12 ms·
UK's Investigatory Powers Bill to become law despite tech world opposition
- rasengan 3y agoKing Charles has cancer so he won’t have to deal with the backlash of this. It is truly ridiculous that this has become a law in the UK. The internet is weakening and fracturing at intense speed - faster than it grew.
- alephnerd 3y ago> King Charles has cancer so he won’t have to deal with the backlash of this. What backlash? Are you going to go lobby in Westminster? Or hit the street and riot/direct action against it? The reality is most people don't care, and complaining on a forum online does nothing.
- rasengan 3y ago> The reality is most people don't care, and complaining on a forum online does nothing It has to start somewhere. Last time the King faced adversity from the people, it was due to an anonymously distributed pamphlet.
- robxorb 3y ago> complaining on a forum online does nothing. This probably isn't true. Forums are voluminous online and regularly contain such complaints, partly as the anonymity gives people a feeling of being more free to express themselves, versus other types of social group interactions. Given that cohesive and cooperative direct action from organised groups is relatively rare, it could be seen as statistically likely direct action at least sometimes resulted from a group unifying over discussion on a forum.
- switch007 3y agoThe monarch signing a bill in to law is just a formality. Nobody holds them accountable for it. Agree with your other points
- hgyjnbdet 3y agoPretty sure even without cancer Charlie wouldn't be aware of any backlash, even if there was one. His role is ceremonial at best. I agree the law is ridiculous though. I hope big internet companies boycott the UK, speaking as a UK citizen. This law won't catch anyone remotely tech sazzy.
- pch00 3y ago> I hope big internet companies boycott the UK So at least there's a potential bright side for people in the UK :-)
- basisword 3y ago>> King Charles has cancer so he won’t have to deal with the backlash of this. It has nothing to do with him in reality. The monarch has to give ascent to new acts of parliament and by convention always does. They don't (overtly) interfere politically.
- stoobs 3y agoThe government creates these laws, not the reining Monarch. Royal assent is a ceremonial process at this point as the powers to refuse a bill are very, very rarely exercised.
- goodcanadian 3y agoRoyal assent is a ceremonial process at this point as the powers to refuse a bill are very, very rarely exercised. From Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_assent https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Royal_assent): "The last bill that was refused assent was the Scottish Militia Bill during Queen Anne's reign in 1708." Even that was only done on the advice of government ministers who had second thoughts after the bill was passed.
- gnuser 3y ago“Ceremonial” etc: Behind Closed Doors: Oaths to the Monarch (who, by the way, was besties with necro-pedo-murderer Jimmy Saville) Gtfo of here brits - the Irish were on the right side of history and it’s high time for a revolution and you know it’s true!
- adammichaelc 3y agoWhat you say is triggering. Triggered by the darkness. It’s okay to be afraid of the unknown. But it’s also time to take a look within ourselves and see that we are co-creating something. Do we want it? Is this the best we can do as a human race? The Irish people have a bit of luck on their side. They follow their hearts and speak up. The ancient Celtic DNA knows. It’s a magical people, and I mean that in the sense of the Magi; enlightened men and women of knowledge who brought the sciences and the arts to humanity. The Irish were conquered, but the power and wisdom within the DNA cannot be conquered. It’s all within. Like an ancient quantum computer. It sits. Waiting to be tapped by the brave one who dares to look outside the program.
- dogleash 3y ago> The internet is weakening and fracturing at intense speed - faster than it grew. The writing was on the wall a decade ago. You'll get Cable TV 2.0 and you'll like it. An army of sycophants and chumps are working to ensure it.
- cynicalsecurity 3y agoIs anyone still surprised the UK doesn't respect the privacy of their citizens? If the UK still was in the EU, this would have never happened.
- switch007 3y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_of_Investigatory_Powers_Act_2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Regulation_of_Investigatory_Po... We were in the EU in 2000 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigatory_Powers_Act_2016 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Investigatory_Powers_Act_2016 And in 2016
- echelon_musk 3y agoRIPA 2016 was to legalise practices exposed by Snowden. The "regulation" part in the title is just newspeak smokescreen. They regulated themselves.
- basisword 3y ago>> If the UK still was in the EU, this would have never happened. I wouldn't be so sure about that. The original act passed in 2016 and was already an abomination.
- Symbiote 3y agoThe EU court ruled against this law in 2020: https://www.blueprintforfreespeech.net/en/news/eu-court-rules-users-data-cant-be-collected-by-isps-for-surveillance https://www.blueprintforfreespeech.net/en/news/eu-court-rule...
