15 ms·
The Internet Archive's last-ditch effort to save itself
- lobito14 3y agoA certain group of people don't like to keep memories, at least inconvenient memories to them. Check who's been fighting the Internet Archive for several years and you'll understand who this people are.
- lobito14 3y agoThe author seems to be paid to write this, and other articles, he's probably on the payroll of a 3 letter agency.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoThe "National Emergency Library" was obviously a huge mistake, and I'm surprised that IA continues to defend it. The problem is, their online book lending is far from the most important part of the Internet Archive, and by continuing to fight for it, they risk losing everything, including the entire rest of the archive which seems to me to be far more important. The Internet Archive has become the de-facto default location to upload anything rare, important, or valuable, and a terrifyingly large amount of history would suddenly blink from existence if it were brought down.
- ideamotor 3y agoWell said
- idle_zealot 3y agoWhile I agree that the book lending is only a small portion of the value provided by the IA, it makes sense that they're making a stand here. Losing this battle would establish precedent that format-shifting legally aquired copies of media is not protected under fair use, which would be disastrous to preservation efforts of all kinds going forward.
- bombcar 3y agoI think they're intentionally tying it all together because they know that the "emergency library" was a heap of shit (you can't argue you can digitally lend the same document multiple times simultaneously, it makes no sense). They're basically holding the Internet Archive hostage to try to force this thing through.
- jprete 3y agoI think it's a serious mistake that they allowed unlimited borrowers at a time, because that shifts from fair-use format shifting to effectively making multiple copies of the format-shifted document. That said, IANAL and I don't know what actual legal conclusions were arrived at from the trial or appeals.
- account42 3y agoI think it's a serious mistake that they used DRM at all. That positions them right along the publisher narrative which is exactly where they should not be.
- LeoPanthera 3y agoThis has nothing to do with format shifting at all. The IA's normal book-lending service works that way, but the "emergency library" allowed more copies of a book to be "borrowed" than they actually physically owned. This is straight-up piracy, and there's a 0% chance of it being legally justified.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- toomuchtodo 3y agoThis might kill the Internet Archive as a legal entity in the US if the outcome is particularly unfavorable, but LibGen, Scihub, Z-Library, Anna's Archive etc aren't going away. > This is straight-up piracy, and there's a 0% chance of it being legally justified. Agree to disagree. Copyright has worn out its welcome when it is locking up culture for life + 70 years at a time [1] [2]. The Internet Archive could archive and maintain these works in cold storage (both physical and digital), only to make them public again 100-200 years from now, but that would not be keeping with "Universal Access to All Knowledge." Disk and bandwidth is cheap, and the planet is big. [1] https://www.copyright.gov/history/copyright-exhibit/lifecycle/ https://www.copyright.gov/history/copyright-exhibit/lifecycl... [2] https://www.princeton.edu/news/2003/02/21/lessig-were-copyright-war https://www.princeton.edu/news/2003/02/21/lessig-were-copyri... (no affiliation, but a fan and a supporter, and believe in defending public goods)
- bombcar 3y agoIf the IA is a single point of failure, better we learn that now instead of later.
- ggjkvcxddd 3y agoThat doesn't make sense. Of course it's a "single point of failure". I don't think anyone could have ever thought otherwise. A competing archive service would undoubtedly be great for humanity.
- vgkjfhwebfk 3y agohttps://archive.ph/ https://archive.ph/
- bombcar 3y agoThis one is even more frightening, as it's (as far as I know) a one-man show that could disappear at any time.
- vgkjfhwebfk 3y agoYes, it could, but IA, which - up to now - looked more professional and reliable could, too. And, unexpectedly, that's what's happening now. Maybe archive.ph will also surprise us, by being more resilient. Anyway, it's an alternative, for now.
- rbanffy 3y agoThis is NOT anywhere near what the IA provides.
- vgkjfhwebfk 3y agoYes, it's an alternative, not a copy. For example, it doesn't provide "emergency library" style borrowing, and maybe this missing feature is a pro, not a con.
- ranger_danger 3y agoMy problem with the "rest of the archive" is that it's arguably 98% unchecked mass piracy that their own people seem to be ok with, in the form of "we're not copyright police, so just upload whatever you want and let companies deal with it later." which is exactly what Jason Scott has said.
- hackernudes 3y agoCould it be that the alternative is losing stuff forever?
- leotravis10 3y agoSadly, yes. It's more of a reason why you should download the stuff you want and need before it's too late: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39908676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39908676
- ghaff 3y agoYes. If there is something you think you might personally want in the future and you can download it today you probably should. But it’s probably not terabytes.
- ghaff 3y agoThe vast bulk of content is lost forever and given how much is created I’m not even sure that’s a bad thing. And if literally everything were magically siphoned up I’m also not sure that’s a good thing.
- idle_zealot 3y agoOf course it is piracy. This coloring of "bad" piracy with "good" things like libraries and preservation is an important step in dispelling the broadly pro-copyright culture we live in. It draws a clear picture of what copyright robs us of by presenting a case were violating it has a sense of moral righteousness.
