12 ms·
Big Tech to EU: "Drop Dead"
- ranger_danger 2y agoTried to post it 5 days ago but it never went anywhere: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40345656 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40345656
- hackernewds 2y agoit happens. Internet points are worthless
- _the_inflator 2y agoVery valid points. In my view they miss the mark however. Blaming Apple for optimizing their platform model isn’t the problem, it became a problem. Imagine 2007 and the following years already with the EU act in full effect. AppStore would be dead on arrival. In my view Apple’s AppStore went from feature some people have when they buy a smartphone to necessity. 2007 and even 2016 was a perfect time to opt for a live without smartphones. Not so 2024. So EU should change Apple’s and Google’s status from producer to provider of essential service like electricity for example. Some often overlooked fact is, that Apple decides at will who is allowed to publish apps via AppStore and who is not. This is an area where regulation is needed in my opinion. In other areas of life you simply cannot take down businesses at will, while Apple can.
- rowanG077 2y ago> AppStore would be dead on arrival. Yes, exactly! That's the point. The mobile ecosystem would look heaps better without it.
- brg 2y agoWe have the world without it available for inspection. The Android ecosystem is a shambling mess compared to the quality that is availabe in the Apple Playstore. It does look heaps better on many dimensions.
- viraptor 2y agoYou can search for a specific name on appstore and get mostly a screen of spam. I'm not sure where you see the quality difference.
- Tade0 2y agoI worked for a guy who made a fortune on an iOS app named "Ugly Meter". Any difference in quality stems from the fact that Apple product users are more willing to pay for things. The free apps are equally bad in both stores. Meanwhile Android allows for alternative stores like F-Droid, where you won't see the usual spam, as the apps are FOSS.
- wiseowise 2y agoNot anymore. These days PlayStore is roughly on the same level. Source: I have both.
- rowanG077 2y agoI don't really see a difference in quality between the two. There is bottom feeding trash in both.
- nelsonic 2y agoPlease elaborate.
- mrweasel 2y agoHonestly I don't think most users care, at all. The complaints regarding the AppStore comes from a few tech companies and a small percentage of highly technical users. For everyone else it's fine. The EU mandating alternative stores or side-load won't significantly hurt Apples bottom line. The most valid complaint, and this is something Apple needs to address world view, is the move towards in-app purchases and subscriptions. I believe that is due to a limitation in the AppStore, where Apple isn't allowing upgrade pricing, but allowing subscriptions to enable features. In-app purchases is destroying the AppStore. You could say: Well that would be fixed with an alternative store, but I have serious doubts about other app store operators not being tempted by the recurring revenue as well.
- Someone 2y ago> Imagine 2007 and the following years already with the EU act in full effect. AppStore would be dead on arrivaL. Why do you think so? I think it would be different, but not dead. Giving their users a simple means to discover selected apps would still be win-win for both Apple and their customers, even if users had other means to obtain the apps. Apple could also charge companies for having their apps in that store.
- petre 2y agoThere's also the argument that they made enough money with these monopolistic practices and it's now time to stop or share their stash with the EU. How could have the legislator forseen all of these practices in order to codify them into laws? Regulation usually comes after abuse.
- viraptor 2y agoWhat do you even mean? There's no payments to EU in this case. How would they share the stash?
- petre 2y agoThrough the huge fines they are subject to if they violate the the law.
- viraptor 2y agoThe EU fines are typically fairly small. Every time one is given, you can see someone on HN commenting it's spare change for the company. Those fines in practice are set to "pay this symbolic amount and fix things, or the next fine will be huge". I don't think anyone refused to implement the required fixes yet.
- pasc1878 2y agoApple - and the rest of the large companies manage to order their payments so that their profits are offshored out of Europe. Which means they are not paying the corporate tax an EU resident company would. So EU is not getting their fair share.
