10 ms·
Tribler: An attack-resilient micro-economy for media
- synctext 3y agoTribler founding professor here, AMA. 2x on HN frontpage! Most attention we had during 18 years of coding.
- troyvit 3y agoHow well would tribbler work for disseminating content, such as a documentary, that might get a person jailed if they put it out on more mainstream social media?
- synctext 3y agoWhistleblowing documentary spreading in Europe or upper Americas might go OK with solid operational measures such as open wifi war driving, etc. China, Russia, etc: nope.
- CapitalTntcls 3y agoHi, I'm curious about your alternative model for capitalism. How does it aim to change the logic of capital accumulation? Since companies are driven by profit, the entire system revolves around capital growth and competition, which ultimately leads to the emergence of monopolies and billionaires. How does your model address these issues?
- synctext 3y agoWe simply iterate on Linux and Wikipedia work. The principle we hope will work is to out-compete abusive platforms. Textbooks say capitalism requires realistic future profit and growth. The goal is to show Wall Street that profitability of Big Tech advertisement model is doomed. Forming non-profit collectives we aim to organise alternatives which are superior to existing offerings. So you still end up with a monopoly, just under democratic governance. This is in-line with the thinking at European Commission level, DG Grow [0]. We are trying to invent the tech to form digital collectives which scale beyond millions. Very hard. Plus collective decision making. Then you have self-sovereign citizens owning these collectives, not markets. By design Tribler is self-organising and self-scaling. We have build a DAO using shared Bitcoin capital [1] with one extension using fancy crypto based on FROST [2]. [0] https://etendering.ted.europa.eu/cft/cft-display.html?cftId=15777 https://etendering.ted.europa.eu/cft/cft-display.html?cftId=... [1] https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3565383.3566112 https://dl.acm.org/doi/pdf/10.1145/3565383.3566112 [2] https://repository.tudelft.nl/islandora/object/uuid:f45f85a0-b634-43d9-bd18-2bd9398d2c13/datastream/OBJ/download https://repository.tudelft.nl/islandora/object/uuid:f45f85a0...
- azinman2 3y agoIf advertising model is doomed (so far all the signs suggest otherwise), wouldn’t “big tech” just adjust models? What makes you think they just go away? I’m not sure why technology is the “solution” to an alternative… people seem to just want good content delivered well. Content creators want to make as much money as possible. And that’s for “honest” content… the internet is filled with disinformation and people trying to spread conspiracies, recruit for X, or otherwise mass influence the entire population. How a decentralized Bitcoin based model magically get us amazing content, something people want to use, and minimization of negative forces? Why is technology the key issue?
- synctext 3y agoIndeed, its not about the tech. Changing the business model is key. It might be hard to re-imagine the content industry without the current monopolists. Linux showed how disruptive an open model can be. See here a description + full implementation of a music industry based on Creative Commons content. Artists release their music and receive direct Bitcoin donations from fans. 100% artists, 0% music label, 0% Big Tech, 0% credit card fee. It's a Bitcoin DAO with Spotify-inspired music discovery. [1] https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/files/11814767/First.Deployed.DAO.with.True.Full.Decentralisation.pdf https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/files/11814767/First.Depl...
- stcredzero 3y agoIndeed, its not about the tech. Changing the business model is key. It might be hard to re-imagine the content industry without the current monopolists. Linux showed how disruptive an open model can be. There is a stark difference between the case of Linux and content. In the case of Linux, ROI is measurable in dollars. In the case of content, value is in large part the perception of customers. This is going to be very difficult in the particular use case of news media, which is arguably the most critical area. We're already in a situation there where "value" is in the form of the strengthening of biases and misinformation. The point here, is that to succeed, Tribler might have to find a niche where superior value generation becomes undeniably obvious to some sizable segment. (Perhaps music can serve this function.)
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoI want to see your project succeed, and I'm probably not alone. What kind of help do you need?
