11 ms·
iTerm2 and AI Hype Overload
- schappim 2y agoI sympathise with the author of iTerm 2. Posts like this can be very demotivating when working on a free product. If you enjoy iTerm (as I very much do), you can donate to the author here: https://iterm2.com/donate.html https://iterm2.com/donate.html
- mmastrac 2y agoI'm glad the article questions _whether this is even a problem_, but it seems they tried to answer it and failed to come up with a convincing argument: > I don't get it. It's a very optional feature that you have to: > Go out of your way to enable, supply your own API key > (and pay for it yourself), enable something that is not > enabled by default. Why are people reacting so strongly > to this? ... and the article's answer(s), which I don't think are a very convincing rebuttal: > A lot of it boils down to having this "shoved down > their throats". It's the fact that it's being added > to a tool without the user having the agency to decide > if they want it to be added or not. > I think that one of the greatest errors that was made > with putting this in iTerm2 was making a big show of it, > and by not letting you use local models (such as with > Ollama) instead of having OpenAI be the only option. I mean, this is open-source. You get a lot of features without any agency here, you are free to edit those out and it has no impact if you don't use it. If someone wants a local model, why not submit a PR instead of complaining? Local models have OpenAI compatibility! https://ollama.com/blog/openai-compatibility https://ollama.com/blog/openai-compatibility * EDIT: I see that the OpenAI URL is configurable under Advanced > Experimental > URL for AI API. Perhaps this already works?
- rideontime 2y ago> you are free to edit those out It takes much less effort for me to simply switch back to Terminal.app.
- mmastrac 2y agoAssuming you're unhappy with this (I am neutral on it), I'm actually curious: what do you lose by iTerm2 having an opt-in feature that you don't need to use? How do you replace all the lost features of iTerm2 that aren't in Terminal.app? And if there aren't any features you're losing out on, why did you even switch to iTerm2?
- rideontime 2y agoThis was in response to the suggestion that one "edits" out the feature.
- 39896880 2y ago> what do you lose by iTerm2 having an opt-in feature that you don't need to use? Trust. “AI” features are a trust rubicon. Once you add it, the assumption is that surveillance is now baked in.
- mmastrac 2y agoUhh, I don't understand. It's an open-source project with a ton of eyeballs on it. Are you saying that someone is going to sneak in a change to exfiltrate all keystrokes in a massively popular terminal app without anyone noticing? Is this risk new somehow?
- dcow 2y agoUhhh what? localhost to ollama is surveillance?
- r053bud 2y agoI guarantee this is the beginning of iTerm2 becoming a closed-source paid product. Oh, I'm sure there will always be an "open source" version of it, but we have all seen this movie before.
- madeofpalk 2y agoWhy would you think this? There are plenty of open source products which intergrate with APIs, including OpenAI.
- lamontcg 2y ago> It's the fact that it's being added to a tool without the user having the agency to decide if they want it to be added or not. This is some wildly narcissistic logic. Other people are free to add features to the software that they write, that is their agency.
- chrsig 2y agoThis really stood out to me. Fork a github repo and manually merge in every upstream commit yourself if that's how you want software delivered to you.
- Delmololo 2y agoIt doesn't matter if a small group of nerds don't like it. No one really rips out iTerm2 from a mac setup and they can throw their Mac out of the window with iTerm2 if they really hate AI that much (because it has ai and will get more, you had to get out of your way with Siri and co already anyway...) And as I said it before: this is not a hype. Look it up. Ai delivers already things it doesn't fit hype. And no ai will not go away, at least I'm not seeing a single thing right now indicating a platoon very soon.
- koryk 2y agohttps://github.com/koryk/reverse-ai-search https://github.com/koryk/reverse-ai-search I have been working on something like this that fits better into my existing bash/zsh workflow. So I landed on using ollama and a small widget that tries to mirror the same behavior of ctrl+r aka reverse-i-search. Barely functional, but I have found value from it.
- rideontime 2y agoMy personal problem with this is that I have no confidence in the answer provided by an AI. If I search the internet for help with some command line operation, I can try to find a reputable source that provides not only the command I'm looking for, but an explanation of the syntax that a) gives me confidence that it will do what I expect it to and b) allows me to learn how to construct that command so I can do it myself next time. This is, of course, less true today than it used to be, now that Google is likely to show me some convincing AI slop at the top of my results.
- ein0p 2y agoI do have this confidence if by AI we mean GPT4. I already routinely use it to generate small scripts and complex command line incantations. My memory is better spent elsewhere imo
- sharkjacobs 2y ago> I have no confidence in the answer provided by an AI You don’t need to have confidence, these are shell one liners, you can generate it, run it, and verify the results in the time it would take you to open a browser window or scroll halfway down a man page. And if it doesn’t work, then you can still fallback on those.
