10 ms·
A skeptic's take on beaming power to Earth from space
- cratermoon 3y agoFor me, the definitive critique of space-based solar power was written in 2012, by Tom Murphy. https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/ https://dothemath.ucsd.edu/2012/03/space-based-solar-power/ I haven't followed developments in solar cells or power transmission closely, but I get the sense that there's only been minor, incremental, improvements. The math still doesn't work.
- xaellison 3y ago"antennas so big that we cannot even simulate their behavior. " - does anyone know what that means?
- rsync 3y agoThe detail that has stuck in my mind since the last time I read about this is: Thermodynamically speaking, if you transmit electricity from outside the Earth onto the Earth – even if you do it perfectly efficiently – you are, by definition, heating the planet. Based on that I concluded that it is superior to generate electricity with inputs that are already hitting the Earth… But I’d be very interested to learn more about this.
- tectonic 3y agoThis is false, if your SBSP conversion efficiency on the ground is better than solar panels on the ground then you will add less energy to earth by collecting the power in space and transmitting it to the ground then by changing the reflective albedo of desert to a very nonreflective material like solar panels.
- pfdietz 3y agoHmm. If your PV has efficiency > the albedo of the ground it covers, it will be better than SBSP, even if the rectenna is 100% efficient (assuming the emissivity of the PV is at least as good as that of the desert in the far IR). This assumes the rectenna has the same optical properties as the ground it covers. One could improve the PV by making it highly reflective in the near IR at wavelengths below the bandgap of the cells, while still being highly emissive at the longer wavelengths where it will radiate heat.
- bee_rider 3y agoYou could put the solar panels between the sun and Earth so they only capture photon that would have otherwise hit Earth, if that really matters. This would even be nice because if we wanted to cool the planet down we could just redirect some rays. But I think using an appreciable amount of the power provided to Earth by the sun is still sci-fi stuff anyway, so we probably can’t make an appreciable dent either way. Sagan put us at around Kardashev .7, it is a log scale shifted by a constant, apparently we’re under .2%, of what hits the Earth, I guess. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kardashev_scale
- jandrese 3y agoIf you set the thing up in the L1 Lagrange point it will have the same day/night problem that traditional solar has. You would need at least two, but probably realistically 3 different antenna farms to collect the power and the satellite would need to be able to track the beam across the surface of the Earth. Most of the proposals I've seen have the array in geosynchronous orbit so it can easily remain pointed at a fixed spot on the Earth.
- Retric 3y agoYou could also beam power from L1 to geosynchronous orbit and then to a single ground station. It really depends on how efficiently you can beam power, but hitting Type 1 on the Kardashev scale hits limitations based on radiative cooling into space vs incoming energy. However, it makes sense to have hundreds of ground stations simply to minimize transmission losses on the ground. And presumably utilizing ground stations 24/7 is vastly less critical than maximizing the return on space based infrastructure.
- RF_Savage 3y agoAt these power levels the power beaming array starts to look a lot like a weapon. One with a beam that can target distinct areas. Easy way to fry large amounts of your adversarys telecoms infra. It will not put you back to the stone age, but 1970-1980 is not out of the question. For wireless communications that is.
- gmuslera 3y agoNot all that energy will end as heat. And the surface that it may cover won't be significant compared with the Earth one. And if it is, it may shadow enough surface to actually cool down Earth. In any case, it won't be worse than releasing a good amount of the captured solar energy in chemical form for millions of years in around a century.
- glitchc 3y agoI think the more important facet is the output stage. Almost all energy consumed gets converted to heat, with only a small portion doing usable work. Unless there's a massive improvement in the electrical foundations of compute, we will be producing large amounts of heat no matter where the energy is sourced from.
- beefield 3y agounless... the compute happens also in space? Given how dirt cheap solar has become, how cheap shipping stuff to space is becoming and how little there are clouds and nights in the space making solar power production intermittent, it sounds like it might be economically feasible in not so distant future. (no, I haven't done any math on this. If it checks out, feel free to steal the idea)
- rockemsockem 3y agoHeat dissipation in space is hard.