- synctext 3y agoWe love to have more help! Hardest part is debugging. So running Tribler and reporting bug in Github. We are in desperate need of Win/Mac/Linux users which will help us with reproduce bugs. One time we found bugs in Python Async IO standard lib [1]. The 'once in a week' bugs are difficult to capture. [1] https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/pull/7926 https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/pull/7926
- nathan_compton 3y agoThe reason I don't run TOR exit nodes is that I neither wish to support criminal activity (of at least certain types) nor do I want to get entangled with law enforcement for doing so. Since this is TOR-like, what are my legal liabilities if I am running this software?
- synctext 3y agoTribler does not include a Tor exit node!
- wongarsu 3y agoBut can you download data from regular bittorrent peers using Tribler? And if yes, how does my traffic reach them? Suppose I want to download a torrent that's only seeded by one person running Deluge. My understanding was that this would involve making a connection to another Tribler user, and that user making the connection to that seeder. That would make every client a sort of exit node for bittorrent traffic, even for torrents they don't download. Is that not how it works?
- wongarsu 3y agoFrom my outsider's view, the part where you need the most help is actually your website. From the https://tribler.org https://tribler.org homepage it's very hard to figure out what tribler actually is, and the only screenshots are hidden away in the support and developer categories, and all feature vastly different menu items (without clear indication how to get those features, if they even still exist). The API documentation isn't linked anywhere. And while installing the client and downloading your first torrent is easy enough, there isn't a lot of info on how to do anything else. And the help that does exist is outdated or wrong. The https://www.tribler.org/howto.html https://www.tribler.org/howto.html seems to be for a completely different version than what I get when I download and install the Windows version, and 3 out of 4 steps don't work as described (The text in 2 is completely wrong/outdated, I don't even have the menu item for 3, nor the icon for 4)
- thejohnconway 3y agoI’m curious about the rewards/tokens aspect. Is this done using cryptocurrency (you mentioned bitcoin, urg, upthread), or something else?
- hanniabu 3y agoThey smartly aren't answering b/c of how hostile HN is to crypto. Look how receptive these comments have been so far, that's a clear sign of HN's bias.
- ddtaylor 3y agoIt's a subject that I am interested in and involved in yet I will never discuss it on Hacker News again. The attempts I made to genuinely interact related to crypto have been terrible on this website. It's unfortunate because I feel there is a very good discussion there regardless on whether you are for or against it but we don't get to see that discussion.
- synctext 3y agoThere is no crypto in Tribler. We have something much older then Bitcoin. It's a simple ledger who helped whom in the network. Simple case of earning points by helping others. Economically, its complex. Coin creation is decentralised, everybody prints their own 'money'. The value of that help-currency is based on how connected you are to the globally connected transaction graph. Then we maintain fairness in this micro-economy against freeriders. See study with 160 million trust records and 95k users [1]. [1] https://research.tudelft.nl/files/89353583/1_s2.0_S1389128621001705_main.pdf https://research.tudelft.nl/files/89353583/1_s2.0_S138912862...
- hanniabu 3y ago> We have something much older then Bitcoin Then it's flawed. There's a reason why all earlier implementations failed. They were incomplete.
- DRosario 3y agoHave you checked out Farcaster? https://docs.farcaster.xyz/ https://docs.farcaster.xyz/ FC built a sufficiently decentralized platform, which seems to align with Tribler. They already have apps to compete with twitter/reddit (warpcast), tiktok (drakula), and others. A video service would be a great fit in the ecosystem.
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoAny service built on cryptocurrency is a terrible idea for the future; there exists no such thing as scarcity in cyberspace.
- kouru225 3y agoScarcity is just a natural consequence of trust
- jolmg 3y agoWhat do you mean?
- kouru225 3y agoCrypto is a solution to establishing trust in a decentralized ledger system: proof of stake and proof of work prevent people from adding fake transactions to the blockchain. It’s just a natural consequence that this creates scarcity.
- pyinstallwoes 3y agoIt doesn’t establish trust. It’s the opposite of trust. It establishes paranoia, and even then, how can you be sure your screen is the truth?
