7 ms·
Physically attractive attorneys tend to have greater success in federal court
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 3y agoWhat about state court.
- emjoes1 3y agoMaybe this explains why people on tv seem uglier now than 10 years ago. We must have a war on beauty now.
- Rinzler89 3y agoCorrection: Physically attractive people tend to have an easier time in general at everything in life that involves IRL person-to-person interaction. Try going to interviews with missing front teeth and see how far you get. Thank you for attending my TED Talk, now feel free to spend that research money on curing cancer instead of studying obvious things humans knew for hundreds of years.
- causal 3y agoScience is still worth doing to confirm our intuitions, but I agree that this headline approaches a tautology. "People who other people like tend to be favored by those people"
- SJC_Hacker 3y agoPhysically attractive people are going to have an advantage in many things, depending on the field. However, sometimes it doesn't matter all that much. And I think in some circumstances it works to their disadvantage esp. when it comes to women. Some Youtube personalities have been able to succeed despite not being very physically attractive, e.g. Sabine Hossenfelder (sp.), or not even showing their face at all (e.g. Perun) They are just know WTH they are talking about and present it in relatable/funny way.
- _trampeltier 3y agoIt just doesn't matter (or at least less) if you know people over time. If it is just a few days, it allways does matter.
- pishpash 3y agoCover on, SH is playing the Debbie Downer character so needs to look like that.
- parpfish 3y agoI think a lot of people have some intuition that Berkson’s paradox is at work and that’s where the disadvantage comes in. If skill and attractiveness are unrelated but there’s a filter process at some point that only lets people through if they’re hot OR talented, you’ll see a negative relationship between skill and attractiveness after the filter. the prosecutor example is interesting because it suggests that either thats not happening
- pishpash 3y agoIt doesn't say that's not happening. It says they are winning cases.
- tokai 3y agoOn the other hand many youtubers can stay successful even though they are horrible people making bad content, while being physically attractive.
- lapcat 3y ago> now feel free to spend that research money on curing cancer instead of studying obvious things humans knew for hundreds of years. This is a false dichotomy. We can and indeed should study medicine and psychology, among countless other subjects. The author of the article isn't a medical researcher and wouldn't be able to cure cancer regardless of whether he received research money for that. Moreover, the article gives no indication that it was funded by any grants. Professors publish articles as part of their regular jobs. Unless you're proposing that universities abolish all departments except medical research? I'd guess that it's probably cheaper to prevent cancer than to cure cancer. One way to help prevent cancer is to successfully sue and/or prosecute companies who introduce cancer-causing substances into the air, water, food, and other parts of our environment. Thus, I'd say that the factors resulting in courtroom success are relevant to the fight against cancer.
- photonthug 3y ago> Unless you're proposing that universities abolish all departments except medical research Doesn’t follow, and I’m sure you’re not proposing that funds/time/attention spent in one place can be double spent in another. It’s reasonable to criticize a waste of resources since there’s always a real opportunity cost
- lapcat 3y ago> It’s reasonable to criticize a waste of resources I don't believe it's a waste of resources. > there’s always a real opportunity cost Pitting cancer research vs. psychology research is a false dichotomy. (And again, the article author didn't appear to receive any extra funding for this research aside from his regular professorial salary.) Society spends vast sums of money on a vast number of things. If you want to talk about a waste of resources, I could list a million things that are worse than this research, not just worse as in less useful, but worse as in actively harmful to society.
- tombert 3y ago> I could list a million things that are worse than this research, not just worse as in less useful, but worse as in actively harmful to society. The thing that comes to mind is the “manufactured ewaste” that people buy on AliExpress and Wish.com and Temu. The products on there are enticingly cheap, but are often so crappy that they rarely even get a single use, and end up in a landfill. Plastic waste is bad, but I am even more concerned with potential problems with lithium batteries piling up in landfills, not even considering the potential ethical issues with mining the resources for the battery. It’s one thing to me if the device you are actually using was made with dubious labor, it’s another if it’s a device that will immediately become waste.
- klipt 3y agoMaybe we would cure cancer faster if we rewarded the smartest students instead of the most attractive ones.
