7 ms·
Surveilling the masses with wi-fi-based positioning systems
- spr-alex 2y agoI work at Supernetworks where we're building secure by default Wi-Fi routers. Our software had the ability to assign MACs to interfaces for a little while now, and as a response to this study we've now also added MAC randomization, now in the dev branch, and generally available in our next release (https://github.com/spr-networks/super https://github.com/spr-networks/super). Many cards which support WDS//AP-VLAN have no trouble with updating the BSSID. For use as a travel router the UI makes it simple to randomize both the AP BSSID/MAC as well as interfaces working as WiFi client stations for internet uplink.
- canadiantim 2y agoSo is bringing your own travel router while traveling the current best practice for securely connecting to public wifi's?
- transpute 2y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40494994 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40494994 SSIDName_optout_nomap
- sambazi 2y agopretty please don't fall for that crap
- canadiantim 2y agoWhat's wrong about it?
- staplers 2y agoIf you had a nice enclosure for these routers you could take a large share of the prosumer market and be a "privacy" version of unifi. As an average home user, I would love something like this (interface and features) but with a nicer looking hardware (wife tax).
- spr-alex 2y agoYes, We have some prototypes and will have some nice enclosures coming soon that we'll make available via our website at https://www.supernetworks.org https://www.supernetworks.org
- mrbluecoat 2y agoIn addition, some parental controls would be nice (feature parity with, say, Gryphon). I see your subscription tier offers some of that (schedules and domain logging).
- throw0101d 2y ago> Our software had the ability to assign MACs to interfaces for a little while now, and as a response to this study we've now also added MAC randomization, now in the dev branch […] Will it follow what the IEEE is proposing? * 802.11bh: Enhanced service with randomized MAC addresses * 802.11bi: Enhanced service with Data Privacy Protection * https://standards.ieee.org/beyond-standards/data-privacy-and-ease-of-use-in-wireless-networks/ https://standards.ieee.org/beyond-standards/data-privacy-and...
- spr-alex 2y agoThese amendments might not apply to BSSIDs/Access Points but refer to enhanced privacy features to stop the fingerprinting of stations as well as providing ways for APs to identify stations under randomization, across a complicated network.
- transpute 2y agoNote the privacy-impaired 802.11bf: WLAN Sensing, https://www.ieee802.org/11/Reports/tgbf_update.htm https://www.ieee802.org/11/Reports/tgbf_update.htm & https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/02/27/1088154/wifi-sensing-tracking-movements/ https://www.technologyreview.com/2024/02/27/1088154/wifi-sen... > Someone outside your home could potentially tell when it’s vacant, or see what you are doing inside. Consider all the reasons someone might want to secretly track someone else’s movements. Wi-Fi sensing has the potential to make many of those uses possible.. it could be used by corporations to monitor consumers, workers, and union organizers; by stalkers or domestic abusers to harass their victims; and by other nefarious actors to commit a variety of crimes. The fact that people cannot currently tell they are being monitored adds to the risk. “We need both legal and technical guardrails".. > At least 30 million homes already have some kind of Wi-Fi sensing available.. When the new standard comes out in 2025, it will allow “every Wi-Fi device to easily and reliably extract the signal measurements".. With Wi-Fi 7.., “the sensing capability can improve by one order of magnitude”.. The committee did discuss privacy and security.. But they decided that while those concerns do need to be addressed, they are not within the committee’s mandate.. Wi-Fi sensing is more concerning than cameras, because it can be completely invisible. IEEE standards are a minimum starting point for interoperability. Security and privacy improvements can be implemented in open-source code, to inform future revisions of IEEE standards.
