9 ms·
Globalization was supposed to align the values. They're diverging
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- neom 3y agoI've had this thought stuck in my head for the past 10 years that comes up a lot, I wonder if anyone has written on it or research it, but it's simple and goes something like: globalized industrial/economic integration came before strong tight cultural integration. I think that is probably a true enough framing? I sometimes then try to think about what the world would be like if the reverse had happened, but it's quite a lot to think about, so I give up quickly.
- gessha 3y agoHow would achieve cultural integration without trade? This reminds me of how much technological progress the British had to make so they can reach India. I also wonder what life on the Americas would’ve looked like if the Europeans didn’t wipe out the natives with deceases, horses and guns.
- soco 3y agoThe question is: when did those Europeans cease to be Europeans and started to be Americans? Is there some overlap with the wiping out of the natives? Of course the distinction is insignificant when looked at from the natives' side, but there's a difference between European nations sending people to wipe out natives, and European people fleeing their countries to become Americans and en passant also wiping out natives. Or I didn't really understand your point.
- gessha 3y agoTo answer your question, I don’t think there’s a clear point where Europeans become Americans when they move and I don’t think it overlaps with repressions of natives. I think the people immigrating to the Americas all had many known and unknown reasons to move. While visiting the Ellis Island of Immigration in NYC, I read some of their records. You can tell from the recorded stories of immigrants. As a European who immigrated to the US in my adult life, I think of it as mixing of dyes. You’re no longer completely European and not as American as the ones born here. There’s beauty and sadness in the process. Also, my point was less about the missing natives and mourning them but about imagining what life would’ve looked like if the two cultures blended in a more peaceful way. This [1] is related to my point about peaceful coexistence, puritans, native Americans, etc. [1] https://www.npr.org/2023/12/07/1198908282/the-lord-of-misrule https://www.npr.org/2023/12/07/1198908282/the-lord-of-misrul...
- neom 3y agoYup, that's the first big question, also I didn't mean to put an absolute on them, it was more the emphasis switched. Then I think the answer becomes: slowly. That's also why it's hard to think about, it's such a different reality, where would we be today technologically, and where would we be socially? Maybe it's a pointless thought experiment, but personally I find it somewhat interesting.
- lasermike026 3y agoIt was always a lie.
- lenerdenator 3y agoIt sort of did for the EU/UK, Japan, South Korea, and Anglo/Francophone North America. It didn't with China, where they think they can do better than the global economic system that drastically improved their standard of living.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- aprilthird2021 3y agoThe global economic system has nothing to do with tolerance of abortion, homosexuality, etc...
- lenerdenator 3y agoIt has everything to do with it. I'm in the Midwest. Know who buys into abortion bans, homophobia and the like around here? People who would have had a decent job 50 years ago before we shipped those off, but now get stuck in their small town 120 miles from the nearest city of note.
- aprilthird2021 3y agoI grew up in Tennessee amongst many similar people, but they had those views before NAFTA and the shipping off of US manufacturing jobs. Those views are their traditional religious views which predate electricity, tbh.
- ajmurmann 3y ago> In 1981, 39% of Australians said childhood obedience was important and 45% said divorce was justifiable. That same year, 32% and 10% of Pakistanis respectively agreed with those statements. In 2021, only 18% of Australians compared to 49% of Pakistanis said childhood obedience was important, while 74% of Australians and 15% of Pakistanis viewed divorce as justifiable. I wish there was more raw data here. This is the only raw data provided and in it acceptance of divorce in Pakistan grew by 50%. It's still low at 15%, but the relative growth is significant! Given the article claims correlation with wealth growth, Pakistan probably isn't a great example, since their economy has been relatively flat. Not saying the article is wrong, but I'd simply love to get more data to understand the magnitude.
- hx8 3y agoFurthermore, I wonder what the views of childhood obedience are those people actively raising a child in each country. I would say "childhood obedience is not important" because I don't spend time near children.
- Dalewyn 3y agoWhile "children must be seen, not heard" of ye olde days is probably too strict for parents of today, I do think there is value in childhood obedience. Namely, it nurtures and grows discipline; and a lot of that simply can't be taught properly without starting from a very young age because that's when moral compasses are molded. You're always going to be under someone in life and life is never going to go perfectly your way. What separates those who succeed from those who fail is whether you know how to handle it, which childhood obedience will teach you.
- vundercind 3y agoJust getting through the day-to-day with kids who aren’t at least some minimal amount of obedient would be a living hell. We’re talking about tiny little people who are inclined to run in parking lots and cut up the curtains to make clothes. You really need them to at least not do that kind of stuff as much as they might like to.
- orangesite 3y agoYes well… I can see where the confusion would arise if we believed keeping foreign policy unchanged and just calling it globalization would somehow align the values.