- persnickety 3y agoIt establishes both trust by separating it from mistrust (paranoia if you will) by making the division explicit and assigning trust to some people and operations and not others. If you think it's concerned about screens, you're wrong. It's concerned about "did this person really do this"?
- zadler 3y agoHi I’d like to try plugging into Tribbler as a content backend for beastie.fi, which seems to have similar goals.
- ajb 3y agoDo content creators currently make any income from your platform? If so, what are the statistics of this (best, typical, etc)
- jszymborski 3y agoWhile I can't say I've really used Tribler a lot, I've been following the project for most of those years. Thanks for working so hard on a such an admirable project.
- digdugdirk 3y agoCould this be run in the browser (via wasm, lets say) as a base layer service to build decentralized versions of twitter/facebook/etc on top of?
- Qem 3y agoTime to test tribler again. Great project. I installed it 3-4 years ago. Looked great, but I couldn't get it working properly, because IIRC it required two open ports, one for regular torrent protocol, another for their content discovery protocol, and my VPN provider allowed only one port available to forwarding, per user per IP.
- synctext 3y agothnx Qem for you enduring patience! We're now multiplexing everything on 1 port. If you use our Tor-like decentralised onion routing feature that works. Sadly, in normal mode we need two forwarded ports. Both Libtorrent download lib and our decentralised gossip requires their own port. We gossip about trust, content discovery, and torrent health.
- Qem 3y agoThank you all Tribler developers. Your project is awesome. With today Internet siloed in, projects to re-decentralize are a critical need.
- inSenCite 3y agoThis is a super cool project (first time I'm hearing about it), great work to everyone involved! Is the intent to have multiple tribler-like instances serving different (content) domains or more of a one-spot search that content providers can serve their content through? I ask as I'm wondering about how you foresee this "degrading" as it scales as that is where most current content platforms fail apart as they try to grow/maximize audience.
- synctext 3y agoGlad to hear it! Indeed, most platforms have a central point of failure somewhere. Note that Bittorrent swarms never get overloaded, we use that same technique: extreme decentralisation. With increased load that website, discovery server, or load balancer gets overloaded. With Tribler we decentralised everything to the extreme of Bitcoin and Bittorrent. So there is no "degrading", as long as the freeriders are somehow detected. See our 2007 architectural documents [1] [1] https://git.gnunet.org/bibliography.git/plain/docs/Concurrency_and_Computation_-_TRIBLER.pdf https://git.gnunet.org/bibliography.git/plain/docs/Concurren...
- runeks 3y ago> Earn seeding tokens How can this be possible in a non-centralized manner?
- __MatrixMan__ 3y agoWhy wouldn't it be possible? My friends know what when I show up to a party, I usually bring a drink or a dish or something. There's no centralized database for this, they know because they've eaten and drank those things. We don't use tokens to keep track of this, but we could. The situation seems similar with seeding. It's just not commonly done because you have to build and maintain a web of trust for it to to work, and that's often a level of user responsibility that's hard to cultivate. But if you need that web of trust anyway (e.g. for filtering out ads ad other disinformation) then you might as well use it for consensus about who is a good citizen and who is not. (I have no idea if this is Tribler's approach, it's just on my mind because I've been designing something quite like Tribler, and it's my approach.)
- yieldcrv 3y agoIt’s pretty easy to build an emission or reward schedule into the rules of a decentralized network when the software that nodes are running see another compliant node, they expect for it to be rewarded so they all conform to the additional issuance of tokens you just need to make sure that sybil attack attempts improve the network, as the attacker adds more nodes to earn more
- hanniabu 3y agoWith blockchain, but HN would hate to hear there's a usecase
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fwip 3y agoIt uses Bitcoin
- 3y ago
- _nalply 3y agoCorporate has learnt to misuse honorary or voluntary non-paid work in the software ecoystem and grabbing power. For example one big media outlet could adopt Tribler. At first everyone rejoices because it is recognition but what if it turns out to be an attack? How is Tribler resilient against taking over from Corporate? Of course, it's Open Source and everybody can fork. But still, could an attack be possible?
