7 ms·
How do you accidentally run for President of Iceland?
- bell-cot 3y agoImagine living in a world so wonderful that you actually had to look on relatively obscure web pages to find such UI screw-ups...
- readthenotes1 3y ago"People don't read" should be tattooed on the back of every designer's hand. Of course, they won't read it before they design something that requires deep engagement through reading.
- educaysean 3y agoJust the designers? Tattoo it on the back of everyone's please
- btilly 3y agoIs there any point in tattooing it on the back of the hands of people who don't read? That said, https://readabilityformulas.com/readability-scoring-system.php https://readabilityformulas.com/readability-scoring-system.p... is a good sanity check. Over half of people can't read text above a grade 8 readability. Worse yet, we aren't conscious of the effort that reading takes. Not until we are struggling. So competent people have little sense of the barriers they create.
- teddyh 3y ago“1. Users don’t have the manual, and if they did, they wouldn’t read it. 2. In fact, users can’t read anything, and if they could, they wouldn’t want to.” — <https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/26/designing-for-people-who-have-better-things-to-do-with-their-lives/ https://www.joelonsoftware.com/2000/04/26/designing-for-peop...>
- pmontra 3y ago3. And if they do read something, they don't understand what they read, either because it's poorly written or because they start from different assumptions than the ones the writer had in mind.
- _carbyau_ 3y agoI like to think about design as a communication medium. So for most stuff the manual goes straight to the shelf. Unless it is something particularly powerful or complex, I see having to refer to the manual as a failure in UX design. So yeah, I don't want to refer to the manual.
- klyrs 3y agoAlso, a good warning sticker to put on books
- alexchamberlain 3y agoBut who would read the tattoo?
- kome 3y agoGood luck to aunt Helga!
- themaninthedark 3y ago>Don’t make people think or read too much — they’ve got things to do That is great an all but when you are endorsing someone for a serious position of power, shouldn't we want them to be engaged and thinking?
- meowster 3y agoYes, but presumably those people read it and registered knowingly. It's the people who did not want to run for presidency that did not read.
- h1fra 3y agoit's not a vote, it's the possibility for a candidate to participate in the election. imo we have the same process in france (slightly more complexe) this is just a process to pre-eliminate jokes and unserious people then you still need a regular campaign
- themaninthedark 3y agoI understand that it is not a vote but it is basically signing an online petition. Here is the expected behavior: The prospective candidate asks someone to support them and sends them the link. The supporter is supposed to scroll the list, find the candidate and click to support them. This is failing because the first element that the supporter sees is the register link. I do think that the redesigned page looks better but in my view endorsing someone or signing a petition is not a task that someone should take lightly.
- kgermino 3y agoThat's fair, but why would they see (what they think is) "log in to endorse someone" as the part of the process which requires deliberative thought? Yes they should consider who and whether to endorse, they should probably check to make sure they're doing the endorsement correctly, but if you're looking for the Log In button to do the endorsement and you see what looks like a normal EULA above a prominent Log In button of course some percentage of people are going to skim over that.
- noashavit 3y ago> Be wary of generic buttons. lol
- jonwinstanley 3y agoThis is bad/confusing design for sure. Add this to the (probably) huge list of examples. I remember there was a terrible UX error a while back in Hawaii wasn't there? And the "butterfly ballot" issue in the 2000 election is another.
- jarofgreen 3y agoThis one? https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jan/15/hawaii-missile-false-alarm-design-user-interface https://www.theguardian.com/technology/2018/jan/15/hawaii-mi...
- jonwinstanley 3y agoYes. Crazy. False positive missile alerts are kind of upsetting to people
- ljf 3y agoAnd link to the butterfly ballot https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/nov/19/bad-ballot-design-2020-democracy-america https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2019/nov/19/bad-ballot-d...
- imzadi 3y agoFor a clear illustration of how much that ballot screwed Al Gore, look at Pat Buchanan's vote in Palm Beach county, compared to every other county. He clearly got 2000+ votes that were meant for Al Gore. Gore lost by less that 550 votes. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidential_election_in_Florida https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2000_United_States_presidentia...
- pquki4 3y agoI never understand why people think the following "fire extinguisher inside" sticker is a good idea: https://www.firesupplydepot.com/fire-extinguisher-inside-label-4x4-bl105.html https://www.firesupplydepot.com/fire-extinguisher-inside-lab... To me it is the same thing as the La La Land fiasco.
- greenavocado 3y agoWhen a fire breaks out and you begin to panic the stickers help reduce cognitive load by instinctually guiding people to cabinets containing fire fighting equipment. What is the problem?
- Symbiote 3y agoPerhaps the point is the text? The European version of that sticker has a picture of an extinguisher, sometimes with text in the local language underneath.
- Detrytus 3y agoIs picture better though? This actually looks like a bottle of soda next to a Christmas tree: https://www.brady.eu/signs/iso-7010-sign-fire-extinguisher-cps-3185749?part-number=816887 https://www.brady.eu/signs/iso-7010-sign-fire-extinguisher-c... Even panicked people can still read and a big "FIRE" word is actually quite easy to recognize, unlike the picture above.