- rideontime 2y agoHow do I verify the results?
- 2y ago
- tiffanyh 2y agoData Privacy? Is a 3rd party getting every key stroke I make and output it produces?
- api 2y agoAFAIK not if you don't turn this on, and not what you don't type in the box. My big disappointment is that you can't use providers other than OpenAI. Stop this. It's like making a web browser that can only use Google. AI APIs are actually kind of simple. Make it so I can pick one including a locally hosted one (ollama etc.) if I want.
- cchance 2y agoNo it isn't its a disabled feature by default, that requires an API key even if you do want it, its opt-in for gods sake
- yoyohello13 2y agoToday's opt-in is tomorrow's opt-out.
- verdverm 2y agoCould get some overzealous security groups in fortune 500 banning its use though. Can the IT department ensure it is not turned on by their developers on work machines?
- mushufasa 2y agowould be awesome if this used a local llm. there are several open ones on hugging face fund for terminal command help with low parameters. I'm thinking something like llamafile would be awesome to ship with this app cross platform (though iterm2 specifically could probably assume apple silicon architecture support only). Benefits would be - no external dependencies (OpenAI payment, network availability...) - no data leaving my device - it could deeply learn my configs and filesystem to give specific commands as opposed to general guidance (I know you can embed and send to OpenAI but I'd really not want to share all my hard drive)
- mmastrac 2y agoIt appears to be configurable: DEFINE_STRING(aitermURL, @"https://api.openai.com/v1/completions https://api.openai.com/v1/completions", SECTION_EXPERIMENTAL @"URL for AI API.\nA ChatGPT API endpoint should be here. Note that this URL is only used if the model name does not begin with `gpt-` because those models used an older API."); https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/blob/a196d31658a8d0aa2dc55c68c0dd28d6e70b3433/sources/iTermAdvancedSettingsModel.m#L768 https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/blob/a196d31658a8d0aa2dc5...
- saghul 2y agoI tried it but I get an error: "There was a problem with the AI query: Error from OpenAI: [] is too short - 'messages'" According to the docs it only uses that if the model doesn't begin tieh gpt- and uses an old API, so alas it doesn't seem compatible with ollama. Edit: here is the relevant part of the code: https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/blob/a196d31658a8d0aa2dc55c68c0dd28d6e70b3433/sources/AITerm.swift#L518 https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/blob/a196d31658a8d0aa2dc5... Looks like adding ollama support is really a matter of changing a few lines of code. Edit 2: Seems to be fixed in the next beta release: https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/commit/fcd212490626f1d8ea975ba444a1ea735a4ad859 https://github.com/gnachman/iTerm2/commit/fcd212490626f1d8ea...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- xyst 2y agoFor those that need an alternate (and cross-platform) terminal: - alacritty - kitty are decent alternatives I have found as a drop in replacement. Might need to add tmux if you were reliant on the window/pane management of iTerm2
- galkk 2y agoI term has a killer feature that neither of suggested have - native control of tmux (tmux -CC). For heavy tmux user it could be a deal breaker, especially given that kovid (kitty author) is hostile towards tmux.
- citruscomputing 2y agoEh, I'm really not a fan of iterm's tmux integration. It tries to do too much. I can't have my tmux statusbar (only the iterm one) and it really wants you to use iterm panes (and iterm commands to split them...). I like that my terminal config is mostly portable.
- radicality 2y agoWhat does the tmux integration actually do? I use tmux all the time on my mac all servers, but I remember I once tried the iterm integration and everything was very confusing and I turned it off. I just always start iterm, start or attach to existing tmux, and just have 1 tab open and use tmux normally. Then I sometimes open up other tabs, where I ssh into various servers and `tmux -a` to my session there. What extra stuff do I get from this "tmux integration" ?
- galkk 2y agoJust convenience. Instead of tmux panels and windows you get native macos windows, that you can manage with rectangle or any other app.