- ccvannorman 3y agoreminds me of "EEE" for incumbents to destroy new platforms; "Embrace, Extend, Extinguish"
- hkt 3y agoAlways lovely to see projects like this. I used it years ago after thinking "surely there must be some kind of tor-like thing for bittorrent" and lo and behold, there was tribler. At that point hidden seeding and downloading were both done via tor-like outproxies, eg, out to the regular internet. I recall talk from the issues page about intra-tribler media, eg, anonymised from end to end - does anyone know if this has been achieved?
- synctext 3y agoYes, you can do end-to-end encrypted hidden seeding. See technical docs (slightly outdated) [1]. Everything in Python was too slow. With Rust implementation we get 10x the speed, 160 Mbit/s anon tunneling. [1] https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/wiki/Hidden-Services-Specifications-for-anonymous-seeding https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/wiki/Hidden-Services-Spec...
- barfard 3y ago[dead]
- ementally 3y agoGreat project, but can the devs comment on https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/2014-December/007999.html https://lists.torproject.org/pipermail/tor-dev/2014-December... >[tor-dev] N reasons why the spooks love Tribler (Number N' will surprise you)
- amenhotep 3y agoECB and random.randint, wow. I'm not sure any dev comment could redeem crypto sins like that in such a project.
- tribler 3y agoDeadly mistakes from 2014. Full redesign and new Rust code.
- simcop2387 3y agoLooks like there was a discussion back then on the github issues, https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/issues/1066 https://github.com/Tribler/tribler/issues/1066 EDIT: Had a chance to look through it now, looks like they addressed all the concerns back by 2015 i.e. 1. Replacing the custom crypto code with more standard libraries (looks like they settled on NACL/libsodium's implementations). 2. Switched to AES-GCM and then later ChaChaPoly 3. Fixed up the tor protocol issues too. Probably more but there's a lot going on.
- jazzyjackson 3y agoAre you suggesting the subject line is inappropriate? I just thought spook meant spy (probably the only audience to whom strong encryption and anonymity actually matter) I guess there's an older more offensive meaning.
- hgyjnbdet 3y agoLast I looked at tribler it was an attack resilient torrent/tor-like network client. Now it's a micro-economy for media. That's a pivot!
- aldeluis 3y agoThe use of Tribler was problematic in my case because it uses a random torrent cache that was instrumentalized for lawfare after a political problem with my public employer in Spain. I was accused of having pedophile content on my computer after the prosecution's expert selected the corresponding torrents and downloaded them. It seems there are always pedophile torrents in a random sample of torrents. The political problem was that I refused to alter statistical data for a "scientist" that wanted to publish that women after abortion develop mental health issues. They search my job computer for something to kill me and found tribler cache. https://www.publico.es/actualidad/rioja-paga-estudios-salud-mental.html https://www.publico.es/actualidad/rioja-paga-estudios-salud-... It was hard. Lost job, six years under juditial prosecution... at the end, the case was dismissed, I could show that the torrent cache was not personal, but the damage was great. Be careful if you are an activist or have political involvement. I'm unaware of the workings of the current version, hope it encrypts the torrent cache somehow.
- nextaccountic 3y agoWhy does tribler automatically download random torrents without user intervention? Is it just to perform distributed search? In this case, it downloads random torrent _metadata_ right? How could the case be brought with just metadata? Regardless of whether the torrent cache was personal or not, if it was just metadata it still didn't contain anything illegal
- jazzyjackson 3y agolinking to illegal data may be prosecuted as distribution, even if you're not the host if you're contributing to a distributed index where people are searching and retrieving material thanks to the meta data on your drive, IMHO that's pretty close to distribution
- amelius 3y agoSo if someone puts a sticker on your car that has the url of an illegal website, then you may be prosecuted for illegal distribution?
- thomastjeffery 3y agoThere's a lot of focus here on the alternative economy part, but I think that's way less interesting than the rest of what this tech offers. What we really need is alternative moderation. The most fragile/vulnerable part of traditional torrent trackers is centralized forums. It's also the most problematic aspect of social media. A successful decentralized alternative to content moderation would drastically change the world.
