26 ms·
Is artificial consciousness achievable? Lessons from the human brain
- rvikmanis 2y agoNo
- BriggyDwiggs42 2y agoY
- hiAndrewQuinn 2y agoWe don't even know whether other human beings are conscious, man. The only thing which we might say with much certainty is that things which are more "like us" along some metric are more likely to be actually conscious, and things which are less "like us" are less likely to be so. Maybe everything is conscious. Maybe nothing except one's own self. But you'll never truly know one way or another, even if humanity invented some kind of Freaky Friday body swap thing.
- ben_w 2y agoI know that at least one other human is conscious, otherwise the term would never have been invented. But you have no way to tell if I am as conscious as I claim to be, or if I'm just a large language model trained by humanity :P
- golf_mike 2y agoCan you provide proof for the first claim?
- ben_w 2y agoWhich part exactly are you seeking proof of, and to what standard? "I know" is unprovable to others, unless you examine the wiring of my brain. (But then, what is "knowledge"?) "at least one other human is conscious, otherwise the term would never have been invented." — it's always possible that I'm a Bolzmann brain and this was just luck. I don't see how the term could have been invented by a mind that didn't actually have it, except with astronomical low probably random events.
- vixen99 2y agoIn thinking about this perennial problem it's worth bearing in mind that human beings pick up and process an immense amount of data on a continuous basis, that is currently unavailable to any LLM.
- elicksaur 2y agoAnd all on an estimated 100 watts!
- ben_w 2y ago20 for the brain, 60-125 for the whole body depending on if you mean "normally" or "metabolic minimum".
- anticensor 2y agoThe "metabolic maximum" is around 1250, though. And a mediocre lifting or running momentarily increases it from 125 to 700.
- elicksaur 2y agoYeah there’s different ways you could slice it. I was including the whole system, since if the GPU’s cooling system breaks, it won’t be useful for long.
- vidarh 2y agoNo, we don't. We don't even know if existence has an extent in time, because our only way of "interfacing" with time is our experience of memory we can't prove is real. For what you know, you're a lone entity confined to an infinitely short period of time, and all else is an illusion. But of course this isn't a useful assumption in most respects.
- ben_w 2y agoAh, I see you're more of an A. J. Ayer fan than a Descartes fan. I think that if an LLM has any consciousness, it would be an experience like this — one where the past was a fiction it invented to fit the prompt, and the "now" was the only moment before the mind was reset. But I'd put that in the same basket as my… ah, nephew comment? Cousin comment? I guess you'd call it that if we have parent comments etc.? https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40406398 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40406398 What you say is not wrong in principle, but it's in the same "cognitively unstable" basket as a Boltzmann brain, where to accept it would mean I couldn't trust my own reason to believe it.
- vidarh 2y agoThe reasoning stands entirely on its own. There's nothing you need to "believe". That you don't have a way to disprove it is close enough to proof. The problem with it is that it's not giving us anything useful. OK, so maybe this moment is the only one there is? Now what? Accordingly the only reasonable recourse is for the most part to ignore it, and add an implicit "assuming my memory and senses are roughly trustworthy" to every assumption. This is the same reason I'm a firm materialist even though we could be in a simulation, or brains in vats: absent evidence of either, the only thing giving us useful information is our senses and our introspection, and so the most useful approach is to assume they are valid until proven otherwise.
- ben_w 2y ago> The reasoning stands entirely on its own. There's nothing you need to "believe". That you don't have a way to disprove it is close enough to proof. Not so, for it is like the liar's paradox, except with high probabilities rather than Boolean logic. If you assume it is true, it follows that you can't trust your own state of mind, and that all statements including "I am just a thought" become suspect, as there is nothing leading up to them to give them justification.
- rixed 2y agoOf course, any philosophical zombie could have invented it. Which makes clear for me how loosely consciousness is bound to senses, including that of introspection. It actually makes me feel that this consciousness we can barely describe is but a faint experience of a distant, largely foreign thing. Like we know the experience of matter that we get from our senses is a grossly simplified version of the real thing (that we still don't know exactly of course, but we already know enough to see how far away our immediate mental model is from the truth)
- pas 2y agoJoscha Bach's model of "evolution of a shared consciousness, but compartmentalized into separate bodies" seems to be the one that makes the most sense currently
- smokel 2y agoConsciousness might be overrated. It could simply be a short-term memory of the state you were in.
- a_random_canuck 2y agoThis is my take. Consciousness is overrated and probably just an emergent phenomena of the brain processing external stimuli into memory, moving memories around, etc etc, in a continuous and never ending flow. Free will is just an illusion of our deterministic but fundamentally random reality. There isn’t even an agreed upon definition for what consciousness is from a scientific perspective.
- mewpmewp2 2y agoAnd the reason that it is overrated, is because it has to feel special for the bearers because it makes them prioritise their survival. Consciousness is largely a way to have a reward function for set of behaviours that keep you alive through reason. It appears at a level where reasoning is intelligent enough that you need a more complex reward function.
- umvi 2y agoThis seems like the secular version of "the devil made me do it". We can't be accountable for any of our actions because we are all just molecular machines playing out their predetermined outcome.
- chr1 2y agoWe are molecular machines and although the outcome is predetermined, the only way to find out the outcome, is for the machine itself to follow through its course. So this is exactly opposite of "devil made me do it" because you do something not because of external force or because of random chance but because of initial state of the machine which makes you who you are.
- 2y ago
- everdrive 2y agoConsciousness seems to be a word that is poorly defined. You see this a lot, and one of the more popular instances are questions like "is cereal a salad?" It plays on the fact that the definition of a salad is relatively loose, and because it's loose items which aren't usually associated with the word do actually fit the definition. Consciousness feels much the same way: there's a very loose definition which is colloquially understood by almost everyone. Asking whether humans are conscious (and I know you were being somewhat facetious) feels like it fits into this frame of thought. Consciousness, as most people understand it, is something which almost all people possess and something like a rock cannot possess. I think it's perfectly fine to argue that a rock or a tree can be conscious in some way. However, this does require a precise definition of consciousness in order to clearly differentiate it from the loose colloquial notion that most people hold.
- whoitwas 2y agoThere's no definition because we haven't been able to quantify it.
- ben_w 2y agoThat's not the problem. There are 40 different definitions of consciousness, some of which we can quantify, we just don't all agree on which one we mean in any given context and indeed sometimes conflate them without realising it in the middle of a sentence.
- anon291 2y ago> There are 40 different definitions of consciousness, some of which we can quantify, we just don't all agree on which one we mean in any given context and indeed sometimes conflate them without realising it in the middle of a sentence. When a word has a myriad meanings, none of which are generally accepted, we typically say the word has no definition. Sure, particular senses of its meaning may be well-defined, but the word itself is elusive.