- ben_w 3y agoAnd the Earth is in space, so if we get to the power consumption level where Earth governments need to care about the direct planetary heating effect of the energy source, it's still a win to do the hard thing (dissipation) somewhere else, like the Moon or something.
- exe34 3y agoUgh solar wind and cosmic rays. You'd need to use very inefficient CPUs with enormous features instead of the latest small node.
- rockemsockem 3y agoAlso true!!
- actionfromafar 3y ago
- epistasis 3y agoThe same thing happens when we create heat on earth with nuclear energy, when >50% is directly used to heat the earth via waste heat, and the electrical part becomes >99% waste heat (some tiny fraction of energy is probably permanently converted to chemical bonds, etc.) However, this is completely dwarfed by the dynamics of flux in and out of the earth. I forget the exact order of magnitude but I think it's around 100TW, and of course about that amount needs to be rejected to space. The key dynamics that provide us balance are of course the exact and precise quantities of greenhouse gases in the atmosphere, albedo, etc. And of course, coal and natural gas are releasing stored heat energy too, but their contributions to changes in the atmosphere far exceed the contribution from direct heat energy on the surface of the earth.
- maxerickson 3y agoThe flux is roughly (but more than) 100 petawatts. Human energy utilization is on the order of 100 terawatts.
- fastball 3y agoReally? So we're only 3 orders of magnitude off? Seems like we can definitely get to appreciable levels of i/o in the near future.
- nojvek 3y agoTotal solar energy hitting earth = ~45 Petawatts Total power used by humans = 16 Terawatts. https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/135642main_balance_trifold21.pdf https://www.nasa.gov/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/135642main_b... What we get from the Sun in one hour, is how much we use for the whole year. All our energy needs can be covered if we can tap into just 0.00001% of energy received. About 100km2 worth of solar panels. If every residential and commercial building was covered with solar roof - we’d have all our energy needs covered during day time. It’s free energy if we know how to use it. Plants do and they make up >99.9% of biomass on this planet. The problem with C02 is it traps the heat. All useful work is done when high energy packets from sun in ultraviolet and visible light get dissipated into heat (infrared). If we don’t solve greenhouse gas problem, we can’t use more energy since we’d be out of equilibrium.
- IshKebab 3y agoThis is like the very last possible issue with this plan. It's like worrying about a space elevator unbalancing the earth's rotation. You need to get a better handle on orders of magnitude.
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoExponential growth sneaks up on you. They probably thought the same thing in 1895 about the negligible magnitude of human greenhouse gas emissions.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mjhay 3y agoThere's no exponential growth, that's thermodynamically impossible. Heating the Earth with the microwaves would increase the Earth's radiation into space commensurately. It doesn't get stored forever. This would result in a new equilibrium almost immediately, with an unmeasurably greater temperature. The Earth is always almost exactly in a radiative balance with space, except on pretty short timescales. If it weren't, we'd quickly cook. The radiation the Earth receives from the Sun fluctuates orders of magnitude more over solar cycles, but it's debated whether that even has a meaningful effect on global temperature.
- mitthrowaway2 3y ago(I'm not referring to exponential growth in temperature over time due to constant input power, but rather to exponential growth in input power over time because it's required for economic growth).
- pdonis 3y ago> exponential growth in input power over time because it's required for economic growth It isn't. The amount of energy (and raw materials generally) required to produce a given amount of economic output is not constant. It gets smaller as technology advances. That offsets the effect of increased economic output. Indeed, as more and more economic output becomes information instead of physical objects, the average amount of energy required per unit of economic output will shrink even more.
- m463 3y agominiscule in comparison to greenhouse gas emissions, which can make the entire planet capture and hold more energy, not just a satellite.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- TheDudeMan 3y agoAll nuclear power is also extra heat for the earth.
- pfdietz 3y agoAnd much more, per unit of electricity consumed.