- catoc 2y agoWhy not just keep using iTerm2? Benefits: -You can keep using a terminal app you apparently like (understandably, it’s great) -You don’t have to find and install a replacement -You don’t have to re-add tmux -Not actively enabling a new chat feature you don’t like costs very little time Downsides: -…
- eriri 2y agoI looked into the issue tracker and gosh, its getting so toxic there. https://gitlab.com/gnachman/iterm2/-/issues/11470 https://gitlab.com/gnachman/iterm2/-/issues/11470
- bloopernova 2y agoFrom reading that issue, it sounds like some people are worried about compliance with security policies (whether personal or corporate) I'm very happy with iTerm2, its features are useful to me, but I can't see myself using the AI chat feature when I have copilot in VS code. I could see a use case for people unfamiliar with certain commands, something like "please sort this output by the first then fourth columns". But if I'm writing a script or small Python utility, then VS code will be where I do it. For compliance though, the AI integration could be a separate binary that you can access via the command line, although as pointed out in a reply, that's the same as a code path that isn't used. However, it is easier to block a separate binary, so maybe that's the thinking there? Instead, maybe the people who have an issue with this feature would be happy with an optional setting "assign this keyboard shortcut to the AI binary". Or a feature flag that says "do not access the network under any circumstances".
- nulld3v 2y agoI get the compliance perspective but it feels stupid to bring it up now, especially since iTerm2 has already had integrated network features for a long time. Agreed on the "do not access the network" feature flag though, every program should have that. Or really it should just be a toggle in the OS on a per-app basis.
- nomel 2y ago> Agreed on the "do not access the network" feature flag though, every program should have that. I would claim that is not the responsibility of the app. That should be the sandbox/OS responsibility, to make sure it's actually true, rather than an app providing a checkbox that potentially does nothing.
- 2y ago
- cchance 2y agoSeriously confused, the article first screws up royally saying its not opensource, which they correct, but then discuss "shoved down their throats" ... a feature that exists but is not enabled by default and doesn't even work if you don't provide a key. It's absolutely rediculous that supporting something, thats opt-in not opt-out is causing a ruckus lol, people really have too much fuckin time on their hands to bitch about things. This is like bitching that Firefox allows us to enable a proxy server, and throwing a fit that a feature exists even as an option to be enabled.
- verandaguy 2y agoYou're right across the board. My only issue with it is general-purpose AI fatigue. Everywhere I look, blog posts use the same generic-looking AI art (I can't quite put it into words, but you probably know the look I'm talking about), social media posts are written up using genAI (e.g. Linkedin will now ask you if you want AI to write your post for you -- though let's be honest, original thoughts are few and far between on there to begin with), and while interviewing recently I received multiple warnings about disabling any AI assistants in my editor (to me, it's kind of a bummer that that's a big enough issue to mention at all). I have, in principle, nothing against an opt-in feature that requires unmistakable user consent and a specific sequence of actions to enable. I'm just kinda tired of AI in general, and I'm also worried about potential licensing issues that may arise if you use genAI in your terminal to write scripts that weren't permissively licensed before being used as part of a training set. That's nothing new though, I had, and have, the same concerns with Github Copilot. I also recognize that my complaint is pretty personal (not counting the licensing thing). My low-level annoyance with genAI isn't something the AI industry at large should seek to resolve. Maybe I'm more set in my ways than I should be at this point in my life. Either way, it's a factor for me and a few other tech people I know.
- SoftTalker 2y ago> while interviewing recently I received multiple warnings about disabling any AI assistants in my editor Weird. Does the company forbid its staff to use AI assistants? I get that they want to find out what you know. If you know how to solve problems using an AI, isn't that what they are going to (increasingly) expect you to do on the job? In fact, demonstrating that you can effectively use AI to develop, would seem to me to be something they'd want to see.
- noncoml 2y agoJust another buzzword that has to be added to every product until it gets forgotten like it never existed. Past wall of fame - Network - Big Data - Blockchain - Cloud - NFT - VR
- apantel 2y agoAlso: Smart Smart home Smart phone Smart watch Smart thermostat Etc.
- geerlingguy 2y agoNot sure you're being downvoted—probably the last bit of your statement... but there is a wave of "jam AI into it or you're not keeping up with the Joneses" in every application and tool I've noticed over the past year now. It's nauseating, really, and I think for some devs they probably thought their terminal environment was the last place they'd see anything AI pop up, so they're taking out the pent up annoyance out on iTerm2.
- john2x 2y ago3D TV and Cinema
- Shank 2y agoI use Network every day, and continue to use it, for example, to access this website. Not all of these are created equal!
- noncoml 2y ago
- efitz 2y agoHow is this different than say, searching stack overflow for a command or chain of commands? You still have to enable the feature, and you still have to hit enter. If you are running commands in a privileged terminal then you ought to already have enough experience to be skeptical of commands that you don’t understand, and ensure that you do understand them before you run them. The only thing that caused me any concern about the demo was that the user action to take the proposed command from the prompt window back into the terminal, was unclear. That is the dangerous step, and should be hard to do accidentally and be very clear on impact.