- tombert 3y agoJust because something appears immediately obvious doesn’t imply we shouldn’t study it. Plenty of “common sense” thing are wrong, and even when “common sense” is right, it can be useful to figure out the “why” or to what extent. Yes, attractive people generally have an easier time in life, we all know that, this is surprising to nobody, but at the same time, it probably doesn’t affect every field equally. Being attractive probably matters an awful lot in the modeling industry, but probably matters less in the tech support industry. This doesn’t mean that it matters 100% in modeling or 0% in tech support. Also, I mean, how much money is spent on truly useless stuff? I spent multiple years working for the marketing tech team of a company. Wall Street traders contribute a lot less to the world than medical researchers but get paid an order of magnitude more. It’s hardly like this is the low hanging fruit in fund-reallocation.
- riedel 3y agoI think putting a more constructive aspect to it would be great though. I guess there is still judicial systems in which everyone wears a rob and wigs. Was it studied if this lessens the effect? Wonder if it makes sense to come back to those things to counteract biases.
- tombert 3y agoI don’t think it needs to supply a prescription, at least in the initial research. I think it’s valid enough to determine if the bias exists before we try and figure out solutions for it.
- User23 3y agoThey also tend to be smarter[1]. What we perceive as physical attractiveness is obviously some kind of mate selection adaptation. It’s no surprise that it would correspond with both intelligence and fertility. The halo effect exists because it’s a somewhat valid heuristic. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289610001315 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01602...
- missingrib 3y agoIt correlates, which could also explain a link in the opposite direction. Secondary sex characteristics sometimes have nothing to do with overall fitness. You can see this most clearly in animal species where the females value elaborate ornamentation, like peacocks. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisherian_runaway https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fisherian_runaway and https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexy_son_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sexy_son_hypothesis.
- trimethylpurine 3y agoIt's a soft science anyway... >The first measure introduced an objective counterpart to human ratings by employing a machine learning algorithm developed by Megvii (Face++ Beauty Score). Apparently obfuscating a subjective variable makes it objective in soft science research. I lose interest immediately after that.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- pvg 3y agoOmit internet tropes. Please don't post shallow dismissals, especially of other people's work https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- banish-m4 3y agoI think the "homeless guy" social experiment where he tries unsuccessfully to get a table but then drives off in a Lambo is the peak of our social progress. That and the % of poor and minority men in prison.
- whycome 3y agoOh, so that's why they used to make them wear those silly wigs.
- causal 3y agoImagine masked-singer style trials
- bicijay 3y agoPhysically attractive people tend to have greater success in life.
- jajko 3y agoLook who works on average in those big corporations, ie finance or consulting. Way above average looking women and above average guys, on average :)
- mathiasgredal 3y agoWhich begs the question, if attractiveness is such a big predictor of success, why hasn’t everyone evolved to become very attractive? The evolutionary pressure for increased attractiveness should be very high, since it affects so many areas of your life, from career success, to getting partners etc. Is it that the speed at which we evolve to become more attractive is superseeded by our ability to become better at discriminating for attractiveness?
- gnicholas 3y agoIt's possible that people have evolved to be more attractive than a long time ago, but the issue is not of absolute beauty but rather relative attractiveness. There will always be a top 10% and a bottom 10%, even if the entire population increases in attractiveness across the board. But separately, it's not clear that attractiveness is hereditary in the same way that height, for example, is. If two tall people have kids, they will almost certainly be tall. It's also incredibly unlikely that two short people will not have kids that are tall. With attractiveness, heterogeneity between generations is much more common. I know some very attractive people who have not-very-attractive offspring, and vice versa. It depends on how the features of the two parents mix together.
- warcher 3y agoI mean at the very minimum there lies a great deal within our locus of control that can influence overall attractiveness. Are you in shape and well groomed? So many are not, and it’s weird that people don’t at least try to hit that Pareto inflection point within their own possible range of attractiveness, knowing, as we all do, that it makes a difference.
- vouaobrasil 3y agoLesson: if you're not physically attractive, become a mathematician.
- paulmd 3y agoIt is too late, for I have already notated you as the physically unattractive attorney.