- kadoban 3y agoThis is orders of magnitude away from being anything like a concern.
- tehjoker 3y agoIf you read some criticisms of our economic system, they propose that growth will continue unabated without any limits, but after a couple hundred years, that exponential gets to the point that all the waste heat cannot be dissipated from the earth any longer and it all breaks down.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- rgmerk 3y agoIf you’re postulating unbounded growth, seems pretty arbitrary to not postulate engineering solutions to this problem (eg shift the energy intensive industry off-Earth).
- mjhay 3y agoThe Earth is in radiative balance with space on all but very short timescales. The extra heat, even if it were enough to matter, dissipates quickly.
- schiffern 3y agoWe're not talking about just a one-time pulse of heat, it would be a constant stream of energy. To maintain the same radiant balance the Earth's surface would need to reach a higher equilibrium temperature. We currently have an energy budget that's 0.1% of insolation (and compounding growth at 2-5% per year), so if SBSP actually scales to its market opportunity then the effect could certainly be large enough to matter.
- thelastgallon 3y ago67% of energy is wasted as heat: https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/sites/flowcharts/files/2023-10/US%20Energy%202022.png https://flowcharts.llnl.gov/sites/flowcharts/files/2023-10/U... This will change when we switch to renewables.
- Turing_Machine 3y agoWhat? Renewables are still subject to the laws of thermodynamics and other laws of physics. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_engine#Efficiency https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_engine#Efficiency Typical power stations (whether fueld by renewables or not) have efficiencies considerably less than 50% (the examples in this article give 40% efficiency for coal, 48% for nuclear, and 33% for geothermal). Photovoltaics (not being Carnot-cycle heat engines) aren't subject to these specific limitations, but they have their own problems. Typical efficiencies for current mass-production models are around 20%, while "lab curiosity"-level cells still haven't broken 50%. Note that this is just the generating side. There are also similar waste heat losses on the consumption side (for example, charging and discharging batteries is anything but 100% efficient, as anyone who's actually tried to use a modern laptop on his lap can attest).
- schiffern 3y ago>Photovoltaics... are around 20% The difference is, that 80% doesn't show up on anyone's "books." For coal, you actually need to go dig that 60% out of the ground and burn it, and it still emits a bunch of CO2. For a fuller articulation of the point HN user thelastgallon is making, see this link: https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/electrification-energy-efficiency https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/electrification-en...
- Turing_Machine 3y ago> The difference is, that 80% doesn't show up on anyone's "books." Well, no. You still have to pay the amortized cost of the installation and real estate, the salaries of the employees, and many other things, all of which would be less if the efficiency were higher than 20%. For example, if the photovoltaics were 40% efficient (the same as coal), you'd need only half the real estate, half the semiconductor-grade silicon, and likely half the cost of many maintenance activities, none of which are free. > https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/electrification-en https://www.sustainabilitybynumbers.com/p/electrification-en... This site doesn't even mention solar or the efficiency thereof.
- creer 3y agoYou also affect how much energy (heat) you radiate from earth's surface into space, by choosing the right color, materials of buildings or land around you.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- what-no-tests 3y agoGee if only the Sun were somehow capable of beaming energy to the Earth. /s
- dwpdwpdwpdwpdwp 3y ago"Each megasat could then convert gigawatts of power into a microwave beam aimed precisely at a big field of receiving antennas on Earth. These rectennas would then convert the signal to usable DC electricity." What are the consequences if, for some reason, the aim becomes not-so-precise?
- marcosdumay 3y agoI guess SimCity 2000 guaranteed this is the first thing everybody thinks about. It seems that practicality and efficiency concerns limit the beam at between 10% to 30% of the solar intensity. Every single design falls in that range.
- banish-m4 3y agoFuturama predicted it: https://youtu.be/0qksm5cRtcU https://youtu.be/0qksm5cRtcU Unfortunately, most of these impossible proposals lack any form of passive failsafe. Plus, the insurance liability question maybe an unsurmountable unknown.
