14 ms·
Show HN: Every mountain, building and tree shadow mapped for any date and time
I've been working on this project for about 4 years. It began as terrain only because world wide elevation data was publicly available. I then added buildings from OpenStreetMap (crowd sourced) and more recently from Overture Maps data. Some computer vision/machine learning advancements [1] in the past few years have made it possible to estimate tree canopy heights using satellite imagery alone making it possible to finally add trees to the map. The data isn't perfect, but it's within +/- 3 meters of so. Good enough to give a general idea for any location on Earth. Happy to answer any questions.
[1] https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-023-02206-6 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41559-023-02206-6
- manuelmoreale 2y agoRelated product: https://shadowmap.org/ https://shadowmap.org/
- dalmo3 2y agoI've signed up for shadow map while house hunting and it was worth every cent. Shade map just crashes my phone every time.
- smusamashah 2y agoThe sun view with angles clearly displayed is very informative on this one. EDIT: Lots of features are not free though. Pricing dialog keeps popping up when you click around things.
- VenturingVole 2y agoI love this - I was looking for something exactly like it yesterday and you've built it. Specifically, I was looking to factor in shading to work out the likely amount of solar panels I'd need for both electricity and solar hot water across the seasons. Nice - great work!
- codingminds 2y agoI love the idea, but sadly it's not very precise in our case. There are even buildings on the property that - as far as I know - never existed in that place.
- VenturingVole 2y agoThis looks fantastic - well done for putting so much effort in to creating it. Literally a few days ago I was looking for something exactly like it, so that I could work out the likely amount of solar panels I'd require when factoring in seasonal shadows cost. I imagine the solar industry to be a target market of yours and wish you lots of luck with growing it.
- goliathDown 2y agoHow are you handling shading for dense wooded areas? I'm looking around at some neighborhoods with dense redwood trees in the northern California region. I know in the middle of the day a decent amount of shadow will still be in the area, which comes from the density of the forest and the length of the trees. From what I'm seeing, this shading is not accurate to the wooded areas I frequent. But, that's probably a really hard problem to tackle. If there's no data on tree height, it seems impossible to accurately portray shadow extrapolations for forests. Especially since the forests can have a high frequency of change. Super cool project, I hope this continues to grow!
- AlexDragusin 2y agoA cool use of this is to visually identify clusters of tall buildings, usually business districts and the distance and relationship to the other clusters and the areas in between. Set it around 7AM and an appropiate zoom and start thinking of business ideas.
- dexzod 2y agoIs it accurate though?. If I fix the time and slide by the month, I expect the shadow to move east to west, but it only grows or shortens, which would mean the sun is exactly at the same vertical line on ground every day of the year but the height above horizon changes.
- dolmen 2y agoIt fun to do that (lock the time, slide by day) and see what happens on DST change.
- semi-extrinsic 2y agoIt shouldn't be on a vertical line, it should follow the solar analemma for your location. It's essentially trivial to add this, I think the creator just needs to add equation of time correction?
- kpennell 2y agothis is amazing
- SideburnsOfDoom 2y agoChecked my specific area. Has shadow from a tree that fell over and was removed 6 months ago.
- jakubmazanec 2y agoI'm sorry, but for 18:00 Dvořáková street in Brno, Czechia, it is very inaccurate. It shows half of the street without shadow - but I know empirically the whole street is in shadow. Great idea and awesome implementation (fast and instantly responsive!), but sadly useless.
- davidw 2y agoThis is pretty cool. I bet you could sell something like this to real estate people. It's useful to see what kind of shade a place gets in, say, January.
- dolmen 2y agoIt would have more potential for sellers of solar panels... if it had the shape of roofs right (which it doesn't as I look to my house).
- davidw 2y agoSure, that'd be good too, but even for real estate... it'd be good for someplace that's colder and darker in the winter to get an idea of what things are like. For instance this fancy neighborhood on the hill has expensive housing, but in January it's already getting pretty dark quite early: https://shademap.app/@44.07882,-121.32535,13.88804z,1704151791358t,0b,0p,0m https://shademap.app/@44.07882,-121.32535,13.88804z,17041517...
