fedora ( sorry Debain, but it looks like Stable is a bit behind what I need hardware support wise). Microsoft is making a serious argument for going full Linux + maybe a PS5 for competitive gaming ( since anti cheat is Windows only by design).
- pkossum 2y agoOddly enough I game on windows, and have been considering your last sentence, though I'm mostly waiting out Arm Linux for battery life considerationz.
- 999900000999 2y agoI also use Windows for music. I really really don't want to switch to OSX here since a 4TB drive is literally a 1200$ upgrade for Macs. Compared to 200$ when you can upgrade it yourself. Music production isn't great on Linux.
- tim333 2y agoThere are always external drives with macbooks. I guess neither system is perfect.
- aaronmdjones 2y ago> sorry Debain, but it looks like Stable is a bit behind what I need hardware support wise bookworm-backports has kernel 6.6, which is the very latest LTS series. Is this not new enough?
- 999900000999 2y agoI don't understand how to install backports. I'm generally not a hardcore Linux person. Fedora seems to be more up to date out of the box.
- akomtu 2y agoThis feature isn't for individual users, it's for corporations that want to control their employees. If a corporation was a man, it would be a tyrant that demands to know everything its subjects do and think, and wants to control what they do and think.
- xyst 2y agoThis is so wild. What kind of a-hole in the C-level suite of MS thought this was a good idea?
- xbmcuser 2y agoConsidering how stupid/unsophisticated an avg computer user is. The worlds scammers income is going to sky rocket in the next few years as more people get new computers with built in recall.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xbar 2y agoWell, we've got the next 6 months to make 2024 the year of the Linux desktop...
- fabiensanglard 2y agoFor a moment my perception of Microsoft was that it has become a cool company (github acquisition, Linux Sub-sytem). I was impressed by how Satya Nadella turned the company around (at least in terms of image). Between Recall and the mandatory account login to install Windows 10 I am progressively reverting to how I felt about them.
- 29athrowaway 2y agoGitHub became the data source for OpenAI Codex and GitHub Copilot not long after it was acquired. The #1 merit of Nadella is pushing for increased accessibility.
- WhyNotHugo 2y ago> For a moment my perception of Microsoft was that it has become a cool company I think that they've been trying very hard to give out that image without really changing who they are. It's not the first time that they try hard to look like they've changed, and it won't be the last.
- fifteen1506 2y agoYes. Marketing. In the end, they are working for decision makers who can spend money. Typical IT guy (not head) cannot spend money without 3 approvals from different departments.
- WWLink 2y agolol they never really sold me on it. WSL1 with its nano processes is neat, but Teams is a disgusting mess and MS has been rather consistent with treating their users like cattle.
- temp3000 2y agoThis is another nail in the coffin for me, as a life long Windows user. My next install is Linux single boot.
- WhackyIdeas 2y ago
- FerretFred 2y ago> The overwhelmingly negative reaction has probably taken Microsoft leadership by surprise. For almost everybody else, it won’t have. I sometimes (always) wonder which planet Microsoft leadership live on - it's certainly not the real world that you and I live on.
- danpalmer 2y agoThe privacy concerns here are real and massive, and I suspect this will get worse before it gets better. However. This is the holy grail of computer usage. A good version of this could be the killer app for modern AI. Because of that, ripple are going to keep trying to make this feature happen. There’s already a popular implementation on macOS. I’m excited for the end-state, but apprehensive about getting there.
- Slyfox33 2y ago"Holy grail of computer usage". Really...?
- Dalewyn 2y agoOne of the most popular features ever used on every computer is the Undo button. One of the most common questions every computer user has at any given moment is some variant of "What/Where was it?". I agree it's a holy grail, but it's also a road paved with good intentions.
- Slyfox33 2y agoRecall isn't an undo button. It's just screenshots lol.
- falcor84 2y agoI'm somewhat with the parent on this. Getting this right will probably take a long time but can eventually bring us something like J.A.R.V.I.S, whereby an AI agent can reason about all activities you've performed on the computer in the past and give you advice or perform full tasks for you based on that. We can argue whether we want to give the AI that level of trust, but I'm very interested in the potential.
- beretguy 2y agoMicrosoft will probably encrypt that db or something to try to convince people it’s safe.