- snickerbockers 3y agomost of these proposals are downright ridiculous because they're couched in environmentalism but they act like nature will be totally fine to have a giant microwave laser or an artificial second moon.
- micromacrofoot 3y agoIt seems like it could be safer/easier to charge batteries in space and ship them back down... which probably speaks to the feasibility of ideas like this.
- bell-cot 3y agoVague recollection from studying this years ago... The "receiver" is more-or-less a field "covered" by a spiderweb of bent coat-hanger wire. That doesn't block the sun, and making it huge (low power/sq. m) is quite cheap. Since you don't want clouds/rain/fog to block the microwaves, the frequencies you use are ones which water does not absorb well. So if the beam hits a person...he probably can't even notice it.
- gmuslera 3y agoToday's solar storm might be a good way to prove if we could ever rely on that, even if it were possible.
- HPsquared 3y agoHow about a conductive space elevator? You could physically wire solar panels to the end.
- ben_w 3y agoYou could, but the minimum length of a space elevator is 35,786 km and the maximum distance between two points on the surface of the Earth is about 20,000 km, so you might as well just build a surface power grid: your winter solstice midnight is someone else's midday summer solstice, and no dunkelflaute is worldwide. Much easier on the ground, too, because you don't need to invent even one single new tech — not even better superconductors because even aluminium will work if you make the "wire" thick enough (scare quotes because, by coincidence, the circumference of the earth, 40,000 km, almost perfectly matches the conductivity of aluminium, 3.8e7 S/m, and you get a 1 Ω line from a 1 square meter cross section, which is a pretty thick "wire"). Plus, once it gets down from a space elevator, you then have to distribute it around the ground anyway.
- jandrese 3y agoUltimately the problem with these plans is that solar panels are cheap, but launching them into space is not. There is no point in the near future where launch costs become so cheap that it doesn't make sense to do this instead just building ten times as many panels for the same cost and installing them around the world. The math may change if we ever deploy a space elevator or do asteroid capture and orbital mining/manufacturing, but those are all in the distant future.
- spiralk 3y agoIf SpaceX succeeds with Starship, projected launch costs to LEO could be as little as $10/kg. Even off by an order of magnitude, $100s/kg might be enough to make it viable. There are plenty of population centers where land is scarce or there are bureaucratic hurdles due to stubborn land owners.
- adrianN 3y agoA solar panel weighs like 10kg and costs about $100. Then you also need equipment to produce the microwaves, fuel and an engine to keep the thing in place...
- spiralk 3y agoSo hypothetically, if it was roughly 2-3x the cost to deploy into space, there may be situations where it would be viable. No land usage on the ground, no maintenance, power could be beamed to various parts of the globe as its needed, etc. Ground based solar still wins watts/$ probably, but the better comparison might be versus small modular nuclear reactors. I think costs are close to the smaller reactors, but larger reactors are still more cost efficient. It would be like an SMR that did not require regulatory approvals and could cover a larger area as needed.
- xp84 3y agoNo maintenance? Really? One ‘aiming’ motor goes bad, and this thing could easily fry a long strip of the earth when it loses its lock on its ground station. I don’t think I want such an Elon Musk type of promise as “no maintenance” in this situation. Everything needs maintenance, and while space does different things to machines than air does, they still wear.
- throw9474 3y agoSBSP is a cover for new military capability. Increase the array size by 2.5x and you get a true death ray: https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-based_solar_power#Safety https://wikipedia.org/wiki/Space-based_solar_power#Safety
- joshmarinacci 3y agoI've always wondered (especially after a Dr Hossenfelder video about it). Even if we figured out all of the tech to get such a solar cell satellite into orbit for a reasonable cost, they still need a giant ground station to accept the power. How much power would that ground station generate if it was simply a bunch of solar cells instead of microwave receiver? A space cell might get power 24/7, but if 75% is lost in the conversion, how is that better than a ground based cell that gets power for only 6 hours a day?