- mvdtnz 2y agoA stack overflow answer that is downright wrong is likely to be downvoted or removed completely. An answer that works but has subtle security issues is likely to have comments warning readers to be cautious. AI has none of this. An AI will tell you with full confidence to use a command that it doesn't understand, it merely constructed it from a statistical model that is impossible to understand completely. That command may work, or it may be totally invalid, or it may expose you to a major security risk. We really don't know.
- zer0tonin 2y agoI think the feature is dumb but also the backlash is completely pointless. It literally doesn't get in your way in any manner. It's only extremely hypothetical concerns (read bullshit) about sending random data to openai.
- throwawa14223 2y agoI have a fairly strong preference for tools that don't contain LLM, but you're right compared to all the other uses of LLM this is pointless. Edit Because I hit submit too soon: George Nachman is a great guy who delivers a cool tool for free and doesn't deserve the pushback.
- octernion 2y agoyou are going to hate most software with that attitude over the next few years
- Xelynega 2y agoWhy should they care about 'most software' if they have tools that work for them? For example I don't hate iTerm because I don't need to. I can just use a better terminal emulator and get on with my life. People say the same about vscode, why spend the energy hating it instead of just using neovim and forgetting it exists.
- throwawa14223 2y agoThat's fine it isn't really designed for me and I'm a software engineer so if I want something bad enough I can try my hand at making it.
- justsid 2y agoAs someone who similarly suffers from AI fatigue, I already do. I can’t wait for the AI hype cycle to follow the blockchain path, I just hope whatever comes afterwards isn’t even worse.
- delichon 2y ago
- lordgrenville 2y agoI love iTerm2. It has a gazillion features, most of which I don't want and never use (but I love the small subset I do use). I saw the new AI stuff on the release notes, thought, "ugh, lame, I'll never use that", and moved on with my day.
- adamomada 2y agoiTerm2 is so good, it’s worth using macOS just for the crazy good terminal. I love the quake term hotkey access and while I’m sure other terminals can easily do it too, I think it might have been the first?
- vundercind 2y agoTerminal.app, even, is no slouch among terminal programs. Uncommonly-great input latency, for one thing.
- c-hendricks 2y agoI think the only thing keeping me on iterm is terminal.app's lack of a way to easily disable mouse integration. If you're using a TUI that works with the mouse but need to select some text, in iterm you hold Option and can select. In Terminal.app you need to use the menu to turn mouse handling off, select your text, then turn it back on.
- vundercind 2y agoYeah, Terminal.app isn’t necessarily better than iterm2, depending on what you need out of your terminal emulator. The latter’s got more features, for sure. The Mac platform’s just blessed with two way-above-average terminal emulators, one installed by default, is all I mean.
- cromka 2y agoI believe Yakuake/Kuake for KDE first introduced it some 20 or so years ago. I’ve been using it since its early days on Linux. EDIT: looks like someone even investigated that: https://babbagefiles.xyz/quake-drop-down-terminal-history/ https://babbagefiles.xyz/quake-drop-down-terminal-history/
- ics 2y agoPeople are just trying things out and it will be some time before developers and users settle on what works best for them. In this case, you need to provide your own API key which is a pretty good filter for who wants to use it. Maybe it's distasteful to follow hype in certain cases although this one appears actually useful, even if minimally to the author. I would be more concerned with AI-in-the-OS or other deeply embedded system making it impractical to avoid.
- Delmololo 2y agoGuess why Apple made m4? Why Windows is adding an ai key? Not sure what Ubuntu and other distributions will do but they will probably add it too. (I'm not against this, just stating it)
- zer0tonin 2y ago> Guess why Apple made m4? Because they need a gimmick to sell new ipads to people who don't really understand what a nanometer means in the context of semiconductors?
- Delmololo 2y agoNo. To accelerate ai for Photoshop, after effects, local enhanced Siri, voice to text and text to voice.
- ics 2y agoIt is a good point and I am cautiously following developments on these because it will not be a pleasant surprise out of the blue. Users need to see how it helps, developers need to see where/how it fits, companies "need" (will) test people's tolerance everything imagined in between. The analogy is broken a little by subscription license trends but otherwise I'd suggest it may be like getting a car with either manual or automatic transmission. Most people will opt for the automatic and pay more because it's easier. A still sizable portion will opt for the manual either for simplicity, control, cost savings, or a combination of these. A developer will not want to leave the market for AI-powered versions of their app on the table so obviously they'll pursue it; users given the choice will have needs based on some other context. Maybe a journalist wants GPT powered research tools and plain editing software. A romance novel writer can handle their own research but appreciates GPTs to help synthesize that into outlines and exposition. Will everyone get the kitchen sink without any say or will boundaries emerge which lead to different patterns of providing software?
