8 ms·
Everything about this rebranding has been baffling to me. First, the original brand was great and pretty much untarnished, and there was no split/merger of busi
by ryandrake 3y ago
Everything about this rebranding has been baffling to me. First, the original brand was great and pretty much untarnished, and there was no split/merger of business happening that would encourage it. There doesn't seem to be a business purpose to rename it. Second, these hamfisted attempts to try to get the new (terrible) name to stick. It's just not going to work. The huge number of existing users will always think of it as Twitter. It will at best become The Service Formerly Known As Twitter. It just feels like in software when you get a new Product Manager on the project who just wants to superficially "leave his mark" on the product in some way and then move on. Except this PM paid billions to do it.
- rco8786 3y agoApparently Elon has been trying to push the "X" brand on things throughout his career, but always had someone stop him until he had complete control of things. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X.com_(bank) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X.com_(bank) https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2023/07/25/elon-musk-paypal-twitter-x-rebrand/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/history/2023/07/25/elon-musk-...
- Hamuko 3y agoIs there a company he owns where "X" is not a thing? There's X the social network, Tesla Model X, SpaceX.
- hyperhopper 3y agoHe literally got removed from Paypal, "his first company" for trying to push the x.com thing there. That's why he owns the domain. It was stupid then and he held a grudge ever since which is why he's pushing it everywhere else since.
- pavon 3y agoI haven't seen any strong evidence that that was the real reason he was ousted. It seems more to me like something that was too good not to go viral, rather than actual fact.
- valianteffort 3y agoNo he got removed for trying to switch their servers from linux to windows.
- HillRat 3y agoHe also got removed for creating systemic, existential risk for the company by handing out $10k line limit credit cards to anyone who wanted one, resulting in a 50% chargeback rate. There are so many reasons for them to have gotten rid of him that the answer is highly underdetermined.
- Yeul 3y agoInteresting this got AliBaba into trouble with the CCP. As 2008 proved handing out credit can lead to disaster.
- dboreham 3y agoHe owned x.com before he went to PayPal (they acquired his company which was called: x.com). When ousted, the domain continued to be owned by PayPal until later they ended up selling it and eventually he bought it back.
- PaulDavisThe1st 3y agoThere was quite an extended period where all the developer docs for PayPal were on x.com/something ... I found it all quite confusing.
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoThat’s not true. It was mostly over their servers. Elon Musk’s startup was running Windows while Peter Thiel and Max Levchin’s was running Linux. Musk wanted to migrate everything to Windows due to the more mature (at the time) APIs and Levchin was adamant on staying with Linux. He was also busy trying to fight fraud, which was becoming an existential threat to the company, and had no time for migrating to a different platform. Ultimately, Levchin gathered several other key people in the company, and went to the investors threatening to quit (and destroy the company) unless they brought back Thiel as CEO. The board sided with Levchin, Theil returned and Musk was out of day-to-day operations. If you’re interested in the PayPal story, I highly recommend Jimmy Soni’s book, The Founders. https://www.amazon.com/Founders-Paypal-Entrepreneurs-Shaped-Silicon/dp/1501197266 https://www.amazon.com/Founders-Paypal-Entrepreneurs-Shaped-...
- rsynnott 3y ago“More mature (at the time) APIs” I mean, while nothing about the web was particularly mature at the time, the idea that Windows was more mature than Linux for it is… peculiar, from the point of view of someone who was messing around with web programming at the time. Note how much difficulty Microsoft had migrating Hotmail to Windows.
- AlchemistCamp 3y agoWere you working in anything banking-related? AFIK, Microsoft was dominant in that sector.
- jsheard 3y agoDon't forget he also named one of his kids X (the Æ A-12 part is their middle name so it's just X for short). There's also xAI, which I think is technically another distinct company rather than part of X/Twitter.
- denton-scratch 3y agoThe guy's a kook. He's like Michael Jackson: a very rich guy, with complete control over who he meets. Unsurprisingly, the people he does meet all tell him what they think he wants to hear. I mean, who's going to tell him something he doesn't want to hear, and then see their name smeared all over Twitter by the richest man in the world? I expected Twitter to crash and burn as soon as he took over; I was wrong. I guess it's like Truth Social - if you're fabulously wealthy, you can run a social media site that's a complete train-wreck, without it ruining you. /me never had a Twitter account. Nor Faceache.
- jrockway 3y agoBecause Tesla has been significantly underperforming the rest of the S&P 500, Elon is not the world's richest person anymore. He's in like 4th place or something.