- 0cf8612b2e1e 3y agoSecondary usage as an impromptu death ray is the only way that pencils out for me. Even if you could cut the receiving area to 1/10 the equivalent solar panel area, the economics of launching a huge space array seem really difficult to ever make economic sense vs fully land based system.
- XorNot 3y agoMicrowaves don't absorb uniformly into materials. You can have a potentially deadly amount of energy, but if you can't actually interact with it then it's harmless. The proposal for rectenna arrays was grids over farmland which could be used for cattle grazing with illeffects to the cattle - simply not enough EM can be absorbed by them for it to matter.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoPutting cells over the area: You get intermittent power. Putting antennas over the area: You get continuous power. And that's the achillies heel of solar--you can't have things shutting down every time a cloud comes over. Furthermore, microwave antennas are mesh, not solid. You won't have full sun under it, but neither will it be dark. That being said, there's a fundamental issue here that without huge improvements in launch costs it's simply not viable unless made out of lunar materials. And note that it doesn't have to be in a synchronous orbit so long as you permit some movement of the antennas. Put say 25 stations out there and 24 ground stations--they keep hopping to the next station as the Earth rotates underneath, the 25th station is offline because it's in shadow.
- pfdietz 3y agoLaser power beaming for aircraft seems more practical me.
- ben_w 3y agoGiven how hot jet engines run, the capability to power aircraft in general that way seems identical to being able to target at least several thousands antimaterial laser weapons that necessarily are designed to be firing almost continuously and which automatically get worldwide coverage. I'm not saying this will never happen (10% odds Musk tries it), but I don't see that being possible without a single world government, as whoever controls such a system will definitely never fear ICBMs or hostile aircraft.
- LorenPechtel 3y agoYou can't hit what you can't see. Put an ablator on the nose of the ICBM. As it approaches burn-through the warhead salvage-fuses. Your defenders have EMP issues, but let's assume they can shield against that. The problem is now the sky is full of electronic ghosts from the first detonation. Pretty soon another warhead comes along through that ghost-filled sky. The defenders have a much harder time locating it accurately enough to fire. And, once again, when it's going to burn through it salvage-fuses. The sky gets worse. You can stop any given missile. Stopping a whole string of them is quite another matter. (Same as an aircraft pilot beating an incoming missile. Do it right and you can use the missile's speed against it, forcing it to make a turn it can't. But now you're out of position and can't do it against a second missile coming in some seconds behind.)
- me_again 3y agoThis was one of the ideas pursued in the Reagan-era Strategic Defense Initiative, aka Star Wars. They weren't able to develop a system that would work against ICBMs. Powering an aircraft is both easier and harder; the aircraft presumably isn't making evasive maneuvers and trying to stop you from powering it, but the economic and safety constraints are harder.
- 3y ago
- Joel_Mckay 3y agoIn general, the energy retention model for earth only keeps less than around 3% of the suns energy hitting our atmosphere. Shifting this property even by a fraction of a percent causes cascade shifts in global climate and ecology. "There is always a well-known solution to every human problem - neat, plausible and wrong" (Mencken, 1920) Threat assessment: what if a given technology is wielded by an insane king? ...because all things are eventually... =3 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lITBGjNEp08 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lITBGjNEp08
- brcmthrowaway 3y agoWould Room temperature superconductors change anything here?
- ben_w 3y agoI can't see how, why would you expect them to?
- mike_hearn 3y agoPresumably it'd make it much more practical to store energy on Earth, killing the idea one and for all.
- jjslocum3 3y ago<antennas so big that we cannot even simulate their behavior.> I really would love another sentence or two on this. I can't immediately think why that would be, e.g. don't Maxwell's equations apply at very large scales? Any ideas?
- QuantumG 3y agoThey're talking about simulating big floppy structures in space.