- wizardwes 3y agoInteresting, but I wonder how feasible this actually is. The closest thing I can think of is the ability to selective defederate in things like Mastodon or Lemmy, where the host of your instance can do broad sweeps of moderation by essentially blocking instances that don't fit your instance's stance. The issue is that any moderation past personal blocks amd filters requires leaning against an authority, whether that be algorithmic, democratic, or our traditional style of moderation. And really, that's, in a way, what people want, someone who can handle removing unfavorable content before it gets to you most of the time. I'd love to hear ideas counter to this though.
- thomastjeffery 3y agoThe problem with moderation is that it's inherently hierarchical. Moderation is all about special people deciding what is and isn't said. You can't stop the signal without controlling the network. My idea is to replace moderation with curation. Anyone can share an attestation about what category a peice of media belongs to. Attestations are backed by the authenticity of whoever makes them: a web of trust. The hard problem is ambiguous metadata: you can express a given attestation in many ways, but can only parse it in one context. For example, you can filter out all media that is attested to be purple, but that won't stop you from seeing violet. I have an idea for this too, but it's even more out there.
- James314 3y agoDoes the Tribler Client automatically turn my computer into an exit node?
- FearOfTheDuck 3y agoNo
- spxneo 3y agoWhat is the onramp/offramp process for the tokens used in this micro-economy? If somebody seeds Independence Day 2 and by some miracle becomes the most seeded movie, how does that somebody cash out his tokens? If somebody wants to download Independence Day 2 what and how is it being converted into tokens?
- yobbo 3y agoThe goal here seems to be to incentivise bandwidth-sharing, but this is not the main problem. For a "decentralized youtube" to ever make sense, the problems that need solving are how to compensate content-creators/owners, and how to prevent piracy.
- chottocharaii 3y agoTwo problems: - Incentivising decentralised infrastructure (this solves that) - Incentivising content creation (completely different issue, will always require a political solution, and cannot be solved by technologists)
- heycosmo 3y agoI think many proposed solutions to the creator compensation problem end up glossing over a fundamental difficulty: once an easily-distributed work (like anything digital) is in a consumable state (and thus copy-able), it becomes basically free. The idea that $10 for a digital copy of an album that is already on youtube (or a friend's harddrive) should be a viable business model is weird to me in this day and age. I have recently been wondering about a threshold-based "media economy" where creators don't actually show us anything (except for clips or samples or low-res versions, etc) until they are guaranteed a certain amount of income. It's basically kickstarter. A musician makes an album, goes on kickstarter and asks for $10,000 to release it. Once $10k is reached, the songs go up on a server, or are released on bandcamp, spotify, or any of the usual channels. Additional money beyond the threshold can be made, but it will be as difficult as it is now. But they have already reached $10k (set by them) so everyone can feel good that the musician has earned what they feel they deserve. I'm sure there are many problems with this. For one, many artists aren't creating just for money. They want to show us their creations, and with a threshold, they would have to hold back until it is reached (in the case of musicians, they might not even be able to play a new song at a show until the threshold is reached, b/c smartphones). There may be a critical mass problem, too. If two artists are similar and one releases immediately while the other waits for the threshold payment, the latter may drift into obscurity. There must be some allure to the withholding, though? What other problems kill this approach? Could it work for open source software, too? Make your thing, don't share it. Demo it, ask for the release payment, then put it on github.
- tw04 3y ago>Could it work for open source software, too? Make your thing, don't share it. Demo it, ask for the release payment, then put it on github. I think it would be far more reasonable to put the source into escrow, to be released when a threshold is met. I've seen closed source vendors do that when they're smaller to ensure a large customer is not left high and dry should they go bankrupt or be acquired by someone who kills the product. I don't foresee anyone being willing to see a demo of a piece of software, then writing a check for it before using it. In the closed source world you pretty much ALWAYS have to do some sort of POV/POC before anyone will buy your stuff.
- 3y ago