- refulgentis 2y agoThank you so much for doing this. Sublime and moving in a way only things that are novel and required a ton of effort can be. Visualizing over time and seeing this gave me an interpretation of sunrise as removing shadows, and sunset adding them, gave me goosebumps.
- paiute 2y agoHas the trees on my property pretty spot on. Kind of creepy.
- codingdave 2y agoFirst off, this is cool and well done. I did notice an oddity, but the fact that we're all complaining about oddities and edge cases (pardon the pun) shows how well done it is. In any case, the wonky thing I noticed is that it effectively shows shadows on the edges of forests, but not on the forests themselves (at least in my area).
- n_plus_1_acc 2y agoI had the same issue.
- sndean 2y agoDoes anyone know if the shadow of the Washington Monument actually reaches the Potomac River in the morning? [1] That'd be cool to see, but seems like the sun would never be bright enough at 6:30 AM. [1] https://shademap.app/@38.88916,-77.03523,14.41656z,1717151250683t,0b,0p,0m,qd2FzaGluZ3RvbiBkYw==!38.9038!-77.04013 https://shademap.app/@38.88916,-77.03523,14.41656z,171715125...
- davidmurphy 2y agoI'd like to see outdoor park / landscape designers actually think of shade issues when thinking of shade umbrellas, shade roof overheads, etc. I used to work outdoors somewhere where the "shade" providing roof and umbrellas were useless many hours of the day, due to the actual position of the sun.
- bcjordan 2y agoYou might consider making a tool for wireless internet service providers and mapping Crown Castle / other roof antenna space services. This would be really helpful in determining uplink reach (just may need some parameters on roof-top blocking structures)
- sershe 2y agoNice project, but I wouldn't claim 3m precision, at least not around steep terrain. I checked if I can use it for climbing areas, and a spot around here that goes in the shade around 1pm this time of year is still shown in full sun around 3-4pm.
- bicx 2y agoI’ve wanted to build an app that could estimate total solar energy generation for boondocking RVers (meaning the position changes a lot), and if what others are saying about the paid version is correct, this seems like an intriguing way to improve solar energy generation estimates.
- re 2y agoAt zoom levels where buildings aren't loaded, they're treated as casting no shadow, which causes the site to hugely underestimate the amount of shade for dense urban areas. I can see how this would be a hard problem if you're doing the shadow rendering on the client side, but is it something that you have thought about trying to solve?
- oblib 2y agoI'm impressed! I live on a forested ridge above a horseshoe bend in a big lake and there's a fairly steep hill behind our home. Our home is surrounded by big oak trees but there is a big front yard that's all lawn, and behind us there is a lot of open space where we have a pretty big garden and a pretty steep hill below that is forest with big hardwood trees. It pretty much nails down when and where it's shady.
- vjerancrnjak 2y agoExcellent. Now an app giving directions that maximize walking in the shade, or the sun, can easily be built.
- dyauspitr 2y agoDefinitely not right for my 30 acres. Doesn’t take into account that more than half is covered by trees.
- thomasben 2y agoNice projet ! I didn’t know such a tool existed. Will definitely use it when changing home !
- liampulles 2y agoMy and my neighbours properties are not correctly rendered here... that's almost certainly due to my being in South Africa and the data not being that rich in my area - still a very cool tool though!
- kolinko 2y agoChecked it on my neighborhood in Warsaw and wow - it seems to work well
- jjslocum3 2y agoDoesnt work for the map around my home. While the buildings in my neighborhood generate shadows on the map, none of the trees do.
- irrational 2y agoIs this using my browser's location to center the map? Because the starting place was close to my house, so I assume that is the case. This doesn't seem to be taking trees into account. My neighborhood is filled with douglas firs that are 200+ feet tall and cast a lot of shade.
- xjm 2y agoThe Eiffel tower's is fun (:
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- surfingdino 2y agoSuch a useful tool for photographers! Thanks!