- lindboe 3y agoMy two cents, though I'm no expert: I'd bet it's what the computational EM community (and other fields) calls a "multiscale" problem. EM solvers - that is, simulators that numerically solve Maxwell over some geometry-and-source boundary conditions - find E- and H-fields at certain "mesh points". In other words, they discretize 3-space into a grid and calculate solutions to Maxwell at those points. In general, you'll want your mesh to have subwavelength distance between points, and perhaps even less in regions with complicated geometry or parts of your geometry you're particularly interested in. In the microwave regime, this means mesh points will typically have tens of centimeters or less between them. However, given that the receiving antennas in satellite-based solar power are orders of magnitude larger than that, trying to simulate such a large structure and still keep your mesh points relatively dense is just asking for the curse of dimensionality to bite you. In other words, it's certainly possible with enough compute time, but we have better things to do with our GPU cores, especially since the whole point of antenna simulation is to assist with design by allowing you to run a bunch of simulations to tune your design without having to fabricate a bunch of DUTs. Again, I'm not really an expert, but my understanding is that this kind of multiscale problem is a hot research topic right now, not only in computational EM but in many other areas of physics simulations, especially those governed by nasty PDEs (e.g. fluid dynamics) or those which involve complicated structures at multiple scales (e.g. VLSI design).
- TheDudeMan 3y agoIt might only be viable if the majority of materials come from off-Earth, like the moon.
- Laaas 3y ago> As the recently retired head of space power systems at ESA Ah, he’s European.
- credit_guy 3y agoThe main issue with beaming solar power from orbit to surface is that this can be a weapon at a push of a button. There is no way you can make the owner of that orbit-based power station to promise they'll never redirect the beam, under any circumstances, cross their heart and hope to die. The only way to not have that threat is to not have the power station up there. And that's how it's going to be. No matter how technically feasible the idea will ever be, it will never materialize, because the weaponization potential cannot be eliminated.
- BobbyTables2 3y agoIf one just concentrates solar energy that would have hit other parts of the Earth, I don’t see why there would be a net heating. That said, large scale concentration could still be extremely distributive on a regional scale.
- whatshisface 3y agoEvery square in of the Earth is within the range of a weapon of mass destruction already. What's another? (Speaking realistically, it would not be a weapon. These things take acres of antennas to collect power from.)
- credit_guy 3y ago> These things take acres of antennas to collect power from. Ok. Now imagine you redirect the beam to a random substation somewhere. What's the likelihood some of the transformers will fry? Or you point the beam at some cellular phone network towers? Russia is at war right now, and they have lots of antennas pointing up, both for anti-air defense and for electronic warfare. All those would be immediately vulnerable to a concentrated power beam coming from the sky. How likely are they to say, "sure, no big deal, as long as you promise to only use that stuff for power generation, we are totally, absolutely fine with it" ?
- maxerickson 3y agoThe beam isn't necessarily concentrated enough to be damaging, so it isn't obvious that such a system would be a weapon. In other words, the weaponization potential can be eliminated, and doesn't exist in lots of proposed designs.
- Animats 3y agoThis idea made more sense before batteries started to get good. But solar + batteries can get you through the night now. A panel in space can capture maybe 3x as much energy as one on the ground over a 24 hour cycle. But there are losses in transmission and huge costs to get the thing into space.
- cyberax 3y ago> But solar + batteries can get you through the night now. They can't get you through a month of Dunkelflaute in Germany (that's a 1-in-100 years event), when the normal renewable energy generation is less than 10% of the nameplate capacity.
- XorNot 3y agoOver time solar is only ever about 10% the nameplate capacity. Over a year my roof top panels in Australia get about 12.5% their nominal - i.e. about half of the daytime they'll see. The German grid mix very obviously crushes back down to being fossil fuels every night.
- cyberax 3y agoYes, my bad. I meant 10% of the normal average generation. Here is an example: https://energy-charts.info/charts/power/chart.htm?l=en&c=DE&stacking=stacked_absolute_area&interval=month&year=2019&source=sw&month=01 https://energy-charts.info/charts/power/chart.htm?l=en&c=DE&... - for about a week the renewable generation crashed in Jan 2019. And it can happen for almost a _month_ of sustained low performance.