- tgv 3y agoIndeed. A state can pass whatever legislation, but it's not the highest authority in EU member states. States still have to obey the various agreements, treaties and rulings, although enforcing that falls back onto the member states themselves. So a sufficiently determined government (Poland/PiS, Hungary) can still get away with a lot.
- EGreg 3y agoLest you think it's just the UK, we have such laws in USA now making their way through Congress, and already in place around the world: https://community.qbix.com/t/the-global-war-on-end-to-end-encryption/214 https://community.qbix.com/t/the-global-war-on-end-to-end-en...
- anonzzzies 3y agoIt’s just a matter of time for it to happen everywhere unfortunately: it’s possible, it’s easy, most people don’t know or care or understand, so keep trying and it’ll happen.
- chrisfinazzo 3y agoShort of a law that forbids the math which makes encryption possible, this is noise. Wake me up when there's an actual threat to privacy in... (checks notes........) OH WAIT The heat death of the Universe will come first -- Carry on, nothing to see here...
- kmeisthax 3y agohttps://xkcd.com/538/ https://xkcd.com/538/
- tivert 3y ago> Short of a law that forbids the math which makes encryption possible, this is noise. So your "solution" is to break the law and suffer the consequences? I think you misunderstand law. It's not about making things impossible, it's about making possible things unappealing so you won't do them.
- chrisfinazzo 3y agoIt’s impossible to break laws that are impractical and unenforceable? That’s cute.
- tivert 3y ago
- deadbabe 3y agoTruly, I believe we live in the medieval era of the technological adoption curve. Such laws should be seen as barbaric by future governments.
- graemep 3y ago> the medieval era You mean the era in which we got things like the Magna Carta, rights of due process, habeas corpus, the gradual abolition of slavery (at least in western Europe), the gradual transfer of power from monarchs to parliaments etc. I think our direction of travel is a lot worse now!
- jjgreen 3y ago... we got things like the Magna Carta Did she die in vain?
- sandbags 3y agoBrave Hungarian peasant girl that she was.
- ben_w 3y agoMagna Carta, which was about the relationship between a king and his own feudal lords, which was violated by both sides and annulled by Pope Innocent III, leading to the First Barons' War — one of the many UK civil wars besides the one commonly known by the title "The" Civil War? > the gradual abolition of slavery (at least in western Europe) Even with that caveat, didn't that really only happen after the medieval era?
- graemep 3y ago> Magna Carta, which was about the relationship between a king and his own feudal lords. Among other things. Some important bits applied more widely, such as the right to a fair trial which applied to any "free man". It was a also a recognition of existing law that had developed earlier. > Even with that caveat, didn't that really only happen after the medieval era? No, slavery declined in medieval times, and was abolished in England by the Normans around the 11th/12th century. Serfdom continued but serfs were not chattel slaves (they could not be traded) and has rights. European participation in the slave trade revived in early modern times, in and between colonies. Slaver was not revived in Europe itself.
- cjk2 3y agoOh brilliant, I am sure our utterly fucking incompetent and inept security services having more data will lead to better outcomes. choke Salman Abedi choke. (for anyone not in the UK, he was already well known to the security services [MI5] and managed to kill 22 people in a suicide bombing)
- Akronymus 3y agoIf I had a buck for every time someone like that was "known to the authorities" I'd have quite a bit of money. This is a pretty blatant power grab, rather than anything actually positive.
- echelon_musk 3y agoInstead of admitting blame failures are used to increase budgets. The simple arguments of "we didn't have enough funding" or "we weren't allowed to collect more data" will be used. More tax payer money is then spent to cement power through mass surveillance and the cycle repeats.
- balderdash 3y agoIt’s all about competence - it’s why a couple have of competent programmers can stand up and website/program/app for orders of magnitude less time and money than government or large corporate IT can. I’m sure the same is true in law enforcement / intelligence, more power/money is simply the crutch for the incompetent to be more productive
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- tgv 3y agoOTOH, new mass surveillance in combination with optimistic use of new tech will lead to ruining thousands of innocent lives. It's as if they thought that the Horizon scandal was just a bit of bad publicity for a good idea.
- francis-io 3y ago"Additional safeguards have been introduced – notably, in the most recent round of amendments, a 'triple-lock' authorization process for surveillance of parliamentarians ..." Thank god, I'm glad the politicians that passed this law will be protected from it /s
- kmeisthax 3y agoI bet you in 10 years there will be a scandal where the Tories spied on an opposing party MP, or vice versa. Doesn't even need malicious intent because the mere act of doing this carries the stench of malicious incompetence.