- miken123 2y ago> Imagine 2007 and the following years already with the EU act in full effect. AppStore would be dead on arrival. No, it wouldn't have been, as the DMA only applies to 'gatekeepers' and if you're new, you're simply not a gatekeeper. You need at least 45 million monthly active users and 7,5 billion of revenue for three years. > So EU should change Apple’s and Google’s status from producer to provider of essential service like electricity for example. That's the whole point of the DMA: designate these parties as 'gatekeepers', providing essential services ('core platform services' in terms of the DMA). Once you are, you have certain obligations that should allow proper interoperability with other/smaller parties.
- afiori 2y ago> You need at least 45 million monthly active users and 7,5 billion of revenue for three years Minor nitpick that does not really changes the point but might provide context: these are the criteria to automatically be classified as gatekeeper. You can be a gatekeeper even if you do not meet them, but the EU needs to prove that you meet some other more detailed criteria.
- jochem9 2y agoFun fact: Apple originally didn't want an app store and wanted to go with web apps. It was only when third party apps installed after jailbreaking got super popular, that Apple opened their own app store (and then made it a huge commercial success). So it actually shows that a third party app store would thrive, even if there is no first party app store. Especially if there were no barriers for using such a third party app store, such as requiring a jailbreak.
- IanCal 2y ago> Some often overlooked fact is, that Apple decides at will who is allowed to publish apps via AppStore and who is not. Overlooked? It's the key issue the EU is bringing up around appstores isn't it?
- riffraff 2y ago> Imagine 2007 and the following years already with the EU act in full effect. AppStore would be dead on arrival. App stores on platforms where competition is allowed still thrive, I'm sure you heard of Steam?
- nottorp 2y agoAnd funny enough, Steam has some competition, namely GoG. Speaking of game stores, how about an "alternate iOS app store" that only has hand curated pay once games? Might entice me to actually check mobile games again and even buy some.
- deleted 2y ago[deleted]
- freetanga 2y agoXbox, Sony and Nintendo each has its own e-store plus physical copies (first and second hand) in many retailers. Epic, Rockstar, EA, Paradigm, etc each have their own e-Shops too. Any dev can choose to sell direct too (your Mac, Win or Linux will happily install third party software) And Steam has GoG and other competitors (I often used Humble Bundle) You
- NekkoDroid 2y ago> (I often used Humble Bundle) Do note that Humble Bundle keys are often Steam keys provided to the developers by Steam at no extra cost IIRC.
- qp11 2y agoApple and Google are not the same thing. Google is a ponzi scheme propped up by trapping everyone in a War for finite Attention. They tell content creators/advertisers+marketers(corporations that pay)/politicians we can get you eyeballs, no matter how much content explodes, not matter how many people are competing for finite attention. Its basically Fraud. People will work it out in their own sweet time cause its the largest ponzi scheme of all time. (Google subprime attention crisis) Apple benefits from the Attention War just like anyone who has more cash benefits, cause they can outspend anyone to capture Attention.
- bitpush 2y agoBud, are you OK? You seem to be raging against everything. Capitalist companies exist to make money, and they make money by providing a service that users want. Sometimes they are bad for uses (alcohol, cigarretes, gambling) but nobody is forcing anyone to buy any of these things. Just because a user likes to spend $1500 every year on latest iPhone because it makes him "feel cool" or "have self worth" isnt fraud. Apple is just catering to that person.
- wiseowise 2y agoIt’s not a fraud, but it’s scummy.
- grishka 2y agoThe problem is not just the app store, it's the lack of sideloading, the fact that as a developer, you HAVE to go through the app store to have an iOS app at all. The fact that Apple forcibly inserts itself between you and your users and acts as if they had a role in you earning this relationship. While in real life, app stores themselves hardly earn apps any users. Most of the time, people install an app thanks to the app developer's own marketing efforts. If you want a real-world example of an app store on a platform where there are alternative methods of app distribution, just look at macOS. Same idea, same rules, but there is sideloading as an alternative. It turns out neither users nor developers are having any of it.
- ahzhou 2y ago> AppStore would be dead on arrival Certainly not. PMF was already established via the jailbreaking scene and Installer.app / Cydia. Millions of people went through the annoying processing of jailbreaking their phone to get apps.