- leotravis10 3y ago> The Internet Archive has become the de-facto default location to upload anything rare, important, or valuable, and a terrifyingly large amount of history would suddenly blink from existence if it were brought down. Here's the related discussion: Stop using the Internet Archive as the sole host for preservation projects | 87 points by yours truly | 27 days ago | 27 comments https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39908676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39908676
- coldpie 3y agoYou are directing your ire at the wrong party. Hachette has nothing to gain from continuing to pursue this lawsuit, the only possible outcome (as you correctly state) is the world becomes a worse place. The behavior they object to has already stopped, and they've got a judgment to prevent it happening again. Hachette could drop enforcement of the judgment, both parties can dismiss the appeal, and no one loses anything. Hachette's owners see an opportunity here to destroy a public good, and they are taking it. Hachette are the bad actors trying to destroy what you find valuable, not the IA.
- justinclift 3y ago> Hachette has nothing to gain from continuing to pursue this lawsuit ... They're probably just making sure that the next place that wants to pull something funny, doesn't. Ye old "lets make an example out of them" thing.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Dalewyn 3y ago>Hachette has nothing to gain from continuing to pursue this lawsuit They do: Legal precedent. IA made themselves into an easy, prominent target by doing something everyone else agreed to not do via Gentlemens' Agreements(tm) and precedents set by lesser transgressions, so now they're reaping what they sowed. The book publishers stand to gain legal precedent that doing what IA did can and will result in legal consequences severe enough to ruin you.
- sangnoir 3y ago> You are directing your ire at the wrong party. Hachette has nothing to gain from continuing to pursue this lawsuit, the only possible outcome (as you correctly state) is the world becomes a worse place. Hachette obviously benefits from teaching would-be unlimited "lenders" a lesson. Even anti-DRM, "buy my books only if you can afford" authors were against this hare-brained lending scheme because the IA didn't even bother to buy a single copy of the books they were "lending". The blame squarely falls at the IA's feet; being an idealist doesn't give you the rights to delve into illegal behavior, regardless of the righteousness of your cause or the depth of your conviction. If the world is better with an org in it, and it jeopardizes it's own ability to remain a going concern, it's clear to me who is culpable. "Too good to die" doesn't exist.
- tithe 3y ago> a terrifyingly large amount of history would suddenly blink from existence One response to that is the "The Offline Internet Archive" [0], which includes software to crawl Internet Archive collections and store them to a local server [1]. [0] https://archive.org/about/offline-archive https://archive.org/about/offline-archive [1] https://github.com/internetarchive/dweb-mirror https://github.com/internetarchive/dweb-mirror
- xingped 3y agoHow much data does the IA store? If only storage were cheaper, I'd be way more of a digital hoarder.
- RobotToaster 3y agoAccording to their about page, 145+ Petabytes.
- jzb 3y agoI'm gonna need a bigger NAS...
- _flux 3y agoSo apparently a 20 TB HDD can be purchased at around $250, plus perhaps $30 per hdd slot with a computer (I just recall a number of this range from calculating years ago how much it costs to have storage at home), making it 2 million dollars—without any redundancy, so maybe twice that. On the other hand you can already have 24 20TB HDDs for maybe $7000 (with required other hardware), and that's almost 0.5 petabytes. I imagine it would be able to archive all things a single person cares about. Now only if there was a way to interconnect these smaller storage pods to each other..
- speedgoose 3y agoFor the redundancy at this scale, perhaps tape storage is interesting. Though the prices for high density tape seem to not be low enough to be public, and IBM scam their customers by advertising storage capacity before compression.
- cfmcdonald 3y ago> The problem is, their online book lending is far from the most important part of the Internet Archive, I disagree. Archiving information for future researchers is valuable, but giving access to information to people right now is also very valuable. Most people's access to texts for research is very shallow, unless they are part of a research university. Google Books hosts many works that are out of copyright, but there is a century-long dead zone that is inaccessible. I write a history of technology blog and the Internet Archive lending service has saved me thousands of dollars and many hours that it would have taken to track down the same research materials on eBay. Realistically, I just wouldn't have bothered, and the material I write would be of lower quality or not get written at all. (That said I do agree that the emergency library was a strategic and legal mistake.)
- _DeadFred_ 3y agoGreat, now you get access but then the year this free access is established is the year NEW information stops being created and/or the quality goes down hill (funny how making something free stops a lot of people from doing it for a living). Now everyone's content is 'lower quality or not get written at all' because the content that makes your's not 'lower quality' is no longer produced (most people/businesses don't work for free).