- transpute 2y ago> we're building secure by default Wi-Fi routers In addition to RPi hardware, it would be helpful to support Rockchip RK3399 and RK3588 SoCs that have minimal binary blobs, since these can used with open-source Arm Trusted Firmware (TF-A) for secure boot, to ensure that only owner-authorized OS and firmware are running on the device. > Many cards which support WDS//AP-VLAN have no trouble with updating the BSSID. Do these M.2 WiFi cards support AP/VLAN and BSSID updates? Qualcomm Atheros QCA6174 Wi-Fi 5 Qualcomm Atheros QCNFA765 Wi-Fi 6
- karma_pharmer 2y agoRockchip RK3399 and RK3588 SoCs Just so people don't get confused, there is a huge world of difference between these two chips. They are not in the same category. Rockchip RK3399 is 100% blobless. You even control the EL3 Trustzone Secure World! This is True Root. Rockchip RK3588 still needs blobs in EL3, the highest privilege level. We've been hearing rumors for years now about "oh they'll open source it next month for sure" and it.... just. never. happens. Please stop spreading this rumor. Source or GTFO, Rockchip.
- transpute 2y agoFeb 2024, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39490540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39490540 & https://review.trustedfirmware.org/c/TF-A/trusted-firmware-a/+/21840 https://review.trustedfirmware.org/c/TF-A/trusted-firmware-a... > Rockchip have sent a few patches to the TF-A project here to support [RK3588].. From TF-A we can now build a complete working BL31 and replace the closed binary blob with an open-source binary that we can compile ourselves.. There are still some missing parts and the most important that is remaining right now is the DDR training blob, which is still closed source.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoLike I said: blobs in EL3, the highest privilege level. We've been getting these "almost there" announcements quarterly for multiple years at this point.
- nox101 2y agoThis sounds very cool and IIUC could replace my EdgeRouterX($60) I currently use. Suggestion, your site is not understandable to me. At the top it says you make routers. Under products it lists a a PI5 HAT. Is that a router? It sounds like it's a Wifi card for a Raspberry PI?? PI5 Pod, Is that a router? It says "bundled with PI5 Router" ??? "CM4 Capsule" is that a router? Is this site only for people who already know these terms? It also claims all this runs locally but then says you have a subscription... ?!
- transpute 2y ago> It also claims all this runs locally but then says you have a subscription... ?! Looks like the subscription is for those who want to help fund the project. Not many functional differences, maybe those are handled in the config GUI?
- karma_pharmer 2y agoMost wifi baseband firmware "helpfully" leaks the true eeprom-written MAC address in places like management frames and beacons: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13839540 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13839540 As of 2017 the authors of the paper above found MAC leaks in a shocking 96% of all android phones. And the remaining 4% aren't proven to be leak-free -- they simply hadn't noticed any leaks by the time they wrote the paper. Unless you have fully open-source firmware on your baseband, like ath9k_htc, there's really no way to prevent this leakage. Or even be sure if it's happening. https://wiki.debian.org/ath9k_htc/open_firmware https://wiki.debian.org/ath9k_htc/open_firmware With open source baseband firmware you can guarantee that the baseband never even has access to the hardware MAC address. You can even reflash the MAC address eeprom (on every boot if you like!)
- spr-alex 2y agoWe actually have an intern researcher working on a path towards an open source implementation of 802.11 for wifi 6 cards but do not have an ETA when our first proof of concept will be released. We've also reported mac leaks to vendors -- we found stations would transmit packets with their non randomized state in certain scenarios, we'll blog about it when vendors release their fixes. But more importantly I also want to say that I do not expect the MAC leaks are happening in most beacons & probe responses, which is what Apple and Google and others collect for their positional database with wi-fi SSIDs and BSSIDs. There's still ways to fingerprint, from digital fingerprints, to signal fingerprints unique to the radio and antennas and board, where machine learning can cluster and classify devices that are going to be very hard to anonymize for privacy. Projects like https://www.nzyme.org/ https://www.nzyme.org/ actually apply fingerprinting techniques for defense to detect Rogue APs that could manifest in an actively attacked environment. They can pick up wifi implants as well as the Rogue AP attacks.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoan open source implementation of 802.11 for wifi 6 cards For which baseband chip, specifically? I mean this would be great, but I have a very hard time believing any baseband vendor gave you enough documentation to achieve that -- especially not without an OSS-prohibitive NDA. Would love to be wrong about that. It happened once, but that was back when Atheros was an independent company -- before they were Qualcommized. Also, aren't all the wifi 6 baseband firmwares cryptographically signed? Best case it'll be as "open source" as Tivo was. We've also reported mac leaks to vendors That's good, but I don't think the whack-a-mole approach inspires much confidence. There have been so many of these problems that at this point we really need to take the car keys away from the drunkard and have the baseband chip and the MAC-bearing eeprom be separate devices which can only communicate via the CPU. Or just have the CPU derive the MAC from the CPU's own serial number. Or maybe just not have hardware MAC addresses at all.
