6 ms·
GM collects driver behavior data then sells access to insurance companies
- jjgreen 3y agoAside, but I was surprised to see the (well justified) phrase "pissed off" in a US article, I thought that was a Britishism? [edit] thanks all: TIL ...
- toast0 3y agoNo, that's common in the US. "Taking a piss" as an idiom that means ranting at someone? is not common. If we take a piss, it's just urination.
- ozymandias8 3y agoBrits use “taking _the_ piss”. But they also use “pissed” to mean drunk.
- toast0 3y agoYeah, that's how uncommon it is; I don't even know the right form. Pissed to mean drunk is like depends on your friend group? There's people who might say "i got pissed last night" and I'd be like what were you mad about? But other people I'd accept it as an indication of drinking...
- MikeTheGreat 3y agoHere in the US "taking a piss" means to urinate. Example: "Where's Bob?" "He's in the bathroom, taking a piss"
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- realce 3y ago"Take a piss" and sayings where "Piss" is used as a noun is the Britishism - "Pissed off" seems universal in the English-language world ime
- foobarian 3y agoDoesn't that mean a different thing in the UK? UK: "The line was too long so they pissed off to the pub" US: "They were pissed off because an aggressive driver cut them off"
- jebarker 3y agoNo, it means the same thing in both countries. That UK usage is possibly used by some people but I don't ever recall hearing it in my 30 years there.
- skeeter2020 3y agowhat about "kiss my piss"? is that less common? :)
- jebarker 3y agoI have never heard that in either country!
- jstanley 3y agoIn the UK you'd say "queue" instead of "line", if I'm interpreting the context correctly.
- jjgreen 3y agoUK: They were pissed off that the queue was too long, decided to go out on the piss instead so pissed off to the pub to get pissed.
- vel0city 3y ago"Pissed off" is a pretty common phrase in US English to mean being angry. We tend to not use the other varieties of "pissed" that British and other English speakers would use though. Some examples would be "being pissed" (being drunk) or "taking the piss" (mocking someone).
- BugsJustFindMe 3y ago> GM (and some apologists) will of course proclaim that this is only fair that reckless drivers pay more God it's like the author is intentionally trying to make me not give half a shit about this. It IS fair for reckless drivers to pay more! What the fuck? How would that not be fair? If you care about spying, please talk about the problems with spying in a way that doesn't involve people being freely able to do things that endanger the lives of others. Surely there was a less insane angle to attack this from? But maybe I'm just an apologist.
- tomp 3y agoDoes anyone's insurance go down? If not, it's just an excuse by insurance companies to make more money.
- javawizard 3y agoMine does! The last two renewal cycles my insurance bill has dropped by ~3%. It's not much but it's something. I suspect it has to do with my car getting older and my comprehensive being worth less.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- vel0city 3y agoDo average prices to fix cars go down? Have people generally been driving cheaper or more expensive cars over time? Why would we expect insurance to go down on things more expensive to insure? Taking a quick peek, while insurance rates have been going up for while most insurance companies' margins are pretty similar to their historical margins.
- richwater 3y agoBuilding on top of this, many states limit how much increases can be, which makes it difficult for insurers to respond to quickly changes market forces like we saw in COVID. Labor + Parts became so much more expensive but coverage costs were unable to be increased. https://www.npr.org/2024/03/07/1236504265/auto-insurance-costs-more-everywhere-but-the-problem-is-especially-bad-in-califo https://www.npr.org/2024/03/07/1236504265/auto-insurance-cos...
- btbuildem 3y agoThat's a strongly-worded article! But practically speaking, what can consumers (or consumer orgs) do to fight back? Can I look under the dash, rip out an offending component and stomp on it until it's a pile of shattered debris? Can I hire a hacker to put in workarounds and disable the snitching apps? If the industry have their way, it will soon become illegal to drive without connected telemetry continuously reporting back. And yes, there are such great, positive uses for this type of technology. We could use the logged data to create individual drivers' profiles, and with this, curate personalized guides and training to help them become better drivers. Gamify the experience to give positive feedback and hand out useless awards of Best Driver In Mocktown or whatever.
- JumpCrisscross 3y ago> what can consumers (or consumer orgs) do to fight back? Sue [1]. [1] https://www.freep.com/story/money/cars/general-motors/2024/03/22/gm-data-firms-lexis-nexis/73057931007/ https://www.freep.com/story/money/cars/general-motors/2024/0...
- everyone 3y agoVote with your wallet. Never buy a car that has any of that crap in it.
- boringg 3y agoBut doesn't that crap lower the cost of ownership? I wouldn't buy it -- but isn't that the argument?