- askafriend 3y agoWell Michael Jackson is also one of the most talented musicians and entertainers of the last 100yrs. His wealth is the least impressive or defining thing about him. I do get the point you're trying to make though. Just thought that emphasis was a little off. Just like with Elon, you have to consider that extreme outcomes are the result of extreme people or people that were forged in extreme circumstances (which is certainly true of Michael Jackson).
- arp242 3y agoI feel both Musk and Jackson could have greatly benefited from a few more people telling them "you idiot, that's fucking mental". In general being in a position where this doesn't happen is not good for your sense of reality (very rich, very famous, a lot of political power, or something else). In that sense Michael Jackson having sleepovers in his bed with 12-year olds[1] and Musk's x.com rename are very similar. [1]: taking the most generous interpretation; no comment on whether he was a nonce or not.
- SketchySeaBeast 3y agoEx-Wives
- extraduder_ire 3y agoThe model X is part of a separate scheme, to have models S, 3, X, and Y. The 3 was initially meant to be an E until ford sued to prevent it.
- elcritch 3y agoSeems Musk always had a desire to use "X" from his pre-Paypal days. He made a boastful post about buying Twitter, didn't actually want to follow through but was forced to do it by the courts. My take is that Musk then sorta went "f-it, I had to buy Twitter. I might as well try and make it into X."
- leereeves 3y ago[flagged]
- mocha_nate 3y agoHis first payment company before he merged with PayPal was X.com
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- MattGaiser 3y agoThe purchase was never about business in the first place, so the running of it could be just as bad.
- fundad 3y agoExactly! Ownership is not in it for revenue. They'll say they don't care about revenue to everyone who asks. To be baffled, one has to ignore all of that. There is strong nostalgia for aw-shucks persona of an inventor-turned-business-owner. https://www.cnbc.com/2023/05/16/cnbc-exclusive-cnbc-transcript-elon-musk-sits-down-with-cnbcs-david-faber-live-on-cnbc-tonight-.html https://www.cnbc.com/2023/05/16/cnbc-exclusive-cnbc-transcri... https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/dealbook-summit-2023-elon-musk-interview-transcript https://www.rev.com/blog/transcripts/dealbook-summit-2023-el...
- adql 3y agoWell, admitting otherwise would be admitting failure of managing that company and we can't have that!
- jsheard 3y agoNearly a year into the rebrand x.com still redirects to twitter.com, rather than vice versa, which you'd think would be the first thing they'd want to fix.
- duxup 3y agoThat's one of those situations that feels like: "Executive just hasn't noticed / lost attention span, and engineer is leaving a workaround for a bad call in place."
- Hamuko 3y agoI imagine that changing it would break a lot of things, otherwise they would've done it already. Copying a link to a tweet already makes it an x.com link too.
- shadowgovt 3y agoBecause domain names are tied to security model, they're often the last thing you can fix. So let's say, hypothetically, they build in a redirect from twitter to x-dot-com. Off the top of my head... - All logins are now busted. Some percentage of users is lost forever because they can't remember their login credentials and instead of going through the recovery flow, they go use Bluesky. - A huge amount of third-party integrations are busted because they aren't using client libraries that understand redirects - A full code audit is necessary. Someone has hard-coded twitter.com into a critical system somewhere. Other people have referenced a variable, but it's the wrong variable. Still others are looking up the value in a database somewhere that doesn't have a search frontend anyone knows about. And some other database has a huge cache of absolute URLs it vends and everyone who built it got fired by Musk. This is probably the most predictable-cost step, but it's still a cost to be paid. - A significant number of users are confused. The median of web user is profoundly ignorant of how the web works, and no matter how much you warn them and how much you prepare them, day-of-switch they will panic. Staff up your support team. Customers-lost-forever-two-point-oh. - Every business integration needs to be updated. Google App Store, Apple App Store, Amazon Appstore... They all have bindings to twitter.com, and some part of their flow will panic and flag a security issue if they see it's turned into a redirect to elsewhere. That probably triggers a security audit of every version of the Twitter client (and those companies aren't particularly inspired to foot the bill on Musk's behalf, billionaire that he is...). Hell, Google indexes twitter.com via a dedicated side-pipe. Will that side-pipe handle a redirect? (source: I've been in the side-seat for a merger-become-rebrand, and the number of things people expect to "just work" and don't is impressive).
