5 ms·
Updating California's grid for EVs may cost up to $20B
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoBad headline. Not only are the costs spread over decades, the extra sales of electricity (replacing fuel sales) cover the cost of the upgrade, while lowering the per unit cost of electricity. They mention this in the article so there's no real excuse other than clickbaiting.
- floatrock 3y agoIt's also more of a range. > Li and Jenn came up with a range of anywhere between $6 billion and $20 billion
- krallja 3y agoIn addition to that, spreading the costs evenly across the 40 million residents of California, it’s a whopping $500 per person. Not exactly cheap, but also not a political nightmare to find the funding.
- lazide 3y agoKeep in mind, many areas of California already have absurd electrical pricing and rising ($.50+/kwh) and everyone was promised a long time already that there would not need to be grid upgrades to support EV’s. Which was transparent BS. So here we are again, likely going to get more out of proportion increases due to things that were promised to not be needed.
- bombcar 3y agoThere was a short time where people were making an argument (and it wasn't entirely impossible, either) that on-home solar would "balance out" EV charging so that the overall increased load on the grid would be minimal. That didn't pan out for various reasons.
- lazide 3y agoI remember many of these pronouncements recently being during rolling brownout/blackouts due to high loads in summer AND after PG&E had stopped providing decent pricing for infeed from home solar systems. I agree that some of the discussion was before the BS was apparent, but a lot of it was well after it was obviously not how this was going to work. Still possible (if in a setup with good insolation!) to provision your own home solar setup and charge off that - and high income folks, it would likely pay off pretty quickly due to the current insane rates - but then that’s why the utility companies seem dead set on trying to stop it too.
- bombcar 3y agoWhat I've seen is that where it used to be quite worth connecting to the grid and "feeding back" because you'd get paid the current retail price, now it is complicated enough and paid little enough that many people just don't bother feeding back at all.
- lazide 3y agoYeah, it was part of the short term incentives to get people to roll out solar. Now they pay wholesale prices when buying it back (often zero or even negative during peak insolation) and charge retail when selling it - any by retail I mean ‘crazy high usage based numbers which make no sense’. I know a bunch of folks which installed solar themselves to cover their AC costs because the utility still charges crazy high rates during peak insolation - even while they are having to load shed - and their electric bill dropped to almost nothing afterwards. They didn’t even need batteries.
- ericmcornelius 3y agoFor starters - many of the utilities charge more for daytime and "peak" usage hours in the TOU plans. Which is also when they're overproducing solar and having to shed load. But hey, no sense looking for logic here.
- lazide 3y ago
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoThe PV is about ~$300 per person (when spread out over decades). You're fighting a losing battle living in California if you're going to complain about spending ~$0.03 per day to have electric cars...
- lazide 3y agoThat’s the claim, right now. Originally it was $0. I left California awhile ago. My current (peak) electrical rates are less than $.15/kwh, and i’m not far from the border though.
- seanmcdirmid 3y agoWho ever claimed $0? I get why you left California. Up here in Seattle we pay 10-13 cents? But I probably wouldn’t notice much if we paid 50 cents.
- lazide 3y agoPre ~ 2023 the party line was 'we don't need to do anything in generation/distribution infrastructure, we just need to roll out more chargers'. With hints or even promises of REDUCED electric rates, not increased rates. Search seems to be prioritizing more recent articles, so harder to find references, but there are plenty out there. I remember reading dozens of articles at the time which all insisted that costs would stay the same or go down, and we didn't need to make more generation capacity because EV use would never be a meaningful portion of electrical demand. "In addition, by including new rate structures in the pilot programs, California may be able to shift load in ways that defers expensive new generation or transmissions assets. This remains to be seen, but could result in lower rates overall." [https://www.csis.org/analysis/utility-involvement-electric-vehicle-charging-infrastructure-california-vanguard https://www.csis.org/analysis/utility-involvement-electric-v...] Here is the California Legislative bill passed on the topic in 2022 - and the focus is on building more chargers. [https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml?bill_id=202120220AB2700 https://leginfo.legislature.ca.gov/faces/billNavClient.xhtml...] Here is also the mandate to increase more charging infrastructure too, and assess effectiveness. [https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/reports/electric-vehicle-charging-infrastructure-assessment-ab-2127 https://www.energy.ca.gov/data-reports/reports/electric-vehi...] By 2022, they were trying to get folks to switch to grid controlled charging [https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/ev-charging/new-california-rule-will-cut-costs-of-home-ev-charging https://www.canarymedia.com/articles/ev-charging/new-califor...] which is a bit crazy for the end consumer, and could even be a large scale safety issue. Essentially centralized rationing. In 2023 is when supply/demand issues got so obvious that people started to call BS [https://calmatters.org/environment/2023/01/california-electric-cars-grid/ https://calmatters.org/environment/2023/01/california-electr...]. Notably, around then is also when the Diablo Canyon nuclear plant decommissioning got canned (despite it being past it's design life, with known and expensive to remediate radiation leaks). Seattle doesn't need AC, but a lot of housing does have electric baseboard heating. Those folks would definitely notice if electricity ~quadrupled in cost!
