14 ms·
Apple Has Removed Airfoil Speakers Touch From The iOS App Store
- PythonDeveloper 14y agoThis is exactly what I've been talking about wrt App development on Apple. If Apple likes your product, and they steal your features for their OS or apps, they kick you out so they don't have any competition. IMHO, it's a real douchebag business decision, and anyone with a popular unique app should always expect Apple to screw you over with no notice and have a contingency plan in the works.
- bluthru 14y agoSo which is it, software patents are good and this is "stealing", or software patents are bad and this is inevitable?
- ConstantineXVI 14y ago"Stealing" features is one thing, taking advantage of your control over a particular market to shut out the "competition" you "stole" said features from isn't justifiable in any way (IMHO).
- bluthru 14y agoI don't really like it either, but is this something that could be legislated somehow?
- anigbrowl 14y agoHey, it's Apple's marketplace - private property and all that. Nobody has a right to sell there. Now, I also think this is a dick move, but it's because of dick moves like this that the patent and copyright systems exist in the first place, and why I think they need to be reformed rather than abandoned.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoNever said it was illegal, just unethical.
- samineru 14y agoI wish that we could rely on the companies that are increasingly controlling semi-public commons like social networks and software repositories to have some integrity and respect for the roles that they are playing in this regard.
- ajross 14y agoExactly. If Apple clones this thing and produces a better product, it's a good thing, because we all have better software to use. Likewise, if Microsoft were to produce a better browser than, say, Netscape, no one would complain. When either company leverages its control over the market to exclude its competitors using mechanisms other than technical quality, that's a bad thing and needs to be condemned.
- freehunter 14y agoI'm waiting for the day when the App Store (et al) become classified as a "market", in the sense of "shutting competitors out of the market". On a desktop, Microsoft can't get away with making a browser (for example) and then locking out all other browsers. That's abuse of their monopoly position. Apple should be living up to the same standards in mobile. I view mobile as more of a game console than a PC, but if Apple wants to insist that they're fully functional and "post-PC", they have to live by the same standards.
- cooldeal 14y ago>I view mobile as more of a game console than a PC, but if Apple wants to insist that they're fully functional and "post-PC", they have to live by the same standards. Apple does not insist the post-PC devices are fully functional. In fact, Jobs compared PCs to trucks and iOS devices to cars. By post-PC they imply that lockdown that comes with it.
- koeselitz 14y agoOne may believe that it's unscrupulous to undercut another company and co-opt their ideas without believing that the software patent system is tenable or just. Similarly, I believe lying is generally unethical; but I certainly don't believe there should be a law against lying.
- pcopley 14y ago"Repeal perjury laws!" - koeselitz
- drumdance 14y agoIt's one thing to steal an idea. It's another thing altogether to deny access to the market.
- bede 14y agoI don't think anyone is complaining about the theft of the feature here. It's the fact that Apple is leveraging its power as the ecosystem owner to harm the competition. Everyone expects Apple to call the shots on their own app store to some extent, but it becomes unacceptable when well intentioned and heavily invested developers get screwed over by Apple making anticompetitive exceptions to their own, already volatile, set of rules.
- baddox 14y agoIt's the latter. It's unfortunate for these app developers, but it's not tough to predict when you look at Apple's history with the App Store.
- mikeash 14y agoWait, how is this related to software patents?
- acdha 14y agoSoftware patents are bad, full stop. This, however, has nothing to do with that: it's about consumer choice: making a better product and tempting people away with it is normal and healthy but abusing a lead in one market to prevent people from being able to make a choice in another is always bad. This is the strongest criticism of Apple's app store policies: on the Mac if you get Karelia-ed that's not pleasant but it's a business risk you assume along with the possibility of any other large company entering the market. On iOS, Apple will preemptively kill your ability to sell a product before their competitor even ships, preventing your customers from even being able to decide that they prefer the app which ships with the OS.