- crystaln 2y agoPeople who think this feature is dumb are the same ones who thought graphical user interfaces and languages with memory management built in were dumb. Engineers must be open to new ideas. Personally I spend a lot do time googling arcane parameters and if AI can help me avoid that, it’s a win. If you don’t want to use it great. Good for you. You’ve spent enough time on the command line to know all the inconsistent insanity. Not everyone has or wants to.
- ErneX 2y agoI feel bad for the devs, the overreactions about this completely optional feature they can just ignore are ridiculous.
- crystaln 2y agoWait until Apple announces their deep integration with Open AI.
- racl101 2y agoAm I oversimplifying this or is it as simple as: "just don't turn it on" ??? I upgraded this morning too and saw updates too. It's been 3 hours since, continued working on my terminal, it has not gotten in my way at all. It's a non-issue for me. What am I missing?
- joshstrange 2y agoIt’s really that simple and everyone complaining about it is either horribly misinformed (at this point that’s on them) or trolling.
- xinayder 2y agoAnother point brought out is that iTerm2 may be offering their users data, for free, as training data for LLMs. You need an API key to use the built-in ChatGPT feature, but do you need a key if you're just feeding data to the AI?
- joshstrange 2y agoThe mid/disinformation in this comment almost makes me want to flag it. What an absolutely absurd idea that can be easily confirmed (it’s open source) and is borderline libel against the developer who has been maintaining this project for over a decade. It’s a crazy conspiracy theory that we can confirm or deny by looking at the code and it’s a theory about a practice (OpenAI taking training data from sources sending it to them not using the API, and also OpenAI doesn’t train on API data) that we have never seen in the wild.
- soraminazuki 2y agoThe amount of FUD and vitriol displayed by some circles for a small and non-intrusive optional feature is insane. This is especially evident in the issue tracker. The response is more vicious than Windows shoving AI in the start menu, and it's baffling. I have no use for the feature, I can write shell commands on my own. But why in the world would I go berating the developer over this? Why would anyone? iTerm2 is a gift that users owe him for, not the other way around. I see this in some open source communities. Is this kind of thing normal?
- pocketsand 2y agoStrange that people would be upset over an optional feature. I like the idea and may enable it.
- tmountain 2y agoFunny, I just switched to alacritty after using iTerm2 for over a decade because I wanted to get closer to a no frills experience (do one thing well). This was after trying warp terminal which is firmly heading in the opposite direction. Whatever the case, it’s nice to have a bunch of great options.
- amanzi 2y agoI did the same thing last night. Spent 10 minutes setting up a config file, which I then added to my dotconfig repo, and had Alacritty working perfectly. Highly recommended!
- leftcenterright 2y agoCould you share some more insights about your experience with Warp? I have been meaning to give it a try for the feature set around workflows.
- tmountain 2y agoWarp is really radical. It’s a completely reimagined terminal experience. It’s an AI first experience with the intention that you never need to Google another command invocation. They have a feature which allows you to save and label frequently used commands for easy access. Input and output are completely separated. It feels truly innovative, but for me, it was too much of a departure from the familiar environment of a traditional terminal. I can see people that are ready for it truly loving it. The only major downside is that they require you to register to use it, and I have seen people mention that it sends a lot of data “home”. I can see that being a dealbreaker for many. My low-tech alternative approach is to use alacritty with atuin and starship. Three tractable suckless programs that work beautifully together. Like anything, it’s a matter of preference and needs. HTH
- jedberg 2y agoA lot of people are angry or don't understand the feature. Am I the only one who actually loves this feature? I'd say 50% of my interactions with GPT are "Make a command line to do X". Right now I have to copy/paste back and forth to the GPT and tell it what happened. Having all of that built into the terminal is fantastic! The only feature I would ask for is obfuscation -- when I'm doing it for work, I am always careful that I change my question such that I get the right answer without revealing any company information. Of course a solution to this is enabling someone to point at another model that they control, either locally or hosted privately.
- liveoneggs 2y agoIsn't it much much better suited to be an editor integration you can use inside of fc?
- yareal 2y agoWould you like iterm to provide Google search results? Should iterm have discord chats or irc channels in it? It's not what I want iterm to do, I want iterm to be a great terminal.
- joshstrange 2y agoDo you use tmux? If not are you appalled that iTerm2 has support for that? What about the other billion config/settings/features of iTerm2 that you choose not to use? iTerm2 is a great terminal. It was great before the update and it’s still great after the update.
- infecto 2y agoDon't assign an api key to it then?