- cess11 3y agoWe learn that symbol and others before we learn to read.
- mynameisvlad 3y agoYou get exposed to the symbol for a fire extinguisher that much as a child? I would expect encountering it at some point not before reading.
- jannyfer 3y ago> Many of these people are seriously vying for president (yep, my aunt Helga), some of them have undoubtedly signed up as a joke (nope, not the comedian) Reykjavik had a comedian as mayor: https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/sep/15/jon-gnarr-comedian-mayor-iceland https://www.theguardian.com/world/2014/sep/15/jon-gnarr-come... His memoir was a good light read. Poignant and hilarious.
- r00fus 3y agoComedians would actually make great politicians because the overlapping skillset is quite similar.
- joemi 3y agoPretty sure he's the same one mentioned vying for president. His name showed up in the list when I visited the page. (I will always love the fact that a prominent politician in Iceland used to be in the Sugarcubes with Bjork.)
- arnarbi 3y agoHe's also the one running for president. https://grapevine.is/news/2024/04/03/comedian-and-former-reykjavik-mayor-jon-gnarr-announces-presidential-bid/ https://grapevine.is/news/2024/04/03/comedian-and-former-rey...
- irrational 3y agoThe thing that surprises me the most is the page is in English. I know nearly everyone in Iceland is very fluent in English, but they all speak and read Icelandic too.
- einherjae 3y agoBoth English and Icelandic versions are available (potentially hidden in the burger menu on mobile): https://island.is/forsetaframbod https://island.is/forsetaframbod
- crote 3y agoThat's very common in smaller countries. The government exists to serve its citizens, not the other way around. When you know a significant minority is less than fluent in your somewhat-obscure local language, providing a translation for that minority is almost a no-brainer. For example: I am a Dutch citizen. Due to the European Union I have the right to live and work in Iceland. If I were to move there, I'd gain the right to vote in local elections (not national ones, gotta be a citizen for that) - without speaking a word of Icelandic. I'd also have to do taxes, renew my driver's license, and all the other government stuff. Either I and the thousands like me are going to use Google Translate and screw it up, or they'll just have one of the many bilingual workers provide an official translation. It makes a lot of sense to just translate all official government pages, making an exception for this specific page is probably more work than just translating it too.
- Scoundreller 3y agoAlso because Europe, thanks to the frequency of jus sanguine, people like me can be born and raised in Canada but be a citizen of some European country because my parents were born in its predecessor country many decades ago. So I’m eligible to vote (tho I don’t), but minimally speak that language and have spent minimal time there. I’d also assume Google Translate will do better translating from English to $OtherLanguage than Icelandic to $OtherLanguage. So makes sense to put up a translation into English (or other common language) and make sure it’s correct.
- remram 3y agoHonestly this is worse than a "design issue" of the button styles or "people not reading" here. "Register to collect endorsements" does not explicitly say whose endorsements. It is possible to read this sentence as a (slightly odd) way to say "Register to have your endorsements collected". "Collect" is a rather ambiguous verb, if I saw a button on a different website saying "register to collect favorites", I would understand that the website is building the collection, from my clicking on items... not that others will fav my profile. "Register as a candidate to collect endorsements" would have been much clearer, whether the visitor read the preceding block of text or not.
- golergka 3y agoI assumed the page was in Icelandic and the author translated the UI for his english-speaking audience?...
- luplex 3y agoNope, there definitely is an english-language version, at least of the site that's live now. https://island.is/en/presidential-election-candidates https://island.is/en/presidential-election-candidates
- arnorhs 3y agoOr simply: "become a president"
- titanomachy 3y agoI think Amazon has a patent on "becoming a president in one click", you might have to pay them some royalties.
- seabass-labrax 3y agoI was going to point out that Amazon is American, and thus would have been unlikely to file in Iceland. Unfortunately, however, Iceland is a party to the Patent Cooperation Treaty, so it is probable that an patent that Amazon holds in the USA would have also been granted in Iceland. P.S. Iceland the country, not the retailer, in case that's not clear in this context ;)
- stcredzero 3y agoI keep on noticing moments bad UX creeping into apps, more and more, for little possible benefit. Do frontend people simply not think about 2nd and 3rd order consequences anymore? Here's an example: Disappearing affordances. For some reason, the button to remove the background from Google Meet went from being its own "Remove Background" button, to all background thumbnails becoming a toggle button. This is fine, so long as the selected background is visible. But if it's not, perhaps because the selected background is outside the viewport of the scrollable selector, then what's happened, is that the affordance of the "Remove Background" button simply disappeared.
- Ekaros 3y agoClear issue is that why are these not separate systems or pages entirely. Registering for this process should be entirely separate from using it. And if also paper forms are accepted, whole process should need more tracking from canditate.
- joemi 3y agoFor a country whose population is just 399,189 (according to 2024 census), I don't think what you propose is necessary. Edit to add: I'm not sure if you added the "or pages" later or if I just missed it when replying, but my response was specifically about the suggestion that they should be separate systems. Separate pages totally makes sense, and I do think that's a good solution.
