16 ms·
The rise of the disposable car
- rntn 2y agohttps://archive.ph/N4uIU https://archive.ph/N4uIU
- pfdietz 2y agoFor a humorous and oddly interesting YouTube view on what happens to bad engines in cars, see the I Do Cars YouTube channel. Come for the oil starvation, stay for the newly installed inspection ports. On a good day, he'll get some parts to sell from each core. He also occasionally goes through the process of pulling usable parts from an entire junked car. https://www.youtube.com/@I_Do_Cars https://www.youtube.com/@I_Do_Cars
- pjbk 2y agoYes! Enjoyable and I have learned a lot about how car engines work and are built watching it. And how some companies (cough - Audi - cough) intentionally overengineer their designs so much to boost service and repair cash flows.
- hindsightbias 2y agoI'll add: https://www.youtube.com/@TheCarCareNut https://www.youtube.com/@TheCarCareNut SUVs and smaller trucks are now almost universally moving to 4cyl and 6cyl turbos with iffy CVTs. The channels run by folks with greasy overalls are pretty uniform in saying these vehicles won't last like their predecessors (even the Toyotas).
- yareally 2y agoIs this a genuine sentiment or just people upset that their favorite vehicle won't have a massive gas guzzling engine anymore? There are a number of people that also dislike trucks with aluminum bodies, despite that aluminum alloys can be strong (aircraft use them all the time) and it keeps your truck from turning into a rust bucket after 5 years of snowy winters. Car ownership is not always a rational thing and people will defend some strange platforms based only on emotion. How are the CVTs in these trucks iffy compared to other CVTs? There's a number of reliable auto makers using CVTs for years, such as Subaru, Honda and even Toyota on their other vehicles. CVT transmissions have been in mass produced cars longer than most of us have been alive.
- pfdietz 2y agoCVTs are also much cheaper to manufacture than traditional transmissions.
- yareally 2y agoThat doesn't alone make them terrible though. CVTs have less complexity, so they will be cheaper. Dependable cars have CVTs for reasons other than cheapness. For example, a dual clutch transmission is complex and expensive, but at the same time, I wouldn't call it better. There's tradeoffs in all types of transmissions. My car might have one, but if I were driving a truck, I don't think I would want a DSG.
- pfdietz 2y agoIndeed, that was not a criticism.
- jandrese 2y agoWhich also makes them cheaper to replace, which is good because you will likely need to replace it at least once in the lifetime of the car.
- Brian_K_White 2y agoBoth turbos and cvts are genuinely a reliability downgrade. It's because of fundamental and unavoidable reasons in each case. This applies to all vehicles, old or new, including ones they've already been used in for years like how turbo is a standard part of practically all large deisels. "a number of reliable auto makers using CVTs for years" is an utterly valueless statement. It says, proves, disproves, or even merely indicates, nothing. There are countless reasons for any company to do anything, including for a "reliable" automaker to use a less-reliable part or design. Both turbos and cvts increase gas mileage. Simple as that. That one thing has become so important that it's now worth sacrificing other things to get it.
- vel0city 2y agoCVTs (generally) rely on belts sliding on cones. With more weight, you need more torque, with more torque you get more wear on the internal components. This is a big reason why CVTs have historically targeted smaller cars instead of larger trucks. When it comes to motor reliability, generally speaking a smaller engine with higher compression running closer to its peak output all the time will have more wear than a slightly larger engine that doesn't have to run at as high of pressures and load percentage. Lower RPMs needed for the same power output means less friction on all the components in the motor. There's a lot of variances in that so it is not exactly a given. These kind of go away with more modern "eCVTs" which don't rely on belts and hybrid systems which can help even out that peak engine load challenge. But still, turbos will generally reduce your reliability. More moving parts, higher pressures, etc. The questions are, will the increased efficiency balance out the reduced reliability and will the motor reliability be the thing that does the car in at the end.
- dragontamer 2y agohttps://www.spglobal.com/mobility/en/research-analysis/average-age-of-vehicles-in-the-us-increases-to-122-years.html https://www.spglobal.com/mobility/en/research-analysis/avera... The opposite. With cars reaching much more advanced ages today, when a collision happens it's a write-off. The modern car isn't 'disposable'. In fact, all statistics point to us holding onto cars longer today than ever before. Today's cars are the most durable that they've ever been.
