8 ms·
GDPR: Is It Worth It?
- FredPret 3y ago> The very people who comply with and execute the GDPR consider it to be positive for their company, positive for privacy and not a pointless, bureaucratic regulation. It's their job to do GDPR, of course they consider it a positive.
- gatinsama 3y agoSo, regulators consider that regulating is good. Science is amazing, really.
- bojan 3y agoNot just regulators, I'm a developer in the EU and I find GDPR a great thing. I have yet to find a fellow developer here that disagrees. Yes, it can sometimes be a hassle to comply with it. But it's a no-brainer that it's a good idea. In that sense is this site a bit of a bubble. In real life it's not even a discussion.
- ranger_danger 3y ago> I find GDPR a great thing. I have yet to find a fellow developer here that disagrees. Besides compliance costs, operational complexity, impact on small businesses, inconsistent implementation across EU Member States, and extraterritorial reach and global compliance challenges... IMO a lot of the text in the law is extremely vague and subjective, while simultaneously sounding very longwinded and authoritative. > Consent should be given by a clear affirmative act establishing a freely given, specific, informed and unambiguous indication of the data subject's agreement to the processing of personal data Notice it says “should”, not shall. Does this mean consent is technically optional? What is their definition of informed, affirmative, or agreement? Requiring companies to remove individual records from backups also quickly proves to be a practical impossibility. And it’s ironic to me that the law requires you to have even more centralized control over personal data from start to finish than they have now. To me this is a bit alarming from a security AND privacy perspective. > The requirement to notify regulators of data breaches Here’s a scary thought… what if they just stopped acknowledging breaches in the first place and claim they weren’t aware of it? What if they actually were unaware because the system was designed that way? There’s no law against being oblivious to breaches. Other undefined terms such as “undue delay,” “likelihood of (high) risk to rights and freedoms” and “disproportionate effort” will require further clarity by the courts or regulators, or time for specific market practices to develop. They don’t even define what a website is. Does that require HTTP be used to qualify? Or HTML? What about FTP or other protocols? Also, it forces even non-EU platforms with zero domestic presence to risk being blocked due to not complying with rules that don’t even apply to them. Seems like net neutrality is fundamentally incompatible with GDPR in some ways. What if the US blocked EU sites for not being free enough?
- remus 3y ago> Besides compliance costs, operational complexity, impact on small businesses, inconsistent implementation across EU Member States, and extraterritorial reach and global compliance challenges... In my experience the compliance cost really isn't that big for the vast majority of businesses. Where it does get trickier is if you're collecting a lot of data relative to the size of your customer base e.g. facebook, google etc. and in those cases I think some extra eyeballs on how data is handled is sensible. Pretty much everything GDPR gets you to do is good practice, so if as a business you can't comply then imo your business is on shaky ground. For example: - Right to be informed -> have a privacy policy which explains what data you collect, what it's used for, how long you keep it, when you delete it and so on. - Right of access - > have a mechanism for providing users with a copy of their data. - Right of rectification -> have a process where you can update customer data. [1] > There’s no law against being oblivious to breaches. Im not sure where you got this idea from. One of the seven key principles of GDPR is "Integrity and confidentiality (security)" or more explicitly "You must ensure that you have appropriate security measures in place to protect the personal data you hold." [2] Being oblivious to breaches clearly goes against this. > Also, it forces even non-EU platforms with zero domestic presence to risk being blocked due to not complying with rules that don’t even apply to them. GDPR applies to the resident who's data you are processing, so if as a business you wan to deal with those customers you need to deal with those laws. Seems reasonable enough to me. [1] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/individual-rights/individual-rights/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-re... [2] https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-resources/data-protection-principles/a-guide-to-the-data-protection-principles/the-principles/integrity-and-confidentiality-security/ https://ico.org.uk/for-organisations/uk-gdpr-guidance-and-re...
- ranger_danger 3y ago> Being oblivious to breaches clearly goes against this I don't see how it does. Even "ensuring appropriate security measures" is subjective in the first place, plus as we all know, no amount of security is perfect and breaches will always happen either way. Even if you took enough subjectively appropriate security measures, and it still happened anyway, there's nothing that guarantees you'll even know about it in the first place.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Not just regulators, I'm a developer in the EU and I find GDPR a great thing. I have yet to find a fellow developer here that disagrees. I know lots of developers who are still today incredibly furious about the legal effort that complying to GDPR requires (even if they - typically - don't intend to track users).