- devjab 2y agoI’m not sure if I understand your project correctly, but can this fix the issue with tracking people by location from their phones? Either way it’s a cool project. I’m Danish, I think the only way to really prevent mass surveillance through WiFi is through laws and legislation. It used to be legal to track people here, but thankfully it’s not anymore. I still remember when there was an outcry from smaller municipalities when they could no longer track people on their “walking streets”. I’m not sure if you have those in other countries but they are basically the “central” street with a lot of shops that are only for pedestrians. Virtually every Danish city has one, larger cities have multiple. Anyway, smaller cities used to track people to see which parts of those streets were popular and which weren’t. Now they didn’t exactly do it for sinister reasons as such. Our smaller cities have issues with what is called “city death” where their “waking streets” lose shops because people go to larger malls. Then they might add a play ground or other cultural things, or even help shops with rents in order to increase an even popularity in their “waking streets”. Despite their good intention it was still mass scale surveillance.
- wolvesechoes 2y ago> It used to be legal to track people here, but thankfully it’s not anymore. It not legal anymore, except when you are big enough or you are the one that decides what is legal or not.
- yardstick 2y agoFrom your site: “ Why should your vacuum be able talk to your doorbell? Inadequate network isolation makes breaches worse.” Just got to say- that would be awesome for my vacuum to stop making a loud noise when someone pushed the doorbell, so I wouldn’t miss the person! (But I do completely get the underlying sentiment)
- transpute 2y agoAn untrusted vacuum and doorbell can each talk to trusted HomeAssistant for coordination, while isolated from each other.
- fennecfoxy 2y agoUnfortunately wisp/biz/cafe net providers often seem to block randomised mac addresses on device side (I'm guessing the sign on portal they force people thru registers by mac).
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- m463 2y agoI think phones should have location-based wifi (and maybe bluetooth). Meaning, if your location is home, turn on wifi, else turn it off. Unfortunately apple/google/carriers have a vested interest in making our devices very promiscuous. (location services, advertising/surveillance, offload cellular, etc)
- balderdash 2y agoThat would be a great feature the only places I use WiFi besides home/work is the airport/plane, hotels, and occasionally other offices or people’s homes. There is no need to be broadcasting driving/walking around etc.
- gruez 2y agoThis paper is about surveilling locations of APs (ie. hotspots), not the devices that connect to them. Thanks to MAC address randomization the latter is basically a non-issue. >I think phones should have location-based wifi (and maybe bluetooth). >Unfortunately apple/google/carriers have a vested interest in making our devices very promiscuous. (location services, [...] You don't see the contradiction here? You want your phones to have location-aware features, but right afterwards say that you don't want it because it makes your device "very promiscuous".
- yjftsjthsd-h 2y ago>> Unfortunately apple/google/carriers have a vested interest in making our devices very promiscuous. (location services, [...] > You don't see the contradiction here? You want your phones to have location-aware features, but right afterwards say that you don't want it because it makes your device "very promiscuous". I don't think it's a contradiction. You can have a phone that knows its own location without telling Google/Apple where it is, and that uses that information to toggle features. (I'm kind of skipping the cell carriers because you do have to give them coarse location by virtue of how cell network work.) A device can get location by purely passive GPS without involving any external services, but that's a pretty sucky experience (slow lock, low precision)... I think you can do AGPS without telling anyone where you are, though. Anyways, my point is that there is a world of difference between you having your information/location and anyone else having it.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- juunpp 2y ago> We find what appear to be personal devices being brought by military personnel into war zones, exposing pre-deployment sites and military positions. Is this verified? Does the military not ban Apple/Google personal trackers?