- somenameforme 3y agoThere's a strong correlation between attractiveness and IQ [1], which in turn is going to result in there being a strong correlation between attractiveness and anything that higher IQ would be predictive of - which presumably includes success in court. [1] - https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0160289610001315 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S01602...
- _Parfait_ 3y agoThis is interesting...considering the high IQ profession aren't seemingly littered with attractive people. I'm sure there are stronger correlations for that case though.
- MattGaiser 3y agoSome argue that relatively, they are. https://www.ft.com/content/4d3b1346-2c5b-11e5-8613-e7aedbb7bdb7 https://www.ft.com/content/4d3b1346-2c5b-11e5-8613-e7aedbb7b... We just don’t notice the relatively uglier people.
- saltminer 3y agoPaywall bypass: https://archive.is/Kbcrl https://archive.is/Kbcrl
- dctoedt 3y agoYears ago I read that the first Rothschilds to go into banking (men, of course) were not especially attractive. Financial success supposedly helped successive generations of the men to marry attractive women, so that later generations of men in the family looked like models or movie stars. (I wouldn’t know a Rothschild if I saw one so can’t opine on that.)
- Rinzler89 3y agoIt's not about marrying more attractive spouses for breeding better looking offspring, but what a lot of these studies miss is that wealthy people who are genetically disadvantaged have the funds the invest in their appearance to become better looking: best timely medical care, fixing teeth, becoming taller, correcting posture, hair implants, plastic surgery and skin care, hiring professional trainers and nutritionists, living in nice, quiet, green areas to reduce stress and sleep better, and other potential quackery rich people have access too like blood transfusions. Just look at Jeff Bezos and Elon Musk before and after they became wealthy, they're better looking despite being 10-20 years older. Basically, higher IQ can help you build wealth, and higher wealth can help you become better looking, but high IQ is not directly responsible for better looks.
- NickM 3y agoThere was a great short story by Ted Chiang about the biases that surround physical attractiveness. In the story, people could have a brain implant to suppress the brain’s ability to judge other's beauty (or lack thereof). It was pretty thought-provoking and not the typical predicable dystopian parable that most brain modification stories fall into. I find it fascinating that people seem to care so little about this particular bias when compared to other types of discrimination.
- vkou 3y agoIt's very difficult to quantify this one.
- scarmig 3y agoIs it? The actual discrimination can be quantified in a typical way. Attractiveness is only a bit trickier, but there's a high degree of agreement on attractive vs unattractive. Give a team of raters a group of people, present them pairs of people and ask them to select the more attractive one. Then you can create an average ordering, which you can map to whatever numerical range you want, and that score would be highly predictive of what future raters (and the real world) would find attractive.
- cyanydeez 3y agoBasically the same way most people are rating LLMs. Beauty is only subjective in the abstract.
- bookofjoe 3y ago>"Liking What You See: A Documentary" is a science fiction novelette by American writer Ted Chiang, published in the 2002 collection "Stories of Your Life and Others." >Plot summary The novelette examines the cultural effects of a noninvasive medical procedure that induces a visual agnosia toward physical beauty. The story is told as a series of interviews about a reversible procedure called calliagnosia, which eliminates a person's ability to perceive physical beauty. The story's central character is Tamera Lyons, a first-year student who grew up with calliagnosia but wants to experience life without it. Story: https://waldyrious.neocities.org/ted_chiang/liking-what-you-see-a-documentary https://waldyrious.neocities.org/ted_chiang/liking-what-you-... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liking_What_You_See:_A_Documentary#:~:text=Plot%20summary,-The%20novelette%20examines&text=The%20story%20is%20told%20as,to%20experience%20life%20without%20it https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Liking_What_You_See:_A_Documen....
- spxneo 3y agoNot just physical attractiveness, but skin tone matters in America where the conscious and subconscious biases are formed before children speak which are then reinforced through media which decides for them what is attractive and what is not, and manifested in their reality. The target groups almost suffer trauma, passed on to their children and their children, paraded as not humans but caricatures of the dominant megalomaniac Pan-Euro-American psyche.
- trimethylpurine 3y agoDo you live in the Middle or Far East and you're comparing?