- raganwald 14y agoIf Apple likes your product, and they steal your features for their OS or apps, they kick you out so they don't have any competition. Yes! Sharecropping in the Orchard: http://weblog.raganwald.com/2004/11/sharecropping-in-orchard.html http://weblog.raganwald.com/2004/11/sharecropping-in-orchard...
- earl 14y agoYour point is more than fair, but at this point, does anyone not know the deal with Apple (and Google and Microsoft for that matter?) All these companies are looking out for #1. If it becomes in their interests to screw you, look out. Apple: examples too numerous to mention. Microsoft: the whole world by delaying the internet for 6-10 years by killing off all alternate browsers then stopping any development. Everyone who purchased a computer basically ever by forcing manufacturers to always buy their OS no matter what they sold on the computer. Google: skyhook, google+, dropbox, etc.
- raganwald 14y agodoes anyone not know the deal with Apple Hopefully very few. I wrote that at the end of 2004, and it seems simpler to link to it than to repeat the same old, same old arguments all over again.
- hristov 14y agoGoogle may create a competitor but will not try to prevent you from doing your own thing. That is really the most you can hope for. You cannot honestly expect another company to not enter your business because you thought of it first (except if you have a patent of course). But Google will not use any of its substantial infrastructure to prevent you from doing your own business. They will still list you in the search results, offer your software in the android store, allow you to buy ads, etc. This is very different from what is happening here.
- earl 14y agoOne of the examples I gave, Skyhook, so clearly contradicts your entire post that I have to assume you're intentionally lying. Because that was exactly google preventing someone from executing their business essentially via blackmail. See also their negotiations with Yelp / scraping their results. Oh, and twitter results. So all in all, bullshit.
- kalleboo 14y agoI remember a time before Jobs returned when Apple would buy the third-party apps that they put into their OS, instead of just ripping them off.
- ConstantineXVI 14y agoiTunes (fka SoundJam), GarageBand[1], and Siri were all bought under Steve's watch. [1] strictly speaking, it's the developers they bought (along with Logic)
- stuartjmoore 14y agoCoverflow was bought, too.
- philwelch 14y agoIt really just goes back to the concept of "barriers to entry". If Apple can reproduce your software easily, they will. They might even do it better than you. They'll only go out of their way to buy you anymore when you've implemented something like Siri that's actually difficult, or something like Logic that has a massive and lucrative installed base. If you implement something trivial, don't be surprised when your competitors reimplement it instead of giving you a millions-dollar signing bonus just for your ideas.
- kalleboo 14y agoGood point. I guess the difference is those are apps they couldn't recreate themselves for cheaper than the purchase cost, whereas they used to buy trivial apps (MenuClock being a good example of that).
- dctoedt 14y ago> all bought under Steve's watch It's on Steve's watch (a Navy term). /pedantry
- josephcooney 14y agoa military term /double-pedantry
- jsz0 14y agoIf Apple likes your product, and they steal your features for their OS AirTunes came out in 2004 and AirFoil followed a year later as a software accessory compatible with AirTunes.
- cletus 14y agoWhat you're describing is the situation every time you develop on someone else's platform: Apple's, Microsoft's, Facebook's, everyone's. If you're developing apps for a platform you want to be in one of two positions: 1. The app is secondary to whatever service you're providing (eg the Facebook app on iOS); or 2. You're developing games. Everything else has to walk a fine line between failing and being successful enough that it gets absorbed into the platform. Apple is just like everyone else in this regard. No platform owner is going to ignore something that they decide has become of critical importance to their platform. It's simply a fantasy to assume otherwise. If you're not in one of those two categories you're basically hoping to be the lucky one who gets bought out (eg the official Twitter mobile client).
- lucian1900 14y agoWhen Windows grows a new feature, old apps providing that feature don't get shut down instantly.
- pantaloons 14y agoIn fact Microsoft has in some cases gone to great pains to avoid introducing features for which independent ecosystems already exist.