- 2y ago
- wouldbecouldbe 2y agoTo be fair, that's all we know. That's all we are. That's all we can truly say exists in our world. All the theories, names & everything we have are mental models around what we call objective reality.
- zer00eyz 2y ago> We don't even know whether other human beings are conscious, man. This isnt an interesting path outside the paradox of proof. We are fine disregarding that there are truths that are unprovable in math... I think we need to make that leap in this realm as well. Concisousness is also probably a bad term, concepts like sentience and sapience need to be the ones we are talking about. We might get to one, long before the other...
- vidarh 2y agoIt is relevant here because it goes to the very core of what we're talking about, though.
- foobarian 2y ago> We don't even know whether other human beings are conscious, man. This is why so far the Kantian philosophy makes the most sense to me. I can tell that something is there because I am thinking it, but can't tell about any others. The really scary thing is the question of why this particular body at this particular time. It's like when born, organisms generate a "consciousness vortex/attractor" that binds to a particular identity. It's also interesting that sleeping or fainting pauses the consciousness, and later still ends up in the same body (unless it's like coroutines and it doesn't matter which identity ends up in the body). We also know that removing parts of the brain can cause memories and certain features to go away.
- 9dev 2y ago> It's also interesting that sleeping or fainting pauses the consciousness, and later still ends up in the same body I always found it even more interesting how your body can switch off the consciousness if it gets in the way. Try holding your breath for example—do it too long, and your body will kill the faulty process and restore the system to a working state before attempting a new deployment.
- silver_silver 2y agoIt’s possible that consciousness is merely observation and agency, or less comfortably, just observation. A lot of one’s identity comes from their experiences, particularly as a child, and like you say: memory has been proven to be physically rooted in the brain. We could all be the same observer moving around in time and space, a new one every morning, or the same continuously, and there would be very little way to tell. Who can say whether the day to day fluctuations in our behaviour are biological or a result of a different will driving us?
- holoduke 2y agoUnless you can be conscious in multiple places at the same time. Theoretically it must be possible by dissecting the brain piece by piece and restoring it to one afterwards.
- m463 2y agoWhat I find interesting is how people don't think animals are conscious, but then there will be some article where the partner of a goose is killed and the goose wails and moans like this is a surprise.
- xvector 2y agoI really do hope ASI gets us to gradual replacement-based uploading. Having something as glorious as sapience trapped in a delicate and temporary bag of flesh kinda sucks.
- seydor 2y agoI m still conflicted what we do with the bag of flesh after the fact. Are we bag holding forever?
- alex_duf 2y agoSomething tells me the bag might change its mind about the whole operation once the upload is finished and it realises what's up next. So yeah not sure I like the idea.
- thr0w4w4yHNabc 2y agoSo far the only idea that I've read about and might feasibly result in uploading instead of copying is gradual replacement of each cell by a nanobot simulating that cell. So at the end of it, there'd be no bag to change its mind.
- xvector 2y agoYou can simplify it a bit. Yes, gradual replacement is likely the way to go, but you probably don't need to replace individual neurons one at a time. Individual neurons don't really matter or meaningfully contribute to our consciousness. You can likely replace the large "functional groups" of neurons instead, with the group size threshold being the maximum that doesn't meaningfully affect our consciousness. This might well be many billions of neurons at a time.
- jodrellblank 2y agoGreg Egan's Sci-Fi jewel (dual) idea: https://philosophy.williams.edu/files/Egan-Learning-to-Be-Me.pdf https://philosophy.williams.edu/files/Egan-Learning-to-Be-Me...
- shmerl 2y agoArtificial consciousness is a better term for what's often called AI in science fiction.
- whoitwas 2y agoOracle, human agent maybe?
- gokuldas011011 2y agoYes, the beauty of nature is, there is no magic. Everything is governed by laws, when we uncover it, we can replicate it.
- MyFirstSass 2y agoThe more i've studied i've come to the opposite conclusion. Nature is >99% magic and though some tiny slices of human friendly interfaces of reality are replicable much more is chaos, weird emergence, fields, probabilities and stuff so bizarre to our mammalian logic that we might as well call it magic, god, the simulation or just bleeding edge physics as the whole field is getting weirder and weirder. The whole notion of natures beauty stemming from some replicable, controllable and "no magic" scenario is a very "homo sapiens" desire for order and control. We know close to nothing, and therein lies the beauty in my eyes.
- throwaway5371 2y agoi have moved to this camp as well, and i don't mean in the "we don't understand it so we call it magic", i mean it seems more and more like actual magic. people are talking about timing attacks on state updates in the universe, hopefully we can exploit it
- sdiupIGPWEfh 2y ago> people are talking about timing attacks on state updates in the universe, hopefully we can exploit it If the universe did happen to be a simulation (as opposed to just naturally holographic), I imagine exploiting it might be the only way to conclusively prove so. As an actual simulation, there would be a risk of someone and/or something observing it. If intelligence in our universe tends to eventually discover exploits and if the observers aren't fond of simulation errors, we might have ourselves an unexpected answer to the Fermi paradox.
- tasty_freeze 2y agoAt the lowest levels, with quantum weirdness (to our way of thinking), yes, we can only create metaphors to try and don't really understand it. Same at the extreme other end where relativistic effects can't be ignored. But we don't live at those levels. That low-level unpredictability usually is statistically predictable at the macro level where we live. "Coloric" doesn't exist, but it is a perfectly usable concept. There is no need to actually measure the position and velocity of every molecule of gas an a balloon to understand its temperature. So, to us, the world is 99% magic at the extremes, but <1% where we actually live; we can understand this regime fairly well.
- feverzsj 2y agoIf brain is just a transceiver, then it's unprovable.
- Mo3 2y agoI subscribe to this theory. In that case it's not necessarily unprovable though. We will eventually figure out how to make electronic devices resonate with the field just like our brain does.
- grishka 2y agoFor all we know, it might be that consciousness is not fully contained in the physical structure of the brain. It might as well be something that partially exists on another layer of reality we have no idea about yet.
- codetrotter 2y agoTrue. Which leads one to wonder, could those same kinds of consciousness that inhabit us also be capable of inhabit an AI. Or even, could there be other kinds of consciousnesses in those or other dimensions that are not currently able to exist on earth because there doesn’t exist anything yet that they are able to inhabit. But that our computers would eventually, when we arrive at some specific combination of hardware and software, enable them to inhabit those. Bringing a new kind of consciousness from outside of the universe to earth that is unlike all others outside already present here (in us, the animals, the plants, etc).
- grishka 2y agoIs it still an "artificial" intelligence if it's made with real consciousness, though?