- andersa 2y agoThe real question is why the hell can said infostealer malware access the file. Can we PLEASE have proper per-process file access restrictions on Windows already - like MacOS has had for a decade now ????? Why is win32 app isolation still not done?
- buro9 2y agohttps://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-endpoint/enable-controlled-folders https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/defender-endpoint/enable-c... this works surprisingly well to prevent an app from going too far into folders it should not access. It's a bit opaque though, not as simple as *nix owner/group/everyone permissions.
- andersa 2y agoThis seems like a start, but just marking applications as "trusted" doesn't cut it. We need real rules like each program can only access its own installation folder, its own user data folder, and any folders the user has explicitly granted access to for that program. I may "trust" a video editing app, for example, so I can access my raw content folders. It should still be completely impossible for that process (or any spawned from it) to access my browser session information in case of an RCE from loading a malicious video.
- frankjr 2y ago2017: People are willingly buying a spy device to put into their homes. 2024: People are willingly activating a key logger.
- Shank 2y agoI actually think that was 2023 with Rewind. At least with Rewind you’ve gotta download the app yourself and run it. The in-progress OOBE setup for Recall does not even have an opt-out. Instead, it offers to open the settings panel after you’re done with setup, rather than just giving you an off switch: https://x.com/tomwarren/status/1796681578984182066 https://x.com/tomwarren/status/1796681578984182066
- TiredOfLife 2y ago2600 BCE: People are willingly writing their thoughts and experiences on papyrus
- tetris11 2y ago2600 AD: People are willingly writing their thoughts and experiences on papyrus
- 6510 2y agoRight, and having your own kinda stopped being a thing right then and there. We had Ted Kaczynski I suppose but we didn't quite understand what he was on about. Crass - Where Next Columbus? (1981) https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8lZUxHX8e8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U8lZUxHX8e8
- WhyNotHugo 2y agoI question the usage of the word "willingly". People aren't really aware of the consequences of their actions. The people of Troy didn't "willingly" bring in a huge wooden horse full of enemy soldiers. They "unknowingly" brought in a horse full of enemy soldiers.
- tetris11 2y ago2017: People are forced to swallow spy devices in order to continue to interact with their work/life communities 2024: People are forced to swallow keyloggers in order to continue to use their desktop PCs. Most don't know what they're agreeing to, because most people don't have the time to be experts in tech despite it affecting every factor of their lives, much in the same way that tech people don't have the time to be be farming and agriculture experts in their free time despite it affecting every factor of their lives.
- thrownawaysz 2y ago> because malware can now target a single file with huge amounts of valuable information By that logic password managers are also no-no.
- exe34 2y agodo you think there's a difference of scale here?
- soraminazuki 2y agoFor password managers, the alternative is password reuse. Big difference.
- isomorphic- 2y agoAt least the password manager I use has solid encryption. I can control where the file lives and what file permissions it has. For instance, I can keep it on a USB stick that I only insert when I need a password and then remove the stick afterwards. I do not remotely whatsoever trust Microsoft or Windows to keep their Recall database secure and offline. Attackers will know exactly where the file is, unlike with my password manager. There's no shortage of Windows privilege escalation exploits to gain TrustedInstaller status to read any file on the system.
- usrbinbash 2y agoExcuse me, when did password managers collect information about everything their users do on a massive scale?
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- cududa 2y agoNeither these two paragraphs or the source they’re paraphrasing (https://doublepulsar.com/recall-stealing-everything-youve-ever-typed-or-viewed-on-your-own-windows-pc-is-now-possible-da3e12e9465e https://doublepulsar.com/recall-stealing-everything-youve-ev...) indicate anything matching the headline at all. The source article is a QA with himself. There’s 1 tweet references, that shows a screenshot of a truncated SQLite db that shows a log of the applications opened via the user UI shell: https://x.com/gossithedog/status/1796218726808748367?s=46&t=J18CxvXnlT-e5_OdlgWfAw https://x.com/gossithedog/status/1796218726808748367?s=46&t=... Whoopty doo. There are many, many sources throughout Windows that can give you a list of recently opened applications (that have existed for 10-25 years)
- probably_wrong 2y agoI regularly get spam claiming that a hacker has compromised my device, has been filming me jerking off through my own webcam, and will send screenshots to my friends and family if I don't send them bitcoins. You know, the usual. Once Recall is out the story will go from laughable to worrying - all they'll have to do is change their text to include instructions to open Recall (the same way old websites would open 'file:///' to show they 'knew' what's on your PC) and regular people will lose their minds (and money). And then there's the age-old adage "if you can see it you can exfiltrate it" - it didn't work for DRM and it won't work here. Malware will steal this data.
