5 ms·
Seems a bit much calling it a scam. That to me implies malicious intent which I don’t think is in place here. Bad/imperfect products happen even to well meaning
by Havoc 3y ago
Seems a bit much calling it a scam. That to me implies malicious intent which I don’t think is in place here. Bad/imperfect products happen even to well meaning companies.
Must admit I’m surprised by the aggressiveness of it all. It’s almost like an echo chamber where people have decided it’s ok to pile on
- suyash 3y agoYes, that is bit much but the main point being this projection technology is nowhere novel, I have been playing with pico projectors and modern ones comes with Android OS so it's just a mini projector. However the only thing innovative here is natural voice interaction powered by modern AI but that also seems to be very slow for any practical purpose.
- soneca 3y agoIs the hand movement to control what is being projected on your hand as a menu “nowhere novel”?
- infecto 3y agoHonest question, is it much different than how VR headsets track hand movements and gesture in VR?
- soneca 3y agoFrom the reviews, it seems different and worse. But it is something novel that requires serious research. Even if the result is disappointing, it is novel enough to not make the it a “scam using old te vc projection”. That was the point of my rhetorical question before.
- infecto 3y agoDoes it require serious research? I am not trying to be difficult but I have seen write ups on basic hand gesture tracking from 5+ years ago.
- soneca 3y agoDepends how you define “serious”. I am defining “serious for a consumer product company”. Putting that in a small device seems quite a feat. If you define “serious” as “particles colliding” or “drugs that cure some type of cancer”, then no. Keep in mind that I am using “serious” as opposed to “scammy”. I thin this pin is far from a scam.
- infecto 3y agoThats fair. I guess I am biased with one of the initial story that described the genesis of the product during a cliff top retreat on Benioff's property. All the hype, the demonstrations, but the actual product falls flat of any real functionality. There is a disconnect between the hype they sold and what they released. That is scam territory.
- wruza 3y agoI remember my buddy casually controlling the volume in his car by rotating the index finger cw/ccw with his hand on a gearbox handle. It was round 6-7 years ago. Nothing projected on his hand though, as it was all projected on a windshield, only visible to him. BMW 7, iirc.
- suyash 3y agohand is just a surface bro, I don't think it has anything to do with hand, light will bounce back on any opaque surface, just think of it as a mini projector and it's not even full RGB spectrum colour.
- soneca 3y agoThe hand movement controls what is being showed in the projector, which are inputs of the computation it does. You speak with such confidence. Always a reliable red flag that you don’t know what you are talking about.
- corobo 3y ago> Must admit I’m surprised by the aggressiveness of it all. It’s almost like an echo chamber where people have decided it’s ok to pile on This seems to be a really common occurrence recently - I know the internet can be mean, I've been on it since the peak of IRC, but it seems way more intense these days. The moment something is marked as the bad thing, hordes of people absolutely pile onto it out of nowhere. Is this something I've just not noticed, a more people online thing, long term effects of covid (the virus itself and/or the lockdowns), a result of whatever algorithm tweaks Elon has been making, are people just pissed off in general, etc? It feels bizarre how aggro the internet has become! I think psychology might call this Splitting, which honestly seems to describe the business model of social media platforms these days too, so maybe there's a connection there. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Splitting_(psychology) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Splitting_(psychology) Off topic but using as an example of this: This tweeted photo, showing a pub in the UK that allows dogs, but bans children. Bit edgy, sure, but look at the bloodbath in the replies/quotes! It's absolute chaos! https://twitter.com/hifromkyle/status/1779548610528415809 https://twitter.com/hifromkyle/status/1779548610528415809
- blackhawkC17 3y agoIt’s plain old mob mentality. It’s been that way since we were hunter-gatherers in the forests.
- corobo 3y agoAye fair point, I guess I've just been noticing it happening more because I noticed it happen and am now tuned to see it - that Baader-Meinhof frequency illusion thing.