- gcp 14y agoAntivirus programs and CD burning are two good examples. Microsoft built a big developer base in part by not totally screwing them over. But looking at iOS, maybe they shouldn't have bothered.
- zmmmmm 14y ago> What you're describing is the situation every time you develop on someone else's platform: Apple's, Microsoft's, Facebook's, everyone's. Ah, so that's why FireFox and Chrome were banned from Windows. Oh wait they weren't. Ah, so it must be why the Amazon Appstore for Android can't be installed on Android any more. Oh wait, it can, along with dozens of other app stores. But it does explain why the Kindle app is crippled on Android so that Google Books can take prime position. Oh wait, it's not. You have a point, but you try to use that point to gloss over the real issue here. On other platforms your product just has to be good enough to succeed (eg: Kindle app). On Apple's platform(s) it is not about being good, in fact the better your product is the more threatened it is by Apple's anticompetitive practices.
- ryannielsen 14y agoYou're assuming you know why the app was pulled. Was it pulled because Apple's going to introduce a competing feature in iOS 6 and doesn't want the competition? Or was it pulled because the app is using the leaked AirPlay encryption key? Or was it pulled for some other unknown reason? We don't know. Frankly, I doubt Apple would give a damn about competition for a feature they plan to introduce in iOS 6. They don't care about other apps that reimplement iOS features, such as music players or (now) mail clients. Why give a damn about AirFoil? Finally, unless you own, or no one owns, the platform on which you're developing, you're always at risk for something like this happening. This is nothing new, and it's definitely not behavior that's isolated to Apple.
- calinet6 14y agoTrader Joe's does this too. They test your products in-store, then clone them and sell their own if they're successful.
- roc 14y agoDoesn't Apple have some boilerplate that specifically disallows peer-to-peer content transfer in iOS apps? Streaming-only may edge around the language, but may still run afoul of the intent. I think it may be premature to blame this on Apple removing a competitor to make way for a first-party feature. I think their content partners are just extremely sensitive about this issue and these clauses and their enforcement are just a price Apple is currently willing to pay to keep them happy. See also: wifi hotspot functionality and provider desire to charge for tethering.
- smackfu 14y agoI don't think it's in the current guidelines (it's not in the Oct 2010 one). Someone with a developer account can check.
- deleted 14y ago[deleted]
- js4all 14y agoI suspect that this app uses Apples's leaked key for airplay encryption. In that case I would understand the rejection. I can't wait for the official explanation.
- cbryan 14y agoThis. A thousand times.
- calinet6 14y agoYep. It's a reverse-engineered protocol using a leaked encryption key. The developers had to know this wouldn't last forever.
- cooldeal 14y agoThe fact that there is no reason given to the app developer for the rejection is a separate and bigger(IMO) problem here. >I can't wait for the official explanation Is there a guarantee of one? If the issue becomes a PR nightmare, maybe. Gruber would call this "Measure twice, cut once" and a good move by Apple.
- mikeash 14y agoWhat Gruber actually said about this is, "I can’t imagine what Apple would object to with this app, or why they wouldn’t provide Rogue Amoeba with a precise explanation before removing the app." Although I imagine if it was some company he didn't see favorably, he would probably go for your explanation rather than the one he actually posted for this.
- fpgeek 14y agoI just realized that Rogue Amoeba isn't just a random company making iOS and Mac apps. They aren't even just a random company that Gruber likes. Rogue Amoeba is a past sponsor of Daring Fireball, including being the debut sponsor of the Daring Fireball RSS feed [1]. Given that, I'd be surprised if he'd said anything else. That doesn't mean what Gruber said here is wrong (I don't think it is), but that is important context nevertheless. [1] http://daringfireball.net/2007/07/regarding_df_feed http://daringfireball.net/2007/07/regarding_df_feed
- lukifer 14y agoThis is the great irony of a free market: that it includes the creation of closed, private markets which are decidedly un-free. (Apple's the biggest jerk about it, but there are many others, such as the game console manufacturers, or Amazon's app store). And as evidenced by the App Store's enormous success, the market does not inherently select in favor of open markets versus closed ones. Apple of the 2010s is much more deserving of DoJ investigation than 1990s Microsoft ever was. And if I had my druthers, ecosystem monopoles of this type would be blatantly illegal, and manufacturers would be obligated to include jailbreak capability in every single device. (Not holding my breath.)