- jrmg 3y agoThe lawsuit is not about the “National Emergency Library”. It’s about, as the IA calls it, “Controlled Digital Lending” - which the IA was doing before and after the “emergency”, and is still doing now. The idea that, if they have a physical copy of a book, they can lend, one-for-one, a digital copy. The “National Emergency Library” was basically uncontrolled - they were ‘lending’ digital copies of books they did not have physical copies of. But there are no lawsuits about that - presumably because they stopped and it would be bad publicity fore book companies to pursue them about it now. I do wonder if it’s what precipitated the book companies’ ire - but I also think a lawsuit about “Controlled Digital Lending” was coming sooner or later anyway.
- gojomo 3y agoNo, the publishers' lawsuit also took issue with the "NEL". It's just that the lower court's judgement didn't really focus much that issue, because they found the broader/simpler and more-foundational "can you loan a format-shifted ebook 1:1 from your physical book" issue against IA, which then makes an anti-NEL conclusion almost automatic. So NEL-related arguments haven't yet been the focus of the rulings, despite being part of the original lawsuit. Thus, also, IA's appeal is mostly about that foundational finding – though section II of the IA appeal brief says that if the appeal succeeds on "ordinary controlled digital lending", the NEL ruling should also be rejudged: >Il. THIS COURT SHOULD REMAND FOR RECONSIDERATION OF THE NATIONAL EMERGENCY LIBRARY Publishers do not deny that the district court’s NEL ruling depends entirely on its analysis of ordinary controlled digital lending. Resp.Br. 61-62. If the Court reverses the latter, then it should also reverse and remand the former. It need not address Publishers’ arguments about the justifications for NEL (Resp.Br. 62), which should be left for the district court in the first instance.
- jrmg 3y agoYou’re right - I remembered the judgement, which, to heavily paraphrase, basically said “the NEL doesn’t matter if CDL is not allowed, so we only really need to consider that”.
- darksim905 3y ago>National Emergency Library Context?
- lucb1e 3y agoContext in here: https://lunduke.locals.com/post/5556650/the-internet-archives-last-ditch-effort-to-save-itself https://lunduke.locals.com/post/5556650/the-internet-archive... (see also the discussion thread https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40201053 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40201053 "259 points by rbanffy 4 hours ago")
- jawns 3y ago> Maybe you and I are on the side of The Internet Archive. Maybe we are such big fans of Archive.org that we want to come to their defense. > But feelings don't matter here. Only facts. And the facts are simple. The Archive's actions and statements (and questionable legal defense) have all but ensured a loss in this case. This is what has surprised me about people's defense of IA. When you look at the facts and ignore the admittedly good work they do elsewhere, it's clear that they not only ran afoul of the law but thumbed their noses at it. But so many people are quick to come to its defense because they love IA so much for the other stuff they do and don't want it to go away.
- bluefirebrand 3y ago> it's clear that they not only ran afoul of the law but thumbed their noses at it When laws are bad, people should thumb their nose at them Good on them for using the platform they have to try and push for real change, at personal risk to themselves and their operations too
- bell-cot 3y ago> When laws are bad, people should thumb their nose at them When the electrical code says that there should be no voltage in the light sockets, then people should stick their fingers into them - regardless of what numbers the voltmeters show. Right?
- 0xedd 3y agoYou misread; He didn't say all laws are bad. But, only an idiot can think that a world where corps write laws isn't corrupt. None of us, right?
- mminer237 3y agoI don't even think this law is bad, other than maybe being too harsh. If this was allowed, why would anyone ever buy a book? I'm not going to pay any amount of money for a book I can legally digitally download for free. I realize physical books have an attractive quality, but I don't think that's enough to support an entire industry.
- nanolith 3y agoMy wife is a librarian. The elephant in the room here is that patrons are shifting toward a preference for digital distribution. However, Fair Use has not caught up. So, libraries end up spending a large portion of their operating budget "leasing" ebooks from publishers at extraordinary markup over the print copies. These leases are only good for so many "check outs" -- often as few as 4-6 -- after which point, the lease must be renewed at a price that can be 2X or 3X the cost of the print book. It's downright predatory. IA may have gone beyond pushing the envelope and well into stepping over the line on this one, but it is an important legal challenge. I don't think IA will or should win, but I do hope that their loss shifts the needle of public opinion a bit toward actual Fair Use.
- greyface- 3y agoIt makes me incredibly sad to see the Internet Archive continue to argue that a DRM system (which is what controlled digital lending is) is a liberatory technology whose usage should be expanded. Libraries should stop lighting money on fire buying expensive short-lived licenses from publishers, and start referring patrons to LibGen, Anna's Archive, Sci-Hub, etc.