- h0l0cube 2y agoAnd that it still is, with a new lightweight feature that needn’t bother anyone unless they wish to enable it.
- whimsicalism 2y ago
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- throwup238 2y ago> It's everywhere, and it's exhausting. Part of my job requires me to keep up with the latest advances with AI and I'm unable to. Everything happens so much. Good god yes. I'm bullish on AI, have been playing with it a lot over the past year, and am now making a commercial AI-powered desktop app but this is exactly how I feel. I went from feeling the most excited I've been since I started programming as a kid to feeling like I'm drowning. Today on the front page of HN between a fifth and a quarter of the articles have been about AI of some sort. Not necessarily LLMs but between the Microsoft AI annoucements, a post on RAG and another on neural networks, CLIP representations, it feels like it's non stop onslaught of AI news that I try to keep up with and we're more than a year into the hype.
- samatman 2y agoI have sgpt installed and configured and use it practically every day. Great tool, almost magic when it works right (four out of five, maybe?). Less time reading tldr, man pages, browsing for random breadcrumbs, more time doing things. I recommend it. I also switched to WezTerm from iTerm awhile ago, largely because iTerm does so much stuff which isn't a emulating a terminal. I have a tool for querying OpenAI from the command line, I don't need or want it built into my terminal emulator, just doesn't jibe with my philosophy. I keep iTerm around for the "Quake terminal" feature, though. That remains pretty slick. The outrage and self-entitlement is absurd imho. Making it disabled-by-default rather than merely not configured seems like a reasonable accommodation, and is the likely outcome of all this hoopla. People who are complaining that their security policy won't allow it are either confused or dishonest: it makes a network call if you ask it to, the endpoint is either blocked by your policy or it isn't, this adds no new capabilities from a security standpoint. Probably politically wise to emphasize that it works with any OpenAI compatible endpoint, including a local one. The program is not in fact tied to OpenAI in any way and it might unruffle some featheres. It's reasonable to want your terminal to just be a terminal, and not feature badges, alerts, log search, its own autocomplete, triggers, annotations, a password manager, and now AI integration. If that's what you want, iTerm hasn't been the emulator for you for a long time. That's fine, there are options.
- dmix 2y agoThat feature sounds really cool. Not sure it should be the terminal app doing it though. Is there a MacOS app that does "Quicksilver" (cmd-space Spotlight box) style input that injects the GPT text at cursor or puts it into your clipboard?
- Igor_Wiwi 2y agoI built something similar with GPT-4o support https://github.com/gogainda/cmdhelp https://github.com/gogainda/cmdhelp Mac users just can download the built executable and start using it. All you need is an API key
- freehorse 2y ago> one of the greatest errors that was made with putting this in iTerm2 was making a big show of it Big show? You have to get several paragraphs into their announcement to read the first mention, middle to end of the list of features they add. In this huge announcement, only three paragraphs are devoted to their AI integration. When I updated, they presented a window showcasing 4 of the new features, the AI integration being the 3rd in the list. If some people here were not as hysterical about it, I may not even have noticed.
- hoherd 2y agoI think they mean when you open the app for the first time after installing the update you are walked through a series of slides showing off the new features, which ... I don't know if it's ever been done before with iTerm2, but if it has it is long enough ago that I don't remember it.
- soraminazuki 2y agoiTerm2 does that with big releases, and the release note said it was 2 years of work. I recall seeing the same dialog when it added the Python scripting API along with other features.
- freehorse 2y agoI have never seen anybody ever complain about a slideshow of 4 features that pops up once after an update and one can easily close pressing x without even getting through them. This is common for software after an update. Should they try hide what they added? I bet more people who use iterm2 learnt about it here than those who would have learnt about it from iterm2 devs. And btw as I wrote, the AI integration was 3rd in the list. You have to press the "next" button 2 times to get to it. One could have pressed x on the first slide and not even get to see that. The amount of effort put here into complaining about something that can ignored with 0 effort is absurd. And I cannot shake the feeling that this would have almost never been done for any closed source project.
- joshstrange 2y agoThat line made me discredit the author and the whole blog post. You have to be willfully uninformed to say something so wrong and the very next line is complaining about not being able to use ollama or similar which you absolutely can by changing the API endpoint in the settings. The author has clearly no idea what they are talking about.
- stephc_int13 2y agoBad timing I guess. The current FOMO-driven AI push by Microsoft/Google/Apple etc. is quite ridiculous to be honest. I think there is a use case for this tech, but it is also fairly limited in its power, trying to replace all computing with kit bashed AI stuff don't seem like a good idea. The backlash and outrage is probably too much, as usual, there is a part of social contagion, but still...