- bee_rider 2y agoThe EU will win this if they want. Their trump card is that, actually, making the EU not a viable market for the most annoying US tech companies would be a huge win for many of their constituents.
- kernal 2y agoApple should play their Trump card and threaten to pull out of the EU. The EU would blink first because the public backlash would be career ending.
- viraptor 2y agoRight, get rid of their 2nd largest market, at size ~⅔ of the US one. Yes, that will definitely show the EU who's the boss. /s
- yard2010 2y agoBut what if they will though? Won't china happily replace the EU market? It's much bigger too and Winnie the Pooh doesn't care about ppl privacy that much
- refactor_master 2y agoI think it’s much more likely that China sees this as “Apple refuses to bend to local laws”, and in turn kick them out. Remember, China has its own online universe and Apple is just desperately trying to be part of it. https://www.mobileworldlive.com/apple/china-forces-apple-to-remove-whatsapp-threads/ https://www.mobileworldlive.com/apple/china-forces-apple-to-...
- Hamuko 2y agoApple is losing market share in China and iPhone shipments are down almost 20%. What bold strategy is going to make Chinese sales make up for the entirety of the European Union? https://www.reuters.com/technology/apples-q1-phone-sales-china-fall-191-huaweis-up-70-2024-04-23/ https://www.reuters.com/technology/apples-q1-phone-sales-chi...
- kernal 2y agoConsidering how restrictive third party app stores are on iOS the title should really be Apple to EU: Drop Dead. Google should do the same thing, I'd love to see them fine Google over it.
- userbinator 2y agoI'm in favour of opening up platforms and interoperability, but not the GDPR. Maybe in this case, "an enemy is an enemy of a friend".
- pheggs 2y agoI feel the same. The GDPR appears super difficult to comply with, even impossible in some cases, and very restricting. I just hope negative effects of (in my opinion) overregulation wont hurt the EUs economy too badly, but that wont be visible for another couple of decades
- aebtebeten 2y agoThe GDPR is trivial to comply with: don't track (let alone process) personal data.
- pheggs 2y agoYes I agree its a good idea to not track personal data, but thats by far not the only rule in GDPR
- mtts 2y agoCorrect, but “not tracking personal data” is in fact not a rule in the GDPR. “Only store personal data you really need” is, qualified with “and don’t share it with others”. Cookie walls exist because companies insist on handing over their visitor data to external ad networks.
- tyfon 2y agoWhat other rule do you find impossible? Data portability? The users right to delete data? Data processing agreements? Data security? Article 30? They are all fairly trivial unless you do shady stuff really. Step one if is really looking at what you process as stipulated by article 30, a lot of the other stuff is much easier after that. One of my roles is as a DPO in a bank in Europe, and it's far from impossible to comply.
- aborsy 2y agoPay or Okay is reasonable to some extent (depending on the amount). Do European countries hold themselves and the local companies to the same standards, respect their citizens and their privacy rights? I remember a French institution could not buy our product, because they had a contract with a local manufacturer. They explained to us that they are obliged to buy from this company, or otherwise go through a complicated process of explaining to the government AND the company why that company doesn’t meet their needs. Sounded absurd! They had to sort of get the permission of the competitor company!
- piecerough 2y ago> I remember a French institution could not buy our product, because they had a contract with a local manufacturer. I doubt this is a EU thing. It's due to exclusive contracts/licenses. This happens everywhere?
- IanCal 2y agoIt sounds a lot like like approved suppliers too, which is common in large orgs.
- mackwic 2y agoJust so you know, it's a common practice in the US. As europeans, we are almost required to open LLCs in your states, do a joint venture with a local US company, and hire US persons to sell to US people. It's a matter of fact that the EU is still more open to commerce from US, than the US is with the EU.