- pessimizer 3y agoThat's not a legal argument; you're arguing that crime should be officially encouraged by libraries and the Internet Archive. That's essentially an argument that they should commit suicide in protest of the entire idea of copyright. I'm not saying that speciously. If it's fine that they encourage the public to go to shadow libraries, there's no need for the public to go to shadow libraries; because they've then become de facto legal and the libraries might as well distribute the material directly (or aid with access and provide resources for the shadow libraries.) If it's not fine that they encourage the public to go to shadow libraries, when they do it they've called their own distribution of copyrighted materials into question by implying that they do the same thing as shadow libraries. DRM is an overlay over copyright which gives copyright owners some security that they'll be able to hold on to most of the distribution of what they own. It's really a pretense, because you can have DRM without copyright. DRM is just a weak, autonomous enforcement layer being bolted on. That pretense is the only thing that's keeping IA online at this point. Otherwise, there would be no excuse to allow their distribution of copyrighted works at all. If you want to fight copyright, fight it directly, don't gamble the IA for it. The giant multinational companies that own the vast majority of copyrights are begging you to stake the entire IA on such a sucker bet.
- ghusto 3y agoThere's a lot of sentiment here uncritically equating "right" to "the law". Yes, they almost certainly will not win because it seems (at least to a layperson like me) that they've broken the law. However, that doesn't mean the law is right.
- acuozzo 3y ago> There's a lot of sentiment here uncritically equating "right" to "the law". I wonder what percentage of the population is stuck in stage 4 of Kohlberg's "Stages of Moral Development".
- Analemma_ 3y ago> There's a lot of sentiment here uncritically equating "right" to "the law". No, that is not what's happening and you are willfully misreading the people who disagree with you. The people who oppose IA's decision are doing this because it was foolish to tie the continued existence of the Archive to a designed-to-fail protest action. I encourage protesting unjust laws, but if you set things up so that your inherently-doomed protest will take a critical piece of infrastructure down with you, people are going to be pissed. Don't take something people rely on and make it collateral damage.
- rbanffy 3y agoHow much is Hachette worth? Can some tech bro just acquire it and make this thing just go away?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jonathankoren 3y ago[flagged]
- rst 3y agoHachette is one of four plaintiffs; a majority stake is currently held by Vivendi, which is worth over $10 billion. Another, HarperCollins, is owned by Rupert Murdoch's NewsCorp, and the Murdochs might just not want to sell.
- ezekiel68 3y ago> Rupert Murdoch's NewsCorp Not any longer (since Sept 2023).
- darksim905 3y agoYou have no idea what you're talking about.
- rbanffy 3y agoI wouldn't believe for a second the Murdochs have given up on that power.
- ksherlock 3y agoIt's actually not just Hachette, it's also Wiley, Penguin Random House, and HarperCollins.
- mostlysimilar 3y agoWhat are the worst consequences of losing the appeal? Could this put the Internet Archive out of business or seriously impact its ability to operate?
- leotravis10 3y agoI feel that if they lose, they'll be nearing death's door as it would open up to even more lawsuits (they're already fighting the record labels) and I won't be surprised if various other industries such as the gaming industry would file one next. More here in this essay: https://old.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/1bswhdj/if_there_is_a_book_on_internet_archive_your/ https://old.reddit.com/r/DataHoarder/comments/1bswhdj/if_the... Related discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39908676 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39908676
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mminer237 3y agoThis lawsuit is only about 127 books they were pirating, which at the statutory $150,000 damages for willful infringement would be $19 million, barring any punitive damages. That's most of their revenue for a year, and several years' net income: https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/943242767_202112_990_2023031521121278.pdf https://apps.irs.gov/pub/epostcard/cor/943242767_202112_990_... The real risk is what other lawsuits this might bring on. Given the Internet Archive was doing the same thing with 1.4 million other books, they could potentially be liable for billions of dollars if everyone jumped on this.
- tgsovlerkhgsel 3y agoHow likely is it that a "Internet Archive v2 foundation" will be founded, "partner" with the Internet Archive, rescue all the content, and the IA v1 is allowed to go bankrupt? Because I surely won't donate money just to fund greedy copyright holders, but I'd be happy to fund The Archive.
- 3y ago
- _aavaa_ 3y ago"At bottom, [the Internet Archive’s] fair use defense rests on the notion that lawfully acquiring a copyrighted print book entitles the recipient to make an unauthorized copy and distribute it in place of the print book, so long as it does not simultaneously lend the print book. But no case or legal principle supports that notion. Every authority points the other direction." First of all, why isn't that supported? Why shouldn't they be allowed to distribute that book digitally at a 1:1 ratio? Secondly, isn't this part of what their case is arguing for though? Wouldn't this be the case that sets that precedent?
- Dalewyn 3y agoSee the relevant bit of the law here: https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/108 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/17/108 Of particular relevance is subsection (g) which explicitly states distributing the one copy permitted under this law multiple times simultaneously is illegal.
- nadermx 3y agoWell, hold on. They are allowed to make one copy. Then g specifically says they are allowed to distribute one copy. Doesn't say it always has to be the same copy. It is in fact their one copy.
- Dalewyn 3y agoHere's the relevant bit of subsection (g): >(1)is aware or has substantial reason to believe that it is engaging in the related or concerted reproduction or distribution of multiple copies or phonorecords of the same material, whether made on one occasion or over a period of time, TL;DR: If you make more than one copy of a physical copy you have rights to and/or distribute that copy or copies multiple times simultanenously, the protections granted by this law do not apply. This law only protects public libraries if they make one and only one copy and distribute (lend) that copy out once at a time on separate occasions. There are clauses in this law permitting up to three copies in other circumstances, but those are not immediately relevant for this conversation.