- spxneo 3y agoRest of the globe just doesn't compare with the rest. In North America especially its subtle/overt hateful ignorance. In Europe its overt hateful ignorance. In Middle East its a mix bagged. The racism outside these parts is mostly based off curious ignorance, (they just havent seen foreigners for a long time due to isolating themselves). My first parent comment was to describe systematic and intentional hateful ignorance of the West and below I lay out the religious origins of this: Western perception is especially vulnerable through image/narrative manipulations with gaslighting, labeling and ignorance being its main tool of oppression especially when told through manufactured stories from a religious authority traditionally apt at targeting groups that rejects its main state religion (ex. Jews persecuted in Catholic Europe) which uses fear and idolation to further cement others as undesirables/dangerous/lesser. The rest of the world see the cumulation of such lazy thinking in Western political spectrums, both believing they are better than the rest of the world, supported by populist foreign & domestic policies through slogans and manufactured merit warps its subjects that simply cannot see past the illusion. Societies gets complex before entering decline and we are finally seeing this play out even in institutions that we all agreed would be free from these biases for a fair trial. Western exceptionalism is crumbling.
- Wytwwww 3y agoI find it hard to believe that racism in Europe and NA is particularly more rampant than in the rest of the world. Probably the complete opposite these days.
- andai 3y agoHalo Effect strikes again! https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Halo_effect Most common manifestation of this is that attractive people are perceived to be more intelligent, morally good, etc.
- aj7 3y agoNot by me.
- anon115 3y agoI almost if not always by experience tends to be the complete opposite... go ahead try interacting with those 'physically attractive' people.
- jajko 3y agoYou talk about those that are already spoiled by their environment, I guess we all have seen it more than once. Attractive women are 'hit' by this particularly hard - all those guys trying to get them to bed, get another score, the curve is exponential with beauty. Women usually hit on guys they like with much more subtlety, and stop when told directly immediately. Men, often not so much, even these days. One of my ex-gf (pretty, smart, rich, very hard working commodity trader) told me on a bad day its about 30 unknown guys who try to strike conversation out of blue, 'go to coffee', etc. She was so tired of this since she saw every possible pick up line, every situation they tried to create, every expensive cocktail sent her way. Its extremely hard for women to not get spoiled by such constant attack, imagine this constantly from teen years, it drills into your personality. Those who persist despite this are really awesome, driven and very strong internally, or broken beyond repair in some way. My ex was a mix of both. Good luck to her wherever she ended up. Yes, its mostly fault of us guys, even if only all those before you.
- fsckboy 3y ago>She was so tired of this that when she ages out of it she'll look at her craggy face in the mirror and breathe a sigh of relief? very likely not. not criticizing her or the men hitting on her, we are animals who try to spread our genes, and we like being found attractive as much as we like finding attractive. It creates a bit of a prison for us, it's impossible to be free of the side effects.
- Apreche 3y agopsypost.org? This looks like one of those content farms sites that we criticize google for including in its results. These kinds of domains need to be banned from here as well.
- pxeger1 3y agoIt’s not quite a content farm but it doesn’t seem to be the highest quality science journalism site. https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/lcd9xa/whats_going_on_with_people_of_rscience_calling_to/ https://www.reddit.com/r/OutOfTheLoop/comments/lcd9xa/whats_... has some somewhat interesting discussion.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- qarl 3y agoI just love the idea that in our system of justice you're more likely to be determined "correct" if you're attractive. It's perfectly dystopian. Justice is blind? LOL!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- bookofjoe 3y ago>Justice Isn’t Blind: Attorney Attractiveness and Success in US Federal Court https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-law-and-courts/article/justice-isnt-blind-attorney-attractiveness-and-success-in-us-federal-court/B3A133A42209B4A911A7C9A8440885F1 https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/journal-of-law-and-c...
- anon115 3y agoput a bag over their heads
- rzmmm 3y agoI wish more studies like this would separate the effect of things people have no control of. Attorneys clothing can have big impact. But also eye color, skin color, etc. can have impact. In my opinion there is important difference between these sources and how acceptable they are.
- howmayiannoyyou 3y agoImagine the legal malpractice claims we can now file in Federal cases where we lose with an ugly attorney.
- dboreham 3y agoRecommend reading the book "The Knowledge Illusion". People believe text in a larger font, for example. Taller people are more trusted. Your brain is not doing what it tells you it's doing.