- Caligatio 2y agoI always scratch my head about articles that lump Meta, Apple, and Google together when it comes to regulations. They all have different problems that require different solutions. Apple - consumers give the company for hardware which is locked into a closed ecosystem. Apple extracts extra revenue by enforcing this closed ecosystem. There can be no competition other than not purchasing their hardware in the first place. Google - consumers sometimes give them money (for both hardware and services) which Google then uses to push their other products to the detriment of their competitors. Due to Google's size, the competition is at a massive disadvantage. Also, given that most consumers don't give them money, Google needs to make money off of their consumers and the most profitable method is to monetize PII. Meta - consumers basically never give them money (excluding Oculus) so Meta needs to make money off of their consumers. The most profitable method is to monetize PII. I have a little more sympathy for Google and Meta's situation as the EU wants them to maintain their free services while simultaneously reducing their ability to monetize their most valuable asset, consumers' PII (note that PII ultimately belongs to the consumer but it's still the thing that the companies use to make money). There needs to be some sort of happy medium here when people want something without paying for it but also don't want what's valuable about them being a user - their PII - to be monetized. To be clear, these multi billion/trillion dollar companies don't need anyone defending them. However, it would be interesting to see what the EU's position would be if Meta started as an EU company.
- nroets 2y agoI, on the other hand, have a lot more sympathy for Apple: Many highly successful people and many businesses have never owned any of there products. They are not a monopoly. Why can't market forces just regulate them ??
- Sharlin 2y agoBecause personal computer market (let’s face it: the primary or only personal computing device of most people today is a phone or a tablet) are a duopoly, with the other actor also being one of the monopolistic tech giants.
- punnerud 2y agoI wish there could be added a signature to GDPR export, that can be validated. This way you can transfer data to a new platform and the new platform can trust that the information is not manipulated. Let me and a couple of friends move out of Facebook and bring all our prior interactions with us. (The signature should be invalid after example one month to avoid the value of data breaches, with periodic signature key release)
- ein0p 2y agoI’m an Apple fan and I keep hundreds of thousands of dollars in Apple stock, and I still hope we at least get side loading out of all this. I do not believe this would be in any way detrimental to Apple - most people don’t give a shit. But for me and others like me it’d be pretty neat to do on my iPhone and iPad what I can already do on my Mac: install my own software that is not arbitrarily time limited.
- makeitdouble 2y ago> I do not believe this would be in any way detrimental to Apple They wouldn't be ropped in kicking and screaming if that really was the case.
- throwaway_qiwuw 2y agoMuch like my 8 year old, I think they lack the perspective to behave like an adult here. Several companies have fought what they thought were unwanted regulations only to view them as useful later on. Time will tell if they were right to kick and scream or not.
- pjerem 2y agoYeah. Especially in Apple’s case, I don’t understand how they can’t see that a more open iOS could easily dominate the market.
- patrickmcnamara 2y ago> the eight-year-old General Data Protection Regulation Wow. It's actually only been enforced for six years but that time absolutely flew by.
- LAC-Tech 2y agoRemember when local US companies with zero EU presence were geo-blocking EU visitors in-case they were found to be in-violation of the GDPR? Presumably the fear was a crack team of EU secret service agents would kidnap and illegally extradite them to stand trial in Brussels.
- Hamuko 2y agoYou mean remember the thing that is still very much a thing? I also occasionally get geo-blocked by Japanese websites too.
- Kwpolska 2y ago> in-case they were found to be in-violation of the GDPR Oh, they definitely are. Those geo-blocks still exist, not only for small mom-n-pop businesses.
- switch007 2y agoOh dear you're going to trigger the pro EU crowd who don't like being told EU law doesn't apply in the US
- jnurmine 2y ago
- jauntywundrkind 2y agoWhat's kind of weirdly ironic about this is it's governments upkeeping a Declaration of Independence of Cyberspace. It's governments keeping vaster colossuses still from gobbling up our most personal devices & connectivities & keeping them bound forever. Apple has made itself sovereign king over a wide sector of cyberspace, and the governments have to play the part of tyrant smasher. This is not how the DIS told it's story, but mercy heavens be do we need someone to prevent our closest tools from being bound forever against us. If that's governments so be it.
- LAC-Tech 2y agoImagine a world in which the EU instead funded research & implementation of public protocols to undermine US big tech? IE, they mention chat clients in the text, why not create something in the spirit of XMPP (or even revive it if the technical merits remain relevant?) I can almost feel it in my bones that there's a protocol behind "feed" websites like twitter & linkedin. Break the walled garden with open standards. I mean we know the real answer is. The EU hates innovating especially when it could be regulating. But it's a fun thought experiment.