- BoxOfRain 3y agoIt brings to mind the fact the Inner Party of Oceania had the privilege of turning their telescreens off.
- causal 3y agoThis, and requiring tech companies to consult the government before rolling out security updates, make it seem evident that safety isn't really the motivation.
- kypro 3y agoI'm a cool headed person, but reading that sentence was rage inducing for me. There's literally no good argument to protect politicians other than corruption. If politicians are worried these powers could be used to target them then it could be used to target literally anyone, and the concern shouldn't have been that they could be target, but that anyone could be targeted. Plus, if this bill is only going to stop bad guys then they should have anything to worry about anyway right? I mean isn't this what we are told!? Should we be worried about these powers being abused or not!? What a fucking joke.
- hogepiyo 3y agoUK leading the way on this draconian bullshit as usual. You know its bad when your hope rests on big tech throwing down the gauntlet.
- cjk2 3y agoWe do indeed lead the way in draconian bullshit. We also lead the way in making it utterly unworkable and useless through incompetence, cost cutting and cases getting shot down by ECHR though. Think of us as an example to the rest of the world on how to do a shitty job of consultation, legislation and implementation!
- kwhitefoot 3y ago> cases getting shot down by ECHR though. Weren't the Tories going to get the UK out of the European Convention on Human Rights? And thus remove the possibility of appealing the the European Court of Human Rights.
- cjk2 3y agoYes they are. They have a valid point leaving it regarding immigration, but the side effects of it are far more advantageous to them personally and this is not being discussed.
- xyst 3y agoUSA is not too far behind. FISA was reauthorized despite outcry from many people. https://archive.is/3vKoO https://archive.is/3vKoO In a post-911 world, the people leading this country still leading by fear.
- A_D_E_P_T 3y agoThe UK government seems hell-bent on the control and micromanagement of its own population. Their recent smoking ban -- which is sure to make cigarette smoking cool again with young people -- was a joke. This hyper-surveillance measure is a lot less funny.
- FredPret 3y agoSometimes, when I read the news, I can hear the theme music to Deus Ex
- yoyohello13 3y agoI’ve been playing cyberpunk recently and I can’t help the feeing of “this is just our current world with more biotech.”
- trinsic2 3y agoI'm actually reminded of the movie Children of Men, which seems much more of a realistic view of a dystopian landscape in UK over the next 20-50 years.
- logicchains 3y agoOr V for Vendetta, we're practically already there.
- 3y ago
- SillyUsername 3y agoTor is about to become a lot more mainstream in the UK.
- azalemeth 3y agoHonestly, although VPNs get a bad rep, there's (in my opinion) a good argument for using one here on privacy grounds. Use two or three-hop routing to frustrate correlation attacks, route your entire internet traffic to one or two other places chosen at random, use DNScrypt / DOH and have the freedom to choose who gets to slurp your data -- and the ability to change them easily. Mullvad's move towards open firmware, diskless servers, and proving verifiability to end users is something I can get towards. [C.f. https://mullvad.net/en/blog/system-transparency-future https://mullvad.net/en/blog/system-transparency-future] I'm sure nothing wrong will happen with delaying security updates if they ever actually use that clause...
- Eisenstein 3y agoAs a bonus you get to fill out 500 captchas every day.
- londons_explore 3y agoI have little confidence in the security of TOR. I believe any competent adversary can do packet timing correlation attacks, and it turns out just 30 seconds of web browsing gives enough timing data to narrow down to just 1 tor user, since the tor userbase is fairly small. I'm guessing there are ~10 nation states who can deanonymize tor, and I strongly suspect the UK is on that list.
- tetris11 3y agoref for the timing attacks, please
- hazeii 3y agoCheck out VPN's in Australia (Australian citizen currently in the UK)
- Lio 3y agoAs far as I can tell most UK media has hardly covered this. It's sad but expected that the BBC have ignored this.
- cjk2 3y agoThey probably don't want to draw attention to the fact that they use RIPA legislation to catch TV license evaders.
- deepsun 3y agoI don't understand, if BBC is a government agency, why cannot they be sponsored from taxes? Why the hassle of TV licences?
- lozenge 3y agoHistory. It was a way of letting people who don't have TVs not pay a license. There was also an extra charge for colour TVs. Edit: Oh, the BBC isn't a government agency, it's operationally independent. But always becoming less so, as the board is mostly appointed by the government now.