- fifteen1506 2y agoI don't see Recall being axed. Disabled by feature flag? Sure. Disabled by default? Sure. Once Windows stops having administrator accounts, they'll enable it by default. As Smith would say, "it's inevitable".
- Xeamek 2y agowym by "Once Windows stops having administrator accounts"?
- fifteen1506 2y agoI may have dreamt this since I found no evidence online, but I thought "Windows 12" or similar would have only regular accounts. I assumed they would redirect filesystems calls for that, similar to the mechanism Windows Vista introduced and since has had no visible improvements.
- usrbinbash 2y ago> As Smith would say, "it's inevitable". To which I reply: sudo rm -rf /agents && echo "the only windows here are made of glass"
- dankobgd 2y agoImagine using windows in 2024
- jmkni 2y agoThe domestic abuse point is a chilling one An abuser being able to access their partners/kids computers and go and see every thing they have done is terrifying Can we just not do this at all?
- WhackyIdeas 2y agoYes, my ex would have loved to have used this to see everything I was doing on a computer… then dox all my private data to Facebook for a laugh.
- fragmede 2y agonannyware has existed for decades before this, just like tracking devices existed before Apple air tags.
- Slyfox33 2y agoYea but very few people install it. Now it comes prepackaged.
- mercurialsolo 2y agoBeyond the technology community I doubt that the loss of personal privacy is being discussed at large. Ad trackers had already made internet privacy a myth for the vast majority of the world; we now are seeing this permeate onto personal devices and subsequently to our environment with these always on, silently tracking devices - in the name of convenience. Perfect recall, no need for memory, available at your fingertips - with T&C that completely disregards your need for personal privacy. The challenge though is the "better" alternatives where a mix of privacy and convenience is there is not always convenient. We have and continue to be marketed convenience at the cost of privacy. What we need is consumer data privacy to really become a societal and government concern and for devices which infringe on this to really go through the same scruity as say a drug going thru FDA approval.
- curious_cat_163 2y ago> Beyond the technology community I doubt that the loss of personal privacy is being discussed at large. Actually, people in the US are worried about privacy in the age of AI. [1] [1] https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2023/10/18/how-americans-view-data-privacy/ https://www.pewresearch.org/internet/2023/10/18/how-american...
- makkesk8 2y agoI used to use Manictime[1] to achieve something similar, although, that was for time tracking purposes. But I can admit I've used it multiple times to find websites and documents that I forgotten the name of using the screenshots. But in essence, It suffers from the same flaws as Recall. [1] https://www.manictime.com https://www.manictime.com
- jstummbillig 2y agoI think, roughly, having good access to information is a super power (good being a mix of mostly: quick, simple, easy, accurate, free). My personal information is most valuable to me, so having access to that is specially powerful. The only way to make that happen is to store that information somewhere. The best way to do anything, that I just want the benefits of, is automatically. And now we are here. It feels monstrous but, to me, the above still stands. How to connect the dots to get to a place that feels good, I do not know. I would not be shocked if it turned out to be mostly about adjusting ourselves to it over time. But I am almost 100% positive we will all* want this super power, in some much better and much more complete form, in our future lives. And not being able to have it will feel absolutely silly, from there on out forever.
- temp3000 2y agoThe tradeoff is security and privacy. Important things. If you click the eye icon next to a password, or paste a secret to an env var you are now exploitable. If you have something you want to keep private or shred this is another place to delete (or forget to do so). So there are plenty of anti-benefits to this superpower.
- jstummbillig 2y agoI understand. Nobody* will care. People already have traded privacy and a comprehensive personality profile for silly streams of video, photos and text on social media for the past 20 years. Imagine what happens, when you get something immensely useful out of it. Today, nobody will work with you, if you are unable to manage E-Mail. In the future, nobody will work with you, if you can't properly use the time information dimension that this technology enables. You will simply look demented by comparison.