- pythonic_hell 2y agoThe irony of your statement is that many of the core tech, protocol and software systems underpinning these big tech companies were developed in the EU.
- LAC-Tech 2y agoIn the EU != by the EU. By EU I'm referring to the governing bodies, ie my reference to the EU regulating things. If you re-read what I said with that in mind, does it make more sense to you?
- planck01 2y agoThe EU is not a tech company. Then yet, they are funding these kinds of things. Check for instance https://gaia-x.eu/ https://gaia-x.eu/ However, these projects don't really have good results and generally are better made in the private sector. Same in the US actually
- Animats 2y ago> Imagine a world in which the EU instead funded research & implementation of public protocols to undermine US big tech? That was tried, decades ago. Machines Bull. Plan Calcul. Cyclades. Minitel. Didn't win.
- Kwpolska 2y agoXMPP never died. A more modern open standard is Matrix. The problem with open/alternative chat apps is the network effect — everyone is already on iMessage/WhatsApp/Messenger/etc and they aren't going to install Element and figure out the entire decentralised network thing to talk with one weirdo.
- gherkinnn 2y ago[flagged]
- detolly 2y agoDoes anyone know if the DMA would apply to Playstation? Shouldn't I be allowed to boot whatever software I want (Linux) on my PS5?
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoWell, AFAIK you're allowed to, but that doesn't mean Sony needs to make it possible for you. That said, if Sony falls under the DMA, they may need to allow sideloading apps or 3rd party stores.
- grishka 2y agoConsoles aren't generally seen by people as general-purpose computers, neither are they marketed as such by their manufacturers. They're seen by most people as appliances for playing video games.
- karma_pharmer 2y agoI don't see cellphones as general purpose computers either. For exactly the same reason why I don't see game consoles as general purpose computers: neither one will run arbitrary programs. They only run programs that are blessed by their manufacturer. Both are appliances. I'm really failing to see the distinction here. Big tech will simply declare that phones aren't "general purpose computers". There is no reasonable endgame here in which: (a) this is enforced against cellphones and (b) this is not enforced against game consoles and (c) the EU doesn't end up looking completely ridiculous and arbitrary. I'm betting that they cave on (b). It's the least painful option. The EU is going to have to enforce this against game consoles in order to be taken seriously.
- SSLy 2y agoVideo Consoles are a semi-luxury product, not essentials to modern society like smartphones are.
- seec 2y agoI need to have an app on my phone to manage my health care payment. I don't need a console for anything in particular. It's hardly the same thing. Some services are not even available on a traditional computer FinTech started as mobile apps and they added website support later. It's stupid but that's how things are, the majority has chosen...
- mattlondon 2y agoIs this "Big Tech" or is it mainly just Apple throwing it's toys out of the pram because it's not getting it's own way after years of acting aloof? Yeah Facebook are jerks but they've always been jerks... But what about Amazon or MS or Google or Netflix or others? Are they acting in the same way? The article seems fairly light on any details of the people we'd traditionally think of for "Big Tech"?
- Lio 2y agoIn this scenario Apple is the great dictator from the 1984 ad and the EU is the British woman with the hammer. I can’t even get music I’ve bought, from Apple, off my iPhone and onto my mac without an extra recurring subscription. Apple aren’t “curating” that experience they are gouging me.
- Animats 2y agoThe EU is also grinding forward towards classifying all gig workers controlled by "platforms" as employees, with the platform subject to all employment laws. See "Improving working conditions of persons working through digital labour platforms "[1] Background: [2] Last vote in the European parliament: 554 votes in favour, 56 votes against and 24 abstentions. This is somewhat weakened but still stronger than anything in the US. Uber is worried. [1] https://oeil.secure.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/popups/ficheprocedure.do?reference=2021/0414(COD)&l=en https://oeil.secure.europarl.europa.eu/oeil/popups/ficheproc... [2] https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/platform-work-eu/ https://www.consilium.europa.eu/en/policies/platform-work-eu...