- rqtwteye 3y agoThat's the latest trick in news reporting these days. Sometimes they report the total cost, sometimes the yearly cost, sometimes over ten years. I guess that's part of the effort to make numbers have an emotional effect while making them hard to compare. School buses, football fields, width of a hair, elephants and so on, 2/3rds vs 66%. Most people have no idea how to compare them.
- 7e 3y agoTwenty billion dollars is 20,000 clean hydrogen refueling stations.
- NewJazz 3y agoMhm then how much to transport fuel to all those stations?
- fsckboy 3y agocan still do that after electric doesn't pan out
- infecto 3y agoHyrdogen cars are DOA.
- toomuchtodo 3y agoToo late. https://electrek.co/2024/04/19/dc-fast-charging-station-for-every-15-gas-stations/ https://electrek.co/2024/04/19/dc-fast-charging-station-for-... ("The US now has 1 DC fast charging station for every 15 gas stations") https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/electricity-locations https://afdc.energy.gov/fuels/electricity-locations https://supercharge.info/map https://supercharge.info/map https://web.archive.org/web/20240425142724/https://www.whitehouse.gov/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/figure1.png https://web.archive.org/web/20240425142724/https://www.white...
- eagerpace 3y agoI feel like this thought pattern just assumes all electrical generation will be done the same way as always, from a central source. Two big things are already happening to change this paradigm though. 1) Batteries are allowing us to transmit energy asynchronously 2) Distributed generation with solar “The grid” needs updates for sure, but it doesn’t need 10x capacity increase. That’s just fud.
- infecto 3y agoWhat does it mean to "transmit energy asynchronously"?
- bittercynic 3y agoTransmit the energy when it's cheap, instead of at the moment it's going to be used.
- infecto 3y agoasync is a strange choice but perhaps the closest equivalent from a software vernacular. time-shifted energy transmission/generation.
- glitchc 3y agoBatteries managed by individual users will never replace big infra. They are simply not resilient enough. This kind of logic is akin to saying mesh networks are all we need to deliver reliable internet to everyone. No, CTTH, FTTH or satellite is what we need to deliver reliable internet to everyone, and those require big infra. Furthermore, to a point in the article that folks on Ars are spouting, if everyone is charging during off-peak hours, then those aren't off-peak any more. They're now on-peak hours. Grids are required to deliver steady reliable power even under peak usage. 10x is likely an underestimation of how much extra capacity we will need if everyone switches to EVs.
- eagerpace 3y agoUnder the current rules, yeah, but the rules and how we think about this need to change too. For example in my state the process for selling energy back to the grid from a residential account is extremely limited and had a capped number of users. Batteries aren’t resilient enough today but they have grown leaps and bounds over the last few years. New chemistries and ways of controlling them are making all kind of new possibilities. As much as I don’t like some of the rules in CA the requirement for solar on new builds is brilliant. The hardware has become so cheap and rolling the labor and design into the initial construction means a short pay back period.
- bushbaba 3y agoThat’s not that bad when you consider the cost of oil and gas infrastructure
- floatrock 3y agoThat's a big scary number to your average California taxpayer. What's frustrating about these articles is there's no talk of what's on the other side of the scale. What's the cost of doing nothing (and presumably stifling the rise of EV's so we can do nothing)? Continued dependency on fossil fuels (and the associated oil infrastructure, health, and the you know, global existential stuff), and the occasional transmission line hook failing from severe wear, dropping the line, and burning down a good chunk of the state. On the other hand, presumably if you're upgrading the transmission lines, you're going to replace those 80-year-old worn down hooks at the same time. I don't like using grid update subsidies to bail out corporate malfeasance on negligently-deferred maintenance, but pragmatically, how many Paradise's is 6-20B worth?
- jeffbee 3y agoThere are alternatives beyond "do nothing". For example, reducing vehicle-mile demand through better development patterns, or widespread adoption of the dramatically more efficient electric bicycle.
- oefrha 3y agoSimply spending $20B is like at least two orders of magnitude easier than any of your proposed alternatives in this country.
- Tagbert 3y agowhy don't we just build giant Arcologies and move everyone into them. easy. /s
- rickydroll 3y agoA terrestrial version of Ark B??
- jeffbee 3y agoConverting the state to EVs also costs 100x more than $20 billion because you are ignoring the trillions it will cost to replace the ICE fleet.
