37 ms·
Substack Writers Concerned as Subscriptions 'Plummet' Due to Follow Feature
- pmontra 3y agoI have no idea about how Substack works. Are subscriptions paid to authors and is following for free?
- coldtea 3y agoSubscriptions have free and pair tiers (you get to see more posts, or in some cases, the same, with a paid subscription). Subscription also means you're getting the new posts via email as a newsletter (and the author has your email). Following is just free and you aren't getting an email for each post, you just see a notification in the Substack app/website.
- jprete 3y agoIf that's really the follow feature that writers are complaining about them I don't see how that matters. Aside from needing an internet connection, the web site is usually the superior way to see the content, and also allows for commenting. Substack doesn't charge more or less to users who choose to get emailed or not.
- coldtea 3y ago>the web site is usually the superior way to see the content Which is irrelevant, Substack was marketed and promoted itself as a newsletter focused service, not as "yet another blogging platform with social media aspirations". Authors were promised to have control of their audience, to even take elsewhere if they wanted to move, as they'd be just email addresses subscribed to them. Everything they've done since (in the last 1-2 years) is to move away from that into a tightly centralized social media platform. >Substack doesn't charge more or less to users who choose to get emailed or not. It makes subscribing optional if you want to follow someone (whereas before it was the only way), which means less newsletter subscribers, which means authors don't get to have their audience: Substack keeps the control. This also means less paid subscribers, even if nominally they can still go out of their way to subscribe and then get a paid tier.
- WheatMillington 3y agoThe article did a terrible job of helping me understand the difference between a subscription and a follow.
- sosodev 3y agoWhen will people learn that you can't trust any of these platforms? It's easy to make the argument that the network effects outweigh the risks but I would take a stable, smaller income stream over something like this any day.
- coldtea 3y agoWould you take 50 subs, $250/month, and crickets otherwise, over 1000 subs, $5000/month, and frequent new subscriptions?
- mvdtnz 3y agoWhat if your stable income stream was half as big as what you could make on a platform? How about one tenth? Everyone will draw a line somewhere.
- jimbokun 3y agoBut there’s very little lock in. Move your writing to some other platform or host your own blog, and tell your readers where you moved to. Of course, the big question is whether you can keep the Substack email addresses. Otherwise you need to hope your readers see on social media your new home.
- jprete 3y agoAs far as I know Substack doesn't have any real lock-in at all for the author - if you leave you bring everything with you. I think they're primarily bungling it up and not actively trying to enshittify, although I'm not well-placed to judge.
- throwaway420690 3y agoAre you joking? There’s huge lockin… you lose all your audience when you move
- anonylizard 3y agoWell that proves substack is providing value. It proves the platform, that offers a high concentration of high average writing quality blogposts and a reliable trusted platform (For readers), has more value for readers, than some particular writer's writing. This whole paid-blog space didn't even exist before substack, except for a handful like stratchery. So clearly its substack/marketplace that made things possible, not the writers. So writers should examine their egos before they complain this way. Its like the indie game devs who whine about steam, forgetting that before steam, the PC game marketplace was a nuclear wasteland dominated by piracy and MMOs.
- chatmasta 3y agoI don’t understand why writers would use Substack to monetize their writing instead of a blog with a paid membership. Is it simply because no such product exists? One explanation would be that Substack provides discoverability of authors who readers would otherwise not notice. But I’m skeptical of this explanation, because my personal experience of discovering posts on Substack has rarely, if ever, been driven by Substack discoverability features. Most Substack sites I’ve found via link aggregators or Twitter. So if Substack isn’t providing discoverability, then their main value is providing publishing and monetization tools. That might make for a nice product, but it’s not a defensible one. If writers could substitute Substack with a self-hosted product providing the same monetization and publishing tools, without affecting the discoverability of their posts, then they would have no reason to stay on Substack if it introduces features that harm their main value of monetization and publishing tools.
- kristjansson 3y agoSubstack was basically marketed as Blog-(ok, ok, 'newsletter')-with-paid-membership-as-service?
- simonw 3y agoHow would you setup a blog with paid membership? And it needs to also deliver every post via email, because most people have no idea what an RSS reader is. Self-hosting anything with a billing mechanism, even using something like Stripe, is decidedly non-trivial for most people. Substack is by far the easiest option for that I've seen.
- ancientworldnow 3y agoGhost does all that.
- chatmasta 3y agoWell, if they start harming their business by removing that core value-add in favor of boosting discoverability (which I posit is not a core value-add), then perhaps more products will emerge to fill the gap. It wouldn’t be hard to offer the monetization and email features as a hosted Wordpress service based on a Wordpress plugin. That would probably be enough to pull some writers off of Substack.