- aestetix 3y ago> The world's peoples were particularly less likely to agree on the ethics of homosexuality, euthanasia, divorce, prostitution, and abortion. Residents of wealthy countries grew more comfortable with all those topics, while residents of poorer countries were less so. Why did the trend towards tolerance and self-expression stall in poorer nations? Extreme bias on the part of the author. Also, the statement is objectively untrue. It appears that the author has opinions on hot-button issues, calls his opinions "tolerant," and proceeds to wonder why poor countries disagree with him.
- unglaublich 3y agoWhat other people do with their bodies is not a hot-button issue. You either accept it and are tolerant, or you don’t and you are intolerant. So yes, being uncomfortable with others’ freedom of sexuality, etc. is by definition intolerant. You can be a heterosexual Christian conservative married for life 3 children housewife while still being tolerant of those that are not.
- throwaway22032 3y agoThis ignores the fact that societal norms affect your ability to live your life. As an extreme example, imagine trying to find a stable husband and raise a family in a world in which every other woman treated sex as being valueless and beautiful women wandered the streets naked and giving it up to passers by. It might be intolerant to prefer a society that isn't like that, but that doesn't automatically make it bad. edit: Most of the responses here are missing the point because they're trying to take a side (in a deliberately fake, over the top scenario) rather than engaging with the concept. The behaviour of other people affects you and it's perfectly normal both to want to surround yourself with others who share your values, and to exert pressure to push wider society in that direction.
- soco 3y agoAnd in this discussion thread nobody labeled either these positions good or bad. However, if one believes being intolerant is bad, yet stays in their position while trying to rationalize it away, that's called cognitive dissonance.
- majikaja 3y agoFirst worlders became irresponsible and decadent
- aprilthird2021 3y agoThe article assumes that wealth should correlate with an increase in, decidedly secular values (tolerance of homosexuality, divorce, abortion, freedom of expression, etc.) In a vacuum this makes sense; poverty causes people to be very dependent on each other to share resources, and when any group of people depend on each other so much, they need a set of shared rules and norms to govern their interactions with each other. Rich people can live relatively more independent lives and so for them self-expression is obviously easy to endorse. Poorer people depend on each other and the better they fit in the more accessible to resources they have. They thus have no incentive to bring more non-conforming people into the fold to diminish their resource pool and erode their shared values which help them work together with the people they depend on. But this strikes me as one of those things statistics and surveys cannot measure. I am from one of the "poorer" and "anti-Western" countries, and even as people have become wealthier there has been a staunch anti-Western sentiment. It feels to me, without much statistical proof to back it up, that two things occur: 1. There's lots of distrust for people who become wealthy and also are seen as selling out the shared morals and values of their people, in every country, Western or otherwise. You can see the anger hurled towards Hollywood celebrities by conservatives and conservative religious people in the US as an example. But a solid chunk of American rich people are conservative morally. They tend to keep their American values in tact and are relatively humble. Consider Bill Gates who wears a Casio watch, Zuckerberg who dresses in t shirts, Buffett who eats McDonald's every day, etc. These are very American traits every one. Alternatively, many of the elite in poorer countries are more American than they are from their own people. They retain very few cultural aspects of their own people. In essence, most of the elites of the third world are like Hollywood celebrities rather than down to Earth people who the masses can see themselves in. This isn't always true (Ambani is a notable exception), but it's often true. 2. As other countries have not yet totally bought into the Americanization of the world, they're aware of and wary of the pitfalls that come with it. The shift towards liberal values have come with great individual freedom and enormous strides in humane treatment of others, but they've also come with increasing isolation, the breakdown of families, shrinking and aging populations, and many other negatives. It wasn't clear to people before that conservative values might be the glue that keep large families and tight-knit societies together (it may not even be true, but the perception that it might be still grows). So I'd say the lag in those values spreading around the world has given people time to think about whether the tradeoff is worth it. Many still say yes, but larger and larger numbers of people are pushing back than before
- everdrive 3y agoWas globalization supposed to "align the values?" I'm not sure this is really true. The closest argument I've heard in this regard is that globalization will generally make people more capitalistic, and more liberal. (in the "small l" sense) I'm not sure that's any reason to think that this would make people adopt the same values. I also have ZERO reason to think that to the degree that things are splintering, globalism has anything to do with it. I'd lay that blame on social media. It's social media and the internet which present a different reality for me than for my next-door neighbor, and social which feeds me the most interesting (ie, extreme) views on just about any topic I could hope to research.
- coffeebeqn 3y agoGlobalization is at its root manufacturing resources in the place its most efficient/cheapest. I don’t know that it’s “supposed” to do anything else - maybe some of the foolish end of history thinkers thought that but I don’t see how that premise would lead to anything other than what it says on the tin
- vundercind 3y agoIt was (I think it’s finally starting to wane now that reality is becoming impossible to ignore) regarded as nigh-fact by the neoliberal consensus that has driven Washington since the early ‘80s. Like they’d just dismiss anyone who questioned it as clearly an idiot.
