4 ms·
When a foreclosure auction is won by the lender, the price is not very indicative of the market value. Usually, lenders will bid up to somewhere around the out
by toast0 3y ago
When a foreclosure auction is won by the lender, the price is not very indicative of the market value.
Usually, lenders will bid up to somewhere around the outstanding loan amount. And typically, the loan amount is known. If you have an idea for how much you want to pay, and it's much less than the loan amount, you won't bid, because there's no point.
Combine that with typically a very short period before announcement and auction, during which time the borrower may not be compelled to cooperate with due dilligence (or may refuse to cooperate despite having a duty to), and yeah, you're not likely to get bidders. If the property was easily sold near the loan amount, the borrower likely would have done it.
Edit: an article from April claims a loan amount of $83M [1]. Asumming that's roughly accurate, this auction says nobody is interested in paying around $83M for this building on short notice. You need "good funds" at the auction: cash, a cashier's check or ability to do an immediate wire.
[1] https://therealdeal.com/texas/fort-worth/2024/04/05/opal-holdings-faces-1-6m-in-mechanics-liens-in-fort-worth/ https://therealdeal.com/texas/fort-worth/2024/04/05/opal-hol...
- seanmcdirmid 3y ago12.3 million is pretty down there though, that no one thinks the building is even worth the loan amount, and that the loan amount was at least 10% (I bet it was much higher though) indicates the building isn’t worth much.
- colechristensen 3y agoI don’t think so. Basically you can be sure the lender is going to pay the loan amount so unless you’re willing to pay more you’re not going to bid at all because why bother.
- mucle6 3y agoI don't see how this prevents economics from taking over. If nobody bid over 12 million, thats a signal that nobody thought it was worth say 20 million. Otherwise they would have bid.
- harry8 3y agoMy understanding of OP: Say the loan amount on the building is 100m you know you ain't getting for less than that because the lender will bid up to there at least if anyone is bidding. You think it's worth 20m? Go home, that bid will not win and everyone knows it. You bid 20, lender outbids you. you bid 30, again outbid as far as the loan amount at least. This 12.3M is the equivalent of the auction being passed in with a reserve price of the loan amount, whatever that amount is, possibly much higher than 12.3M. In this circumstance the auction is a farce and you could not buy it for 12.3M+ or anything like it. I can't vouch for the truth or accuracy of _any_ of that, but I believe that is the point being made.
- bruce511 3y agoThe worth of the building is only one of the factors. The other side is the risk. Actually, the worth side is relatively easy to calculate. But the risks are hidden. Likely there wasn't access to do a proper inspection. Likely tenant leases are not visible. In some cases outstanding bills (especially taxes) come with the building (and are unknown, and likely significant since the seller defaulted on this loan.) So auction prices don't reflect "worth" they reflect "risk". Usually these unseen costs exceed the hammer price (sometimes by a lot).
- maxerickson 3y agoI don't see how there's a coherent split between value and risk. I guess you are using worth to mean potential value or something like that.
- walrus01 3y agoA very large office building built in 1981 is going to be coming up on the need for some expensive plumbing repairs very soon, if there's no record of it being done recently. And probably contains lots of other unrefurbished space that couldn't be rented out at grade A office space $/sqft rates. Interestingly enough the building does seem to have a marketing website which shows several full-floor office spaces for rent with floor plans, but no photos of the space.
- Y_Y 3y ago
- walrus01 3y agoThis does provide an amusing mental image of some theoretical commercial real estate person who specializes in distressed properties, not specifically this auction, but showing up to some "auction on the courthouse steps" type thing with an actual Pelican case crammed full of USD 100 notes. I wonder what's the largest recent real estate transaction that's been done actually in cash. I imagine it would raise a few KYC red flags and reporting requirements, of course. In practical terms of course we all know that "cash" payment really means "ability to execute a SWIFT transfer for the funds within one business day".