- imp0cat 2y agoNice! If you park on the street, you can use this to figure out where to park to keep your car cooler during summer.
- carbocation 2y agoVery cool. I looked at the Bay Bridge and it gets the towers but probably not the bridge itself (this is a trivial point except for folks right by the bridge, but fun to look for edge cases).
- thih9 2y agoHere it is not showing any shadows in Honolulu mid-May around noon: https://shademap.app/@21.30371,-157.85237,16.56781z,1716848914555t,0b,0p,0m!1717122008477!1717182568921,qaGF3YWlp!21.30455!-157.85568 https://shademap.app/@21.30371,-157.85237,16.56781z,17168489... Which is how it should be[1]; cool! [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lahaina_Noon https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lahaina_Noon
- alentred 2y agoVery nice. I was considering installing a few PV panels and was looking for something like this to estimate the solar exposure in various time periods. Works nicely to get an initial idea.
- guiraldelli 2y agoI guess this calculator [1] and tools such as [2] and [3] might help you, as well. [1]: https://re.jrc.ec.europa.eu/pvg_tools/en/tools.html https://re.jrc.ec.europa.eu/pvg_tools/en/tools.html [2]: https://findmyshadow.com/ https://findmyshadow.com/ [3]: http://shadowcalculator.eu/ http://shadowcalculator.eu/
- Euphorbium 2y agoWow, I had such an idea years ago when walking under blazing sun following gps directions, I wished that it would plan the route according to shade.
- lithiumii 2y agoA Chinese map (https://www.amap.com/ https://www.amap.com/) has it, but only for some cities in China.
- eevilspock 2y agoI've thought of and yearned for this too. Conversely, in the winter I'd like a path with maximum sun exposure. There's a dark and a troubled side of life; There's a bright and a sunny side, too; Tho' we meet with the darkness and strife, The sunny side we also may view. Keep on the sunny side, always on the sunny side, Keep on the sunny side of life; It will help us every day, it will brighten all the way, If we keep on the sunny side of life.
- kilian 2y agoWhen it doesn't have height data it seems to set every building to the same height. Interesting, but it does make it inaccurate in my country.
- cr125rider 2y agoOpenStreetMaps is pretty coarse with building heights. Seemingly just an integer with most buildings being 1 (stories?) from what I’ve seen.
- Aachen 2y agoI don't have this data at hand, and often it's hard to see from out front or differs for different parts of the building. So while an avid OpenStreetMap contributor, I rarely add height info to buildings Perhaps I should look into high resolution height data (that is, high enough that an individual building shows up at all) with licenses that allow use in OSM and at least tag the buildings that show having a mostly uniform height. For example in the Netherlands, AHN is amazing (hundreds of points per tree! It looks like a 3d wireframe render of the entire country, truly amazing) but the license is not permissive enough.
- Kim_Bruning 2y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HnOJirSCn8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1HnOJirSCn8 Due to the initial location, an extra verse can now be added to this song. (About a little Café in Sneek that is somehow tenuously linked to pretty much everything)
- simonbarker87 2y agoThis site is great but it's only an approximation. We've used this website for years for checking the sun in various potential homes and holiday rentals. It's a half decent approximation but it doesn't really have proper height data (I think it's using standard building classification from Open Street Map data?) so it's only a guide.
- dolmen 2y agoIt definitely has no data about roof shapes.
- noduerme 2y agoFunnily enough... it's completely missing the vacation rental mini chalet my neighbors built which casts shade over most of my backyard. I suppose this means it won't be missed on any surveys if it mysteriously gets knocked down.
- jodrellblank 2y agoI’m surprised; I was thinking they might buy a few satellite photos through a sunny day and just… look at where the shadows are (with code). Maybe working back from that could feedback how high the buildings might be.