- throwway120385 3y agoYeah, it was actually neatly resolved here by applying separation of concerns and just doing the totally different things on different pages. People wanting to endorse a candidate are not the same as people wanting to be a candidate.
- simonw 3y agoThey are now - the site was redesigned once this problem became clear!
- falcor84 3y agoThat site clearly had UX issues and I'm glad it was redesigned, but I disagree with your statement in principle. I think it would actually be great for democracy if every time you were asked to support some official, you had a call-to-action for taking their role. On that note, I don't see any issue whatsoever with 82 people running for presidency - why not more? "Politics are too serious a matter to be left to politicians" -Charles de Gaulle
- Wowfunhappy 3y ago> On that note, I don't see any issue whatsoever with 82 people running for presidency I wouldn't have an issue if the election used ranked choice voting. Otherwise, however, it could be a disaster, with the winning candidate only having a tiny percentage of the vote.
- technothrasher 3y agoI remember watching a bit on TV years ago about the president of Iceland flying commercially just like any other passenger. I thought at the time there was no way the president of a country really flew around like that. Years later I found myself sitting behind the president of the Turks and Caicos islands on a commercial flight and thought, "huh, I guess I was wrong."
- resolutebat 3y agoThe Prime Minister of Singapore, a country that could very easily afford a fleet of private jets if they wanted to, travels on Singapore Airlines. If you're a frequent flyer based on Singapore, running into extra security because he's on board is a not-uncommon occurrence.
- bobthepanda 3y agoSingapore also specifically prides itself on its airline being rated one of the best in the world. Though I don't think the Emir of Dubai flies Emirates.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoEmirates should be in Abu Dhabi
- bobthepanda 3y agoNo, Emirates is Dubai and Etihad is Abu Dhabi.
- inemesitaffia 3y agoOh thank you
- draculero 3y agoThe current president of Mexico, at the beginning flew commercial flights but after a year or two he got tired of the sneering and insults (well deserved).
- jcarrano 3y agoIf that happened to me I'd take it as a sign from the heavens and I'd keep pushing forwards.
- altodemo 3y agoCan we focus on the fact that anyone in this country can register to run for a president? When do we fight for such right to freely nominate and endorse each other for leadership positions in our countries, too?
- seabass-labrax 3y agoWhat's kind of a problem for me is that, in my country, namely the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland, doing such a thing would amount to high treason. Lowering my sights from 'King' to 'Prime Minster' is more doable, but technically that is not a democratically elected position anyway; it's an appointment by the favour of the reigning monarch. That is, you can freely endorse someone, but the King isn't obliged to take any notice. The truly direct and democratic path to leadership is that of running for membership of the House of Commons, which is not something I haven't considered with some seriousness on occasions. However, independent candidates rarely get as far as their party-affiliated counterparts.
- Dylan16807 3y agoThe US is about the same, isn't it? https://ballotpedia.org/Ballot_access_for_presidential_candidates#Requirements_for_independents https://ballotpedia.org/Ballot_access_for_presidential_candi...
- altodemo 3y agoIn one country it’s so easy, you can do it by accident (11 people this last weekend). In US it’s possible… with hundreds of thousands signatures, thousands of $ and going through 50 bureaucratic procedures. About the same, huh?
- Dylan16807 3y agoYou need to read the article more carefully. A bunch of people accidentally signed up to the process that lets people collect endorsements. They still need 1500 endorsements to actually get on the ballot. Much like you need 800 signatures to get on the ballot in New Jersey. Making it digital instead of paper is more convenient but doesn't change things all that much. And while some states have pretty big numbers for signature count, at most they seem to be a pretty similar percentage of the population to Iceland's 1500. Most states are far less. Edit: I forgot to address needing 50 filings, but that's easy compared to the signatures. The population-adjusted equivalent of a candidate with 3 hardcore supporters in Iceland is a candidate with 2500 hardcore supporters in the US.
- gmdrd 3y agoIt seems there is a correlation between appearing at the beginning of the list of candidates to endorse and having a last name that starts with "A".
- strken 3y agoI never noticed that Medium blocks pinch-to-zoom on mobile! (At least, in Firefox for Android.) That's a really obnoxious design choice in itself, and it's particularly bad when there are desktop screenshots in an article like the one here.
- userbinator 3y agoIn the redesigned version, the “Log in” button has been replaced by a link that reads, “establish a collection of endorsements,” which is much, much clearer. That seems unnecessarily verbose, and still slightly ambiguous. How about "Endorse a Candidate" and "Become a Candidate"?
- Akashic101 3y agoThis would help a bit, but loads of people still see a button and click the button without realizing what they click on. It's best to keep stuff as far away as possible, especially when one of the actions is to become the potential president of Iceland
- szszrk 3y agoI love how the website on UX design actively locks your possibility to zoom in on mobile. It sends me a clear message that I should search for UX knowledge elsewhere.
- rlhf 3y agoEconomic factors really play a significant role though. Languages spoken by smaller populations or in remote areas may face challenges in economic development.