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- amanzi 2y agoThis is the bit resonated with me the most: "One of the main bits of feedback I've seen from people online is that iTerm2 having AI involved at all is enough to get them to want to switch away to another terminal emulator. They've cited the reason as exhaustion due to overexposure to AI hype." I have paid accounts with both OpenAI and Anthropic, so I'm not anti-AI in general, and I understand that it is opt-in, and requires your own API key to get it working. But it's the hype exhaustion that gets me. I really don't want AI in my terminal, just one keystroke away from sending some slop to a remote server. And just knowing that my terminal is capable of that is enough to turn me away.
- wrs 2y agoIt’s many keystrokes away. You have to type the thing you want sent to OpenAI. Manually. It appears 95% of the people complaining about this feature don’t actually know what it is.
- hombre_fatal 2y agoYeah, 95% of the people complaining never even opened up the "Engage AI" box much less the Codecierge panel.
- amanzi 2y agoI uninstalled iTerm2 before trying out the feature, but have watched the linked demo video and read the docs, and my point still stands - the generated code is a single key-press away from being sent to a remote server. It's like copying a terminal command from StackOverflow and pasting it directly into your terminal and hoping it works as described.
- wrs 2y agoThat is literally what people do with Stack Overflow, and yet there are no mobs with pitchforks demanding that the Paste command be removed from iTerm2.
- 2y ago
- metadat 2y ago> iTerm2 is the world's most popular terminal emulator Is iTerm2 really that popular? I used it in the past but then I found the stock mac terminal.app works just fine. And I'm a pretty extensive terminal monkey.. just don't want to install more apps unless there's a significant benefit. The AI feature in this instance is interesting but not quite compelling enough to risk sacrificing my currently very snappy and responsive CLI experience.
- leftcenterright 2y ago2 posts on HN front page about it right now [1] and 3 within 12 hours [2], seems quite popular :) 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40428032 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40428032 2. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40425428 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40425428
- verdverm 2y agoI wonder if the VS Code terminal is now the most popular. Since I migrated back to a Mac, I have also chosen VS Code, and have no need for the builtin terminal or iterm
- Patrick_Devine 2y agoMy biggest issue w/ stock terminal.app is the rendering is terrible compared to iTerm. Try running `docker run -it --rm ghcr.io/pdevine/thisisfine` on both terminal.app and iterm2. Terminal.app completely butchers the line spacing.
- adamomada 2y agoI think that terminal usage is either non-existent (Windows cmd.exe or Mac users and Terminal.app) or so fragmented (Linux) that a small share of Mac devs specifically choosing the same alternative and actually using it puts it high on the list. Just a guess and I’d still like to know how they came up with it
- wrs 2y agoIt has lots of potential killer features, depending on your workflow. To name one example, the tmux integration is great.
- autopilot23 2y agoI wanted RTL support (e.g. Arabic) with the new update and got this instead :(
- Lerc 2y agoAt what point do we call behaviour like this bigotry? In the field of AI there are many issues to be debated and legal findings to be made. People have disagreements on a lot of even basic premises yet proponents on either side will state them as fact without providing an argument. I have seen people post messages on generative AI forums about how to handle the hate they receive. All too often people on those forums handle it by behaving like a 12 year old childishly retaliating. When it comes to products with AI features, it stands to reason that there will be a lot of new things and a lot of them will be useless. It's an interesting new technology that nobody knows exactly where it fits in. We only find that out by experimentation. My only concern with an optional feature like in iTerm2 is if it consumed significant resources when not used. Ie. Does it significantly contribute to bloat. If not then the objection is not to the feature itself but to the idea of the feature. That seems to be a step fraught with danger.
- mikl 2y ago> At what point do we call behaviour like this bigotry? When big tech stops being creepy. Companies like Microsoft, Facebook, Google, etc. have taught us to be constantly vigilant, if we want to have any sort of privacy. They’re always finding new creative ways to datamine us. No reason we’d trust OpenAI either.