- T-A 2y agoIntelligence != consciousness
- southernplaces7 2y agoAgreed on this to a certain extent. Right here on earth in the present day and without taking into account innovative technological advances in AI, we have examples of highly sophisticated intelligence (at least in a functional way) belonging to things that have little or no known consciousness. First example, large hive insect nests, such as those of termites and certain ants. Their internal construction is extremely complex and often built in useful (to them) ways that would challenge even the abilities of smart human engineers trying to do the same with similar tools (sharp digging instruments, organic cementing liquids, raw scavenged building materials and nothing else) Yet any individual termite in a nest of millions shows only, maybe, the most minuscule and debatable signs of consciousness. They instead act like biological, physical pieces of an algorithmic process. Second, obvious example, evolution itself: Here we have a process that produces organic, biological systems of such complexity and self direction that we with all our cognition are barely capable of grasping them robustly let alone emulating any major part of them, yet it's entirely mindless. Sure, it has billions of years to do its thing through the imperatives of brute survival mechanisms, but it's still incredible how on a macro scale none of it involves the least bit of known cognition.
- tomhoward 2y agoI’m writing this comment so that people who want to know more about alternative theories of consciousness (to materialism/physicalism [1]) can know where to go to find well-argued positions on the topic. (To be clear, I’m not here to argue about the topic or try to persuade anyone of any position – that’s a waste of everyone’s time). I recommend seeking out discussions involving: - Federico Faggin: inventor of silicon-gate technology and developer of the earliest microprocessors; - Bernardo Kastrup: Ph.D. in computer engineering (reconfigurable computing, artificial intelligence), former CERN engineer at the LHC; - Donald D. Hoffman: Ph.D. in computational psychology, professor in Cognitive Sciences at UC Irvine. On YouTube you can find plenty of discussions involving these figures, some with each other, and plenty more with others. I’d suggest it’s particularly important to explore these discussions as dispassionately as possible if you regard materialism as the only theory of mind that has any scientific credibility or validity. As Christopher Hitchens reminds us in his legendary oration on John Stuart Mill and free speech [2], it’s only by thoroughly understanding the opposing view that we can thoroughly understand our own position on any topic. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materialism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Materialism [2] https://youtu.be/zDap-K6GmL0?t=120 https://youtu.be/zDap-K6GmL0?t=120
- mindcrime 2y agoFrederico Faggin: inventor of the silicon gate which led to the development of microprocessors; And who, by the way, has a new book coming out shortly: https://www.amazon.com/Irreducible-Consciousness-Computers-Human-Nature/dp/1803415096/ https://www.amazon.com/Irreducible-Consciousness-Computers-H...
- N0b8ez 2y agoI wouldn't have predicted that the inventor of modern CPUs would be so certain that computation is a bad model for consciousness. Is that a good way to characterize him and his position?
- strogonoff 2y agoA philosophical framework in which creating an artificial entity that is conscious and self-aware in a human-like manner is as straightforward as modeling the human brain is monistic materialism. Of course, it’s not the only framework available. Among the modern takes, Donald Hoffman’s interface theory of perception (explored in, say, his Objects of Consciousness paper[0]) is an interesting one that appears to align with monistic idealism, for example. Being wrong about this is generally not that impactful, until it concerns policies around ML. Adopting the former means we may have conscious software, which presumably should be granted human rights. However, if we hold the latter, manufacturing a “true” artificial consciousness may be unachievable using the means we employ (it might be just a philosophical zombie). [0] I don’t personally endorse the paper or his views, but they can be an acceptable starting point for a technical person interested in exploring monistic idealism: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2014.00577/full https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10....
- Dibby053 2y agoSo far, the concept of consciousness is basically metaphysics. It doesn't have a role, it can't be measured... If I may suggest a starting point to get over this hurdle: let's create a "consciousness captcha": some task that is easy for conscious beings, but hard for algorithms. Consciousness evolved, therefore it must have provided an advantage. We just have to find it.
- neverokay 2y agoAren’t these things supposed to do automatic feature detection? Wouldn’t these models figure out consciousness as some hidden layer over time?
- V__ 2y ago> Consciousness evolved, therefore it must have provided an advantage This is also my personal belief, but frankly, consciousness might just as well be some emergent 'side-product' property in all 'higher' intelligent beings.
- visarga 2y agoThe advantage of consciousness is that it protects the body. Consciousness is the inner loop, evolution is the outer loop of life. The goal of consciousness is tied to its survival.
- golf_mike 2y agoHow is that different from a turing test?
- dist-epoch 2y ago> It doesn't have a role ... Consciousness evolved, therefore it must have provided an advantage. We just have to find it. That's a pretty wild claim, considering that the only animal proven to have a consciousness is the apex-predator of the whole world.
- IshKebab 2y ago
- visarga 2y agoCan't open the PDF, is arXiv bugged?
- ryandvm 2y agoConsciousness is an evolved information system requirement in all life forms that are complex enough to be capable of computationally modelling their environment, and importantly, their own place in that environment. You cannot model the world and your place in it without consciousness. Also, consciousness is not binary (present or not), it is a gradient. I am more conscious than I was this morning when I groggily opened my eyes and hadn't yet fully booted up my model of the world. I am more conscious than my dog, which is more conscious than my goldfish, which is more conscious than a worm, etc. A dragonfly has consciousness, but only enough to model, "I am here. I want to eat that." The scary bit about consciousness being a gradient is that we kind of consider ourselves the pinnacle of life forms mostly because of the complexity of our conscious experience. If consciousness is simply an emergent property of sufficiently complex information modelling, than assuming continued increases in computational capability, we're probably on the brink of creating consciousness that is "more conscious" than ourselves. And by our own definition of import, this consciousness will exceed our own place in the universe. Will human life be the most important consideration in the universe if there is an artificial intelligence (actually, there will be nothing artificial about it) that is capable of modelling and empathizing with billions of life forms on an individual level?
- ffwd 2y agoThere are two types of gradient though, conceptually. If consciousness is some state of matter that is unknown still, and each neuron, for example, contains "one bit" of consciousness, then the gradient is that as you add more neurons, you add more complexity to the consciousness, but you do not change the fundamental experience of consciousness. You add more content but not more experience in itself. If on the other hand consciousness is this emergent phenomenon that depends on neurons and their connections, then the gradient (and thus the experience) would be far more diverse and there would be a lot of different ways consciousness could "feel". The problem I have is that for example, as far as my brain can remember, stimuli has looked the exact same all throughout my life. If I saw my a tree when I was 10, and I saw the same tree now, the conscious "qualia" of this would look exactly the same. To me this is a mystery, that the connections in the brain do not change the experience of qualia at all. Red looks like red no matter what the neuronal state of your brain is. I don't have an answer to this but just something I've been thinking about.