- liveoneggs 3y agoDo good-looking salespeople sell more cars?!? Does an attractive bartender get more tips?! The potential for studies are endless!
- yazzku 3y agoWho would have thought about it, right? Imagine the possibilities. A whole new world unfolds before you.
- exe34 3y agoProbably, but this kind of study isn't to convince you, it's to convince the other idiots who would claim being attractive doesn't make a difference, that showering and wearing deodorant is what makes an attorney successful.
- generalizations 3y agoReminds me of how the early internet was a breath of fresh air: > My crime is that of judging people by what they say and think, not what they look like. - The Conscience of a Hacker (http://phrack.org/issues/7/3.html http://phrack.org/issues/7/3.html)
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fsckboy 3y ago>No one with displeasingly asymmetric features. this is a pet peeve of mine. I remember back around the time that the paper(s) were published establishing that facial symmetry played a big role in attractiveness. Before that time, nobody ever said, "oh, how attractive, look at that facial symmetry", because the point was that we are not consciously aware of what makes somebody attractive, it's our (metaphorical) lizard brain making those judgements, like the way we can generally tell M/F for people very far away. (and to add on, before this it was a quite popular "psychology experiment" to show two pictures of people, their left and mirrored left, and their right and mirrored right, to demonstrate that our faces are not symetric. One usually looked like a brooding criminal, and the other a beatific calm) so, announcing whether you find somebody attractive or not is a far more authentic piece of information than your judgement of how symmetric their face is. Symmetry is far from the only input, and it's not conscious, it's only part of the wiring of the brain. It is interesting to learn that the brain has wiring for unconscious symmetry measurement. Now, I do wonder if, developmentally, the conditions that allow facial symmetry to develop somehow also allow higher IQ wiring to develop, or something hand wavey like that.
- karmakaze 3y agoI would say that's wrapped up in "makes me laugh." Aside from slapstick and puns requires thinking outside the box and making distant but (humorously) relevant connections. It also ties into "gets me" finding the same things funny.
- catlikesshrimp 3y agoI can think of a couple reasons of why perfect axial symmetry is mechanically advantageous. I must also mention that we aren't perfectly symmetric anymore. The most obvious difference is the heart, but the brain is no longer functionally symmetric anymore, either.
- FpUser 3y agoNo shit Sherlock. With some exceptions physical attractiveness always adds to the chances.
- gnicholas 3y agoInteresting that they only looked at federal appellate court trials, where there are only judges. I would think there would be an even larger effect in jury trials. Although the overall conclusion is not surprising, it is at least modestly surprising that professional judges (as opposed to jurors) are swayed by looks. On the other hand, it's possible that there is a correlation between the best attorneys and the most attractive attorneys (because they were given many opportunities coming up through the ranks), and what is being measured in this study is actually the correlation between high-skill attorneys and winning outcomes. I doubt that at the Supreme Court level there is any difference.
- miki123211 3y agoThis is one thing that could probably be solved by AI. For these high-stakes situations, we could benefit from an algorithm that turns everybody into a nondescript face attached to an autogenerated, toneless voice. You don't technically need AI for that, text chat is enough, but text chat is far slower than voice conversations, and people seem to prefer video in many contexts.
- liveoneggs 3y ago"solved" by optimizing the outcomes to whatever biases are trained into the model? Please think through this type of thing for one minute before proposing robocop + judge dredd as a good future.
- miki123211 3y agoI'm not saying the AI should make the decisions, that's silly. It should merely be a face and voice changer, turning everybody's face and voice into something far more generic and unattractive. All the decisions would still be made by a human judge talking over video, but the judge wouldn't see how attractive the attorneys are, but would have to focus on what they're actually saying.
- tennisflyi 3y agoYes
- fennecbutt 3y agoThis is why juries suck as well. Not just attractiveness bias, but having been on juries, all sorts of biases people have come out, age, sex, appearance matching their perceived gender, sexuality, the list goes on. Humans are really not great when it comes to stuff like this. Hell, we can't even stop eating so much sugar and buying cheap plastic crap to throw away. We shouldn't be trusted with anything.