- temp3000 2y agoIf that is the case then like anything else let’s make it, well… good. And that includes making it safe, secure and privacy focused. A good delineation is your work PC will be spied on (assume anyone in the org can see what you are doing, even before this tech). Opting out of it on personal devices is fine. You wont look like an idiot or be refused work I am sure.
- wkat4242 2y ago> During testing this with an off the shelf infostealer, I used Microsoft Defender for Endpoint — which detected the off the shelve infostealer — but by the time the automated remediation kicked in (which took over ten minutes) my Recall data was already long gone. Yeah... This is a BIG issue with the modern generation of antimalware solutions. The old signature-based detection is great and immediate. But it has drawbacks. It only detects already-known malware. Not tailored stuff used only on one specific target. Also, malware can change its own signature adaptively. and hook into known-safe binaries. So, a modern antimalware uses AI learning and behavioural analysis. Why is notepad.exe suddenly logging all your keywords? Ban it. The problem is: This takes a while. The tool can be configured to block it before someone looks at it, but it still takes a while. At the point that this happens, the damage is often already done. At an enterprise level this is not a huge problem because it does mean the problem is detected, and by the time it is investigated it's possible to stop the source of the malware and ban it from all the other 100.000 PCs by using signature detection or other mitigations. On personal PCs this is more of an issue because they don't have a dedicated SOC (Security Operations Centre) jumping on to these things. Also, the noise level is an issue in the enterprise, set the detection threshold too high and your SOC gets overwhelmed by all the detections and becomes ineffective. Anyhow, this is indeed a good argument against Recall. When it was first introduced last week, people stated that it wasn't a big deal because malware can install its own key/screen logging. However a repository of the last 6 months of activity is indeed a very juicy target to exfiltrate quickly before detection.
- rakoo 2y agoI had to make it through 3/4 of the article before realizing that "Copilot+" is not, in fact, Copilot, or an enhanced version of it, but a line of computers. The marketing department also has some work to do.
- croes 2y agoSeems like the Key & Peele's Computer History sketch needs an update. https://youtu.be/s0lUbqDrFWU?si=47kGfhA-PVuctWep https://youtu.be/s0lUbqDrFWU?si=47kGfhA-PVuctWep NSFW
- rafaelgoncalves 2y agoThanks for the video. Like someone commented, i think too that this sketch will not get old so soon, more with all "AI" getting pushed.
- DarkmSparks 2y agoI dont even need to read beyond the title for a change, its been more than 10 years now since I have used windows in a business environment (linux on my main machine, mac for my second) and there is already no way I would go back to it. But good grief wtf. I was mostly joking when I said before MS was intentionally trying to kill windows, but is there actually any other explanation for implementing this "feature"?
- chx 2y agoThe real harm in Recall and I so much wish there was an authority who stepped in and slapped Microsoft into next week because of it: abusive relationships. Now your abuser can see everything you've done on your computer so if you try to get out your situation will worsen and also because of this you might not dare to seek help on said computer.
- chx 2y agoThe real harm in Recall and I so much wish there was an authority who stepped in and slapped Microsoft into next week because of it: abusive relationships. Now your abuser can see everything you've done on your computer so if you try to get out your situation will worsen and also because of this you might not dare to seek help on said computer.
- 6510 2y agoWhy stop there? It should also transcribe videos and everything said around the computer. Then, since it becomes possible to deduct the users opinion about just about everything if need be failing back on friends, family and coheard association it can also do our shopping and autofill the voting ballots silently on the background, without bothering me. I mean, I have no idea how to stop laughing inappropriately at the moment but I know the product exists, that it can be delivered to my doorstep and that I can afford it.
- croes 2y ago>Q. Are Microsoft a big, evil company? >A. No, that’s insanely reductive. They’re super smart people, and sometimes super smart people make mistakes. What matters is what they do with knowledge of mistakes. Never attribute to malice that which can be adequately explained by neglect, ignorance or incompetence. But >Q. Did Microsoft mislead the BBC about the security of Copilot >A. Yes. >Q. Have Microsoft mislead customers about the security of Copilot? >A. Yes. For example, they describe it as an optional experience — but it is enabled by default and people can optionally disable it. That’s wordsmithing. Maybe at some point we should reconsider.