- andrewstuart 3y agoHow can there be so many rich tech people and none willing to be patrons for this?
- criddell 3y agoWhy make a big donation now? Chances are it will only end up in Hachette’s pocket.
- jazzyjackson 3y agothey don't need more money, they need someone else's legal advice than their current counsel
- lucb1e 3y agoI wonder, if you averaged the HN comment thread at the time and took that as legal advice (or even better, if they had announced it and then waited with publishing all those books until there were 24h worth of comments and then used that as legal advice whether to go through with it), if they'd be in a better position now
- imiric 3y agoRich tech people didn't get rich by fighting for just causes, and against the interest of other rich corporations. There's no money or prestige in backing IA.
- tombert 3y agoI love IA but honestly they're almost not a library anymore. You can find entire ROMsets for a lot of consoles for games that are still being commercially sold both physically and digitally, you can download without any kinds of restrictions (no attempts at controlled digital lending or anything like it), and without having to see a bunch of ads for "Horny and Single MILFS in your area". You can also download full TV series that are currently still available on Netflix and full movies and lots of other stuff. I'm all for archiving, and I think they'd have a case if this were Abandonware or Lost Media, but I fear that a lot of stuff on there simply isn't and their ambivalence towards flagrant abuses of copyright is going to get them repeatedly sued. It's annoying, because IA is a wonderful resource and it would be a shame if they get sued out of existence.
- criddell 3y agoEven though I think it was foolish, I do kind of understand the logic. The IA wants to preserve digital media. Sometimes it’s a website, sometimes it’s a CD, sometimes it’s a ROM image, and sometimes it’s a scan of paper. In the end though, I don’t think it’s the archiving part that got them in trouble. It was providing access to that archive.
- tombert 3y agoYeah, I mean, if they just had an archived ISO of every PS3 game in existence sitting on hard drives in the back, I don't think that would be a problem and I doubt that would get them sued because I think that would likely fall under fair use, especially for a library (IANAL), especially if they had purchased legitimate copies of the games and/or had them donated. In fact, I suspect that if they did some kind of controlled lending program of the PS3 games, or the ISO was available to use upon request (e.g. like the US library of congress), that likely wouldn't get them sued either, but as it stands I'm not seeing a fundamental difference between IA and ThePirateBay, sans the lack of viruses and popups from the former.
- troupe 3y ago> (e.g. like the US library of congress) Does the LoC do something like this?
- 0xedd 3y agoDisgusting world we're hurling towards.
- anononaut 3y agoI've been saying this for thousands of years.
- sam1r 3y agoI truly enjoyed the authors’ tone throughout. It felt like a condensed drama / saga. Can’t wait to hear what happens next!
- RecycledEle 3y agoThose who destroy The Internet Archive must live in our memories.
- jeremypipes 3y ago[flagged]
- nadermx 3y agoThe thing that everyone seems to be glossing over, is the internet archive is in fact a none profit. This gives them a very different angel in their appeal.
- geye1234 3y agoShould I assume that this latest tilt at a windmill is going to cause IA to get decapitated by a blade, and start preparing for a world without the Wayback Machine and the other legally non-controversial bits of IA? Is it too late for them to turn back from this craziness and settle out of court for a non-fatal amount?
- favorited 3y ago> Is it too late for them to turn back from this craziness and settle out of court for a non-fatal amount? They have already done so. Part of that settlement allowed them to appeal the result, which is what this is.
- sourcepluck 3y agoThe discussion here makes for tawdry reading I must say. If the relatively technologically capable are apparently predominantly convinced now that copying a file is the same as stealing a physical good then the Internet Archive is already in bad shape.