- yieldcrv 3y ago> I imagine it would raise a few KYC red flags and reporting requirements, of course. real estate industry is exempt from AML/KYC requirements, they lobbied Congress and won secondly, you can use a lawyers IOLTA account for these large transactions, its pooled money from all of their clients - usually retainers and settlements - but nothing dictates that limitation. Banks consider them institutional investors that already did KYC. but. I mean. The client could be from anywhere and the lawyers account cant get probable cause on it for just that. It’s a known gap in the US AML/KYC framework. DOJ and thinktanks and the EU have been aware for at least a decade.
- zb1plus 3y agoThat's wild that we have to deal with AML/KYC buying a few dollars of crypto but a multimillion dollar real estate translation just goes through without the government sniffing its nose into things. Just goes to show you how unfair the system is towards the little guy.
- yieldcrv 3y agoJust shows how bad crypto sector is at buying politicians Ross could have been free with a donation to Trump’s campaign, it was pay to play
- gruez 3y ago>real estate industry is exempt from AML/KYC requirements Source?
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- topspin 3y agoWhat is indicative of market value is the fact that the auction yielded no better buyer. These stories about huge markdowns of commercial real-estate are not surprising. This case is indicative of the predicted instability in local and regional banking sector. Pinnacle Bank Texas is a part of a regional bank that is badly exposed in commercial real-estate, where borrowers are defaulting left and right. There is something approaching $1 trillion in commercial real-estate mortgages coming due this year, and much of it can't be feasibly refinanced due to prevailing interest rates, vanishing tenants and other problems. 2024 is going to get interesting. My prediction is: it's an election year, and The Powers That Be don't want a big banking blow-out, so there's going to be bail outs, the national banks are going to be pressured to clean up some of the mess, etc. More consolidation, more public debt, more kicking the can.
- 01100011 3y ago> something approaching $1 trillion in commercial real-estate mortgages coming due this year, From what I hear, you'll just see a lot of loan modifications and adjustments. Basically no one wants mass defaults to happen. Not saying there isn't some other hidden issue in the financial system, but CRE isn't going to be the thing that brings it down.
- nostromo 3y agoA few region banks may fail, but they’ll be bailed out just like SVB.
- theturtletalks 3y agoWas SVB bailed out? I thought they were over leveraged, but had customer’s funds and gave those back. Did I miss something?
- dpe82 3y agoThey were not. The bank failed; FDIC came in and shut them down and then sold the remaining assets to First Citizens. Previous SVB shareholders were wiped out. That's how the system is supposed to work.
- wodenokoto 3y ago> cash, a cashier's check or ability to do an immediate wire. OT, but I couldn't help noticing that when you put "cash" next to "immediate wire", you must mean actual paper and coin cash. I don't think you can buy anything in the US for $12.3 in suitcases of cash.
- walrus01 3y agoYou probably could if you showed up with $12.3m in cash and you were like, provably a wealthy family from Saudi Arabia or Qatar or similar that suddenly showed a motivation in investing in US real estate, but there would still be many questions asked (to your lawyer) for KYC/AML purposes.
- Supermancho 3y agoWould need escrow, even with cash. Someone has to count it and insure the amount consists of legitimate bills.
- jtriangle 3y agoYou don't need escrow, strictly speaking. With something like this you will, of course, be required to use escrow by the seller.
- dannyw 3y agoReal estate is exempt from KYC/AML.
- wakawaka28 3y agoProbably because the asset is stationary and could be seized by the government at any time.
- to11mtm 3y agoIt's not really 'exempt', it just tends to work differently and in this case other controls are expected to be 'working'. To your first point, it can't be moved out of the country/etc. However, Real Estate as a funnel for AML is definitely a thing and normally you'll get trained on it. I think another factor in this case however is the other 'related' controls; if a bank is writing cashiers checks, assuming it's a US Bank of course, for any amount over a few grand they should have done their AML work, thus providing identification/etc when 'qualifying' for the option likely serves as the paperwork required on their end.