- MikeTheGreat 3y agoSerious question: how does one find out if a given car (make/model) has that stuff in it? I'm kinda-sorta thinking about replacing my 2006 car, maybe. The last time I bought a car I definitely didn't have to worry about it spying on me :)
- mortos 3y agoIt's a bad faith argument. I'm not as familiar with the other markets, but this would mean avoiding all Japanese cars. Which is a bad idea if you also want a reliable car and/or value. I'm just familiar with the data collection and the flow of data to insurance companies for JDM cars. A quick look at an EFF article and you should probably also avoid every car manufacturer.
- crazymoka 3y agoDon't forget easy theft. Car manufactures should be held more accountable for how easy it is to steal a car.
- sircastor 3y agoEvery time my insurance renews they try to sell me on plugging something into my OBD2 port so they can gather data on my driving. That’s a hard pass. My insurance has gone up quite a lot, but this is something I don’t want to compromise on. Adjacent to this, in my state I can save ~ $200 on my EV registration if I plug in a tracking dongle to read mileage. For some reason, just reading the odometer difference is not enough.
- zbrozek 3y agoI have yet to hear a good explanation of why the odometer isn't sufficient. Either the cost to manually read is outrageous or there's nefarious secondary purpose.
- floatrock 3y agoAny schlub can slip the tech at your autoshop a $20 to misread the odometer. Need more work to fake a digital reading. This is all around the bigger issue here is how we fund road work: often it's done with a state tax on gasoline sales, so the more you use the roads the more you pay for them. Worked great, reasonably fair, even somewhat punished heavier vehicles (road wear is something more-than-linear to weight, and heavier cars generally need more gas). And then those pesky non-gas electrics came onto the scene. So you now you have a system and a bureaucracy funded by a not-terrible pay-as-you-go tax, and suddenly lots of users don't need the thing your taxing. What's a bureaucracy to do? Well, if you're in a state that thinks EV's are woke propaganda and an existential threat to your truck-based manliness, simple: you charge absurd annual registration fees and say "well, we gotta get the equivalent road tax somehow, so lets do it all at once upfront and ignore any of the equity talk about turning a pay-as-you-go into a massive flat upfront fee because only libtards care about equity." Other states say "alright alright, we can split this registration fee into 4 quarterly installments" and they deal with the extra paperwork of now "keeping your registration up to date" is much more complicated. No sympathies for Orwellian government-must-observe-your-odometer all the time, but I also see how it's a bureaucracy that was built around one system that worked ok struggling to adapt to a new technology.
- mint2 3y agoThat’s not how insurance rates work but okay I see the populist rage appeal of the headline and usually that gets loose with facts. Edit: to clarify, overall rates are set based on the aggregate loss of the overall customer base in each state plus some profit margin. This is the whole pie. Driver characteristics like the car data is used to segment those rates on the individual level so each is a different sized piece of pie but one slice being bigger means another’s are smaller. The actual effect of driving data shouldn’t impact the average rate, only the individual rate with individual increases balanced by individual decreases. So the headline would be just as accurate if it said the sharing is reducing rates. That’s how it works. But yes, not having the data sharing opt-in is unethical. The actual reasons rates are sky rocketing is inflation and increased accident rates. Anyway, care to point out what’s wrong about this comment or is it the standard shoot the messenger type deal?
- ChrisArchitect 3y ago[dupe] More: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40134734 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40134734
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoRelated: Lawsuit accuses GM of sharing drivers' data with insurers without consent https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40134739 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=40134739
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoother lawsuit news from last month: Florida Man Sues G.M. and LexisNexis Over Sale of His Cadillac Data https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/14/technology/gm-lexis-nexis-driving-data.html https://www.nytimes.com/2024/03/14/technology/gm-lexis-nexis... Discussion: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39709991 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39709991
- ChrisArchitect 3y agoFollowed by: General Motors Quits Sharing Driving Behavior with Data Brokers https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39793903 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=39793903
- xyst 3y agoAt a some point, I did opt into this program with an insurance company in exchange for reduced rates. Driving was considered “A” rated but eventually opted out. The $10-12 per month saved was not really worth it. Their tos and privacy policy indicate it would only be used for internal rating and wouldn’t be shared. But wouldn’t be surprised if the data ended up being available to other insurance agencies via a data broker. Wish there was a way to check.
- wil421 3y agoThere is[1], I checked and it was blank. They mailed it to me. https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/request https://consumer.risk.lexisnexis.com/request
- xyst 3y agoThanks, seems to be the primary way most insurance companies share this type of data (accidents, claims). At least I have peace of mind with 1 of these companies.