- Aurornis 3y ago> The moment something is marked as the bad thing, hordes of people absolutely pile onto it out of nowhere. This isn’t “out of nowhere”. Humane and their AI pin have been marketed an d talked an kur all over Internet tech spaces for a very long time. I’ve been seeing talk about the Humane AI pin in these same channels (YouTube, Twitter, tech websites) frequently since they were funded. People have been forming opinions and skepticism for a long time. The key thing that changed is that the product finally transitioned from hypothetical to reality, and suddenly everyone’s thoughts were confirmed all at once. This is nothing like your photo of a pub getting talked about on Twitter for a brief moment. AI and AI hardware have been a hot topic for years and Humane has been pushing marketing materials and demos on social media for a long time. They made themselves the center of the conversation. Now the rubber hits the road and they have to deal with being the center of the conversation without having the substance to back up their big social media push. The real mob mentality is all of the people who are arriving late to this multi-year buildup and trying to scorn the reviewers and critics.
- beepbooptheory 3y agoI agree with you semantically, but these days I'm less and less concerned with "intent" when it comes to scams. It ultimately just revolves down to empty moralism about "people today," and fails to grasp the issue at hand. Like how phone scammers are often themselves trapt in a system beyond their control [1]. Or even case in point with this thing. Maybe the owners aren't malicious, but if not, they are clearly somewhat being scammed themselves by AI hype, to the point they are willing to invest so much in the chatbot box, tie their entire business presumably to one current API or another, however bad an idea we know that is. There are just many long chains of debt, confusion, hyperstition that are knotting around us, with no clear source. One person's scam turns into another's "innovation" before turning again back into a scam for the end user. If we are really getting ready for the AI future, we need to get used to being wronged and taken advantage of by technically blameless entities, whose intent is logical, capitalist, and at least nominatively "benevolent." The era of morality itself might soon turn to something else! In a world so predetermined and calculated, where there is such advanced science around influencing thought, cybernetics, etc, how does it even make sense anymore? Or at least, how is focusing on something like intent here even satisfying anymore beyond saying "bad people do bad things"? 1. https://www.propublica.org/article/human-traffickers-force-victims-into-cyberscamming https://www.propublica.org/article/human-traffickers-force-v...
- jkestner 3y agoI agree that intent is not relevant, but humans must be held accountable for outcomes. Ever since we've had algorithms that appear to make decisions, we've been fighting this idea that _humans_ are "technically blameless entities", just following orders from the black box. We must not get used to it.
- zikduruqe 3y agoWhen the content of the writing can't generate revenue, the hate and anger can.
- ilrwbwrkhv 3y agoAah yes. Classic cult tactics. If anyone calls you out on your nonsense, they are all haters. Recently saw this guy Alex Hormozi, complete scammer, use this strategy on YouTube.
- brookst 3y agoIt’s an unfortunate trend, but it is also an age-old reaction to hubris. Humane made the fatal PR mistake of trying to convince the world they had a revolutionary product that would change everything… without selling the benefits of the product. That triggers a bunch of memes, from emperor’s new clothes to pride before a fall. Add in a general societal distrust of tech and AI, plus the age-old derision for geeks/nerds, and Humane could not have set themselves up better for fiasco if they had tried. I do think it was all well meaning and earnest, not at all a scam. But their over-the-top marketing for v1 of an experimental tech gadget was really clueless.
- paulcole 3y ago> Humane made the fatal PR mistake of trying to convince the world they had a revolutionary product that would change everything Segway walked so Humane could run. As a college student I remember the lead up to the Segway reveal on Good Morning America. I was so excited for it that I set my alarm for 6AM to watch it. I remember being so confused and annoyed. Fool me once...
- unsupp0rted 3y agoYou mean "Project Ginger" aka "IT"? https://www.wired.com/2001/01/ginger-may-be-motorized-scooter/ https://www.wired.com/2001/01/ginger-may-be-motorized-scoote...
- paulcole 3y agolol I didn't realize it had been that long. maybe I was just looking for a bright spot in the world after 9/11?