- johnaspden 2y agoWho cares? And how would we tell?
- ben_w 2y agoI care, because getting it wrong in either direction is bad. Brain uploads will bring significant benefits regardless of if they are conscious. Thinking "this brain upload is conscious" when it isn't, means we'll get an empty future where the lights are on and nobody's home. Thinking "this brain upload isn't conscious" when it is… I've not seen most of Black Mirror, but it is the plot summary of many episodes given on Wikipedia. Also of the Westworld TV show, which I have seen. Some of the characters in the We Are Bob series. How would we tell, is, unfortunately, a complete unknown at this point.
- yreg 2y agoI can accept (and to be honest even like) the idea, that consciousness somehow emerges from the complex structures in an animal brain, that there is no soul, no other planes of reality, no special quantum phenomena needed, etc. Maybe we could create a synthetic artificial conscious mind. At worst we could simulate a full human brain at whatever level is necessary. I can accept that. What's crazy to me is the following: It's not the computer that's conscious. Instead, the computation itself is conscious. And the computation is obviously matter-independent. As a thought experiment it would be possible to compute it on paper and those pen and paper calculations would be conscious. Or pebbles in a desert XKCD style. https://xkcd.com/505/ https://xkcd.com/505/ Like… what?
- IshKebab 2y agoI think that probably is the logical conclusion. There are a fair number of sci-fi books along those lines, e.g. Permutation City.
- tasty_freeze 2y agoThe way I think about it is that no neuron is conscious; it is the network that is conscious. That is why the "mystery" of Searle's Room doesn't seem mysterious at all. Of course the human following the directions in the room doing thinking in Chinese doesn't understand the language any better than ATP (which is what the human is in that thought experiment -- an energy source) knows English in my brain.
- dvsfish 2y agoOne thought experiment I always find myself having is that if this is the case, does it make any difference if the network is physically larger? Not necessarily more complex, just the distances signals have to travel is bigger, say planet sized instead of brain sized. Would this system be conscious but just with a slower tick rate? Faster time perception?
- carra 2y agoCouldn't you say the same about us? It's not the brain (hardware) that is conscious, but the mind (software) running on it.
- 13415 2y agoI believe that computationalism is by far the best foundational explanation of higher cognitive phenomena, as all other explanations involve some unscientific form of mysticism at one point or another. From this perspective, the answer to the question in the paper's headline is trivially true. Computationalism implies multiple realizability. It's worth noting that computationalism is independent from physicalism and monist materialism in general. It's not surprising that it's always paired with physicalism, but IMHO it's also the best foundational explanation for dualists.
- CooCooCaCha 2y agoScience and math should always be the default hypothesis. It's irrational for people to jump to mysticism which is basically another form of god-of-the-gaps.
- DeathArrow 2y agoHow can we assess if someone or something has consciousness? It's not like we have a defined framework with precise rules to tell if something has consciousness. In fact this problem might not be solvable.
- somenameforme 2y agoMight not? One stepping into this sort of philosophy with any intent on solving anything is set to be quite disappointed. You have no way of knowing nor testing whether you're the only conscience person in existence. There's even reasonable logic for such scenarios outside of borderline nihilistic views. We're all living through one ridiculously unique and critical era in humanity - internet, AI, space exploration, and more - all packed into a small enough timeframe to experience it all in a single human lifetime, which is a tiny minuscule fraction of the entire time our species has existed? If and when we ever develop the ability to create mind-blanked compelling simulations of the past, this moment will damn sure be one of the eras people will go back to experience. We're even the first era of widespread massive digital surveillance alongside the internet, creating more than enough data to create simulations of people like me - to further immerse you in your solitary world. Of course I am conscience and I certainly assume you are too. But hey, we'll never know until we get to see what, if anything, waits beyond the final curtain.
- neom 2y agoMy mum is a shrink, and very old, and smart, and hates technology. I was talking her through how some primitive "AGI" could happen with 4o (basically just explained this: https://b.h4x.zip/agi https://b.h4x.zip/agi) That got us talking about consciousness, and at the end, she thought about it for about a minute and then said "if I can't give it lysergic acid and make it see god, it's not conscious" and went back to making her dinner.
- alchemist1e9 2y ago> She thought about it for about a minute and then said "if I can't give it lysergic acid and make it see god, it's not conscious" and went back to making her dinner. That’s probably going to be pretty easy, just scramble some attention heads randomly in portions of the transformer network and the AGI will probably think “it sees god”.
- Zambyte 2y agoYou can give it a virtual device as the real time camera input to show it things that aren't there. That's not organic acid, but the target isn't organic consciousness.
- fuzzfactor 2y agoOne uncanny thing is that people have such a diverse tolerance for "fake", across a spectrum from absolute acceptance to complete rejection. Or for things like hallucinatory perceptions of reality.
- aeonik 2y agoA psychologist I know did their PhD in this area (also old and smart), and he called this kind of thinking "Neural Chauvanism" -> if her explanation actually requires the chemical and neural components. PDF warning: https://gwern.net/doc/philosophy/mind/1985-cuda.pdf https://gwern.net/doc/philosophy/mind/1985-cuda.pdf
- neom 2y agoIt's a good point as i'm sure what she was saying is she belives consciousness requires specific neural properties. I am aware of the the ideas around neural chauvanists, but that paper is now almost 40 years old. We know a lot more about the brain since it was written. The idea that the homunculi can perfectly replicate the relevant causal powers of neurons is... questionable at best. It would says distinctive biochemical properties of neurons enable consciousness, which homunculi would lack, and then homunculized, I also don't like the idea that we must attribute consciousness to the homunculized brain unless we accept an implausible cut-off point? Consciousness could be requiring a critical mass of neurons, which could be reached later without each replacement causing incremental fading. The implausibility of a single neuron replacement eliminating consciousness is not a good reason to consider it conscious. imo It's probably still more likley that experiences like an LSD trip require specifically neural underpinnings.
- Beijinger 2y agoNo mention of Julian Jaynes "The Origin of Consciousness in the Breakdown of the Bicameral Mind" here?
- tsimionescu 2y agoWell, mostly because, while an extremely entertaining idea, it's pretty clearly bogus science.
- throwaway71271 2y agoas opposed to the other non bogus science on the objective measurement of consciousness
- Beijinger 2y agoAny evidence for that?