- p_l 3y agoThen they should change whoever is advising them on law, cause they got duped.
- Y-bar 3y agoI’m a run of the mill developer and I consider it a net positive. Less sensitive customer data to process. Less stuff compromised in case of a security breach. Easier to say no to product managers who wants to unnecessarily track customers. Faster response times since fewer scripts are loaded on fist visit. The largest flaw is the lax enforcement in some EU countries.
- seszett 3y agoThis is about the random sysadmins and devs that have to ensure their app or systems must comply with GDPR. Not the regulators.
- jonwinstanley 3y agoIt's usually not their main job. In many companies, managing GDPR is a responsibility that just gets added to someone's job description.
- james-bcn 3y ago> It's their job to do GDPR, of course they consider it a positive. No, actually it is annoying to do. But it is extremely positive. The two things do not conflict. It's annoying for restaurants to maintain the high level of hygiene that the laws enforce. But I expect most people in the restaurant business see it as a positive (and I'm not going to the restaurants that don't...)
- superkuh 3y agoThe removal of WHOIS information for domains that GDPR directly and indirectly resulted in has made the internet a drastically less communicative space. In the old days you could always just email someone if they had a .tld website. Now communication is usually not possible.
- luismedel 3y agoIMHO privacy is important. If a domain owner wants to be contacted, they know where to put their contact info.
- Animats 3y agoIf you're a business, you should be required to have the actual name and address of the company in Whois. That's a requirement for the .us TLD, by the way.
- p_l 3y agoGuess what, corporate contact information does not fall under GDPR.
- Animats 3y agoRight, that falls under the European Directive on Electronic Commerce, which is strongly against business anonymity.
- luismedel 3y agoThe law already forces you to put it clearly in your site, AFAIK.
- Animats 2y agoIn which jurisdictions? California law does, if you accept payments. It's not, as far as I know, a US federal requirement.
- solardev 3y agoFor you EU citizens, how do you feel about cookie banners?
- farmdve 3y agoThey are annoying, but I quite like the option to choose. I definitely prefer not to have tracking cookies.
- Sprint9935 3y agoThey are an annoyance, but it is great not to have websites track you if you select them not to.
- michalstanko 3y agoExtremely annoying.
- mpweiher 3y agoI hate all the illegal consent popups.
- blueflow 3y agoIts great to know which websites track you and which don't.
- jraph 3y agoThey are annoying, disrespectful, unwarranted and unasked for. But with uBlock Origin and Firefox, we have solid tooling to almost never see them now. GDPR is also not the issue. The issue is incentives to track people.
- anonzzzies 3y ago> They are annoying, disrespectful, unwarranted and unasked for. The tracking itself is : if there is a banner, it shows you this company is indeed disrespectful.
- anonzzzies 3y agoThey are annoying but not needed if people would respect privacy. How about don’t use tracking or collecting too much info? Then you don’t have to put them.
- MenhirMike 3y agoYes, yes it is.
- osigurdson 3y agoGDPR: All websites ask if cookies are ok. If not ok, can't use website. Everyone clicks ok. Amazing work, regulators.
- msk-lywenn 3y agoI always click no and the websites do work. What do you mean?
- Sprint9935 3y agoEveryone doesnt click ok. You can typically use websites if you dont click ok.
- michalstanko 3y agoI wonder how many websites show a cookie banner and don't change a thing whether you click Accept or anything else.
- Macha 3y agoThe last study I saw was about 15% for ways detectable client side (e.g. loading ad tracking scripts before the banner is interacted with or despite negative interaction). Probably a bit higher when you consider server side tracking and those who make up some not-legally-valid claims of legitimate interests.
- marcosdumay 3y ago> If not ok, can't use website. If you care to read it, you'll find out this is the opposite of what it says.
- estebank 3y agoGDPR is not the ePrivacy directive. The later is the one that resulted in the cookie banners, the former protects the right of Europeans to have their private data remain so.
- 3y ago
- gatinsama 3y agoThe study only tells us that some workers who implemented GDPR think it was worth it. As if they had enough information and context to judge whether the extra work was useful. But people do have a bias to believe that their work is useful. The study does not tell us if GDPR is worth it. It's not.