- nearlyepic 3y agoPresumptuously: It's stupid and irrational because this wasn't a decision that was made based on reason - it was an emotional one. Elon is a bag-holder. He bought x.com in the dotcom boom and doesn't want to admit that the domain he paid a good chunk of money for is worthless - hence the (failed) attempt to make a brand out of it.
- dom96 3y agoAny ideas how much he paid for the domain back then?
- pjc50 3y agoIt was actually bought back from paypal in 2017, for an undisclosed sum. https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/10/15949862/elon-musk-x-com-paypal-tesla-spacex-domain-name https://www.theverge.com/2017/7/10/15949862/elon-musk-x-com-...
- twisteriffic 3y agoAnd now he's sold it to twitter and pocketed the cash.
- zettabomb 3y agoSo far I really haven't seen anyone seriously call it just X. Most news orgs seem to resort to "X (formerly Twitter)" or similar. Some still call it Twitter, not even an acknowledgement that it's been renamed. At least Meta had the sense to just change their app splashscreens and such (e.g. Facebook by Meta). And it seems that Alphabet doesn't make any effort to make their presence known.
- rsynnott 3y ago> Most news orgs seem to resort to "X (formerly Twitter)" or similar. I mean, if nothing else, "X did [something stupid]" just looks like someone forgot to fill in a template; no-one is going to publish an article with 'X', unqualified, in it.
- tzs 3y agoX also makes search harder. I'd like to see HN add a recommendation that in headlines about X the submitter should change the X to Twitter.
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoThe thing that really bothers with me with this is why couldn't it just be "Twitter by X"? You want to make an "everything app", that's great Elon, let's call that X. Now what do we call all the mini apps inside the everything app? Oh, they're called "X", too? So you're using "X of X" to call a cab, and "X of X" to send a message, and these are different apps inside the mega app? How does this naming make sense?
- user_7832 3y agoThat would be too sensible. Sarcasm aside, they probably were hoping to convert the brand name twitter has to 'x', but failed to realize how sticky the name was/is.
- jsheard 3y agoEven X itself resorted to putting "Formerly Twitter" in its App Store and Play Store taglines after their daily installs fell off a cliff. Previously the tagline was just "Blaze your glory!" but nobody knows what that means.
- ben_w 3y ago> The Service Formerly Known As Twitter Was thinking almost exactly this while reading a recent BBC article — their style guide appears to be that the company's name is "X, formerly Twitter,"
- nprateem 3y agoYou have to write that (or similar) in UIs too since X just looks like a mistake/null value.
- hiccuphippo 3y agoI once tried to click in the X logo to close a modal.
- andsoitis 3y ago> Everything about this rebranding has been baffling to me. First, the original brand was great and pretty much untarnished, and there was no split/merger of business happening that would encourage it. There doesn't seem to be a business purpose to rename it. Stated goal is to gradually transform it into an “everything app” — https://theconversation.com/elon-musk-aims-to-turn-twitter-into-an-everything-app-a-social-media-and-marketing-scholar-explains-what-that-is-and-why-its-not-so-easy-to-do-211023 https://theconversation.com/elon-musk-aims-to-turn-twitter-i...
- baobabKoodaa 3y agoFirst, fire 80% of developers. Then, make the remaining developers create an "everything app" (in addition to the workload they already have with the Service Formerly Known As Twitter app). Something, something. Profit ???
- gwern 3y agoAside from being a long-standing obsession of Musk's, the thing about the 'everything app' is that it's the Hail Mary move which could make the Twitter thing anything but a dumpster fire immolating $20b+, Musk's reputation, and several years of his rapidly-shortening QALYs. If you force as many people as possible to subscribe, you can then flip them to the 'everything app' and bootstrap a big enough bloc of customers to matter that you control their demand. (cf. Stratechery). It's not going to work, but it is the only story you can tell yourself and employees about how the Twitter saga ends in any way other than Musk losing interest and getting distracted by AI again and Twitter spiraling into the drain and possibly being dumped into bankruptcy by its debt load.
- omegaworks 3y ago>it's the Hail Mary move which could make the Twitter thing anything but a dumpster fire immolating $20b+ While Twitter wasn't making money hand over fist, it was bringing in $4,500million in ad revenue prior to the rebrand and had years where it was marginally profitable. Musk's saddling Twitter with interest on the debt he paid to buy the company is one of the reasons it's immolating money.
- pjc50 3y agoKetamine is a hell of a drug. https://www.wsj.com/business/elon-musk-illegal-drugs-e826a9e1 https://www.wsj.com/business/elon-musk-illegal-drugs-e826a9e...