- dsalfdslfdsa 2y agoThe OP's article was careful to make this distinction, and I think it's very interesting (as well as being the crucial point of the article). Cars are now more reliable and last longer, but when they do develop a problem, it's less economically viable to repair them.
- dragontamer 2y agoThe definition of 'Totaled' is when a comparable car on the used market can replace your vehicle for less than or equal to the repair costs. As such, it makes no sense to repair a totaled vehicle. You should instead buy a comparable used vehicle. But saying the word 'Disposable' is pretty bad with regards to the headline. It doesn't capture the full effect of what the stats are showing. That is, we are all keeping vehicles for longer. Longer miles, longer life. Repair costs for old vehicles always grows as old parts tend to be harder to find (factories have shifted production to newer vehicles. So you are forced to look for scrap). Meanwhile, older cars lose more and more value as they age.
- StableAlkyne 2y ago> As such, it makes no sense to repair a totaled vehicle. You should instead buy a comparable used vehicle. I sometimes wonder how much the carbon footprint of the auto industry would change if people preferred to fix them instead of throwing the whole thing away just because of a fender bender or an expensive part broke
- beretguy 2y agoTangential but related: There are full parking lots with brand new cars that go under press or get disassembled for parts because dealership don’t want sell them at a cheaper prices. https://www.costulessdirect.com/blog/where-brand-new-unsold-cars-go-to-die/ https://www.costulessdirect.com/blog/where-brand-new-unsold-... From article: > the unsold cars that are older than two years old, will have no alternative but to be either crushed, dismantled and/or their parts recycled. Want to see for yourself? Do a quick search on Google Maps of Baltimore, Maryland, looking south of Broening Hwy in Dundalk, there you will see a massive expanse of space where many unsold cars are currently parked.
- ip26 2y agoEvery day in the United States, a large number of cars are being produced. Most of these cars never get sold to customers because people just can’t afford them. Oh yes, that makes perfect sense, every day they make 100 cars and then scrap more than 50 of them. The car manufacturing industry can’t stop producing new automobiles because they would have to close their factories and lay off thousands of their workers. Right, layoffs, that never happens.
- hn_throwaway_99 2y agoYeah, I thought the actual premise was interesting (I'm sure there is a good amount of unsold inventory that is recycled/destroyed/etc., just like in any goods industry) and was interested to learn more about the mechanics of the process, but that article was just ridiculous - 0 actual numbers and it felt like it was written by a third grader.
- bluGill 2y agoLayoffs do happen, but they are hard to do because the auto makers are selling some cars. The factory works at one speed, and so if they sell 100 cars but make 200 what can they do. The above is why companies try to do just in time manufacturing. However this is always easier on paper than the real world. Those factories need to shutdown for a week-several months every year to repair tools and rearrange for the next model year, and they need some cars saved up for that. In addition other disasters mean sometimes they can't get parts and so there is more reason to have a buffer of unsold cars.
- dsalfdslfdsa 2y agoObviously we need technological development, to keep everyone in a job. What when we cannot maintain or afford those systems? This includes systems of production, as well as the products themselves.
- jseliger 2y agoI live in Phoenix and now take Waymo regularly, and it seems like we're close to a world in which most people take self-driving cars most of the time, crash rates plummet, and these kinds of articles come to resemble articles from 1910 about horse-related problems. Humans suck at driving: https://jakeseliger.com/2019/12/16/maybe-cars-are-just-really-bad-but-theyre-normal-so-we-dont-pay-attention-to-how-bad/ https://jakeseliger.com/2019/12/16/maybe-cars-are-just-reall...
- neogodless 2y agoDefine "close." (Anecdotally, I'm outside Harrisburg, and there are no self-driving cars in... this state? People drive their cars just like cave people did, with their hands on the wheel!) Of note, the article mentions your sentiment near the conclusion: > Perhaps one day we’ll all whizz around in self-driving cars and accidents will be rare. But that’s still a ways off.