- martyvis 2y agoThey seem to have proper shadow information. I live in a semi-rural village and shadows from trees along our street are quite accurate ( and seem to be based on one section before it was cleared a year ago or so)
- simonbarker87 2y agoThe trees thing seems to be new, I’m not sure I’ve noticed that before
- Woeps 2y agoPlus it seems to be missing a boat load of trees in the streets. But it's pretty cool overall! And I'll keep it in mind as we're in the process of looking for a new home.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- thih9 2y agoRelated mapbox-gl-shadow-simulator source code: https://github.com/ted-piotrowski/mapbox-gl-shadow-simulator https://github.com/ted-piotrowski/mapbox-gl-shadow-simulator
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- crtified 2y agoI don't know how the mechanics of it would work, but some kind of local accuracy index would be very useful in such broad maps. Because the elephant in the room with most global dataset compilations is that the accuracy varies greatly from place to place. Some countries or regions have detailed data, others have generic or unclassified blobs. Some data is older, some is newer. An ideal tool reduces the need for detailed provenance checking upon every usage.
- igtztorrero 2y agoimpressive, wonderful gem of software, super useful for companies that install solar cells. congratulations, it is a very good job.
- mikkom 2y agoI just had to check some really rural places and went to some random village in tibet. As there is no information about trees or buildings there, just roads, it surprisingly doesn't work - it just shows some shadows based on terrain heights in middle of empty village road grid. So as expected, if the site has height information it can draw shadows but definitely not for "every building" etc that the title claims.
- faraggi 2y agowell... of course?
- mikkom 2y agoI personally thought the interesting part of the submission was the "every" of the title, ie there might have been some AI algo that could have somehow approximated height and shadows based on multiple satellite images or use some data that is not available for everyone (hence the "every" could have applied) Currently it's an approximation of shadows based on unreliable open data which is nice but not that special.
- HeatrayEnjoyer 2y agoThey shouldn't be using "every". It sounds like the kind of thing American programmers say.
- davidmurdoch 2y agoSome people still thinks words should mean what they mean.
- davidmurdoch 2y agoThe irony that I've written a typo in a comment about words is not lost on me.
- tetris11 2y agoFirst time I've seen my workplace as the default centre for a map like this. Someone from the Technische Fakultät did this?
- worksonmine 2y agoIt's not a default center it's just your IP address and will change for everyone.
- t1c 2y agoIt's location based. The default place on the map for me was the Airbnb I'm staying at right now
- zild3d 2y agoIP geocoding based
- abdusco 2y agoLooks useful for photography. You can see where the light and shadow areas will be and plan out where and when to go.
- Waterluvian 2y agoI made an application like this waaaaay back in grad school. The hardest part is that it looks believable but getting accurate data is just so difficult. And behold, it’s missing the entire forest my street is in.
- rwmj 2y agoOne thing I often wonder is do car crashes happen more frequently when the sun is low in the sky and facing traffic? Surely someone has got together the data on traffic accidents, maps, times and a model of the earth/sun to work this out! (Google search results for this are full of spam from a mix of motor insurance companies and sunglass companies)
- tazlor 2y agoThere is a section of I-70 in Colorado that experiences temporary closures due to severe sun glare at certain times of the day and year. https://www.codot.gov/travel/sunglare https://www.codot.gov/travel/sunglare
- jnsaff2 2y agoPerplexity thinks yes. https://www.perplexity.ai/page/Do-Car-Crashes-kmZIsMnbR4qcdxteR.12yg https://www.perplexity.ai/page/Do-Car-Crashes-kmZIsMnbR4qcdx...
- Aachen 2y agoCouldn't tell you where I've read this but I heard years ago that it makes a difference indeed. Now I'm wondering if that was just the person who said or wrote it just giving an example of what kind of considerations you need to incorporate when optimising for safety, or if they actuality had data on this
- kfarr 2y agoYes
- grecy 2y agoAs a young driver I was given the advice that if you see a lot of oncoming cars using their sunshade or squinting into the sun as they come towards you, it's time to pull over and wait it out. Driving with the sun at your back is never a good time to be on the road.