- Cthulhu_ 2y agoUber should be worried, but also because they are no longer cheaper than the established competition (taxis) that already had the labour laws in place.
- fleshdaddy 2y agoFor me at least it’s not actually the price of the Uber but that I know what it will be up front. I wasn’t really taking cabs until uber was ubiquitous though so maybe that’s not the same for everyone.
- bryanrasmussen 2y agoIn Denmark taxis are great and are used all the time, but I think Uber is illegal here anyway so...
- emptysongglass 2y agoTaxis are not great here in Denmark, I don't know why you'd think to state this. They are also not "used all the time", instead used sparingly because of how outrageously expensive they are. Taxis are run by cartels here who have carved up Denmark amongst themselves. Drivers wait in queues, idling, and are paid to idle, sometimes dozens of cabs at a time. As a result, taxis in Denmark are some of the most expensive in the world. Uber was banned here in Denmark because the taxi companies saw a threat to their easy money. Drivers wanted to drive independently and for a brief period where Uber was allowed to operate, competition flourished and prices came way down. I'm not saying Uber is a good thing but pretending or even suggesting that the taxi companies are somehow an ethical or good alternative is absurd.
- red_admiral 2y agoThere's a spectrum from a ban on all innovation on one end, to your car collecting data about your sex life and selling it to insurers without your consent or an option to opt out on the other end (the sex life bit was in Kia's privacy policy, along with things like trade union membership). Personally, I think the EU is a lot closer to a sweet spot than the vision of the FAANG. Apple is an odd case as they're actually ok on user privacy as far as I can tell, they just want to milk their closed ecosystem as much as they can. The EU has some ideas I personally disagree with like the whole EIDAS article 45 thing, but if I had to pick between the EU and Meta's vision for the future, I'm much closer to the EU's one.
- fauigerzigerk 2y ago>Meta’s answer to this is a “Pay or Okay” system, in which users who do not consent to Meta’s surveillance will have to pay to use the service, or be blocked from it. Unfortunately for Meta, this is prohibited (privacy is not a luxury good that only the wealthiest should be afforded). I'm a bit torn on this one. If the EU decided to ban the use of personal data for advertising outright, it would be radical but consistent. But what they appear to be doing is to give people a choice to say yes or no while not allowing them to trade their personal data in exchange for services. Justifying this with a slogan like "privacy is not a luxury" seems weirdly out of touch with any possible reality. If most users were declining the collection of personal data and more services switched to a subscription model, then the entire service would become a luxury for a large share of the world's population. On top of that, privacy would be lost for everybody as there is nothing that eradicates privacy more thoroughly than making a payment.
- hwbunny 2y agoKick them out of the EU. We need our own solutions. Big tech stifles innovation, steal data and use underhanded practices all around. Just look at youtube. It's the same (worse) in the last 10 years. No innovation whatsoever. EU is not the wild west US people accustomed to. Bombard them malicious big tech entities back to the stone age.
- slazaro 2y agoAm I the only one a bit weirded out by a headline that's basically "X said Y" where Y is in quotes, but it turns out that X is not a well-defined entity, and Y wasn't actually said by anybody? Regardless of the content of the article, it just doesn't seem like a good look. And I donate to the EFF! It's just... weird to me.
- amai 2y agoI wonder why the EU invented a new name to state the obvious: tech gatekeepers = tech monopolies
- planck01 2y agoBecause of better and easier to prove legal definitions. It's not about the lack of competition, but just the number of users you have.
- EasyMark 2y agoI would love to see the EU to tell some US tech companies to drop dead and some new smaller corps emerge within a more customer friendly attitude. I would certainly sign up from across the pond if they extended the same customer friendly policies, even if it cost a bit more.
- thefz 2y ago> Apple appears to be playing a high-stakes game of chicken with EU regulators, effectively saying, “Yes, you have 500 million citizens, but we have three trillion dollars, so why should we listen to you?” Retreat then and gift 500mil users to your competition, I am pretty sure nothing of value will be lost.