- kube-system 2y ago> I'm outside Harrisburg Hell, out there you've still got people using horse and carriage.
- kiba 2y agoI welcome self driving technology when they become available, but from a system perspective, cars and car related infrastructure imposed tremendous cost on our environment and urban fabric.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- nickthegreek 2y agoPhoenix doesn't really have the related weather concerns of the midwest which allow Waymo to flourish in your state.
- nytesky 2y agoIt’s also a grid roadway as a post-automobile city. Granted they got SF working too, which is pretty varied terrain but it took a lot of training. I guess we can roll it out city by city but will they ever recoup the cost?
- zolbrek 2y agohttps://archive.is/N4uIU https://archive.is/N4uIU
- csours 2y agoReminds me of this: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40266464 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40266464 https://eugeneyan.com/writing/simplicity/ https://eugeneyan.com/writing/simplicity/ “Simplicity is a great virtue but it requires hard work to achieve it and education to appreciate it. And to make matters worse: complexity sells better.” — Edsger Dijkstra Especially: Complexity signals more features.
- notjoemama 2y agoGM requiring Google integration and eliminating Apple Car Play and Android Auto makes me think a brand new model is immediately disposable. If I have choice removed from me, in particular a choice I very much care about, then I’m going to care about owning that car less. The more that happens the more people may view vehicles as pure utility and much easier to walk away from for any reason, especially repair cost. Who cares whether you replace a Chevrolet with a Ford when they are untouchable boxes? Insurance companies would love this BYW. If they can find a cheaper alternative that’s another brand, you’ll be reimbursed for that, not what you originally bought. It certainly looks like many small choices are being made towards automobiles being truly disposable.
- Terr_ 2y ago> If I have choice removed from me I think this points to a slightly deeper issue sitting just below "consumer choice", which is "tight coupling." It sounds like GM has made a tighter-coupling between their vehicle and one particular brand of smartphone, and that's suggestive that other tight-couplings might exist elsewhere the design. The more tightly-coupled parts (to particular brands, form-factors, and proprietary connectors) the harder/more-expensive it will be to keep the overall car-system working over a decade or two as some of its hard-dependencies stop getting built. So a lack of smartphone choice isn't just annoying, it also suggests something about the designers not planning for long-term maintenance.
- bluGill 2y agoI think it is also a trust issue - GM doesn't trust Apple will approve updates to their iphone app and so won't risk it. Also Apple charges a lot of $$$ to car company to connect to carplay and I think GM called their bluff. I'm not sure what the costs to android auto are or why GM wouldn't still connect to that. Note that as a consumer I don't trust anyone above. Sure GM's app will work great now, but in 3-6 years I expect they will decide drop support for my currently working car in their app. Apple and Google will also change their OS and so the app that does work with my car won't work anymore on new phones. I also expect updates to CarPlay/Android Auto that won't work with my old car in a few years. Nobody in this business wants to provide support for the average car which is currently 12 years old - unless you pay which someone driving a 12+ year old car won't want to do. (GM provides parts for those older cars, but people pay for those parts)
- salad-tycoon 2y agoI just want a cheap, safe dependable car. Anti lock brakes, a couple of air bags, crumple zones, maybe Bluetooth, real dials, two base versions: AWD and non AWD. That’s it. No telephony, no on star, no breathalyzers. I don’t need to play Witcher in it. Just need it to turn on and then off after running around. I’m holding onto my ancient POS because it’s impossible apparently to find the above. Everything is new and full of drive by wire, telephony, spyware crap. Oh and the prices… come on! I never was a car buff, I wish I had been as it definitely appears we have ended an era and I mourn isolated from the gear heads.
- hoelle 2y agoHonda and Toyota are still cheap, safe, and dependable. Our CR-V is such a great value I don't actually understand how they turn a profit.
- AnarchismIsCool 2y agoI wish there was an actual community of people building open source cars. It exists for fucking airplanes but there's __nothing__ on the vehicle market. Pool some money, crash test a couple, get some shop in asia to make frames. Make it fairly modular, something like an EV version of the 1995 ford ranger, something where people can throw whatever they want on the back and turn it into anything. Super bare minimum, no egregious plastics all over the inside, just use off the shelf parts and people can customize as they see fit.