- junto 14y agoYour comments are absolutely spot on.
- Pewpewarrows 14y agoPeople tend to conveniently forget that it's the consumers in an economy who define a monopoly. There's nothing inherently wrong with it. If a monopoly occurs because the majority of consumers are giving that product/service their money, then it must be deserving of it. If enough people are dissatisfied with the quality, they'll turn to new business, and the monopoly will cease to exist. The market has and will continue to regulate itself without legislative interference. I see no reason for the government to get involved with Apple's private marketplace. Edit: I'll put it this way: You don't like Apple's closed market because they can define arbitrary rules that makes it hard to compete. How is that any different than a Government defining arbitrary rules on the national marketplace?
- cooldeal 14y ago> If enough people are dissatisfied with the quality, they'll turn to new business, and the monopoly will cease to exist. Wish it were so simple, but the problem is the ecosystem. A new business will not start out with 500K apps and developers won't develop apps till a platform has a lot of users, a chicken-and-egg problem. Users don't like buying devices with only a few apps available. Looks at WebOS, it was a good platform but died. This is not even mentioning the real costs of switching, like not having access to already purchased apps and content because they're locked down(music, movie, ebook purchases). It was a big problem with Windows in the 90s, you had to get a Windows computer to run software needed to be compatible with others.
- api 14y agoPeople get angry about this, but if they do they don't understand what iOS is. iOS is a console platform. Developing for iOS is a bit like developing for XBox, Nintendo, etc. It is a fundamentally different platform from Windows, Linux, and MacOS.
- PythonDeveloper 14y agoPlease.. help me agree with you by naming one game that was on XBOX for YEARS, which was subsequently removed from XBOX because it was too similar to an upcoming, unreleased feature?
- itg 14y agoThe issue here is they used the encryption keys from the leaked ROM. However, Apple should do a better job communicating that.
- guelo 14y agoHow do you know this but the app developer does not?
- lloeki 14y agoWhat is sure is that they include the key. From [0]: > The other major feature in Airfoil Speakers is the new Enhanced Audio Receiving option. With an inexpensive in-app purchase, your iOS device becomes a full-fledged mobile AirPlay receiver! This is only possible with the leaked AirPort ROM private key. As soon as I saw the title on HN I thought that was the most likely cause of the removal. Occam's razor and all. Including the Apple private key in Airfoil Speakers Touch was, if not stupid, at least a very bold move from Rogue Amoeba. [0] http://rogueamoeba.com/utm/2012/04/25/turn-any-ios-device-into-an-airplay-receiver-with-airfoil-speakers-touch-3/ http://rogueamoeba.com/utm/2012/04/25/turn-any-ios-device-in...
- Steko 14y agoAssuming RA included this key and they probably suspect this is the reason but it stands to reason that they can still play dumb and say they haven't been told why the app was yanked. note: followed lloeki's link above into the comments and there's this from RA's Paul Kefasis (italics mine)... "There should be no legal issues here whatsoever. Airfoil Speakers on the Mac and PC has had this receiving functionality for years now, and now it’s on the iOS platform as well. Airfoil Speakers is a clean-room implementation of the AirPlay protocol. Further, as you note, Apple approved the app after review. So, we don’t anticipate any issues here."
- clarky07 14y agoApple has a history of copying some apps, i.e. Instapaper etc, but they don't have a history of removing them afterwards. There could be plenty of perfectly reasonable reasons for this. I'd wait until actually finding out why before accusing them of anticompetitive behavior.