- lelandfe 2y agoOne would hope after https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracking-app-gives-away-location-of-secret-us-army-bases https://amp.theguardian.com/world/2018/jan/28/fitness-tracki...
- gruez 2y agoBasically any sort of Android/iOS device by default will report back the location of nearby APs. Given how important phones are (eg. for entertainment or keeping in touch), it's basically impossible to ban them.
- eximius 2y agoFeels like the theatre of war where opsec literally means life or death to yourself, you'd be willing to leave your device at base or faraday it or something.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoYeah but then millennials came along.
- yellow_postit 2y agoMultiple militaries have had locations disclosed via Strava. BYOD is everywhere.
- ezconnect 2y agoThat is a known fact and widely reported to have caused security issues. Even in the Ukraine conflict if the Russian army doesn't follow protocol of NOT BRINGING your phone to deployment they get targeted instantly by US missiles. SIGINT can map phone signals showing large group of people in certain areas just by having your phone on and all this privacy thing turned off.
- croes 2y agoOriginal source https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40454706 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40454706 Related article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40464184 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40464184
- karmakaze 2y agoOn my Android 12 phone, I have the following things disabled: - [ ] Location - Improve location accuracy [ ] Wi-Fi scanning [ ] Bluetooth scanning - [ ] Google location accuracy - [ ] Google location history - [ ] Google location sharing - App-level permissions - Allowed all the time: None - Allowed only while using app: Maps, Lyft, Uber, Uber Eats What's funny is when searching "location" in settings is that the "Google ..." ones aren't listed and have to be hunted down manually under Location/Location services. I sometimes temporarily enable Location, but most often I'll just enter addresses manually into the apps and dismiss any requests for location access. Of course anything with internet access can still guess location based on the public IP address used to connect to any server. Maybe a VPN could help, but then you have to trust that party too.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- blueflow 2y agoBe 100% sure by leaving your smartphone at home. Checking WhatsApp & Co once daily is enough.
- dannyw 2y agoThis just isn’t practical for anyone with kids, etc.
- dark-star 2y agoI wonder how people checked in on their kids in the 90s, before smartphones were a thing? /s
- cornflake23 2y agoTried it, alas, without success -Two big factors: 1. the infrastructure that made this possible in the 90s isn’t there anymore (at least in my part of the world). 2. The surrounding world requires information exchange at physical boundaries. These too have now been “digitized”. Where might we turn to?
- dirkmakerhafen 2y agoWait what, this was not public knowledge? I have been using apple geolocation api for the last 6-7 years to regularly download a snapshot of all access points in the world. https://github.com/dirk-makerhafen/apple-bssid https://github.com/dirk-makerhafen/apple-bssid (the basic request code, not the mass downloader part)
- inasio 2y agoNitpick: Figure 2 should have been loglog, rather than semilog-y, I would love to see more details rather than the near vertical line (graph is Cumulative geo-located BSSIDs as a function of the number of API queries)
- datahack 2y agoHas nobody ever heard of Google sidewalk or what?
- _trampeltier 2y agoThere is, since ever, a website with wifi routers and location https://www.wigle.net/ https://www.wigle.net/
- sambazi 2y agopls don't discriminate against ppl that lived in a world before wifi was a thing
- benopal64 2y agothank u for doing gods work. wifi-less people have been around for centuries.
- sambazi 2y agoand discrimination against us has absolutely soared in the last decades
- lgats 2y agohttps://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/6vpej2/wp_you_are_a_time_traveler_while_traipsing_about/ https://www.reddit.com/r/WritingPrompts/comments/6vpej2/wp_y...