- dolmen 2y agoCrossing the road as a pedestrian neither.
- joshspankit 2y agoA tall tree on my street was lost last year: it shows the shadow for it even though it’s not on the satellite image. Now I wonder where it gets the tree data from.
- kylecazar 2y agoSimilar situation here with a patch of trees. From the About: "The shadows displayed by default are estimates gathered through indirect means like crowd sourcing and low resolution data." Not sure what low resolution data they are using for the trees (I can't imagine mine were crowdsourced given I'm the only house around). Probably not worth it for me but apparently the premium version has more accurate/current data.
- sandos 2y agoIt says it is using openstreetmap, so you can probably edit that tree if its added to OSM.
- joshspankit 2y agoAfter reading this I went through all the OSM datasets I could see (including double-checking the layers) and none of them showed the tree. Now I’m even more curious.
- Workaccount2 2y agoIt's coming from public LIDAR data, which captures both trees and the ground below them (and is able to tell which is which).
- joshspankit 2y agoCan you point to which LIDAR dataset? I did not see any openstreetmap datasets with the tree present.
- virtualritz 2y agoGoogle maps in the browser on desktop had a similar feature when you zoomed in enough to see building footprints. It showed shadows for current time of day, based on building height and -footprint. I used it all the time, in the summers of 2014/2015 to pick places to have lunch at, that were in the sun, when I had a corporate job in the center of Berlin. It stopped working/being displayed at some time, don't remember which year after it was. I guess not many people knew about it and the discontinuation of it can be booked under "general enshittification of Google products".
- dpierce9 2y agoAt the time they had an advertising product they were offering to solar installers based on site quality that used this feature. If I had to guess they probably stopped offering it when that product didn’t take off.
- NemoNobody 2y agoStuff like this reminds me how awesome people can be
- dmd 2y agoThis doesn't seem to have ANY of the trees in my neighborhood (in Massachusetts) even though there are just tons of very large ones.
- dmd 2y agoAlso, apparently no trees cast a shadow at noon?
- xkcd-sucks 2y ago+1 at this time of year it is simply incorrect in my location per my understanding of what a "shadow" is, unless their definition is like complete occlusion in the dead of winter or something
- nottorp 2y ago"Worldwide trees" is just marketing. I just checked and it has no trees where i live. It does have the buildings although if i look out the window their shadows are a tiny bit too short for my location.
- strogonoff 2y agoIf you are a photographer, I can recommend Sun Seeker on iOS. It integrates with compass (so you can see, e.g., where the sun will rise/set in real time), but also has this map mode showing sun position relative to terrain, angle relative to horizon, etc., at a given time of any day. Though it doesn’t try to paint shadows (which I think would be error-prone anyway for most locations), it is a one-time purchase that costs comparatively little and does not try to upsell a premium version.
- interloxia 2y agoThe buildings boxes are a bit misleading, at least of the places I checked. It would be nice to have some sort of visulaisation of the height data that they use. I really like the Annual Sunlight and hours in the sun layers. It's really nice to be able to instantly see the shading at different times of the year without having to awkwardly select a date.
- tecleandor 2y agoI've used it a couple times to show how the new luxury towers they're building in my neighborhood block the sun to the older/cheaper low-rise homes... :(
- goqu 2y agoThis is so useful when buying a house in the country that sun is as valuable as gold and you want to maximise it in the backyard. Great tool.
- dolmen 2y agoYou especially want to maximise the sun to light your solar panels.
- wesamco 2y agoHow the heck did it automatically pan the map to my current location, my small town, in an Incognito window, on page load? Is IP geolocation this accurate and accessible to every website nowadays? If this website can do this I assume every website I visit can do it too?
- antod 2y agoMine started in a different city about 520km away. And I wasn't incognito. Probably a lot more to do with your country, your ISP or coincidence than anything else.
- mcslambley 2y agoI can't speak for this website specifically but Cloudflare makes it pretty easy to geolocate users based on request headers.