- passwordoops 3y agoWould be cool if a few writers got together and quantified the before/after subscription rate
- kfk 3y agoI struggle to make the VC math work on Substack. They take a 10% cut on paid subscriptions. They need 1 billion in paid subscriptions to have a $100m revenue, which at a hopefully 30% ebit would put them in the $0.5-1 billion evaluation (maybe). Now, at an average of $200 of paid subscribtions, it would take 5m paid users to achieve a 1 billion revenue. If we assume a very generous paid / non paid user ratio of 10%, it means Substack needs 50m total users to have 5m paid users. You tell me, that with 50m users, Substack would be content to make “only” $100m per year?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- anonylizard 3y agoWell, the counterexample is all those writers trying to setup some open source system for their blog, or move to some competing service. This leaves two possibilities 1. They are financial idiots 2. The competing services are also priced/costed at a similar amount to substack, such that the writers can afford to pay the difference for ideological reasons. That competition exists for substack is telling enough, that there's still money to be made here. As for whether $100m is enough, substack is an very cheap platform to run. It can be run by a craiglist sized team if must. It is cheaper than any major publication, by virtue of not having either writers nor editors on staff. All the additional cost and VC requirement for substack came from it paying big dollars to attract famous writers, which it is no longer doing (And fired the teams managing those relations). There's also nothing stopping substack from adding ads to the free-users, much like how netflix does it. There's plenty of ways to monetize 50m users without infringing on the core experience. Also this wouldn't turn substack into medium, as the core issue with medium was the membership was site-wide, whereas substack is writer-level.
- 1123581321 3y agoThey have a paid ratio of around 6% (around 35M subscribers, 2M paid.) Some correlating of past subscription and revenue figures suggests each subscribed user nets Substack $11 revenue. So perhaps 130 million total subscriptions to hit 100M revenue. If that's compared to a mediocre social network like Twitter, which supposedly can show ~$45/year/user of ads, if Substack can get a quarter of its non-paid subscribers to view ads that are a quarter as effective (smaller economies of scale, weak ad partner etc.), they would still quadruple their total top line revenue. And it's all upside from there because they can get better at selling ads at scale and they can grow unpaid followers by diluting their brand once they're confident it'll pay off. That, unfortunately, explains the VC case to me. I'd much rather them be a smaller company that focuses on taking real money.
- s1mon 3y agoThere are a small number of people/sites who I have given money/subscribed to on the internet. Substack has never been something I wanted to help with. Anything with dark patterns to get you to subscribe completely turns me off. I respond to individuals or small groups saying "hey this stuff you like to read takes time to write, and for me to do this for a living and continue to create stuff, it would be really nice if you contributed a small amount of money" For example: https://kottke.org/members/ https://kottke.org/members/ https://www.patreon.com/acegikmo/membership https://www.patreon.com/acegikmo/membership
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoSubstack creators can disable the subscription popup on their own substacks. If you notice some writers that have deliberately disabled those dark patterns, consider subscribing to them!
- film42 3y agoCan you? I tried to do this, even asking their AI support and it replied with something like, "Substack was built to help writers build their audience. If you are not looking to build your audience, Substack is not the right product for you." So lame.
- emestifs 3y ago"Substack was built to [100x investment for investors]. If you are not looking to [help us 100x our revenue], Substack is not the right product for you"
- mitthrowaway2 3y agoWriter Dashboard -> Settings -> Publication details -> Subscribe prompts on post pages (on/off). Subscribe prompts may include modals, pop-ups, and other ways to encourage readers to subscribe to your publication. (There are several other toggles that control similar settings as well).
- 3y ago
- walterbell 3y agoDo substack writers receive the email addresses of followers, as they do with subscribers, i.e. can they migrate their audience of subscribers+followers to another platform at any time? Substack has long provided RSS. Do they offer RSS feed analytics to writers?
- jprete 3y agoFrom what I've heard writers who choose to leave bring the whole email list with them.
- proactivesvcs 3y agoWasn't this also around the time of the "free speech ideals" incident? I wonder how the appearance or suggestion (accurate or otherwise) of supporting Nazis might also affect the platform.
- anonylizard 3y agoIt doesn't affect the platform in any significant way. Because brands on substack belong to the writer, not the site. The money making substack writers don't care, every writer's substack is its own ecosystem. Substack is also no ads, so no advertisers to please. It has no bandwidth costs like youtube. It also doesn't care about normies who would be scared by this. Normies do not pay $5-10/month for some random internet writer, normies scroll tiktok.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- notatoad 3y agoI don't really understand the problem here. "following" doesn't give the same content as a paid subscription, it doesn't make sense that anybody is cancelling their paid subscriptions to follow instead. a follow on substack only gets you the same content as a free subscription with no access to paid articles, so what does it matter if somebody subscribes instead of follows? is the complaint here really just that these people want a vanity metric that makes their "subscriber count" higher so nobody can tell that most of those subscribers aren't paying subscribers?
- soneca 3y agoFollowers on Substack only is much less valuable than a subscriber for which you have the email address. This is a first step for Substack to control who see your posts, when, and insert ads amid your content. You also can’t export followers like you can with subscribers. I also suspect that a free subscriber is more likely to become a paid subscriber than a follower. So they diminish your earn potential, decrease the audience of your longer form writing (usually the reason someone creates a newsletter to begin with) and lock you in, making you lose control on how you communicate with your readers.
- notatoad 3y agoah, authors get the email address of subscribers but not followers. that's the peice i was missing, thanks.
- Seattle3503 3y agoThat's what I was trying to figure out. Is it because the real value add of subscription was adding the writer ones feed? Rather than getting access to paywalled content.
- noplat 3y agoI think the fundamental problem with newsletter / blog subscription model is that it is just way too expensive for the subscriber. There is a rule of thumb that people are usually prepared to pay about $2 for an hour of entertainment: cost of books, magazines, renting a movie from online streaming service, even netflix/hbo subscription based on the actual usage hours fall in a roughly the same price bracket. But paying $5 or $10 for one blog subscription seems very expensive when ou realise how much actual time you spend reading it. Not viable in the long term.