- wcunning 3y agoCurrent lack-of-supply causing increased cost and delays in just about every single major grid interconnect/hookup/switching component would indicate that the present day cost of the upgrade is not likely to be fully correct. I'm a little too lazy to grab the link, but for context listen to an episode of Odd Lots from Bloomberg from a week or two ago about issues facing property developers all over the sunbelt getting switch gears and transformers for new commercial multi-tenant buildings. The combination of EV charging stations and AI data centers is making grid upgrades more than double their previous decade growth trends, which is throwing power companies and electrical infrastructure component manufacturers for a loop and they're not bringing supply online nearly fast enough, particularly in light of complex grid rollouts like all the renewable that CA is requiring by law. Combine that with a general lack-of-supply of the skilled labor necessary (linesmen and electricians with high voltage/commercial training and experience) and you won't see it happen on time or in budget. Also, for comparison, grid upgrades require a certain amount of new infrastructure installation in places without current right-of-way, which has gone particularly poorly for the high speed rail out there, so I would be willing to take a bet that this follows a similar growth curve of at least tripling the high end estimate.
- ericmcornelius 3y agoPG&E CEO pay was $9.3 million in 2018, $18.5 million in 2019, $6.2 million in 2020, $51.2 million in 2021, $14.1 million in 2022 and $17 million in 2023. Just sayin.
- jeffbee 3y agoIf you think that is a lot, you're never going to believe how much 30 million EVs would cost.
- AdamN 3y agoThere's no comparison of how much grid improvements would cost without EVs so I don't know if $20B is alot. California has 5th highest GDP in the world at $3.9T so .5% if all that money was spent in one year but actually over a decade it's .05%.
- bdcravens 3y agoSounds big by itself. However, this is spread over time, and the *annual* budget for transportation in California is $33B
- bryanlarsen 3y agoAnd the cost of updating California's grid to support the increased use of air conditioning is also $20B.
- photochemsyn 3y agoDetails: > "Paying for the necessary upgrades will be pricey, but there's a lot of uncertainty here. Li and Jenn came up with a range of anywhere between $6 billion and $20 billion. They put this in context in two ways. The total capital invested in the existing grid is estimated to be $51 billion, so the cost of updating it could be well over a third of its total value. At the same time, the costs will be spread out over decades and only total up to (at most) three times the grid's annual operation and maintenance costs. So in any one year, the costs shouldn't be crippling." There's no doubt that switching from a primarily fossil fuel-based transportation system to an electricity-based one is going to be expensive, but good transportation systems have positive knock-on effects on economic growth, and the side effects - cleaner air, independence from fossil fuel price swings, etc - are more than worth the investment. In contrast, giving $100 billion away to finance endless war in Europe and the Middle East - after dumping well over $1 trillion on Iraq and Afghanistan (pre-debt-interest) - is just a recipe for long-term economic decline. This is why China is an economic success story - they built a national high-speed rail network, the world's best, while the US was playing at imperial neocolonialism.
- tristanb 3y agoCool - just roll that into the next monthly 600% PG&E rate increase.
- NeoTar 3y agoAlthough the headline isn't great, the article does do what I've been taught to do by the BBC's More-or-Less programme, and ask 'is this a big number'. It's very easy to not comprehend big figures, so there are a few techniques to make them relatable - bring it down to the cost of an individual and/or per year, and to compare to other costs. Here they have chosen to compare it to the existing cost of the grid, and the existing maintenance and operation costs, but which seems like a good comparison (if you haven't read the article, it's about one third of the cost of the existing grid, or about three times the annual operation/maintenance costs) An alternative would be to say it's a cost of about 500 USD per Californian, or about 50 USD/year which isn't nothing, but doesn't feel like an outrageous figure.
- sahaskatta 3y agoBelieve it or not, there are a lot of opportunity to solve a lot of these challenges with software. https://smartcar.com/blog/electric-vehicles-power-grid https://smartcar.com/blog/electric-vehicles-power-grid https://smartcar.com/blog/what-increasing-power-outages-tell-us-about-grid-modernization https://smartcar.com/blog/what-increasing-power-outages-tell... Disclosure: I work for Smartcar and my company has a small role in the greater efforts solving these challenges with APIs.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoActual paper (edit, nope previous paper on similar topic by same authors): https://evs36.com/wp-content/uploads/finalpapers/FinalPaper_Li_Yanning.pdf https://evs36.com/wp-content/uploads/finalpapers/FinalPaper_... edit 2: the actual paper https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2317599121 https://www.pnas.org/doi/10.1073/pnas.2317599121
- throwaway22032 3y agoIs this actually a cost? At some time in the future oil prices will eventually tend towards infinity, at some point before then it'll be 200, 500, 1000 a barrel. At that point the grid upgrade and EV transition will be a huge cost saving. It's just investing for later, surely?
- davedx 3y agoSame thing in Europe. Governments are getting involved providing bridge financing to grid operators so the upgrades are done on time - or at least, less late. Bit of a failure of planning though
- djsudysgcc 3y ago$20B? That’s it? 13 million households in CA. $1500/household. $9/month electric utility surcharge for 30 years at 6%. Hardly noticeable.