- bluGill 2y agoPeople make their own airplanes. What nobody tells you is that most people who complete the airplane would be time and money ahead getting a job at McDonald's and buying a completed airplane once they saved up enough money. However there are not enough people who want an airplane to pay for the costs/liability of setting up a factory to build one and so you have no choice if you want a new one. People also build their own cars from scratch. It isn't as well known, but it is done. Again not a good use of time or money but if you want something specific that isn't on the market you have no choice.
- tonetegeatinst 2y agoI'm conflicted. I know modern vehicles are so complex and if something breaks it actually is cheaper to just go bet a new car.....but I don't really like that. On the other hand, most of my close family that I know has a vehicle that is fixable. I know how to do basic stuff like change oil, change a tire or break pads, but I also know how much vehicles are digital and I really don't enjoy that.
- talldatethrow 2y agoEvery vehicle is fixable. When you replace your modern vehicle, someone buys it and fixes it and sells it for a profit. I've had friends trade in $30k vehicles with problems for $15k and then be surprised when it's on the dealer website in 7 days for $30k fixed.
- rconti 2y ago> modern vehicles are so complex and if something breaks it actually is cheaper to just go bet a new car it's not.
- nimbius 2y agoThe rich have been flogging this idea since cash for clunkers. That, because they run through cars like shit through a goose, you will too. Speaking as a master diesel mechanic, this is a deleterious line of thinking for anyone with less than a few million dollars. Every car has 20 years of parts, and most Japanese cars have closer into 50 years of parts. Any engine built after 2010 will likely last half a million miles or more as a feature of quality control and automation alone. Maintaining a well running vehicle long term with a local mechanic is always cheaper than buying a new car every 5 years, and just because insurance says its "totaled" doesn't mean it isnt fixable and safe to drive.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- jandrese 2y agoIt's usually not the engine that fails. The transmission is far more likely to be the weak point, and after that it is rust destroying the body or frame. The average age of a car is like 13 years old. Most people are definitely not buying new ones every 5 years.
- nimbius 2y agoI agree, a transmission is really only good for around 200k miles. However, you can buy a used transmission in most cases for under 3 grand, and again labor for this thanks to automation is likely less than $500. The real blocker I dont mention is time. Your shop will need that car for a few days and shipping will take time too. At some point the wait isnt worth it anymore. The upside is, 2 used Toyotas are still cheaper than a new one new Toyota
- jandrese 2y agoThat and you're not getting another 200k miles out of that used transmission. The other thing that people don't talk about as much is the parts market got seriously messed up during COVID and still hasn't fully recovered. It's more common now for repair parts to either be unavailable or enormously marked up. Like a particular repair might only take a few hours and what should be a few hundred bucks in parts, but the car gets totaled because one of the parts is unavailable or inexplicably costs thousands and the shop doesn't want the liability of hacking together an alternative solution. Especially if the missing part is an ECM or sensor or something else that might make the car fail an inspection.
- snakeyjake 2y agoThe increase in total loss designations by insurance companies is due to the extremely high costs charged by the shops contracted by them to do repairs. The designation of a car as "totaled" is often an illusion and there is a thriving parallel market of auction houses, repair shops, salvage titling companies, and resellers who take the "ruined" cars, fix them, and sell them on the used market. Insurance companies could deal directly with the lower cost shops but just like the Concur Travel cancer that is spreading across corporate America there are extremely perverse incentives between executives and boards to keep the system the way it is with all of the major players dealing only with each other. There is probably an auctioneer within 30 minutes of where you are right now who will sell you a "total loss" car that you can repair, or have repaired, for a minuscule fraction of what an insurance contractor will charge-- often for less than the insurance payout (to both you and the adjuster). Like all things fucked in our economy, the trend of exorbitant repair costs took off when private equity started buying up the regional insurance repair contractor near-monopolies like Service King (Carlyle Group) and Caliber Collision (Leonard Green).