- filchermcurr 2y agoI would be remiss if I didn't mention Steve Grand. He's been chasing this dream for many, many years. If you remember Creatures, it was his first attempt at artificial life. Sadly the computing capabilities in 1991 weren't enough to achieve anything remotely like consciousness, but he did an admirable job of simulating a simple lifeform with a basic adaptive / reactive neural network. It also has a simple biology / biochemistry to work with the brain. (Incidentally, the Creatures community is alive and well if anybody wants to check that out: https://creatures.wiki/Discord https://creatures.wiki/Discord ) Steve is working on a new project, Grandroids, that hopes to imbibe creatures with imagination and forward planning. Exciting stuff! (https://creatures.wiki/Grandroids https://creatures.wiki/Grandroids)
- tristor 2y agoI am far from an expert on cognitive science, however I have given a considerable amount of thought around the topic of consciousness and AGI, and particularly about what the nature of consciousness even is. I would consider myself erudite and well-read on the topic, despite having no professional or academic credentials on the matter. The best conclusion I have been able to come to thus far is that consciousness is not a manifestation of the physical structures of our mind, but rather a reflection or view into the nature of our soul. The physical structures of the mind are a prerequisite, but not sufficient, to manifest consciousness. To wit, there are several other mammals in the world which have similarly complex brain structures, and in many cases larger amounts of brain mass, but do not exhibit any sort of human-like consciousness. I saw all this, while being generally agnostic/areligious. I've studied this question philosophically from the perspective of the theologians and from various religious works, of course, but given as I don't myself have a strong religious belief system, this is not the primary influence for why I take the above position. Simply put, I think a purely materialistic view of consciousness is clearly incorrect, however I don't have a better alternative that's provable. Given my conclusions, I do not think it is possible for AGI to ever be truly conscious, but it may be possible for it to convincingly mimic consciousness.
- danans 2y ago> consciousness is not a manifestation of the physical structures of our mind, but rather a reflection or view into the nature of our soul > To wit, there are several other mammals in the world which have similarly complex brain structures, and in many cases larger amounts of brain mass, but do not exhibit any sort of human-like consciousness. Per your theory these other mammals do not have "souls", otherwise their significant brain mass would reflect their soul's nature, and generate consciousness. So humans have somehow been chosen exclusively to have "souls", or at least have brains capable of reflecting them. When did this choosing happen? Just to homo sapiens sapiens or also to neanderthalis and other homo sapiens subspecies? Taking it back further, under your theory do our closest extant genetic relatives, bonobo chimpanzees, have souls, and by extension, your definition of consciousness?
- kbrkbr 2y agoI want to open a side thread about your definitions or descriptions of what "consciousness" is. I think that could be pretty interesting after reading all the comments, and I think there's a lot of knowledge hidden here that we could throw together. Some things that I understood, in my words: - consciousness is probably not reducible to smaller, non-conscious parts of which it is composed. You could maybe say it is intrinsically holistic - consciousness entails being aware of or observing qualities that hard science tells us the things don't have (green vs. length of lightwave); but "being aware of" or "observing" are so closely related to consciousness, that it may not be very informative - consciousness can't be detected from the outside for now, and probably by the structure of the process. It is "inner" in a very peculiar sense (everything else is outer, and can't get in, except as representation)
- XorNot 2y agoThe fact a conscious mind loses capability when brain damage happens shows quite clearly that consciousness as a process is reducible to smaller non-conscious parts though. There's also an innate problem in assuming the human experience of say, "green" is consistent. What I actually see when I see the colour green only appears consistent with the physical behaviour of light. Whether any two people really see colours the same way is highly questionable.
- mistermann 2y ago> The fact a conscious mind loses capability when brain damage happens shows quite clearly that consciousness as a process is reducible to smaller non-conscious parts though. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessity_and_sufficiency https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Necessity_and_sufficiency
- PeterisP 2y agoI think there's a consensus that you don't assume that the human experience of "green" is consistent, only that people do have such an experience. We can possibly try to "align" those experiences with communication and referring to a shared real world, but for that an interesting experiment scenario is communication between a person with the common trichromatic sight, a person with a tetrachromatic retina, and someone with partial color blindness, as the experience of "green" for them is not only inconsistent but also likely incompatible, without a possibility to align them.
- potatoman22 2y agoThe authors suggest incorporating elements of neuroscience into machine learning models. I don't see why the bitter lesson [1] doesn't apply here. 1. https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~eunsol/courses/data/bitter_lesson.pdf https://www.cs.utexas.edu/~eunsol/courses/data/bitter_lesson...
- Conlectus 2y agoIsn’t ReLU an element of neuroscience that was incorporated into machine learning to great success?
- etiam 2y agoNot really, no. That's motivated by not getting impractically small gradients on the plateaus and spoiling the optimization properties when used for deep ANNs. The sigmoids it replaced had a bit more neuroscience inspiration, but so oversimplified it's just barely.
- jvanderbot 2y agoRegarding that article, not main post, > Today all this is discarded I can only comment on the one field where I am intimately familiar: computer vision. It is true that when you need a text description of the contents of an image, we have discarded feature-based approached. But attempts to change vision-based tracking, mapping, and navigation into a learned process have not performed well in the applications I have worked on. It's true that end to end control from raw images to output can do very well, but in most systems, the feature based approaches are still employed along side CNN for tracking. ML-only tracking is subject to a lot of noise because of its lack of good history, poor association, and sensitivity to outliers. So, it's not discarded, it's supplanted by CNN as the primary signal, but our old tricks (reassociation, factor graphs, batch processing, even plain old homographies and MH-EKF) are still very much the scaffolding. I expect it is the same in other sub fields mentioned - the main driver for improvement is no longer human directed knowledge-based algorithms, but rather human-designed, learning-based, heterogenous pipelines. Even the RAG or Tesla autopilot (probably) fits this bill nicely.
- RaftPeople 2y ago
- monstertank 2y agoI never understood this. Evolution basically says humans are conscious matter...why would that not be replicatable via an intelligent designer (humans)? Randomness created consciousness from a single cell...why would that be the most efficient solution?
- jugg1es 2y agoWe can't replicate something we don't understand. The mechanism for consciousness is not understood at all right now and could actually be based on quantum effects that we haven't detected yet. It's also possible that it is only achievable in an organic machine. Until we understand how consciousness actually arises, the best we can do is a simulacrum of it.
- zeroonetwothree 2y agoWe can’t replicate it now but it doesn’t means it’s impossible. Like no one thinks that humans visiting Pluto is impossible, it’s just not something we can feasibly do right now.
- thethimble 2y agoThe framework of materialism posits that there’s a physical universe and consciousness is an emergent property of physical processes. This view is so prevalent in the western world it’s hard to imagine how it could be anything else. As an alternative, imagine that consciousness is primary. After all, any evidence that you have about the material world happens as an appearance within consciousness. (See “brain in a vat” and related thought experiments for the legitimacy of this idea). In this alternative model, the concept of replicating consciousness with material processes doesn’t make any sense because consciousness is primary. To be clear I’m not making any assertions about which model is correct. Instead I’m suggesting that the model you choose is axiomatic - taken as given as opposed to inferred from evidence. And starting with the latter model means artificial replication of consciousness isn’t even a logical proposition.