- xp84 2y agoIt is very cheap and easy. Even the free versions of the database available from maxmind are plenty accurate for town level. At my last job, I built a little docker image that used the free maxmind DB and kept it up to date, and ran a node server which returned some JSON telling estimated lat/long, city name, country, etc.
- regularfry 2y agoCheap, easy, and wrong. It puts me a clear 800km away from where I'm actually sitting, and I'm sitting in a major UK city. It's put me on the wrong continent before now. That was fun.
- littlestymaar 2y ago> It's put me on the wrong continent before now What did you expect after leaving Europe? /s
- wesamco 2y agoI guess the accuracy really depends on your location or ISP. I believe my ISP rarely or never rotates IP addresses, and on top of that I think my ISP provided router is assigned an IPv6 address and it prioritizes using it, because when I visit whatismyipaddress.com with JS disabled, it can only show my IPv6 address, but if I enable JS it can show an IPv4 address too (I assume through the WebRTC IP leak method, which requires JS)
- nnyms1 2y agoA similar app that I found recently (as they were nominated for an Apple Design Award) that does this is Sunlitt [0]. Very polished and generally well designed. [0]: https://www.sunlitt.app https://www.sunlitt.app
- js8 2y agoIs there a tool that could convert OSM map into a perspective view from a given location? And show what peaks and notable buildings are visible?
- davidmurdoch 2y ago"Every" seems to be a bit of a stretch trees part. It's got maybe 5% of the tree shadows near me.
- BurningFrog 2y agoWeirdly, it's got ~1/4 of the buildings in my downtown area.
- dangerwill 2y agoSuper cool! But it seems to think that very small elevation changes are like mountains. The couple small hills in my local park don't cast a shadow haha.
- janpmz 2y agoThe Nazca lines in Peru seem to align with the shadows of the mountain, I made two videos to demonstrate it: https://x.com/janBuild/status/1796472554905022785 https://x.com/janBuild/status/1796472554905022785 In the second video, you can see that the shadow seems to align with a curved line during summer solstice: https://x.com/janBuild/status/1796473232658518133 https://x.com/janBuild/status/1796473232658518133
- thinkingemote 2y agoInteresting! The area is at the tropics so there's not much shadows for the majority of the day. And it seems as if its only very early in the morning where these shadows occur. A small change in time and the shadow changes greatly. Equally a very small variation in elevation of the mountain and plain may give different results.
- Terr_ 2y agoHmmm... I'm not an astronomer, and I wondered if they might have once been more-exact. It seems that while Earth's orbit has long term variations (eccentricity, obliquity, precession) the shortest of those cycles is still quite a lot longer than the estimated age of the Nazca lines. (Precession with a 26ky cycle, Nazca lines at 1.5 to 2.5ky.)
- DoctorOetker 2y agothe shadow of the smaller and smaller peaks seems to also touch/trace thinner and thinner lines, these lines seem very different compared to the actual animal depictions in other Nazca lines. Could these lines be explained by diffrent rates of photosynthesis / occasional vegetation debsity variations selectively protecting the soil from erosion? One nature demarcates curves, humans and animals will adapt to them in their choice of path.
- blastro 2y agoWow! This is an awesome observation
- renewiltord 2y agoWow, is this a novel theory? That is the first time I’ve heard of it.
- deckar01 2y agoIf anyone builds a version of this that accepts crowd sourced phone images to increase the accuracy with photogrammetry (before I get around to it) I will give you shademaps.com.
- temp3000 2y agoCould also source this from images uploaded to Google etc?
- jblindsay 2y agoI love this, although I do wonder how accurate it is, given the likely limited underlying elevation data source. It reminds me a lot of an application for creating shadow animations based on digital elevation models that I wrote some time back https://www.whiteboxgeo.com/manual/wbw-user-manual/book/tool_help_wbwpro.html#shadow_animation https://www.whiteboxgeo.com/manual/wbw-user-manual/book/tool...
- mlhpdx 2y agoI’ve been watching shadows for the last 90 minutes and I have to says this tool isn’t perfect, but it’s pretty good.