- kragen 3y agoaverage capacity factor for utility-scale solar pv in california is 29%. no state in the usa is as low as 10%. why is your rooftop like maine?
- XorNot 3y agoSydney, Australia. Temperate climates have a lot of grey sky, and we've had a lot more recently.
- cupcakecommons 3y agoderegulate nuclear
- Vegemeister 3y agoOnly one measly paragraph on the obvious improvement, eliminating the microwaves. Instead, launch independent steerable mirror satellites of the most economically efficient size, and point them at the highest bidder. No heavy transmitters or PV cells. No new ground-based infrastructure that has to be built before you can do anything useful.
- MichaelZuo 3y agoThe atmosphere is opaque to sunlight very often... Because of clouds.
- zith 3y agohttps://www.reflectorbital.com/ https://www.reflectorbital.com/
- dkbrk 3y agoCasey Handmer did a couple of excellent articles on this topic: - Space-based solar power is not a thing: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/space-based-solar-power-is-not-a-thing/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/08/20/space-based-so... - No really, space based solar power is not a useful idea, literature review edition: https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/09/20/no-really-space-based-solar-power-is-not-a-useful-idea-literature-review-edition/ https://caseyhandmer.wordpress.com/2019/09/20/no-really-spac... You can get into the weeds of the detailed costings, safety, etc, but I think the clearest argument is this: > The problem with beaming power using microwaves is that the monetizable value per Watt is incredibly low, because essentially unmetered electricity comes out of the walls of every building. The trick is to increase the value per Watt, by increasing the value and decreasing the power. The value is increased by modulating the microwaves with high speed data, and the power can be reduced by a factor of a million or so without hurting this method. Indeed, customers pay only for the data, and not for the transmitted electrical power, which is pathetically low at the receiver. Communications satellites remain the killer app for the commercial space industry And then you look at the fact that almost every satellite communications company has gone bankrupt at some point. SpaceX with Starlink being a notable exception, but OneWeb which superficially looks pretty similar has already gone bankrupt once. If communications, which is many more orders of magnitude more valuable than power, is not enough to stave off bankruptcy, then there is no possibility of beamed power being economical without a commensurate improvement in the efficiency of space launch. And that's just a baseline as a necessary condition, not actually a sufficient condition for it to be a sensible business.
- kazinator 3y agoIf god wanted power to be beamed to Earth from space, she would have put a giant reactor in the sky.
- octopoc 3y ago...the Sun (also wouldn't the appropriate word be "goddess"? Interestingly in ancient German tradition the sun is female and the moon is male)
- kazinator 3y agoThat was not intended as a riddle, so I have not prepared stickers, unfortunately. Personifications of the sun and moon in ancient German lore had better make them respectively female and male, because otherwise the assignment would clash with the grammar, which has them as "die sonne" and "der mond".
- nnurmanov 3y agoThere is another problem to solve, which is cooling the Earth. What does it take to shield the Earth from Sun so less solar power reaches the Earth? Is there such technology?
- jaggederest 3y ago"Tin foil". Arranged in the right shape, and spun to maintain positioning at L1. About a million square kilometers give or take should do it, plus ancillary things like positioning thrusters etc. Call it five to ten million metric tons, if we're using ultrathin kapton with sputtered aluminum. Launch costs alone would be in the upper billions to low trillions, combined with construction and maintenance, probably 1-2 trillion as a lowball estimate. N.B. this only reduces power by a factor of 0.1%, about 1 W/m^2!
- dudeinjapan 3y agoDude where's my Ion Cannon?
- lupusreal 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinned-array_curse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thinned-array_curse
- williamDafoe 3y agoWe don't have the tech to send astronauts to work on a geostationary or geosynchronous satellites. Its a high earth orbit (22,000 miles) and all our tech is for low earth orbit (shuttle, ISS, 400-800 miles) where the ship and station are protected by earth's electromagnetic field and the propellant requirements are much less ... To the best of my knowledge we have never repaired a geosynchronous or geostationary satellite..