- browningstreet 3y agoSegway worked exactly as advertised. They are still being made and sold. The problem is that the product didn't _mean_ what the company hoped.
- 3y ago
- swiftcoder 3y ago> Seems a bit much calling it a scam. That to me implies malicious intent which I don’t think is in place here. Bad/imperfect products happen even to well meaning companies. There's no malicious intent in producing glossy promos videos of a device you know a priori does not (and cannot) work, becaue it violates a few laws of physics? I feel like some folks around here have become very innured to false advertising
- blackhawkC17 3y agoIt's hubris and overconfidence that's common among startup founders who think they've found the solutions to all the world's problems. But it's not a "scam" to release third-rate hardware after overhyping it. Magic Leap and many other startups did the same. "Scam" should be reserved for actual fraudulent startups like Theranos and Outcome Health.
- akaru 3y agoStrange hill to die on. Lots of people scam by expecting to right their wrongs in the end. Hell even Theranos may have believed with enough scam money they could eventually have made right with the tech. Still a scam. Same here. If it’s not what you’re selling, it’s a lie, and a lie is a scam.
- YetAnotherNick 3y ago> Strange hill to die on Not at all strange. The problem is that scam has certain meaning and if we use scam more liberally we dilute the meaning. If every company is a scam(as almost everyone intentionally overhypes or does something similar to humane), then no company is a scam. Is google a scam as they scripted the gemini video?
- nathan_compton 3y agoI think the issue here is that arguably startup culture has _redefined_ scam to _not include_ "fake it till you make it gotta get funding" bullshit. In a previous era that stuff might arguably have been non-controversially been though of as a kind of scam. My own experience with startups is that they often hew as close to the line of scam as they can get away with and this behavior has been normalized.
- svantana 3y agoThey are not calling this product a scam, but rather noting its similarity to laser projection projects of the past that (obviously) turned out to be scams. A subtle but important distinction.
- realfeel78 3y agoWrong. > Humane’s website and other promotional material have a series of fake still images (“Photoshopped” images overlayed on hands). While even these pictures are pretty low-resolution (much less than a true 720p image), they turn out to be much better than what is seen in the videos of the Humane projector.
- svantana 3y agoNowhere in this quote (or the article) are they calling Humane a scam?
- datascienced 3y agoIt ain’t pig butchering.
- throwaway4good 3y agoHumane AI should have paid off some social media influencers. Or paid for some social media management. Or hired a PR firm. Or whatever you call it. Now they are getting the Fisker treatment.
- realfeel78 3y agoPR can only do so much.
- gizmo 3y agoEvery once in a while a highly funded startup launches a hilariously bad product. Five or so years ago everybody (rightfully) made fun of the juicero. Before that we had Google Glass (glasshole). Today the Humane Pin has to suffer slings and arrows. Humane AI would never have been able to raise 230+ million had they been truthful about what could be built with the current state of technology. Did the investors understand that you have to recharge the Humane Pin every 2 hours? Did the investors know their laser projection press photos are photoshopped? Did the investors know the laser projector doesn't meet the advertised resolution? The Humane Pin is science fiction. In many ways the Humane Pin is like Theranos. Holmes probably didn't mean to defraud people. She just raised money for a product that couldn't be built with the current state of technology.
- edent 3y agoI think if I were investing a few million into something, I might ask "what's the battery life?" or "Can I try it on my hand?" before coughing up the cash. But then, I'm not a VC. I guess they go off vibes?
- MobiusHorizons 3y agoThose questions probably get asked, but long before any real product exists, so the answer is optimistic or just plain imaginary. By the time the real product exists, a lot of money has been spent and there is a lot of pressure to drum up hype for a product that probably doesn’t deliver.
- Workaccount2 3y agoYou'd think if you were contemplating a $10m investment in a promise-the-world startup, you'd spend the $20k to get an expert analysis of the project.