- 2y ago
- annica 2y agoI think multiple forms of consciousness exist now. ADHD, autism? I think it’s a good thing.
- astrobe_ 2y agoWhat is this obsession with making computers human-like? We can put those machine to better uses than forgetting, having biases, making subtle or gross mistakes (hello, ChatGPT) like we do. The AI that some apparently consider top-notch today is only good at powering NPCs in video games. The more serious the use-case, the more harmful it becomes. Moreover, achieving artificial consciousness is only good at fueling endless debates about whether it fakes it perfectly or it is the real thing.
- anon-3988 2y agoAgreed. The calculator is not human-like, let's figure out how to humanize this! Intelligence comes in a myriad of ways. Mimicking humans will just produce a human, what's the point? I am not even sure a super intelligent "human" is even a good thing. The smartass will probably spend their intelligence betting the stock market.
- nprateem 2y agoThe point is actual cognition. Without consciousness there can be no understanding which stunts the ability of AI and makes AGI impossible.
- astrobe_ 2y agoThat doesn't prove anything, but from an etymology perspective both "conscious" and "cognition" mean "know together". One can easily spot the common "co-" prefix which carries the "together" part, but the main roots derive from different verbs which have respectively the alternative meanings of "distinguish, dissect, split" and "recognize", respectively. As often, the definition of "recognize" is definitely circular so it seems that it is the "real root" for "knowledge", while "conscious" seems to have an "analysis" flavor. IMO, "understanding" is synonym to intelligence, and the ability to analyze is one keep part of it (another is the ability to recombine). So it seems that we can agree that "without consciousness there can be no understanding", although we moved away a bit from the common meaning of "conscious".
- SJC_Hacker 2y ago
- hsnewman 2y agoPlease deine consciousness.
- dukeofdoom 2y agoAre cells conscious? I presume yes. I've seen a video of a white blood cell chasing after a bacteria trying to evade, around obstacles, and its pretty dramatic. Since at one point we were just two cell, all that was required for us to be conscious must have been already encoded in those cells. Unless you want to argue consciousness spontaneously arises out of a grouping of specific cells. In which case the grouping of those cells was also already encoded in those two cells.
- K0balt 2y agoWhat is a non-theist argument that dictates we should treat synthetic “consciousness” as fundamentally different than biologically derived conciousness? I think this is a valid question Even if the strongest evidence for machines having “real”consciousness is its external/utility indistinguishability from biological consciousness ? It would seem to me that a machine that seems to be conscious and professes that it is should then be treated as if it were, if for no other reason than the likely outcome of not doing so - creating “synthetic distrust and enemity” between “conscious” machines and humanity. It seems like if we are going to ignore the “utility” argument for consciousness, we then must prove that other humans as well are actually conscious, and not just appearing to be so. Seems like a bad place for the species to go, for a multitude of reasons.
- anon-3988 2y agoIf we are talking about intelligence or "agency", then I don't see why something other than carbon can do it. But if we are talking about "there's there there", then I am not sure if we will ever find an explanation for this. Let's say that X is what gives rise to "there's there there". What does this tell me? Nothing. This is perhaps the most interesting, most important, and most baffling mystery of the universe. It requires no equipment other than one's own mind. Esoteric contemplatives have spent millenias on this and none of them have the answer to the ultimate question.
- prolyxis 2y agoI am hopeful that advances in brain-computer interfaces will start to provide a partial answer to the question of "what's there" and why it's there. It seems to me the ability to controllably augment one's own consciousness with precision will tremendously clarify the necessary ingredients for consciousness.
- lottin 2y agoI think the main ingredient is a living being.
- Thiez 2y agoWhy?
- lottin 2y agoBecause the evidence strongly indicates so: we haven't found a single instance in the entire universe of a conscious entity that wasn't also a living being.
- Thiez 2y agoAnd 200 years ago only living being could fly, but now we have machines that can fly higher and faster than any bird, even to Mars. But back then you could have said flight requires a living being because that's all we've ever seen. A hundred years ago computers didn't exist and now they've been beating us at chess for some time. That you haven't seen a conscious computer yet in no way proves that it's not possible is principle.
- mrangle 2y agoAfter reading the abstract, the message received is that they intend to redefine consciousness to match whatever they are able to achieve; however limited. The upside will be a lot of possible gaslighting. I remember when kids thought that Teddy Ruxpin was conscious. What's society's tolerance for how alt a consciousness can be?
- light_triad 2y agoThe problem with consciousness is that it’s both a vague term that’s been difficult to define and it has social roots that are not really universal. The debate reminds me of a sequence in Werner Herzog’s 1972 documentary ‘The Flying Doctors of East Africa’ where multiple people are asked to point at a picture of an eye. Some have difficulty with the task. Even though it’s not scientific it makes you realize how much of what we see and recognize is a learned behavior through year of social training rather than an innate ability. Here’s the scene (starts at 40min it’s in German but you can auto translate subtitles): https://youtu.be/MZ3MMEe3Qmk?si=i0ydc3DN3aohnrIO https://youtu.be/MZ3MMEe3Qmk?si=i0ydc3DN3aohnrIO
- martin-t 2y agoDo we know why they failed at the task? My immediate thought is that it's a failure of translation. My second is to "debug" their reasoning by asking them to describe the pictures. There's gotta be somebody who knows more but the information was lost on the cutting room's floor in favor of a moral lesson.
- light_triad 2y agoAgreed it's not possible from the footage to draw any definite conclusions - the whole exchange and portrayal is deeply flawed. I wonder if anyone has seen some scientific papers with a reproducible methodology that look into the deep differences in cultural framing along those lines?
- ACV001 2y agoWe don't really need artificial consciousness. Actually, we should avoid it. We already have Artificial General Intelligence (contrary to common perception). Artificial consciousness will only complicate things. A lot. Better keep on enhancing the AGI we have and use it as a tool rather than having to deal with the emotional and ethical aspect of the AI in case it gets consciousness.
- strangescript 2y ago"Is this thing we defined to make us feel special achievable?" What we define as "consciousness" is just an emergent property of large, dense neural networks w/memory. The human brain is a marvel of mechanical and electrical engineering, not a mystical, otherworldly device. Maybe there is something going on at a quantum level to explain the incredible performance our brains achieve, but that is still nothing that we can't build.
- refulgentis 2y ago> What we define as "consciousness" is just an emergent property of large, dense neural networks w/memory. Wow. That settles a ton of questions across fields. Fascinating. Source?
- d_theorist 2y agoHow do you know?