- gojomo 3y agoFrom the headline to the details, this is a deeply misinformed take on the arguments, current case status, & possible outcomes. "Save itself"? Despite occasional prior histrionic kayfabe about "IA in existential danger" in the media (& HN threads) – sometimes fanned by the IA's supporters themselves – that's never been the real stakes. For the serious librarians, publishing businesspeople, and lawyers involved, this has been about legal clarity for a gray area at the intersection of copyright, fair use, & traditional rights of first-sale and library practices. It's not really about damages, nor the IA's (or traditional publishers') existence. Instead: the principles controlling what's allowable going forward. To that end, per Wikipedia, as of eight months ago (August 2023), the lawsuit parties already reached & had the court approve a negotiated settlement that caps the potential costs to the IA at a survivable level, & sets ground rules for future similar e-book activities that the Hachette et al (4 major publishers) plaintiffs and AAP (publishers' trade group) find acceptable. But further: this mutual settlement permits IA to continue its legal appeal on the principles involved. From <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hachette_v._Internet_Archive#Final_judgment https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hachette_v._Internet_Archive#F...>: > On August 11, 2023, the parties reached a negotiated judgment. The agreement prescribes a permanent injunction against the Internet Archive preventing it from distributing the plaintiffs' books, except those for which no e-book is currently available,[3] as well as an undisclosed payment to the plaintiffs.[25][26] The agreement also preserves the right for the Internet Archive to appeal the previous ruling.[25][26] That is: the publishers were never b-movie villains trying to destroy a public resource; the IA was never reckless anarchists gambling all its other programs for a quixotic legal precedent. They were all adults with a legitimate legal dispute about what's allowed, seeking a clear definitive resolution in the culturally-appropriate manner. And via the settlement and appeal, the parties are still working out the issues. This author misdescribes the IA as "a profitable enterprise (bringing in between $20 and $30 million per year) that is on the verge of a potentially devastating legal ruling which could put [it] out of business". But IA is a non-profit, arguing for a mission-critical principle – a principle which is a plausible extrapolation of existing fair-use rights and library/IA practices into a new domain. And it's doing so with explicit permission under the existing settlement, capping financial risks far below any existential risk. This author further deceptively excerpts IA's central argument as being just "Controlled digital lending is not equivalent to posting an ebook online for anyone to read". Against this, the author writes, essentially, "nuh-uh, that's exactly what they did". In fact the full necessary context of IA's argument is: > First, Publishers disregard the key feature of controlled digital lending: the controls that ensure borrowing a book digitally adheres to the same owned-to-loaned ratio inherent in borrowing a book physically. Publishers repeatedly compare IA’s lending to inapposite practices that lack this key feature. Controlled digital lending is not equivalent to posting an ebook online for anyone to read or copy (contra Resp.Br. 27) or to peer-to-peer file-sharing by companies like Napster (contra Resp.Br. 5). Neither practice is based on use of a library’s lawfully acquired physical copy, and neither ensures that only the one person entitled to borrow the book (or recording) can access it at a time. Controlled digital lending is also distinct from the digital resale considered in Capitol Records, LLC v. ReDigi, Inc., 910 F.3d 649 (2d Cir. 2018). Contra Resp.Br. 35. The former’s purpose is nonprofit library lending, while the latter’s was commercial resale. Controlled digital lending is fair use, even if these other practices are not. That is: the heart of IA argument is that its "controlled digital lending" practices were technologically limited in purpose and duration to be like libraries' other traditional legal reuses of owned works. (Typically, this meant maintaining the 1:1 physical-copy-to-leant-ebook ratio, but even under the temporary "National Emergency Library" program, it meant no permanent unrestricted copies were created – all rights-managed borrowings could and did expire when the crisis ended and normal book sources reopened.) This author's manipulative clipping distorts the IA's filing into a strawman not matching the actual arguments advanced.
- Giorgi 3y agoCopyright is outdated and needs to be canceled, as well as patent system and everything that restricts mankind's free access to the information.
- GrantMoyer 3y agoRegardless of the legal merits of the Internet Archive's case, and regardless of Hachette Book Group's insistence otherwise, it's clear from Hachette's arguments and public statements that they would be happiest if public libraries altogether didn't exist and fair use was erased from law. And regardless of what the law is, the Internet Archive an other libraries should be allowed to lend out a digitized copy of a physical book they own while the physical book is not in use (i.e. controlled digital lending). This is especially true for books without an official digital edition. Hachette doesn't want this, because they want to extract as much revenue from libraries as possible through continuing subscription fees for digital catalogs. Finally, while I agree that the Internet Archive's arguments that the National Emergency Library's unlimited lending should be fair use were always tenuous, I'm still saddened that the arguments failed, and think the precedent their failure sets is much worse for society than the precedent from their success would have been.
- Udo 3y agoHopefully in the far future the IA will be distributed over many individual user nodes, but that doesn't seem feasible right now. What we need right now are 2-4 high powered individuals or companies building local mirrors. Hopefully the IA would cooperate in setting these up. These mirror organizations should be distributed around the globe in different jurisdictions, and they need to take the negative lessons from IA into account: for example, they should probably be structured such that the legally precarious data-serving arm is a different entity from the organization that owns the server space. We absolutely need this kind of resilience, and we need it now. Otherwise this time will retroactively be dubbed the digital dark ages because so very little information actually survived and made it out. Someone in this thread was estimating about USD 2M investment in hardware, then 1M facilities and a small team of people for initial setup, plus connectivity costs and maintenance - let's say 4M initially and about 1M ongoing costs yearly. A single wealthy individual could fund one of these sites. You don't even have to be "rich" to fund this, being well off would be enough. If you fit this description and you're feeling altruistic or are looking for a lasting legacy that will benefit humanity far into the future, use a portion of your capital to make this happen.
- ethanholt1 3y agoIf this makes the IA website go down, we are going to lose so much important internet history. For example, Garry’s Mod recently had almost all of its Nintendo addons taken down, and they were republished on the IA. So if we lose the IA, we might honestly lose quite a lot of preserved media, between games, videos, audio, and everything else.