- Lerc 2y agoI agree that there is an issue with large tech companies having undue influence over society, and that they frequently against the interests of their users. I would applaud regulation that mitigates these negative behaviours. I have never had a Facebook account because I did not agree with their user-is-the-product model. This is my personal choice. People usually only find this out I tell people I can't do the thing they want me to do because it is on Facebook. The usual response is surprise, followed by general acceptance. I do not see how this relates to AI though. AI is not a business, it is a technology. The antipathy seems to be directed at AI itself, not any particular company. I am all for criticism of company behaviour if it is well argued. I don't like the blanket "X is bad, everything X does is bad". Apart from being a non sequitur, I don't really accept the absoloute "X is bad" for any company. Companies are composed of individuals, those people have influences, agency, and beliefs. To say that they are uniformly bad is to say that every individual who works their is bad. By all means criticize bad behaviour of companies. Criticize the leadership that let it happen, and keep on doing so if they let it continue. Declaring the lot of them to be evil is not only counter productive, but taking the easy way out. The idea of defeating them is just some revolutionary fantasy and without any other means to modulate their behaviour you are just supporting the status quo. Absolutely, be constantly vigilant. Just remember to make a case for your point. An optional feature that you don't have to use does not seem like a good reason to hate a iTerm2. It would be like me declaring I am no longer going to use a web browser because it has the ability to view Facebook, I simply don't use that feature.
- ungreased0675 2y agoThere’s a perspective I haven’t seen yet that may explain the backlash: I would never integrate OpenAI into a terminal program I was building because of hallucinations, a lack of trust in OpenAI, and other reasons. I’m not an anti-AI Luddite either, hopped on the AI train in 2015. So, when someone else integrates OpenAI where I don’t think it belongs, I feel like I can’t trust their judgment, and therefore can’t trust them to make good product management decisions in the future. Adding questionable features is a red flag indicating the product team isn’t focused or has poor judgment. Put another way, you don’t put the person that says Taco Bell is quality Mexican food in charge of arranging catering for the company Christmas party. I can’t trust them to not screw it up.
- __loam 2y agoRight, the point is not that the feature is opt in, the point is that you can no longer trust the maintainers to make good decisions.
- octernion 2y agoi think 99% of folks would take an occasional hallucinated ffmpeg option in exchange for never having to look up the man page again. i trust the iterm dev's judgement even more after this since it's an ideal use case. gpt-4o seems fantastic at generating cli flags and such, not sure what troubles you have run into. i am questioning your judgement of their judgement, hah.
- Xelynega 2y agoThe question isn't "is it useful", it's "should it be part of the core of the application". If this meets the bar for "worth inclusion in the core of the application", I would rather stick to terminal emulators that are spending their time on making the terminal emulator more responsive rather than adding gimmicks that have to be maintained.
- tzs 2y agoAren't plenty of people already using OpenAI for help with command lines without there being any integration? They copy/paste between the LLM's web interface and their terminal. All this integration is doing is making it more convenient for those people by removing the need for them to manually relay between the terminal and the LLM.
- mikl 2y agoCringed when I read the changelog for the new version and saw that they added AI features. That’s like the last thing I want in my terminal.
- some1else 2y agoAccess LLMs from the command line: https://github.com/simonw/llm https://github.com/simonw/llm
- paulmd 2y agoNo, it’s the opposite and some people very obviously have an AI Pessimism Overload at this point. People need to grow the fuck up about whatever particular aspect of AI is making them personally salty (there are a number of common answers) and realize these models actually do deliver real value for people right now, and that they are going to have to learn to live with those feature being present in products even if they personally choose not to use them. It’s the same thing in hardware, there is a large group of people who are not emotionally mature enough to realize that not every product is meant for every customer and just because you wouldn’t personally purchase some product that isn’t suited for your uses, doesn’t mean nobody will and that it shouldn’t exist. This is the same thing with people wanting to sandbag development of LLM features because they personally don’t use them. Well, tough.
- joshstrange 2y ago> I think that one of the greatest errors that was made with putting this in iTerm2 was making a big show of it, and by not letting you use local models (such as with Ollama) instead of having OpenAI be the only option. This line alone makes me completely discredit the entire post. A. There was no “big show” made. It wasn’t the headlining feature in either the release notes nor the post-install popup. People here on HN and probably on other social media made a big deal about it but iTerm2 itself did not. B. You can change the OpenAI API endpoint to point to ollama or some other local OpenAI-compatible API (aka every major local LLM tool has this) People are up in arms over an opt-in feature and it’s frankly embarrassing. On top of that, the feature is pretty shit IMHO. You can’t undo/redo in the popup, it has no history, it wouldn’t paste the result of the command into my terminal (I had to do it manually), no way to retrieve the command again after closing the popup, and no way to alter the command if there was a problem. Using ChatGPT is still a way better experience. Lastly, all the “I’m switching away from iTerm2!” comments/posts are just crazy. I mean, I guess I wish I had nothing better or more important to do in my life than go looking for a terminal replacement (a central and hugely important tool I use many times every day to do my job) just because it added a feature I don’t want to use and don’t have to use… Did all those users get up in arms about the tmux support if they don’t use tmux? Or any other of the vast config options iTerm2 has? I just don’t get it, people are being so irrational about this.