- bpye 3y agoA black and white TV license is still cheaper than colour, £57 vs £169.50.
- TillE 3y agoMostly for dumb historical reasons, currently justified as slightly protecting them from the government cutting their funding. Objectively European TV licenses are just a terrible wasteful idea, basically creating an entire parallel tax collection system. Of all the important, vital things a government funds, I'm not sure why a public broadcaster should have any special insulation from the usual democratic decision making.
- ben_w 3y ago
- stranded22 3y agoWhat are people's thoughts around vpns for select devices at home for nafarious activity? So most traffic goes through open net, and tv (for example) goes through a privacy first vpn provider with an exit in, say, Switzerland. And Proton mail for a small amount of email with the rest via apple. Essentially - would it be less of a flag. And would they even care about a bit of streaming
- azalemeth 3y agoI do this the other way around. All my traffic goes through a privacy-first multi-hop VPN provider, and data from things I don't trust and don't care about (set-top boxes, smart TVs [which I detest!], games consoles, house guests, etc) goes through the clearnet and provides a reasonable degree of cover. Literally everything else gets onion routed to some degree, to frustrate correlation analysis. I know that TOR users are logged specifically; I don't know about VPNs directly. All I want is for people to not spy on me. I'm not a criminal and I do nothing wrong(!) -- apparently an impossibly hard ask! Something someone on HN might be able to answer is this: is there a reason why you couldn't try to configure Wireguard to have a constant bandwidth mode? Continually transmit UDP packets and again frustrate timing or correlation analysis -- if every client spoke to the server on one of a predetermined number of speeds continually then the burstlike connections coming from that server to a potentially identity leaking service (e.g. gmail.com) could not easily be correlated with the origin of the traffic. I imagine that would make it easier to have some stronger degree of privacy protection in aggregate.
- tomxor 3y agoInteresting idea. It would only be effective against timing analysis if all clients connected to the wg server use this constant bandwidth mode (otherwise your traffic could be identified through negative correlation against other connections). It would also have to be aggressively rate limited to make it practical for anything with a battery over wifi, even a constant 2Mbit is not ideal for wifi and will cause a lot of battery drain since radios are most efficient when they can do burst communication. Or maybe it could be limited to bursts at some interval for better bandwidth, or better efficiency (but not both)... that would also make it easier to manage the traffic since it's no longer real-time. I doubt there is any way to configure wireguard to behave like this, it has quite a specific purpose and wireguard's design focus is performance and security rather than obfuscation from traffic analysis. Maybe it's not necessary to modify WG if the traffic can be manipulated just before the WG interface... [edit] Talking of timing analysis, this was the side channel in specter/meltdown that was demonstrated to extract cryptographic keys from JS in the browser. Browser responded by just lowering the resolution of JS timers and introducing noise. Maybe this would also be sufficient for a wireguard connection at the cost of slightly worse latency performance. The tricky part is how the timing resolution would be tied to activity on the WG server, i.e you would need the packets to be spread out further and further the less activity there is on the server, so you actually end up with better performance the busier the server is. It would also come at a performance cost to routing which would be forced to hold on to packets artificially.
- csmattryder 3y ago> "These changes mean that not only will our citizens be better protected from serious dangers such as terrorism and child sexual abuse online [...]" Sometimes you just love it when the band knock out one of their classics.
- Silhouette 3y agoThe Conservatives who have been in government for a long time will most likely lose a general election within a year so we should also be looking at the opposition Labour party's views on this kind of legislation. Perhaps surprisingly given they are currently led by a former human rights lawyer the Labour side also seem to be authoritarian when it comes to technology and surveillance.
- dmix 3y ago> Perhaps surprisingly given they are currently led by a former human rights lawyer the Labour side also seem to be authoritarian That distinction was lost long ago in the west. Canada's left wing liberals/NDP are doing it under the guise of hate speech and protecting kids: https://globalnews.ca/news/10317040/online-harms-bill-canada/amp/ https://globalnews.ca/news/10317040/online-harms-bill-canada... Conservatives more stereotypically spin it for national security/terrorism. But it will come in some form or the other each administration like clockwork. Generally it seems the intelligence services get a free pass from the entire political class on all sides, regardless of pretence, as we've seen in every Five Eyes countries, including Australia.
- walthamstow 3y ago> Additional safeguards have been introduced – notably, in the most recent round of amendments, a 'triple-lock' authorization process for surveillance of parliamentarians Ah yes they've introduced some safeguards. Whom do they safeguard? Themselves!