- transpute 2y ago"Why Your Wi-Fi Router Doubles as an Apple AirTag", 100 comments, https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40430603 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40430603 > In late March 2024, Apple quietly updated its website to note that anyone can opt out of having the location of their wireless access points collected and shared by Apple — by appending “_nomap” to the end of the Wi-Fi access point’s name (SSID). Adding “_nomap” to your Wi-Fi network name also blocks Google from indexing its location.. > "You may not have Apple products, but if you have an access point and someone near you owns an Apple device, your BSSID will be in [Apple’s] database,” he said. “What’s important to note here is that every access point is being tracked, without opting in, whether they run an Apple device or not.. Commonly used travel routers compound the potential privacy risks.. > The Google/Apple opt out (_nomap) needs to be at the end of SSID name. Whereas the Microsoft opt out (_optout) can be anywhere in the SSID name. Therefore, to opt out of both, it would be in this order: SSIDName_optout_nomap
- canadiantim 2y agoVery very useful info, thank you
- chevman 2y agoMy guess is the opt out (versus opt in) nature of this could be the seed of a massive class action lawsuit should the right folks get involved :)
- transpute 2y ago> Asked about the changes, Apple said they have respected the “_nomap” flag on SSIDs for some time, but that this was only called out in a support article earlier this year. If an SSID flag falls in the forest and no one is told to read it, does it opt out? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_a_tree_falls_in_a_forest_and_no_one_is_around_to_hear_it,_does_it_make_a_sound%3F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/If_a_tree_falls_in_a_forest_an...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- 2y ago
- _k2vp 2y agoI’ve been experimenting with this over the past few days: https://github.com/acheong08/apple-corelocation-experiments https://github.com/acheong08/apple-corelocation-experiments Found some interesting things and still working on recording more MITM from my iPhone to see what else is sent.
- edward1 2y ago[dead]
- nbzso 2y agoCall me paranoid, but I have a habit to use a Faraday Bag. Saving a lot of battery and knowing when and where to activate. Welcome to the future. :)
- clort 2y agoHow does a faraday bag save battery? Normally I find that in areas of poor mobile signal, the phone ramps up the power to keep contacting towers and burns through the charge much quicker..
- mrbluecoat 2y agoSame. Airplane mode works better for me in these scenarios.
- fsflover 2y agoOnly if you trust that it does what it says.
- Eduard 2y agoI find this paper's title "surveilling the masses ..." not fitting for the (nevertheless important) findings in this paper. While "mass surveillance" is an ambiguous term, it invokes images of "this method allows wiretapping/reading society's private conversations, and/or pinpointing everybody's precise location in real-time". But actually, the findings are: "this method can be leveraged as an additional statistical proxy for population movement and infrastructure outages/destruction; By taking several assumptions (e.g. BSSID not spoofed; BSSID is seen by some smartphone; BSSID of to-be-surveilled target is known; BSSID is actually used by target and not sold/handed to someone else; target is close to BSSID; BSSID is on; etc.), an individual's historical and possibly current whereabouts may be revealed".
- whatupmiked 2y agoYou seem to be attacking a strawman. "The central goal of the attacker we consider is to gather location and movement data about a large number of devices, either globally or pertaining to a specific region of interest."
- Eduard 2y agoMy critique is not about the paper _content_, it is about the paper _title_, which currently (arXiv:2405.14975v1 ) verbatim is: "Surveilling the Masses with Wi-Fi-Based Positioning Systems". Understand it as a minor pet peeve on my side that I would prefer a less sensational, better disambiguated title in order for the paper to express its content and significance. After all, it's arxiv.org, and possibly a preprint open for feedback.
- nonameiguess 2y agoIt remains to be seen to me what information is really being gathered here that wasn't already available. If you want to know where people are, geographic population demographics and residential density data is generally publicly available in most places. If you want to know where they're moving to, vehicular traffic, bus and train ridership, and airline ticket sales are also public knowledge. This is simply providing another way to say "humans who connect to WiFi networks exist here, here, and here, and move to here, here, and here." Without knowing who actually owns and uses each device, it's hard to see how you can really call this mass surveillance, which typically implies the leakage of information that people expected to be private. The fact that my residential address has a WiFi access point in it does not seem to me to be private information. I can readily guess with at least 99% accuracy that every residential and business address in existence with visible furnishing, decoration, regular cleaning, trash outside, or any other sign of human occupancy, has a WiFi access point attached to it. The threat they mention of intimate partner abuse and stalking whereby an attacker knows a specific person's MAC address and is able to track them if they move but retain the same device is a more obviously real concern, but easily mitigated by simply not retaining the same WiFi access point when you move to a new residential address.