- TerryHasRisen 3y agooh, definitely. people chose IA because it's simple and easy AND is widely recognized. if it goes then so does much of internet history
- lucb1e 3y ago"last-ditch effort to save itself" is the title, "things aren't looking good for the Internet's archivist" the subtitle. But no mention of what losing the lawsuit actually means for IA: is it actually existential as the title and subtitle are alluding to? That's the only thing I care about if we assume (1) the IA is important and (2) they're gonna lose, both of which I think virtually everyone thinks are realistic statements. Bit disappointed by the article because it's rehashing what we know Edit: found the answer > per Wikipedia, as of eight months ago (August 2023), the lawsuit parties already reached & had the court approve a negotiated settlement that caps the potential costs to the IA at a survivable level ^from another comment, <https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40203627 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40203627>, nearly at the very bottom of the thread (perhaps because it looks like a wall of text at first glance? But the most important info is first). Thanks, gojomo! I just hope this appeal cannot make it worse than it is. Sounds like it will soon again be a good time to donate to the IA: they survive, plaintiffs see there is nothing more to take, then we fund their regular operations and hope for no more "emergency" ideas
- dada78641 3y ago> I just hope this appeal cannot make it worse than it is It cannot. The IA already basically got the worst possible judgment. This is also not an existential threat to the IA, and payment has already been agreed upon. The reporting on this is extremely sensationalist.
- londons_explore 3y ago> and payment has already been agreed upon Why bother appealing then? Seems to just be wasting lawyers fees on both sides.
- gojomo 3y agoThe Internet Archive still thinks it has a legitimate fair-use, first-sale, & library rights basis for 1:1 controlled lending of ebooks for which physical copies are held. With the advice of competent counsel, IA clearly estimates its chance of prevailing on that question as worth the continuing costs. At worst, they lose on that question, and then comply with the August 2023 settlement & pay some undisclosed amount to publishers to cover publishers' legal fees. At best, they set an important precedent that saves their (and many others libraries!) ability to lend in the digital era for the one-time cost of a physical book, instead of the new time-limited leasing models publishers are imposing for native ebook lending – which could massively increase library costs even though digital delivery could be far cheaper than physical lnding. Note that even if the odds are long, setting that precedent would be very valuable! The calculation isn't, "are we more than 51% likely to win?", but "even if we've only got a 5% chance of winning, is the win valuable enough to spend for the chance?". What if Sony had given up when the 'Betamax' case was going against it? It appealed to the Supreme Court, and won a unambiguous ruling that home recording of TV was legitimate fair use. That's a result the rightsholders, and those who naively adopt rightsholder-like copyright-maximalist reasoning without acknowledging the counterbalancing factors in the law, had alleged was preposterous. "Clearly illegal!" they said. But despite that bluster, the actual highest court decided otherwise. Without that ruling, VCRs and DVRs would have arrived far slower & on a short-leash fully controlled by incumbent big studios.
- uuddlrlrbaba 3y agoMaybe instead of paying lawyers to enforce copyright these corps should pay the authors more. Its so frustrating that copyright claims provide riches to the middlemen while buyers/consumers and authors/artists get screwed over again and again.
- fb03 3y agoCan't read the article because blocked in my country (Brazil) for some reason (legal demands) ;-(
- stavros 3y agoI wanted to write a piece of FOSS that would allow dissemination of a large dataset. It would basically work kind of like a torrent swarm, you'd have a "tracker" (the Internet Archive) deciding what it wants each person to store (usually the rarest content would get stored preferentially), and the user could say "I want to donate 2 TB of space to the Internet Archive" and would download whatever files the IA thought were most at risk of being lost. This would have the added benefit that, if the IA went down, the public could reconstruct (some of) the dataset from this swarm. I spoke to a few archiving organizations about whether they'd find it useful, but there wasn't much interest. Too bad, I think a lot of people would like to donate some disk space right about now.
- amanda99 3y agoYou could also do some kind of distributed proof that they still have it: ask every host that claims to have a file compute the hash(prefix+content) of the file, where prefixes differ: distributed k prefixes to each client, and then compare them to get a proof that at least some number of copies exist.
- SahAssar 3y agoMaybe I'm just being slow, but how is that different from a normal bittorrent (with DHT)? Are you asking for coordination of which parts are most rare? I though bittorrent already prioritized the least common parts in a swarm.
- stavros 3y agoIt has quite a few differences, namely it's not one swarm, each file (or collection) is its own torrent. This allows for easy updates (clients can get new files without having to re-download everything), it has protection against some attacks, etc.
- SahAssar 3y agoThat is supported in the bittorrent standard: https://www.bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0046.html https://www.bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0046.html https://www.bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0039.html https://www.bittorrent.org/beps/bep_0039.html Not sure what the client support looks like.