- OKRainbowKid 3y agoThis comment only tells me that one specific HN user thinks it's not worth it.
- jonwinstanley 3y agoThis can be an unpopular opinion but I work at a company in the EU and feel the law is very positive for consumers in general. In today's world users hand over their data to a huge number of companies for all kinds of different reasons and it's important to know that those companies are pushed by the law to only collect and retain the information they need to provide their services.
- gpderetta 3y agomore than unpopular is polarizing.
- james-bcn 3y agoThe only part of GDPR most people know about are the website pop-ups, which probably was a bad idea. They don't know about all the other stuff that is really positive.
- piva00 3y agoThe GDPR is not the ePrivacy Directive (the "cookie law"), the ePrivacy Directive predates the GDPR by many years.
- rakoo 3y agoThe pop-up is not part of the law. The law says user should be aware and able to do informed changes, not that they should be annoyed. That part is entirely on companies
- gls2ro 3y agoYes popups are not part of the law. they are an implementation choosen by the websites. Also I put a bit of responsibility on us, the consumers. It does not seem to me that popups are such a real issue since no website reported: we are removing popups because users are so annoyed that they stopped visiting our website.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> The law says user should be aware and able to do informed changes, not that they should be annoyed. Then tell us how companies should implement this law both - without annoying the user - not being in a risk of getting sued If the law does not make this relatively easy, one has a right to be furious about the EU.
- seydor 3y agoThe abstract points to totally unbiased science /s GDPR is way overrated. For most businesses it was a minor annoyance, but the benefits are nowhere to be found. Our data is mashed potatoes now (GPTs) and will forever be. Politicians loved GDPR because it gives them +100 undeserved virtue points. The real problem with BigTech is the addictiveness , and we are only beginning to wake up to it
- jonwinstanley 3y agoSurely the benefits are for the users?
- yyyyybb 3y ago[dead]
- remus 3y ago> ...but the benefits are nowhere to be found. I disagree pretty strongly: - Loads of companies now have tools for getting copies of all the personal data they hold on you e.g. google takeout, which is a direct consequence of GDPR. - Companies are punished for improper handling of personal data e.g. data breaches (though you could definitely argue that more should be done here) - The US government's lacklustre approach to data privacy has been repeatedly laid bare (https://www.gdprsummary.com/schrems-ii/ https://www.gdprsummary.com/schrems-ii/), leading to better data residency practices e.g. many services now have a "store data in the EU" option Not to say there aren't a lot of dodgy things happening in the data collection world, but to say the benefits are "nowhere to be found" is an exaggeration.
- qiqitori 3y agoGoogle Takeout was released in 2011.
- ddxv 3y agoMy least favorite part of GDPR is the requirements around processing EU citizens data inside EU servers. China has similar laws and I think other countries will follow suit.
- snowpid 3y agolet me give the reason why: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010s_global_surveillance_disclosures https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2010s_global_surveillance_disc...
- jonwinstanley 3y agoIf data is processed outside of the EU, presumably it would then fall under different laws?
- jdietrich 3y agoThere is no such requirement. The GDPR allows for the transfer of personal data to non-EU countries, provided that the data controller can demonstrate that the rights of the data subjects will be respected. https://gdpr-info.eu/chapter-5/ https://gdpr-info.eu/chapter-5/
- odyssey7 3y agoYes, GDPR is worth it. It’s not cookie banners. If you’re going to maintain a database about members of the general public, you should be responsible for stewardship of that data. The GDPR requires some forms of data stewardship that are inconvenient for businesses, but that’s why it’s a government regulation. When all businesses have to do it, individual businesses won’t need to put themselves at a competitive disadvantage for expending the cost to do the right thing. Idc about the cookies, they can repeal that part if they want. But keep the rest of it.
- nforgerit 3y agoGerman here. + I like the right to be able download my personal data dump on platforms - cookie banners are a total pointless waste of everyone's time - institutions and organizations use "data protection" and "privacy" as generic gaslighting argument for things they can't do and/or lack competence in and as an excuse for keeping their 20y+ old processes - consumer data is no way safer than before, just the means of collection have changed - the law is so interpretable (e.g. "what is exactly PII data? IP addresses? the evercookie? what is an evercookie?") that, without blindly copying implementations from other sites, you'll probably end up in a grey area - they started using GDPR for politically motivated unrelated prosecution. e.g. the first thing Italy did when ChatGPT went hype was using GDPR to quickly block the service. the case is only somewhat related because of scraped data for learning, however GDPR in my interpretation is about personal data. So all in all is it worth it? I guess no. But YMMV.