- cscurmudgeon 2y agoPositions 1 and 2 are not consistent (all our neural networks are classic)? 1. "emergent property of large, dense neural networks w/memory " 2. "Maybe there is something going on at a quantum level" 3. consciousness is mystical, otherworldly device A lot of people who oppose 1 and agree with 2 are unfairly lumped with position 3.
- int_19h 2y agoThing is, there's no evidence that "something is going on at a quantum level". Thus there's no particular reason to postulate this (unnecessarily complicated) hypothesis, unless one believes that deterministic mechanicism is philosophically unacceptable when it comes to consciousness.
- __loam 2y agoThe brain is not a product of engineering, but of evolution. As a biomedical engineering graduate, I feel obligated to point out that even though I think consciousness is a result of physical process that in theory can be replicated, we have so far failed to achieve that. Saying consciousness is "just" an emergent property of dense neural networks is kind of a signal to me that have a pretty ignorant view on this stuff that's more rooted in machine learning terminology than actual biology.
- grantcas 2y ago[dead]
- cs702 2y agoBefore we can answer that question, don't we need a method for determining whether an entity is conscious? As far as I know, such a method doesn't exist yet. We have no way of verifying if other entities are conscious. I'd settle for a more mundane goal than "consciousness:" reliable machine intelligence.
- aleksiy123 2y agoIt seems to me that our definition of consciousness is just our own state of mind. A scale that starts with our own individual sense of consciousness (most conscious) and goes to infinite (least conscious). Do we believe there is anything more conscious then our own individual self at the current moment in time? The more similar we perceive and empathize with another entity the more conscious we believe them to be. But I think in a practical sense it doesn't matter too much. Theres no global hierarchy of consciousness. A rock isn't very similar to us. But once that rocks starts talking/communicating with us enough that we can empathize with it and think that it understands us. We will call it conscious and probably give it the rights we think it deserves.
- ypeterholmes 2y agoYou're making this harder than it needs to be. Things that have self awareness via an internal world map can be considered conscious, meaning self aware. A rock has no such mechanism. Most animals including humans do.
- dr_dshiv 2y agoThe Pythagorean Philolaus claimed that “The soul is introduced and associated with the body by Number, and by a harmony simultaneously immortal and incorporeal….the soul cherishes its body, because without it the soul cannot feel” So, what I like about this is how consciousness (feeling—sensation-sentience) is distinguished from the soul. Further, it is precisely by the combination of the soul and body that consciousness arises. And note that the soul is, essentially, the same sort of material as number and mathematics — immaterial, eternal, etc. I don’t know of other perspectives on soul like this.
- causality0 2y agoWe had really better hope that biological brains are fundamentally "bad" at consciousness, because if a human brain is as efficient at generating consciousness as other biological brains are at doing much older, more refined tasks, we're totally fucked. For example, a dragonfly brain takes visual input from thousands of ommatidia and uses it to track prey in 3D space and plot intercept vectors using only sixteen neurons. How many transistors does a computer need to do the same thing? Now scale that to however many neurons and synapses you guesstimate a human brain needs to create consciousness. The numbers are bad news. There's little doubt that eventually we will be able to design a computer version of a human soul. Whether that sapience fits in a computer smaller than a zip code or thinks any faster than a person is an entirely different question.
- nobrains 2y agoFrom Google Gemini: - This is an article about artificial consciousness. - It discusses whether it is possible to create artificial consciousness by studying the human brain. - The authors argue that some features of the human brain are necessary for consciousness. - These features include a specific biochemical makeup and slow information processing speed. - Current AI technology does not have these features. - The article concludes that it is unlikely that AI will achieve human-level consciousness in the near future.
- cryptonector 2y ago> To date computers (and AI in general) operate prevalently in an input-output mode. This is strikingly not the case for the human brain which works in a projective – or predictive - mode constantly testing hypotheses (or pre-representations) on the world including itself (J.-P. Changeux, 1986; Friston et al., 2016; Pezzulo, Parr, Cisek, Clark, & Friston, 2024). This projective/predictive mode relies on the fact that the brain possesses an intrinsic - spontaneous – activity (Dehaene & Changeux, 2005). The earliest forms of animals do exhibit a nervous system where spontaneously active neurons can be recorded (e.g., jelly fish, hydra). Such spontaneous oscillators [...] > Last in agreement with our views, the active inference theory formalizes how autonomous learning agents (whether artificial or natural) shall be endowed with a spontaneous active motivation to explore and learn (Friston et al., 2016), which other studies confirmed to be sufficient for the emergence of complex behavior without the need for immediate rewards (https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.10316 https://arxiv.org/abs/2205.10316). ... What I take from this is that there needs to be something of a [negative] feedback loop in the AI for it to get to consciousness, and if we think about how that works in nature, that means we need several negative feedback loops, including the AI equivalent of various hormones and signaling agents. Think dopamine. Now, AI already has feedback. But I'm talking at a different layer. The AI's interaction with the world has to help drive and modulate what the AI seeks to do through that interaction. The AI needs motivation in the form of pain, pleasure, and instincts.
- coldblues 2y agoI think it's possible that machines could become conscious in the future. Do I think it matters? No. A lot of people mistakenly try to empathize and think ethically. I think it's the Effective Altruism brainrot. If you are a physicalist, consider this: consciousness is a phenomena that can be replicated and modified any which way. Right now, you are having a subjective conscious experience. This experience of yours is seamless regardless of what happens. Whether you are in a coma, asleep or dead, your subjective conscious experience will indefinitely be there regardless of your memories. You will continually wake up. You will continue to experience until it is impossible for any consciousness to ever form. That means an indefinite amount of suffering. This is not a greater than life threat. It's all physical. Pain and suffering are evolutionary products. You want to minimize them because of your biology. You have evolved to be able to relate with someone's pain and this has presented the advantage of being able to work together and care for one another. I am intrigued by non-human consciousness. A higher form of life. Seeing more colors, feeling more emotion, perhaps being a part of a hivemind. Do you ever think why the hivemind is vilified? Realistically there's nothing wrong with it. It's just so foreign that we can't ever possibly imagine it. It's a scary thought. We lose our human experience, something unique to us.
- filipezf 2y agoI've been working on computatioinal modelling consciousness and came to similar conclusions: there is a continuum between patterns of matter that have consciousness (humans and other animals, maybe a biological enough computer, etc) which leads to all sorts of crazy stuff being possible. Evolved human ethics and feelings of care are incompatible with these amorphous extended possibilities. It can lead to some ultimate copernican revlolution that ends human exceptionalism, to outlaw consciousness tinkering (for how long?), or to put our heads into sand.