- lol768 3y ago> Everything about this rebranding has been baffling to me. Everything about the purchase and the way the company has been run since Elon took the reigns has been baffling. The bizarre forced-push of the X brand is just the tip of the iceberg.
- okr 3y ago[flagged]
- lenerdenator 3y agoWho cares about the handbook way? Idk. Probably the people who remain at Twitter, and to a certain extent, the investing institutions that were courted to help fund the acquisition. Of course, they probably hedged, so they don't care as much, but still. This is a case study in how concentration of capital in the hands of one person can go terribly wrong for the purposes of resource allocation.
- djbusby 3y agoIsn't Twitter valuation down like 60% from that purchase price? That's a tough hedge.
- JeremyNT 3y ago> Everything about the purchase and the way the company has been run since Elon took the reigns has been baffling. The bizarre forced-push of the X brand is just the tip of the iceberg. I dunno, is it that baffling? It seems like he really loved using the product but didn't like the leadership, and he just wanted to own it so he could mess around and have fun following his own whims. Once you get the idea that he doesn't actually care about financial success it all seems pretty reasonable. Like any hobby, for X/Twitter to be a "success" it just has to amuse him, and based on his usage of the platform it seems to be doing that. The amounts of money he's losing are staggering to us but also meaningless to him. Our society has allowed him to accumulate so much wealth that nothing he could do "wrong" in a business sense would meaningfully impact his lifestyle.
- ziddoap 3y ago>Everything about this rebranding has been baffling to me. First, the original brand was great and pretty much untarnished I always thought the rebrand was a complete shame, if only for the reason that "tweet", meaning "to make a posting on the Twitter online message service : to post a tweet" is in the dictionary! What a waste to throw that away.
- mparnisari 3y ago> It just feels like in software when you get a new Product Manager on the project who just wants to superficially "leave his mark" on the product in some way and then move on. Except this PM paid billions to do it. This is how it goes in all big companies :(
- throw2022110401 3y agoTrue but there is no way it would be implemented in such a half-assed way at any other big company (including pre-Musk Twitter). Stuff like this makes it obvious that the people who are still there no longer give a fuck, they just do what they are told with the minimum effort required to collect the paycheck.
- visarga 3y agoWhat can you do if he likes "X". It used to sound cool at some point decades ago.
- Philadelphia 3y agoThe X Games, X-treme X-men, Xander Cage in XXX era
- babypuncher 3y agoEveryone I know has partially adopted the new brand and started calling it Xitter.
- WorldMaker 3y agoWhich is especially fun to pronounce with the Pinyin 'x': https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinyin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pinyin
- xboxnolifes 3y agoUntil just now, every time I saw someone in HN mention Xitter I assumed it was a third-party client like Nitter.
- aidenn0 3y agoHe really likes X. He even named one of his kids that (well X Æ A-12, with the spaces). The A-12 is indeed a reference to the plane that came out of the oxcart project. Æ Musk pronounces "Ash" which is apparently an accepted name for the character, which was (among other things) used as a latinization of the futhorc rune[1] that means "ash tree" 1: HN won't let me paste the rune, not sure if it's limited to BMP on purpose but you can see it on https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ansuz_(rune) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ansuz_(rune)
- segasaturn 3y agoThey government let him name his kids that? I remember a story a long time ago about a couple that tried to name their kid "Brfxxccxxmnpcccclllmmnprxvclmnckssqlbb11116" which is about as meaningful as "X AE A-12", but was blocked by naming laws
- eurleif 3y agoThat was in Sweden, which has naming laws. The US does not have similar laws.
- chimeracoder 3y ago> That was in Sweden, which has naming laws. The US does not have similar laws. The US doesn't have the same sort of naming laws that are common in European countries, but there are state-specific limits around what you can have in a legal name. Specifically, in California, you cannot have diacritic marks in a name, which is part of why people were shocked that Musk was able to name his child X Æ A-12, when someone named Ramón Núñez will have their legal name as "Ramon Nunez" in California.
- yowzadave 3y agoTwo kids! (A girl, named Exa, in addition to X).
- tumsfestival 3y ago
- sam36 3y ago[flagged]
- drivingmenuts 3y agoThe best new name I've seen is Xitter. Very fitting, IMO.
- rurp 3y agoMaybe they need a new slogan to help folks with the transition. Something like: "Don't tweet, Xcrete!"