- croes 2y agoSeems like the Key & Peele's Computer History sketch needs an update. https://youtu.be/s0lUbqDrFWU?si=47kGfhA-PVuctWep https://youtu.be/s0lUbqDrFWU?si=47kGfhA-PVuctWep NSFW
- chewz 2y agoI haven't typed or viewed anything on any Windows PC in like 15 years. And I think anyone shouldn't.... Keep pushing chaps...
- Grimeton 2y agoWhat a lot of people are missing in all this is that Microsoft is coming from one, dialing it up to eleven to then dial it back to 9. By pushing this onto people in a hard way they open the door to come up with a mitigating solution that later is far beyond what we had before recall but not as bad as what they pushed onto people in the first place. So they will reach their goal, as it was never 11, it was always 9.
- dancemethis 2y agomaybe not 9, to avoid breaking compatibility...
- TheAmazingRace 2y agoI understood this reference.
- lencastre 2y agoI didn’t… is because of Windows Nein?
- bravetraveler 2y agoHand wavy fears about the 9th version poorly string matching with 95 or 98 I guess
- Liquix 2y agoback in the day there was a healthy blend of win95, 98, ME, XP, and vista in the wild. it was common for devs to check for older versions with something like `if str(os.version)[0] == 9`. according to legend enough (internal?) software kept breaking that the solution became "don't put a 9 in the version number". iirc they officially stated it was because of how much people disliked win8.
- TheAmazingRace 2y ago
- JakeTehPwner 2y agoTime to stick to only gaming on windows. I’ll use a dedicated and locked down Linux box for everything else.
- labrador 2y agoWhen Steve Jobs said Microsoft had "no taste" to Bill Gates during an interview, I think one aspect of that is that Jobs had high EQ as well as high IQ. Jobs understood how people felt about products. Microsoft doesn't. When I worked at Microsoft I don't remember any conversations about how people would feel about a feature. That was awhile ago, but it looks like nothing has changed.
- loa_in_ 2y agoI think it's beyond the point when M$ makes "IQ choices" that are invasive. It's not a feeling, it's borderline rights violation, if not explicitly waived by EULA.
- paulryanrogers 2y ago> I think one aspect of that is that Jobs had high EQ as well as high IQ. Doubt. Jobs was a deadbeat dad for many years, refused to acknowledge his daughter or even admit that he named a computer after her, treated employees and cofounders like crap, etc. I think Jobs had a very low EQ, perhaps even a sociopath. He was just lucky, shrewd, and ruthless. Accounts of his last days indicate that even he regretted his behavior.
- labrador 2y agoI was speaking to what Steve Jobs had that made him successful, not to his messy behvior and personal life. A lot of great artists were borderline or full on terrible people. We still appreciate their art.
- paulryanrogers 2y agoEven professionally he doesn't seem "high EQ" to me. Often taking undeserved credit and shoving coworkers under buses when it was unnecessary, just for his own greed and ego. He may have even been emotionally manipulative. > A lot of great artists were borderline or full on terrible people. We still appreciate their art. Speak for yourself. Whenever I learn that an artist is a monster, I think appreciate their work much less. Thankfully much of Apple's success is due to the work of hundreds and thousands of others, not solely this "great man" whose worshipped among the faithful.
- dgellow 2y agoWelp, I said before I would wait and see instead of directly dismiss the feature, and now I have my answer. That will be another of these feature to hard disable after windows install…
- dreamcompiler 2y agoSeems to me like Microsoft probably sees Recall as a. A way to capture more personal data and sell it to advertisers, or b. A way to make Windows even more attractive to enterprise customers so that managers can snoop on employees, or c. A handy feature that most users will want. What Microsoft is saying publicly is c, which in itself is a red flag that suggests it's probably not true. The other red flag is that even as tone-deaf as Microsoft is about user wants and desires, even they can't be stupid enough to believe most users want this. So it's gotta be a or b or both.