- Red_Leaves_Flyy 3y agoGlobalization is just a step on the path of capitalizing and commodifying humanity. The wholesale subjugation of most people to toil m so the fruits of their labor can be accumulated by people whose only claim to these spoils is from circumstance, charitably speaking, is an indictment of the very people responsible for this status quo.
- unglaublich 3y agoIt’s true in the commercial sense: we all wear Nikes, AirPods, drink CocaCola and buy Ford.
- apienx 3y agoOver time, global values are becoming more aligned, particularly around ideals like free thought, free speech, and the open exchange of ideas and goods. Yet, this trend towards universal values is clashing with certain cultures that feel threatened. These cultures respond to perceived existential threats by rallying around authoritarian leaders, implementing stricter regulations. Frustratingly, the study focuses too heavily on GDP per capita and largely overlooks the devastating effects of nationalism and religion. https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46581-5 https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-024-46581-5
- Slava_Propanei 3y agoWeird that you think so highly of free thought, when your goal is to replace all cultures with one thought.
- lazide 3y agoCite on ‘global values being aligned’? People interacting with the same systems we do tend to be more aligned, but as you’re calling out a large portion of the populations feel insecure and are lashing out - and going even harder in the other direction.
- hparadiz 3y agoI was recently hanging out in VRChat and it hit me that the people I was talking to were speaking back to me using an almost American accent despite being native nordic Europeans. Culture is homogonizing at an incredible pace.
- _lvbh 3y agoI have a similar American accent despite being Malaysian. Missionary schools do a lot of good there but a side effect is the gradual phasing out of the local culture/language. The older folks (30+) tend to complain about the fact that “kids these days” don’t speak Chinese or Malay and don’t respect whatever semi-religious practices they carry out anymore. I do think making English a sort of universal language is pretty good though. Now that I’m in the UK, it’s extremely refreshing to be able to talk to anyone of any age and be able to communicate
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- zzzeek 3y agothis is a good article with a bad headline. The headline is going to cause a big long thread here about "globalization == bad". The actual article though doesn't really point to globalization as a failure, only that there's a lot of other compounding factors, in particular continuing wealth inequality, environmental collapse, and the opposition of authoritarian nations like Iran, Russia and China, that are continuing to drive global polarization.
- hammon 3y agoUnfortunately all the supposed great value of the West were bytrailed be govs (i.e. in EU). Assange is still in jail for exposing Crimes, America gov is still fighting random wars around the globe, EU is dictating stupid rules to members countries bypassing parlaments (let's talks about cookies warnings on EU websites, or digital acts to censor socialnets, or evev not able to go to work without the nazipass a few years ago), Israel is free to bomb civilians protected by US, LGBTQ propaganda riched an imbarassig level on Walt Disney and netflix and now is getting the opposite reactions by people. But feel free to tell yourself is a matter of money Diverging to this madness seems the least.
- avmich 3y ago> America gov is still fighting random wars around the globe Give credit where it's due, last 3 presidents were consistently trying to reduce the number of foreign - non-USA - countries where American soldiers were operating. Amount of war operations is reduced significantly.
- dgfitz 3y ago*embarrassing, not “imbarassig” for future efforts. My head has been buried in the sand for most of the whole Gaza thing, but it sure looks like a classic case of ‘person A punched person B in the face and did not expect that B would punch A, back.’ Sure there is a lot more to it than that, but what the fuck did people expect Israel to do?
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- cm2187 3y agoA large part of that is the rise of islamism in the muslim world.
- aprilthird2021 3y agoNot really, you see anti-Westernism rising in India amongst the Hindu majority also while the country is getting wealthier
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 3y agoI feel as if people tend to forget that to some degree the way societies are organised, their morals etc, are basically an element of a wider competition. Maybe a society with an 0.5 fertility rate but advanced manufacturing / military capability / whatever wins. Maybe a society with a fertility rate of 4 but that is otherwise quite backwards wins out. Maybe AGI kills us all and makes this irrelevant.
- Hizonner 3y agoI skimmed over it quickly, and noticed that in every example I spotted, the difference had grown, but the direction of change on both sides had been the same. Some countries were moving faster than others, but they were going in the same direction. So I kind of wonder whether the whole framing was mostly chosen for sexiness.
- adolph 3y agoAll data and [and code] are available on the open science framework at https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/F9BZ7 https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/F9BZ7.
- progrus 3y agoThere’s a Bible story about this
- antisthenes 3y agoWhat a weird article and nonsense premise. Globalization was never about values. It was always about capital being global and having access to workforces of multiple countries. It was about squeezing efficiency out of cheap workforces previously unavailable, while shifting all the unsavory stuff out of eyesight of your consumers and constituents. To think that this would "align" the poor country workforce with the developed country consumerist demographic is such absolute nonsense.
- Slava_Propanei 3y ago[dead]