- chaz6 3y agoI have forewarned my employer that if this bill passes I will be considering my position as I am idealogically opposed to being forced to comply with state surveillance.
- kypro 3y agoI wish there were more people like you. Big respect for this.
- hollow-moe 3y agoUnfortunately, someone not like them will happily take the job, possibly with a lower pay as bonus.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pacifika 3y agoThe possibility of state surveillance, I think that is a distinction worth making.
- smashah 3y agoIt's funny how our next PM will be the person who let off Jimmy Saville yet this bill claims to care about CSAM (signed into law by the brother of a known peadophile). 1st amendment is being killed in America, privacy rights are being killed in the UK. Freedom? Democracy? Will of the people? Lol.
- Dig1t 3y ago>"Additional safeguards have been introduced – notably, in the most recent round of amendments, a 'triple-lock' authorization process for surveillance of parliamentarians What does this mean exactly? I'm not familiar with UK government terminology.
- fullspectrumdev 3y agoIt means spying on members of parliament requires a significantly higher level of authorisation than spying on a normal citizen. One law for them, another for us.
- denton-scratch 3y agoThat clause stood out to me too. This sounds like a huge step back towards Spycatcher territory, where MI5 thought it was their job to undermine the Labour Party, because they were all communists.
- BriggyDwiggs42 3y agoThat is utterly mindblowing. Parliamentarians should be more closely surveilled if the concern is national security.
- roody15 3y agoThe older I get the more I see these bills and trends are really based on economics. Politics is more a less a controlled narrative to maintain this style of wealth distribution. The wealthy elite class draws most of its income by exploiting labor. This is done in a variety of ways but essentially most UK Billionaires make their money in private equity (over half.. same in US)... which really means they don't actually do much real labor. Instead they need to extract wealth which often means creating a system where people's labor is exploited. To keep this system in check a control of the narrative is required so you can keep a lower class of workers "occupied" so they don't wise up to the reality of the situation. One common theme is fear.. war on terror, axis of evil states.. some sort of plague..Y2K.. you can probably pull up many themes from the past. The other theme is divide by culture.... you see this today with gender issues.. gay rights, etc. For example in most modern western states... the vast majority of citizens don't really care if people are gay .. they may or may not approve personally but honestly don't mind what people do with their private lives etc... So the narrative has to flipped and made more extreme ..it doesn't matter the issue it has to something that gets people riled up enough that they don't have much mental or emotion energy left to focus on the small group that is exploiting their labor. (So gender issue has to get extreme to the point where we talk about surgical altering children for example) Notice both parties... somehow keep migrants flowing into Europe (and US).. Almost like pressure needs to be kept on keeping wages low. In the US the federal reserve openly states this as the goal ..(https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/us-federal-reserve-says-its-goal-is-to-get-wages-down https://canadiandimension.com/articles/view/us-federal-reser...). Little coverage is given to this and instead a strange spin is attached on how somehow the worker class will actually benefit by being paid less. This is the same with survelliance bills. We must keep an eye on the worker class to make sure they don't organize and wise up to the reality of their situation. My two cents
- mrandish 3y agoWhen I was kid I read Bradbury, Asimov, Clarke and Heinlein while dreaming of how by the time I was "old", I'd for sure be living in a sci-fi future. Humans had landed on the moon only the decade before, NASA had launched Skylab (a REAL space station) and was developing a space shuttle that could go to orbit anytime. Personal computers with modems were actually a thing in stores. Sadly, I now realize I was correct except that I was reading the wrong sci-fi authors. I should have been reading Orwell and Huxley.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cantagi 3y agoUK resident here. The original version gave me the push I needed to get a rPi 2B+, subscribe to a VPN, and use it as a wifi AP that routes all traffic from my house through it. Can you trust a VPN who say they don't log? No, but more so than an ISP who might be legally required to at any moment without you ever finding out. Also, I will now never start a tech company in the UK, and this is because I will never put myself into a position where I am forced to add backdoors to a product.
- will0 3y agoDo you exit the vpn in the UK, or somewhere else?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- akomtu 3y agoUK is a dying state, like the Roman empire, once mighty, now is a small tourist destination. When the good will leaves a nation to its own devices, what's left is a disorganized group of men and women held together by tyranny of a dying dragon of bureaucracy. That bureaucracy doesn't know how to keep a nation prosper, and all it cares about is self-preservation by any means possible.
- EVa5I7bHFq9mnYK 3y agoTourist and money laundering destination.