- pontifier 2y agoI was thinking recently about the inverse of this attack. I have many thieves coming to my warehouse, and was thinking I could broadcast bunch of local ssids to try to see which ones their phones try to autoconnect to. I could then use that info to figure out where they are likely to hang out, and either give it to police or take matters into my own hands.
- p3rls 2y agoHow much have you had stolen in monetary value just out of curiosity? I went schizo myself for a few months after having like $60k worth of stuff stolen from me when the cops did nothing. But you sound like this is just happening continually -- having this daily stress that's gonna get you or someone else killed -- and you probably don't deserve the prison time.
- hellojesus 2y agoAt some loss value it seems like hiring off duty cops is ev+.
- p3rls 2y agoYeah I think everyone tells this guy that, and it'd probably be a good start to try and get himself back in the good graces of Pine Bluff's political types, but for whatever reason it doesn't look like an option and he posts on twitter that he's still getting bulgarized on something like a weekly basis... From my experience I know there's nothing more frustrating than these useless government bureaucrats that can't be bothered to do their jobs until something or someone explodes.
- Hikikomori 2y agoBeacons take up a fair bit of radio space so if you're going to have a lot then have it on a channel you're not using yourself.
- heartbreak 2y agoTheir phones search for known WiFi networks whenever they’re not currently connected to WiFi. You can monitor and log this traffic. Many (most?) modern smartphones randomize their MAC address when not connected, but a few years ago you could look for repeat visitors this way, too.
- ajsnigrutin 2y agoOfftopic, I know, but still... > Wi-Fi-based Positioning Systems (WPSes) are.... Why does every articl have to invent some acronym, and even worse in this case, an acronym that already exists in the wifi context (wifi protected setup - WPS).
- calebm 2y agoI published an open-source tool several years ago which helps map out the wifi world: https://github.com/calebmadrigal/trackerjacker https://github.com/calebmadrigal/trackerjacker.
- ACV001 2y agowow this is huge "Russia-Ukraine War First, we use Apple’s WPS to ana- lyze device movements into and out of Ukraine and Russia, gaining insights into their ongoing war that, to the best of our knowledge, have yet to be made public. We find what appear to be personal devices being brought by military personnel into war zones, exposing pre-deployment sites and military positions. Our results also show individuals who have left Ukraine to a wide range of countries, validating public reports of where Ukrainian refugees have resettled."
- jessenaser 2y agoOn top of that, some networks like Spectrum already report all the MAC addresses that are connected to it remotely to the Spectrum database, instead of just on your network panel locally (because there isn't a Spectrum network panel anymore, only the app). This means that a nation state (USA) can see real time minute by minute who is on that network, and recent devices on that network because Spectrum designed this in their firmware. You can check yourself from the app: Services > Devices on Network > Manage And it will show all of the MAC addresses connected, and recently connected. Even remotely if you are not logged into your network. You also can see the *plaintext* password to your router from this app. Services > Your WiFi Network Which means a nation state also can remotely login to your network without you knowing, and otherwise is bad for security if passwords for millions of homes are plaintext. --- Moral of the story is that even if Apple eventually fixes this, the other side of the tracking that nation states could do could be done at the ISP firmware level. To solve this kind of attack, either allowing open firmware or new legislation is the only to stop this. (Which when has privacy legislation ever happened... is another question for another day).
- sandworm101 2y ago>> To solve this kind of attack, either allowing open firmware or new legislation is the only to stop this. Or just randomize every MAC at the client level, blinding everyone up the chain and no doubt causing many false reports as randomized macs collide.
- jessenaser 2y agoYes this helps the MAC concern, but this means we need wide scale device manufactures to enable this by default, because users won't. Similar level of consensus. Also why is some devices don't support this randomization, or even if they do, the first connection is not supported. When you first activate an iPhone or use a Windows computer, it still does not expose all the settings to randomize the MAC address until you setup the device, so the first connection exposes the actual address to the network. Yet again we need deeper levels of change to fix this.