- nayuki 2y agoRelatedly, I use this website to visualize what angle the sun is coming from: https://www.suncalc.org/ https://www.suncalc.org/
- gHA5 2y agoI'm glad to see this website working again, years ago it broke because they couldn't afford Google Maps costs.
- c0nsumer 2y agoFirst, I went and looked at my house... It's got a lot of tall oak trees near by and in a park across the street. It shows it almost completely in daylight save for building shadows, which is really wrong even right now as most of the house is shaded by trees. Then I see an upgrade button... and it wants me to pay. Yet I can't even validate the data passes a sniff test. Their free tier very much doesn't.
- Jabrov 2y agoI feel like the paid version is actually a bit better for trees
- c0nsumer 2y agoIt may be, but without a way to see that, why would I ever consider paying?
- ok_dad 2y agoYea the shadow data for my area is hilariously wrong. It’s missing a whole forest that shades my house and a road nearby.
- antod 2y agoMine still has a forest next door that was cut down 8-9 yrs ago.
- tppiotrowski 2y agoBy default the tree shadows appear as they would from an airplane, so you would not see any shadows at noon as the top of the canopy is completely in the sun. Try changing to "below canopy" in the Settings and you might see the missing shadows.
- iandanforth 2y agoThe map near my house is so wrong as to be almost unrecognizable.
- brfox 2y agoManhattenhenge: https://shademap.app/@40.75481,-73.98696,14.82042z,1717027946176t,0b,0p,0m!1717147714273!1717201304231 https://shademap.app/@40.75481,-73.98696,14.82042z,171702794... https://www.amnh.org/research/hayden-planetarium/manhattanhenge https://www.amnh.org/research/hayden-planetarium/manhattanhe...
- aembleton 2y agoIts got far more buildings on this map than Open Street Map. Where are they getting the data from, and can it be added to Open Street Map?
- rascul 2y agoAccording to this, a significant area around the front of my house is quite shaded. In reality, it's in full sun. It also doesn't show my backyard being mostly shaded.
- I_o_IllI__o_I 2y ago[dead]
- fckgw 2y agoVery helpful to figure out what seats in a stadium would be best to avoid the afternoon sun.
- Carrok 2y agoViewing Boulder, CO at 8PM is fun to see how the mountains really blot out the sun.
- fscaramuzza 2y agoAs others have done, I first looked for my house. I noticed something I hadn't noticed ever, namely a spot in the neighborhood that is shaded for most of the day. A good trick to know when summer comes and you want to keep your car cool.
- gmiller123456 2y agoIt'd be more useful if they explained why some of the data is so inaccurate, so you could decide what to trust and what not to. In my neighborhood I found some houses not casting shadows, or partial shadows, lot of missing trees, and houses casting shadows onto themselves in ways they can't.
- lupire 2y agoHalf the trees in my neighborhood are missing.
- settsu 2y agoI thought there was a problem with some calculation that only occurred in early March and November (which can be observed by dragging the calendar slider.) Then I realized the "problem" was the Daylight Saving Time changes... existential sigh (Where do I submit a pull request to address that obvious bug??)
- dolmen 2y agoThe bug is that the time displayed should be the local time of the area, an in particular the correct date for the DST change. So the jump in shadows due to DST change in March should not be on the same day in Paris than in New-York.
- underbooter 2y ago[dead]
- anothername12 2y agoSeeing shadows on opposing sides of similar buildings in the same area as me.
- dang 2y agoRelated: Using Lidar to map tree shadows - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36658001 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=36658001 - July 2023 (41 comments) Shade Map Pro - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30532286 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=30532286 - March 2022 (12 comments) Show HN: 3D map of shade around the world - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29827943 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29827943 - Jan 2022 (71 comments) Map of shadows at any place and time - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29681693 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=29681693 - Dec 2021 (4 comments) Show HN: GPX replay map that shows terrain shadows during activities - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28854959 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28854959 - Oct 2021 (14 comments)