- whymauri 3y agoYou'd think, but VCs are lemmings and the moment you convince one to invest a clock starts ticking that makes thorough diligence difficult for everyone else. Get one person to fall for 'just trust me bro' and the hype train follows.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- crote 3y agoYeah, it's a very aggressive statement. The product as-is is obviously pretty crappy, but I do believe there's a reasonable path forwards imaginable. The hardware itself seems to be decent-ish, albeit suffering from the usual first-gen issues. The AI-focused software stack is currently quite bad, but software is easy to update. Pair it with a smartphone, allow 3rd party apps, and it's essentially an alternative to a smartwatch. You lose the screen, but you gain a camera. I'd probably be quite tempted to buy a gen2 myself, even if all the AI stuff doesn't work out.
- realfeel78 3y ago[flagged]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- BobbyTables2 3y agoIt’s a scam targeting VC investors, not the public. Instead of pitching a practical and attainable product, one has to aim for the moon in order to get the VC $$$$. The wilder, the better. Call me crazy, but as a society we’ve decided that “possible” is too boring. While many VC funded companies only want to get bought out (instead of actually being a freestanding successful company), I strongly feel there are a sizable subsection of “founders” that don’t even want to get bought out… They only just want to play the game and collect high salaries along the way… Sadly, they aren’t even to blame. Too many Fortune-50 executives just try not to embarrass themselves long enough to collect insane levels of compensation. Is a wonder that VC founders do the same? Too many startups are really just “playing house” — really flashy website, monochrome headshots of executive team, multiple officies, plethora of partner logos… Only missing substance and a real product.
- ryandrake 3y agoMy only career regret is that I went for "technical chops" rather than charisma and "storytelling chops". Over and over we see founders hauling in millions from [evidently] gullible VCs who hear a story and Want To Believe.
- kmeisthax 3y agoSee also https://youtu.be/PDjleq0PJX0?t=2645 https://youtu.be/PDjleq0PJX0?t=2645
- Zigurd 3y agoAgreed that scam implies intent, but it is a hell of an ego trip. They so much wanted to create a new product category on par with the smartphone they could not admit the right thing to do was pivot to making it a peripheral. Android has all the underlying software, from a secondary screen API for the projector to Google Lens to an AI assistant that they could have done a peripheral that cost 1/3 as much, weighed half, didn't need a midday battery swap, and didn't get burning hot. Samsung would have done that. Maybe they still will.
- msabalau 3y agoBy definition, it isn't "piling on" for this blog to have been written, last December, before the CES AI gadget hype. Anticipating, long before launch, issues that are being discussed now, when reviewers have the device in their hands. Nor, in any way, shape or form is it unusual for a bad/imperfect product to receive poor reviews. That is not piling on--it is normal and expected. No one is literally saying that an individual contributor at Humane is a "scammer" just because they happened to have worked on a project that arguably takes perfectly good sand and subtracts value from it. That happens. A lot. Sometimes you intend to make a product, and you end up working on an empty product-shaped object. Heck, sometimes, say in healthcare, the drug or device you hoped would help people not only does nothing, but actually causes harm. That doesn't mean you were foolish to have started work, but simply because you started with "good intentions" doesn't mean a product belongs on the market. Humane is charging $700 for a device with $24 monthly subscriptions. If someone thinks that such an offering is worthless, or nearly so, it is hardly surprising if they use "aggressive" language to warn people away. If there is anything unusual or unsettling it is that some people in tech seem to feel that it is "unethical" to treat tech companies as anything less than bold innovators, irrespective of what that they ship. If someone is despairing over past week's discourse, one only can imagine how they'd deal with something like Apple's "I'm a Mac/I'm a PC" commercials.
- amoss 3y agoThat was my initial reaction, the word scam is overused these days. But then I reached the comparison section between the photoshopped/ generated images and the real photos.
- paxys 3y agoI'd say the last second pivot to "AI" to try and cash in on the hype is definitely malicious intent.
- aaron695 3y ago[dead]
- __loam 3y agoPeople are getting less patient for hype cycles.