- steelframe 2y agoI used to work on Windows at Microsoft, prior to Windows 10. I've always kept some Windows machines around because I felt that Windows was actually not that bad of an operating system, having personally reviewed a good amount of its source code and seen what the engineering culture was back at the time I was there. I gave ChromeOS a try for some machines I might otherwise have run Windows on, but I kept the Windows machines around for gaming and for the occasional oddball proprietary software package that some family member just had to have. About the time Google dropped its unofficial motto "Don't Be Evil" I started moving away from ChromeOS and back to trusty old Debian. I've recently purchased a Framework 16 with an AMD Radeon RX 7700S GPU and installed Arch Linux and Steam on it. All the games I care about playing at the moment, including Elden Ring and Baldur's Gate 3, run phenomenally well on it. It's 100% stable driving a 2560x1600 display at 60+fps with high graphics settings. I can plug in a PS5 controller and it "just works." With that I now feel truly free of anything Microsoft, in the sense that I don't feel like I'm making any compromises at all with how I want to use my computers by using Linux rather than Windows. I'm going to be installing Arch or Debian Linux on my remaining Windows boxen over the summer. So this is my final adieu, my old friend Microsoft. How far our paths have diverged since we first parted ways. Hit me up again when you've extricated your OS from your cloud and stopped showing ads and integrating privacy-hostile features. I won't be holding my breath though.
- WWLink 2y ago> I used to work on Windows at Microsoft, prior to Windows 10. I've always kept some Windows machines around because I felt that Windows was actually not that bad of an operating system, having personally reviewed a good amount of its source code and seen what the engineering culture was back at the time I was there. I'm curious how the culture was though. I always get the vibe that Microsoft has never been "end user oriented" if that makes sense. They always seemed to be making a product for other businesses. To this day, Windows, Office, and especially stuff like MS Teams feel like they were designed from the ground up for a heavily managed business environment with heavy surveillance and tight controls. Stuff like Telemetry and requiring MS accounts for logging into Windows 10+ seem more of a nod to employers. It's really amazing how much MS has been able to convince users to give controls of their own devices to MS/employers/others. Stuff like using Outlook on a personal phone giving the employer the ability to wipe the employee's phone. Like I don't think they have ever, in their years, seen end users of their products as "customers". I think they see businesses, sometimes independent developers, and advertising firms as their real customers.
- lencastre 2y agoI am not sure about this, but this new feature requires a dedicated AI chip (or maybe even a decent enough GPU), so,… here’s to hoping the guys behind shutup10 can integrate a patch to disable this.
- dmitrygr 2y ago> this new feature requires a dedicated AI chip It literally does not: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40543584 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40543584
- pizzaknife 2y agowhen is this ever going to end? computing is so promising but we use it for activities like this....
- torginus 2y agoIt's a thinly veiled ploy to get training data to train their generative AIs in user activity with the hopes of teaching AI the workflows of people, so it can replace them.
- rswail 2y agoCan't wait for the first corporate legal case where discovery requires them to present the entire history of a person's computer usage, not just their communications. If you're capturing screen shots, then how is something like using Signal or some other encrypted service still possible?
- iamleppert 2y agoI'm licking my lips at the possible market opportunities this will create! We will truly be able to create products to help shield folks from AI Recall and profit like crazy! It's a good time to be alive whenever we can profit!
- partiallypro 2y agoI have no problem with Recall if they give me granular controls on what apps it can and cannot monitor, and that I know it is stored only on my device. It not monitoring incognito isn't enough. If I'm working on a sensitive project, I don't want it looking at Word or Excel either. I don't want it looking at my remote desktop sessions, etc. That should all be able to be blocked. Until it is, I don't want it enabled. I'll still use Windows and look forward to the ARM chips, but I'm not enabling this until all of this is addressed. I can see how it could be very powerful and useful, especially for companies...but it needs controls, not just for myself, but also ones that IT itself could implement in enterprise settings.
- perryizgr8 2y agoI don't know why there's such a big controversy around this. It sounds like any other feature that stores data on your device. How do you think your iPhone shows you screen time stats? It tracks every click every tap and stores it to disk. If you don't like a feature you can turn it off. Personally it sounds interesting and I want to try it out to see if it helps me remember stuff.
- Throwthrowbob 2y agoUsers are noticing: https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/how-to-delete-recall-and-all-ai-permanently/2b55f3be-6b4c-4a05-bfb8-475497603efb https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/how-to... https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/https://answers.microsoft.com/en-us/windows/forum/all/how-to-delete-recall-and-all-ai-permanently/2b55f3be-6b4c-4a05-bfb8-475497603efb https://web.archive.org/web/20240000000000*/https://answers....
- almazzz 2y ago[dead]