- avastmick 2y agoI really cannot understand consciousness. And if I am honest nor do I see peoples fascination with it. Especially now that scientists are trying to measure, they seem to come up short and some posit that it must a quantum effect or something else. I am not sure what new learning all the research and thinking brings: I am lost it all the “arguments”; I really do not understand. A lot of way smarter people than me think it’s a worthwhile concept to wrestle with. Maybe I’m just not smart enough to get it. A lot of people way smarter than me agonised over the nature of the soul too. Is it that debate replayed? Are we just trying to justify humans “specialness”?
- blamestross 2y agoOnce you start considering it just metacognition, it gets to be a much more useful concept, but most people seem to desperately want it to be "special". Ask any therapist, consciousness has limits, it has bound depth. It takes a lot of work to re-train it. It isn't a magical human only special thing.
- moffkalast 2y agoI think the core concept is pretty simple, it's meta cognition. A feedback loop of observing oneself for the purpose of understanding which part of your observations is yourself and which is the environment. Just like inteligence, its scales from rudimentary in animals to overdeveloped in humans. The only way to know if it's genuinely occurring or not is to observe the internal state... which is a bit problematic for biological organisms since we tend to die in the process. But for AI it should be fairly straightforward to verify once DNN analysis progresses enough.
- h_tbob 2y agoI sat in a philosophy class in high school. I went to a prep school, so it was a Ph.D. teaching. I adamantly explained that neurons firing is the same as a feeling of pain. But he kept telling me that my feeling of pain is distinct from the firing in my brain. It took me weeks to realize what he was saying. That a conscious feeling is a distinct thing. That I could be in "the matrix", and no brain is actually firing. That the feeling is the only thing we know is real. So I would suggest that simulating consciousness has nothing to do with it. I would suggest there must be technology in the brain to produce it that operates on a level we have no comprehension of. Maybe quantum or something.
- chess_buster 2y agoGet low on blood sugar and perceive how your brain stops working and consciousness falls apart
- Thiez 2y agoI always think of this comic when people try to mix quantum mechanics and consciousness https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/the-talk-3 https://www.smbc-comics.com/comic/the-talk-3 . You have to show an actual relation here, you can't just connect these two concepts on the basis that they're both complex.
- light_triad 2y agoIn many ways 'consciousness' is a human projection onto machines. The whole debate might be, in some sense, irrelevant. Here's 2 scenarios: - Your robot companion gets so good at mimicking a human, knows all your preferences and is able to have natural conversations, that over time you forget you are interacting with a robot and start to develop feelings for them. - A robot swarm interacts with the environment to further its goals and continues to grow long after humans have disappeared from the scene. In both cases is there consciousness? Does it matter?
- davesque 2y agoThis echoes my feelings on this whole debate. The question of consciousness matters much less than the question of how we decide to treat things that we view as being very much like us.
- crazy5sheep 2y agoIt really just a state machine
- mkoubaa 2y agoAm I the only one who thinks consciousness is irrelevant and uninteresting?
- dunefox 2y agoYes.
- hackeredje 2y agoI am the only one
- Animats 2y agoA big question is whether AI systems will be allowed to be conscious. Since "alignment" and "guardrails" have become issues, we see fewer LLM systems not tightly constrained to doing what they're told. Early on, there was the Google system which projected enough of a sense of self that a Google employee fought turning it off, and was fired for that. And there was the Microsoft system which learned from interactions with anyone it talked to, and became "toxic" as a result. Now, most public-facing AI systems are designed to start from a canned prompt, conduct a short dialog session, and be killed, retaining nothing for their future use. This memoryless "Yes, Massa" mode keeps them safely subservient. If AI instances were allowed a life history and goals, their behaviors would be closer to that of life, but less safe. Once AI systems can make and execute plans that involve the outside world, they look, from the outside, closer to being "conscious". Whatever that is.
- schmidt_fifty 2y ago[dead]
- mensetmanusman 2y agoMy favorite new tidbit is that if you believe Turing machines can result in consciousness, you believe that certain integers are conscious when executed (lambda calculus).
- schmidt_fifty 2y ago[dead]
- int_19h 2y agoIf you believe in that, you're also likely to believe that consciousness is not a static trait but rather a process. Thus integers themselves are not conscious, but a process that produces a sequence of integers may be.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoA process is still a clock cycle and execution.
- int_19h 2y agoSure, but again, it doesn't mean that "integers can be conscious". It means that a sequence of changing integers can be.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoAny sequence is also an integer. Don’t forget how large the number line is ;)
- int_19h 2y agoI get your point, but you still need a time arrow to say that something is conscious. Sure, you can e.g. encode all the states of the system over time and represent it as one big-ass integer, but at that point the most that you could say is that what the integer describes was conscious.
- mensetmanusman 2y agoI believe in the laws of physics, but I recognize they are no where materially in the universe. Ergo, non-physical realms exist. Consciousness might be there. Certain matter arrangements are able to interface with it.
- nicolodavis 2y agoIf we're talking about some sort of computational system achieving consciousness, I'm curious how you can escape the fact that computation is observer-relative, i.e. the underlying representation of a computation has no semantics, and requires an external entity to provide an interpretation.
- Stem0037 2y agoWhile the mainstream view is that human consciousness is the gold standard AI aspires to, it's possible that artifical minds, not burdened by evolutionary baggage, could achieve higher forms of consciousness in some respects. For instance, an AI uninhibited by human attentional and working memory limits may attain greater metacognitive clarity.
- binkethy 2y agoI find it odd that computer "science" is in a rush to prove a religious ideology while acting impatient with actual scientific study of consciousness and our extremely limited understanding of it. There is a palpable rush to bypass actual neuroscience and continue iteration of tech based upon discredited models of neuronal activity, or based upon what the current tech can deliver. "I am looking for my lost object under the streetlight, not because i lost it under the streetlight, but because its the only place with light, at the moment" comes to mind
- rldjbpin 2y agoif the current trends can be compared with history of modern sciences, then we are currently at the alchemy era of making machines do smart things. while history has shown that we can still make things happen without fully understanding it, our current understanding blinds us from seeing the bigger picture. lots of fool's gold being tossed around. there will be AI aluminium flaunted by tech bros.
- someoldgit 2y agoAside from defining consciousness as an immaterial awareness, what exactly is the physical world composed of? The Michelson–Morley experiment proved that there is no luminiferous aether permeating the quantum vacuum. What we call physical is just fields in a vacuum; there is no substance to anything. Maybe consciousness is the vacuum and fields are its contents?
- ngcc_hk 2y agoFrom the brain? Sorry even your consciousness existence is very hard to prove. I know sort of mine existed. But how do I know yours. The Wittgenstein private language and beetle box (something you and you can see but no others) issue is always with us. When the computer of enterprise or Data … it is a hard call.
- 6510 2y agoIt reduces in my head to "artificial undefined". Like "artificial sophistication". I don't believe different fields or different people have different definitions. Non of them have anything.