- nemoniac 3y ago> "what is exactly PII data?" PII is not even mentioned in the GDPR. It is a notion in US law.
- troupo 3y ago> the law is so interpretable (e.g. "what is exactly PII data? IP addresses? the evercookie? what is an evercookie?") It's only interpretable if you never read it. You could start with showing where the law defines PII or where it mentions "evercookies" (or cookies in general)
- ultra_nick 3y agoGDPR would be fine if they had a limits for small businesses. As written, startup founders don't have the resources to comply, so they often end up blocking all of Europe.
- deutschepost 3y agoWhy should small businesses be allowed to spy on their users without their consent?
- nforgerit 3y agoWhy do you think not being willing to put resources to comply to rules equals to intentionally "spying on their users"? How come you think the rules assert that businesses are not able to spy on their users without their consent? You should better look what's inside the law's box instead of just looking at the packaging.
- iteria 3y agoA lot of times, it's not even spying on users. It's not wanting to put in the time and effort to determine if you are in compliance or not. So you block all of Europe and you get around to it if you ever have the resources or care. You might have been in compliance the whole time, but why chance it when IP blocking is easy. That's basically every local US newspaper right after the GDPR passed. Hell, I've worked for companies where I literally know we're not tracking users and we're pretty secure, but we block the EU because no one has the time to check if there was something specific we needed to do. My current company had to rarchitect their entire to deployment pipeline specifically for the EU, not because we changed literally anything, but the laywers found that there was about our cloud host provider that the GDPR disallowed because it was hosted on US soil. We have 1 EU client. I assume if they weren't so big we would have dropped their contract.
- janosdebugs 3y agoMy wife and I run a small (2 person) business in the EU. The largest hurdle was finding a hosting provider (VPS) that wouldn't transfer data outside the EU so we wouldn't have to add SCCs to our privacy policy. As a business owner, I'd say the balance is still positive, it forces some self-reflection on data gathering practices. Not sure about the "hosted on US soil" part, if you are a US company, the data gets transfered anyway when you view it.
- 19h 3y agoAs a German, and as a privacy conscious person, yes, I think it's worth it. As a CTO of an AI company that does automated background checks for international compliance, .. jesus fucking christ, my job is 90% GDPR compliance at this point. off-topic: did you know in Germany you need a court order to surveil Taliban terrorists ... in Afghanistan? Fun times.
- lionkor 3y ago> did you know in Germany you need a court order to surveil Taliban terrorists ... in Afghanistan? Fun times. sounds reasonable, otherwise it'll be abused, no?
- 19h 3y agoAbused how? If you need sigint on a possible bomb threat you learned about via humint in the field and you're waiting for bureaucracy to happen, people will die, and they have died already.
- lionkor 3y agoI could see plenty of ways in which a law like "you can surveil people if xyz without a court order" could be abused
- raphman 3y agoSide note: German intelligence service BND famously argued ~10 years ago that them intercepting satellite communication at their listening station in Bad Aibling does not in fact happen on German soil but in space. Therefore, they argued, their surveillance activities weren't bound by German laws at all. https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weltraumtheorie https://de.wikipedia.org/wiki/Weltraumtheorie
- asdajksah2123 3y agoThe GDPR has been a godsend for me as a developer. It provides me with a language to speak with the product and marketing side of our business when pushing back against unnecessary surveillance and requesting resources for data security. And even when I'm working with a team that is unconcerned about the ethical side of things, the GDPR places a cost on collecting data that can be used to prevent at least some of the worst suggested ideas purely on a net value basis. This was not the case before the GDPR where data security and privacy were of limited concern and everyone was trying to collect as much data as possible on our users. My company's products have never been in the GDPR's radar but even without facing any threat of direct consequence from GDPR it has indirectly been responsible for us creating a significantly better product for both our users and for the company as well.
- plorkyeran 3y agoYeah, there's been a number of times where I've pointed out that the thing product is asking for has GDPR implications and then the critical data collection we Must Have magically turns out to not be all that important after all. Even when we go forward with things in a GDPR-compliant way it's made it a lot easier to push back on some user-hostile things and ship something much less awful.