- joezydeco 3y agoOkay, now do the service bays that sell your odometer reading and service history to CarFax. I had State Farm call me up and say I was exceeding the 10,000 miles per year in my plan so the rate was going up. The car had no telemetry - the dealer sold the data and SF picked it up. The kicker is that I hadn't even gone 10,000 miles yet. They extrapolated the number from an early oil change.
- surfingdino 3y agoNot the only reason why insurance rates are skyrocketing. Cars are expensive and getting more so. Car repair is expensive. Insurers could exert pressure on manufacturers to make cars cheaper, but they are too busy enjoying the profits.
- Scoundreller 3y agoAs a DIY shade tree mechanic, I find car repairs are getting cheaper & easier. New parts are a dog eat dog race to the bottom on margins with more choice than ever, markets for used parts are more liquid than ever and there’s a guide for everything. I can google some vague OBD code (yes, the car will tell you what’s kinda going on!) with my year/model and someone will have a step-by-step guide on “oh, it’s 99% this $11 part, if not, check that”. My own experience with an insurance claim after getting rear ended was this: take it to their preferred shop, or we could choose a licensed autobody shop (they would pay $2800), or cut us a cheque for $1900. We took the cheque and our mechanic fixed it for $950.
- jcpham2 3y agoI’m a hobbyist mechanic and own way too many cars and I agree with your assessment all around. Newer cars are easier and cheaper all-around to fix in terms of parts (maybe labor is higher but it’s doubtful). So if a newer car is cheaper to maintain, why the rising insurance/registration costs for newer vehicles. I own a mix of old sports cars to new SUVs and even a Tesla Model 3. The old cars are cheaper to register so taxed the least yet pollute the most and are the most expensive to maintain in terms of parts. Insurance premiums skew cheaper for older cars too unless it’s an agreed value policy.
- surfingdino 3y agoWas your car still under manufacturer's warranty?
- dawnerd 3y agoAdd in cars being totaled out a lot easier due to "efficiencies" in manufacturing making the cars disposable and of course rising natural disaster events that flood/burn cars.
- freitzkriesler2 3y agoI wonder what happens if you remove or disable the cellular module.
- csours 3y agohttps://www.freep.com/story/money/cars/general-motors/2024/03/22/gm-data-firms-lexis-nexis/73057931007/ https://www.freep.com/story/money/cars/general-motors/2024/0... GM cuts ties with 2 data firms amid heated lawsuit over driver data Published: 1:47 p.m. ET March 22, 2024 Updated: 5:18 p.m. ET March 22, 2024 General Motors said Friday it is severing ties with two data brokers following a lawsuit that connected the automaker to sharing driver data that resulted in higher auto insurance rates for that plaintiff. --- Disclosure: I work for GM, not on this program. I will not be commenting further on this.
- bilsbie 3y agoThe correct answer is stop collecting the data.
- rchaud 3y agoThat's #5 on the list of 5 Standard Excuses, from the 80s politics sitcom Yes Minister. "It was an unfortunate lapse in judgment by an individual party, that has now been dealt with through internal disciplinary procedures". In other words, nothing to worry about, we're squeaky clean again. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Y4PEqvk0Jg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6Y4PEqvk0Jg
- WirelessGigabit 3y agoOnly 2? They could stop sharing it with all!
- deputy 3y ago[deleted]
- mrj 3y agoI was upset about this invasion of my privacy when I found I had been opted into this program somehow -- I would not have accepted it if I knew what it was. I immediately changed that setting in the GM app then requested my info be deleted from GM. Unfortunately, they've already sold it but at least they won't retain it any longer. The article doesn't mention that it's illegal to use this data for insurance in California, happily. Hopefully more governments take that lead. It's fine if people knowingly opt into some insurance program (say), but tricking people into giving away their data for free in a way that they wouldn't benefit from should absolutely be illegal.
- bitcharmer 3y agoI think you're being overly optimistic here. Your data is already out there, and it's reasonable to assume it was not entirely deleted by each organization that got hold of it. There is no way to be sure, really. What's more, companies face little to no repercussions for breaking the law. Most often than not fines are just a fraction of the profit they make off illegal activities.
- mrj 3y agoI'm not optimistic at all, but there is little else I can do. Best case scenario I can prevent the further spread of my data while it bit rots and becomes less useful. I will join the class action that is sure to come out of this, too.
- mmh0000 3y agoI know in some cars you can disable the telemetry system by pulling a fuse. Does anyone know if there is a central resource that has information on how to disable telemetry on common vehicles?