- neuralRiot 2y agoThe catch is that most banks won’t finance “rebuilt-titled” cars, you don’t have a dealer warranty (and most plainly refuse to work on rebuilt cars) and the vehicle has a 50-60% (or less) resale value than a “clean-title”.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoThat's a feature not a bug. It's selective definancialization, and I love it. Same reason why buying tax foreclosures is such a great bargain: you don't have to compete with bank-financed buyers!
- snakeyjake 2y agoDeep down inside I know that is by design.
- bityard 2y agoHuh. Well I happen to be shopping for a used care right now and in my area at least, Craigslist and Facebook are completely swamped with rebuilt title cars. And the vast majority of them are priced the same as clear title cars.
- ChrisMarshallNY 2y agoI was told that the original Mini (Mr. Bean’s car) was designed to be fairly “disposable.”
- jessekv 2y agoBased on the crash test videos I've seen, the passengers were deemed disposable as well.
- bloomingeek 2y agoOld timer here, back in the day (60s thru 80s) owners worked on their cars to save money, this kept garage repair prices in check because they knew we had another choice, ourselves. Today, I still service my vehicles because I purchased the electronic meters and testers that are required. (I realize not everyone thinks they have the ability to service their car, YouTube is a great source. Maybe you don't want to get your hands dirty. While changing out a turn signal light can be a pain, you can do it, thus saving a lot of money. Accomplishing a difficult job is a very good feeling. If you don't have the required tools, rent or borrow them. There are limitations, I tend to drive my vehicles to higher mileage. I won't change out half-shafts anymore or automatic window motors, as I have in the past many times. (I pay the garage to do it now.) But this is due to age, not how difficult the job is. Auto garages are opportunist, they'll charge whatever the market can stand, just like the new car sales. Until we make them change, they won't.
- Clubber 2y agoYouTube is a great resource for instructional videos on how to do stuff like that and fix things around the house. Lots of things.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoCar part prices are a scam... on most cheap cars, a small crash, broken bumper, lights and the radiator (+ all the sensors) means the car is totalled, because just the parts cost more than a new car. How the hell can a single headlight for a cheap car... so just some plastic, not even LEDs yet, cost 800euros? Sadly, until something (culture, new player on the market, regulation....) changes, that car will be totalled and scrapped.
- ianbicking 2y agoIt feels like risk mitigation to me. With all the interconnected aspects of a car the repair might be reasonably priced or might not. If the insurance company just "pays for the repair" then they've committed to either price, or even if they have a limit then they might reach the limit and still need to replace the car on top of it. Or the car might get repaired but have some issues, and there's no good way to just say "this car isn't as good as before the accident, but here's $1000 to make you whole". Instead they declare the car totaled and recoup what they can on the other end. If you want to actually _keep_ your totaled car you'll have to pay for it, because it _does_ have value. I had a car "totaled" when it was rear-ended, but it was still drivable and I would have liked to keep it, do some minimal repairs, and just accepted the wonky back end. But to keep it I would have received something $3,000 less on a $10,000 car and it didn't seem worth it. I don't know if the car was chopped up and helped make other cars whole, or vice versa. Some part of it ended up on a discount used car lot. And that's probably fine. Cars are kind of fungible and declaring a car "totaled" is just a way to take advantage of that and seems like a legitimate efficient-market approach.
- diebeforei485 2y agoA lot of "totalled" cars end up in poorer countries, often sold to buyers who are not made aware of its damage/accident history.
- black_13 2y ago[dead]
- CraigRo 2y agoThe issue is that people who drive super unrepairable cars create externalities for everyone else. Insurance should only cover up to the 90th percentile of repair costs
- nwellinghoff 2y agoI bought a Infinity g35 cash in 2005 and have never let a mechanic touch it. Done all the repairs including ac work myself. There is literally a youtube video that walks you through every step for almost all common repairs for your EXACT model. Its sooo easy and often faster to do it myself instead of go the mechanic and leave it with them multiple days. I would highly recommend young people buy a popular model or platform based car and just learn how to do mechanic work. Its fun and rewarding. Car is currently 19 years old going on 20 and besides the initial amount I bought it for it costs me about 200-300 in parts and fluids to maintain. Hats off to the engineers at Nissian. This thing prints money.