- tobiasbischoff 14y agoDude reverse-engineers Airport Express - steals secret encryption key from ROM. Other dudes use this illegal acquired key to make an app that replicates the function of the original device & submit that to the AppStore of exact that vendor of the device. Somehow it gets thru, now they yank it & anyone really wonders about it?
- btrask 14y agoIt's not illegal. For precendent, see Lexmark International, Inc. v. Static Control Components, Inc. from 2004. Basically, the DMCA does not protect encryption designed purely for vendor lock-in. The Wikipedia has a good overview: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lexmark_Int%27l_v._Static_Control_Components https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Lexmark_Int%27l_v._Static_Cont... Edit: And more broadly, reverse engineering is not a crime.
- tobiasbischoff 14y agoone could discuss if this encryption is for vendor lock in or for preventing someone from dumping the raw-data stream of DRM'emd material. remember the time the airport expresses and airplay for music came to market all music files in the store had fairplay DRM. and while it might not be illegal in all countries, it's clearly against apples terms of use.
- thought_alarm 14y agoAssuming that this functionality is about to become part of AirPlay, what would you have Apple do? Do you have Apple continue to sell this app even though it's about to become a free feature of the OS? Or does Apple not implement this rather logical extension to their existing AirPlay feature simply because someone already wrote a utility to do the same? Both those options are rather lousy for Apple's customers. Any developer who writes a utility to implement some missing feature of the OS understands that their feature probably won't be missing forever.
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoHow is allowing the app to exist a lousy experience for their customers? There is no harm in allowing competing versions of the same feature, especially if the other version was there first and people were using it. I can see rejecting new apps that duplicate existing functionality, but proactively un-approving and pulling apps that implement a feature that might exist later?
- thought_alarm 14y agoYou purchase this app, then the next day Apple announces the same feature built in to the OS. You don't feel ripped off?
- MiguelHudnandez 14y agoNope, I thought it was worth $1 the day before and I would still think it is a nice feature. I'd blame Apple for that for being so opaque or for not including it in the first place. The developer is not the problem in my eyes -- they just made an awesome feature for my phone. Perhaps most customers have a different stance than I do, though.
- thought_alarm 14y agoWell, Apple's saving you the dollar. You can be angry at them for that or not, but it's easy for me to see why they're doing it.
- ChrisLTD 14y agoThe worst part is the lack of information from Apple. If Rogue Amoeba knew what rule their app violated they could be retooling it now. Instead they are in the dark and losing money.
- DigitalSea 14y agoThey remove the and app and oh, what a coincidence iOS 6 has the exact same functionality baked into it. This is one of the issues with the whole closed market thing, Apple can no longer come up original phone features, so they take ideas from popular apps and bake it into their iOS, remove the app they took "inspiration" from and people clap and pat them on the back for being so innovative and introducing a revolutionary new feature.
- chj 14y agoOnly an APP STRIKE can stop this. After all it is the developers that make the App Store prosperous, now they take advantage of the established platform and act like ass hole to the developers. I don't see they will change the behavior if we do nothing but complain.
- fpgeek 14y agoYou're absolutely right that indie developers need to do more than complain if they want Apple to take them seriously. Nevertheless, Apple has formidable tools at their disposal to fight back: ejecting ringleaders, interfering with coordinated action involving their app store (e.g. staggering suspended sales so they didn't all happen on a strike day), ranking penalties and so on.
- droithomme 14y agoThis function will obviously be in the next release, and it's slightly harder for Apple to sell forced upgrades if there is a well designed, intuitive, independent product that maintains backwards compatibility. Therefore the rational MBA type business decision is to leverage the monopoly access to application installation that Apple maintains, and use it to destroy products that threaten even an iota of revenue, no matter what the collateral damage will be.
- beedogs 14y agoApple keeps giving me reasons to jailbreak my phone.