- rqtwteye 3y agoSame here. GDPR has forced us to think more about customer data and how we store it.
- __loam 3y agoEU regulations are why I have a USB-C iPhone with a replaceable battery and a GBA emulator.
- slotrans 3y ago"The very people who comply with and execute the GDPR consider it to be positive for their company, positive for privacy and not a pointless, bureaucratic regulation." I have been involved in multiple GDPR compliance pushes and I want to emphatically state the opposite position. It is not worth it. It is not worth ANYTHING. It should be destroyed.
- warkdarrior 3y agoDo you have more detail to share in support of such a strongly worded opinion?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rzwitserloot 3y agoHere's a thing governments should say a lot more - a combination of being humble and also instilling humbleness in companies that need to hear it: "Look mates, if you don't clean up your stuff, we're gonna have to write a bunch of laws and nobody wants that, so, fix your problems". (i.e: Government is aware legislating something probably results in a highly suboptimal/inefficient endresult, but, it's the only tool governments have. It's just as much on a company / on all companies in a given area of expertise that government sees no way out other than to wield the heavy and inaccurate club of law-making). Separate from the many comments that highlight both how [A] the GDPR is a lot more than those cookie banners and [B] those cookie banners are like those email footers - lawyers gone nuts. A whole bunch of them are not required as per GDPR, just there because someone asked a lawyer and of course they say 'yeah sure add it'. If I ask a painter if it's a good idea to paint my house at this point in time, they're bound to say 'yes': Companies went way too far with it, so GDPR happened. It's a good thing to teach companies that going too far results in annoying laws. It's fine even if the GDPR is a loser - if everybody loses, that's.. sad, and a better law would be much preferred, but that can still be better than no laws, because its mere existence tells companies to try not to go too far. So far, US-based companies do not appear to have understood this (see also: USB-C rules, apple's current problems, repeated and widespread illegal shit going on at banking institutions), but it's worth doubling down on it until they do.
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> Companies went way too far with it, so GDPR happened. It's a good thing to teach companies that going too far results in annoying laws. It's fine even if the GDPR is a loser - if everybody loses, that's.. sad, and a better law would be much preferred, but that can still be better than no laws, because its mere existence tells companies to try not to go too far. What rather happens/happened is that the hatred in the population for the EU increased a lot (as witnessed by the rise of right-wing nationalist parties, even though admittedly there also exist a lot of other reasons for this rise).
- abeppu 3y agoI have been involved in trying to implement GDPR, and one constant source of frustration was it's not actually very clear when a system is fully compliant. We had engineers and product people and legal people who had different understandings of what various terms meant. For example, you have a 'right to object' to a data controller doing further processing of your personal data, and you have a 'right to be forgotten' in which case we should not keep your personal data any longer -- but we need to remember enough that when we encounter you again, we recognize that you've objected to further processing. How are we supposed to know in future interactions that you've opted out if we've deleted all mentions of you and your PII? What does 'deletion' mean? If I have a DB which is based on an append-only WAL which can include write and delete "operations", which mean the DB will respond to queries as if the record were deleted, but the record is definitely on disk, and still gets read into memory but just isn't returned as part of any query, but someone with access to the machine could still in principle read it ... is it 'deleted'? Are you 'forgotten'? What if you're gone from the DB but an old DB backup in cold storage still has a record? What if a columnar file for the datalake in block storage still has a record but you're gone from all DBs that are part of online systems? What if no DB has your raw PII, but your IP was added to a bloomfilter or other sketch datastructure, so it can't be read back out but we could potentially identify with some confidence that your IP had previously been in our logs? I totally think GDPR was a step in the right direction, and I wish my own country would adopt a strong data privacy law. But I also wish that the EU had set up e.g. a certification system, a large set of reference examples for how pieces fit together, or something to give implementing parties some confidence about whether they're doing it correctly.
- p_l 3y agoThe best thing about GDPR is that in case of violation, you're not immediately raked over coals. The responsible national body is supposed to cooperate with willing business in ensuring compliance - if the business cooperates in good faith, the fines are minor or can be waived altogether. And part of such cooperation would be for regulator to help specify down the case.
- abeppu 3y ago
- throwawa14223 3y agoThere still exist data brokers and personalized advertising in the EU so it hasn’t gone far enough.