- throwaway48476 3y agoIt's surprising to me the internet archive isn't raking in the money selling AI training data. There are so many quality resources that aren't available on the internet anymore and aren't discoverable.
- Iris2645 3y agoA bit obvious that hosting this sort of service in the U.S would have bad consequences.
- CivBase 3y agoThere is another story on the HN front page about the FCC fining wireless carriers for sharing location data. Someone left a comment comparing the fine for each carrier to their yearly revenue. The biggest fine was for only 0.1% of the carrier's yearly revenue. What the Internet Archive did was obviously illegal, no matter how well intentioned, and I'm disappointed in how they've handled the situation. But what those carriers did is arguably much worse in regards to the public good. So why is the IA looking at its potential end while those carriers receive wrist slaps?
- apgwoz 3y agoI recently read an article (can't find it, but similar to this: https://blog.reedsy.com/how-much-do-authors-make/ https://blog.reedsy.com/how-much-do-authors-make/) which pointed out that the publishing industry is very similar to Venture Capital where 1 hit pays for a ton of the other books that sell at most 1000s of copies. So, if you make books available for free, with unlimited copies, the publisher never gets their advance back, never funds the next hit, etc, etc, etc. I'm all for freedom for information, but unless we can come up with a distribution model that ensures authors actually get paid... I've gotta side with the publishers here. They gotta pay the authors somehow.
- daniel31x13 3y agoTry Linkwarden - https://linkwarden.app https://linkwarden.app - Preserve bookmarks by capturing a screenshot of the saved page. - Open-source and fully self-hostable. - Support for collaborative bookmarking. P.S. I’m the maintainer of the project.
- lobito14 3y agoWhat about answering and closing the 140+ issues this project has on github. Or are you only providing support to paid users? Using the open source flag for profit without actually provide any support or fixes for several months isn't ok.
- SahAssar 3y agoIt's not at all comparable to internet archive. I think it feels wrong for you to promote your paid app in this thread without bringing any insights to the table.
- gooob 3y agothis is interesting because the internet archive is basically a publicly-funded digital library, just like a real library is publicly-funded. it just isn't so on paper. so this is an opportunity to say "hey, look at what this amazing organization is doing. they're acting as a role model for libraries to digitize their books. let's work together, WITH libraries and WITH government, to better serve the public good that libraries serve. "
- gooob 3y agoyes, maybe they spent some of the profit on personal things that they shouldn't have, but don't a lot of publicly-funded organizations do that? i'm not justifying it. i'm saying that when an institution takes a wrong step, or it is shown that the humans who make up its operating team take advantage of the situation, the whole institution shouldn't be squashed. same reason you don't want to abolish the police force when a handful of them inappropriately take advantage of their power. work with internet archive to set up some transparency for fund-allocation. have them donate profits to libraries around the world.
- vardump 3y agoI hope we don't torch Internet Archive. It might even cause irrevocable loss of information and knowledge. Reminds me of destruction of the Library of Alexandria. [0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Library_of_Alexandria
- norir 3y agoThis is an aspect of the internet archive that I don't use at all. It is disturbing to me that we could lose the actual internet archive, by which I mean the snapshotted history of the public internet over this. These two aspects of the organization seem separable. But I guess there are other organizations that are also snapshotting so maybe it isn't a huge deal anyway?
- matheusmoreira 3y ago> Because of Brazilian government demands to remove creators from our platform, Locals is currently unavailable in Brazil > We are challenging these government demands and hope to restore access soon https://archive.is/h7NDp https://archive.is/h7NDp An internet without archival sites is a censored internet. How fitting.
- lobito14 3y agoThere's a thing called vpn.
- matheusmoreira 3y agoThere's also a thing called authoritarian judge-king-dictators who are above the law and have run out of shits to give about your rights. In Brazil for example there's this one supreme court judge who has threatened to apply totally arbitrary hourly fines worth tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars to anyone enabling such "subterfuge", as he calls it. At this point I wouldn't be surprised if Brazil went full China.
- TerryHasRisen 3y agoDo not let another Library of Alexander burn again.
- leotravis10 3y agoSadly, there's a very good chance it'll happen. Not today, not this year, but in the not too distant future and we have to be prepared for it.
- srackey 3y agoJust move it to Russia, the only country with an enlightened approach to digital copyright law.
- joshspankit 3y agoIf younger generations were given the ability to rewrite the laws around sharing works, I feel like none of this would be in question.
- kryptonomist 3y agoAs a regular user of this wonderful archive.org project, I found it a pitty that no agreement could be found with editors such as Hachette regarding old books. Without archive.org, it seems no money at all was made from them. A subscription to access these old books would be a win-win, with a part redistributed to editors. Access could be made from archive.org or why not, directed to a frame in editor websites. Same for old magazines which are really appreciated by the retrocomputing community.
- NoGravitas 3y agoDon't give Bryan Lunduke any attention. The man has been 100% grift from the start - his turn to producing right-wing and conspiracy content has just been a symptom of this.